India Questions math genius Professor Manjul Bhargava
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- Dr Prannoy Roy speaks to one of the greatest minds of our times Professor Manjul Bhargava.He is the winner of the Fields Medal also known as the ‘Mathematics Nobel’. Professor Bhargava also interacts with an audience of young students about how mathematics could be taught in an interesting way through Indian classical music, games that have basic mathematics concepts , card tricks and the connection between math and music.
Watch full video: www.ndtv.com/vi...
Sir Prannoy Roy, your contribution to Indian Journalism is priceless
🔔
Manjul B is a true representative of Indian culture and its values. Particularly for the "Hemchandra" numbers which invented by Indian mathematician well before Fibonacci.
The days when NDTV used to air informative shows!!!
Paritosh Potukuchi still
Paritosh Potukuchi very true
Paritosh Potukuchi it still shows whether others are busy in hindu muslim stuff
Now is Anti National , and Anti hindu
Every news channel sucks now
His work is in same direction as Ramanujan was doing. Ramanujan was called an infinity man! Check it out his work... Mind blowing....
continuous fractions right?
prime numbers
Angad Singh To be completely honest this man would completely destroy Ramanujan in knowledge. Ramanujan's discoveries are stuff undergrad first year maths majors learn, meanwhile this guy's discoveries are beyond phD level maths. Not to downplay Ramanujan's ability but there are levels to this, Ramanujan unfortunately didn't have a formal western education to fast track him like this guy did.
luther schultz Ramanujan's work was remain unsolved that's why you are saying this. He was the most intelligent person in math . And Recently and indian akshay venkatesh won the fields in medal in mathematics . But Ramanujan's work remain unsolved because he died at very young age.
luther schultz Nobody can touch the level of Ramanujam . Check his wikipedia .
He looked like gangadhar from shaktimaaan .... 😀🤣
Respect 👏
Nope definitely not
*Yeh aaj shakti hai, duniya badal shakti phulon har shakti hai, taroon meh har shakti hai* 🙂...
bhai i came down to mention it and then urs one on top..lol
Rt
Yes... He might be the Shaktiman also , U never know .. 😂😂😂☝️
Manjul Bhargava - one of the greatest minds *India* has ever created !? .... Afaik - Manjul didn't study in India, so what makes India the creator of this genius? Born in Canada & grew up in USA. If anything, those two countries nurtured his intellect & made it flourish. Stop hogging the limelight so desperately.
At least India gave him the Sanskrit language and its wisdom..which he is thankful to
Nishant Sawant it doesn’t matter where he was born or studied. He’s INDIAN and always be.
Alpa Patel are you fucking stupid? How can one be an indian, if they've got nothing to do with India?
He sounds more Canadian than Indian but seems to identify with Indian roots.
Maybe it was a combined effort, second generation kids grow up bilingual so have an automatic advantage of thinking in two different ways.
Nishant Sawant he is son of Indian
Mashalah may Allah bless him and all the hard working students of India ❤ from 🇸🇦
@breathe neet yue hai neet aspirant xdxd
Thank you, professor, for making me study math and not be scared of it, thank you for making me able to sit in the first row in your class at Princeton University 🎓.
I love the way he's always smiling. A great mind.
This guy is just amazing and love the way he talks and really appreciate that he didn't ignore indian culture despite living in Canada and US. I would love to hear more of his interest and views, just fabulous. Salute!
Brilliant interview. Indian youth should be exposed to more such content.
Sanskrit and Maths and our ancient theories. Glad he brought it up.
i love the way he delivers his speech and his humble nature! would love to meet him someday
Loved his spirit and every word from his mouth .......Thank you so much NDTV India for bringing this hero on board🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏
The genius in him is very obvious. So original in his thinking.
love you Manjul sir...you are awesome... guys these kind of persons should be our role models not stupid drug addict Bollywood people
tbh both equally have worked hard and sacrificed a lot in their life. I do agree that drugs aren't something good to do but hey they must have had their reasons as actors/actresses face a lot of criticism and tension that we don't know about and media usually keeps bugging them. I'm not a fan of Bollywood or anything but I just think we all should have an unbiased opinion.
You predicted it 3 years ago ?
@@persona7506 he had a future vision 😂 of today
Don't make fun of drug addicts. You might also someday become fun. Just be more kind with such people. It is a mental disease, not someone to shun
Во всех странах одни и те же проблемы)
As all are questioning to him about his bornplace and education from canada he could prove that he is true indian by starting teaching in india maths in the most wonderfull way of himself...we all know how indian are great in maths so that he can produce many manjul bhargav..
Maths has been a tough nut to crack for most of the students, one has to think so many times to learn it, very few are blessed to be called the genius. Mr. Bhargava is one of them. Hope we in India do get such talents in the coming future. Thanks!
one thing I find about genius people is they had someone in their life who was motivating them and encouraging them to the best.
it is funny how people who really good at math never liked it in school.
Off bat he appeared very humble.
Have met him in person, had lunch, he's one of the humblest human beings I have met. Her mother is a mathematicians as well, she was there too and I had very nice chat with both of them.
Yeah i can feel his humble nature throught the screen
The genius of the math comes from Sanskrit and ancient texts of india and his Simplicity!!! Hats off!! If his classes could be uploaded online, then it would be helpful for the next generation of India.
Thank God ndtv didn't brand him as Sanskrit
Ha bhai sab cheez sanskrit se hi ati hai 🙏🏾 ab bass kar ja
Mathematics is not about numbers - Mathematics is about understanding how things works and why they work the way they work or behave!
Ruff Rider u r talking of Physics
+asnfhtm lzxsje physics is inverse to mathematics
Ruff Rider math is figured out what else is there and maybe when they figured out graphing cosine and secant
Ruff Rider mathematics is the language of knowledge - NDT
Ruff Rider Number theory is about numbers and that is what he was talking about. He never said math in general is just about numbers, he said number theory IS about numbers.
"""Mathematics is """"""the language of Universe. """""""""
Hahaha no not at all
@The Balton it's music my friend!
thats teuth brother i recommend you cosmology
absolutely not , it is a tool to understand the universe not language ,lol
@A.K.Chhatrapati its a tool to understand the language of gods🤡
I am an American Indian from Cali 530!
Hello and thx my Indian brothers!!!
There shouldn't be an age limit on The FIelds medal (40). Andrew Wiles was 41 and solved FLT and didn't get this "Nobel Prize equivalent" in Math. He got a Fields silver plaque, but not the real deal. Simply WRONG.
***** I agree.i also think that the 4 yr interval should be relaxed as well.
+Zoe TheCat get money and create your own awards ceremony then
jackriver1999 I'm not really sure why I deserved that. Solving the worlds most difficult math problems should not require an hourglass
jackriver1999 That is one single and rare example. I realize Mathematicians and Scientists in general do what they do because they love it. They don't do it for glory. I know - because I'm one of them.
Nevertheless, the honor should be provided. If one wishes to decline - so be it.
***** That's a joke right?
Mr.Prannoy Roy thank is also due to you for presenting Manjul Bhargava no doubt he is a great mind and I don"t find you any less. I am senior citizen but I still have curiosity of a cat.Thanks again.
Don't know why but I feel sort of ecstatic throughout this talk session. Real way to teach real numbers!
just because the prize is given after every 4 years that makes it even greater then THE NOBEL PRIZE
One of those rare good videos broadcasted by ndtv. Even my intrest depends on quality of teaching. 👌👌
I loved what he said÷
*In mathematics there is only 1 answer but there are many possible ways to come to that answer!!*
i grew up with an English teaching mom and that made me good in foreign languages, he became a great mathematician most likely due to his mom's profession..and definitely his passion..but lets say that parent's interests influence us greatly..thankful for my mom even though id ve preferred her to be a mathematician hahaha
I felt through out my college days the same as what he said at 5:50, mug up formulas and just apply it. No one explained me why i have to apply that, if i ask they say just remember formula and apply. Then i quit maths altogether. I wish there must be maths teachers who explain the things so maths will be more fun.
I give credit to the maths teacher , who raised him.
His mom as was the case with Ramanujan his mom Indians are not stupid to give mother the status of a goddess
In old "Kannada" language poetry poets used "lagu" "guru" what he mentioned. we are glad that we were thaught this maths in poetry of kannada poems. thank you manjul sir I didn't knew it's significance till you mentioned this
This video has been in my recommendation since years....finally.
In my neighborhood in central Florida math is the sum of all the lessons learned by appreciating the velocity a bullet achieves by applying a trigger. It's simple: the teacher is scared. And the thug wins. And if you succeed at intimidating the teacher you've achieved notoriety, though, of a backward kind. The need to be heard, here, is clearly bigger than the need to listen.
the teacher should call the cops- intimidation with a weapon is assault, a felony.
Regardless of why Fields medal is considered as Nobel prize of math...the monetary compensation is quite less in Fields medal.
A better analogy would be to consider the Wolf prize or the Abel prize which have a similar prestige and monetary remuneration as the Nobel prize and are given out annually.
p.s. the recent Breakthrough prizes might become the most prestigious prizes awarded in coming years.
Thanks NDTV for showing such a genius mathematician
Fibonacci who was an Italian in his book Liber Abbaci mentions it has the Modus Indorum i.e the Method of the Indians which he learnt from the Arabs in northern africa where his father was a trader.His book was the one which introduced the Hindu numerals he learnt from Arabs and introduced to europeans who started calling it Arab numerals. Shame we Indians don't know abt this b'coz we are not taught this. See Mr. Bhargav was influenced by ancient Sanskrit work on Math.Yet we argue whether to learn Sanskrit or German while Germany has most of our ancient Sanskrit manuscripts which they took during colonial time.Of course it was of great importance otherwise they wuldn't have bought it.Not to mention the destruction of our ancient university of Nalanda, Vikramshila by Turkish invaders b'coz of which we lost many valuable work and scholars.
Did anyone notice prannoy roy's face when professor bhargava mentioned the name of sanskrit scholar, Prannoy roy through his channel keeps demonizing sanskrit and anything related to ancient indian traditions because he feels that this will benefit hindutva forces like bjp in the elections. Shame on this congress stooge journalist like prannoy roy who keep forcing nehru's anglacized pseudo-secular, pseudo feminist ideology on people of india and unfortunately some people used to consider ndtv as fair and unbaised but thankfully now that feeling is changing fast.
I hope people soon realize that NDTV is completely biased in favour of congress because When journalists become biased, they try to downplay the mistakes of their favorite party and play up the mistakes of the other party.
Journalists like Barkha dutt, Rajdeep, Shekhar gupta, Vir sanghvi,Ravish kumar, Om thanvi, Abhey kumar dubey,Kumar ktkar,Urmilesh etc always try to hide or downplay congress's glaring corruption and apathy for development and always try to find faults in everything that bjp tries to do.
This trend of biased journalism is as dangerous as showing nag-nagin, and babas on news channels
Devi Vinod Nobody stole India's pride (only a conspiracy theory), but actually restored it.
Naimul Haq Iam stating Facts! It's muslims like you who believe in conspiracy theory.
Kunal Singh The shame is on the party that is using religion (and language), a private choice of an individual, as their winning agenda in a 'democratic secular' nation. It is the religions that are demonizing people and sanskrit is a dead language (do you speak it or just advocate for it?), anything useful in it has been translated into many contemporary languages. If this mathematician learnt it, it is his personal interest and doesn't make the language all so important; moreover, this was about mathematics, not sanskrit
Devi Vinod Haven't read Fibonacci's Italian book, but a lot of us with observation and reasoning power use many a methods that are unconventional and/or not published anywhere formally and methodically. The one that formulates it and proves/applies it rigorously to systems will be able to publish it and will get credit (barring plagiarists and opportunists that are evenly distributed across geography and religion/language and whatever other means of segregating there is in use). An exaggerated example would be that someone who notes that things thrown up tend to fall to the ground, claiming that it is he/she, not Newton who should be credited for the theory of gravity. This kind of silly outcry about sanskrit (you even anglicize the word!) and about the brilliance of ancient Indians has gone on for a while and is rejuvenated by lazy opportunist politicians and babas to make a living without working like the rest of us.
5:03 absolutely nice words ....somewhat relatable
mathematics become magic with the help of data collected from students itself🙇🙇🙇🙇
Hemachandra poetry used Fibonacci series in his poems...though the series wasn't discovered yet!!
don't call him the best mind has India is ever created, In past India was had, Srinivasa Ramanujan
jealousy does not suit in mathematics
Shravan watch 11:04 to 11:20
Bose?
chill bro
The mathematical God called ramanujan. RIP
My god is ramanujan the man who knew infinity, agree like here
you are stupid!
@@mohdwaseem7048 you are illiterate
Genius... So much down to earth 🙂
mother a math professor....grand-dad a sankrit scholar who introduced him to vedic maths. did not attend the maths classes which made maths not so fun........ these are the keys. vedic maths being the master key
Nice introduction of a genius in mathematics.
This interview should really be shown to the curriculum setters of Indian Board Councils! Integration algorithms really do suck! Math is art! 15:00
He is the commette member of NEP 2.0.
This is the Prannoy Roy we loved when we were young. We would wait for his 'World This Week' program as he would bring best in the world to his viewers particularly to the young minds .
This interview with Prof. Bhargav was just marvelous though too short to unravel the the creative mind of this genius with examples from music , poetry and other arts and the mathematical soul into these arts !
Unfortunately like mathematics the poetry was also taught ( as a part of 1st or 2nd language in schools) in a very drab and uninnovative way , I say this with very sincere apologies to some few great teachers ! मराठी शिक्षकांनी आणि पालकांनी बालकवी च्या कवितांचा पुन्हा एकदा सखोल विचार करावा ! आज मला तर असे वाटले की कदाचित ते गणितज्ञ होता होता कवी होऊन गेले !
its too freestyle why should non math teachers watch it ?
Seeing these students faces when they were looking at this clever man was a real tonic, it is great to see young people being influenced by someon so far away better than a pop star or a rapper
lot of thngs to learn frm great men
as a mathematics lover, I highly agree with MANJUL BHARGAVA ...
great mind and so humble . respect !!
admire his simplicity...n opinions/concepts on mathematics teaching-learning...
we indians, we americans, we portugueses, we english... We are citizens of the world, stop that idiot nationalism.
Marco L. Lucas true..
Marco L. Lucas nothing wrong with loving your people
Marco L. Lucas I'm Marco L. Lucas, I am Sachin, I'm Manjul Bhargava, I'm Prannoy...We are humans of the earth, stop this idiotic narcissism. The fact is that you are trying to imagine an ideal society while it functions on pragmatic lines. Communities, countries and names do matter. You have chosen your name as your youtube id which proves your hypocrisy.
SACHIN SHARMA Just in case you misunderstood (or didn't get it all) the comment is trying to say that nationality is irrelevant - a society can only be as ideal as individuals that make it up and you are one of those who negates it hiding behind the"no one is ideal", pretty standard excuse. Names are needed to identify individuals in cases necessary (for eg, the medal could not have been given to you, but to Manjul only), and all that is Manjul's work, not just any individual's AND not any country's. Geographic locations are necessary in working out things in which weather is important or you're travelling. Race is important (though fading rapidly) in medical analyses, and so on. Rest of the 'isms' in the society are created and preserved by opportunists looking to overpower and grab, and followed by brain-washed or subdued (by these opportunists) masses.
Marco L. Lucas I think the context is the teaching SYSTEM within each country. Rote memorization is a VERY POOR METHOD. Apparently, India tends to use memorization over understanding. My own experience (USA) K-12 was diverse. The student is at the mercy of his/her teacher. If the teacher is incompetent, you'd better have motivation to learn yourself. Some teachers are excellent and you can learn a topic at a much deeper level.
Profesor Manjul Bhargava, a genius mathematician from a genius people. Respect from Romania.
The Moment teachers will teach maths for its sheer thinking ability and problem-solving approach not to get good marks in the board, you'll have great mathematicians.
_simple as that_
So serene and pure. Just education and life.
Ndtv plz post the full video on youtube. Its not getting played on yr site or app. Its a treat for ears to hear this professor sir.
www.ndtv.com/video/player/india-questions/india-questions-math-genius-professor-manjul-bhargava/353375?yt watch full interview
Our ancient rich culture of learning mathematics, literature, poetry enriched us. The method of teaching Prof Bhargav repeatedly described is to be implemented at our School, College syllabus.
He's an recipient of prestigious Fields awards in Mathematics ss well as British honor, he's so humble !
Thank you NDTV for such a wonderful talk.... thank you so much...!
Mathematics is beautiful ❤
Hear to all fine minds having origin in India but living abroad and one commonality you would notice is their gratitude towards Indian culture. Indian culture is the mother of all cultures, it's breathing it's very much living. I feel indebted to our great forefathers.
But talented minds in India are not given their due recognition.. perhaps thats what is lacking in our culture which we keep boasting of.
I love maths upto infinity. But Higher order Maths is quite hard to understand. In fact , quality of teaching is important , but at the same time self learning is the bast learning
He is so humble,it's amazing to see him talk
Indian culture is so awesome.. And Sanskrit language is so beautiful
What I did in mathematics.
Lemme tell you.
I was in six.
A man in the bus while travelling to city where I was supposed to go school and he to market.
He said add
These numbers
999
888
777
But answer should be
999
Many people were amazed how this will happen. Many of them said an idiot what kind of question is like.
But I started to find answer at the end solved.
Why I did not say answer doesn't exist because if one asks it must exist.
Till my XII class I created many formulas but unfortunately, all of them already exist.
Knowing that I loose heart and started poetry and written many poems it will be two books collection.
I know accented and unaccented syllables .
My poem consists of four hundred lines containing 14 syllables.
Accented=X
Unaccented=U
XXUXUXU = 7×2=14
There are many poems. Written by me
Our own Sheldon cooper
hes a fucking fictional character.
He is Canadian-American !
minus the sarcastic personality
I thought he was Rajesh Koothrapalli.
u nailed it bro....
People will love mathematics if they see how it is being applied say in fluid dynamics for example. By the way Indian teachers are very good in teaching math. I believe the best way is to show how the math got to applied say in vibroacoustics for example. Ofcourse abstract math can be dry.
*Who agrees that the method of teaching MATHEMATICS in INDIA should be more creative?*
Simple looking but achieve extraordinary achievments in life . Great manjul
He's absolutely correct! Maths suppose to be creative way of solving problems as long as the fundamental supports it!
2:11 Uhmmm.. when did we start to include -1, -2 ... under whole numbers?
2:12 - 1 and - 2 aren't whole numbers
Whole no are those no who are starting from 0
Lol! He really said it wrong. Omg!
ya..
they actually are Integers according to the number system.
What
Was thinking the same when he said it.....
awesum video.
thank u NDTV fr hosting such a show.
I actually tried to make it fun myself and I got addicted.
I didn't know about the poetry the more you know. The more beautiful mathematics becomes.
Y don't we Indian students get these type of teachers
Were indian news used to be this much good?? It's very astonishing
Thanks. Enjoyed the interview.
Maths is typically about problem solving, I belive that Maths works sort of like a computer. This is how it works: To successfully be able to solve anything, A computer undergoes three major and Important steps and they are: Input, process and output. For us humans, when we do Maths we have to typically do the same thing but in a different way. For us Input putting our efforts in, when you think about process, it certainly works in our CPU ( our brain). If the user (which is basically us) does it in a creative and understandable p and easy way, then our output could be much higher than a computer which does it in a Harare way.
what a pleasant and humble guy!
Whole numbers doesn't have negative value
This guy is great.
Great. Fully agree to the concept of mathematics and the beats with poetry.
The Indian sounds like an American and the Anglo sounds like an Indian.
There is no Anglo here. The host is Indian.
Devansh Rathore the whitest Indian I’ve seen. Good for him
Sam Geurdi well a lot Indians have light skin color some even have naturally light brown hair.
Being actually from England, I can tell you he is darker than most white people here. If I didn't hear his accent, I'd assume he's Iranian.
18:20 I was just watching a video about Srinivasa Ramanujan inventing the partitioning formula for integers. I cant believe I've never even know heard of the him before. The man is a mathematical genius.
A beautiful mind
such wonderful polite and talented students, lovely to hear civility and respect on both sides, missing in many so many areas of life
I opted for chemistry pratical rather then chess when my I was in college
She is so simple but genius
It's a he
Shriniwas Ramanujan was the most genius indian mathematician....
Second only to Aryabhatta
@@arunjetli7909 aryabhatta knew nothing that Ramanujam knew
Kumkum Kumari what does that mean
Sada jivan uchch vichar...
Great to listen :)
Monjul wearing Indian attire but anchor is in Anglosaxion clothing! Monjul is a table player as well. Look at this genius ,so simple so pleasent and smiling all the time. God bless him .
What you mean by sum to infinity equals minus one twelfth. Just says an inverted ratios of twelve generates all numbers or a partition sequel. Or if you hit a string of 12 you can get all the notes within that spectrum. Just says edges of a cube.
I didn't know Stevie T was great at math too
He makes a great point. Math teaching should be fun.
To all those like me watching this video and thinking "why didn't I pay more attention to Maths class at School?", I say, don't blame yourself. We should be blaming our education system for making our teachers teach the way they did to make Maths less fun and uninteresting.
True
But we can't blame totally them
In a country as India where earning for survival is a target & added to that feeling of insecure is the reason of lack of developing genios.... developed country provides social security...so u r free to excell in the way u choose....in India talents are buried