The middle and lower tones sound so old and heavy . It’s all sooo spread. Except the top. And now her voice is all spread and moaned. There is no joy or words here is all maaawwwhhhwwrrr.
@CiboCeleste Yes, I realize that other people are hearing things that I don't. Perhaps, I didn't ask my question correctly. What is that leads you to believe she had some technical problems/ what kind of technical problems do you mean.
Well.... Anna Netrebko is a great artist so we are talking about a really good opera-singer.I think the biggest problem are: she is not a real coloratura and she tries to sing more dramatically. Besides... I really don't care that her breathing not perfect (i can hear her support is not 100%ly) but honestly I DO NOT CARE. I'm enjoying what she do, I think she is very good as an artist as well as a singer. Her performance is very amazing. It is more important to me, and her voice is beautiful!
@CiboCeleste Why do you say that? I'm only just becoming introduced to the opera world, so most of the comments criticisms, critiques, etc mean nothing to me because I don't understand what they are criticquing. All I know is that I hear a beautiful voice that's way better than what I can vocalize. LOL!
Does anyone think that Anna hasn't been looking real healthy lately? I've been noticing this, can't figure out if it's just weight gain or something is wrong with her health (maybe doing too much, stress, I don't know!)
I am so fed up with comments challenging the commentators to "do it better." And audiences' responses are neither undeserved nor proof of greatness. I found her interpretation of Anna moving. However, she seemed to struggle a lot. My suspicion: She wants to be a spinto, which she's not. Everything is too chesty and she has major breath problems, causing her coloratura and phrasing to suffer. Hence she's forced to use inappropriate musical mannerisms. And she should lay off the cortisone.
Où cette chanteuse a appris à chanter ? La Scala décidément est descendue bien bas...! Quant à Filianotti c'est pis que tout ! Stephane Lissner me semble-t-il l'avait viré de Don Carlo il y a peu, hummm !!
Suoni troppo coperti, com'è di moda oggi. Non si capisce un tubo, e questa (com'è oggi) non è una voce per Mozart. Ma è di moda oggi cantare tutto copertissimo e oramai i cantanti, di cui la A.N., sono diventati dei robot. Anche colpa dei conservatori e "maestri" che non insegnano più la dizione, il legato, lo squillo e la prosodia. Voce pienamente fabricata (molto bella) ma fredda e senza corpo (vocale)
This is one of the most horrendous performances of this aria I have ever heard. Its insulting that she will go on stage (at la scala no less where tickets are anything by affordable) and sing this garbage, knowing full well this is not a role for her. Its out of tune and sloppy. It enrages me that she can go anywhere and sing anything as horribly as she wants to and people will worship her regardless. She is really shameless.
Видеоклипы
Don Giovanni - Anna Netrebko - act 2 SO BEAUTIFUL SINGING
PIĘKNY GŁOS POZDRAWIAM
Perfect ❤
forse un giorno il cielo ancora sentira a-a-aaaaaa thats ridiculous , the vocalisation don't express in any way the despair of dona anna ...
The middle and lower tones sound so old and heavy . It’s all sooo spread. Except the top. And now her voice is all spread and moaned. There is no joy or words here is all maaawwwhhhwwrrr.
There must be a God, after all
@mozart200657 Yeah, La Scala and Met and Covent Garden and Vienna Oper
@CiboCeleste Yes, I realize that other people are hearing things that I don't. Perhaps, I didn't ask my question correctly. What is that leads you to believe she had some technical problems/ what kind of technical problems do you mean.
non si ccapisce una parola!!! nell'opera il suono non basta, bisogna recitare. le italiane sono the best!!!
Well.... Anna Netrebko is a great artist so we are talking about a really good opera-singer.I think the biggest problem are: she is not a real coloratura and she tries to sing more dramatically. Besides... I really don't care that her breathing not perfect (i can hear her support is not 100%ly) but honestly I DO NOT CARE. I'm enjoying what she do, I think she is very good as an artist as well as a singer. Her performance is very amazing. It is more important to me, and her voice is beautiful!
hahahaha love it
@CiboCeleste ahh okay. thank you for your info! :D
Hedious
@CiboCeleste Why do you say that? I'm only just becoming introduced to the opera world, so most of the comments criticisms, critiques, etc mean nothing to me because I don't understand what they are criticquing. All I know is that I hear a beautiful voice that's way better than what I can vocalize. LOL!
Ouch....
ma perché i tenori hanno la tenorite e non hanno la voce?
Does anyone think that Anna hasn't been looking real healthy lately? I've been noticing this, can't figure out if it's just weight gain or something is wrong with her health (maybe doing too much, stress, I don't know!)
@marioj34
She is even better than Callas
She is MUCH BETTER than Callas!!! 😂😂😂
Donna Anna però è troppo pesante per Anna Netrebko... spero che non si scassi, sarebbe un vero peccato
Inespressiva, almeno per me...
I am so fed up with comments challenging the commentators to "do it better." And audiences' responses are neither undeserved nor proof of greatness. I found her interpretation of Anna moving. However, she seemed to struggle a lot. My suspicion: She wants to be a spinto, which she's not. Everything is too chesty and she has major breath problems, causing her coloratura and phrasing to suffer. Hence she's forced to use inappropriate musical mannerisms. And she should lay off the cortisone.
MINUTO 2.19. si sente DISTINTAMENTE un SALTINO DELLA VOCE DOVUTO AD UNA INTERFERENZA DEL MICROFONO!!!!! un MICROFONO ALLA SCALA! vergogna.
Où cette chanteuse a appris à chanter ? La Scala décidément est descendue bien bas...! Quant à Filianotti c'est pis que tout ! Stephane Lissner me semble-t-il l'avait viré de Don Carlo il y a peu, hummm !!
Suoni troppo coperti, com'è di moda oggi. Non si capisce un tubo, e questa (com'è oggi) non è una voce per Mozart. Ma è di moda oggi cantare tutto copertissimo e oramai i cantanti, di cui la A.N., sono diventati dei robot. Anche colpa dei conservatori e "maestri" che non insegnano più la dizione, il legato, lo squillo e la prosodia. Voce pienamente fabricata (molto bella) ma fredda e senza corpo (vocale)
Brava Anna stai diventando una vera cantante.
L'aumento di peso è anch'esso un buonissimo segnale!!
Brava! Peccato per la dizione....ehm ehm
This is one of the most horrendous performances of this aria I have ever heard. Its insulting that she will go on stage (at la scala no less where tickets are anything by affordable) and sing this garbage, knowing full well this is not a role for her. Its out of tune and sloppy. It enrages me that she can go anywhere and sing anything as horribly as she wants to and people will worship her regardless. She is really shameless.
A real horror...
Lamentable!!!