Wait, didn't Finland and Sweden join NATO after Russia illegally invaded Ukraine? Soooo Russia expanded NATO anyway. Ukraine will join next. Good Job, Vladdy. 😂
Kind of like how the White House never answers questions regarding Israel and the mass murder or innocent civilians including children on a daily basis?
@@arthurpewtey means nothing if NATO had Balls to attack Russia they would have done it already. Wait for BRICS to form its defence alliance then NATO borders with Russia will be small again. Very small.
@Hacker776-o2l if you do just a minute of research you'll find that NATO didn't invade. It was there to support and advise Afghan forces. I'd say that was an overall fail given the shroud of darkness that currently rests on Afghanistan.
@@Hacker776-o2l”Nato” didn’t invade Afghanistan. The US did, because Afghanistan held and helped Al Queda and Bin Laden who attacked IS on September 11.
Then stay away from other countries borders and listened to years of warnings. I don't disagree with anything he has just said. *Coming from a British citizen*
OOh, poor russia always only the victim! Russia never was a victim, it always was the perpetrator, who threatening it's neighbors. By the way Putin: What about a small visit in the Netherlands, for example The hague?
How many countries not on its border has Russia ever invaded? None Yet Europe colonized a lot of the world sometimes stealing colonies from others for fun and profit. The Brits wanted the gold and diamonds in South Africa. The US stole Spains colonies in a cheap shot.
But I can definitely decide who will watch in my house, there is no need for another country to come to my neighbour through my neighbour in the name of freedom, it's neighbour job to watch his home and also when time come he will stand with his neghbour
You think Russia could establish a military base and overthrow the government of Mexico or Cuba, without the US reacting? I'll wait for your honest response.
@@kgosisimanyana dont be an aggressive neighbour and they wont be trying to join it. Nato argument is such crap.......If nato wanted russia 2 years of murder in Ukraine is more than enough reason for nato to step in
Poot seems to think only Russia's security matters. I guess we'll just have to keep demonstrating that it's not the only thing that matters. NATO was created to contain Russian expansionism, which he's demonstrated still needs containment 75 years later.
Who is Putin to command or demand that other sovereign nations do his bidding? If Russia’s neighbors feel rightly threatened by Russia’s expansionism, they have every right to seek NATO protection. He is to blame for their actions….
Putin I tell you one more time and the last. NATO expended because you are treathening those countries like Estonia, Latvia, Finland. You dont have to be Einstein to understand this.
They are not threatened they are lured. The cold war mentality of the US and the Vassal Union is the reason for NATO expansion. Thanks to you there will soon be a BRICS defence pact and then you will learn how others feel when you threaten them with a war alliance.
@@gtaraya Ukraine was in the ussr back then, not as distinct country and countries of Warshaw pact werent neutral, they were pro-soviet, so yes, common borders
At least the brave bbc journalist got the chance to ask a question, not the same for Russian journalists who were ban from western media, banning journalists in my opinion, is the same as burning books, and we all know who burn books in the past.
Ukraine is a puppet state for the us to intervene whenever, theres an actual leaked call of the us ambassador in ukraine with a us governer deciding who is and isn't allowed in the government of ukraine way before the war lol
Putin displayed his utter disregard for the people of Ukraine when expounding on his petty little grievances about the Russian security situation. Putin just wants more control of a vaster area with the power to take it.
Putin normally is very disciplined with his emotions. Obviously with the question coming from Rosenberg BBC Russian foreign correspondent, he looks agitated, good. He should be worried too. Maybe something will happen to him in the near future?
do you realize which country interferes in other countries' political affairs in a really big way???? It's the good old US. Russia is just a beginner in this game, while the US is a professional. So don't criticize Russia when your own country is much worse in that aspect.
@@marthas.4456 Us interfered in Iran, Guatemala and Chile and probably for good reason. And how did they interfere compared to the way Russia interferes with US elections and why?? There is always more to a story.
Have you ever listened to the soldiers on both sides of the frontlines they speak the same language,this doesn't exist between Russia and Sweden or even Finland. It's like comparing oranges and apples to put it mildly they could careless about these countries joining,but they began preparing their defenses in those directions already.
Brother the us has been corrupting ukraine since the early 2000s trying to create a corrupt government and overthrow russia or Vladimir putin don't talk ignorant
Birds of the same feather right? Both narcissists and pathological liars. One’s already a dictator, the other’s a dictator wannabe. Reason why he gushes over the putins and kims of the world.
@@patriciadunmore9767 There were no talks of NATO expansion and the Ukrainian government was against it and so was the public... just more lies from the dictator for life
The biggest liar corporation of the world BBC?? Don’t be insane even they know what hypocrites they are. Saville, Edwards, Schofield ??? How about the jab??? All above board reporting ? Please I would rather trust Putin than anyone from the BBC
Putin talking about justice is beyond ridiculous. His own actions have caused his problems, and now he is blaming everyone else for his corrupt mistakes.
Ok, the problem with expanding NATO is russia. Without problems comming from russia no country would have a reason to join NATO. And it should be fine to show the lie about promises not to expand. If some state wnats to join, it is their choise.
It was the soviet ambassador to the the us along with his soviet commander in cheif who decided to withdraw all soviet weapons from cuba and dismantle the nuclear weapons from cuba 😂@SingapurRUS
@@SingapurRUS Seems like ur too stupid to understand the very different historical context and that Nato is not the USA. Nato is an intergovernmental organization. Every single member would have to agree to an attack, which is not even backed by the law of NATO. Why a baltic state would ever agree to such a risky move, basically dooming themselves, is up to your fantasy.
So you never watched the video of a group of Russians capturing one of the masked military attire wearing armed mercenary at the one protest where shots were fired and they are beating him in a tunnel. They remove his mask and he starts speaking perfect English and says he’s American…..?
Tf are you saying there's multiple reasons for this war just like there's multiple reasons for the us to support it the us has literally said it themselves they want ukraines territory for their materials they want it to attack russia they want it to remove putin they want it to use the ukrainian people for their proxy and not just ukraine there's been other treats done by nato to russia that are completely ignored like this base in Romania where they literally have longrange missiles and they said it was to protect in case form an attack from Iran which is not even close and was never even an idea so maybe get educated media eater
I remember writing a reference for Steve's daughter, when he moved from Berlin to Moscow. I wonder if he is now wishing he had stayed in Berlin, because I wouldn't want to be in Russia now.
Are you in the UK? Because I've seriously considered leaving after not only did the system let me down as a care leaver, but it continued to let me down over and over and over again far into my adult hood. In my country we now have two tier policing, a rapidly growing immigration issue that is adversely affecting the native population. And on top of all of that a government that refuses to listen to it's citizens. And so I've seen the weakness of my nation and started yearning for a leader with a pair of balls, truth is Putin isn't lying here. He actually tried to join NATO many many moons ago which would have secured world peace. And what did NATO say in response? They refused.
Since when did he offer to join NATO if he wanted to join NATO all he had to do was agree to get rid of all his nuclear weapons and the US, Britain and France would have gotten rid of theirs but he refused which was always a condition of him joining NATO
Imagine the list of war crimes this guy would face in front of the international criminal court and all he has to say is "but judge.. NATO kept coming closer😢"
Yo dum a$$, he just told everyone why he invaded, bcs nato was expanding in Ukraine in their door step which made the 2 countries enemy(bcs of U.S), otherwise these 2 were friends before 2014
The reason he invaded was so obvious but still some idiots don't understand, that's why he tried to explain. But people are so dumb that they still don't get it. Stay a loser by the way😂😂❤
@ryanwalters6184 Good point. Another nuisance is when they talk about countries being "Russophbic" as they prove there is a reason for it's smaller neighbors to fear the,. Russia makes me sick. They really expect Ukraine and their neighbors to not be able to defend themselves as it threatens Russia. The opposite is what is really needed. Russia needs to be disarmed so it doesn't try to invade them.
The sick in the head is in the west. Biden is mentally ill, Starmer locks up facebook posts. What is wrong with you? Why are people like you obsessed with Putin/??
@@kgosisimanyana well its a long way back now, there is nothing that can be salvaged from this that will see Russia and its people in a winning position for decades after all this. One mans bad decision is being compounded into worse
There were no laws established, no agreement or treaty signed promising NATO would not expand eastward towards Russia after the fall of the USSR. After Russia fought Georgia and annexed South Ossetia, the other former Soviet bloc countries decided to become a NATO member.
Yes it's fair that your hopes that NATO wouldn't expand are ignored! You don't want NATO to expand because it means that there are fewer countries you can attack without retaliation from NATO. It's pretty simple, if you don't attack a NATO country, then you don't have a risk of warfare with NATO.
@qpvpq5iw5bfa NATO never attacked Iraq, they just supported US operations. In Yugoslavia, NATO only got involved because the country was ethnic cleansing Albania. You can't point to a single instance where NATO started a conflict, instead of reacting to an already ongoing one, because there isn't one.
@@easy6427 According to your logic, Russia attacked Ukraine in order to stop the civil war (since 2014) and, according to some indications, ethnic persecution. Maybe NATO should have stayed within its 1991 borders in order to disturb the geopolitical situation in the world?
@@GavanHogan-u3c But the answer was based on fantasies and outright lies. No promise was concluded not to accept new NATO members, and the invasion of Ukraine had *nothing* to do with russia's security, it is putin's twisted desire to reunite a failed empire. it was a land grab. Nothing more.
He was not comedian like zelensky he was a russian spy so he know about countries security but your comedian zelensky will never understand this. Tell zelensky to join his comedian job.
When have NATO Invaded another country. How many times has Russia decided that it wants another country...let us control your government or we invade. And then just incorporate that country into Russia. Look what Russia is doing in Africa.
@@pzubets Tell the same to Putin. He started this conflict saying he wasn't going to invade Ukraine and then he did. We are assisting Ukraine against this despot in the kremlin who is just trying to redraw the borders back to 1991. He hasn't succeeded so far, has he?
@@hitlegger6282 It isn't about that. Putin was concerned about the enlargement of NATO. Because of his attack against his neighbour, other countries have joined for their protection.
Putin does not know that Ukraine is a Souverän Country and can deal and talk to any Country it likes ?? Ukraine was never member of a system moving Eastwards...
There is no type of document, agreement or memorandum signed about which countries cannot join NATO. NATO does not expand, the countries that make up this organization apply voluntarily to it. The main incentive to be part of NATO is provided by Russia, Sweden and Finland are examples of this.
@@Mary-Kp9ie-p1w Sneaky, you mean like taking the flags off your soldiers' uniforms and sending them to invade a neighbow, all the while denying any involvement? Yeah, that would be sneaky. Its a good thing putina's never done THAT before.
stupid is what stupid DOES! he was never an intelligent, one invading European country and threatening with nuclear weapons shows the size of weakness and stability and now his so-called second army is well… getting to Kiev for a 3rd year in a row ! 😂
A small man has these specific facial expressions when they talk, so much anger behind these eyes, so much insecurity. When he dies, his soul will be so busy removing all the layers of neglected emotions and walls that he pictured to protect him. If only there was a way to witness the process.
Yours is a profound observation. It's a shame he couldn't put his talents to more constructive use. But as you so admirably point out, he's still a human being behind his bluster and prevarications.
@@jimcroft3633he just went on a rant on why he invaded ukraine, which was all bs. Ukraine joining nato pre 2014 was dubious at best. Now after his smo, its an absolute certainty. Ukraine might lose territory in the east, but theyll have at the very least security guarantees from the west, most likely nato membership after the war. Instead of zero new nato members, we now have 3. Way to go vlad 😂😂😂
Show me the signed agreement whereby NATO said it would not expand east. Gorbatschow said himself on camera that there was no such discussion and no such agreement. It's ludicrous - since when can one country decide about the security alliances of its neighbor?
There are no NATO bases in Ukraine. You only have to ask Russian soldiers if they`ve come across any, `nyet` would be the answer because there aren`t any.
There was no coup, Ukraine’s parliament (elected by the people) unanimously voted to get rid of Viktor. No confidence votes occur in democratic governments (this happened to Macron recently, he barely survived the vote). Putin has ruled Russia since 1999. Ukraine had Many leaders since then.
You are right. Poop-in doesn't need to "erupt in fury", all those lies, literally a comedy show, about Ukraine and "NATO bases" come out from his mouth spontaneously.
I would advise Mr Rosenberg to stay clear of hotel windows for a while!
And avoid swimming pools when he is in the west ..
@@susanpfaust one of those .. He knows were he belong ..
Try Mossad @@susanpfaust
He have freedom to ask questions, do Russian journalists have freedom to ask same question from western bloodthirsty leaders??
BS... this is not new... he's well known for this type of antirrusa rhetoric and he's still breathing
Why even bother asking? Putin long lost any sense left of morality or reality.
As an Iraqi I agree 😂with u
Wait, didn't Finland and Sweden join NATO after Russia illegally invaded Ukraine? Soooo Russia expanded NATO anyway. Ukraine will join next. Good Job, Vladdy. 😂
You can't be that thick, surely?
You really have no clue as to what's really been going on !
@@Angus_____apparently you dont. Try to read up on European History. And youll seem a bit smarter
@@Angus_____ Do you ? 😆
@@Angus_____ Why don´t you enlighten us
On top of all that, Putler didn't actually answer the question. Well done Joshua Rosenberg.
That's true 👍
yes he did? he said the justification is the eastward expansion of NATO which is a clear threat to russia
Kind of like how the White House never answers questions regarding Israel and the mass murder or innocent civilians including children on a daily basis?
Putin forced 🇸🇪 and 🇫🇮 into NATO. Imagine russia not invading the neighbors 🤷
They were already in NATO in everything but name.
Big brain move.
@@seanmcelroy5522 Yes. But now they're there in name too. And Russia thus has a huge border with NATO, instead of a small one. Result, eh?
@skitpare2627 Putin threatened Finland, and Finland just laughed and joined NATO
@@arthurpewtey means nothing if NATO had Balls to attack Russia they would have done it already. Wait for BRICS to form its defence alliance then NATO borders with Russia will be small again. Very small.
Putin says he invaded ukraine to stop NATO expansion, but it's the opposite he helped countries join NATO.😂😂
Imagine the spinning, stamping of little feet and swearing in the Kremlin the night that happened.
Why NATO invaded afganistan??
And Russia has been "occupied" by Ukraine, what a disaster!
@Hacker776-o2l if you do just a minute of research you'll find that NATO didn't invade. It was there to support and advise Afghan forces. I'd say that was an overall fail given the shroud of darkness that currently rests on Afghanistan.
@@Hacker776-o2l”Nato” didn’t invade Afghanistan. The US did, because Afghanistan held and helped Al Queda and Bin Laden who attacked IS on September 11.
YES ITS FAIR IF ANOTHER COUNTRY DOENT WANT U TO RULE THEM
You mean unlike US and the Vassal Union + UK 😅
@@koiguidenishikigoi4972 US is ruling over Europe. Look at germany for example, poor country cant even properly investigate the Nord Stream sabotage.
I am sure that applies to yhe countries that the US/UK/NATO are ruling with the iron fist? No?
Then stay away from other countries borders and listened to years of warnings. I don't disagree with anything he has just said.
*Coming from a British citizen*
Russia did not want to rule Ukraine, it wanted neutrality, but it was violated during the coup in 2013-2014.
OOh, poor russia always only the victim! Russia never was a victim, it always was the perpetrator, who threatening it's neighbors. By the way Putin: What about a small visit in the Netherlands, for example The hague?
The Hague is no longer relevant after the world witness what's happening in Gaza 😂🤣🤣
@@kgosisimanyana They can be happy that the Israelis are so friendly...
he probably called his orange buddy in america after this press conference to cry about how things are so unfair !!!
@@kgosisimanyana last we checked the arrest warrant is still active....
How many countries not on its border has Russia ever invaded? None Yet Europe colonized a lot of the world sometimes stealing colonies from others for fun and profit. The Brits wanted the gold and diamonds in South Africa. The US stole Spains colonies in a cheap shot.
imagine being able to think you can pick the curtains in your neighbours house
But I can definitely decide who will watch in my house, there is no need for another country to come to my neighbour through my neighbour in the name of freedom, it's neighbour job to watch his home and also when time come he will stand with his neghbour
You think Russia could establish a military base and overthrow the government of Mexico or Cuba, without the US reacting? I'll wait for your honest response.
Yeah.. I felt that when I Learnt about Cuban missile Crisis.
What is your King doing in Australia 😂
if the neighbor is anything but white u never had a problem with it
He is good in inventing answers. Does not bother him that it is total bullocks.
Russians have a word for it "Vranyo". We know. That he knows. That we know. He's lying. VRANYO.
Don't expand NATO simple answer 😢
Same as Trump then.
@@kgosisimanyana dont be an aggressive neighbour and they wont be trying to join it. Nato argument is such crap.......If nato wanted russia 2 years of murder in Ukraine is more than enough reason for nato to step in
💯💯
Poot seems to think only Russia's security matters. I guess we'll just have to keep demonstrating that it's not the only thing that matters. NATO was created to contain Russian expansionism, which he's demonstrated still needs containment 75 years later.
Not just that, but he made up.stories to justify invading Ukraine. The guy is delusional.
Who is Putin to command or demand that other sovereign nations do his bidding? If Russia’s neighbors feel rightly threatened by Russia’s expansionism, they have every right to seek NATO protection. He is to blame for their actions….
Putin I tell you one more time and the last. NATO expended because you are treathening those countries like Estonia, Latvia, Finland. You dont have to be Einstein to understand this.
The baltic fascists need to stop antagonizing Russia.
They are not threatened they are lured. The cold war mentality of the US and the Vassal Union is the reason for NATO expansion. Thanks to you there will soon be a BRICS defence pact and then you will learn how others feel when you threaten them with a war alliance.
So NATO didn't abide by the agreement?
хотите повоевать? Вам не понравится.
@@thegreatest1176 What agreement?
What a butthurt fool putin is
people like you don't have any good argument up to their sleeve and are just full of ad hominem attacks. Are you a paid bot?
@@marthas.4456 😆 n
To remind you Put's. It was you that walked away from the INF Treaty. It was you that was building
huge long range missiles behind Nato's back.
no you don't understand, russia is the victim here... and when they invaded Ukraine, they were the victim then too.
@@edwardgiovannelli5191 You are joking, right?
Interview with the devil.
Can Russians interview Biden and Scholtz? So who reall has freedom of speech?
During soviet times they were right up against Nato borders, but no body invaded anyone elses territory,His argument is pathetic!
You forgot there’s neutral countries in between? That includes ukraine?
he is pathetic
@@fvolpato it doesnt mean anything
@@gtaraya Ukraine was in the ussr back then, not as distinct country
and countries of Warshaw pact werent neutral, they were pro-soviet, so yes, common borders
@@aristotel_1201 and so are nato. THUS THE NEUTRALITY IN BETWEEN AFTER THE FALL OF USSR.
Like the bbc or not, thats real journalism. Hes the bbcs russian correspondent, he could easily end up in jail.
@@curls9032 Shows Russian journalists what actual journalist is.
@@bg1616you know right Russians journalists are banned in western countries. So your comment is hypocracy
@@vinojsagar5007 The West have banned Russian journalists...like Russia lol 😆
@@vinojsagar5007 unfortunately for the good hardworking Russian citizens, Russian journalists are ALSO banned in Russia
@@TSIRClips I understand that these "good" journalists must be pro-Western. OK
Kudos to the brave journalist. Should not require bravery to ask simple questions, but here we are...
He's afraid poopin will give him radioactive tea.
At least the brave bbc journalist got the chance to ask a question, not the same for Russian journalists who were ban from western media, banning journalists in my opinion, is the same as burning books, and we all know who burn books in the past.
May his hotel room be on the ground floor.
It happens in the West too when you ask about isreal you have to be brave
@@kgosisimanyana no you can ask any question without the fear of the chubby short egotistical leader getting you killed because you hurt his feelings
Ukraine is not part of NATO so how could NATO expand in Ukraine?
With the imaginary military bases that NATO built I suppose.
Ukraine is a puppet state for the us to intervene whenever, theres an actual leaked call of the us ambassador in ukraine with a us governer deciding who is and isn't allowed in the government of ukraine way before the war lol
my country just joined NATO, Putin was to blame. Before his invasion we did not care.
Putin displayed his utter disregard for the people of Ukraine when expounding on his petty little grievances about the Russian security situation. Putin just wants more control of a vaster area with the power to take it.
Same applies to NATO.
@@rockmusic175 NATO is a defensive pact. Its written out pretty clearly in their charter. The exact reason Ukraine cannot join until the war is over.
@@rockmusic175 Both are after the Trillions worth of Natural resources that are in Ukraine Like most wars it's all over greed.
@@lochnessspeedwerkz6557 that's pretty lame. 😂
try another one later, ok?
@@Jojo-bm4tb yet you are unable to counter it with anything
Putin normally is very disciplined with his emotions. Obviously with the question coming from Rosenberg BBC Russian foreign correspondent, he looks agitated, good. He should be worried too. Maybe something will happen to him in the near future?
what ?
Oh and he has never intefeared in any other countries political affairs?!
Next to ones borders is not interference especially during times when a nasty yanki is trying to change the regime
Interfered
Haha he interfeared indeed. Sucker.
do you realize which country interferes in other countries' political affairs in a really big way???? It's the good old US. Russia is just a beginner in this game, while the US is a professional. So don't criticize Russia when your own country is much worse in that aspect.
@@marthas.4456 Us interfered in Iran, Guatemala and Chile and probably for good reason. And how did they interfere compared to the way Russia interferes with US elections and why?? There is always more to a story.
He is disgusting. It's time to stop this BS.
Hear hear
Goodbye Vlad. You will not be missed.
Well what about Sweden AND Finland then?? What lame excuse
Not lame excuse... Ukraine is developing bio weapons... with dangerous military bases . Then after attack... Sweden and Finland joined it .
Have you ever listened to the soldiers on both sides of the frontlines they speak the same language,this doesn't exist between Russia and Sweden or even Finland. It's like comparing oranges and apples to put it mildly they could careless about these countries joining,but they began preparing their defenses in those directions already.
@@chitranshsharma1431 lies
@@bg1616 Total lies from Orc troll.
@@chitranshsharma1431 Finland and Norway are not in NATO to fight Ukraine. That is the dumbest thing I have heard today 🏆
Putins new suit the most expensive thing about him
All I hear is WAH WAH WAAAH! We wanted to expand first! Damn you NATO for ruining our imperial ambitions!! 😢
Brother the us has been corrupting ukraine since the early 2000s trying to create a corrupt government and overthrow russia or Vladimir putin don't talk ignorant
💯
Nato is imperialism
Yup. Lots of crying.
😂😂if that's you hear go look at his 2000s 2010 videos telling you don't expand further ..now they are just responding to you..
Remember Trump says putin is a great guy...
Birds of the same feather right? Both narcissists and pathological liars. One’s already a dictator, the other’s a dictator wannabe. Reason why he gushes over the putins and kims of the world.
Putin it’s absolutely crazy ,……. like a little Potato!
Hey, don't insult potatoes lol
🙄🤔Hitler,s likefood...😅😅😅😂😂😂
Western media and Western leaders are crazy. They are tolking nonsense. 😂
💩💩
If only western politicians were as brave as journalists.
😂😂 nice joke
Western Politicians are stupid thieves so they cant be brave
Они уже такие же глупые, не все сразу 😄😄😄
Putin discovering like a little baby that the world is not fair.
Russian President Putin looks very afraid.
his army is dependent on North Korean soldiers and Iranian weapons, and his economy is circling the drain.
He has a lot to be afraid of.
Totally agree … He’s Fekked up Russia like he fekked up in the KGB in East Germany. Couldn’t organise a P’ up in a Vodka house.
A born and sustained liar.
What lie???
@@patriciadunmore9767 There were no talks of NATO expansion and the Ukrainian government was against it and so was the public... just more lies from the dictator for life
@@patriciadunmore9767 All of his lies.
@@patriciadunmore9767 The 1 big fat lie about NATO, Patricia! But putler huggers are as delusional as their Great Old Tsar...
@@patriciadunmore9767 mf ALL what he's saying is a lie, im russian and i know that lol
The BBC should have called him out on his lies.
The biggest liar corporation of the world BBC?? Don’t be insane even they know what hypocrites they are. Saville, Edwards, Schofield ??? How about the jab??? All above board reporting ? Please I would rather trust Putin than anyone from the BBC
Why calling the BBC Journalist out on Putins lies?🤣😂🤣
which lies fool?
which were lies????? The lies are coming from the western media.
BBC is on the side of Palestinian Muslims , they are not with the west
Vlad getting it wrong again
I dont think he understood the question.
Putin talking about justice is beyond ridiculous. His own actions have caused his problems, and now he is blaming everyone else for his corrupt mistakes.
Ok, the problem with expanding NATO is russia. Without problems comming from russia no country would have a reason to join NATO. And it should be fine to show the lie about promises not to expand. If some state wnats to join, it is their choise.
Tell that to the United States, which was going to invade Cuba when the pro-Soviet regime was established there. Don't be so stupid.
@@SingapurRUS Ok clownboy 🙄🤡
It was the soviet ambassador to the the us along with his soviet commander in cheif who decided to withdraw all soviet weapons from cuba and dismantle the nuclear weapons from cuba 😂@SingapurRUS
@@SingapurRUS Seems like ur too stupid to understand the very different historical context and that Nato is not the USA. Nato is an intergovernmental organization. Every single member would have to agree to an attack, which is not even backed by the law of NATO. Why a baltic state would ever agree to such a risky move, basically dooming themselves, is up to your fantasy.
@@SingapurRUS
Stop repeating Russian nonsense (lavrov) :
There is no connection with Putin's neocolonialist delusions about his neighbors !
Imagine thinking you have the right to tell whole countries what they are allowed to do, what a idiot
Once again Putin dictating what other countries should or shouldn't do.
Answering a question with two dozen questions - a classic and beneath anyone who wants to be respected and taken seriously.
Putin said West is behind 2014 removing of Victor Yanokovich 😂
But no evidence 😂
People protested and kick out Him😂
The coup was his finger puppet Yanokovich stealing the election.
Putin thinks a pro west government democratically elected by the people of Ukraine is a western backed coup. What a clown
Yes, his plan didn't work
So you never watched the video of a group of Russians capturing one of the masked military attire wearing armed mercenary at the one protest where shots were fired and they are beating him in a tunnel. They remove his mask and he starts speaking perfect English and says he’s American…..?
The evidence is there 😂😂the American officials are the evideñce videos are there talking about it check it out don't be lazy
I thought Russia attacked Ukraine to de-Nazify the country. and now it's nato. he can figure it out himself😂🤦♂️🐷
Tf are you saying there's multiple reasons for this war just like there's multiple reasons for the us to support it the us has literally said it themselves they want ukraines territory for their materials they want it to attack russia they want it to remove putin they want it to use the ukrainian people for their proxy and not just ukraine there's been other treats done by nato to russia that are completely ignored like this base in Romania where they literally have longrange missiles and they said it was to protect in case form an attack from Iran which is not even close and was never even an idea so maybe get educated media eater
Vlad trying to stay Valid.
as his army melts and his economy burns.
I remember writing a reference for Steve's daughter, when he moved from Berlin to Moscow. I wonder if he is now wishing he had stayed in Berlin, because I wouldn't want to be in Russia now.
Are you in the UK? Because I've seriously considered leaving after not only did the system let me down as a care leaver, but it continued to let me down over and over and over again far into my adult hood.
In my country we now have two tier policing, a rapidly growing immigration issue that is adversely affecting the native population. And on top of all of that a government that refuses to listen to it's citizens.
And so I've seen the weakness of my nation and started yearning for a leader with a pair of balls, truth is Putin isn't lying here. He actually tried to join NATO many many moons ago which would have secured world peace. And what did NATO say in response?
They refused.
@@Casstielle-j2q Ah yes, we were already waiting for you to defend your tsar, Ivan. Bad news: he'll NEVER achieve his goals!
Since when did he offer to join NATO if he wanted to join NATO all he had to do was agree to get rid of all his nuclear weapons and the US, Britain and France would have gotten rid of theirs but he refused which was always a condition of him joining NATO
@@evangiles4403 ohhh dam, that's something I didn't know. Perhaps it was an offer too good to be true, it's a shame for us all that wasn't taken up.
@@bassbuffricky 🐽🐷🐖
He didn't understand the question 😅
@@SMILEITMIGHTNOTHAPPENYET and asked 8 more or so
Imagine the list of war crimes this guy would face in front of the international criminal court and all he has to say is "but judge.. NATO kept coming closer😢"
It just so ironic that Putin says that one nation security can't come at the expense of another. As he invades another Nation. 😂😂😂😂
Just insane
Yo dum a$$, he just told everyone why he invaded, bcs nato was expanding in Ukraine in their door step which made the 2 countries enemy(bcs of U.S), otherwise these 2 were friends before 2014
The reason he invaded was so obvious but still some idiots don't understand, that's why he tried to explain. But people are so dumb that they still don't get it. Stay a loser by the way😂😂❤
Stupid People like you make Lockheed martin and Raytheon happy😂
@ryanwalters6184
Good point. Another nuisance is when they talk about countries being "Russophbic" as they prove there is a reason for it's smaller neighbors to fear the,. Russia makes me sick. They really expect Ukraine and their neighbors to not be able to defend themselves as it threatens Russia. The opposite is what is really needed. Russia needs to be disarmed so it doesn't try to invade them.
Not insane just sane.. if someone you don't like keeps getting closer to you then you react just like America reacted during Cuban missiles ..
this man's obsession will lead his country into despair. He's sick in his head
The sick in the head is in the west. Biden is mentally ill, Starmer locks up facebook posts. What is wrong with you? Why are people like you obsessed with Putin/??
It already has.
Putin with clear vision, he slowed his leadership to the western world. 😂
@@geo865833 not for long though coz he will çone out victorious at the end
@@kgosisimanyana well its a long way back now, there is nothing that can be salvaged from this that will see Russia and its people in a winning position for decades after all this. One mans bad decision is being compounded into worse
He is not used to someone speaking freely
What fury!?!?
Imaginary
If that is fury, imagine what would happen if he exploded? Ridiculous nonsense.
Putin seems a bit frustrated. Maybe he should drink some of his own tea, and calm down...permanently.
There were no laws established, no agreement or treaty signed promising NATO would not expand eastward towards Russia after the fall of the USSR. After Russia fought Georgia and annexed South Ossetia, the other former Soviet bloc countries decided to become a NATO member.
Putin just a pole smokin , bud lite drinking muppet 👍🇦🇺🤣😂
Please quote anything he said that is a lie.
True. Trump and Musk are smokin Putler's pole too
@@djdilmuz6039 Everything. He is history revising ishweasel. Thats it, pathetic. Trashing his own country for blind ambition.
Yes it's fair that your hopes that NATO wouldn't expand are ignored! You don't want NATO to expand because it means that there are fewer countries you can attack without retaliation from NATO. It's pretty simple, if you don't attack a NATO country, then you don't have a risk of warfare with NATO.
🤡
Are you dump or what 😂😂 NATO wants to expand to Asia now to counter China what will be your excuse now ??
Yugoslavia, Iraq...?
@qpvpq5iw5bfa NATO never attacked Iraq, they just supported US operations. In Yugoslavia, NATO only got involved because the country was ethnic cleansing Albania. You can't point to a single instance where NATO started a conflict, instead of reacting to an already ongoing one, because there isn't one.
@@easy6427 According to your logic, Russia attacked Ukraine in order to stop the civil war (since 2014) and, according to some indications, ethnic persecution. Maybe NATO should have stayed within its 1991 borders in order to disturb the geopolitical situation in the world?
He is firm but does not “erupt”
It was a proganda push
because he believes in his lies
The question was about the security of Russia. And the answer was about the security of Russia.
A good question and a good answer,
@@GavanHogan-u3c Sure troll, sure.
@@GavanHogan-u3c But the answer was based on fantasies and outright lies. No promise was concluded not to accept new NATO members, and the invasion of Ukraine had *nothing* to do with russia's security, it is putin's twisted desire to reunite a failed empire.
it was a land grab. Nothing more.
Putin has always been lofty and in control. Not anymore, I see cracks forming. Huge cracks.
At least Putin is doing better than senile joker Biden or the loud mouth oil thief Trump
Putin's day of reckoning is coming.
How many people has he sent you there death just in the war .
Many but he doesn't force them like someone in a DEMOCRACY 😂😂
As the most boring man in the world,he does talk rubbish 😂
Comedian Zelensky will entertain you with his comedy don't worry😂😂😂.
He was not comedian like zelensky he was a russian spy so he know about countries security but your comedian zelensky will never understand this. Tell zelensky to join his comedian job.
YOU MEAN BIDEN
@@manisankartripura628 I think so mate
He is the man with clear leadership.
The anger of a Tyrant denied.
He didnt even get angry .. he out classes all Western moronic lying senile leaders
His anger makes him more pathetic as his supposed interests have been smashed by many new nato countries
And he said if those countries start to put NATO weapons and troops then they will act 😂😂
Aggression 100% Answering the damn questions 0%
He literally answered the question.
Then why invaded Georgia ?😅
Justice for Palestine
Because ClA orchestrated anti Russian cope !
@@navinasimoes The IDF is already providing them with justice
Because Georgia aspired to join NATO too. See the pattern? It's not Russia expanding, it's reacting to NATO expansion.
@@jankurcek3717 more than a little stupid this little one
Russia got mad at an alliance based on defense. After creating the Warsaw Pact, CSTO, trying to BRICS into a military force. The curtain is ripping.
You definitely drank the kool aid, absolutely fooled
@@stevenvater8720 you mean you drank the koolaid bud?
@@nizzy33K I think you meant Ivan not bud
@@nizzy33K tip.... Read 180 °By feargus o Connor greenwood and unlearn all the lies you've been told to believe
"NATO is a defensive alliance", just like they bombed Yugoslavia and Libya xD
Truth hurts little man
Glad to see Putin isolated. 😅
You are black and I hope the British or European visits your country again coz its like you don't learn..
😂😂😂😂
Putin is such a cry baby
He is telling us it's about ''NATO expansion'' and that Russia is gonna achieve its objectives. That's a big contradiction.
When have NATO Invaded another country. How many times has Russia decided that it wants another country...let us control your government or we invade. And then just incorporate that country into Russia. Look what Russia is doing in Africa.
Russia fought to last russian. NOW A SUPER BEGGAR FOR FOREIGN TROOPS...😂😂
Well Putin, you have even more NATO since Finland and Sweden joined.
Great, just stay out of Ukraine and our western border. Nobody in Russia cares about Finland.
@@pzubets nobody in russia cares about russia either by the look of it.......good to see the interest rates are up to 21% now
We don't have any territorial disputes with Finland or Sweden, and there are no millions of Russian-speaking Ukrainians living there.
@@pzubets Tell the same to Putin. He started this conflict saying he wasn't going to invade Ukraine and then he did. We are assisting Ukraine against this despot in the kremlin who is just trying to redraw the borders back to 1991. He hasn't succeeded so far, has he?
@@hitlegger6282 It isn't about that. Putin was concerned about the enlargement of NATO. Because of his attack against his neighbour, other countries have joined for their protection.
Putin does not know that Ukraine is a Souverän Country and can deal and talk to any Country it likes ??
Ukraine was never member of a system moving Eastwards...
There is no type of document, agreement or memorandum signed about which countries cannot join NATO. NATO does not expand, the countries that make up this organization apply voluntarily to it. The main incentive to be part of NATO is provided by Russia, Sweden and Finland are examples of this.
Putin looks like don't understand the situation ... a bunch of incoherent thoughts.
All I hear Pootin saying! I want I want I want
Better to say what you want than to be sneaky, like many are.
And saying the west didn't stick to the agreements
@@Mary-Kp9ie-p1w Sneaky, you mean like taking the flags off your soldiers' uniforms and sending them to invade a neighbow, all the while denying any involvement?
Yeah, that would be sneaky. Its a good thing putina's never done THAT before.
Can't agree more,truth spoken.A thousand lies can't drown the truth.
You refer to the journalist, be clear in your post.
Russians have a word for it "Vranyo". We know. That he knows. That we know. He's lying. VRANYO.
@@PaulusN-p3m M crystal clear ,both of them have brought out the undeniable Truth.
what a nonsense answer! great question though!
stupid is what stupid DOES! he was never an intelligent, one invading European country and threatening with nuclear weapons shows the size of weakness and stability and now his so-called second army is well… getting to Kiev for a 3rd year in a row ! 😂
America...has invaded 84 out of the 194 countries recognized by the United Nations and has been militarily involved with 191 of those.
A small man has these specific facial expressions when they talk, so much anger behind these eyes, so much insecurity. When he dies, his soul will be so busy removing all the layers of neglected emotions and walls that he pictured to protect him. If only there was a way to witness the process.
What are you talking about ? SOUL ? mmm. The west is lost its power RUSSIA PREVAILS !
Very... It's poetic. You need to write books. Or the help of a psychiatrist
jealous about his success 😂
Yours is a profound observation. It's a shame he couldn't put his talents to more constructive use. But as you so admirably point out, he's still a human being behind his bluster and prevarications.
You need urgent psychiatric help
Steve Rosenberg is an excellent journalist. He’s intelligent and also brave. BBC is lucky to have him..!!
He should do the same when asking Netanyahu questions 🤣🤣🤣🤡
“It is utter rubbish.” 😂😂😂😂
Yet, He didn't answer the question.
Actually he did .
@@jimcroft3633he just went on a rant on why he invaded ukraine, which was all bs. Ukraine joining nato pre 2014 was dubious at best. Now after his smo, its an absolute certainty. Ukraine might lose territory in the east, but theyll have at the very least security guarantees from the west, most likely nato membership after the war. Instead of zero new nato members, we now have 3. Way to go vlad 😂😂😂
900+ days in to a 1-3 day special military operation
He trusted the turkey agreement so the 3day operation was gonna happen ..now Ukraine is crying 🤣
putin is winning.. you can't denied that.
Agreed, pentagon generals are really bad at planning and predicting)
@@kgosisimanyana But I thought you said you invaded to SAVE Ukraine? Now you're happy they're crying?
something here doesn't match up, Ivan.
@@edwardgiovannelli5191 to save Ukraine??it's to save Russia not Ukraine.. yes Ukraine is crying or you want me to say Ukraine leader
Putin is campaigning for his life!
Without a great victory its over for Putin.
🇺🇲
Just like some in the west if the investment fails it's over for them 😂😂
Poohtin the great master strategist trying to save his ass and begging for a hermit country for soldiers 😂😂😂
if putin hate nato why invade ukraine,why not nato???
He isn’t a man but a mafia boss with nukes.
small balls
@@educa2278 it's highly suspected his nukes don't even work anymore.
@joeyhepoleo6503
Because the Pussia's discredited army would get it's a$$ kicked.
@@DomLab-g2nthen tell NATO to send troops there ..
Show me the signed agreement whereby NATO said it would not expand east. Gorbatschow said himself on camera that there was no such discussion and no such agreement. It's ludicrous - since when can one country decide about the security alliances of its neighbor?
yeah, we know, but its all putin has at this point.
I have feared for this guy's life for quite some time now. Very brave.
well, as a fascist eunuch, ofc you love criminals like putin
Potato Putler
is he still crying about Nato expansion lol well maybe someone should have learned to play nice with others and this wouldnt have happened lol
Please be careful Mr Rosemberg, we do not want to hear that something bad has happened to you
We hope you were worried about Snowden too
@@kgosisimanyana snowden would go to fair trial.
Shortie should have thought of that before he went to war with Ukraine.
Thinking doesn't seem to be what he's best - he's more into stealing billions from the Russian people!
It's sad that Ukraine gave the nukes to Russia with that treatment. If Ukraine still had nukes, putin won't dare to attack. So don't cry little man.
Keep crying 😊
They were Russian nukes not Ukraine 😂😂 are nukes in Texas American or Mexican 😂
@@kgosisimanyana They were SOVIET nukes, and Ukraine was a part of the Soviet Union, so Ukraine had just as much right to them as Russia!
The bully thinks he commands the world!
He doesn't think he commands the world he knows that some countries want to command the world and he is standing on 10 toes😂
@@kgosisimanyana uhmmmm, yeah, sure buddy.
Best stick to mundane subjects like how is the weather and Novichok with Putin
There are no NATO bases in Ukraine. You only have to ask Russian soldiers if they`ve come across any, `nyet` would be the answer because there aren`t any.
There was no coup, Ukraine’s parliament (elected by the people) unanimously voted to get rid of Viktor.
No confidence votes occur in democratic governments (this happened to Macron recently, he barely survived the vote).
Putin has ruled Russia since 1999.
Ukraine had Many leaders since then.
Enough, captain Botox.
Putin is humiliated😂
So when did he erupt in fury🤷♂️
Perhaps the bit about Putin dictating what other countries should or shouldn't do regarding Nato.
You are right. Poop-in doesn't need to "erupt in fury", all those lies, literally a comedy show, about Ukraine and "NATO bases" come out from his mouth spontaneously.
@@paolopetrozzi2213 Putin is a nutcase. I’m sure he will be “removed”……. From power soon if you can read between the lines.
@@paolopetrozzi2213 Putin is insane and I’m sure his inner circle will “remove him from power , if you know what I mean