If I had a penny for everytime people say a song is a "flop" just because it doesn't have a billion views in 3 days and doesn't outsell Taylor Swift, I would be a billionaire
@Wojt200 she is least popular member in blackpink for a reason, she is not good enough to be same level as jisoo even lol , her voice like a goat lol dying goat
let's be real, Bruno featuring DID help APT in charts, but it still would have been successful without Bruno. APT is a fun song featuring a Korean game with a fun chant. that in itself secured APT's success.
Plz. It if wasn't for Bruno, that song wouldn't be getting those streams. All of her songs, streams numbers has been low, for somoneone who has 50+k ML in spotify. Toixic with all that promo only charted #90 bb 100 & #1 girl didn't chart at all. The majority of her success been the Apt song, not her ablum or other songs. So yes Bruno dramatically help her.
Rosé album was already highly anticipated when she started teasing her work. If a flop is beating Mariah at number 1 and surpassing Billie eilish 😂😂😂 people are hating for no reason and discrediting her hard work
Idk how she flopped. She got 176 M streams on Spotify first week . Third female artist in world to do so with a debut album (joining olivia and Billie) . She was #3 on ALBUM sales highest for any female korean act . She is #1 on digital artist ranking surpassing Bruno mars , She is the first ever FEMALE ARTIST IN WORLD TO CHART A SONG IN TOP 10 in World's biggest music market . Grammy has praised her she is starting and this is amazing for a debut album. She also joins camila and beyoncé to gain 100M+ streams for debut album
Check some of your "facts". FACE & GOLDEN has more sells and was rank #2 in bb 200. Her ablum total streams was mostly do to Atp , cuz bruno. Take that song out, thier goes her streams.
@@starrynight2638 check again it's female act and yeah definitely bruno that's why her ranks increased after releasing album and more singles got it . Dyk Bruno has collabed with other female artists still Rosé is the one in history to ever chart a song in top 10 in World's top ten market highest albums sales in australia for any Korean act? YK what Bruno Mars contributed to apt but it would have been successful even without him cause it's an upbeat song about a game which is unique itself
Her song toxic till the end didn't charted well like apt but isn't bad to consider flop. APT get number position in many charts but toxic till the end also enter in top 10 of many charts. It just one fandom and some BP solo stans who are calling rosé flop All this below ranking about toxic till the end not about apt. 5th rank at circle chart 4tn debut at uk chart #ROSÉ's self-written and self-produced debut studio album 'rosie' scores the Highest New Entry on this week's United World Chart, landing at No. 1! 💪🔝🆕💥1⃣🌎👑❤️🔥 ROSÉ is the 1st Asian Soloist in history to top both the United World Albums and Singles charts simultaneously with 'rosie
Bruno did play a huge role in her success, especially with apt. All of her songs, streams numbers has been low, for somoneone who has 50+k ML in spotify. Toixic with all that promo only charted #90 bb 100 & #1 girl didn't chart at all. Her ablum itself under perform, Sure it had sales but that's about it. Take out apt, the majority of that ablum streams is gone. Yall seriously downplaying Bruno Impact, especially since his already siting on #1 song "die with a smile".
Ella es super inteligente en cada movimiento que hace....tiene su propia agencia ,tiene a Atlantic Records, Warner Music y Blacklabel....algunos realmente no le perdonan que sea bella, compositora, una voz que trasmite emociones como muy pocos, y sobre todo que es muy inteligente!!!!! Me encanta ver mujeres tan activas involucrada en todo respecto a su carrera.....algunas mujeres reconocemos esto y otros simplemente la odian justamente por esto...es que realmente reunir todas estas condiciones es bastante difícil!!!!!
Her 60 ml are from Bruno …. And no I’m not saying this out of nothing. She had 2 m monthly listeners days before the Bruno collab. After days of apt she had 40 ml all of a sudden bc Bruno ml boosted her… Is not her impact! Is Bruno! If it was her impact all of her other songs would be making 10 million streams daily like jk and jm has been doing when they released their album! And they had less ml . Is about impact ! lol y’all need to stop pretending she has demand 😅
She was posting the success of the first song just for her to stay cricket on the others. 😅😅😅 It’s not that she flopped totally but she would have never reach that heights with out Bruno, PERIOD!!
Nahh becoz of her and her fans her ex who has nothing to do with her now is getting hate She is one of wannabe s of taylor nothing else Bruno made her album to chart If she didnt included apt in her album It was gonna flop Also the amount of playlisting and payola done by her was literally something else
@spawn3721 I'm not a kpop stans for ur info also what I said is true if u r tal3nted u don't need payola but ur favs don't understand this and look for payola We can only be no. 1 if we really have passion
Flop rosé with her depression, i am already depressed i dont want to listen your love life and kissing some dude on mv talking about your ex and cause one innocent men got online hate because you wanted make some kind of drama and promote your flop album
No wonder without blackpink of bruno , she didn't even chart that high meanwhile lisa is ruling everything and lisa can't even sing 😂😂😂😂 , maybe rose need to stop singing depression and start singing love and happiness
@@Kpop_jokes Lisa ruling everything let's be real bro 💀 like seriously . She is flopping way harder than I think. And also she is nowhere in the chart 📈 🗑️
Rose did flop with the other singles lmaooo none of them reached the heights APT did , Bruno helped her out a lot without him, her album would’ve done much worse. Lisa has also been flopping lmaooo.
No, you fool. The Western market is super competitive right now, with good songs landing on the charts left and right. For Rosé, who is transitioning from an idol to an artist in the West, it will be super difficult. Even Lisa is struggling, and she's more popular than Rosé. Lisa can barely top the charts, and the same can be said about Jennie. It's going to take them a while to find their footing.
She was posting the success of the first song just for her to stay cricket on the others. 😅😅😅 It’s not that she flopped totally but she would have never reach that heights with out Bruno, PERIOD!!
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
If I had a penny for everytime people say a song is a "flop" just because it doesn't have a billion views in 3 days and doesn't outsell Taylor Swift, I would be a billionaire
@Wojt200 she is least popular member in blackpink for a reason, she is not good enough to be same level as jisoo even lol , her voice like a goat lol dying goat
let's be real, Bruno featuring DID help APT in charts, but it still would have been successful without Bruno. APT is a fun song featuring a Korean game with a fun chant. that in itself secured APT's success.
Plz. It if wasn't for Bruno, that song wouldn't be getting those streams. All of her songs, streams numbers has been low, for somoneone who has 50+k ML in spotify. Toixic with all that promo only charted #90 bb 100 & #1 girl didn't chart at all. The majority of her success been the Apt song, not her ablum or other songs. So yes Bruno dramatically help her.
@@starrynight2638 No rose = no apt
Also these haters are forgetting that first it's her debut album and second it's Christmas season current 🙄
Lisa released at the same time as Gaga and Bruno and still managed to came second only to be slowed down by Bruno and Gaga.
Rose just simple flopped.
@KM10HM12 bro she released it in August not December like seriously 😒
Just because a song doesn't have a gazillion views doesn't mean it flopped. She is doing really good and doing far better than many kpop idols
True
Rosé album was already highly anticipated when she started teasing her work. If a flop is beating Mariah at number 1 and surpassing Billie eilish 😂😂😂 people are hating for no reason and discrediting her hard work
Idk how she flopped. She got 176 M streams on Spotify first week . Third female artist in world to do so with a debut album (joining olivia and Billie) . She was #3 on ALBUM sales highest for any female korean act . She is #1 on digital artist ranking surpassing Bruno mars , She is the first ever FEMALE ARTIST IN WORLD TO CHART A SONG IN TOP 10 in World's biggest music market . Grammy has praised her she is starting and this is amazing for a debut album. She also joins camila and beyoncé to gain 100M+ streams for debut album
Check some of your "facts". FACE & GOLDEN has more sells and was rank #2 in bb 200. Her ablum total streams was mostly do to Atp , cuz bruno. Take that song out, thier goes her streams.
@@starrynight2638 check again it's female act and yeah definitely bruno that's why her ranks increased after releasing album and more singles got it . Dyk Bruno has collabed with other female artists still Rosé is the one in history to ever chart a song in top 10 in World's top ten market highest albums sales in australia for any Korean act? YK what Bruno Mars contributed to apt but it would have been successful even without him cause it's an upbeat song about a game which is unique itself
@@starrynight2638 I like jungkook and everything but wtf does he have to do with anything
Exactly I loved the video so much
Rose go queen so happy that she entered UK charts , ❤❤❤❤
Evident...its hate because is so sucessful.....the woman is so near perfection......
@@Gabriela-j2c5z lol keep being delulu
No one is to blame other than her solos for sitting her up
Her song toxic till the end didn't charted well like apt but isn't bad to consider flop. APT get number position in many charts but toxic till the end also enter in top 10 of many charts. It just one fandom and some BP solo stans who are calling rosé flop
All this below ranking about toxic till the end not about apt.
5th rank at circle chart
4tn debut at uk chart
#ROSÉ's self-written and self-produced debut studio album 'rosie' scores the Highest New Entry on this week's United World Chart, landing at No. 1! 💪🔝🆕💥1⃣🌎👑❤️🔥
ROSÉ is the 1st Asian Soloist in history to top both the United World Albums and Singles charts simultaneously with 'rosie
I don’t get why some kpop stans (like the ones down here) feel the need to be so fucking toxic all the time. Just shut up and enjoy the damn music 😭
Flop is when your own fans are not even streaming it….. oh wait is what really happened.
Fr.. I also want to be flop like rosé❤
Bruno did play a huge role in her success, especially with apt. All of her songs, streams numbers has been low, for somoneone who has 50+k ML in spotify. Toixic with all that promo only charted #90 bb 100 & #1 girl didn't chart at all. Her ablum itself under perform, Sure it had sales but that's about it. Take out apt, the majority of that ablum streams is gone. Yall seriously downplaying Bruno Impact, especially since his already siting on #1 song "die with a smile".
Ella es super inteligente en cada movimiento que hace....tiene su propia agencia ,tiene a Atlantic Records, Warner Music y Blacklabel....algunos realmente no le perdonan que sea bella, compositora, una voz que trasmite emociones como muy pocos, y sobre todo que es muy inteligente!!!!! Me encanta ver mujeres tan activas involucrada en todo respecto a su carrera.....algunas mujeres reconocemos esto y otros simplemente la odian justamente por esto...es que realmente reunir todas estas condiciones es bastante difícil!!!!!
Her 60 ml are from Bruno …. And no I’m not saying this out of nothing.
She had 2 m monthly listeners days before the Bruno collab. After days of apt she had 40 ml all of a sudden bc Bruno ml boosted her…
Is not her impact! Is Bruno!
If it was her impact all of her other songs would be making 10 million streams daily like jk and jm has been doing when they released their album! And they had less ml .
Is about impact !
lol y’all need to stop pretending she has demand 😅
Actually rose has amazing voice , i dont get haters here
She was posting the success of the first song just for her to stay cricket on the others. 😅😅😅
It’s not that she flopped totally but she would have never reach that heights with out Bruno, PERIOD!!
Nahh becoz of her and her fans her ex who has nothing to do with her now is getting hate
She is one of wannabe s of taylor nothing else
Bruno made her album to chart
If she didnt included apt in her album
It was gonna flop
Also the amount of playlisting and payola done by her was literally something else
@@vanshika_7 why are you kpop stans so toxic like calm down take a chill pill and just enjoy the damn music 💀(although the pfp explains everything)
@spawn3721 I'm not a kpop stans for ur info also what I said is true if u r tal3nted u don't need payola but ur favs don't understand this and look for payola
We can only be no. 1 if we really have passion
SHE FLOPPED! PERIODT.
Redefining success?!? 😂😂😂😂
lol you’re too funny.
@KM10HM12 so true
Flop rosé with her depression, i am already depressed i dont want to listen your love life and kissing some dude on mv talking about your ex and cause one innocent men got online hate because you wanted make some kind of drama and promote your flop album
No wonder without blackpink of bruno , she didn't even chart that high meanwhile lisa is ruling everything and lisa can't even sing 😂😂😂😂 , maybe rose need to stop singing depression and start singing love and happiness
@@Kpop_jokes Lisa ruling everything let's be real bro 💀 like seriously . She is flopping way harder than I think. And also she is nowhere in the chart 📈 🗑️
Brainrot
@krishnabali5054 literally lol !!
Let's be honest , rosé sound like sick goat , which is annoying to listen entire album , I barely handle listen her parts in blackpink song.....
Nice joke like ur username 😂
Then don't listen to it
I really want to listen your buffalo voice plz sing for me
@@anjalichaudhary8106 lol
Rose did flop with the other singles lmaooo none of them reached the heights APT did , Bruno helped her out a lot without him, her album would’ve done much worse. Lisa has also been flopping lmaooo.
No, you fool. The Western market is super competitive right now, with good songs landing on the charts left and right. For Rosé, who is transitioning from an idol to an artist in the West, it will be super difficult. Even Lisa is struggling, and she's more popular than Rosé. Lisa can barely top the charts, and the same can be said about Jennie. It's going to take them a while to find their footing.
She was posting the success of the first song just for her to stay cricket on the others. 😅😅😅
It’s not that she flopped totally but she would have never reach that heights with out Bruno, PERIOD!!