@Markus What size nib is your Lamy 2000? I'm really considering one at the moment (current Safari owner). I like the M, I'm told the 2K nibs are different.
i dont mean to be so off topic but does anybody know of a way to log back into an Instagram account? I was dumb forgot the account password. I love any assistance you can give me
@Roy Jacoby I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site on google and I'm in the hacking process atm. I see it takes a while so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
Your Sailor King of Pens Pro Gear Sky... be still my heart. My favourite nib is the H-MF LF (Lefty) on my Sailor 1911L. I don't know what makes a "Lefty" nib a lefty, but writing with it feels better than the non-lefty one, for me anyway; and I'm right-handed. I tried different H-MF at the store, and I was always going back to this one. I didn't realize it was a "Lefty" until I got home. When I went back to get the silver trim, there were no more, and a restock wasn't planned. This was in the fall of 2018. I haven't seen any lefties anymore. My second favourite is my Fine 14kt nib on my Montblanc Meisterstück 144 - not nail hard at all. My third is the H-B 21kt on a 1911L, then my H-F 21kt (yup) on my 1911S. Honourable mention: Pilot Petit1. I love these types of videos. Thank you so much!
I think Pilot Vanishing Point's 18kt gold nibs are criminally underrated. The pen being retractable completely overshadows the nib's performance. It's extremely smooth, and quite springy for how narrow it is.
I love how steep the pen can go without any performance issues! I write at a really steep angle (approaching 80 / 90 degrees) and my VP always delivers. Both the F and M nib have served me well. I'm waiting to try a Stub nib, maybe for the next special edition...
I agree. I'm a big fan of Pilots. I have several Falcons, some from the days when they bore the Namiki brand and more recent ones under the Pilot brand. Figboot is right that individual nibs on the same model of pen can have their own personalities. But I also have several VPs, in all sizes (B, M, F, and EF) and they are uniformly consistent and great writers. My only mild complaint about the VP is the way ink can build up in around the closure mechanism, but that just forces me to do regular cleaning of the pen, which is not a bad thing anyway.
@@rsanderson100 I wipe the "section" carefully every time I ink it. If no leaking occurs, the ink will only build up on the door, which is not an issue unless the ink which got stuck on the door is highly reactive ( Baystate Blue, for example).
Thank you for this very well documented nibs comparison that encouraged me to make the big jump of buying a Namiki Emperor last month in Japan. Every day since that purchase, I enjoy the wonderful feeling of precision and dynamism in writing with it. Useful to mention indeed that my handwriting is different that with my other loved nibs (MB149, Pelikan1000, Lamy2000, Waterman Edson, Pilot 845…). It’s more expressive with the nib asking for bigger mouvements and allowing some changes in pressure safely. What a joy!
As a Japanese would you please advise me as to which nib should I choose in a platinum 3776 century. I don't want too broad and too narrow. I like the feedback but I don't want it to be scratchy. Is a medium nib good to go?
@@san2881 Unfortunately, I only have two types of Platinum Century, F and SF. I've heard that B is very smooth and easy to write with. I'm sorry that I'm not much help.
@@san2881After living in Japan in 1968 and 1969, I fell in love with Japan. I did take a group of students to Japan in 2001, but I have had little chance to return. My best friend married an American educator’s daughter in Ibaraki, and they eventually settled up in the Sapporo area. I would love to visit them, as we are each in our late 70s now. I hate the cold though. My question is did you still hold to the Custom Urushi and it’s # 30 nib? I know Figboot loves the #50 on the Emperor, but I have a tendency to think the one I can stretch to buy, especially if I see an old Montblanc 149. Are you still happy with the Pilot Custom Urushi? Or, did you too reach for the Namiki Emperor?
Just wanted to thank you. I purchased my first starter pen today and I got the Faber-Castell Loom. I was planning my first trip to the fancy pen shop near me on Friday then they announced on social media they were closing the shop again because of COVID numbers increasing. ☹️ Found a Loom in an art store and the color I liked was $15 less than the other colors for some reason. 🙌🏼🙌🏼 I purchased without being able to try it based on your recommendation and I couldn’t be happier. It’s so smooth and a great size for my hand and I like the weight versus some of the plastic and aluminum models I was considering.
Great video, as always! I'd say my favorite nib is the nib on my 1950 pelikan 400. I got it from my grandfather (it was his pen) and it was in dire need of love. I fixed and tuned the nib, freed up the piston and polished out most of the scratches that were gathered by decades of use. It is just so supple, smooth and wet it is unbelievable. Next up would be my 18K Visconti HS F nib followed by the EF nib on my TWSBI Precision.
WOW! All Japanese top 3! Not surprising at all I guess. Sailor and Pilot are easy to recommend for that near perfect writing experience. And I appreciate how you don't write off those steel nibs just because they're inexpensive, I've had some amazing steel nibs in my collection too. If they were stamped 14K or 18K, no one would question if they were really gold or not. I just spent a bunch of time tuning, heat setting a $200 Bock #8 14K nib. It kept running dry even though there was enough spacing between the tines. I finally had to increase the air exchange by modding the feed to get the desired ink flow. It should have been perfect out of the box for the price.
I never thought I'd ever watch one of these list videos and agree with literally everything on it, but the day has come; even down to the honourable mentions and the Loom. Haven't tried three of them, but I can see why they'd be nice nibs. The only thing I'd add for people who love feedback is the Platinum President, which I think is both the best looking nib in existence and the best feeling heavy feedback nib. I have a theory about why Pilot/Namiki nibs feel so good. If you look at the tip of the nib, it isn't a smooth curve like any other nib. Instead, the Pilot nibs have this unique feature where the tines kink and narrow the part of the tines closest to the tipping. Seems to me like it acts as a little needle with a lot more spring to it than a straight curve from shoulder to tine.
My family has shifted over to mostly using Platinum nibs somewhat organically. It's only been this year that I discovered just how good the Platinum nibs are, after a long time with Montblanc and PIlot nibs. Platinum sort of swept through the house and took over. My everyday writing pens (which are always my current favorite nibs) are now a #3776 Music and UEF. I avoided the feedback train for too long, only to discover just how good it can be.
I cannot afford gold nib pens. How about a list of top 10 steel nibs? And my biggest problem with steel nibs is that most pens uses either Bock or Jowo nibs. Should we consider in house tuning (Diplomat) or grinds (Franklin-Christoph)?
Gadget yoyo Until I got my first Lamy 2000 (on eBay), I rather had multiple Lamy Safari's, Al Stars or 4 TWSBI's Eco with different nib sizes. But nothing compares to my Lamy 2000 with an F nib. And you can only write with one pen at a time, can't you? Sell your Safari's and save for a Lamy 2000. You won't regret it for a minute!
Why are Jowo and Bock nibs a "problem?" Jowo in particular makes excellent nibs that can be tuned or ground to your taste. And both companies make gold nibs, while Bock also makes titanium nibs. To dismiss these excellent steel nibs as a problem doesn't make a lot of sense.
Gadget yoyo The Lamy Safari is a good pen, but the Diplomat Aero with a medium or broad nib is better and the Lamy 2000 with any size nib is better yet. Franklin Christoph is good, but I don’t find their nibs to be worth the money. So I agree that one Lamy 2000 is worth 5 Safaris.
A couple of nibs I enjoy a lot and no one mentioned: 1) The red-lacquered steel Bock #6. It is not just the color, it is actually a lot more bouncy than other bock steel nibs. 2) The "flex" nib that comes on Ranga eyedropper pens - I am not sure who makes it, but it is amazing - smooth and bouncy
I'm not surprised to see so many Pilot/Namiki nibs. Even though I only have inexpensive Pilots, I love the nibs. Also, thumbs up for the Leonardo and the Loom.
I feel like it as a near perfect daily driver nib. It feels awesome, gets the job done every time and I don't have to worry too much about damaging it. I'm dying to try some of Pilot's high end nibs tho.
Great video Dave and a great concept. The heart of the fountain pen IS the nib. i gotta agree with many of you choices but may i add in a few of my favorites: The Platinum 3776 century Kumpoo Soft M nib, Nakaya Heki Tamenuri Soft M nib, Aurora Optima Med nib, Pilot VP med nib and Omas Paragon Med. What do you think?
Bryan thank you for mentioning the Platinum Kumpoo with Soft Medium nib. It is glorious! I will have a Omas Paragon Medium in just a few hours and am thrilled you mentioned it. Was also disappointed the Platinum President not on this list as it has a great nib. You never see me post comments but had to let you know I Agree with you. .Thanks so much. Barbara
I’ve been wanting to see a video like this. It’s hard to parse how different pen manufacturers tune their nibs in comparison to each other and you do a good job describing how each of them feel.
Thanks, this was very informative. Some other nibs I find great and would recommend: 1) Aurora nibs are amazing. They are stiff but smooth and very precise. 2) Santini: the regular gold nibs are somewhat similar to the Auroras in their pleasant feedback. 3) Parker Duofold nibs are also stiff but they are glass smooth. 4) Leonardo steel nibs are amazing. (The are made by Bock, but tuned/modified by Leonardo) The best steel nibs I have. +1) It's fun to have a titanium nib in your collection, it's a significantly different writing experience.
+1 on issues with Leonardo. Their steel Bock nibs are hit and miss, with a lot of misses. They are switching to Jowo as we speak - probably shows the level of unhappiness...
Are the Pelikan M800 nibs true to size. I know you've said the M1000 nibs write much thicker and have heard that many places however I was not sure if this was specific to M1000 or all Souverän pens.
@@FigbootonPens I see. Do you have any M800's you could do a writing sample of or perhaps a video on this subject already? I want to be able to see negative space in between both upper & lower case letters on dot grid paper but also want to have a nib that lays a good flow of ink down and clearly demonstrates all the shading characteristics of most inks. I find that some Japanese EF nibs are too narrow to truly demonstrate strong shading in most inks. I'm leaning towards an F M800 but would consider EF if you think the F writes more like a Medium. Thanks for making such informative videos. Definitely subscribed to the channel.
I just recently had my Great Grandfather's Parker Vacumatic Major (1945q2) with a 14k gold nib (fine, I believe), and it's now my favorite to write with. it's silky even on the copier paper I have to write on at work.
A bit surprised to not see the diplomat aero pen, since you mentioned few times is among your personal favourites. Still, thanks for the review, keep learning about pens with you
You mentioned Mike Matsuyama several times. I have a Franklin Christoph Panther with a Matsuyama 14K medium Cursive Italic that is in my top 10 nibs. It is a custom grind, but all of the others on my list are "out of the box" nibs. They include a Montblanc JFK with a BB nib, at Montblanc Unicef Legrand with OB nib, a Lamy Studio with 14K medium nib, a Waterman Carene with 14k medium nib, and a Faber Castell Loom with Broad steel nib. I love very smooth nibs - the "writing on glass" smoothness. So, I appreciate your description of the Pelikan 800. And I would very much appreciate hearing your comments on the Scribo. My favorite pen "guru" has suggested that a Scribo should be my next pen.
Nice list . Another nib that I am constantly amazed by is the steal nib on the Leonardo Furore - possibly the best steal nib I have ever used. Some interesting nibs in your video that I want to try.
I love the 0.6 Stub Nemosine Nibs. They are so smooth and I can use them even though I write small. Sadly they are no longer but I was able to hoard a few nibs!
David. Great review and list here. I am looking to replace the nib on my Fuliwen World Map pen. Could you recommend a nib that would both fit and give me a great writing experience. I am looking for a FINE nib. I am a noobie pen enthusiast and know nothing about replacing nibs. Thanks,
Hard to argue with this list, David! Least wise, I hit on most of the honorable mentions (823, Falcon, 2000 and Pelikan M800 for me) and a couple of the "true" top 10s -- F-C Loom, Momento Zero Grande, Omas Arco and in wait for my birthday, the Pilot 845. I have to agree with your comments on the M-Z-G -- what a terrific writer and that's with the steel nib! You've inspired me to put my F-C Loom back into rotation.
Good and interesting info, thanks. Worth the 8 ads. I break my nib favorites into two (unordered) groups: Pleasant to use: Faber-Castell Basic B Kaweco Sport BB Karas Kustoms Fountain K Titanium F Noodler's Triple Tail Flex Useful for drawing: Pilot Elite Posting Nib (least feathering nib I have) Pilot Petit1 (nothing special, but deserved being on the list since I use it 95% of the time) Pilot Parallel 6.0 (ground at an angle by Toronto Pen Company) I seem to be on Team Pilot. Oh, and one dishonorable mention: I hate my custom ground TWSBI Eco Architect. Be careful what you wish for.
@@x-changex-outx-oner8224 It's designed to be used on low quality Japanese postcards. The tip is turned down slightly. Generally available in the 912, I believe.
This was fun and instructive to watch. Thanks. This list is very much a personal taste list. For me, if I cannot get a lot of line variation I am not interested in the pen. In addition I just cannot enjoy any nib thicker than an EF point. I would also include some vintage pens to my list. And you did not include nibs that were modified. I would have added some that I have. So I guess I will have to do what you just did but with my favorites. Thanks again for the video.
Did you ever make one of these list videos? We have similar preferences so I checked out your channel but didn’t see one. What are the best/your favorite nibs that meet this criteria (very fine + capable of producing some expressive line variation) and are readily available (i.e. non-modified and not rare vintage)?
Thanks, well done--Just curious you stated that you were on a Flight and writing with the "Namiki Emperor". I'm fairly new to Fountain pens, but I thought flying with a fountain pen, in which Air pressure changes are typical, can cause the pens to leek.--Can you explain what you do so that doesn't happen.--E
I had to come back and watch this a second time while I decide on additions to the collection. Trying to narrow down the right KOP and patiently waiting for Bulkfillers to be available again. I’m torn on the Emperor because I don’t typically care for the cigar shape as much.
I appreciate your description of the Pelikan M800 nib, it makes it definite for me not to get one. I hate glassy smooth nibs, which had been my main complaint about my Lamy 2000 until I got it re-ground.
I have two Pelikan pens. One has a medium nib which writes more like a broad and has a stubbish quality. It is smooth and a wet writer. I like it. The other had a very smooth, non-bouncy, fine nib. It was boring to me, so I switched it to a medium with an architect grind, and now I like it. So I agree, if you don’t like smooth nibs, you might not like the Pelikan.
Very nice stuff! Lol! Not the "Hall of very good" LoL! My current favorites are vintage, one is a stiff Sheaffer's Balance lifetime, two tone 14k, the other is an Eversharp Skyline 14k nib that currently lives in an Esterbrook J... I call the pen my Estersharp... LoL!
The Loom (F) is the greatest value for me. Lamy 2000 (OM), Pelikan M600 (BB, a bit stiff, but very smooth) are great. On a budget I would also recommend TWSBI Eco (B), in a different league, but for everyday throwaround: great!
@@dariusus9870 Maybe that nib would need some work. Strangely in the shop my F nib was smoother than the M. You can see with a magnifying glass if the tines are well aligned. If it is scratchy that would be my first point to look at.
Thank you for another fine fountain pen video! My favorite nib is a Sailor 21k (black, Imperial) zoom. Prior almost every pen I own was a Fine nib so this was like jumping in the deep side of the pool and I fell in love. I’ve since bought an 18k (black, Imperial) zoom nib but it doesn’t come close. As you say each nib, even with all things being equal, can be different. I think also the pen itself can greatly influence it as well as a story of who gave it to us or a struggle getting it and so many outside and individual aspects.
Riveting video. But the terrific pens themselves (excepting the F-C Loom) were a massive distraction. 🙂 I’ve forever been besotted with sublime nibs in any pen I’ve ever owned or used. This is a splendid list. The Visconti Blue Ripple, particularly, fills me with an aching yearning. Both the pen and that nib. I have a bevy of beloved nibs. A few that instantly spring to mind are (in random order): 18k Broad on my Sheaffer Legacy II 18k Broad - on four of my eight Aurora 88 pens 18k Broad Cursive Italic - Pilot Silvern Tsumugi (sterling silver) 18k Medium - Waterman Exception 21k Broad - Sailor KoP
I have a Moonman T1 with a fine steel nib that is nearly glassy smooth. Along with the medium 14k nib on my Pelikan 605 they are my best performing ones. Followed by a broad steel nib on a TWSBI Diamond 580 and fine steel nib on a TWSBI Diamond Mini. Need to obtain a Faber Castell Loom next. Thanks for your Videos! Always a pleasure to watch!
Medium is a great all-around size typically putting down enough for a smooth line for FP friendly paper and in reverse typically fine enough for regular paper
Wonderful list of modern pens. No disagreement. I would add in HM, Visconti Homo sapiens Bronze Age. But truthfully nothing beats the Waterman Ideal 52 flexible nib. 92 years older and writes like a dream. Most inexpensive great nib, Muji aluminum. Damn good nib for under 20.00.
I really like your videos. Honest and straightforward. This is one of my favorits 👌🏼 Namiki nibs are just outstanding. I have the Pilot custom urushi and love the nib.
Very interesting list! Thanks, David. For the first time, I have _none_ of the items in your final 10 list. I do own and very much like two of your three honorable mention nibs, so your top 10 must be spectacular.
I have watched this video at least 3 times now, so I know you are not likely to read this comment, but I really find it interesting. It challenges me to do something similar. I do own a Sailor KOP, a Pilot Custom 845, a Montblanc e14K nib gift from alumn in e e1992 (not today’s 18K), and ASC pen with a great nib, as well as the Pineider Blue Arco. BTU THE BEST NIB I HAVE IS EASILY ONE ON THE SCRIIBO FEEL. It writes like magic, with softness, smoothness, and a natural flex. Sadly wrong, I love it so much, I don’t use it as much because I fear losing it. You probably complicated my major decision. Right now I had decided that th done additional Grail Pen would be the Pilot Custom Urushi. I had used my limited resource argument to say I should be satisfied with the #30 nib, because the bigger pen (an old, retired prof should not stretch to buy..# 50 on the Emperor. Your rate it so highly that I hesitate now. I am probably still prone to selling the Montblanc (I do not need a prestige symbo, and I believe many of my other pens are superior to it) to justify buying the Pilot Custom Urushi. I think that pen will enough for someone my age and in my stage of life…no more big paydays, living off Social Security and a retirement portfolio, with strong duty to leave enough for my to continue our middle class standard of living after I am gone. I may one day pull the trigger on a Pilot Custom Urushi, for, as you suggest in its review, it is a beautiful nib itself. THANKS FOR EDuCATING AND ENTERTAINING US! Once every 5 to 10 years my wife visit her older sister who lives in Banner Elk, one of two places I have been to in N.C. (I have visited Charlotte.). Beautiful state with greater sanity than California. K
I love the M nib on my Sailor 1911L-the feedback on it is really pleasant and makes it stand out among my pens. I’ve got a Pilot Custom 74 (also M nib) coming and I’m curious to see how it compares to the Sailor. I’ve branched out from my favorite M nibs into B and my favorite so far is a Lamy B mounted onto my stainless steel Lamy Studio-smooth with a nice wet ink flow. For a shot time, I did have a FC Loom and while I liked the nib and how it wrote, I didn’t like the polished grip, as it tended to be too slippery for my fingers so I sold it. I would be willing to give it another try, with a grip that has the more matte finish.
Pilot is more smooth than Sailor, which is matter of taste. I like more feedback for glossier paper I usually work with and Sailor is more exotic brand than Pilot. But there are many people that prefer Custom 74. I like Sailor convertors more than confusing mess of Pilot models, they are smaller in capacity but clean out quickly and fit perfectly. Cartridges are similar, I use them only occasionally.
I dont have any high end pens but my best nibs are my FC's and my Nemosine .6 & .8 stubs! They're extremly smooth and theyre really fun to use. Rip nemosine 😔
I think my favorite nibs in my collection is on my Pineider quill nib forged carbon fiber pen. Very bouncy joyous writer. All my Lamy both gold and steel nibs are nice and smooth. I have 2 old Mont Blanc Nobless one steel one 14k that are nice writers. Just got a vintage 254 that is becoming one of my favorits. I have several Pilots, E95s and Vanishing point and vintage Elites, all wonderful writers. Pilots like Lamy are always reliably nice writers. Sometimes the difference btw good and great are hard to decide. If I had the money, I would go for a Sailor King of Pens, or the Pilot Custom Urushi or the Emperor but can't. I love the look of some of the Visconti, but have heard over and over that their nibs can be a crap shoot and most end up at nib meisters to make them usable. Which tells me that Visconti doesn't seem to have quality Control check their nibs.
I received your letter yesterday, thank you very much! Communication Breakdown really describes my letter well! It definetly is a ink I will look into though, it looks fantastic.
Wow! How opinions can vary. I usually use an oblique dip pen with a cheap Zebra G nib. But I have used some of these and still have a 149 BB that is never used. My favorite flex nib is the Fountain pen Revolution gold super flex. My favorite broad nib is a music 3 tine nib. I do use the broad nibs by Goulet pens also. As far as regular nibs ie medium I use Jin Hao.
Glad you're trying fountain pens! I have 3 of the classic sports, black, burgundy and green. I also have a white skyline sport that came as part of a Kaweco calligraphy set with 1.1, 1.5 and 2.9 mm nibs. My classic sports are all fine nibs. I've heard of a lot of issues with kaweco nibs but I lucked out on all but one of the calligraphy nibs that had flow issues. Jet pens replaced it for me, no problem. It is a good idea to flush out new pens with water and doing so may make your one nib perform better... or not. Could also be the ink. Try one of the black cartridges in it. Different colors from the same manufacturer can be more or less saturated and flow differently. Hope you enjoy your pens! And if you do, I'll wager we'll be seeing a lot more fountain pen invoicing and reviews! 😃 I'd love that.
Interesting list of your personal top 10 nibs. I’m sure it has changed since you made this video. It’s very hard to believe the Faber-Castel Loom edges the Pelikan M 1000 nib but I respect your choices.
Hi David... I have just revisited this video purley to write this comment... I have just taken delivery of a Delta "The Journal" with a Fusion nib... wow! I have a few wonderful gold nibs but this nib is an unusual hybrid and is a joy to write with, better than some of my all gold nibs.
Great list and interesting video, but RUclips placed a commercial every two minutes in your video. That was quite off-putting. I don't know if you are aware of this.
I love your vids. I prefer a smaller pen in my hand but it is fun to see your list, and your AMAZING collection and body of knowledge and experience. Thank you.
why is the 823 only an honorable mention when the nib is the same as your 845? from a nib video standpoint, seems like the 823 should also be ranked #4 here :) anyhoo thanks for the list! i've been hunting for the best nib experiences myself. don't think i'll ever get an emperor or an urushi or a KOP (all too big)-- hopefully will get too try those at some point. that said, good to see that the #15 pilot nibs are essentially the best as that's also been my fave so far so seems like i'm not even missing much.
I would like to see a review of fine nibs. I used to go with mediums all the time, but now use fine. The reason is paper: for everyday writing, I'm not going to buy Rhodia or the like, I'm going to grab a few sheets from the laser printer. My Lamy al Star with a fine nib, does a great job with no bleed through. Or maybe make the review "best nibs for cheap paper".
I recently received a Hondian Black Forest pen in an Inkredible box from Truphae and it is absolutely a dream to write with and easily one of my more favorite pens.
Thanks for a thought-provoking and entertaining video. I was very surprised when you got to the King of Pen at No.3, but I quickly deduced what must then be in first place. I do admire the gorgeous Omas Arco.
Rather late to the game, I am happy to agree that you showcase some mighty fine nibs. I have tested King of Pen and Emperor nibs. Just, wow. In my own collection, my Pineider 14k iperflex, Bock titanium #6, and Pelikan m800 18k reign supreme. But, the first gold nib I purchased was on the Hong Dian Mt. Qomolangma (a #5-ish homage to the Namiki Mt. Fuji?) -- very nice bounce and feedback. I doubt I would sell it, although I can imagine gifting it to someone I really care about, if they have demonstrated their love for fountain pens.
My fav of all your videos! I find that nibs are highly neglected but you succeed in making them the superstar of every pen here! Thank you! I may have added the newest Montbanc Calligraphy nib.
@Figboot on Pens May I ask which nib you will be reviewing on the Scribo? The reason I ask is that I'm about to pull the trigger on a Scribo Feel without having an opportunity to try it personally. For me this is a huge investment, so I'd prefer not to make a mistake. I've watched every review I could find and still can't decide on a nib. Right now, it's down to fine flex or medium flex. I'd love to see your review before I decide. Oops, I meant to put this in the main comments, not the replies. Sorry!
Hello dear David Thank you for the time that you spend making these helpfull vídeos regarding fountain pens, I am new in this wonderful word of fountain pen. David do you recommend to use the blue can lubricant W40 to clean and mantain the nibs of my pens? Thank you again, your follower Alfredo Soto from Sahuayo, Michoacán México.
Recently, in the last year or two, I've been happy with Bock Medium and Fine, both steel and titanium, on Karas Kustom acrylic Vertexes and Decographs and Fountain Ks. I think my most expensive pen is a Cross Townsend Titanium with an 18K Medium. I find it very wet and glassy smooth - but it's not my favorite. But in general, I rotate through pens not only for different inks but also for different "feel", and I often write on 24lb linen paper. Thanks for the video. Some really nifty pens, and nibs.
My collection is only just, getting started but I think my favourite nib I'm gonna split into gold & Steel. Gold has to be my Parker Sonnet Medium. It is so smooth & very wet. It's glorious. Steel has to be my italix Parson's Essential medium. It actually writes a little fine, & has a nice feedback. I love it.
Great list. I have the Visconti and Pelican. And yes they all have their personalities. I also believe that of all my pens, the best nibs are: ST Dupont Line D L'Ateler and even smoother is the older Delta Dolce Vita Large nib which is huge and is as smooth as butter.
Thanks for this video. I enjoyed it a lot! Curious how the nibs on the ASC Bologna and the Wahl-Eversharp Decoband ranked? Given your reviews of both, it was surprising neither made even honorable mention. Anyway, thanks again for your work!!
The Namiki Emperor would have to be at the top of my "want" list for pens, but after experiencing Montblancs, Pilots, Visconti's, Watermans, and Monteverde, my whole house has been surprisingly drifting towards Platinum's nibs. I had dismissed Platinum for a while (generally preferring to stick with Montblanc and PIlot's), but after being really impressed with the steel nibs on the Preppy's and on my wife's Curidas, I picked up a #3776 in UEF and another Music nib (unlike you I tend to only go on extremes, since I generally write (aspirationally) calligraphically with flex nibs or stub/italic nibs), and they pretty much instantly replaced my other nibs for "love to write with" and the overall experience. The nibs themselves are really nice to look at, but the intentionally feedback heavy and stiff nib characteristics that I had previously dismissed grew on me almost instantly. I have so much control and precision with the nibs, and they are surprisingly comfortable to use and a pleasure to experience. After using the smoothly ground Montblancs and Pilots as my daily pens for so long, the Platinum nibs were something of a revelation to me in terms of the virtues of the often decried feedback and stiffness of a nib, something that other equally stiff nibs haven't been able to do before this. There really is something special in the Platinum nib design and grind, to me, at least. It also doesn't hurt that Platinum's feed design really strikes me as exceptionally well done, especially when comparing Music nibs and feed designs across the various makers. Still doesn't stop me from wanting that absolutely delicious and covetable Namiki Emperor though. ;-)
Hi David - thank you for this video, it was a great idea. Would I be able to ask a question? I am interested to know how you feel the Pilot Custom 823 nib compares to the others that actually made it on the top 10 list. I do have a Faber-Castell Loom with both the Fine and Medium nibs (which are surprisingly different from each other) and noticed that it made your list above the 823, which was just an honorable mention. I've long been eyeing the 823 as a bit of a stretch goal, so I would really be interested to hear your thoughts on how it compares, maybe especially with the F-C Loom and Lamy 2000. Thanks! Ken
Excellent review. Just one question about the nib. You said the Faber-Castell Loom is the only one on the list that has a steel nib. However, the Leonardo Momento Zero also has a steel extra fine nib, if I thought about this correctly.
WELL... okay... You're probably NOT going to like it, but I'll play, too... haha... GOOD LUCK finding a fountain pen or adapter to use them... BUT I'm an artist, and we are a bit of a flaky and dubious bunch. I'd have to say I LOVE my D. Leonardo No. 120 Catwinkel nib... BUT my FAVORITE is a Hunt No. 102 Crow Quill lithography nib... When working on a scenery, you just can't beat that nib and the right ink for NAILING the tiniest thistle-fuzz down the stems or cross hatching so fine someone would have to put his forehead RIGHT ON the picture to see that they are (in point of fact) parallel hatching lines in both directions... and not some cleverly magical way to get a neutral gray series of shades out of plain black India Ink on typing or copy paper... AND yeah, if you know anything about ink on paper or line and wash, you know just how damn difficult and dubious THAT sentiment really is. Don't get me wrong, I can get along just fine, in the roughing in stages of sketch, working about any of the Fine and Extra Fine nibs. I almost always end up polishing a new nib with my usual slab of leather... It's impregnated (by my own hand) with valve grinding compound on the suede side... AND black jeweler's rouge on the opposite (skin) side... About 2 minutes of "figure-8" strokes with varying angles and rotations to the pen and I flip the leather exposing the rouge... and 2 minutes or so more of the same, and I alcohol and swab it off... a fine stiff nylon brush is employed to get debris out from between the tines... and it's almost no trouble at all to get writing as smooth as silk stockings on a high polished marble floor... minus the broken legs of course... haha... ;o)
Nice ranking :) Pilot nibs are great whatever the price range. I'm in love with the Emperor and the Custom Urushi (which are the ones I use the most), but if you don't want to go the 4-digits-price-tag, one of my favorite I can recommend from them is the "basic" (hem) 14K medium on Namiki Tradition (their entry level maki-e ebonite pens). To me it's butter smooth and can easily stay 15/20 minutes uncapped without drying (and depending of the ink sometimes without any hard-start, like the Pilot Falcon SE btw). The con of this is I hardly use my capless now ^^.
Thank you for this video! To me, the non is the most important part of a pen, it's size and aesthetics of course also drive me to purchase but if a nib isn't pleasing then I may display it but won't ever used it whereas I'll continue to use a pen that's plain or not as pleasing to the eye if it writes well. :)
![KSI - Dirty [Official Visualiser]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VoDh1h1dPUE/mqdefault.jpg)
My favourite’s the Pilot Kakuno. That happy face is the best part of the nib!
Underrated Pen, its my favorite too!
@@AnaKnitsTooMuchyup!: it’s good, but not big fan of section - give me a Pilot78g+ any day!:)
You know it is going to be a good list when the pilot custom 823, Lamy 2000, Pelikan 1000 and 805, and Montblanc 149 all made honourable mention.
Hahaha!
@Markus What size nib is your Lamy 2000? I'm really considering one at the moment (current Safari owner). I like the M, I'm told the 2K nibs are different.
i dont mean to be so off topic but does anybody know of a way to log back into an Instagram account?
I was dumb forgot the account password. I love any assistance you can give me
@Roy Jacoby I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site on google and I'm in the hacking process atm.
I see it takes a while so I will reply here later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
@Roy Jacoby It did the trick and I now got access to my account again. I'm so happy:D
Thanks so much, you really help me out!
Your Sailor King of Pens Pro Gear Sky... be still my heart.
My favourite nib is the H-MF LF (Lefty) on my Sailor 1911L. I don't know what makes a "Lefty" nib a lefty, but writing with it feels better than the non-lefty one, for me anyway; and I'm right-handed.
I tried different H-MF at the store, and I was always going back to this one. I didn't realize it was a "Lefty" until I got home. When I went back to get the silver trim, there were no more, and a restock wasn't planned. This was in the fall of 2018. I haven't seen any lefties anymore.
My second favourite is my Fine 14kt nib on my Montblanc Meisterstück 144 - not nail hard at all.
My third is the H-B 21kt on a 1911L, then my H-F 21kt (yup) on my 1911S.
Honourable mention: Pilot Petit1.
I love these types of videos. Thank you so much!
I think Pilot Vanishing Point's 18kt gold nibs are criminally underrated. The pen being retractable completely overshadows the nib's performance. It's extremely smooth, and quite springy for how narrow it is.
I love how steep the pen can go without any performance issues! I write at a really steep angle (approaching 80 / 90 degrees) and my VP always delivers. Both the F and M nib have served me well. I'm waiting to try a Stub nib, maybe for the next special edition...
@@Honeycreepin I own a VP stub and it shines when used at a steep angle.
I agree. I'm a big fan of Pilots. I have several Falcons, some from the days when they bore the Namiki brand and more recent ones under the Pilot brand. Figboot is right that individual nibs on the same model of pen can have their own personalities. But I also have several VPs, in all sizes (B, M, F, and EF) and they are uniformly consistent and great writers. My only mild complaint about the VP is the way ink can build up in around the closure mechanism, but that just forces me to do regular cleaning of the pen, which is not a bad thing anyway.
@@rsanderson100 I wipe the "section" carefully every time I ink it. If no leaking occurs, the ink will only build up on the door, which is not an issue unless the ink which got stuck on the door is highly reactive ( Baystate Blue, for example).
Can't agree with more!!! 💯💯
Thank you for this very well documented nibs comparison that encouraged me to make the big jump of buying a Namiki Emperor last month in Japan. Every day since that purchase, I enjoy the wonderful feeling of precision and dynamism in writing with it. Useful to mention indeed that my handwriting is different that with my other loved nibs (MB149, Pelikan1000, Lamy2000, Waterman Edson, Pilot 845…). It’s more expressive with the nib asking for bigger mouvements and allowing some changes in pressure safely. What a joy!
Just got a Pilot Custom Urushi and the nib is absolutely sensational. Perfect ink flow, touch of tactile feedback, hint of flex. Gorgeous.
As a Japanese, I am very happy to see that Japanese fountain pens dominate the top rankings.
I also love custom URUSHI.
As a Japanese would you please advise me as to which nib should I choose in a platinum 3776 century. I don't want too broad and too narrow. I like the feedback but I don't want it to be scratchy. Is a medium nib good to go?
@@san2881 Unfortunately, I only have two types of Platinum Century, F and SF.
I've heard that B is very smooth and easy to write with. I'm sorry that I'm not much help.
@@san2881 There is a comparsion of all 3776 century nibs from Yoseka Stationery.
@@san2881After living in Japan in 1968 and 1969, I fell in love with Japan. I did take a group of students to Japan in 2001, but I have had little chance to return. My best friend married an American educator’s daughter in Ibaraki, and they eventually settled up in the Sapporo area. I would love to visit them, as we are each in our late 70s now. I hate the cold though. My question is did you still hold to the Custom Urushi and it’s # 30 nib? I know Figboot loves the #50 on the Emperor, but I have a tendency to think the one I can stretch to buy, especially if I see an old Montblanc 149. Are you still happy with the Pilot Custom Urushi? Or, did you too reach for the Namiki Emperor?
Just wanted to thank you. I purchased my first starter pen today and I got the Faber-Castell Loom. I was planning my first trip to the fancy pen shop near me on Friday then they announced on social media they were closing the shop again because of COVID numbers increasing. ☹️ Found a Loom in an art store and the color I liked was $15 less than the other colors for some reason. 🙌🏼🙌🏼 I purchased without being able to try it based on your recommendation and I couldn’t be happier. It’s so smooth and a great size for my hand and I like the weight versus some of the plastic and aluminum models I was considering.
Have fun with your new toy!
are you using a fine or medium nib?
@@aegystierone8505 it came with a medium nib which is my preference.
Great video, as always!
I'd say my favorite nib is the nib on my 1950 pelikan 400. I got it from my grandfather (it was his pen) and it was in dire need of love. I fixed and tuned the nib, freed up the piston and polished out most of the scratches that were gathered by decades of use. It is just so supple, smooth and wet it is unbelievable.
Next up would be my 18K Visconti HS F nib followed by the EF nib on my TWSBI Precision.
WOW! All Japanese top 3! Not surprising at all I guess. Sailor and Pilot are easy to recommend for that near perfect writing experience. And I appreciate how you don't write off those steel nibs just because they're inexpensive, I've had some amazing steel nibs in my collection too. If they were stamped 14K or 18K, no one would question if they were really gold or not.
I just spent a bunch of time tuning, heat setting a $200 Bock #8 14K nib. It kept running dry even though there was enough spacing between the tines. I finally had to increase the air exchange by modding the feed to get the desired ink flow. It should have been perfect out of the box for the price.
I never thought I'd ever watch one of these list videos and agree with literally everything on it, but the day has come; even down to the honourable mentions and the Loom. Haven't tried three of them, but I can see why they'd be nice nibs. The only thing I'd add for people who love feedback is the Platinum President, which I think is both the best looking nib in existence and the best feeling heavy feedback nib.
I have a theory about why Pilot/Namiki nibs feel so good. If you look at the tip of the nib, it isn't a smooth curve like any other nib. Instead, the Pilot nibs have this unique feature where the tines kink and narrow the part of the tines closest to the tipping. Seems to me like it acts as a little needle with a lot more spring to it than a straight curve from shoulder to tine.
My family has shifted over to mostly using Platinum nibs somewhat organically. It's only been this year that I discovered just how good the Platinum nibs are, after a long time with Montblanc and PIlot nibs. Platinum sort of swept through the house and took over. My everyday writing pens (which are always my current favorite nibs) are now a #3776 Music and UEF. I avoided the feedback train for too long, only to discover just how good it can be.
Thanks for sharing, very entertaining. I miss the inlaid Sheaffer nib, like in the Legacy or PFM.
I cannot afford gold nib pens. How about a list of top 10 steel nibs? And my biggest problem with steel nibs is that most pens uses either Bock or Jowo nibs. Should we consider in house tuning (Diplomat) or grinds (Franklin-Christoph)?
@The Truth I can get 5 Lamy Safari for the price of 2000
Gadget yoyo Until I got my first Lamy 2000 (on eBay), I rather had multiple Lamy Safari's, Al Stars or 4 TWSBI's Eco with different nib sizes. But nothing compares to my Lamy 2000 with an F nib. And you can only write with one pen at a time, can't you? Sell your Safari's and save for a Lamy 2000. You won't regret it for a minute!
Why are Jowo and Bock nibs a "problem?" Jowo in particular makes excellent nibs that can be tuned or ground to your taste. And both companies make gold nibs, while Bock also makes titanium nibs.
To dismiss these excellent steel nibs as a problem doesn't make a lot of sense.
I love my Diplomat Aero in broad. Its a great pen
Gadget yoyo The Lamy Safari is a good pen, but the Diplomat Aero with a medium or broad nib is better and the Lamy 2000 with any size nib is better yet. Franklin Christoph is good, but I don’t find their nibs to be worth the money. So I agree that one Lamy 2000 is worth 5 Safaris.
A couple of nibs I enjoy a lot and no one mentioned:
1) The red-lacquered steel Bock #6. It is not just the color, it is actually a lot more bouncy than other bock steel nibs.
2) The "flex" nib that comes on Ranga eyedropper pens - I am not sure who makes it, but it is amazing - smooth and bouncy
I'm not surprised to see so many Pilot/Namiki nibs. Even though I only have inexpensive Pilots, I love the nibs. Also, thumbs up for the Leonardo and the Loom.
My 18k vanishing point ef is so smooth yet so loud. Writing on cheap paper as a lefty makes a racket and i love it.
I absolutely love the nib on my Pilot Custom Heritage 92. It's smooth with a touch of feedback and has a little line variation as well
The CH92 is high on my list as well. It made the "long list" for me, but not the short one.
I feel like it as a near perfect daily driver nib. It feels awesome, gets the job done every time and I don't have to worry too much about damaging it. I'm dying to try some of Pilot's high end nibs tho.
Great video Dave and a great concept. The heart of the fountain pen IS the nib. i gotta agree with many of you choices but may i add in a few of my favorites: The Platinum 3776 century Kumpoo Soft M nib, Nakaya Heki Tamenuri Soft M nib, Aurora Optima Med nib, Pilot VP med nib and Omas Paragon Med. What do you think?
Bryan thank you for mentioning the Platinum Kumpoo with Soft Medium nib. It is glorious! I will have a Omas Paragon Medium in just a few hours and am thrilled you mentioned it. Was also disappointed the Platinum President not on this list as it has a great nib. You never see me post comments but had to let you know I Agree with you. .Thanks so much. Barbara
I love the close-ups of the nibs! While I am getting into some vintage nibs, there is something special about these more modern nibs.
I’ve been wanting to see a video like this. It’s hard to parse how different pen manufacturers tune their nibs in comparison to each other and you do a good job describing how each of them feel.
Thanks, this was very informative. Some other nibs I find great and would recommend: 1) Aurora nibs are amazing. They are stiff but smooth and very precise. 2) Santini: the regular gold nibs are somewhat similar to the Auroras in their pleasant feedback. 3) Parker Duofold nibs are also stiff but they are glass smooth. 4) Leonardo steel nibs are amazing. (The are made by Bock, but tuned/modified by Leonardo) The best steel nibs I have. +1) It's fun to have a titanium nib in your collection, it's a significantly different writing experience.
My Leonardo Momento Zero didn't write out of the box. I had to get them to send a replacement.
+1 on issues with Leonardo. Their steel Bock nibs are hit and miss, with a lot of misses. They are switching to Jowo as we speak - probably shows the level of unhappiness...
Are the Pelikan M800 nibs true to size. I know you've said the M1000 nibs write much thicker and have heard that many places however I was not sure if this was specific to M1000 or all Souverän pens.
More true than the M1000, but I find them to be bit on the broad size of each tipping.
@@FigbootonPens I see. Do you have any M800's you could do a writing sample of or perhaps a video on this subject already?
I want to be able to see negative space in between both upper & lower case letters on dot grid paper but also want to have a nib that lays a good flow of ink down and clearly demonstrates all the shading characteristics of most inks. I find that some Japanese EF nibs are too narrow to truly demonstrate strong shading in most inks.
I'm leaning towards an F M800 but would consider EF if you think the F writes more like a Medium.
Thanks for making such informative videos. Definitely subscribed to the channel.
@@thomascampanis It was several years ago...but there is a M805 review on my channel.
I just recently had my Great Grandfather's Parker Vacumatic Major (1945q2) with a 14k gold nib (fine, I believe), and it's now my favorite to write with. it's silky even on the copier paper I have to write on at work.
A bit surprised to not see the diplomat aero pen, since you mentioned few times is among your personal favourites. Still, thanks for the review, keep learning about pens with you
It was close to making the list. It's in the thumbnail, if that counts for something. :-)
Love that loom nib, posts well too. That would be a good top ten list also, “top 10 best posting fountain pens”.
Finally I found someone who actually answers a question, not the usual, "it all depends..." Thank you, subscribed !
Scribo! Happy to hear you'll be discussing-- I'm very interested but know just about nothing about them. Really looking forward to this one!
Glad that I have one of your top ten. I absolutely love the M nib of the 845. I hope to be able to try the top three one day.
Awesome Omas Arco block! You are the coolest of the pen guys. I love admiring your collection.
The variety of pens and the special interest videos that you produce are truly enjoyable and informative.
Thanks for watching!
@@FigbootonPens You are welcome.
My favorite steel nib is the Diplomat Aero. I have broad and fine. They are amazing!
You mentioned Mike Matsuyama several times. I have a Franklin Christoph Panther with a Matsuyama 14K medium Cursive Italic that is in my top 10 nibs. It is a custom grind, but all of the others on my list are "out of the box" nibs. They include a Montblanc JFK with a BB nib, at Montblanc Unicef Legrand with OB nib, a Lamy Studio with 14K medium nib, a Waterman Carene with 14k medium nib, and a Faber Castell Loom with Broad steel nib. I love very smooth nibs - the "writing on glass" smoothness. So, I appreciate your description of the Pelikan 800. And I would very much appreciate hearing your comments on the Scribo. My favorite pen "guru" has suggested that a Scribo should be my next pen.
Nice list . Another nib that I am constantly amazed by is the steal nib on the Leonardo Furore - possibly the best steal nib I have ever used. Some interesting nibs in your video that I want to try.
I love the 0.6 Stub Nemosine Nibs. They are so smooth and I can use them even though I write small. Sadly they are no longer but I was able to hoard a few nibs!
It's a shame Nemosine went out of business. I really miss their inks.
David. Great review and list here. I am looking to replace the nib on my Fuliwen World Map pen. Could you recommend a nib that would both fit and give me a great writing experience. I am looking for a FINE nib. I am a noobie pen enthusiast and know nothing about replacing nibs. Thanks,
Sorry. I am not aware of what replacement nibs (if any) will work with that specific pen.
Hard to argue with this list, David! Least wise, I hit on most of the honorable mentions (823, Falcon, 2000 and Pelikan M800 for me) and a couple of the "true" top 10s -- F-C Loom, Momento Zero Grande, Omas Arco and in wait for my birthday, the Pilot 845. I have to agree with your comments on the M-Z-G -- what a terrific writer and that's with the steel nib! You've inspired me to put my F-C Loom back into rotation.
Great review. Thanks. Also like the stainless steel nib on the Pineider Avatar UR. I have it in F.
Good and interesting info, thanks. Worth the 8 ads.
I break my nib favorites into two (unordered) groups:
Pleasant to use:
Faber-Castell Basic B
Kaweco Sport BB
Karas Kustoms Fountain K Titanium F
Noodler's Triple Tail Flex
Useful for drawing:
Pilot Elite Posting Nib (least feathering nib I have)
Pilot Petit1 (nothing special, but deserved being on the list since I use it 95% of the time)
Pilot Parallel 6.0 (ground at an angle by Toronto Pen Company)
I seem to be on Team Pilot.
Oh, and one dishonorable mention: I hate my custom ground TWSBI Eco Architect. Be careful what you wish for.
What differs (tip wise) with the posting nib?
@@x-changex-outx-oner8224 It's designed to be used on low quality Japanese postcards. The tip is turned down slightly. Generally available in the 912, I believe.
@@ichirofakename
👍👍👍👍 thanks for the feedback. Looks like another excuse to buy another pen😆😆😆.
@@x-changex-outx-oner8224 heck yeah
Watched again in 2021, only one ad, yay.
Thanks for a very interesting review. It's fun to contrast and compare what I own with what someone else has experienced with the same model nib/pen.
This was fun and instructive to watch. Thanks. This list is very much a personal taste list. For me, if I cannot get a lot of line variation I am not interested in the pen. In addition I just cannot enjoy any nib thicker than an EF point. I would also include some vintage pens to my list. And you did not include nibs that were modified. I would have added some that I have. So I guess I will have to do what you just did but with my favorites. Thanks again for the video.
Did you ever make one of these list videos? We have similar preferences so I checked out your channel but didn’t see one. What are the best/your favorite nibs that meet this criteria (very fine + capable of producing some expressive line variation) and are readily available (i.e. non-modified and not rare vintage)?
Thanks, well done--Just curious you stated that you were on a Flight and writing with the "Namiki Emperor". I'm fairly new to Fountain pens,
but I thought flying with a fountain pen, in which Air pressure changes are typical, can cause the pens to leek.--Can you explain what you do
so that doesn't happen.--E
As long as I keep the nibs facing up while they are not being used on a flight, I have not experienced any issues.
@@FigbootonPens thanks--M
I had to come back and watch this a second time while I decide on additions to the collection. Trying to narrow down the right KOP and patiently waiting for Bulkfillers to be available again. I’m torn on the Emperor because I don’t typically care for the cigar shape as much.
I appreciate your description of the Pelikan M800 nib, it makes it definite for me not to get one. I hate glassy smooth nibs, which had been my main complaint about my Lamy 2000 until I got it re-ground.
I have two Pelikan pens. One has a medium nib which writes more like a broad and has a stubbish quality. It is smooth and a wet writer. I like it. The other had a very smooth, non-bouncy, fine nib. It was boring to me, so I switched it to a medium with an architect grind, and now I like it. So I agree, if you don’t like smooth nibs, you might not like the Pelikan.
I actually sold my m800 a few month back bc I don’t like how smooth it is.
Mike Shi I understand why.
It’s funny how tastes are different. His description cemented my desire for an M800!
@@fearlessknits yeah lol. Me too, pretty much. I think i would go for a medium hmmmmmmm...
Got my eyes on the m800
Very nice stuff!
Lol! Not the "Hall of very good" LoL!
My current favorites are vintage, one is a stiff Sheaffer's Balance lifetime, two tone 14k, the other is an Eversharp Skyline 14k nib that currently lives in an Esterbrook J... I call the pen my Estersharp... LoL!
The Loom (F) is the greatest value for me. Lamy 2000 (OM), Pelikan M600 (BB, a bit stiff, but very smooth) are great.
On a budget I would also recommend TWSBI Eco (B), in a different league, but for everyday throwaround: great!
@@dariusus9870 Maybe that nib would need some work. Strangely in the shop my F nib was smoother than the M.
You can see with a magnifying glass if the tines are well aligned. If it is scratchy that would be my first point to look at.
for the leonardo did hhe mean the steal one or the gold one
#1:Titanium stub on 1st. Gen Stipula 22.
#2: Delta m Millennium nib
#3: Sheaffer Balance m
Thank you for another fine fountain pen video!
My favorite nib is a Sailor 21k (black, Imperial) zoom.
Prior almost every pen I own was a Fine nib so this was like jumping in the deep side of the pool and I fell in love.
I’ve since bought an 18k (black, Imperial) zoom nib but it doesn’t come close.
As you say each nib, even with all things being equal, can be different.
I think also the pen itself can greatly influence it as well as a story of who gave it to us or a struggle getting it and so many outside and individual aspects.
Hello Mr David. Please tell me which of the following have larger nib.
a) Mont blanc 149
b) Pelikan M1000
The MB is wider, and the M1000 slightly longer.
@@FigbootonPens Thank you sir for your response.
That OMAS Milord Arco is absolutely gorgeous. The little block of material you have is very cool.
Riveting video. But the terrific pens themselves (excepting the F-C Loom) were a massive distraction. 🙂
I’ve forever been besotted with sublime nibs in any pen I’ve ever owned or used.
This is a splendid list. The Visconti Blue Ripple, particularly, fills me with an aching yearning. Both the pen and that nib.
I have a bevy of beloved nibs. A few that instantly spring to mind are (in random order):
18k Broad on my Sheaffer Legacy II
18k Broad - on four of my eight Aurora 88 pens
18k Broad Cursive Italic - Pilot Silvern Tsumugi (sterling silver)
18k Medium - Waterman Exception
21k Broad - Sailor KoP
I have a Moonman T1 with a fine steel nib that is nearly glassy smooth. Along with the medium 14k nib on my Pelikan 605 they are my best performing ones. Followed by a broad steel nib on a TWSBI Diamond 580 and fine steel nib on a TWSBI Diamond Mini. Need to obtain a Faber Castell Loom next. Thanks for your Videos! Always a pleasure to watch!
Medium is a great all-around size typically putting down enough for a smooth line for FP friendly paper and in reverse typically fine enough for regular paper
Wonderful list of modern pens. No disagreement. I would add in HM, Visconti Homo sapiens Bronze Age. But truthfully nothing beats the Waterman Ideal 52 flexible nib. 92 years older and writes like a dream. Most inexpensive great nib, Muji aluminum. Damn good nib for under 20.00.
Agree on Muji. No question.
Have you tried the platinum president ? I am a bit surprised that its not in this list
I really like your videos. Honest and straightforward. This is one of my favorits 👌🏼
Namiki nibs are just outstanding.
I have the Pilot custom urushi and love the nib.
Thanks for watching!
Very interesting list! Thanks, David.
For the first time, I have _none_ of the items in your final 10 list. I do own and very much like two of your three honorable mention nibs, so your top 10 must be spectacular.
I have watched this video at least 3 times now, so I know you are not likely to read this comment, but I really find it interesting. It challenges me to do something similar. I do own a Sailor KOP, a Pilot Custom 845, a Montblanc e14K nib gift from alumn in e e1992 (not today’s 18K), and ASC pen with a great nib, as well as the Pineider Blue Arco. BTU THE BEST NIB I HAVE IS EASILY ONE ON THE SCRIIBO FEEL. It writes like magic, with softness, smoothness, and a natural flex. Sadly wrong, I love it so much, I don’t use it as much because I fear losing it. You probably complicated my major decision. Right now I had decided that th done additional Grail Pen would be the Pilot Custom Urushi. I had used my limited resource argument to say I should be satisfied with the #30 nib, because the bigger pen (an old, retired prof should not stretch to buy..# 50 on the Emperor. Your rate it so highly that I hesitate now. I am probably still prone to selling the Montblanc (I do not need a prestige symbo, and I believe many of my other pens are superior to it) to justify buying the Pilot Custom Urushi. I think that pen will enough for someone my age and in my stage of life…no more big paydays, living off Social Security and a retirement portfolio, with strong duty to leave enough for my to continue our middle class standard of living after I am gone. I may one day pull the trigger on a Pilot Custom Urushi, for, as you suggest in its review, it is a beautiful nib itself. THANKS FOR EDuCATING AND ENTERTAINING US! Once every 5 to 10 years my wife visit her older sister who lives in Banner Elk, one of two places I have been to in N.C. (I have visited Charlotte.). Beautiful state with greater sanity than California. K
I'm glad to hear you are enjoying your collection. Thanks for watching!
I love the M nib on my Sailor 1911L-the feedback on it is really pleasant and makes it stand out among my pens. I’ve got a Pilot Custom 74 (also M nib) coming and I’m curious to see how it compares to the Sailor.
I’ve branched out from my favorite M nibs into B and my favorite so far is a Lamy B mounted onto my stainless steel Lamy Studio-smooth with a nice wet ink flow.
For a shot time, I did have a FC Loom and while I liked the nib and how it wrote, I didn’t like the polished grip, as it tended to be too slippery for my fingers so I sold it. I would be willing to give it another try, with a grip that has the more matte finish.
Pilot is more smooth than Sailor, which is matter of taste. I like more feedback for glossier paper I usually work with and Sailor is more exotic brand than Pilot. But there are many people that prefer Custom 74. I like Sailor convertors more than confusing mess of Pilot models, they are smaller in capacity but clean out quickly and fit perfectly. Cartridges are similar, I use them only occasionally.
I dont have any high end pens but my best nibs are my FC's and my Nemosine .6 & .8 stubs! They're extremly smooth and theyre really fun to use. Rip nemosine 😔
I didn't know that Nemosine just shut down its business, I do have Nemosine Singularity fitted with Franklin Christoph 1.5mm stub HP Steel.
I think my favorite nibs in my collection is on my Pineider quill nib forged carbon fiber pen. Very bouncy joyous writer.
All my Lamy both gold and steel nibs are nice and smooth. I have 2 old Mont Blanc Nobless one steel one 14k that are nice writers. Just got a vintage 254 that is becoming one of my favorits. I have several Pilots, E95s and Vanishing point and vintage Elites, all wonderful writers. Pilots like Lamy are always reliably nice writers. Sometimes the difference btw good and great are hard to decide.
If I had the money, I would go for a Sailor King of Pens, or the Pilot Custom Urushi or the Emperor but can't. I love the look of some of the Visconti, but have heard over and over that their nibs can be a crap shoot and most end up at nib meisters to make them usable. Which tells me that Visconti doesn't seem to have quality Control check their nibs.
I received your letter yesterday, thank you very much! Communication Breakdown really describes my letter well! It definetly is a ink I will look into though, it looks fantastic.
Wow! How opinions can vary. I usually use an oblique dip pen with a cheap Zebra G nib. But I have used some of these and still have a 149 BB that is never used. My favorite flex nib is the Fountain pen Revolution gold super flex. My favorite broad nib is a music 3 tine nib. I do use the broad nibs by Goulet pens also. As far as regular nibs ie medium I use Jin Hao.
Glad you're trying fountain pens! I have 3 of the classic sports, black, burgundy and green. I also have a white skyline sport that came as part of a Kaweco calligraphy set with 1.1, 1.5 and 2.9 mm nibs. My classic sports are all fine nibs. I've heard of a lot of issues with kaweco nibs but I lucked out on all but one of the calligraphy nibs that had flow issues. Jet pens replaced it for me, no problem. It is a good idea to flush out new pens with water and doing so may make your one nib perform better... or not. Could also be the ink. Try one of the black cartridges in it. Different colors from the same manufacturer can be more or less saturated and flow differently. Hope you enjoy your pens! And if you do, I'll wager we'll be seeing a lot more fountain pen invoicing and reviews! 😃 I'd love that.
While I don't have the pens on this list, the Pelikan M805 is my favorite pen in my collection.
Is the nib on the Omas Milord the same nib they used on the 360? I have one coming in the mail and I can’t wait to try it
Was hoping for the Peerless to make an appearance, the nib on that is super! Fun video, thanks Figboot
I considered it. It was close to making it.
Interesting list of your personal top 10 nibs. I’m sure it has changed since you made this video. It’s very hard to believe the Faber-Castel Loom edges the Pelikan M 1000 nib but I respect your choices.
Hi David... I have just revisited this video purley to write this comment... I have just taken delivery of a Delta "The Journal" with a Fusion nib... wow! I have a few wonderful gold nibs but this nib is an unusual hybrid and is a joy to write with, better than some of my all gold nibs.
Great list and interesting video, but RUclips placed a commercial every two minutes in your video. That was quite off-putting. I don't know if you are aware of this.
I agree
I love your vids. I prefer a smaller pen in my hand but it is fun to see your list, and your AMAZING collection and body of knowledge and experience. Thank you.
The OMAS acro celluloid nib , you say it's 14kt but tgr pictures shown says it's 18k what's the reality?
It's 18k...I just misspoke.
@@FigbootonPens thank you. A Big fan from India . Keep up the good work
The Loom is smooth, but velvety smooth instead of silky smooth.
Ha
Among the cheap, the KAIGELU "EF", fitted in the MOONMAN 'Sandalwood' it has been an unexpected surprise to me.
why is the 823 only an honorable mention when the nib is the same as your 845? from a nib video standpoint, seems like the 823 should also be ranked #4 here :) anyhoo thanks for the list! i've been hunting for the best nib experiences myself. don't think i'll ever get an emperor or an urushi or a KOP (all too big)-- hopefully will get too try those at some point. that said, good to see that the #15 pilot nibs are essentially the best as that's also been my fave so far so seems like i'm not even missing much.
It’s not the same.
I would like to see a review of fine nibs. I used to go with mediums all the time, but now use fine. The reason is paper: for everyday writing, I'm not going to buy Rhodia or the like, I'm going to grab a few sheets from the laser printer. My Lamy al Star with a fine nib, does a great job with no bleed through. Or maybe make the review "best nibs for cheap paper".
I recently received a Hondian Black Forest pen in an Inkredible box from Truphae and it is absolutely a dream to write with and easily one of my more favorite pens.
Thanks for a thought-provoking and entertaining video. I was very surprised when you got to the King of Pen at No.3, but I quickly deduced what must then be in first place.
I do admire the gorgeous Omas Arco.
Rather late to the game, I am happy to agree that you showcase some mighty fine nibs. I have tested King of Pen and Emperor nibs. Just, wow. In my own collection, my Pineider 14k iperflex, Bock titanium #6, and Pelikan m800 18k reign supreme. But, the first gold nib I purchased was on the Hong Dian Mt. Qomolangma (a #5-ish homage to the Namiki Mt. Fuji?) -- very nice bounce and feedback. I doubt I would sell it, although I can imagine gifting it to someone I really care about, if they have demonstrated their love for fountain pens.
My fav of all your videos! I find that nibs are highly neglected but you succeed in making them the superstar of every pen here! Thank you! I may have added the newest Montbanc Calligraphy nib.
Beautiful nibs are the best, especially the two tone ones with cool engraving.
God bless.
The loom seems like a grea value
It is. The section is not for everyone, but it's a great pen.
Anyone knows if all Faber Castell steel nibs are the same? because I like other Faber Castell pens, but I don't really like the design of the Loom
@Figboot on Pens May I ask which nib you will be reviewing on the Scribo? The reason I ask is that I'm about to pull the trigger on a Scribo Feel without having an opportunity to try it personally. For me this is a huge investment, so I'd prefer not to make a mistake. I've watched every review I could find and still can't decide on a nib. Right now, it's down to fine flex or medium flex. I'd love to see your review before I decide. Oops, I meant to put this in the main comments, not the replies. Sorry!
@@marilyngardner4269 It's a Feel...fine nib. I have not had the chance to ink it up, though.
I actually use the Loom's nib with my TWSBI Eco. The TWSBI feed fits fine with it.
Great review. I think the S. T. Du Pont Orpheo has a great nib as well. It lays a wet line with a very smooth feel
Hello dear David
Thank you for the time that you spend making these helpfull vídeos regarding fountain pens, I am new in this wonderful word of fountain pen.
David do you recommend to use the blue can lubricant W40 to clean and mantain the nibs of my pens?
Thank you again, your follower Alfredo Soto from Sahuayo, Michoacán México.
Absolutely not! Do not use WD40 on your pen. It will damage your pen pen beyond repair.
Thank you David I appreciate your timely response, god bless you.
Recently, in the last year or two, I've been happy with Bock Medium and Fine, both steel and titanium, on Karas Kustom acrylic Vertexes and Decographs and Fountain Ks. I think my most expensive pen is a Cross Townsend Titanium with an 18K Medium. I find it very wet and glassy smooth - but it's not my favorite. But in general, I rotate through pens not only for different inks but also for different "feel", and I often write on 24lb linen paper. Thanks for the video. Some really nifty pens, and nibs.
where to get a Danitrio ?
My collection is only just, getting started but I think my favourite nib I'm gonna split into gold & Steel.
Gold has to be my Parker Sonnet Medium. It is so smooth & very wet. It's glorious.
Steel has to be my italix Parson's Essential medium. It actually writes a little fine, & has a nice feedback. I love it.
My two favorite nibs are the Platinum 3776 medium and a Jowo fine (I know, I know!) tuned to perfection by Brian Gray of Edison Pens.
Waterman Carene 18k gold medium. Great looking and glass-smooth writer.
I have the fine and it's also a wonderful nib to write with.
@The Truth yeah ! same for caran d'ache .
Great list. I have the Visconti and Pelican. And yes they all have their personalities. I also believe that of all my pens, the best nibs are: ST Dupont Line D L'Ateler and even smoother is the older Delta Dolce Vita Large nib which is huge and is as smooth as butter.
Thanks for this video. I enjoyed it a lot! Curious how the nibs on the ASC Bologna and the Wahl-Eversharp Decoband ranked? Given your reviews of both, it was surprising neither made even honorable mention. Anyway, thanks again for your work!!
The Namiki Emperor would have to be at the top of my "want" list for pens, but after experiencing Montblancs, Pilots, Visconti's, Watermans, and Monteverde, my whole house has been surprisingly drifting towards Platinum's nibs. I had dismissed Platinum for a while (generally preferring to stick with Montblanc and PIlot's), but after being really impressed with the steel nibs on the Preppy's and on my wife's Curidas, I picked up a #3776 in UEF and another Music nib (unlike you I tend to only go on extremes, since I generally write (aspirationally) calligraphically with flex nibs or stub/italic nibs), and they pretty much instantly replaced my other nibs for "love to write with" and the overall experience. The nibs themselves are really nice to look at, but the intentionally feedback heavy and stiff nib characteristics that I had previously dismissed grew on me almost instantly. I have so much control and precision with the nibs, and they are surprisingly comfortable to use and a pleasure to experience. After using the smoothly ground Montblancs and Pilots as my daily pens for so long, the Platinum nibs were something of a revelation to me in terms of the virtues of the often decried feedback and stiffness of a nib, something that other equally stiff nibs haven't been able to do before this. There really is something special in the Platinum nib design and grind, to me, at least.
It also doesn't hurt that Platinum's feed design really strikes me as exceptionally well done, especially when comparing Music nibs and feed designs across the various makers. Still doesn't stop me from wanting that absolutely delicious and covetable Namiki Emperor though. ;-)
You said the loom was the only steel nib in the list, so I got a bit confused about the nib on the Leonardo.
Is that the steel or gold extra fine nib?
Hi David - thank you for this video, it was a great idea. Would I be able to ask a question? I am interested to know how you feel the Pilot Custom 823 nib compares to the others that actually made it on the top 10 list. I do have a Faber-Castell Loom with both the Fine and Medium nibs (which are surprisingly different from each other) and noticed that it made your list above the 823, which was just an honorable mention. I've long been eyeing the 823 as a bit of a stretch goal, so I would really be interested to hear your thoughts on how it compares, maybe especially with the F-C Loom and Lamy 2000.
Thanks!
Ken
What about the sheaffer legacy and parker duofold nib??🤔
Excellent review. Just one question about the nib. You said the Faber-Castell Loom is the only one on the list that has a steel nib. However, the Leonardo Momento Zero also has a steel extra fine nib, if I thought about this correctly.
does Visconti make it’s own nibs?(or are they actually JoWo?:)
WELL... okay... You're probably NOT going to like it, but I'll play, too... haha...
GOOD LUCK finding a fountain pen or adapter to use them... BUT I'm an artist, and we are a bit of a flaky and dubious bunch. I'd have to say I LOVE my D. Leonardo No. 120 Catwinkel nib... BUT my FAVORITE is a Hunt No. 102 Crow Quill lithography nib... When working on a scenery, you just can't beat that nib and the right ink for NAILING the tiniest thistle-fuzz down the stems or cross hatching so fine someone would have to put his forehead RIGHT ON the picture to see that they are (in point of fact) parallel hatching lines in both directions... and not some cleverly magical way to get a neutral gray series of shades out of plain black India Ink on typing or copy paper...
AND yeah, if you know anything about ink on paper or line and wash, you know just how damn difficult and dubious THAT sentiment really is.
Don't get me wrong, I can get along just fine, in the roughing in stages of sketch, working about any of the Fine and Extra Fine nibs. I almost always end up polishing a new nib with my usual slab of leather... It's impregnated (by my own hand) with valve grinding compound on the suede side... AND black jeweler's rouge on the opposite (skin) side... About 2 minutes of "figure-8" strokes with varying angles and rotations to the pen and I flip the leather exposing the rouge... and 2 minutes or so more of the same, and I alcohol and swab it off... a fine stiff nylon brush is employed to get debris out from between the tines... and it's almost no trouble at all to get writing as smooth as silk stockings on a high polished marble floor... minus the broken legs of course... haha... ;o)
Nice ranking :) Pilot nibs are great whatever the price range. I'm in love with the Emperor and the Custom Urushi (which are the ones I use the most), but if you don't want to go the 4-digits-price-tag, one of my favorite I can recommend from them is the "basic" (hem) 14K medium on Namiki Tradition (their entry level maki-e ebonite pens). To me it's butter smooth and can easily stay 15/20 minutes uncapped without drying (and depending of the ink sometimes without any hard-start, like the Pilot Falcon SE btw). The con of this is I hardly use my capless now ^^.
Thank you for this video! To me, the non is the most important part of a pen, it's size and aesthetics of course also drive me to purchase but if a nib isn't pleasing then I may display it but won't ever used it whereas I'll continue to use a pen that's plain or not as pleasing to the eye if it writes well. :)