Dogs live life at half our life's!! So that means they make every moment count!! So if they decide no in that moment! They know you are still caring for them so they can decide yes at some other time!! So live your life like a dog in a way lol make every moment count!!
Very interesting, thought provoking. I already question everything and now I've been made aware of more questions! 😊 nothing exists on a personal level until it is thought about, even if a person hears about somthing new they process the information in their thoughts.
As a supporter of the human capability of free will ...i`ll say : What a great video. I am not anglo-lingo by first choice, but i understood every word...well presented! Mindboggling as it is is i was looking for inductrines along the entire video...and found none. Grand work!
That is certainly the opinion of the minimally educated and maximally uninformed. It also relies entirely on the baseless assertion that consciousness is the result of a correct arrangement of quarks & gluons.
Here’s an experiment people. When you wake up tomorrow do the exact opposite of what you normally d,you know what I mean. Take a different way to work talk to someone you normally wouldn’t. Watch what happens when you get back to your normal route. It will feel and almost be differs somehow.
If no one has a will of his/her own, whither justice? If everyone is in possession of his/her own free will, why all the constraints on behavior? Worse, why is it when we follow any systematic existence out to its logical extremes, things become meaningless?
To judge something is to express opinion and that exemplifies free will. If it’s an excellent video, then you’re saying it was possible for it to have come out worse. Or that it’s above par, and that shows that the creator had free will to make it bad or excellent, or even just have gotten somewhat lazy and created an average video. However, he chose excellently! His will and determination is what made it excellent. If there’s no free will then nothing is good, bad, or in between. It just “is”
Remember the Indiana Jones movie. The knight “He did not choose wisely” Fascinating. The suit that we reside in has free will while awake. Consciousness resides outside the body according to research and those who have experienced it. The soul which is unending has the control? Guiding our greatest failures and greatest successes.
There is free will, but it is stuck at the atomic level. Immanuel Kant was a German philosopher who claimed that "what is good for me is good". This is how atoms think too.
Atoms do not think. They do not decide to go to the pub. They do not decide to get on a bus instead get a taxi. Are you saying atoms are so advanced that they can think? 😂 You need to stop and think why do I have these episodes of schizophrenia.
@@Vile_Entity_3545 Fortunately, atoms don't think like humans. They don't get on the bus just with you. I hope you are also made of atoms. They even know how to build a galaxy, but no one taught them. And they also know the secret of eternal life.
Actually.. atoms, whether at the quantum or larger level, as defined by classical physics- would not have the capacity/capability to think. It’s been proven by quantum mechanics, that something else is driving atoms.. consciousness. An analogy.. you’re playing a video game, the atoms making up the images on the tv screen, are certainly not thinking in the classical sense.. they are not “doing it on their own”. The atoms on the screen are imbued with the consciousness of the video game creator, and the players. Our physical bodies are no more solid than anything on a screen.. in fact, atoms are never at rest, always moving.. we are a collective infinite consciousness, experiencing a temporary individual reality. Wanted to add.. I believe, the reason for the delay-when measuring the moment of deciding something then executing it.. is another indication that our pure consciousness is driving our physical bodies. Even when doing the experiment.. telling my wrist to move.. I myself can tell I’m “thinking” about moving my wrist before I actually tell it to move.. Donald Hoffman-reality is an illusion.. good stuff:)
@@srhg7014 Bugs don't have brains in their heads, but they still think somehow. Classical physics only applies to clock gears. For metal atoms, the quantum and quantum for the atom's free will.
Every thought you have starts out at a "Superposition" and can stay there or move to a yes or a no position. This is how thoughts (and decisions) mirror quantum physics.
Thx to an enjoyable video of thinking and reasoning. To your Q the answer is both - we have both free will and not. Depending on how we judge that. In using only our mind as a determinant of free will it will [almost] always give us the illusion that we have no free will, like we never know what's really behind our thinking or reasoning about it. Or the Q is that "will" of such "importance" to say free or not free? Similar to quantum state of a particle as the thought of will (free or not) in a double-slit experiment, to understand the wave form of same that lies behind our mind or thinking, or what is "that will" prior to the concentrated particle (mind). The mind (particle) will never grasp our innermost will (the wave form) behind what really is our will - but understanding or knowing that, is reckoning or knowing that there is free will, but not in the way we usually think about it, Thinking is only the particle form of our consciousness. So the Q is rather what is our consciousness and is free will then an important part, or actual part, of it then? But in our mind can not grasp our consciousness so we might better stop questioning it and dive into what's behind it, the seemingly randomness of endless possibilities not reached solely by our thinking about it. Ok, just a thought in the early morning in a different timezone playing with a few words in the middle of nowhere, maybe another planet 🙂 Must wake up and get me an expresso now, that's using my free will, isn't it?
Think of life as a computer game, a role play game. Your born into a story. At the beginning of the game, you have no idea on what is actually going on, so you start learning how to do things. You gain experience and skills from this process. Everything you do in the game, is for you to decide, however it don't change the fact that the game also has an Ending, and no matter your choices, the ending is set. How you get to the end of the game.... Thats for you to figure out The meaning of life is to Experience it.
Bottom line many make choices thru the ego all those are bad paths the only good path one can take is if we listen to the voice of reason aka the spirit and that is it that simple. Free will is there if you willing to use it and take it for yourself be silent be still stop everything.
Have you ever thought for a second that all life is meaningless in the grand stage of the universe and no matter what we think, attempt to stop, change or even delay the inevitable end to all light.
Free will was given by God as clearly indicated in scripture. He allows us to make our own mistakes. He still retains the right to interfere at His discretion. But by and large, He isn't allowing tragedies to occur, He us honoring our free will ability to fuck up and learn from it.
I had an episode where I forgot every decision I made as I made it. I went back and forth on the spot. I was trying to put a key in the door lock. I made the decision to put the key in the door but forgot that before I did. Free will playing games? No. Just a case of Transient Global Amnesia. It passed.
The universe is perfectly predictable but our creator built us not to be able to measure it precisely EVER because mystery is an important part of our existence
"Our Creator" ?...The Universe is Our Creator, there is no Bearded Man sitting Watching Planning our Lives Etc...we're a Product of our Environment, not a Intelligent Being...it would be VERY childish to believe in some 'Magical All Powerful God' that Somehow Controls everything in the Universe, We thought of a "Creator-God" when Humans were Ignorant of the Universe and it's Workings, When We believed the Earth was the Center of things and everything Oerbitted US!..Before we realized We're just dust really....specks of Matter that clumped together and over time the Mix of Molecules created different Lumps...and WE ARE ONE OF THOSE LUMPS!...NOTHING MORE!..Our Creator is Under Our Feet...Above us..Outside us...and Inside us.. There's NO creator but the Universe.
Man can never know all the mysteries of this life and this universe. We have to understand that we can’t know everything,we are extremely limited beings….why we don’t even really know the mysteries of our own bodies,we put food in our mouths but all the functions that take place after that are beyond our control ! The marvels of this temple (body) are just that, a marvel. Only god knows .our mission on earth is to recognise that and submit to his mighty plan through guidance he sent down through the prophets and Devine books.the last of them being the holy prophet Mohammad (s a w) and the glorious Quran …..
Great vid! Nicely done! Perhaps our "free-will" comes into play before birth, where we work on the "blueprint" to our life and once we're born, we're limited on our "free-will." Perhaps, it's something we need to realign with from the physical side after we're born, but either way, we gotta follow the blue print we laid out for ourselves.🤔 Just a thought. The algorithms brought me here. Now, I'm subscribing. Algorithms are good for some things.😂 Much love.💖
You cannot realign the biological blueprints that were chosen by your parents and are evident in every cell of your body. The only realignment that is possible is to create the next generation with proper inherited genetics, proper altered genetics, and healthy early childhood synaptic development. You can influence what type of human is brought into the world, but there is no fixing them after that. They just run their course in the absence of free will.
Great video and wonderful topic, .. The old questions of , is everything exactly as it is meant to be? Clockwork theory has reminded us that there is a lot more how the universe functions, have we already made all those actions that we did today half an hour ago, on some other parallel existence? Perhaps anti mater and our so called junk DNA actually facilitates that what we think is our free will ,somewhere else but half an hour ago ? I Enjoyed this video very much and thank you to everyone who works on putting this together for the channel. And eventually us the subscribers, please know that it’s appreciated,well done all ❤
Let's keep it simple. Einstein's theory of special relativity has been extensively tested and demonstrates that the Universe behaves like a block where past, present, and future coexist. Therefore, the movie has already been filmed, and we are witnessing its playback at a rate of one second per second. Most likely, the entire movie is nothing more than the product of a simulation that already exists on a cosmic DVD or streaming. The simulation has already run, and now we are witnessing its playback. Millions of years ago, there was no consciousness on the planet, which shows that our presence in the universe is completely irrelevant to it, so don't worry, be happy.
"Choice," is an illusion. One can voluntarily do everything to serve "god" and or act as the extension of god. We are all part and parts of the same stuff. !(: "Free will," just means you can go live out the hard lessons first hand ;)!
Now I think you should make a video about storing memory in our subconscious and our cerebellum and memory bank!! And how we can access memories and knowledge within the four realms!!
In a realm of queries, where semantics weave, Debate unfolds, definitions to retrieve. A dance of quantum possibilities told, In this cosmic tale, mysteries unfold. This video, a tapestry of thought, Leaves us questioning, what have we sought? In the dance of free will, a quantum ballet, Where possibilities swirl in a mystical array. A reflection profound, in philosophy's gaze, Science and reason, in a nebulous haze. The human experience, a canvas untamed, In the quest for meaning, where minds are framed. Semantics may toy, with words and with fate, Redefining the boundaries, we contemplate. A symphony of questions, echoing clear, As free will aligns with what we hold dear. An exploration, profound and deep, Through the corridors of uncertainty, we creep. In the quantum embrace, where truth may reside, This video beckons, our beliefs to confide. So, let us ponder, with curious delight, As the tapestry unfolds, in the quantum night. Questioning everything, a journey untold, In the dance of free will, our stories unfold.
But could you have choose anything other than the choices you made or were they always inevitable w the info at that time? Having choices doesn’t prove free will but is a clue to the possibility.
I don't believe in clockwork determinism. I do not believe that my outcomes would be of any importance to some higher power. I'm just not that important in the universe. I believe that the universe is always changing, but it was never created and will never end. There was no Big Bang. Too many people are obsessed with knowing the unknowable. @@steveunderhill5935
In our own experiences, we cannot objectively determine whether our spontaneous choices come from our own original impulse or as a reaction to preordained conditions. But as for simulation theory.. Who or what could honestly be bothered? The amount of input required would be beyond the job description of most deities let alone any (no matter how hard-working) living being! But whilst I mostly reject any deterministic thinking, we do experience one thing that should give us pause. That is synchronicity. To greater or lesser degree, synchronicities where the outer world suddenly aligns with our own thoughts pose a couple of uncomfortable questions. Either the outer world was influenced by my thought, or my thought was determined by the course of the outer world. Both ideas suggest some sort of fate or predetermined plan.. In reality there has to be some sort of interaction between the potential and the actual realities.
Free Will *does* exist but it's not as 'free' as we may like to believe. The term 'Free Will' implies an open ended response/decision/answer system, where absolutely any possibility could be your response to any decision. In practice however, 'Free Will' is limited to a fixed number of possible choices (unique to each time it is applied). For example: * - You choose the color of shirt you'd wear today, but your decision is limited to the colors that shirts may be sold in or limited to the colors of shirts you own. * - If asked about attending a friend's birthday party, you could choose to attend or decline or reserve to decide at a later time. You're always limited by a fixed number of possible choices. There is not a single moment when you have absolute Carte Blanche. Theoretically speaking, every single outcome, with the outcomes then leading to other choices and so on, could be calculated by an appropriately designed computer program.
Nietzsche's nihilistic approach is a good starting point. Maybe the 'key' is to understand that all concepts, be they scientific, philosophical, or otherwise, are of human construct and can only attempt to be communicated within the constraints of language, which again is a human construct. To see through fresh eyes...
Free will? Hmmm. In the stream of time and events we are carried along with the current. Yet in our journey our free will is mostly limited by our POV as long as we exist on this mortal plane. There are certain constraints that are deterministic, such as wars, economies, place of birth, etc. But like a fish we "choose" how we will navigate determined as much by our perceptions as by reality. IMHO we are constrained both by causality and our own determination. Ultimately It's one of those crazy irresistible force vs immovable object type of conundrum.
We have choices. After severe injuries we can will ourselves to heal and renew. We can work through the pain and build our bodies back up. The body is miraculous at healing. Either we can give up and allow our bodies to atrophy after trauma or we can build ourselves back up again. It’s a choice and we can make it happen. I’ve seen much evidence of this in my personal life to know that people can be stubborn and work through pain, heal and renew. It is not easy, but there is no other way than to try and stay dedicated. It can take years. Keep on, one day at a time. Focus on today, on the present, one minute at a time. Blessings.
...and thats the result of eating the forbidden fruit. Drowning in a sea of "Who's right and who's wrong, what's true and what's false, what matters and what doesnt". Questionning everything will drown you in an infinite loop of questions all leading to the main question: "Why Are We Here".... Best way to stay afloat is to follow our own righteous purpose. But whats purpose if life is an illusion? And you're back questionning everything again: "Did the forbidden fruit really existed?....
Unless omniscient it seems impossible to confirm with certainty how much free will we have, if any. I know I feel like I do even if living in a predetermined simulation. I want to make decisions taking consequences into consideration. I live as if facts exist and we all share the same realty regardless of differing beliefs. The universe seems a mix of order and chaos.
Free will has nothing to do with physics. Physics say I can’t fly, float, or levitate without mechanical assistance while on Earth, free will says I can still try although I may unalive myself because physics exists.
The destination is always the same because creation happened was over instantly but the past to get there is the free will it's not about the destiny it's always about the journey.
Oddly enough, quantum computers, and their Q-bits being either 0, 1 either or both, is actually a working computer that "calculates" faster than digital computers. So is it really random, and can this randomness actually lead to exact calculations? I guess it can. No one may be able to truly understand quantum physics, but it can be used in precise ways. "Reality, what a concept." - Robin Williams
Every single choice we make is based on an emotion. Emotions are based on a chemical reaction. That’s why people all say “I feel…..”. Think about that.
So. Many. Questions. Did an Ai intelligence write this film? Who curated the images? Where are the artist credits? This is an AMAZING video but it seems off. Must rewatch. I will have more questions
Free willl is fact. The ability of the human mind to manifest absolute alternate reality wholly new concepts and convince itself of its truth is free will on steroids. The mind has no limits and can reach across space/ time.and reality itself. The question is Does a thought truly exist if the beholder never shares it with the outside world. Is it lost as if it never happened or is the information therin part of the entirety of information which make up this reality.? Please post your testable proof as to the answere...
noone can stop the will of the allmighty, insted of gods mercy gods creation is allrdy determinated....created...so our fre will, is to move in this creation
Derive a number at random in that many days drive thru the round about twice, have friend roll dice or flip coin to go around again yes no ? See what happens!
I will now rant about something that either makes total sense or is completely senseless. Im not saying this is right or wrong, just what I currently believe and am open to thinking differently about it too. I think that some peoples views of what determinism and quantum mechanics are needs to change for it to make more sense. If you've never experienced very bad depression and suicidal thoughts, then it would be hard to predict what someone like that would do, even the person with suicidal thoughts would find it hard to understand what they want to do because they are in a very chaotic state of mind. Just because from an outside perspective we cannot understand what they would do, and even to the person experiencing it doesnt know, it doesnt mean that there isnt a process happening to determine it. Language and with it our personal perspective on the world and human concepts just end up clouding the way we think about things. Your conscious mind is bothered and clouded by thinking about these complex/arbitrary concepts such as suicidal thoughts, but the unconscious mind is breaking down these concepts into more fundamental and less chaotic concepts/reasons for you. What does this mean? It means your unconscious mind is what is governing your conscious thoughts, and its not random. It breaks down these complex concepts into more simple terms (for example why do you pick up a phone? A phone is just a random arrangement of atoms but to your conscious mind you view it mainly as a phone and a device you can use to do any number of things through your view of reality. Your unconscious mind breaks down what a phone is into smaller and smaller concepts until eventually you probably reach a point of, I picked it up to feel better in that moment. It goes a bit beyond picking up the phone because you want to scroll instagram or talk to a friend) in an effort to make more sense of them so it can then determine the most optimal way of receiving "happiness"/"understanding"/"authenticity to the individual and their unique make up", but it can only do this based on previous experience and that individuals own world view and perspective on all the human concepts it knows. Depressing thoughts and suicide are extremely complex thoughts tho. In order for the conscious mind and unconscious mind to understand the reasoning's behind suicidal thoughts, the unconscious mind has to break this chaotic concept down so far that what it becomes left with is not a clear understanding of the concept. If the mind stays in this state for an extended period of time tho, it finds patterns in these broken down concepts in an effort to create reasons for understanding the chaotic thought of suicide. To observers when hearing those reasoning. It would just sound almost like nonsense. The number of hoops they had to jump through to justify that line of thinking. All the observer can do is make assumptions based on their own knowledge and experience to attempt to understand the chaotic experience and concept it has been told. If their brain has also went through something similar, it can recognize some of those patterns of broken down concepts already to make understanding it easier. It is however probably impossible to ever know the entirety of some someones experience, and so its probably impossible to fully determine someones actions. You can compare this to photons of light an how they appear to be in-deterministic until the moment they are observed. Its the same as the mind is. A thought can not be observed from an outside perspective until the moment it has been acted out or said out loud. Consciousness and experience is the manifestation of the quantum world in the macro reality. Its allowing us to almost peer at what is going on with subatomic particles. You can think of a person as being in a super position of possible states and those possible states are determined by their experience and view of reality and also the stimulus that is it currently receiving. You can think of the entirety of humanity as in a quantum super position too. Its impossible to say where humanity will be in the far future because thinking that far ahead requires too many complex concepts to create a clear image of it. We can make fairly likely claims where we may be in a few years tho. Those claims however are ever changing based on how humanity behaves and does what it does as a whole. You can even think of an area of your desk as being in a quantum superposition. You can predictably claim that dust will accumulate on it in the same way you can predictably claim that humanity will live until next year. You cant predict the formation of accumulated dust or how long it will even take for you to even see it as something that's dusty, but it will accumulate the way it does because how much dust there is around and the flow of air or lack there of in the room over many days or hours and the way the each individual spec of dust (with their own unique formations like snowflakes) interact with the air around it. You can also think of this or any text as being in a quantum superposition. I myself wrote this with a certain intention and meaning, but everyone who reads it will view in through the lense they view the world in and get different intentions and meanings. The very text itself could have a seemly infinite number of possible interpretations. Its inherently chaotic. To a dog it has no meaning, to a person it ends up having the meaning it has due to their previous experience and perspective on the individual words and text as a whole. If you could simulate everything in the entire universe you would be able to predict all of those actions. There is causal reasoning behind everything. Just because free will and consciousness may not exist in the traditional concept or understanding you or we have of it. Doesn't mean that everything has to be meaningless. If everything really is meaningless, then everything is also full of meaning too. Just remember that because someone does something rude or mean. Its not because they are a "bad" person. Its just because their circumstances in life have led them to have a particular world view in which behaving that way makes sense to them. I dont think I can hate someone like that instead of feeling bad for them and hoping they can get better or even try attempt to help them myself. You can be the person that changes the meaning that person sees in things, and they can then be that person for someone else in a cascading fractal effect, of which you are already apart of a seemingly near infinite amount of already. I do not however agree with the criminal aspect of the video. You can say it was the universe that made them do that. But criminals also think in human concepts. Not in universal causes. Its the situation that humanity created for that criminal to experience life the way he did which caused him to turn into a criminal. Which was avoidable in retrospect, if we just understand that its us that created the criminal, and that we should want to change that going forward as a species. We basically of mocked and made fun of that by creating such a chaotic environment for them to try and make sense of until they became a criminal who we then locked up and punished. Doesn't really sound fair does it. Im not saying we shouldn't lock up criminals, only that we have to accept this is the society we created and that we should try our best to make a brighter world for the people around us rn and the people in the future, but also yourself. Search for what makes you happy and do it, just dont get too caught up in chaotic concepts. Just keep asking yourself why you do the things you do.
There is no such thing as free will , the most basic of all choices you don’t have control over. You should be able to choose what you like and dislike. But you don’t have that simple basic choice. You can’t choose
wow.....lot of depth .......in this video. amazing how our ,minds wander(aimlessly) about with so many theories//arguments about cause and affect , determinism, free will etc etc when we don't have God and his book (quram) in our lives. please please read Quran it will talk to you and give you your answers. please
I hate to be picky but quantum physics is not random. Some outcomes are more probable than others and therefore they are not random. Complete randomness is scientifically impossible. However, I agree that the idea of free will is problematic mainly because language is problematic and the unknowable which is what Wittgenstein was trying to point out. When it comes to philosophy the first lesson I learned was that philosophy is not about confusing yourself with circular arguments. It is about giving knowledge a perceptive where common ground is a possibility. I think free will is best understood in its political sense. It is part of human right that is given to individuals. Therefore, the important aspect of it is who owns it and not how a particular decision comes about anywhere along the spectrum of random and reasoned. Then we can extrapolated that to ourselves in which case their is no need to have the interference of problem of mind and body. It is the right to choose in which case one can say it might not be free but it is still mine. We are allowing freedom of choice. The idea of responsibility is not and should not be associated with free will. Responsibility is the consequence of a choice imposed on an individual by society or himself. It is a judgment and dependent on who makes it and within what context. Social responsibility is a manufactured notion as are all the other human laws created for the of sake co-existence. You don't have to be "irresponsible" to make an "irresponsible" choice. It is a value judgment imposed not chosen.
There is no 'free will' in the material/deterministic world as we are all bound by something called 'Karma'. Thou in the ethereal/emotional world we have a Free Will to choose HOW we RESPOND to the 'impulses' and the 'reality' of the material world. We should be (through the proper use of the free will) the masters of our emotions. E-motion (energy in motion) should be controlled ... that is the free will.
I still get annoyed about AI voiced content. It is very convincing, but here and there the cadence is just wrong enough to know that a script is being read absent understanding.
At time 1:46 delivered as: "OK, for traditional descriptions of free will, we first see it as the ability to freely choose one of several possible alternatives to make decisions, the outcome of which cannot be known in advance'" instead of "OK, for traditional descriptions of free will, we first see it as the ability to freely choose one of several possible alternatives, to make decisions the outcome of which cannot be known in advance'". The pause should be after "alternatives" not after "make decisions".
You could choose s certain flavor of ice cream but be misunderstood and then served a different flavor which you decide to go with so it wasn't your choice at all but not determinism
Free will or not - hmm... I believe we have free will to the extent that we may chose from several different paths. Each, results in the sane end, just a differing story, along the way. Afterall - this is all just a computer sym. Quantum mechanics dictates such.
No free will. Criminals get theirs because the just also act without free will. Not simulated. The start had some amount of energy that determined the space by sending the things instantly to their location. But in the space nothing stops so it’s weird. Probably in the larger it also does not stop but still it’s real but does not last. Can things stop probably not.
Its obvious the Sphinx statue was originally a lion and reworked with the human head . The head is too out of proportion . The British and other Europeans turned that complex in to a theme park essentially and probably ruined loads of ancient artifacts .Also the stone pots are another funny one the older granite pots have perfect symmetry and are precisely carved yet the newer ones are pottery or look ragged .
Adding a comment will always have a future comment outcome! Just thinking outside the vox and putting your perspective in the web or lige around you! Will always be acknowledged by somebody :).
Free will is simple you make the decision but outside factors influence the decisions you make. If you have ever been married you know what I mean 😮. I should make a video.
If you mentioned about simulation theory then forget to study and make a video about new concept about simulation theory its called the "The second law of infodynamics"
It's not a new concept to me. In fact, I thought I created this concept until I saw this video. I believe at 100% of deterministic theory. There is no chance or probability. If something's happen, it is because it was supposed to happen. If you win at a lottery with 50 millions possibility, we call it chance. but there is none. Why? Cause we cannot calculate in advanced the result in a restraint amount of time. Everything that we don't understand, we call it chance or probability. But this is all a illusion. We have the illusion of freewill and it is fine to have that illusion. We cannot apply deterministic theory to our lives and let the consequence happen cause we would become lazy. But even that last concept I just told comes into the equation of deterministic theory. A butterfly will influence the weather cause everything comes into the equation. Everything is one.
Not sure But if we had free will we could had choosed how things should happen in this life sinve no one will choose jaiĺ the world could had been of balanced if life was fair
After 3 minutes I'm board and already typing comments. Questioning why I am watching a long winded video attempting to sound esoteric, but instead superficial, full of meaningless deepness. Cut to the chase, the one question to ask, is consciousness or self a product of the brain or something external to the brain? All who work in medical fields associated with the brain agree, according to "the science", consciousness or self is a product of the brain. Yet 50% of those same professionals say they personally believe there must be something more to consciousness, a spiritual level, that consciousness or self is external to the brain and body. The physical universe as we experience it, is deterministic, free will does not truly exist if consciousness is merely a construct of the brain and environment; only if consciousness or self is external and exists before and after the body. {quantum brain theories on consciousness have no proven validity and discounted by most}
My puppy has free will, when I tell her No! She says yes.
lol dealing with mine atm trying to listen to this profound knowledge but the choice I made moths ago to get her has determined my fate😂
...lol..and dont get me started on CATS!😂
Id like to rescue a three wheeled puppy...
So does my wife!
Dogs live life at half our life's!! So that means they make every moment count!! So if they decide no in that moment! They know you are still caring for them so they can decide yes at some other time!! So live your life like a dog in a way lol make every moment count!!
One day they'll look back at this debate and laugh. What we lack is perspective.
True “Free Will” in a modern controlled civilization is very rare .
Very interesting, thought provoking. I already question everything and now I've been made aware of more questions! 😊 nothing exists on a personal level until it is thought about, even if a person hears about somthing new they process the information in their thoughts.
We all like to be entertained. God is no different. Free will is unpredictable. That’s the entertainment value to this lab experiment.
As a supporter of the human capability of free will ...i`ll say : What a great video. I am not anglo-lingo by first choice, but i understood every word...well presented! Mindboggling as it is is i was looking for inductrines along the entire video...and found none. Grand work!
If "everything is as it should be" Free will doesn't exist.
Also the universe is perfectly balanced. So every action and reaction is factored in the system from the beginning
Correct, but we do however have the "experience" of free will, so..🤷
@@smashingtwoscoops4999 the "steak" is not real
Birds are not real. I am glad someone else said exactly what I was thinking from the beginning. ❤😊
That is certainly the opinion of the minimally educated and maximally uninformed.
It also relies entirely on the baseless assertion that consciousness is the result of a correct arrangement of quarks & gluons.
Here’s an experiment people. When you wake up tomorrow do the exact opposite of what you normally d,you know what I mean. Take a different way to work talk to someone you normally wouldn’t. Watch what happens when you get back to your normal route. It will feel and almost be differs somehow.
If no one has a will of his/her own, whither justice? If everyone is in possession of his/her own free will, why all the constraints on behavior? Worse, why is it when we follow any systematic existence out to its logical extremes, things become meaningless?
Free will is an illusion created by man. Excellent video.
Free will is given to us by God and enforced by His son Jesus.
How did he create it if he didn't have the will to do it?
Simply, you get steering and brakes. It is up to you to use them and how much. But is there auto (in born) steering and brakes, in my experience, yes.
What is it to create?
To judge something is to express opinion and that exemplifies free will. If it’s an excellent video, then you’re saying it was possible for it to have come out worse. Or that it’s above par, and that shows that the creator had free will to make it bad or excellent, or even just have gotten somewhat lazy and created an average video.
However, he chose excellently! His will and determination is what made it excellent.
If there’s no free will then nothing is good, bad, or in between. It just “is”
Remember the Indiana Jones movie. The knight “He did not choose wisely” Fascinating. The suit that we reside in has free will while awake. Consciousness resides outside the body according to research and those who have experienced it. The soul which is unending has the control? Guiding our greatest failures and greatest successes.
Free will of perception is all that matters.
There is free will, but it is stuck at the atomic level. Immanuel Kant was a German philosopher who claimed that "what is good for me is good". This is how atoms think too.
Atoms do not think. They do not decide to go to the pub. They do not decide to get on a bus instead get a taxi.
Are you saying atoms are so advanced that they can think? 😂
You need to stop and think why do I have these episodes of schizophrenia.
@@Vile_Entity_3545 Fortunately, atoms don't think like humans. They don't get on the bus just with you. I hope you are also made of atoms. They even know how to build a galaxy, but no one taught them. And they also know the secret of eternal life.
@@sakkmattvery interesting point, maybe atoms have the universes "DNA" just like we are made of human DNA
Actually.. atoms, whether at the quantum or larger level, as defined by classical physics- would not have the capacity/capability to think. It’s been proven by quantum mechanics, that something else is driving atoms.. consciousness. An analogy.. you’re playing a video game, the atoms making up the images on the tv screen, are certainly not thinking in the classical sense.. they are not “doing it on their own”. The atoms on the screen are imbued with the consciousness of the video game creator, and the players. Our physical bodies are no more solid than anything on a screen.. in fact, atoms are never at rest, always moving.. we are a collective infinite consciousness, experiencing a temporary individual reality.
Wanted to add.. I believe, the reason for the delay-when measuring the moment of deciding something then executing it.. is another indication that our pure consciousness is driving our physical bodies. Even when doing the experiment.. telling my wrist to move.. I myself can tell I’m “thinking” about moving my wrist before I actually tell it to move.. Donald Hoffman-reality is an illusion.. good stuff:)
@@srhg7014 Bugs don't have brains in their heads, but they still think somehow. Classical physics only applies to clock gears. For metal atoms, the quantum and quantum for the atom's free will.
Free will is the illusion, all the choices you have and ever will make have already been made. We play out through the light s if we have a choice.
Brilliant understand everything
Fantastic video, thank you!
Every thought you have starts out at a "Superposition" and can stay there or move to a yes or a no position. This is how thoughts (and decisions) mirror quantum physics.
Excellent video, as usual. Of course, we are forced to make choices in our daily lives, or else choose apathy, which sucks even worse LOL.
The only free will we have is to chose what kind of slave we want to be.
And even that has its limits.
Thx to an enjoyable video of thinking and reasoning. To your Q the answer is both - we have both free will and not. Depending on how we judge that. In using only our mind as a determinant of free will it will [almost] always give us the illusion that we have no free will, like we never know what's really behind our thinking or reasoning about it. Or the Q is that "will" of such "importance" to say free or not free? Similar to quantum state of a particle as the thought of will (free or not) in a double-slit experiment, to understand the wave form of same that lies behind our mind or thinking, or what is "that will" prior to the concentrated particle (mind). The mind (particle) will never grasp our innermost will (the wave form) behind what really is our will - but understanding or knowing that, is reckoning or knowing that there is free will, but not in the way we usually think about it, Thinking is only the particle form of our consciousness. So the Q is rather what is our consciousness and is free will then an important part, or actual part, of it then? But in our mind can not grasp our consciousness so we might better stop questioning it and dive into what's behind it, the seemingly randomness of endless possibilities not reached solely by our thinking about it. Ok, just a thought in the early morning in a different timezone playing with a few words in the middle of nowhere, maybe another planet 🙂 Must wake up and get me an expresso now, that's using my free will, isn't it?
Lol, what? No.
Freier Wille:
Hast du einen Willen ...
... ist es mit der Freiheit vorbei
Classification Leaks Paradox:
If P(X)=0 PROVABLE then P(X)=1
QED.
Great ideas
Think of life as a computer game, a role play game. Your born into a story. At the beginning of the game, you have no idea on what is actually going on, so you start learning how to do things.
You gain experience and skills from this process.
Everything you do in the game, is for you to decide, however it don't change the fact that the game also has an Ending, and no matter your choices, the ending is set. How you get to the end of the game.... Thats for you to figure out
The meaning of life is to Experience it.
Bottom line many make choices thru the ego all those are bad paths the only good path one can take is if we listen to the voice of reason aka the spirit and that is it that simple. Free will is there if you willing to use it and take it for yourself be silent be still stop everything.
Have you ever thought for a second that all life is meaningless in the grand stage of the universe and no matter what we think, attempt to stop, change or even delay the inevitable end to all light.
When I put my body in the cold water, something happens, yes like a dimensional shift
Free will was given by God as clearly indicated in scripture. He allows us to make our own mistakes. He still retains the right to interfere at His discretion. But by and large, He isn't allowing tragedies to occur, He us honoring our free will ability to fuck up and learn from it.
Humans act. It's basically the definition. Acting man requires one choice among many alternatives but choose we must, or we are not men.
God gives us free will to show that we really need him in the end.
I'm blown away. Great video. Now I understand that I do not understand.
I had an episode where I forgot every decision I made as I made it. I went back and forth on the spot. I was trying to put a key in the door lock. I made the decision to put the key in the door but forgot that before I did. Free will playing games? No. Just a case of Transient Global Amnesia. It passed.
blame CERN bro trust
Need to determine free will and opposed to what? God? Society? Yourself? On and on.
Ancients Egyptians believed that our creator knows us better than we understand ourselves. Every decision we make, it already knows what will happened
They believed in multiple gods.
The universe is perfectly predictable but our creator built us not to be able to measure it precisely EVER because mystery is an important part of our existence
"Our Creator" ?...The Universe is Our Creator, there is no Bearded Man sitting Watching Planning our Lives Etc...we're a Product of our Environment, not a Intelligent Being...it would be VERY childish to believe in some 'Magical All Powerful God' that Somehow Controls everything in the Universe, We thought of a "Creator-God" when Humans were Ignorant of the Universe and it's Workings, When We believed the Earth was the Center of things and everything Oerbitted US!..Before we realized We're just dust really....specks of Matter that clumped together and over time the Mix of Molecules created different Lumps...and WE ARE ONE OF THOSE LUMPS!...NOTHING MORE!..Our Creator is Under Our Feet...Above us..Outside us...and Inside us.. There's NO creator but the Universe.
Man can never know all the mysteries of this life and this universe. We have to understand that we can’t know everything,we are extremely limited beings….why we don’t even really know the mysteries of our own bodies,we put food in our mouths but all the functions that take place after that are beyond our control ! The marvels of this temple (body) are just that, a marvel. Only god knows .our mission on earth is to recognise that and submit to his mighty plan through guidance he sent down through the prophets and Devine books.the last of them being the holy prophet Mohammad (s a w) and the glorious Quran …..
Wishful thinking.
Great vid! Nicely done! Perhaps our "free-will" comes into play before birth, where we work on the "blueprint" to our life and once we're born, we're limited on our "free-will." Perhaps, it's something we need to realign with from the physical side after we're born, but either way, we gotta follow the blue print we laid out for ourselves.🤔 Just a thought. The algorithms brought me here. Now, I'm subscribing. Algorithms are good for some things.😂 Much love.💖
You cannot realign the biological blueprints that were chosen by your parents and are evident in every cell of your body. The only realignment that is possible is to create the next generation with proper inherited genetics, proper altered genetics, and healthy early childhood synaptic development. You can influence what type of human is brought into the world, but there is no fixing them after that. They just run their course in the absence of free will.
Interesting.
Great video and wonderful topic, .. The old questions of , is everything exactly as it is meant to be? Clockwork theory has reminded us that there is a lot more how the universe functions, have we already made all those actions that we did today half an hour ago, on some other parallel existence? Perhaps anti mater and our so called junk DNA actually facilitates that what we think is our free will ,somewhere else but half an hour ago ? I Enjoyed this video very much and thank you to everyone who works on putting this together for the channel. And eventually us the subscribers, please know that it’s appreciated,well done all ❤
THERE MIGHT A SIMULATION BUT THE ONE KNOWS, THERE IS NO PERAMETERS.😊 AND THAT IS FREE WILL!
Time is none existent understanding that will get you further than anything else you can imagine
I don't believe time is real either. It's just something made up by humans.
Let's keep it simple. Einstein's theory of special relativity has been extensively tested and demonstrates that the Universe behaves like a block where past, present, and future coexist. Therefore, the movie has already been filmed, and we are witnessing its playback at a rate of one second per second. Most likely, the entire movie is nothing more than the product of a simulation that already exists on a cosmic DVD or streaming. The simulation has already run, and now we are witnessing its playback. Millions of years ago, there was no consciousness on the planet, which shows that our presence in the universe is completely irrelevant to it, so don't worry, be happy.
"Choice," is an illusion.
One can voluntarily do everything to serve "god" and or act as the extension of god.
We are all part and parts of the same stuff.
!(: "Free will," just means you can go live out the hard lessons first hand ;)!
Wow❤
Now I think you should make a video about storing memory in our subconscious and our cerebellum and memory bank!! And how we can access memories and knowledge within the four realms!!
In a realm of queries, where semantics weave,
Debate unfolds, definitions to retrieve.
A dance of quantum possibilities told,
In this cosmic tale, mysteries unfold.
This video, a tapestry of thought,
Leaves us questioning, what have we sought?
In the dance of free will, a quantum ballet,
Where possibilities swirl in a mystical array.
A reflection profound, in philosophy's gaze,
Science and reason, in a nebulous haze.
The human experience, a canvas untamed,
In the quest for meaning, where minds are framed.
Semantics may toy, with words and with fate,
Redefining the boundaries, we contemplate.
A symphony of questions, echoing clear,
As free will aligns with what we hold dear.
An exploration, profound and deep,
Through the corridors of uncertainty, we creep.
In the quantum embrace, where truth may reside,
This video beckons, our beliefs to confide.
So, let us ponder, with curious delight,
As the tapestry unfolds, in the quantum night.
Questioning everything, a journey untold,
In the dance of free will, our stories unfold.
Choose free will or you can clock in.
"Freewilll" is the space I create between action and reaction.
Images,pics and thoughts can be transferred by resonance but matter itself cannot
As long as there exists more than one choice, of course there is free will.
But could you have choose anything other than the choices you made or were they always inevitable w the info at that time? Having choices doesn’t prove free will but is a clue to the possibility.
I don't believe in clockwork determinism. I do not believe that my outcomes would be of any importance to some higher power. I'm just not that important in the universe. I believe that the universe is always changing, but it was never created and will never end. There was no Big Bang. Too many people are obsessed with knowing the unknowable. @@steveunderhill5935
O How Love I thy works...Gratitude ❤
In our own experiences, we cannot objectively determine whether our spontaneous choices come from our own original impulse or as a reaction to preordained conditions. But as for simulation theory.. Who or what could honestly be bothered? The amount of input required would be beyond the job description of most deities let alone any (no matter how hard-working) living being! But whilst I mostly reject any deterministic thinking, we do experience one thing that should give us pause. That is synchronicity. To greater or lesser degree, synchronicities where the outer world suddenly aligns with our own thoughts pose a couple of uncomfortable questions. Either the outer world was influenced by my thought, or my thought was determined by the course of the outer world. Both ideas suggest some sort of fate or predetermined plan..
In reality there has to be some sort of interaction between the potential and the actual realities.
Nothings free.
Everything has a price.
Free Will *does* exist but it's not as 'free' as we may like to believe.
The term 'Free Will' implies an open ended response/decision/answer system, where absolutely any possibility could be your response to any decision.
In practice however, 'Free Will' is limited to a fixed number of possible choices (unique to each time it is applied).
For example:
* - You choose the color of shirt you'd wear today, but your decision is limited to the colors that shirts may be sold in or limited to the colors of shirts you own.
* - If asked about attending a friend's birthday party, you could choose to attend or decline or reserve to decide at a later time.
You're always limited by a fixed number of possible choices.
There is not a single moment when you have absolute Carte Blanche.
Theoretically speaking, every single outcome, with the outcomes then leading to other choices and so on, could be calculated by an appropriately designed computer program.
Nietzsche's nihilistic approach is a good starting point. Maybe the 'key' is to understand that all concepts, be they scientific, philosophical, or otherwise, are of human construct and can only attempt to be communicated within the constraints of language, which again is a human construct. To see through fresh eyes...
You bring up a good point: If GOD gives you free will why do people get punished for disobeying? That isn't free will
Everything has its purposes, uses, abilities (scope) and or a role
THANK YOU . KNOW WHY. BE CAUSE
Free will? Hmmm. In the stream of time and events we are carried along with the current. Yet in our journey our free will is mostly limited by our POV as long as we exist on this mortal plane. There are certain constraints that are deterministic, such as wars, economies, place of birth, etc. But like a fish we "choose" how we will navigate determined as much by our perceptions as by reality. IMHO we are constrained both by causality and our own determination. Ultimately It's one of those crazy irresistible force vs immovable object type of conundrum.
We have choices. After severe injuries we can will ourselves to heal and renew. We can work through the pain and build our bodies back up. The body is miraculous at healing. Either we can give up and allow our bodies to atrophy after trauma or we can build ourselves back up again. It’s a choice and we can make it happen. I’ve seen much evidence of this in my personal life to know that people can be stubborn and work through pain, heal and renew. It is not easy, but there is no other way than to try and stay dedicated. It can take years. Keep on, one day at a time. Focus on today, on the present, one minute at a time. Blessings.
...and thats the result of eating the forbidden fruit.
Drowning in a sea of "Who's right and who's wrong, what's true and what's false, what matters and what doesnt".
Questionning everything will drown you in an infinite loop of questions all leading to the main question: "Why Are We Here"....
Best way to stay afloat is to follow our own righteous purpose. But whats purpose if life is an illusion?
And you're back questionning everything again: "Did the forbidden fruit really existed?....
If we have no access to our subconscious, then how can we say that we have free will in the decisions we make?
@8:02 We cannot predict what people will do but live as if we can predict what they will do.
Unless omniscient it seems impossible to confirm with certainty how much free will we have, if any. I know I feel like I do even if living in a predetermined simulation. I want to make decisions taking consequences into consideration. I live as if facts exist and we all share the same realty regardless of differing beliefs. The universe seems a mix of order and chaos.
Great video Ty
Free will has nothing to do with physics. Physics say I can’t fly, float, or levitate without mechanical assistance while on Earth, free will says I can still try although I may unalive myself because physics exists.
The destination is always the same because creation happened was over instantly but the past to get there is the free will it's not about the destiny it's always about the journey.
Oddly enough, quantum computers, and their Q-bits being either 0, 1 either or both, is actually a working computer that "calculates" faster than digital computers. So is it really random, and can this randomness actually lead to exact calculations? I guess it can. No one may be able to truly understand quantum physics, but it can be used in precise ways. "Reality, what a concept." - Robin Williams
Every single choice we make is based on an emotion. Emotions are based on a chemical reaction. That’s why people all say “I feel…..”. Think about that.
Depending on the physics. There's a huge difference between the newtonian and the quantum physics.
Thank you 🙄🙂✔️
I believe we have a bit of wee frill, but no free will, unfortunately. 😐
I think we do have free will. God have us that. Hard\good question tho
Ok ya got me with the title but I’m happy to report it’s NOT click bait.❤
So. Many. Questions. Did an Ai intelligence write this film? Who curated the images? Where are the artist credits? This is an AMAZING video but it seems off. Must rewatch. I will have more questions
Free willl is fact. The ability of the human mind to manifest absolute alternate reality wholly new concepts and convince itself of its truth is free will on steroids. The mind has no limits and can reach across space/ time.and reality itself. The question is Does a thought truly exist if the beholder never shares it with the outside world. Is it lost as if it never happened or is the information therin part of the entirety of information which make up this reality.? Please post your testable proof as to the answere...
wrong
@@stephencraig9523 let me try to match your level of competency when it comes to counter arguing. I'm right! I win!! Buhahaha!
Thoughts arise.
I think it's either a little bit or all of it. everything you described here is happening.
Free will and prophecy do not go together. I have learned that if it weren't for the sins of others some of us may not be here
noone can stop the will of the allmighty, insted of gods mercy
gods creation is allrdy determinated....created...so our fre will, is to move in this creation
Derive a number at random in that many days drive thru the round about twice, have friend roll dice or flip coin to go around again yes no ? See what happens!
I will now rant about something that either makes total sense or is completely senseless. Im not saying this is right or wrong, just what I currently believe and am open to thinking differently about it too.
I think that some peoples views of what determinism and quantum mechanics are needs to change for it to make more sense. If you've never experienced very bad depression and suicidal thoughts, then it would be hard to predict what someone like that would do, even the person with suicidal thoughts would find it hard to understand what they want to do because they are in a very chaotic state of mind. Just because from an outside perspective we cannot understand what they would do, and even to the person experiencing it doesnt know, it doesnt mean that there isnt a process happening to determine it. Language and with it our personal perspective on the world and human concepts just end up clouding the way we think about things. Your conscious mind is bothered and clouded by thinking about these complex/arbitrary concepts such as suicidal thoughts, but the unconscious mind is breaking down these concepts into more fundamental and less chaotic concepts/reasons for you.
What does this mean? It means your unconscious mind is what is governing your conscious thoughts, and its not random. It breaks down these complex concepts into more simple terms (for example why do you pick up a phone? A phone is just a random arrangement of atoms but to your conscious mind you view it mainly as a phone and a device you can use to do any number of things through your view of reality. Your unconscious mind breaks down what a phone is into smaller and smaller concepts until eventually you probably reach a point of, I picked it up to feel better in that moment. It goes a bit beyond picking up the phone because you want to scroll instagram or talk to a friend) in an effort to make more sense of them so it can then determine the most optimal way of receiving "happiness"/"understanding"/"authenticity to the individual and their unique make up", but it can only do this based on previous experience and that individuals own world view and perspective on all the human concepts it knows. Depressing thoughts and suicide are extremely complex thoughts tho. In order for the conscious mind and unconscious mind to understand the reasoning's behind suicidal thoughts, the unconscious mind has to break this chaotic concept down so far that what it becomes left with is not a clear understanding of the concept. If the mind stays in this state for an extended period of time tho, it finds patterns in these broken down concepts in an effort to create reasons for understanding the chaotic thought of suicide. To observers when hearing those reasoning. It would just sound almost like nonsense. The number of hoops they had to jump through to justify that line of thinking. All the observer can do is make assumptions based on their own knowledge and experience to attempt to understand the chaotic experience and concept it has been told. If their brain has also went through something similar, it can recognize some of those patterns of broken down concepts already to make understanding it easier. It is however probably impossible to ever know the entirety of some someones experience, and so its probably impossible to fully determine someones actions.
You can compare this to photons of light an how they appear to be in-deterministic until the moment they are observed. Its the same as the mind is. A thought can not be observed from an outside perspective until the moment it has been acted out or said out loud. Consciousness and experience is the manifestation of the quantum world in the macro reality. Its allowing us to almost peer at what is going on with subatomic particles. You can think of a person as being in a super position of possible states and those possible states are determined by their experience and view of reality and also the stimulus that is it currently receiving. You can think of the entirety of humanity as in a quantum super position too. Its impossible to say where humanity will be in the far future because thinking that far ahead requires too many complex concepts to create a clear image of it. We can make fairly likely claims where we may be in a few years tho. Those claims however are ever changing based on how humanity behaves and does what it does as a whole. You can even think of an area of your desk as being in a quantum superposition. You can predictably claim that dust will accumulate on it in the same way you can predictably claim that humanity will live until next year. You cant predict the formation of accumulated dust or how long it will even take for you to even see it as something that's dusty, but it will accumulate the way it does because how much dust there is around and the flow of air or lack there of in the room over many days or hours and the way the each individual spec of dust (with their own unique formations like snowflakes) interact with the air around it. You can also think of this or any text as being in a quantum superposition. I myself wrote this with a certain intention and meaning, but everyone who reads it will view in through the lense they view the world in and get different intentions and meanings. The very text itself could have a seemly infinite number of possible interpretations. Its inherently chaotic. To a dog it has no meaning, to a person it ends up having the meaning it has due to their previous experience and perspective on the individual words and text as a whole.
If you could simulate everything in the entire universe you would be able to predict all of those actions. There is causal reasoning behind everything. Just because free will and consciousness may not exist in the traditional concept or understanding you or we have of it. Doesn't mean that everything has to be meaningless. If everything really is meaningless, then everything is also full of meaning too. Just remember that because someone does something rude or mean. Its not because they are a "bad" person. Its just because their circumstances in life have led them to have a particular world view in which behaving that way makes sense to them. I dont think I can hate someone like that instead of feeling bad for them and hoping they can get better or even try attempt to help them myself. You can be the person that changes the meaning that person sees in things, and they can then be that person for someone else in a cascading fractal effect, of which you are already apart of a seemingly near infinite amount of already.
I do not however agree with the criminal aspect of the video. You can say it was the universe that made them do that. But criminals also think in human concepts. Not in universal causes. Its the situation that humanity created for that criminal to experience life the way he did which caused him to turn into a criminal. Which was avoidable in retrospect, if we just understand that its us that created the criminal, and that we should want to change that going forward as a species. We basically of mocked and made fun of that by creating such a chaotic environment for them to try and make sense of until they became a criminal who we then locked up and punished. Doesn't really sound fair does it. Im not saying we shouldn't lock up criminals, only that we have to accept this is the society we created and that we should try our best to make a brighter world for the people around us rn and the people in the future, but also yourself. Search for what makes you happy and do it, just dont get too caught up in chaotic concepts. Just keep asking yourself why you do the things you do.
There is no such thing as free will , the most basic of all choices you don’t have control over. You should be able to choose what you like and dislike. But you don’t have that simple basic choice. You can’t choose
Well, thats all good & well, but how does this all connect up with the themes of Free Willy?
wow.....lot of depth .......in this video. amazing how our ,minds wander(aimlessly) about with so many theories//arguments about cause and affect , determinism, free will etc etc when we don't have God and his book (quram) in our lives. please please read Quran it will talk to you and give you your answers. please
I hate to be picky but quantum physics is not random. Some outcomes are more probable than others and therefore they are not random. Complete randomness is scientifically impossible.
However, I agree that the idea of free will is problematic mainly because language is problematic and the unknowable which is what Wittgenstein was trying to point out.
When it comes to philosophy the first lesson I learned was that philosophy is not about confusing yourself with circular arguments. It is about giving knowledge a perceptive where common ground is a possibility.
I think free will is best understood in its political sense. It is part of human right that is given to individuals.
Therefore, the important aspect of it is who owns it and not how a particular decision comes about anywhere along the spectrum of random and reasoned. Then we can extrapolated that to ourselves in which case their is no need to have the interference of problem of mind and body.
It is the right to choose in which case one can say it might not be free but it is still mine. We are allowing freedom of choice.
The idea of responsibility is not and should not be associated with free will. Responsibility is the consequence of a choice imposed on an individual by society or himself.
It is a judgment and dependent on who makes it and within what context.
Social responsibility is a manufactured notion as are all the other human laws created for the of sake co-existence.
You don't have to be "irresponsible" to make an "irresponsible" choice. It is a value judgment imposed not chosen.
There is no 'free will' in the material/deterministic world as we are all bound by something called 'Karma'. Thou in the ethereal/emotional world we have a Free Will to choose HOW we RESPOND to the 'impulses' and the 'reality' of the material world. We should be (through the proper use of the free will) the masters of our emotions. E-motion (energy in motion) should be controlled ... that is the free will.
A question that goes either way 👁️
I still get annoyed about AI voiced content. It is very convincing, but here and there the cadence is just wrong enough to know that a script is being read absent understanding.
At time 1:46 delivered as: "OK, for traditional descriptions of free will, we first see it as the ability to freely choose one of several possible alternatives to make decisions, the outcome of which cannot be known in advance'" instead of "OK, for traditional descriptions of free will, we first see it as the ability to freely choose one of several possible alternatives, to make decisions the outcome of which cannot be known in advance'". The pause should be after "alternatives" not after "make decisions".
Some people call it free will but it's just multiple options like an advanced pathway book
You could choose s certain flavor of ice cream but be misunderstood and then served a different flavor which you decide to go with so it wasn't your choice at all but not determinism
Free will or not - hmm...
I believe we have free will to the extent that we may chose from several different paths.
Each, results in the sane end, just a differing story, along the way.
Afterall - this is all just a computer sym.
Quantum mechanics dictates such.
No free will. Criminals get theirs because the just also act without free will. Not simulated. The start had some amount of energy that determined the space by sending the things instantly to their location. But in the space nothing stops so it’s weird. Probably in the larger it also does not stop but still it’s real but does not last. Can things stop probably not.
Its obvious the Sphinx statue was originally a lion and reworked with the human head . The head is too out of proportion . The British and other Europeans turned that complex in to a theme park essentially and probably ruined loads of ancient artifacts .Also the stone pots are another funny one the older granite pots have perfect symmetry and are precisely carved yet the newer ones are pottery or look ragged .
It's fascinating that structures the Romans built still stand, but the road they paved the years ago crumbles and needs replacement.
Adding a comment will always have a future comment outcome! Just thinking outside the vox and putting your perspective in the web or lige around you! Will always be acknowledged by somebody :).
Free will is simple you make the decision but outside factors influence the decisions you make. If you have ever been married you know what I mean 😮. I should make a video.
Free will is you decide what you will do. Don’t know what the other 99% of what you said has to do with it
If you mentioned about simulation theory then forget to study and make a video about new concept about simulation theory its called the
"The second law of infodynamics"
It's not a new concept to me. In fact, I thought I created this concept until I saw this video.
I believe at 100% of deterministic theory. There is no chance or probability.
If something's happen, it is because it was supposed to happen. If you win at a lottery with 50 millions possibility, we call it chance. but there is none. Why? Cause we cannot calculate in advanced the result in a restraint amount of time.
Everything that we don't understand, we call it chance or probability. But this is all a illusion. We have the illusion of freewill and it is fine to have that illusion.
We cannot apply deterministic theory to our lives and let the consequence happen cause we would become lazy. But even that last concept I just told comes into the equation of deterministic theory.
A butterfly will influence the weather cause everything comes into the equation. Everything is one.
Not sure
But if we had free will we could had choosed how things should happen in this life sinve no one will choose jaiĺ the world could had been of balanced if life was fair
This video leaves me with only one… well, question: What is it exactly that bothers you?
You might want to read a book by David Bohm or something.
After 3 minutes I'm board and already typing comments. Questioning why I am watching a long winded video attempting to sound esoteric, but instead superficial, full of meaningless deepness. Cut to the chase, the one question to ask, is consciousness or self a product of the brain or something external to the brain?
All who work in medical fields associated with the brain agree, according to "the science", consciousness or self is a product of the brain. Yet 50% of those same professionals say they personally believe there must be something more to consciousness, a spiritual level, that consciousness or self is external to the brain and body.
The physical universe as we experience it, is deterministic, free will does not truly exist if consciousness is merely a construct of the brain and environment; only if consciousness or self is external and exists before and after the body. {quantum brain theories on consciousness have no proven validity and discounted by most}
Read Robert Sapolsky's book determined & you will realize there is no such thing as freewill.