Activity 1.5: The Deep Dive Procedure 1. “From the buildings in which we live and work, to the cars we drive, or the knives and forks with which we eat, everything we use was designed to create some sort of marriage between form and function.” 2. The folks at IDEO state that they are not experts in any given area. But they do claim to be experts on the process of how you design stuff, which they apply to the innovation of consumer products. 3. After the team of designers is brought together, introduced to the problem and informed they have five days to “pull it off,” what phase of the design process do they immediately engage in? a. After the team of designers is brought together, introduced to the problem and informed they have five days to “pull it off,” they engage in the “investigate and research” stage of the design process. 4. Give two examples of what the team members did during this phase. a. One team member visits a store and talks to some employees where he learns that the shopping clocks have been clocked in at 35 miles per hour across the parking lots. b. Another team member visits a store and learns that most shoppers don’t like to let go of their carts while shopping. Only a few leave their carts at various places to go and retrieve their groceries. 5. List five rules-of-thumb that IDEO employees follow when they share ideas during the brainstorming phase: a. One conversation at a time. b. Stay focused on topic. c. Encourage wild ideas. d. Defer judgment. e. Build on the ideas of others.
6. Why should wild (and sometimes crazy) ideas be entertained during the brainstorming phase? a. Wild ideas should be entertained during the brainstorming phase because you can build off of those wild ideas and they will end up being better ideas which would not be possible if everyone said the same things. 7. After the brainstorming phase was over, the team narrowed down the hundreds of ideas by voting for those ideas that were not only “cool” but also buildable in a short period of time. Which phase of the design process includes brainstorming and narrowing ideas? a. The phase of design process that includes brainstorming and narrowing ideas is the “select an approach” phase. 8. IDEO believes that the ideas and efforts of a team will always be more successful than the planning of a lone genius. 9. Once the ideas were narrowed down and divided into categories, the group was split into four smaller teams. For which phase(s) of the design process was each of these groups responsible? a. Each of these groups was responsible for the “develop a design proposal,” “make a model or prototype,” and “test and evaluate the design using specifications” phases of the design process. 10. The leaders at IDEO believe that playful behavior and a fun environment are two important reasons why their employees are able to think quickly and creatively to produce innovative results. 11. Sometimes, people come up with great solutions that work by trying their ideas first and asking for forgiveness later. 12. Design is often a process of going too far and having to take a few steps back. What phase(s) of the design process would the critique of the four mock-ups come under? a. The critique of the four mock-ups comes under the “communicate processes and results” phase of the design process. 13. Upon critique of the four teams’ models, it was obvious that none of the teams had developed an optimum solution. However, the people at IDEO believe that it is important to fail often in order succeed sooner. 14. What percentage of the entire week’s time did it take to fabricate the final prototype? a. It took one day to fabricate the final prototype which is 20% of the entire week’s time. 15. Instead of showering his design team with a tremendous amount of praise, what did the boss require his employees to do with their new design? a. The boss required his employees to go to local supermarkets and see what they thought of their new design. 16. Of all the things that we are surrounded by every day, what has not been placed through the design process? a. Of all the things that we are surrounded by every day, nature is the only thing that has not been placed through the design process.
I'm here for Group Leadership and Dynamics, basically IDEO's idea of assiging job roles based on talent rather than seniority (who's highest on the corporate ladder).
Ha ha I am one of those engineering teachers that assigned it. But I retired five years ago. Nice video, but I am surprised they haven't found something else that's more up to date.
I might be echoing the sentiments of many others here, but as a technical person deeply immersed in R&D, I found that video to be incredibly inspirational and enjoyable. It encapsulates the key ingredients for success within an innovation-driven environment!
yeah, IMO the biggest problem is the lack of the main basket. What happens when you buy items that aren't bagged (like milk), or you get items that are big (like a night stand or something). Also, the children would be unsafe according to most safety precautions, as they could easily lift the handle then fall out, nothing is locking them in.
@@salty_slug The problem is when it comes to storing these cart. Because the usual carts go into each others, but these carts cannot and they take a lot of space.
Well, I wasn't impressed with the shopping cart. Neither were most stores apparently. So, for those of you taking courses, it's time to learn an important side of design: taking and giving criticism. Let's do a list of everything wrong to make our point! So first off, all four wheels turn. It's a neat idea, but I'd have to see it in use first. While this allows sideways movement, it also makes reorienting the cart harder since you can't provide leverage on fixed wheels. Again, interesting idea, but being unable to slide is a lesser issue than being unable to turn. Also the added complexity reduces long-term durability. We already know how carts with only two turning wheels suffer as they age. Next problem, the bottom storage is practically removed. Larger objects like dog food, boxes, toilet paper, and generally anything that can't fit into a full basket go there, however this shopping cart uses a "W" design which is not only weaker than the standard design, but less able to hold a variety of objects. Bagged or smaller objects would be left precariously perched on a bar that's improperly anchored. Actually, this goes nicely into the next problem: No large basket. First off, hooks are stupid. No one likes carrying the bags alone, and making it needlessly complicated for the bagger and customer simply to "defeat tyranny" is ridiculous. It’s art for the sake of art weakening a device with utilitarian origins. It also puts a lot stress on a small portion of the bags handles, and once again restricts what can be purchased. Do you want to buy milk? Well, you have to bag it, and no you can't use paper for that, and you better hope those bags are stronger than the current affair, because everyone knows those just NEVER break. Also, you could throw in the environmental impact of those plastic bags, although this was from the 90s, so they get a pass. Well, it reduces cart theft you say! Nope! If a person needs a cart, they're still taking it. Don't get me wrong, it's a beautiful selling point to say that even a homeless person (as an example) desperately looking for something to carry their possessions in wouldn't choose your crappy cart over the current standard, but in all truth they'll still use yours because at the end of the day they can use the hooks or baskets to carry their necessities until they find someplace with a decent cart. Also, kids will still find a way to make it into a go-cart. Well, you say, if you’re worried about baskets, why not use the smaller ones!?! Well, that's great, except you're once again left with a smaller holding area (limiting your max product size and what you can purchase with one cart as opposed to a single large basket that can hold a bag of dog food as easily as it can a bottle of coffee creamer, while still allowing for stacking), and you've added something else to steal! Because baskets are easy to fit in a car! Hence why you're not usually supposed to take them outside! Also, who else thinks it is a fantastic idea to leave your main cart behind, possibly with your kid or purse in the back, all the while lugging around a basket you didn't want in the first place because you chose to GET A CART. Also, if I’m just making a short jaunt away from the cart to pick out a few small goods, why would I need to carry the smaller basket that may already have items in it? I can just get the item and come back. Also, just a nitpick, one of the baskets appears to slide a little too far back. I get that it's likely to make up for the reduced carrying capacity, but it just makes it harder to unload your goods after. Alright, let's talk about those handles. Well, for one thing the redesign has removed the convenient rear basket for purses, wallets, and coupons (which was never perfect, but at least had a flap to try and hold in your stuff) all so that some people could fit a kid in there. The bar over the kid's head is also great, because every parent knows how fun that’s going to be, holding the child against the back while fighting to get the bar down from above. It's also easier for them to push up and slide out of without the parent's notice, and there's a noticeable lack of the standard cart seat belt. The cup holder was a nice idea, but it's on the handle that flips up. Ooh, speaking of the flip up, I didn't see any locking mechanism on the handle, so again large loads are at a disadvantage. I get the distinct image of people trying to push the cart, only to have that handle flip up constantly (I've used compacting Dollys with a similar design that did just that). It also has the problem of feeling too low (something to avoid for older customers) while also feeling top heavy. The wheels are all on the same plane front-back, making it feel inherently unstable, and again bad at turning. Ooh, almost forgot that scanner! Interesting idea, but all it can do is provide a single price scan for estimation, something that in-store price checkers, and also the clever invention of "Labels with numbers on them" have removed the need for. If it tries to tally everything, it will undoubtedly be left with errors as people mis-scan or forget, and while it may help with some estimations, in the end it just slows down the shopping experience, and raises the price of the cart from the simple metal frame. It also needs to be constantly updated to changing store prices, and maintained. It can't be used as an official scanner since people won't scan everything (theft is always an issue) and no one wants to lug around the weight of a measuring system like the current personal checkouts. Oh, and speaking of stealing, that thing is ridiculously easy to steal. I mean, I don't know how else to say it, it's just perfectly pocket sized. You could chain it, but that reduces the freedom of movement and is still easily cut. You could place it in the handle as was originally proposed, but then maintenance becomes even harder. Last thing to think about, it’s harder to store. Yes, they still could (with a slight redesign) slide into each-other like regular carts, but then you have to have another stack alongside with a far greater number baskets, with the 5 per cart shown here making the number of additional baskets absurd. If you try to go to a lower end of the curve, like 3 per cart, busy days and holidays will leave dozens of carts unusable because those hooks do jack if you don't have bags, which are part of checkout. Honestly, this feels like the 90s edition of Solar Roadways. Everybody thinks it’s cool until you realize that it’s cheaper, longer lasting, more durable, safer, and produces more energy to just build regular angled panels along the side of normal asphalt roads with (maybe) glowing reactive paint. Listen, I get that this was a 5 day challenge in the 90s, and the video was focused on teaching new workplace principles rather than good design, but this was….ugh. Let’s just say the cart was very distracting for me. And yes, I know, most of my complaints could be argued. My arguments don't account for all the factors since I just whipped this up after a first viewing, and I am by no means a professional cart maker (or professional anything), and even then some stores focused on selling smaller quantities of items (like Whole Paycheck) wouldn’t run into these issues, but the reason we have the carts we do is because it is the easiest design that fills the greatest number of requirements. When working to design something for large-scale general use, like a shopping cart, you can’t sacrifice certain generalized features (such as a large basket) for specialized features (such as modularity) that at best add situational benefit. You have to design it for the 90 year old grandmother as much as you do for the 20 year old college student, or the 1 year old passenger. A lot of the ideas are interesting, and could maybe be implemented in another way, but the cart itself- as it stands now- is not salvageable. Sorry if that comes across as a little overly critical.
+TheFirstObserver Some ideas are or were reality here in the netherlands. The thing that all four wheels turn is used on every shopping cart here and it works great for me. I can also remember we used to have the scanner. It was used exactly as they showed it in the video. You just scanned the product and when you left you payed with a computer system. There was a guy at the end that randomly checked if people didn't steal anything. You also couldn't steal the scanner because of the guy watching at the check out. I can see why they removed it though. But I agree. There must be a reason why every shopping cart doesn't look like this already right?
+freddie4321 It looks like the principal on building that cart would be more than for most carts. I don't buy the idea that it won't get stolen, people will steal cart just to ride them. It holds less volume. The bag hooks on there are going somewhat obsolete as grocery stores these days typically make you pay for bags or in some cases have even banned plastic bags.
Hey Comment Scavengers, to everyone watching this for homework or classwork, I recommend changing the Speed setting to 1.25 or 1.5, just to get done faster because this is a looong video. Other than that it's a good vid, would watch again, I rate 8/8 pretty great.
For everyone saying it is old and out of date. The Engineering Design Process is still valid. Even the Amazon checklist ordered online was developed using Brainstorming, Prototyping, testing, teamwork, etc. The bones of the program are still relevant, if not the round glasses and mustache.
Uhhh...they legit predicted the Amazon store's process of purchasing groceries. Also, that cart looks awesome, however I feel that the bag holders would be destroyed from bumping and other sources of wear and tear.
if you are here for a work sheet go on GOOGLE and type in INTRIDUCTION TO ENGINEERING DESIGN ACTIVITY 1.5 THE DEEP DIVE._______________________________YOUR WELCOME.
Man I'd like to gather up a team kinda like this, and work. I mean what better environment and position can you have than this? Wow. Love IDEO guys. Respect.
Thank you for sharing!! Yup! also here because of a homework assignment for entrepreneurs St. Louis - Washington University Skandalaris Center/Mission Center L3C I love this cart!! The scanners are used at Stop and Shop stores (Massachusetts). I don't like that child seat thing (since I don't have children, if I had to babysit, the kid would slide right on out of it..what about a baby carriage...they didn't have anything for that. *They need more women and minorities in the think tank/design groups at Ideo!! (at least back when they created this)
You're all welcome. I spent more time reading the comments than watching the video. In IDEO, how are project leaders chosen? > The project leader is chosen because he or she is good with groups What does it mean if you have a big red ball on a post? > You are a big guy What does one do with wild ideas? > Build off the wild ideas What is the purpose of the first time client meeting? > Train the client so they can understand how the process works and what they can expect What should you do in order to succeed sooner? > Fail often You're all welcome. I spent more time reading the comments than watching the video.
Can someone give me the answers to these questions and I'll love you forever 1. What was the problem that the design team was trying to solve? 2. To what degree was the solution to be realized? Was the design team's intention to merely sketch an idea and be done? Was the intention to come up with an idea, build it, and stop there? Or, was it it the design team's intention to design, build, and test an idea? What expectation(s) did the design have to meet before it would be considered a successful solution to the problem? In other words, what did the solution have to do? 3. What criteria did the solution have to meet? What limitations did the design team have to work with? Was there time constraint to get the project finished?
No here for any test or something, just out of interest. Glad I did, this was super interesting! Thanks to people like these that make all our lives easier :)
My favorite teacher left the school the first year i had him. He was such a good teacher i miss him now I won’t have him again when I eventually apply for our engineering track :’)
I've always wanted to get into Engineering, but I don't have the money to go to University. What kind of assignments are given based on this video? I've experienced an example of the deep dive at a manufacturing conference.
As a MBA student, I am here because my Entrepreneurship and Venture planning professor asked to watch this and make a report on design thinking in class tomorrow.
Fun shopping cart design but haven't seen it anywhere. I'm thinking the new cart is still of value to thieves or homeless since they carry their loot or wordly possesions in bags. The creative process or lack thereof was the most fun part of the video. Maybe the cart needs to be something that is not a cart? Hmmmmm, I think I need to go and patent a new idea:).
This video would have nowhere NEAR the amount of views it has if it weren't assigned by so many teachers as mandatory viewing.
That's a FACT.
lol
Here for classwork after a National Test lol
Am teacher. Can confirm.
Lol
Activity 1.5: The Deep Dive
Procedure
1. “From the buildings in which we live and work, to the cars we drive, or the knives and forks with which we eat, everything we use was designed to create some sort of marriage between form and function.”
2. The folks at IDEO state that they are not experts in any given area. But they do claim to be experts on the process of how you design stuff, which they apply to the innovation of consumer products.
3. After the team of designers is brought together, introduced to the problem and informed they have five days to “pull it off,” what phase of the design process do they immediately engage in?
a. After the team of designers is brought together, introduced to the problem and informed they have five days to “pull it off,” they engage in the “investigate and research” stage of the design process.
4. Give two examples of what the team members did during this phase.
a. One team member visits a store and talks to some employees where he learns that the shopping clocks have been clocked in at 35 miles per hour across the parking lots.
b. Another team member visits a store and learns that most shoppers don’t like to let go of their carts while shopping. Only a few leave their carts at various places to go and retrieve their groceries.
5. List five rules-of-thumb that IDEO employees follow when they share ideas during the brainstorming phase:
a. One conversation at a time.
b. Stay focused on topic.
c. Encourage wild ideas.
d. Defer judgment.
e. Build on the ideas of others.
6. Why should wild (and sometimes crazy) ideas be entertained during the brainstorming phase?
a. Wild ideas should be entertained during the brainstorming phase because you can build off of those wild ideas and they will end up being better ideas which would not be possible if everyone said the same things.
7. After the brainstorming phase was over, the team narrowed down the hundreds of ideas by voting for those ideas that were not only “cool” but also buildable in a short period of time. Which phase of the design process includes brainstorming and narrowing ideas?
a. The phase of design process that includes brainstorming and narrowing ideas is the “select an approach” phase.
8. IDEO believes that the ideas and efforts of a team will always be more successful than the planning of a lone genius.
9. Once the ideas were narrowed down and divided into categories, the group was split into four smaller teams. For which phase(s) of the design process was each of these groups responsible?
a. Each of these groups was responsible for the “develop a design proposal,” “make a model or prototype,” and “test and evaluate the design using specifications” phases of the design process.
10. The leaders at IDEO believe that playful behavior and a fun environment are two important reasons why their employees are able to think quickly and creatively to produce innovative results.
11. Sometimes, people come up with great solutions that work by trying their ideas first and asking for forgiveness later.
12. Design is often a process of going too far and having to take a few steps back. What phase(s) of the design process would the critique of the four mock-ups come under?
a. The critique of the four mock-ups comes under the “communicate processes and results” phase of the design process.
13. Upon critique of the four teams’ models, it was obvious that none of the teams had developed an optimum solution. However, the people at IDEO believe that it is important to fail often in order succeed sooner.
14. What percentage of the entire week’s time did it take to fabricate the final prototype?
a. It took one day to fabricate the final prototype which is 20% of the entire week’s time.
15. Instead of showering his design team with a tremendous amount of praise, what did the boss require his employees to do with their new design?
a. The boss required his employees to go to local supermarkets and see what they thought of their new design.
16. Of all the things that we are surrounded by every day, what has not been placed through the design process?
a. Of all the things that we are surrounded by every day, nature is the only thing that has not been placed through the design process.
Thx bro
thanks !!
What a chad thanks bro
omg this needs more likes
I could kiss you right now.
Hmmm... now how many of these views are from engineering students? :D
me
99.99% of them.
I'm here for Group Leadership and Dynamics, basically IDEO's idea of assiging job roles based on talent rather than seniority (who's highest on the corporate ladder).
this guy
me
lol only here for homework smh
So I am I lol
sameeee #OB
Antonio Cleveland same
Same man... we are probably all doing the same types of assignments.
arn't we all
I thought my class was the only one that was watching this for homework. Dang.
Project lead the way man, it's everywhere.
facts
Meeee too
No no.. they still got us doin this lmfao
@@WillemLawyer woah… six years later and it still is homework
This video is officially over 10 years old. Still being assigned by teachers.
the documentary itself is from 1999, it is older than me and yet ??????
Gotta love engineering homework
+Emerson [Nova] engineering? what school you go to?
foh
Real dude
My freshmen year ddp hw smh
Looks like a lot of kids got assigned this, not even in an engineering class and got assigned it
I'm doing year 12 business and enterprise
Anyone else here from PLTW engineering class
Me
me
me 7th grade
Me!
KingSauce
Here for homework.
+tailsofUSSR21 Aren't we all?
+Shivashriganesh Mahato Yeah, I'm fully sure we are.
Teachers, giving us lessons via RUclips...
(grumbles off in a corner)
hahaha same
ChaliblueTails same fml ughhh
ChaliblueTails Same
Only here for Homework,Any one else?...
this mans looks like dash's teacher from The Incredibles
i said that in class (my teacher didn't find it funny)
EXACTLYYYY
If you're working on the fill in the blank questions look up 1.5 deep dive answers. 👌
lmao i just fineshed that then i read this comment.
tnks
Noodle Lover thanks 🙏🏼
THANK YOU!! :D you save me from a 0
I feel like the resurrection of Jesus. Everyone. Your welcome.
Freshmen engineering and design brought me here and it looks like I'm not alone.
same
yep
It’s basically a tradition at this point XD
Ha ha I am one of those engineering teachers that assigned it. But I retired five years ago. Nice video, but I am surprised they haven't found something else that's more up to date.
I honestly haven't seen anything like this, even the new open minded techie culture is focused on computers or software only.
@@lukemcpartlan9213 No you can, you just have to wait for the right person to come around and do it.
MIT Class brought me here.
I might be echoing the sentiments of many others here, but as a technical person deeply immersed in R&D, I found that video to be incredibly inspirational and enjoyable. It encapsulates the key ingredients for success within an innovation-driven environment!
Engineering class brought me here but this is actually quite entertaining.... just the homework isn't!
The homework is real
Surely I'm the only one watching this as required material for engineering.
*reads comments*
Oh wait
I'm watching it for digital media...
and I dont see any kind of cart that looks like that in 2019
Big sad
yeah, IMO the biggest problem is the lack of the main basket. What happens when you buy items that aren't bagged (like milk), or you get items that are big (like a night stand or something). Also, the children would be unsafe according to most safety precautions, as they could easily lift the handle then fall out, nothing is locking them in.
@@salty_slug The problem is when it comes to storing these cart. Because the usual carts go into each others, but these carts cannot and they take a lot of space.
Well not exactly, I remember some modern cart with a removable basket!
well 2021 sucks
thanks for keeping this public and allowing more design students to view it
Well, I wasn't impressed with the shopping cart. Neither were most stores apparently. So, for those of you taking courses, it's time to learn an important side of design: taking and giving criticism. Let's do a list of everything wrong to make our point!
So first off, all four wheels turn. It's a neat idea, but I'd have to see it in use first. While this allows sideways movement, it also makes reorienting the cart harder since you can't provide leverage on fixed wheels. Again, interesting idea, but being unable to slide is a lesser issue than being unable to turn. Also the added complexity reduces long-term durability. We already know how carts with only two turning wheels suffer as they age.
Next problem, the bottom storage is practically removed. Larger objects like dog food, boxes, toilet paper, and generally anything that can't fit into a full basket go there, however this shopping cart uses a "W" design which is not only weaker than the standard design, but less able to hold a variety of objects. Bagged or smaller objects would be left precariously perched on a bar that's improperly anchored. Actually, this goes nicely into the next problem: No large basket.
First off, hooks are stupid. No one likes carrying the bags alone, and making it needlessly complicated for the bagger and customer simply to "defeat tyranny" is ridiculous. It’s art for the sake of art weakening a device with utilitarian origins. It also puts a lot stress on a small portion of the bags handles, and once again restricts what can be purchased. Do you want to buy milk? Well, you have to bag it, and no you can't use paper for that, and you better hope those bags are stronger than the current affair, because everyone knows those just NEVER break. Also, you could throw in the environmental impact of those plastic bags, although this was from the 90s, so they get a pass.
Well, it reduces cart theft you say! Nope! If a person needs a cart, they're still taking it. Don't get me wrong, it's a beautiful selling point to say that even a homeless person (as an example) desperately looking for something to carry their possessions in wouldn't choose your crappy cart over the current standard, but in all truth they'll still use yours because at the end of the day they can use the hooks or baskets to carry their necessities until they find someplace with a decent cart. Also, kids will still find a way to make it into a go-cart.
Well, you say, if you’re worried about baskets, why not use the smaller ones!?! Well, that's great, except you're once again left with a smaller holding area (limiting your max product size and what you can purchase with one cart as opposed to a single large basket that can hold a bag of dog food as easily as it can a bottle of coffee creamer, while still allowing for stacking), and you've added something else to steal! Because baskets are easy to fit in a car! Hence why you're not usually supposed to take them outside!
Also, who else thinks it is a fantastic idea to leave your main cart behind, possibly with your kid or purse in the back, all the while lugging around a basket you didn't want in the first place because you chose to GET A CART. Also, if I’m just making a short jaunt away from the cart to pick out a few small goods, why would I need to carry the smaller basket that may already have items in it? I can just get the item and come back.
Also, just a nitpick, one of the baskets appears to slide a little too far back. I get that it's likely to make up for the reduced carrying capacity, but it just makes it harder to unload your goods after.
Alright, let's talk about those handles. Well, for one thing the redesign has removed the convenient rear basket for purses, wallets, and coupons (which was never perfect, but at least had a flap to try and hold in your stuff) all so that some people could fit a kid in there. The bar over the kid's head is also great, because every parent knows how fun that’s going to be, holding the child against the back while fighting to get the bar down from above. It's also easier for them to push up and slide out of without the parent's notice, and there's a noticeable lack of the standard cart seat belt.
The cup holder was a nice idea, but it's on the handle that flips up. Ooh, speaking of the flip up, I didn't see any locking mechanism on the handle, so again large loads are at a disadvantage. I get the distinct image of people trying to push the cart, only to have that handle flip up constantly (I've used compacting Dollys with a similar design that did just that).
It also has the problem of feeling too low (something to avoid for older customers) while also feeling top heavy. The wheels are all on the same plane front-back, making it feel inherently unstable, and again bad at turning.
Ooh, almost forgot that scanner! Interesting idea, but all it can do is provide a single price scan for estimation, something that in-store price checkers, and also the clever invention of "Labels with numbers on them" have removed the need for. If it tries to tally everything, it will undoubtedly be left with errors as people mis-scan or forget, and while it may help with some estimations, in the end it just slows down the shopping experience, and raises the price of the cart from the simple metal frame. It also needs to be constantly updated to changing store prices, and maintained. It can't be used as an official scanner since people won't scan everything (theft is always an issue) and no one wants to lug around the weight of a measuring system like the current personal checkouts.
Oh, and speaking of stealing, that thing is ridiculously easy to steal. I mean, I don't know how else to say it, it's just perfectly pocket sized. You could chain it, but that reduces the freedom of movement and is still easily cut. You could place it in the handle as was originally proposed, but then maintenance becomes even harder.
Last thing to think about, it’s harder to store. Yes, they still could (with a slight redesign) slide into each-other like regular carts, but then you have to have another stack alongside with a far greater number baskets, with the 5 per cart shown here making the number of additional baskets absurd. If you try to go to a lower end of the curve, like 3 per cart, busy days and holidays will leave dozens of carts unusable because those hooks do jack if you don't have bags, which are part of checkout.
Honestly, this feels like the 90s edition of Solar Roadways. Everybody thinks it’s cool until you realize that it’s cheaper, longer lasting, more durable, safer, and produces more energy to just build regular angled panels along the side of normal asphalt roads with (maybe) glowing reactive paint.
Listen, I get that this was a 5 day challenge in the 90s, and the video was focused on teaching new workplace principles rather than good design, but this was….ugh. Let’s just say the cart was very distracting for me. And yes, I know, most of my complaints could be argued. My arguments don't account for all the factors since I just whipped this up after a first viewing, and I am by no means a professional cart maker (or professional anything), and even then some stores focused on selling smaller quantities of items (like Whole Paycheck) wouldn’t run into these issues, but the reason we have the carts we do is because it is the easiest design that fills the greatest number of requirements. When working to design something for large-scale general use, like a shopping cart, you can’t sacrifice certain generalized features (such as a large basket) for specialized features (such as modularity) that at best add situational benefit. You have to design it for the 90 year old grandmother as much as you do for the 20 year old college student, or the 1 year old passenger. A lot of the ideas are interesting, and could maybe be implemented in another way, but the cart itself- as it stands now- is not salvageable.
Sorry if that comes across as a little overly critical.
I really didn't like that cart. :P
+TheFirstObserver Some ideas are or were reality here in the netherlands. The thing that all four wheels turn is used on every shopping cart here and it works great for me. I can also remember we used to have the scanner. It was used exactly as they showed it in the video. You just scanned the product and when you left you payed with a computer system. There was a guy at the end that randomly checked if people didn't steal anything. You also couldn't steal the scanner because of the guy watching at the check out. I can see why they removed it though.
But I agree. There must be a reason why every shopping cart doesn't look like this already right?
+freddie4321 It looks like the principal on building that cart would be more than for most carts. I don't buy the idea that it won't get stolen, people will steal cart just to ride them. It holds less volume. The bag hooks on there are going somewhat obsolete as grocery stores these days typically make you pay for bags or in some cases have even banned plastic bags.
+TheFirstObserver nah
Oh man, I remember this! I really hated that shopping cart....
Still do! XD
Hey Comment Scavengers, to everyone watching this for homework or classwork, I recommend changing the Speed setting to 1.25 or 1.5, just to get done faster because this is a looong video. Other than that it's a good vid, would watch again, I rate 8/8 pretty great.
bruh, this was made 11 years ago, why tf am I watching this for an assignment, the highest quality is is 480p, lmaoo probably shot on a blackberry
I'm assuming all these views are students who are in engineering class BC SAME SMH triggered as HEK 😤😤😤💯👏🏿
I'm here for the homework. lol
Educational RUclips video viewed only by students trying to complete homework:
Category : *Comedy*
Bruh moment
Gotta love how teachers make you watch 8-year-old videos.
over 10 now. time flies doesnt it
Technically it's 22 years old.
For everyone saying it is old and out of date. The Engineering Design Process is still valid. Even the Amazon checklist ordered online was developed using Brainstorming, Prototyping, testing, teamwork, etc. The bones of the program are still relevant, if not the round glasses and mustache.
Hello fellow engineers
Greetings engineer!
Lol Just Here from DDP Class, Thanks Mr Wanliss ✌︎✌︎✌︎
Faux Alot ayyyy
Do you go to BTHS
Vixin Victory, Yes I do 🙃
Cool, I got Mr Bigsby
@@vixinvictory9629 I got Mr. Coyle
Uhhh...they legit predicted the Amazon store's process of purchasing groceries. Also, that cart looks awesome, however I feel that the bag holders would be destroyed from bumping and other sources of wear and tear.
This is actually interesting engineering hw
Oops looks like this is a homework video lol
Just in case the original gets deleated
Activity 1.5: The Deep Dive answers:
I fucking love you for this
Bro respect
10:38 The teachers gonna casually act like they didn't see this part before assigning this video to thousands of students
And some in middle school
Who here is from Michigan State?
Purdue representing!
Boiler UP
Nope I'm from Texas
Utah here!
I'm just from a high school in michigan
The grind don’t stop my dudes✌️
Here for engineering class hw...
me too but I'm in 7th
Sameee
Who isn't?
Design and Production Class anyone?
This guy looks exactly like the guy from the incredibles. .
if you are here for a work sheet go on GOOGLE and type in INTRIDUCTION TO ENGINEERING DESIGN ACTIVITY 1.5 THE DEEP DIVE._______________________________YOUR WELCOME.
You are a life saver
i got this assigned in DDP at Brooklyn tech
same
@@kristyflow1644 lmao nice I guess?
Man I'd like to gather up a team kinda like this, and work. I mean what better environment and position can you have than this? Wow. Love IDEO guys. Respect.
i got beef with my engineering teacher for making me watch this
Thank you for sharing!! Yup! also here because of a homework assignment for entrepreneurs
St. Louis - Washington University Skandalaris Center/Mission Center L3C
I love this cart!! The scanners are used at Stop and Shop stores (Massachusetts). I don't like that child seat thing (since I don't have children, if I had to babysit, the kid would slide right on out of it..what about a baby carriage...they didn't have anything for that.
*They need more women and minorities in the think tank/design groups at Ideo!! (at least back when they created this)
You're all welcome. I spent more time reading the comments than watching the video.
In IDEO, how are project leaders chosen?
> The project leader is chosen because he or she is good with groups
What does it mean if you have a big red ball on a post?
> You are a big guy
What does one do with wild ideas?
> Build off the wild ideas
What is the purpose of the first time client meeting?
> Train the client so they can understand how the process works and what they can expect
What should you do in order to succeed sooner?
> Fail often
You're all welcome. I spent more time reading the comments than watching the video.
Thanks
Can someone give me the answers to these questions and I'll love you forever
1. What was the problem that the design team was trying to solve?
2. To what degree was the solution to be realized? Was the design team's intention to merely sketch an idea and be done? Was the intention to come up with an idea, build it, and stop there? Or, was it it the design team's intention to design, build, and test an idea? What expectation(s) did the design have to meet before it would be considered a successful solution to the problem? In other words, what did the solution have to do?
3. What criteria did the solution have to meet? What limitations did the design team have to work with? Was there time constraint to get the project finished?
Here for the engineering homework smh
No here for any test or something, just out of interest. Glad I did, this was super interesting! Thanks to people like these that make all our lives easier :)
working on that engineering homework
Brooklyn tech gang
ayyyyyy
Imagine a tall person trying to shop with this cart. No more feet for them
i just got this as an assignment even though we watched this same video in class last year lmao
Homework Time! XD
My favorite teacher left the school the first year i had him. He was such a good teacher i miss him now I won’t have him again when I eventually apply for our engineering track :’)
I ask myself what am i doing here
I wish I was not in Engineering Class
I've always wanted to get into Engineering, but I don't have the money to go to University. What kind of assignments are given based on this video?
I've experienced an example of the deep dive at a manufacturing conference.
This was assigned to us in high school… For us, it was supposed to be an example of the engineering process at work.
I have to watch this for my fucking biology homework,
BIOLOGY!
Can anyone explain what the company does for each step of the design process
As a MBA student, I am here because my Entrepreneurship and Venture planning professor asked to watch this and make a report on design thinking in class tomorrow.
Has anyone ever seen a store that uses shopping carts like this?
sigh wtf mr tarrac my head hurts i can’t do this 9 years ago i was only 6 pls pls i cant do this anymore
homework tingz 😌😌🙈🙈🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
I am glad that my professor recommended us to watch this. This is inspiring
I cant be the only one that is watching this for school. 😭😭
Awesome video, the fundamentals never change.
Mr. Gajan, I sat through all 22 minutes just for you.
These comments are distracting me from my homework, hey look a shiny penny.
Who is from cs374 of KAIST?
Hi
He is the teacher from the Incredibles that caught the kid on camera going fast hahahaha
I always wondered how the modern cart was made... You see these everywhere!
German economics student here. Apparantly we are not the only ones who have to watch this cause our profs assinend assigned us this
only here for the goddamn hw smh
Fun shopping cart design but haven't seen it anywhere. I'm thinking the new cart is still of value to thieves or homeless since they carry their loot or wordly possesions in bags. The creative process or lack thereof was the most fun part of the video. Maybe the cart needs to be something that is not a cart? Hmmmmm, I think I need to go and patent a new idea:).
Yo who got the answers ?
Excellent video for my small group's class. Thank you for uploading.
Someone post a summary so we dont actually have to watch this ty
This video: *exists*
Everyone: AnYoNe FrOm PlTw?
anyone doing homework in 2019 XD
Yes.
It's one of my marketing assignments. I think it is a industrial design studio. My major is industrial design.
Great idea
Any computer science students here?
Well it took 20 more years for the self scanning thing to really pop off
No kidding. I have to right a 1-page response to this by tomorrow.
So, what you guys get for number 4?
here for group communication homework
Mr. Tarrac's class, what is up my fellow funky classmates
sigh,,,big daddy’s class is something else
@@gut__water9643 yea
'Just drop your children in here....' wait WHAT
18:16
I want this shopping cart personally.
Anybody here for homework in 2020
How many Engineering students are watching this?
Tens of thousands.
All these engineering students forced to watch this meanwhile I'm a fucking Art student and I've still gotta watch it!
A good prototype does not necessarily mean it is going to be adopted in the market worldwide...
Have to see it multiple times a year in multiple classes. So annoying.
It's really been 4+ years and they didnt change the assignment........
Homework. That's all I have to say
Got assigned to watching this video for a Business Innovation lecture smh