BEE GEES - How Can You Mend A Broken Heart LIVE @ Melbourne 1974 12/16
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 дек 2013
- "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart" is a song released by the Bee Gees in 1971. It was written by Barry and Robin Gibb and was the first single on the group's 1971 album Trafalgar. It was their first US No. 1 single and also reached No. 1 in Cashbox magazine for two weeks.
Barry and Robin Gibb wrote the song in August 1970 with "Lonely Days" when the Gibb brothers had reconvened following a period of break-up and alienation. "Robin came to my place," says Barry, "and that afternoon we wrote 'How Can You Mend a Broken Heart' and that obviously was a link to us coming back together. We called Maurice, finished the song, went to the studio and once again, with only 'Broken Heart' as a basic structure, we went in to the studio with that and an idea for 'Lonely Days', and those two songs were recorded that night". They originally offered the song to Andy Williams, but ended up recording it themselves, although Williams did later cover the song on his album You've Got a Friend. Barry also explains, "We might imitate a certain group, later on, the group will pick up on the song and say that suits us." Maurice Gibb possibly had a hand in the writing of "How Can You Mend A Broken Heart" although the song is officially credited to Barry and Robin Gibb. The 2009 release Ultimate Bee Gees officially credited Maurice for the first time as co-writer of the song, for both the "Ultimate" CD and DVD, and it was credited to the moniker Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb.
The song was recorded on 28 January 1971 in London, the same day as "We Lost the Road", "When Do I", "If I Were the Sky", "Bring Out the Thoughts in Me" and "Ellan Vannin".
I can think of younger days when living for my life
Was everything a man could want to do
I could never see tomorrow, but I was never told about the sorrow
And how can you mend a broken heart?
How can you stop the rain from falling down?
How can you stop the sun from shining?
What makes the world go round?
How can you mend a this broken man?
How can a loser ever win?
Please help me mend my broken heart and let me live again
I can still feel the breeze that rustles through the trees
And misty memories of days gone by
We could never see tomorrow, no one said a word about the sorrow
And how can you mend a broken heart?
How can you stop the rain from falling down?
How can you stop the sun from shining?
What makes the world go round?
How can you mend this broken man?
How can a loser ever win?
Please help me mend my broken heart and let me live again
Songwriter: Barry Gibb / Robin Gibb
How Can You Mend a Broken Heart © Universal Music Publishing Group
#jivetubin #BeeGees #BarryGibb #TheBeeGees #RobinGibb #MauriceGibb #BrothersGibb #TheBrothersGibb 
Видеоклипы
Over 50 years of hearing this song, and it still give me tears. They were, and still are. the best of the best...
YES
2022 Still reduces me, too xoxox
Truly the best ❤️
Agreed!
Was die da noch für Frisuren hatten
Barry, Robin and Maurice forever and ever.
So True
Same here... Loved BEE GEES FOREVER
No computers just beautiful music
Eles maravihozo s amo
W
To this day, I still have goosebumps listening to them. No voices can be as pure as theirs. Thank you Bee Gees for sharing your amazing talent with all of us.
Beautiful performance!
Robin was always my favorite, I cried when he died
In their prime, no one came close to the emotional live performances of Robin and Barry. When they shared the lead vocals like this one, it was and is a classic (lyrics and vocalization).
Love the Bee Gees. I am 68 years young and still love them. ❤️
So do i.
@@suneethaiusa647 Ditto!
@@jeffreyfeinstein5525 Thanks for this. I can't imagine Al Green singing it but I'm going to hunt it down and keep an open mind! ETA: I listened to it and I thank you for the suggestion.
67 here. Me too. 🌞
@@same5952 I'm sorry this comes late - ah did not recieve any notifications.
Well, thanK yoU for acknowledging me, a stranger.
It kinda helps to listen to these but ah feel it can hurt as well.
And if this makes ANY sense, it seems the 'real time' past has been being erased without sensitivity to its actual feelng.
Lkely maby live longer going with the times.
Ah had admired and partcipated with other races besides 'my own'. But the closeness of those doors seem now distant yet hopefully some good eternal.
Found it by accident and danced with my mother, who was someehat liberal in the day that lberal had integrity. You know, nyc, lol.
((Even,ah wrote her a song from my heart one evening.
The Bee Gees did beautifully with this song on different levels! So tell me, how DO you mend a broken heart pls? lol
( ' ; *)^
Masterpiece
I am 66 my days of great love songs!!
Pure gold!
this is what song supposed to be,.. not only being classic,.. but ever lasting!!👍👍💝💝
A long time ago I sat in prison (11 1/2 ) years . Many many nights I sat on my bunk ,under my blanket and cried to this song. The sadness of the sound of the words and music would carry me into a deep depression. Somehow with this song and never giving up I survived. I have been out a long time now ...doing very well. No more days of depression and loneliness BUT I have never forgotten this tune. I still put my headphones on and listen.... because it reminds of time goneby . This song and the BeeGees will always have a place in my heart
The Bee Gees will always be known for their overbite and great songs.
how could anyone ,not love this song.
Easy. Don't be stupid. We all have different tastes. Get real.
I would love it more if Robin could have sung more than the opening lyrics solo. Why did Barry ALWAYS have to take over and drown the others out.
How could anyone not love them all?
Linda canção vezes perfeitas maravihoza
No other group has even come within a mile of The Bee Gees. God bless Barry, sole survivor of the four talented brothers ~ may he find peace and happiness through it all.
Dr Spaseebo....You must have never heard of the Beatles ...
Beatles don't even come close
Obviously everybody has their own taste in music. But to say The Beatles don't even come close it's ridiculous. How about The Beach Boys. Great harmonies Just like the Bee Gees.
@@innis52carra They certainly outlasted the Beatles!
@@shooter5028 Don't leave out the Stones, still rockin strong!
This pulls at your heart...so full of emotion
You got that right Jane, we all can relate to a broken heart at some point in our lives!
Robin had the greatest voice
Hey Jane how you doing today?
mems, of '71 nz seems were like brothers, my voice culture, mathes quite nicly, delicate, sensive, LOVING~LIKE A CHILD~
Beautiful
How can one band be so great, from the start of their career to the end? It blows my mind
My mind too. They were amazing.❤️
Great comment
Because they were just very, very talented?
You can't compare these guys to no other group, not only was they brothers they were so gifted and talented. Each was his own person together was pure bliss. I never get tired of hearing these guys. They are number one for me. Will continue listening to the bee gees till I leave this world.afa n.a.JJ.
私も聞き続けます。バリーが神様で全てが成り立ちました。バリーがなければ成り立たなかった。素晴らしい兄弟です！
I was in high school when this meditative love song came out and I still love it to this day.
The Bee Gees were hands down the best band for decades!
As a Senior in High School I was asked what my favorite group was. I replied The BeeGees! That was clear back in 1970-71! Still true today!
Robin' and Barry 'voices are just wonderful. I love this group!
So young and georgeous. 😍
Robin's vibrato is so unique. They each have their own riveting charm.
C est vrai
I love robbin
@@theking5620 .Yes ,he did . That cannot be denied . Perhaps he redeemed himself in time , I really don't know .
Robin's. Deep alto voice in Mondays Rain (1966) at age 16. Just phenomenal.... .he sounded like some vintage singer. ....
Yes, their voices were unique and a musical instrument of their own.
Robin is hauntingly beautiful and amazing at singing ❤
Nearly half a decade ago and they still bring back memories! Nothing like them today!
Did you mean half a century? Half a decade would be 2018 or 2019.
I get chills LISTENING to this masterpiece.
Moi aussi
Barry n Robin Blend beautifully with their own fantastic Sound!!💖
Donna puopolo que palavras lindas...amo os bee Gees
Barry's voice is penetrating. Amazing he was blessed with that beautiful voice.
The memory of this song in 1971 by the Bee Gees is a heartbreaker! Days gone by forever!
Such talent...!
I AGREE
There will never be another group like the Bee Gee’s.
Once in a lifetime, you'll get a group that stands out like noone else. They are the BeeGees.
I love this song so much,since my younger days,today i'm 65 ,getting older but my memories of the Bee Gees music is still in my very heart and soul..
I hear you.xxx
I always enjoyed listening to all their music. Am now 63 years old. I remember all the music they made since the 60's. They are all gifted. God bless Bary and his whole family.
With you, Felina!
One of the best groups ever. I'm 68yrs.old and the memories are still fresh like yesterday.
Al Green really does a beautiful job singing
How can you mend a broken heart
Amazing harmonies , voices like angels ♥️ phenomenal band with unrivalled longevity . Love them 💋
Bee Gees The Best forever 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Barry,Robin, maurice, luv u forever...
Probebly the best ' soul' song .ever . .
Luv u robin so much
too many broken hearts out there including mine and im 76 years old
Robin voice is so beautiful! Just can't get enough of him.R.I.P ROBIN
Always Remembered By His Very Unique Voice❤
So true Marlene
I love Robins voice.
Робин ангел
Não consigo para de ouvilis simplesmente maravihozos amo
ALWAYS IN MY HEART AND MY MIND !!
ALWAYS!!!♥♥♥
ใครไม่รักBee Gees
ลองฟังดูแล้วจะหลงใน
น้ำเสียง..ขอบอกเราฟังมาเกือบ60ปีแล้วค่ะ😴🌷🐝
Essa música é tudo pra mim.Principalmente cantada por ele.
Beautiful voice of Robin
Beautiful song, words are so true. Love you Robin & your music will never die. Bee Gees music can never be replaced. RIP Robin/ Mo/ Andy 2-15-19
WOW THIS IS AMAZING ROBIN SINGING WITH HIS WONDERFUL BROTHERS BARRY AND MAURICE
Hi Linda.beautiful how are you doing?
Los amó, es un deleite escucharlos , hasta el día de hoy Robin, Moo están cantando en el cielo, Barry Dios le bendiga y nos siga cantando amén
Perfect together. I love them.
Love them.
They exceptional that Robins voice truly unique
❤❤❤,bee gees forever 10,2018
Who the bloody hell cant like this?
Love you boys forever and ever!!!!!
Gosh, this sounds so good, so mellow. Great voices, great song, unforgettable.
Absolutely brilliant harmonising from these very naturally talented brothers wow very moving stuff .🕺😎👍
Amo demais
Amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo amo
So talented brothers!
Bee Gees Forever!
Cant stop watching Robin so good looking and that voice .one in a million times over
I agree with you!!!
ขอโทษค่ะตกภาษาEng
They were a good looking family ♥️💋
Yes they were!!! I just love them so much! Every song reminds me of the 70s daytona coco ect ...5 dollar gas in car hit the beach in our string bikinis! We were so lucky ! So screwed up now now with traffic and everything ...we used to park on the beach .And to think they were little further down in Miami, back then though I was into my ex ,so I wouldnt have drove back then .
I can't stop watching Robin either. My favorite Bee Gee, my favorite singer period. RIP dear Robin.
OMG what a power voice Barry.
Agree...in this song and others, he went from soft and sweet to strong and clear while holding notes.
One of my all-time favorite groups, and I'm 75
Imprecionante !!!! Esta csncion es mucho ❤❤❤❤ 🎉🎉eternos Bee Gees🤗🤗🌞🌍💎magicos 🎩🎩🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇🥇
How can u mend a broken heart 💔 when it's been broken in many pieces
Been a fan since I was 12 now I am 58 and still love there songs
Love this song .And Robin is in my heart forever.Love him💓💓💓💓
Every time I hear Robin sing I want to cry but it's happy tears he was so great.
"Please Help me mend my broken heart... and let me live again"... Now that's inspiration. 👍😉❤
If you let all the people in the world sing this song, you pick Robin out rite away.! My gosh….what a voice. !!!!!! Not even Frank Sinatra.
Essa música é linda demais.
Barry❤🌷aehhhh
No one will ever be like the Brothers Gibb.
Love the BeeGees forever , comfort of losing Andy!
PLEASE MEND MY BROKEN HEART..STILL SAD.🎸❤❤❤
1971 sticks in my heart for eternity--with this song
I feel sorry for you that didn't get to hear the Bee Gees in their early days. My my so much talent. RIP Maurice and Robin
They were all the very best.
The very very best of all time. Good clean music you can understand. God bless them all.
Even though I've been a fan for many years, the songs in this concert will always be how I remember the Bee Gees.
Fantástic!!!
I keep praying that this music will circle back...it just has to...
Top form for sure!
I remember them from a copy of the 1997 One Night Only concert that I watched when I was in grade school..now I'm binging on their videos here..
THESE WERE AND ALWAYS WILL HAVE A VERY SPECIAL PLACE IN MY HEART ! SO MANY BEAUTIFUL MEMORIES OF A VERY , VERY SPECIAL FRIEND . ❤ 💖 💕
Eravate uno dei gruppi preferì! Troppo bravi e simpatici e legati.....alla mia gioventù....vi ricordo sempre....
Sweet sweet U all.. Thank you for bringing us all these beautiful melody sounds of music!
Rest in Peace, Robin, Maurice and Andy...God loves u all.
Dear Barry, hang in there, you are so amazingly talented .. We enjoy Bee Gees..
How Can I mend a broken, make me tears! I lost my husband six years past now.. Only our own pains, we handle ourselves.. Till we all meet our loves ones in Heaven..
This is life, everyone will go through, it’s sad but have to moved on.... Till oneday will all meet again in Heaven!
Hugs♥️🙏
Still no answer on how to mend a broken heart.
Have listened to this song since the 1970's still love it.
What a very nice voice from the talented boys. Robin and his brothers have created most beautiful songs that makes 70s so memorable era in the life of my generation...
❤❤❤ saludos desde él salvador al señor Berri gibb y a todos los fans preciosas canción me encanta ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Such a heart wrenching song and sung so beautifully.
This is soooooo good
I just love this group of BGees I love this song too
Hi Sarah , How are you doing?
Awesome ,brings back so many memories i listened to this on the radio delivering news papers as a kid.
Robin's finest voice ever💚
Beautiful!
Lindos, perfeitos,vozes divinas, talentosos, cheios de estilo, marcaram uma geração ! Sempre serão sucesso! AMO BEE GEES. Obrigada.
I’ve heard them my whole life, I’m really just now appreciating the love and passion that’s such a beautiful part of their performance. Their love of music is in the hearing of it. 🥰
RIP Maurice and Robin. God bless Barry. 🙏 💜🙏
How do u compare this group to any other. There voices, their sound and harmonizing is extroidinary!!!!!. No group will even come close to them. Miss them. Wish they were all here together again. Loved them then love them now. BRAVO TO THE VERY BEST GROUP EVER. RIP all who r gone. I'm sad writing this. .😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💔💔💔💔
THE BEE GEES💖🕺👬🧑🤝🧑🌟🤩
Great!🎼🎵🎹🎸🥁🎤📀👍👏
From Hong Kong🙋♀️🌏💝🌺🥰
Barry Gibb is Mother Nature's Masterpiece!!!!
Perfection.xxxxx
Thank you Barry gibb sing that that music on my date brith
Only The Bee Gees could make an addition word like 'AND,' stand out and have incredible meaning.
Robin was awesome!
Que musica magnifica que te llenan el alma y me recuerda a mi juventud
Ciao Angela Franco da Varese
Robin cantando parecia um anjo!!!! Para mim, é, Sinatra, Mario Lanza, Freddie Mercury, e Robin Gibb!!! "Para mim"!
Absolutely amazed at the incredible harmonies. Such talent may never be seen again. One of a kind
Maybe the best ever w elvis.
Still watching. 2022. The wonderful Robin and brothers. ❤
I just love all your songs . Brings tears and smile.
Ik Hou ook van de BeeGees van in mijn jeugd en zeker van Robin en ik ben ook 68 jaar ❤❤❤ik Ben van Belgie