I'm glad it helps, as I mentioned I'm just a little bashful about doing the whole "model" thing. Still, if it helps you choose the product that's right for you I'm happy to do it! Though, don't expect a catwalk spin or anything...
Carl, I know I'm late commenting on this, the video is date stamped two years ago. But, I'm glad you're addressing the challenges faced by those of us who are "differently shaped". I find it challenging being stocky, I'm short but have broad shoulders, and breadth around the midsection. This makes finding jackets, and shirts a challenge. Finding pants with a 28 inch inseam is also a challenge; but, that's a separate issue. I like that the jacket is well made, with good materials, and is at, a reasonable price, for leather jackets. The removable fleece collar liner is a great addition too. Thanks!
As someone who is also “differently shaped” I appreciate the shot of you wearing it. Only thing would be best to see it in a long shot to see how it looks on you from head to toe.
“Differently shaped” lol. That jacket looks amazing Carl. I recently bought one myself not too long ago and it was quite expensive BUT worth it and I really wanted one. But mine is plain with no awesome details like yours. Great vid my friend.
Carl Murawski I just saw this now. Smh! It’s not a bomber but more like just a plain ol jacket without lots of pockets and all. If that makes sense lol
It would also really help if you include your height weight and jacket size you bought so we have a frame of reference. Thanks. Very nice and objective review.
My experience with Satchel and Page was excellent and I love the jacket I purchased. I bought the Montgomery in mahogany and the fit and quality are excellent. Their customer service was quick to answer questions and they shipped the same day I ordered. They also offer AfterPay. Satchel and Page is a great company. Thanks for the recommendation.
is their montgomery jacket similarly designed to a denim trucker jacket or is it not? I'm eyeing to buy their montgomery jacket too. looks awesome! just trying to reassure myself. lol. Thanks!
From someone that worked in the retail industry for quite sometime, don’t get deceived by the fit of the items on models. Those items, in catalogues and website are mostly tailored to fit the models body in order to make them look good. Most of the time they’re sample sizes (40R jacket, Medium shirt and 30 or 32 waist). It’s always better to try on the item itself. Like the video says, take your time and check on item, reviews and fit as much as you can.
Hey Carl just got this. It's my first leather jacket, it's more substantial than I expected. That tartan lining is really beautiful, really enhances the look. The one thing I don't agree with you on is the throat latch. I'm a leather jacket newbie so I may be wrong but I find the latch kinda uslesess, when the zipper is closed all the way up the latch doesn't do much. Other than that it's a great jacket!
Agreed. Ultimately I had to return the jacket mostly due to the gussets on the side. On my body the gussets flared out a lot which ruined the silhouette of the jacket from the back and side.
Carl, just wanna say that today I watch again the video you made about Goodyear-Welted construction(one of your best videos for me), and I think it would be a great idea to do more educational type videos explaining how classic and no so classic men clothing is made. Cheers ;)
Thank you, I’d love to make more educational videos and I’d really like to hear some of the things you’d like to see. I did the video on American Woolen last week but it was sort of a brand/process hybrid. I’m interested to hear your thoughts.
Love the look (as you know!) and the fit on you seems near perfect! One other thing i that being a bomber its tough to really wear this in mid winter so its really only good for 40+ F. Im curious to see how you make it work- layering with this should be loads of fun!
Carl , I'm a heavy set guy and it really does help when you wear the jacket.When I see a model wearing a product ,say a leather jacket I find it hard to relate to and I'm never sure it will look good on me 😂. So please don't be bashful, it really helps folks like me when you try on the jackets .
Everyone on a budget should look around every second hand store in their town for the perfect leather jacket. Look around every one a few times and the larger ones on a weekly basis until you find a perfect fit in the perfect style. Look at every single leather jacket in the store. I volounteer at one, good items usually sell in a few days, and nothing is kept around longer than six weeks. So yes, looking through them once a week is worth it. It's a big time investment but with the right eye for quality you'll end up with a beautiful leather jacket for 30-60 bucks that outclasses anything in the 100 dollar to 200 dollar range
Hey Carl! Was wondering if you have ever tried Huckberry's line of leather jackets? I like the style and look they have, but I am unsure on pulling the trigger on getting one (mostly because of the pricing).
As a quick addendum to this video, I want to make a quick first impression of the Montgomery Jacket that Satchel and Page sell, as Carl did a great review of the Bomber. The only size currently left for the Montgomery jacket is large. I'm 6ft and not "differently shaped" or super buff. I personally don't prefer the Bomber's look, but I was super stoked for the Montgomery so I risked it being just a little large: - As I understand it, most sizing recommendations have you measure the entire circumference of your body. The Satchel and Page sizing chart seems to recommend from the center of the armpit and down. A little strange, but manageable. - The jacket's shoulder (from the ends of the shoulder seams where it meets the arms) is about 19.5 inches wide, measured from the back. My shoulders seem to be 18.5 inches wide and the jacket seems to fit my shoulders nicely in the sense that my shoulder's curves are matched by the jacket. The sizing chart on their website suggests that medium might have been small for me at 18.25 inch shoulders recommended. -My "pit to pit" size, which appears to be a modifier version of chest sizing is about 21.5 inches from the center of the pits. The sizing chart suggests medium and I think I agree. There is slightly too much material for me, though I still think it looks fine. I have been planning on bulking up a little, so I'll fill out just a bit and this should be fine. -My "mid" size, appears to be about 20in putting me between medium and large, though medium probably would have been fine. -My "waist" size is 21, which puts me at large, though I'm not personally sure how much the waist size matters. -My sleeve length is about 25in which would be a medium and the sizing chart is correct, the large is just barely too much. -Front length: With only an inch difference between medium and large I don't think it matters. Having said that, I measure myself at 22in, though the large sizing is fine in my eyes. Overall, I'm very pleased with the fit of the Montgomery jacket. Carl mentions how nice the gusset on the Bomber jacket is for freedom of movement and he's absolutely right - Montgomery doesn't have gussets and reaching up will take the jacket up with your arms. Reaching forward pulls the cuffs a bit back, but is no problem.
Based on this review I bought the “updated” version of this Bomber Jacket late 2020. I am impressed with the overall quality of the jacket…but…there is a major design flaw, in my opinion! The Jacket sleeves are just too tight…specially around the armpits! So tight that it actually feels uncomfortable to use, even wearing only a T-shirt! I am 6’ 180lbs (chest 44 in) and got the XL, following size recommendation from Satchel & Page…and it is definitely the “right” size…and sizing up to XXL is not an option because the sleeves would be too long. I couldn’t return the jacket because I am not living in the USA and by the time I got it, it was too late to send it back, according to the return policy. For international buyers, due to long shipping times (& cost), I would NOT recommend this jacket…in case it doesn’t fit you, it is a logistic nightmare to return the jacket. It’s a shame, because it is really a nice Jacket. …it looks nice hanging in my wardrobe 🤷♂️😬
I’ve been searching fir s high quality brown suede bomber any suggestions? Any experience with this jl roacha guy? Who makes leather and suede bombers.
the leather thickness seems not comparable with the one on AERO jackets. I've got two of them and they are a tank! Ok, you really need to wear them in for a longer time an they might be a little bit too warm for summer, but I'm sure they will last my lifetime =)
Hi Carl, I really like this jacket but I am based in Europe and couldn't find a European brand who makes similar jackets. checked designers like Boss / RL / Riess and also Belstaff. could you recommend a brand with a similar design / quality / price?
I don’t have any experience with Peter Manning but my friend Brock loves their stuff. I also know that there is a limited supply of these left, unless they decide to re-release it.
Well hello differently shaped brother! I went with an XL which is why the sleeves are a bit long, but it offered more room in the torso so it was a welcome compromise.
I am in desperate need of your help! I have had my eye on this jacket for over 4 years, and now that I am in a position to afford it they are sold out of my size and discontinued! I am extremely sad that I missed out on it. Do you know of any comparable alternatives in the same price range? I just saw that Thursday Boot Co. just released a similar one and was wondering if I could get your advice? Thanks so much! Love your channel and keep up the great work!
Hey Alex! Sorry to hear you missed the window on these man, that's a bummer. The first thing I would do is email Satchel and Page to see if they have any left in stock. Just because its sold out doesn't mean they don't have a few stragglers, and its worth a shot! If that doesn't work, I'd be wary of Thursday Boots. If their leather bags are anything like their jackets, it's passable at best. If it were you I'd check out Gustin and see if they have any leather jackets coming out in the near future. They're awesome, made in the USA, and really affordable. If you simply can't wait, I highly recommend Schott Bros. They're another heritage brand with a reputation for quality, and they have a huge selection. Finally I think its worth looking at the new leather jackets from Taylor Stitch, they look incredible and are made by Golden Bear.
Carl Murawski hey thanks so much for the advice! Unfortunately I had already emailed them and they are definitely sold out. What do you think the odds are you'll be able to review the Thursday boot Co jacket at all?
@@AlJohnDeLange Alex go to Gibson and Barnes.com.... Better quality at similar prices...and they will have what you want in stock...or will custom make one for your exact measurements.
I am quite a short guy with a height of 66 inches, I really want to buy one of these cool jacket for myself, but I am not sure the size they shown online, I definitely wear the small, but I think it probably would be bigger .😭
I bought a Gibson and Barnes "Civil G-1" about 15+years ago in lambskin/black.....(The milspec model has no hand warmer pockets)....and it still looks like the day I got it. From what I can tell the quality of my jacket is FAR superior in construction to the one you are reviewing...and a tad less expensive.....Still it's priced right at $500 +/-......but with good quality you should always get what you pay for. When I was in the Navy the pilots always gave their "issue G-1" to their girlfriend and ordered the "milspec version G-1" Gibson and Barnes for their service use....They looked, fit and felt superior to "issue" and were highly coveted by the junior officers. My son will enjoy it long after I'm gone....and his son will as well. Quality never goes out of fashion
Hey there, looking for a high-quality Macready jacket [you know, The Macready from The Thing]. I know that was a Schott I-S 674 M-S model, long discontinued. If i was looking for something as close to that as possible [preferably not by Schott, even: nothing against them, but i just feel their quality's a bit lacking lately], what would i be looking at? Thanks!
I have a question about the fit of this jacket. I just got one in a medium and it’s very tight in the arms. It’s like I’m wearing a woman’s jacket. Shoulders and body fit well. I’m a pretty thin guy. I wear a medium slim in shirts. Did u size up? Also was your zipper on the opposite side?
What makes me skeptical about online catalog ordering is the Thumbnail photo you used I have seen on several different websites advertising leather coats so if anyone can use these photos it may be misleading as to what your actually going to get when you order from that site. Online ordering is a very risky undertaking. But that is a nice coat you got.
I like this video. I learnt new word. Gussetted back, bi swing/action back. I like that look. I like Rick oconnells leather jacket in the mummy returns 21 minutes into film. Dark brown textured, no shine looking with point collars with button enclose and gussetted back that ends towards lower back with a 2 inch band across lower back like this satchel and page one, and waist length to bum level. And slash pockets, not Indiana Jones patch pockets like this satchel and page one. Satchel and page are you getting the hint?😉 Design a Rick oconnell jacket. There's enough Indiana jones
Well, of course this will depend on the person and their preferences. I'd say this is good down to about 30 or 40 degrees with just a long sleeve beneath it.
Carl Murawski no problem, what grain can you recommend at the 500 price point? I know one of these is 100% sheep leather. Since there are sales right now I’m lookin at picking one up, but of great quality.
For a company thats really just using an old style, save a few hundred dollars and hit up an army/navy surplus store and grab a G1 for $150 or less. Just go with your chest size or 1 size smaller.
*Goes to S&P website to look. Discontinued! Dammit! Well, back to Wilson's leather I guess But yeah, having both G1 and B2 pattern bomber jackets, I do love the look of these things. Retro cool in any decade
Probably many have seen the bomber jackets made by either Buzz Rickson or by Eastman Leather. But for a far better deal, yet quite authentic and good construction you should check out Gibson and Barnes (out of San Diego, CA area, with some of the construction being done in northern Mexico). The source of leather is excellent, and G&B insists upon details that follow the traditional form very carefully. So, you can get a great A2, or G1, with real mouton, and even the perforations and labeling you would see on the originals. I obtained one of their "Civil A2" model which has side-entry handwarmer pockets, a feature which is not consistent with the original A2 design, but which is good for those cold days. www.gibson-barnes.com/ G&B cater to actual pilots with helmets, mic equipment, storage bags, jumpsuits and so forth. But these same pro pilots tend to like the flight jackets from the forties and fifties too.
Hey just wanted to remind you for that harness boots video I commented it a while back and I really wanted your opinion on it just in case you forgot mate
Carl Murawski I've already brought some I got it from topman these amazing black suede boots that look exactly like the SLP Wyatt's for about a tenth of the price on an in store deal I usually wear it with my black leather jacket and the usual bad boy look but it's summer here and all black is too hot but it's the perfect weather to bust out suede in england. Just wanted some style ideas is all
I was just wondering why you never seem to mention the likes of Aero, Bill Kelso, Eastman to name a few. They are really producing the best leather jackets. As for price you do get what you pay for. £700+ for a jacket is worth it and should be seen as an Investment. Thanks
This is an example of a "civil" G-1 (Navy type) flight jacket from Gibson and Barnes: www.gibson-barnes.com/prod-293977/Civil-G1.html# They have not only basic leather flight jackets of very high quality (and accurate details), but also loving recreations of famous flight jackets from the war, like the 1943 model A2 jacket, or "Flying Tigers" models. These are more expensive. I own a civil model A2 in brown goatskin. The leather is excellent, and all the construction is fantastic, not a stray stitch anywhere. This company also sells helmets and headsets, as well as all other suits and items for professional helicopter and aircraft pilots. It's not someplace just in business for the role play. Their customers often make a living flying. The owner is a former USMC aviator, and this is now family-run. Prices beat most of the others without any reduction in quality.
Wested Leather is reasonably priced you don’t have to spend a lot of money for a good jacket I got eight of them and I’m telling you wested leather is the way to go although I do have Burmans to the years and many other Leather Jacket
@@CarlMurawski thanks i have a yood one every year or so , and thanks for this channel i appreciate it . I like to dress nice but i need my clothes durable , so i often settle and thats getting old.
Too Indiana Jones looking. I like Rick oconnells in the mummy returns 21minutes into movie. Dark brown non shiny textured leather jacket i think. Slash side pockets. Gussetted back. A 2inch wide panel across back on lower back of jacket similar to this one. And stitching 3 inches from bottom of hem of jacket all across with no knitted hem. Button enclosure rather than zip. Satchel and page should watch movie and replicate it.
Hand warmer pockets are a dead giveaway that it’s phony. I realize it’s not milspec but if you are going to ape the milspec vibe, go all the way. The jacket is nice enough, but you can buy authentic G-1’s for way less than the S&P version. If you really want to pry open the wallet, Eastman and/or Real McCoy’s sell super authentic reproductions but they’re gonna cost you.
Carl Murawski about 20 years ago I had an Eastman B6 (kind of like a B3, but lighter and even more snug...) and like a fool, I sold it along with a Hanhart fleiger Luftwaffe watch. Got a ton of money for them but I’d rather have them both back! I can’t touch either one of them for what they go for now...
It’s insane how much that level of quality goes for these days. On one hand, you’ll have it forever. On the other, it will cost you one months mortgage payment!
Carl Murawski when I was young & single I’d just put it on a credit card... my wife would kill me for spending that kind of money on a jacket now! By the way, as many of your vids as I’ve watched I thought I was already subscribed!! I am now for sure though. Great work my friend, keep it up!
If you are looking for a "Flight jacket" that looks like a flight jacket, ie is authentic, then go to Eastman leather. This is a poor and not very authentic lookalike.
I wouldn’t spend that much money on something that looks average on me if I were you. Plenty of other clothes that’d make you look like a stud but this is not it my brother
![Rob49 - On Dat Money (with Cardi B) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fTFS58mHJh8/mqdefault.jpg)
For those interested, we're re-launching this jacket (with a few tweaks...thanks for the feedback, Carl!) in late September.
What is the weight going to be like on the release? Thanks!
Literally cannot wait for this.
I literally just ordered mine. It hurt me paying so much but since it's their last time making it before discontinuing it
im just coming across your jacket now and i see that it's low in stock, are you intending on relaunching it?
@@msherwood69 We plan to make another run of jackets in early September. The plan is to offer the Bomber in Brown and the Montgomery in a new suede.
I definitely think you should "model" the jacket and other items you review so we can see how it looks on. As always, great review. Thanks!
I'm glad it helps, as I mentioned I'm just a little bashful about doing the whole "model" thing. Still, if it helps you choose the product that's right for you I'm happy to do it! Though, don't expect a catwalk spin or anything...
Thanks For Sharing.Your Videos Always Instructiv And You Feel The Passion...
LEGIT, WHERE HAVE YOU BEEN MY ENTIRE LIFE I LOVE YOUR CHANNEL!!
Haha, I've been hiding but you found me! Thanks for watching my videos!
My girlfriend is gonna kill me if i buy anoyher thing you reviewed but this is too good to pass up
Steve DelLanno lol well said
That tells you that you don't want her as your wife.
lol pussywhipped.
She may, but WILL ask you to drape over her on a cool night stroll.
That’s what they say at first then they are like omg I love it
Great vid, that Jacket is going to look even better in a couple of years.
I think you're right, once the creases set and it gets a little wear it will be dyn-o-mite!
Carl, I know I'm late commenting on this, the video is date stamped two years ago. But, I'm glad you're addressing the challenges faced by those of us who are "differently shaped". I find it challenging being stocky, I'm short but have broad shoulders, and breadth around the midsection. This makes finding jackets, and shirts a challenge. Finding pants with a 28 inch inseam is also a challenge; but, that's a separate issue.
I like that the jacket is well made, with good materials, and is at, a reasonable price, for leather jackets. The removable fleece collar liner is a great addition too. Thanks!
Really appreciate the on body shots man great review
Very nice review. I definitely gonna buy these jackets. Even I am a bit on the heavier side, but this jacket had an amazing fit
As someone who is also “differently shaped” I appreciate the shot of you wearing it. Only thing would be best to see it in a long shot to see how it looks on you from head to toe.
Thanks for this wonderful review. I just bought one last night from S&P because of this video. Awesome job!
Awesome! Let me know how you like it!!!
will do. i bought the montgomery jacket in brown.
Oh that’s a sharp look. I had a hard time choosing between that and the bomber.
“Differently shaped” lol. That jacket looks amazing Carl. I recently bought one myself not too long ago and it was quite expensive BUT worth it and I really wanted one. But mine is plain with no awesome details like yours. Great vid my friend.
Thanks Carlos, did you get a bomber?
Carl Murawski I just saw this now. Smh! It’s not a bomber but more like just a plain ol jacket without lots of pockets and all. If that makes sense lol
It would also really help if you include your height weight and jacket size you bought so we have a frame of reference. Thanks. Very nice and objective review.
My experience with Satchel and Page was excellent and I love the jacket I purchased. I bought the Montgomery in mahogany and the fit and quality are excellent. Their customer service was quick to answer questions and they shipped the same day I ordered. They also offer AfterPay. Satchel and Page is a great company. Thanks for the recommendation.
They’re excellent on all fronts and I think it’s because they’re a small company depending on their customer service. Enjoy that awesome jacket!
is their montgomery jacket similarly designed to a denim trucker jacket or is it not? I'm eyeing to buy their montgomery jacket too. looks awesome! just trying to reassure myself. lol. Thanks!
From someone that worked in the retail industry for quite sometime, don’t get deceived by the fit of the items on models. Those items, in catalogues and website are mostly tailored to fit the models body in order to make them look good. Most of the time they’re sample sizes (40R jacket, Medium shirt and 30 or 32 waist). It’s always better to try on the item itself. Like the video says, take your time and check on item, reviews and fit as much as you can.
Nice to have a men fashion review without all the sponsorship. Sold out in my size!!!!!!
Hey Carl just got this. It's my first leather jacket, it's more substantial than I expected. That tartan lining is really beautiful, really enhances the look. The one thing I don't agree with you on is the throat latch. I'm a leather jacket newbie so I may be wrong but I find the latch kinda uslesess, when the zipper is closed all the way up the latch doesn't do much. Other than that it's a great jacket!
Agreed. Ultimately I had to return the jacket mostly due to the gussets on the side. On my body the gussets flared out a lot which ruined the silhouette of the jacket from the back and side.
Carl, just wanna say that today I watch again the video you made about Goodyear-Welted construction(one of your best videos for me), and I think it would be a great idea to do more educational type videos explaining how classic and no so classic men clothing is made. Cheers ;)
Thank you, I’d love to make more educational videos and I’d really like to hear some of the things you’d like to see. I did the video on American Woolen last week but it was sort of a brand/process hybrid. I’m interested to hear your thoughts.
You usually can’t tell the difference from standing distance.
That's a great idea, there are definitely pros and cons to each- consider it in the works!
Love the look (as you know!) and the fit on you seems near perfect! One other thing i that being a bomber its tough to really wear this in mid winter so its really only good for 40+ F. Im curious to see how you make it work- layering with this should be loads of fun!
Thank you my friend~ layering should be a lot of fun with this piece!
Carl , I'm a heavy set guy and it really does help when you wear the jacket.When I see a model wearing a product ,say a leather jacket I find it hard to relate to and I'm never sure it will look good on me 😂. So please don't be bashful, it really helps folks like me when you try on the jackets .
It actually fits you really well!
Thank you!
Carl, great video. Can I ask for suggestions on sizing? which size did you bought? do they run true to size?
You sold me on this leather jacket, it just arrived, it's so beautiful, comfortable but the leather is very thick
I’m so happy to hear that!!
Love the jacket!
Everyone on a budget should look around every second hand store in their town for the perfect leather jacket.
Look around every one a few times and the larger ones on a weekly basis until you find a perfect fit in the perfect style. Look at every single leather jacket in the store.
I volounteer at one, good items usually sell in a few days, and nothing is kept around longer than six weeks. So yes, looking through them once a week is worth it.
It's a big time investment but with the right eye for quality you'll end up with a beautiful leather jacket for 30-60 bucks that outclasses anything in the 100 dollar to 200 dollar range
Hey Carl! Was wondering if you have ever tried Huckberry's line of leather jackets? I like the style and look they have, but I am unsure on pulling the trigger on getting one (mostly because of the pricing).
actually i think your zipper is supposed to hang over that throat latch to keep it from going down, my ronix supreme lifejacket has one on it
As a quick addendum to this video, I want to make a quick first impression of the Montgomery Jacket that Satchel and Page sell, as Carl did a great review of the Bomber.
The only size currently left for the Montgomery jacket is large. I'm 6ft and not "differently shaped" or super buff. I personally don't prefer the Bomber's look, but I was super stoked for the Montgomery so I risked it being just a little large:
- As I understand it, most sizing recommendations have you measure the entire circumference of your body. The Satchel and Page sizing chart seems to recommend from the center of the armpit and down. A little strange, but manageable.
- The jacket's shoulder (from the ends of the shoulder seams where it meets the arms) is about 19.5 inches wide, measured from the back. My shoulders seem to be 18.5 inches wide and the jacket seems to fit my shoulders nicely in the sense that my shoulder's curves are matched by the jacket. The sizing chart on their website suggests that medium might have been small for me at 18.25 inch shoulders recommended.
-My "pit to pit" size, which appears to be a modifier version of chest sizing is about 21.5 inches from the center of the pits. The sizing chart suggests medium and I think I agree. There is slightly too much material for me, though I still think it looks fine. I have been planning on bulking up a little, so I'll fill out just a bit and this should be fine.
-My "mid" size, appears to be about 20in putting me between medium and large, though medium probably would have been fine.
-My "waist" size is 21, which puts me at large, though I'm not personally sure how much the waist size matters.
-My sleeve length is about 25in which would be a medium and the sizing chart is correct, the large is just barely too much.
-Front length: With only an inch difference between medium and large I don't think it matters. Having said that, I measure myself at 22in, though the large sizing is fine in my eyes.
Overall, I'm very pleased with the fit of the Montgomery jacket.
Carl mentions how nice the gusset on the Bomber jacket is for freedom of movement and he's absolutely right - Montgomery doesn't have gussets and reaching up will take the jacket up with your arms. Reaching forward pulls the cuffs a bit back, but is no problem.
Too lazy to do a full video. Here's some blurry iphone photos imgur -> /a/CO7ZxJ2?
Looks good on.
Dont sugarcoat it. Women love curves
Hahaha, well said!
Good point
That's the reason I keep my huge belly.
If Tony Soprano can wear a leather jacket and get away with it so can we
I have a question could you review the black rivet bomber jacket
Just found your channel and am really liking your reviews. Thanks.
Thanks for watching!!!
I wear an Avirex raider that I bought over 30 years ago.
Based on this review I bought the “updated” version of this Bomber Jacket late 2020. I am impressed with the overall quality of the jacket…but…there is a major design flaw, in my opinion!
The Jacket sleeves are just too tight…specially around the armpits!
So tight that it actually feels uncomfortable to use, even wearing only a T-shirt!
I am 6’ 180lbs (chest 44 in) and got the XL, following size recommendation from Satchel & Page…and it is definitely the “right” size…and sizing up to XXL is not an option because the sleeves would be too long.
I couldn’t return the jacket because I am not living in the USA and by the time I got it, it was too late to send it back, according to the return policy.
For international buyers, due to long shipping times (& cost), I would NOT recommend this jacket…in case it doesn’t fit you, it is a logistic nightmare to return the jacket.
It’s a shame, because it is really a nice Jacket.
…it looks nice hanging in my wardrobe 🤷♂️😬
I’ve been searching fir s high quality brown suede bomber any suggestions? Any experience with this jl roacha guy? Who makes leather and suede bombers.
I don’t have any experience with JL Rocha. If you’re looking for the best of the best I’d recommend Himel Brothers, they’re top notch.
Ahahah same feeling from France, back in the days when I ve got these horrible jackets that you describe at the start of your video 😆
Do you spray your leather jackets for the rain? Or do you think that you don’t need to?
the leather thickness seems not comparable with the one on AERO jackets. I've got two of them and they are a tank! Ok, you really need to wear them in for a longer time an they might be a little bit too warm for summer, but I'm sure they will last my lifetime =)
Hi Carl, I really like this jacket but I am based in Europe and couldn't find a European brand who makes similar jackets. checked designers like Boss / RL / Riess and also Belstaff. could you recommend a brand with a similar design / quality / price?
Great video, I’m torn between this jacket and the one from Peter Manning. Have you had any experience with any of their products?
I don’t have any experience with Peter Manning but my friend Brock loves their stuff. I also know that there is a limited supply of these left, unless they decide to re-release it.
Carl Murawski
Thanks for your reply! How does the ribbed cuff fair with wearing a watch?
Carl, if you don’t mind me asking, what size is your chest, and what size jacket did you get? The fit on yours is good.
What temperature range would you say this jacket could be used in? I live in Austin TX..our winters can be 40-60 degrees.
Also wondering this, but I live in a much colder Chicago. This looks like a warmer weather jacket but the wind resistant, though I could be wrong.
Great video. I am also “differently shaped” and wondering what size you went with?
Well hello differently shaped brother! I went with an XL which is why the sleeves are a bit long, but it offered more room in the torso so it was a welcome compromise.
Awesome, I usually have trouble deciding between a Large and X-large.
Thanks for your help. Glad to see somebody putting CT on the map.
I’m trying!
I think I prefer the Wested jackets though. Awesome pricing, fantastic build quality.
Agreed. I have a Wested jacket as well. Half the price with good leather and has options for custom sizing
I am in desperate need of your help! I have had my eye on this jacket for over 4 years, and now that I am in a position to afford it they are sold out of my size and discontinued! I am extremely sad that I missed out on it. Do you know of any comparable alternatives in the same price range? I just saw that Thursday Boot Co. just released a similar one and was wondering if I could get your advice? Thanks so much! Love your channel and keep up the great work!
Hey Alex! Sorry to hear you missed the window on these man, that's a bummer. The first thing I would do is email Satchel and Page to see if they have any left in stock. Just because its sold out doesn't mean they don't have a few stragglers, and its worth a shot! If that doesn't work, I'd be wary of Thursday Boots. If their leather bags are anything like their jackets, it's passable at best. If it were you I'd check out Gustin and see if they have any leather jackets coming out in the near future. They're awesome, made in the USA, and really affordable. If you simply can't wait, I highly recommend Schott Bros. They're another heritage brand with a reputation for quality, and they have a huge selection. Finally I think its worth looking at the new leather jackets from Taylor Stitch, they look incredible and are made by Golden Bear.
Carl Murawski hey thanks so much for the advice! Unfortunately I had already emailed them and they are definitely sold out. What do you think the odds are you'll be able to review the Thursday boot Co jacket at all?
@@AlJohnDeLange S&P is re-introducing this fall
Kenneth Boehnen thanks for the heads up!
@@AlJohnDeLange Alex go to Gibson and Barnes.com....
Better quality at similar prices...and they will have what you want in stock...or will custom make one for your exact measurements.
I am quite a short guy with a height of 66 inches, I really want to buy one of these cool jacket for myself, but I am not sure the size they shown online, I definitely wear the small, but I think it probably would be bigger .😭
Hi. Do you wear Any SCHOTT Motorcycle Jackets?
What about a 38 inch chest,30 inch waist, 5ft 8 tall, 73 inch arm span??
Does anybody know of a brand that makes g1 or a-2 leather jackets here in USA ? Thanks in advance ( if possible not super expensive )😄
Damn now it’s $700
I bought a Gibson and Barnes "Civil G-1" about 15+years ago in lambskin/black.....(The milspec model has no hand warmer pockets)....and it still looks like the day I got it. From what I can tell the quality of my jacket is FAR superior in construction to the one you are reviewing...and a tad less expensive.....Still it's priced right at $500 +/-......but with good quality you should always get what you pay for.
When I was in the Navy the pilots always gave their "issue G-1" to their girlfriend and ordered the "milspec version G-1" Gibson and Barnes for their service use....They looked, fit and felt superior to "issue" and were highly coveted by the junior officers.
My son will enjoy it long after I'm gone....and his son will as well.
Quality never goes out of fashion
How tall are you and how much do you weigh?
You know what's crazy? I ordered mine after watching this video and the day after they were completely sold out.
Yeah they went fast, and from what I understand they’re getting out of the jacket game altogether. It’s a shame because they’re really great.
Hey there, looking for a high-quality Macready jacket [you know, The Macready from The Thing]. I know that was a Schott I-S 674 M-S model, long discontinued. If i was looking for something as close to that as possible [preferably not by Schott, even: nothing against them, but i just feel their quality's a bit lacking lately], what would i be looking at?
Thanks!
I have a question about the fit of this jacket. I just got one in a medium and it’s very tight in the arms. It’s like I’m wearing a woman’s jacket. Shoulders and body fit well. I’m a pretty thin guy. I wear a medium slim in shirts. Did u size up? Also was your zipper on the opposite side?
I did size up, the fit is definitely more tailored so the extra room is welcome.
Was your zipper set up like a women’s jacket too?
No, mine is the traditional American setup. From what I understand the zipper is reversed overseas in some countries.
Ok. Thanks for your reply. Keep up the great work I really enjoy your reviews!
Ok. Thanks for your reply. Keep up the great work I really enjoy your reviews!
Have you loot at Lewis Lethe's!
What makes me skeptical about online catalog ordering is the Thumbnail photo you used I have seen on several different websites advertising leather coats so if anyone can use these photos it may be misleading as to what your actually going to get when you order from that site. Online ordering is a very risky undertaking. But that is a nice coat you got.
what size did u get
I like this video. I learnt new word. Gussetted back, bi swing/action back. I like that look.
I like Rick oconnells leather jacket in the mummy returns 21 minutes into film. Dark brown textured, no shine looking with point collars with button enclose and gussetted back that ends towards lower back with a 2 inch band across lower back like this satchel and page one, and waist length to bum level. And slash pockets, not Indiana Jones patch pockets like this satchel and page one. Satchel and page are you getting the hint?😉 Design a Rick oconnell jacket. There's enough Indiana jones
Carl, in what temperatures can I wear this without having to layer?
Well, of course this will depend on the person and their preferences. I'd say this is good down to about 30 or 40 degrees with just a long sleeve beneath it.
@@CarlMurawski Thanks!
Great review. What is your position on reiss and all saints leather jacket quality?
I’ve never tried either brand so I can’t give you a good opinion, sorry!
Carl Murawski no problem, what grain can you recommend at the 500 price point? I know one of these is 100% sheep leather. Since there are sales right now I’m lookin at picking one up, but of great quality.
M A all saints is good for $400-500. And full grain is the best cut you can get. usually at the very top as for quality
Most of the time tight jackets don’t fit me they are missing arm
We didn't see any definition of the jacket
For a company thats really just using an old style, save a few hundred dollars and hit up an army/navy surplus store and grab a G1 for $150 or less. Just go with your chest size or 1 size smaller.
Great price on this
It really is, but I'm not sure it's available anymore unfortunately.
*Goes to S&P website to look. Discontinued!
Dammit!
Well, back to Wilson's leather I guess
But yeah, having both G1 and B2 pattern bomber jackets, I do love the look of these things. Retro cool in any decade
They are having preorders on their site for their November batch if you are interested
Hi Carl, thanks for your video. What size do you have?
XL
Probably many have seen the bomber jackets made by either Buzz Rickson or by Eastman Leather. But for a far better deal, yet quite authentic and good construction you should check out Gibson and Barnes (out of San Diego, CA area, with some of the construction being done in northern Mexico). The source of leather is excellent, and G&B insists upon details that follow the traditional form very carefully. So, you can get a great A2, or G1, with real mouton, and even the perforations and labeling you would see on the originals. I obtained one of their "Civil A2" model which has side-entry handwarmer pockets, a feature which is not consistent with the original A2 design, but which is good for those cold days.
www.gibson-barnes.com/
G&B cater to actual pilots with helmets, mic equipment, storage bags, jumpsuits and so forth. But these same pro pilots tend to like the flight jackets from the forties and fifties too.
Hey just wanted to remind you for that harness boots video I commented it a while back and I really wanted your opinion on it just in case you forgot mate
Thanks buddy. I haven’t forgot, but is there a brand or two you’re looking at specifically?
Carl Murawski I've already brought some I got it from topman these amazing black suede boots that look exactly like the SLP Wyatt's for about a tenth of the price on an in store deal I usually wear it with my black leather jacket and the usual bad boy look but it's summer here and all black is too hot but it's the perfect weather to bust out suede in england. Just wanted some style ideas is all
I was just wondering why you never seem to mention the likes of Aero, Bill Kelso, Eastman to name a few. They are really producing the best leather jackets. As for price you do get what you pay for. £700+ for a jacket is worth it and should be seen as an Investment. Thanks
There are on sale right now
Yes indeed, for a limited run.
Is this a black leather or a dark brown leather? I am totally blind. I have no vision whatsoever and I don’t think it was mentioned.
The company has discontinued their leather jackets
could you do a review on independence brothers? it's a MTM leather jacket company
What size you wear?
This is a size large
Very Nicce
Sold out
Yeah, these went like hot cakes... 😕
This is an example of a "civil" G-1 (Navy type) flight jacket from Gibson and Barnes:
www.gibson-barnes.com/prod-293977/Civil-G1.html#
They have not only basic leather flight jackets of very high quality (and accurate details), but also loving recreations of famous flight jackets from the war, like the 1943 model A2 jacket, or "Flying Tigers" models. These are more expensive. I own a civil model A2 in brown goatskin. The leather is excellent, and all the construction is fantastic, not a stray stitch anywhere. This company also sells helmets and headsets, as well as all other suits and items for professional helicopter and aircraft pilots. It's not someplace just in business for the role play. Their customers often make a living flying. The owner is a former USMC aviator, and this is now family-run. Prices beat most of the others without any reduction in quality.
Fuck, what these guys have against us small guys
Wested Leather is reasonably priced you don’t have to spend a lot of money for a good jacket I got eight of them and I’m telling you wested leather is the way to go although I do have Burmans to the years and many other Leather Jacket
Likes jacket, checks website, it’s $645 now. Gotta pay for that Carl clout premium
😂 the prices have definitely increased since this video.
They are not love handles its a wide body kit
Hahahaha I love that!
@@CarlMurawski thanks i have a yood one every year or so , and thanks for this channel i appreciate it . I like to dress nice but i need my clothes durable , so i often settle and thats getting old.
Too Indiana Jones looking. I like Rick oconnells in the mummy returns 21minutes into movie.
Dark brown non shiny textured leather jacket i think. Slash side pockets. Gussetted back. A 2inch wide panel across back on lower back of jacket similar to this one. And stitching 3 inches from bottom of hem of jacket all across with no knitted hem. Button enclosure rather than zip.
Satchel and page should watch movie and replicate it.
喜欢！😄😄👍👍
Man, I’d want it to look my dad’s leather jacket. Is this what this channels all about lol
Satchel Paige was a person. Do you guys know this?
Beautiful jacket but it seems really uncomfortable. Looks way too tight on the arm sleeves.
It's definitely a slim fit, and I think a satin lined sleeve would make them much more comfortable.
I notice high end companies are starting to down grade their quality
Split second hesitation when he said bomber jackets looked good 100 years ago because he knows rhey did not exist back then, but he kept on rolling
we make stich learher jackets
Hand warmer pockets are a dead giveaway that it’s phony. I realize it’s not milspec but if you are going to ape the milspec vibe, go all the way. The jacket is nice enough, but you can buy authentic G-1’s for way less than the S&P version. If you really want to pry open the wallet, Eastman and/or Real McCoy’s sell super authentic reproductions but they’re gonna cost you.
I'd love to get a Real McCoy B3 jacket, but they're like 3K! Still, best of the best and its gonna cost you. On my wish list for sure.
Carl Murawski about 20 years ago I had an Eastman B6 (kind of like a B3, but lighter and even more snug...) and like a fool, I sold it along with a Hanhart fleiger Luftwaffe watch. Got a ton of money for them but I’d rather have them both back! I can’t touch either one of them for what they go for now...
It’s insane how much that level of quality goes for these days. On one hand, you’ll have it forever. On the other, it will cost you one months mortgage payment!
Carl Murawski when I was young & single I’d just put it on a credit card... my wife would kill me for spending that kind of money on a jacket now! By the way, as many of your vids as I’ve watched I thought I was already subscribed!! I am now for sure though. Great work my friend, keep it up!
Knit cuffs. Eck.
Bro that's $650. I'm all for quality but can we get something closer to middle class?
The throat latch is really annoying and ugly sticking out like that when unzipped.
We make leather jackets
Contact us or high grade 100 % leather
Leather jackets are not that expensive
If you are looking for a "Flight jacket" that looks like a flight jacket, ie is authentic, then go to Eastman leather. This is a poor and not very authentic lookalike.
it's not going for the authentic look, authentic is long sleeves, lower arm holes and baggy waist. This is not that
I wouldn’t spend that much money on something that looks average on me if I were you. Plenty of other clothes that’d make you look like a stud but this is not it my brother