percy jackson IS better than harry potter

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024

Комментарии • 33

  • @LimeLighT_is_the_future
    @LimeLighT_is_the_future 11 месяцев назад

    I agree with this although I have only seen the Harry Potter movies I feel likw thw world 🌍building is better than said movies it's so easy to understand especially the 1st books description felt so organic & easy to follow.
    I'm glad u brought up Kane Chronicles since I am currently reading the 1st book. The Percy Jackson universe is soo big & has different relms/Gods/myths they even might have hinted in the 1st book about God, GOD in metaphysical sense & that the Greek gods are weaker gods compared to him. Anyway, I feel like Luke is equal if not a better antagonist/villain than Voldemort. I haven't read the heroes of Olympus yet but the first 5 books I really love how much depth Rick gave to each character in those books that I was surprised & is the main thing I want to see them handle in the show.
    I would love a reaction to the show & a part 2

  • @lucasoliver2571
    @lucasoliver2571 11 месяцев назад

    Facts are facts America!

  • @sydneyylenz
    @sydneyylenz 11 месяцев назад

    but magic british kids 😔

  • @j.s3300
    @j.s3300 10 месяцев назад

    Lies...how so comfortable with lies

    • @poppie267
      @poppie267 7 дней назад

      All i see is truty dear.

  • @Drawingsss
    @Drawingsss 11 месяцев назад

    No thank you, there’s a reason that Harry Potter is the highest selling book series with over 600 million copies made. So, when it comes to why the Harry Potter book series is considered by many to be better than Percy Jackson, there are a few reasons. First, the world-building in Harry Potter is incredibly detailed and immersive. J.K. Rowling created a magical universe with its own history, spells, and creatures that readers can really get lost in. J.K. Rowling had to create this world entirely from her own imagination, whereas Percy Jackson feels more like a fanfiction about Greek gods. While the idea is well executed by Rick Riordan, the idea itself gives off wattpad energy. I mean it isn’t that unique to write about the Greek Gods. It is important to note that the Percy Jackson books came out after Harry Potter, leading many to believe that Rick Riordan was heavily influenced, with some going as far to say he copied Harry Potter. The entire plot line is almost the same, a young boy doesn’t fit in with his family/ school, a mentor comes and tells him that he is special, the boy gets taken away to a camp/school, and a villain causes a problem for the protagonist. So, who came up with the idea really? Additionally, the characters in Harry Potter are beloved and well-developed, with complex relationships and personal growth throughout the series. While you may claim that some of the characters aren’t as complex, I would have you look at the character of Snape. Many readers find him to be one of the most well-rounded and complex characters ever written. Snape's journey is filled with mystery and intrigue, as his true loyalties and motivations are gradually revealed throughout the series. His complicated relationship with Harry and his role as a double agent add layers of depth to his character. Snape's past and his personal sacrifices make him a fascinating and memorable character. How many characters can you think of like this in Percy Jackson? The reader feels some sadness when the mom is taken away, but there is not as much complexity and dimension as the characters in Harry Potter. This brings me to my last point, the Harry Potter series has the most overall appeal and relatability. Harry Potter is such a well rounded book because it has a little bit of everything. It's got magic, adventure, friendship, and even a touch of romance. The story is filled with twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat. The characters are so relatable and you really feel like you're growing up with them throughout the series. Plus, J.K. Rowling's writing style is so engaging and descriptive, it's like you're right there in the wizarding world. It's no wonder that Harry Potter has captured the hearts of readers all around the world!

    • @poppie267
      @poppie267 5 месяцев назад

      LOL all of thise is so fake 😂So many people even the most die hard fans have pointed out how poorly Harry Potter has aged and how shallow the characters truly are.
      I hope you will learn to grow as a person like they did my good friend😉

    • @TappyR
      @TappyR 24 дня назад

      @@poppie267 Incase you are not aware, there is this thing called an 'opinion', and if it doesn't sit right with you then umm.... you're probably the one who needs to learn to grow as a person...'my good friend' .

    • @poppie267
      @poppie267 23 дня назад

      @@TappyR Aaah another cry baby trying to be mature by bringing in opinions.
      But thank you that you consider my your friend.🤭

    • @TappyR
      @TappyR 23 дня назад

      @@poppie267 ‘cry baby’ srsly? That’s the only comeback you know? And you srsly need to get rid of your tone deafness, because I literally put double quotes, that obviously suggests sarcasm. I would consider someone so sensitive to be my ‘friend’ (notice the double quotes?).

    • @poppie267
      @poppie267 23 дня назад

      @@TappyR Oh now you calling yourself a cry baby ? You become more weirder by each comment. But you are hilarious pal. Cry some more.😘