sibelius succeeded in bringing schumann's minimalism, which he had conceived of early on, to blossom. maler asked him: which of your works should i perform? sibelius said: none! maler did not notice in his arrogance, in his never-ending build-up of tension in his works, which never managed to resolve, that this giant from the north had long since surpassed him! put your hat in the dust gentlemen, a genius!
It’s one thing listening to a great piece of music on a CD. Watching the artists and their instruments bringing a great piece of music together is another dimension
It would be somewhat unprecedented to have the timpanist be the first to receive the conductor's and the audience's applause, but in this case it would certainly not be inappropriate. For a recording made 20-some years ago, this is simply at the pinnacle of audio and video work. From every aspect, this is a recording for the ages. Why college students are not required to become familiar with this kind of music is a great mystery to me. I'll never forget my music apprciation class in college. That plus an art appreciation class I took at nearby Rutgers Univ. were so life-changing for me. I'm 78. Dec.18, 2022, St. Joseph, MO. In my later years RUclips has become an unspeakably close companion.
I watch this performance almost every week. Everything about it is just as these previous remarks beautifully describe. Was saddened to read the tympanist had died. Watching the facial expressions of the conductor was so much fun as he is like a musical painter creating a masterpiece. 😊❤
spot on ... I agree completely with you in all points ... by the way ... I'm 10 days older than you ... which means Sibelius and I have the same birthday ...
In high school I listened to this Symphony while reading the Trilogy of the Rings. So it was that I thereafter heard this music in my head whenever I thought of that story. Both Sibelius and Tolkien were influences completely foreign to my life back then.
In my youth I use to play Sibelius's 2nd symphony a lot. What I liked best here was the horn section which had a perfect blend and sonority. I loved the whole performance.
There are so few timpanists left in the world who still perform standing up, the way it should be done! You can't play this work sitting down and do it justice. The look of intensity in his face is priceless, lasting even after the final chord is played. He just rocked!
@@michaelrydzynski8307 The reason why timpanists usually sit down while playing is because of having to adjust the peddles at the bottom of each drum . If you stand up you have a tendency to have to balance on one when changing the drum pitch. The passage that is played at the very end of the Organ Symphony requires no peddle adjustments as the notes are already established on the drums
@@davidparrish2534 Yes.I can attest to him being out of breath at the end. I am a timpanist myself and Sibelius has a lot of long timpani rolls in his Symphonies
I always liked the second symphony, but this performance knocks me down completely off my feet. Now I realised this is one of the greatest symphonic works of all times. I only wish Sibelius could hear how beautifully it is played.
Always love Jarvi's work. The typanist (at the end) looks like he's about to have a corornary. or bolt into the orchestra pit. That's what great music can do!!
The timpanist’s face at 45:30 . He was swept up in it all and apparently deeply moved. How great it must feel to be part of a world-class performance of such a magnificent work.
That roll feels like it goes on forever. The conductors ALWAYS want more volume but you have to hold some back because of 1: if you don't your arms will fall off, and 2: They also always want a crescendo in the last bar.......it's one of my favorite pieces to play on timps :)
So was I….. I was reliving playing it for real last night too in Boston, Uk. What a magnificent performance this recording is I keep coming back to it. Having now played it I can tell you it is a real work out too. I’m exhausted today!
Maravillosa interpretación Amo a Sibelius desde hace mucho tiempo Me gustan todas sus sinfonías, pero hasta esta magnífica interpretación no había apreciado el impresionante final Gracias a RUclips por darnos estas maravillas Un enorme abrazo desde Madrid a todos los amantes del gran Sibelius
Just look at the moment 26:34! That is what I call a perfect observation from the camera man. Contributing to our experience of this music. The camera and the picture is also why this consert moves to the highest ranking, in my opinion.
My high school played the 4th movement for our UIL concert along side Verdi La Forza Del Destino. I was principal clarinet, and it was my first time getting to play in a full orchestra. It was one of the coolest experiences ever. The finale has a special place in my heart, so many good memories from rehearsals and the performance itself.
This performance never fails to bring me to tears. This was my introduction to the symphonies composed by Sibelius and I was smitten with his brilliance. I keep listening to the first three and the fifth performed by different orchestras under different conductors. I always feel I learn more and always appreciate the experience. But returning for the fifth or sixth time to this performance I'm reminded of how powerful it is. It takes my breath away... a performance that was 11 years ago. Awesome that it is on RUclips for us to enjoy!
Curtis, I have already listed to this uptaking approximately 50 times. Call me an addict. And still I notice small parts that earlier passed me without noticing them.
Never noticed until this video how physically demanding the tympany can be. This fellow is superb and powerful. The whole thing's the best Sibelius 2 I've heard--no surprise it came from Jarvi. And among the smartest, most intimate camera work I've seen of a symphony. I guess technology just keeps getting better.
Super beautiful. Thank you so mutch for this very best interpretation. Soulish. Master condacter. Exelente. Clear understanding from conception. Super talented and very effective. Brilliant passion!!!!! Super solist every section!!! Thank you so mutch for this music! Beautiful video!
If I shall give this another comment, Paavo always starts his Sibelius in a relatively fast tempo, so also in this one. But after a while it is slowed down. This initial fast tempo shows us that he dont want us listeners to get struck in the usual slow tempo. In this he is right. This fast opening shapen our ears and make us prepared for whatever will come.
I am not ashamed to say, this whole spectacle brought tears to eyes. I have only looked into this work having heard it a few times in the background on France Musique. As someone says further down, the photography was also riveting. I wish I had been there.
And I believe many listeners don´t understand how good this really is. I am not an expert at all, but I have listened to Sibelius a lot, and also his second symphonie. As I see it, this version has a tenderness, a vulnerability, but also a strenght that is unique. Along with many good musicians in this orchestra Paavo Järvi creates a space that is 100 percent Sibelius. At the end even Paavo seems to be a little bit taken of what he and the orchestra together created.
@@staffanolofsson8201 Hi, Staffan, I am in total agreement with you!!…it is a magnificent rendition!!, Sibelius confession. Jarvi”s rendition of Sibelius’s First Symphony is striking. This is superb. Take care.
Vuelvo a escuchar esta interpretación y cada vez descubro nuevas emociones que tan magistralmente transmite esta Orquesta y su Director. Un espectáculo conmovedor. Aparte del propio espectáculo que nos brinda el Timbalero, especialmente en el último movimiento. ¡¡¡¡¡MUCHAS GRACIAS WOCOMOMUSICA¡¡¡¡¡ por subir esta maravilla. Muchas gracias Sr. Järvi, muchas gracias Músicos de la Orquesta de París.
I can almost feel the youthful Sibelius beaming with pride at the completion of this work, a major forward step in his career, culmination of a long period of writing.
Hi Kenneth; I absolutely agree with you!; this is a magnificent rendition, I many times say: like father like son, but better. Please watch Paavo Jarvi conducting Sibelius First Symphony; it is striking!. Take care.
This is an incredible performance of IMHO the greatest symphony of the 20th century (I'll place the Rachmaninov 2 a close second). The video is remarkable and captures all the orchestra members so involved and enraptured by the glorious music, not the least of which is Jarvi's charismatic leading.
I am glad that more and more people appreciate this music. As I said before, this is my favourite. Whenever I have some not so good experiences on RUclips, I can always go back to this one. It never fails.
Just tremendous. The Second was the first of the magnificent symphonies by this great composer that I heard and it never fails to thrill and move me after 57 years!
I am always stunned by the way of constructing musical development in Sibelius music, especially in his symphonies. He possesses ability of creating tension between pure sound of symphonic groups of instruments. Yet, if needed, he can mix the timbres with outstanding skill. Simultaneously he builds phrases very freely and unexpectedly, against classical rules, which gives his music highly individual quality. Sometimes he uses simple melodic motiv, after he create a chord or few, than appears chromatic passage and finally comes sort of conclusion. First perhaps it sounds awkward. And that's the case: you have to listen carefully to understand. It's not simply given to you. You must be very cautious. Sometimes it is music of abrupt changes, sometimes you here grand ostinatos. His style is so complex... Concerning the whole symphonic concept in this particular composition, it's really amazing. Sibelius goes from a bit ambiguous musical ideas (1st and 2nd movements) towards more concentrated and clear themes (3rd and 4th). Each movement has unique shape and expression, nevertheless you are lead to gorgeous finale. Bravo Jarvi and orchestra! Bravo Sibelius!
I have read your arguments with great interest, and I think you are right. And it is always right to talk about such an interesting symphonie. The only thing I have to argue against is that you say that the second movement is ambiguous, and not so concentrated. I prefer to use other words,
Oh I just love this! Thank you for posting it again. The climax of that final movement takes my breath away and moves me to tears. Sibelius 2 is rapidly vying with Tchaikovsky 6 to be my favourite symphony. I am shocked to learn that the brilliant timpanist died not long after this performance. He is a superb, committed musician and that timpani part absolutely makes the climax of this piece. And the camera work is superb - you feel like you are sweating blood with the musicians - bravo to everyone
Happily the timpanist is still alive, it was just a very bad joke from one of our commentators! And I like your enthusiasm about this, I feel the same.
@@staffanolofsson8201 I think the camera director has amazing empathy with the piece and the way he, at the end and during the applause, focuses on the timpanist’s evident relief emphasises that he knows how integral that percussion is to the climax…
@@sim100 Yes, the timpanist has a very important role in this, and the camera people focus on him a bit. Just look a the moment 26:30! And I think he earns this admiration from the cameras.
This is a wonderful gift to us listeners. I have listened to Susanna Mällki and hr-Sinfonieorchester, an exellent interpretation, and now comes this, that even is a little bit better, if such a thing is possible? And what is it with Finnish conductors and Sibelius? Why are their interpretations always better? Is it so simple that they understand his music better? For me Sibelius second is one one his best, if not the best. With its never ending new motives that comes one after the other it is a well of beauty that never fails to inspire. Thank you Paavo Järvi and Orchestre de Paris.
Adoro esta sinfonia. Ella en alguna forma marcó mi vida desde muy joven. Han pasado los años, sigo amando la música como una de las artes más importantes pero sibelius y Mahler... en fin amo la música desde siempre y el arte en todas sus formas.
Music consists of small parts put together in the best way. These small parts can be used or misused. If you dont have a main thought about putting them together you often fail. Sibelius had a lot of small parts in his back yard and luckily he often succeeded in putting them together in a nice way. Indeed, his putting together struck the audience like a hammer. Cause he had understood that all the small parts needed a main idea, an issue to be, a reason. Together this reason and the small parts shapes a whole that is still worth listening to in this second consert. I find Paavo Järvi and Orchestre de Paris the best in putting together all these small parts. With of course this main idea, the reason.
The timpanist is giving it all he's got. He might need a drink or lie down after all that. I imagine the ideas and feelings inspiring this most Finnish of symphonies would be familiar to Ukrainians standing up to Russia in 2022. Finland was, of course, in the process of breaking away from Russia, and Sibelius was certainly patriotic!
Very excellent. The Sagittarian Epic 😇
sibelius succeeded in bringing schumann's minimalism, which he had conceived of early on, to blossom. maler asked him: which of your works should i perform? sibelius said: none! maler did not notice in his arrogance, in his never-ending build-up of tension in his works, which never managed to resolve, that this giant from the north had long since surpassed him! put your hat in the dust gentlemen, a genius!
HFS, I'm in tears. What a performance!
The Fins make a national hero of a classical composer!! In these troubled times they are an inspiration to us all!! Bravo!
It’s one thing listening to a great piece of music on a CD. Watching the artists and their instruments bringing a great piece of music together is another dimension
Absolutely!
No substitute for live music.
@@gazza2933it’s not in live if it is from a recording though.
It would be somewhat unprecedented to have the timpanist be the first to receive the conductor's and the audience's applause, but in this case it would certainly not be inappropriate. For a recording made 20-some years ago, this is simply at the pinnacle of audio and video work. From every aspect, this is a recording for the ages. Why college students are not required to become familiar with this kind of music is a great mystery to me. I'll never forget my music apprciation class in college. That plus an art appreciation class I took at nearby Rutgers Univ. were so life-changing for me. I'm 78. Dec.18, 2022, St. Joseph, MO. In my later years RUclips has become an unspeakably close companion.
This was recorded in 2010.
I watch this performance almost every week. Everything about it is just as these previous remarks beautifully describe. Was saddened to read the tympanist had died. Watching the facial expressions of the conductor was so much fun as he is like a musical painter creating a masterpiece. 😊❤
@@Kaikena The gentleman was 78 when he shared these touching and thoughtful comments. Let's cut him some slack.
spot on ... I agree completely with you in all points ... by the way ... I'm 10 days older than you ... which means Sibelius and I have the same birthday ...
Wow. The finest Sibelius 2nd on RUclips. It's not even close. Bravo Mr. Bean, I mean Paavo ;)
Quietly one of the finest conductors in the world.
and obviously having a great time doing this piece
In high school I listened to this Symphony while reading the Trilogy of the Rings.
So it was that I thereafter heard this music in my head whenever I thought of that story.
Both Sibelius and Tolkien were influences completely foreign to my life back then.
I understand the Finnish epic "Kalavela" was a major influence on both Mr Tolkien and Mr Sibelius, so that's entirely appropriate!
In my youth I use to play Sibelius's 2nd symphony a lot. What I liked best here was the horn section which had a perfect blend and sonority. I loved the whole performance.
A Sibelius/Järvi marathon is a good way to spend an evening.
Absolutely monumental-Sibelius’ symphony and this performance.
Jean Sibelius born on this date in 1865. What an amazing legacy he left to mankind. His music is shimmering and so northern sounding
Bravo bravissimo Maestro Paavo Järvi
Jean Sibelius , Symphony , two , in D major , Orchestre de Paris , it was very beautiful and inspiring , Thank you
I love the timpanist! He stands up while playing his drums! BRAVO
There are so few timpanists left in the world who still perform standing up, the way it should be done! You can't play this work sitting down and do it justice. The look of intensity in his face is priceless, lasting even after the final chord is played. He just rocked!
@@michaelrydzynski8307 The reason why timpanists usually sit down while playing is because of having to adjust the peddles at the bottom of each drum . If you stand up you have a tendency to have to balance on one when changing the drum pitch. The passage that is played at the very end of the Organ Symphony requires no peddle adjustments as the notes are already established on the drums
He is out of breath at the end..he gave it his all!
@@davidparrish2534 Yes.I can attest to him being out of breath at the end. I am a timpanist myself and Sibelius has a lot of long timpani rolls in his Symphonies
@@richardwilliams473 Thank you for this explanation!
Timpanist has a moment! Bravo!!! Entire performance is just bravo!
I always liked the second symphony, but this performance knocks me down completely off my feet. Now I realised this is one of the greatest symphonic works of all times. I only wish Sibelius could hear how beautifully it is played.
why can't he?
Agreed. This symphony is up there with the best of Mozart, Beethoven, and Brahms
@@malthus101 Umm.... because he died 65 years ago? You think that could be a reason?
@@budsurtees4224 no I don't.
@@malthus101 So then you have a better reason or explanation for how Sibelius cannot hear his music now?
Paavo Jaervi: control, expression at it's finest. Thank you so much!
Always love Jarvi's work. The typanist (at the end) looks like he's about to have a corornary. or bolt into the orchestra pit. That's what great music can do!!
I love it when he puffs his cheeks out, as if saying, " jeez, I made it, again ".
The timpanist’s face at 45:30 . He was swept up in it all and apparently deeply moved. How great it must feel to be part of a world-class performance of such a magnificent work.
Love the moment at 26:40 as well where you can really feel the hush coming over the orchestra to lead into the slow trio
Totaly!
That roll feels like it goes on forever. The conductors ALWAYS want more volume but you have to hold some back because of 1: if you don't your arms will fall off, and 2: They also always want a crescendo in the last bar.......it's one of my favorite pieces to play on timps :)
TRUELY!!!
Outstanding! I am applauding at home!
So was I….. I was reliving playing it for real last night too in Boston, Uk. What a magnificent performance this recording is I keep coming back to it. Having now played it I can tell you it is a real work out too. I’m exhausted today!
Maravillosa interpretación
Amo a Sibelius desde hace mucho tiempo
Me gustan todas sus sinfonías, pero hasta esta magnífica interpretación no había apreciado el impresionante final
Gracias a RUclips por darnos estas maravillas
Un enorme abrazo desde Madrid a todos los amantes del gran Sibelius
Just look at the moment 26:34! That is what I call a perfect observation from the camera man. Contributing to our experience of this music. The camera and the picture is also why this consert moves to the highest ranking, in my opinion.
Say! I just saw on RUclips a list of the top ten syphonies of all time. Couldn't believe that this one was omitted. March 21, 2023..
Popularity isn’t always indicative of greatness
Super super beautiful music. Absolut amazing orchestra!!!! Very humanistic concept. So beautifuly personal.!!
Браво симфония 2 композитор Сибелиус! Браво оркестр и дирижор Пааво Ярви ! Спасибо. Браво!
Bravo il percussionista Timpanista
Sibelius’s music is instantly recognisable. It has a wonderful shimmering quality and so absolutely northern sounding.
A performance for the ages!
My high school played the 4th movement for our UIL concert along side Verdi La Forza Del Destino. I was principal clarinet, and it was my first time getting to play in a full orchestra. It was one of the coolest experiences ever. The finale has a special place in my heart, so many good memories from rehearsals and the performance itself.
This performance never fails to bring me to tears. This was my introduction to the symphonies composed by Sibelius and I was smitten with his brilliance. I keep listening to the first three and the fifth performed by different orchestras under different conductors. I always feel I learn more and always appreciate the experience. But returning for the fifth or sixth time to this performance I'm reminded of how powerful it is. It takes my breath away... a performance that was 11 years ago. Awesome that it is on RUclips for us to enjoy!
Yes, well put! I hope your cat also likes Sibelius.
Absolutely agree.
Curtis, I have already listed to this uptaking approximately 50 times. Call me an addict. And still I notice small parts that earlier passed me without noticing them.
And Curtis, I cant count the times this has brought me to tears.
Never noticed until this video how physically demanding the tympany can be. This fellow is superb and powerful. The whole thing's the best Sibelius 2 I've heard--no surprise it came from Jarvi. And among the smartest, most intimate camera work I've seen of a symphony. I guess technology just keeps getting better.
Clapping! Smiling! All these years later.
Thank you, I love the first movement of Sibelius' Second.
I love it all! What a performance! Everyone, Bravo!
Utterly beautiful and what a wonderful conductor and orchestra THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH
No performance is as interesting and intriguing and captivating as this performance
From
Tokyo of Japan
Super beautiful. Thank you so mutch for this very best interpretation. Soulish. Master condacter. Exelente. Clear understanding from conception. Super talented and very effective. Brilliant passion!!!!! Super solist every section!!! Thank you so mutch for this music! Beautiful video!
Bellissima interpretazione.
If I shall give this another comment, Paavo always starts his Sibelius in a relatively fast tempo, so also in this one. But after a while it is slowed down. This initial fast tempo shows us that he dont want us listeners to get struck in the usual slow tempo. In this he is right. This fast opening shapen our ears and make us prepared for whatever will come.
This was simply magnificent, I was breathless at the end. I thank you all so much.
You can sense Sibelius patriotic spirit for his homeland in this work. The Finale is emotionally powerful. Bravo
MANY, MANY THANKS !!!
Now that's a Symphony!
I am not ashamed to say, this whole spectacle brought tears to eyes. I have only looked into this work having heard it a few times in the background on France Musique. As someone says further down, the photography was also riveting. I wish I had been there.
This is the best interpretation of Sibelius second symphony I ever heard. Paavo Järvi, warm thanks!
And I believe many listeners don´t understand how good this really is. I am not an expert at all, but I have listened to Sibelius a lot, and also his second symphonie. As I see it, this version has a tenderness, a vulnerability, but also a strenght that is unique. Along with many good musicians in this orchestra Paavo Järvi creates a space that is 100 percent Sibelius. At the end even Paavo seems to be a little bit taken of what he and the orchestra together created.
@@staffanolofsson8201 Hi, Staffan, I am in total agreement with you!!…it is a magnificent rendition!!, Sibelius confession.
Jarvi”s rendition of Sibelius’s First Symphony is striking. This is superb. Take care.
@@suzyserling277 But that is Sibelius Second Symphony, fyi.
nah
Ignacio Cardenas Acuña, This is Sibelius' best and beautiful symphony. And Paavo better interpretations.
Vuelvo a escuchar esta interpretación y cada vez descubro nuevas emociones que tan magistralmente transmite esta Orquesta y su Director. Un espectáculo conmovedor. Aparte del propio espectáculo que nos brinda el Timbalero, especialmente en el último movimiento. ¡¡¡¡¡MUCHAS GRACIAS WOCOMOMUSICA¡¡¡¡¡ por subir esta maravilla. Muchas gracias Sr. Järvi, muchas gracias Músicos de la Orquesta de París.
I can almost feel the youthful Sibelius beaming with pride at the completion of this work, a major forward step in his career, culmination of a long period of writing.
I found a new favourite version of my favourite symphony. What a great day. Thank you Maestro Järvi and l'Orchestre de Paris!
Congratulations! I feel the same.
Yes, a kindred spirit here, back to watch it for about the tenth time! So beautiful!!!
Direi esecuzione ed jnterpretazione perfette. Bravissimo.
I like many of the orchestra members smile throughout the play.
I cried several times. Absolutely beautiful performance, enhanced greatly by the videographic values. I loved this.
Hi Kenneth; I absolutely agree with you!; this is a magnificent rendition, I many times say: like father like son, but better. Please watch Paavo Jarvi conducting Sibelius First Symphony; it is striking!. Take care.
After reading this I decided to listen to the whole thing without crying. I broke down in the middle of the third movement.
@@lessismore4470was it at the oboe solo😂
Magnificent performance.. Outstanding timpanist.
Emocionante interpretación, Sr. Järvi y Músicos. comparto la opinión de ser esta la mejor interpretación que he escuchado. ¡¡¡¡¡¡MAGNIFICA¡¡¡¡¡¡¡
This is an incredible performance of IMHO the greatest symphony of the 20th century (I'll place the Rachmaninov 2 a close second). The video is remarkable and captures all the orchestra members so involved and enraptured by the glorious music, not the least of which is Jarvi's charismatic leading.
My favourite performance of this wonderful work. I return to it every day, or so. Magnificent.
I am glad that more and more people appreciate this music. As I said before, this is my favourite. Whenever I have some not so good experiences on RUclips, I can always go back to this one. It never fails.
シベリウスの交響曲第２番。
北欧情緒、溢れる感じがとても好きです。
クライマックスで奏でられるトランペットの旋律は最高ですね。
An absolute favorite is the haunting melody that begins 31:00 and then repeats at 38:55, thrilling!
굉장히 좋은 연주입니다 전집CD 구매했어요
Браво композитор Ян Сибелиус симфония 2! Браво дирижор Пааво Ярви и оркестр ! Спасибо, браво!
Che meraviglia! Splendida sinfonia, orchestra e direttore superbi!
Thank you so much for exellent camera work in this uptaking. It is perfect!!!
The BBC Proms camera people are truly amazing at zooming in on the right instrument at the right time. These people are just as good!
Il percussionista fantastico!!!!👏👏👏👏👏
Just tremendous. The Second was the first of the magnificent symphonies by this great composer that I heard and it never fails to thrill and move me after 57 years!
Simply amazing! Very intense music!
Hace 60 años que canto y lloro con esta música...
Yo tambien!
An amazing performance but an especially excellent video, close ups of the musicians, the intensity of Jarvi, just feel like you're there. Bravo!!!
God bless the timpanist!!! ♥️
Yes, and he is still alive.
A truly masterful rendition, excellently executed! The best I have heard. Superb orchestration. A pure delight.
シベリウスシンフォニー2番を聞いて、自然の厳しさをさまざまと見せつけられた気持ちになりました。時々垣間見る美しい風景は素晴らしいですね。ありがとうございました。🎉🎉❤
I am always stunned by the way of constructing musical development in Sibelius music, especially in his symphonies. He possesses ability of creating tension between pure sound of symphonic groups of instruments. Yet, if needed, he can mix the timbres with outstanding skill. Simultaneously he builds phrases very freely and unexpectedly, against classical rules, which gives his music highly individual quality. Sometimes he uses simple melodic motiv, after he create a chord or few, than appears chromatic passage and finally comes sort of conclusion. First perhaps it sounds awkward. And that's the case: you have to listen carefully to understand. It's not simply given to you. You must be very cautious. Sometimes it is music of abrupt changes, sometimes you here grand ostinatos. His style is so complex...
Concerning the whole symphonic concept in this particular composition, it's really amazing. Sibelius goes from a bit ambiguous musical ideas (1st and 2nd movements) towards more concentrated and clear themes (3rd and 4th). Each movement has unique shape and expression, nevertheless you are lead to gorgeous finale.
Bravo Jarvi and orchestra! Bravo Sibelius!
Interesting observations, well formulated. Thank you.
I have read your arguments with great interest, and I think you are right. And it is always right to talk about such an interesting symphonie. The only thing I have to argue against is that you say that the second movement is ambiguous, and not so concentrated. I prefer to use other words,
This is a fantastic recording. Just sublime.
Oh I just love this! Thank you for posting it again. The climax of that final movement takes my breath away and moves me to tears. Sibelius 2 is rapidly vying with Tchaikovsky 6 to be my favourite symphony. I am shocked to learn that the brilliant timpanist died not long after this performance. He is a superb, committed musician and that timpani part absolutely makes the climax of this piece. And the camera work is superb - you feel like you are sweating blood with the musicians - bravo to everyone
Happily the timpanist is still alive, it was just a very bad joke from one of our commentators! And I like your enthusiasm about this, I feel the same.
@@staffanolofsson8201 Thanks Staffan. I am so pleased!!!
@@staffanolofsson8201 I think the camera director has amazing empathy with the piece and the way he, at the end and during the applause, focuses on the timpanist’s evident relief emphasises that he knows how integral that percussion is to the climax…
@@sim100 Yes, the timpanist has a very important role in this, and the camera people focus on him a bit. Just look a the moment 26:30! And I think he earns this admiration from the cameras.
Sim, I am a little curious, you say "thank you for posting it again". When was it posted the first time?
Magnificent performance! Jean Sibelius would be so proud of all of you!
Absolutely marvelous!
Congratulations Merci
A pinnacle of humanity expressing the divine
This is a wonderful gift to us listeners. I have listened to Susanna Mällki and hr-Sinfonieorchester, an exellent interpretation, and now comes this, that even is a little bit better, if such a thing is possible? And what is it with Finnish conductors and Sibelius? Why are their interpretations always better? Is it so simple that they understand his music better? For me Sibelius second is one one his best, if not the best. With its never ending new motives that comes one after the other it is a well of beauty that never fails to inspire. Thank you Paavo Järvi and Orchestre de Paris.
Järvi is Estonian
@@jonathanwidell7176 Indeed; not Finnish at all. Certainly one the great conductors.
as far as I'm concerned Paavo has one of the best interpretations out there. Strikes the mark impressively in key points
That was utterly stunning.
unice, fantastik, phänomenal, konsequent! thanks master!
Great of Sibelius is off the charts
Adoro esta sinfonia. Ella en alguna forma marcó mi vida desde muy joven. Han pasado los años, sigo amando la música como una de las artes más importantes pero sibelius y Mahler... en fin amo la música desde siempre y el arte en todas sus formas.
I've been to a concert in Tallinn where Paavo Järvi conducted this same symphony (performed by an Estonian orchestra). Same unbounded energy but live.
The brass at the end.... Wow!
You are so amazing, Paavo!!!
Great interpretation for this
wonderful symphony.
Music consists of small parts put together in the best way. These small parts can be used or misused. If you dont have a main thought about putting them together you often fail. Sibelius had a lot of small parts in his back yard and luckily he often succeeded in putting them together in a nice way. Indeed, his putting together struck the audience like a hammer. Cause he had understood that all the small parts needed a main idea, an issue to be, a reason. Together this reason and the small parts shapes a whole that is still worth listening to in this second consert. I find Paavo Järvi and Orchestre de Paris the best in putting together all these small parts. With of course this main idea, the reason.
I have loved Sibelius for a long time. I have never heard a better description of his work than yours. It is so true. Thank You.
@@jamesmatthews905 Thank You!
Thanks for reposting this amazing performance after it was taken down earlier this year. The ending of this inspiring work is truly titanic.
This is a special performance. Superb!
The timpanist is giving it all he's got. He might need a drink or lie down after all that. I imagine the ideas and feelings inspiring this most Finnish of symphonies would be familiar to Ukrainians standing up to Russia in 2022. Finland was, of course, in the process of breaking away from Russia, and Sibelius was certainly patriotic!
감사합니다
What a brilliant performance!
Great symphony, amazing performance ❤❤❤
Bravo!
L'orchestre de Paris est en grande forme et ce grand chef sait parfaitement restituer toutes les nuances de cette symphonie lumineuse
¡¡Excelente interpretación!! Me gusta esta Orquesta con su director. Son sobresalientes.
PERFECTION.
Magistral interpretación de una bellísima sinfonía de Sibelius. Para oir una y otra vez y disfrutar siempre
I like Orchestre de Paris because of clarity and superb sound. easily distinguishable from other orchestras.