Once you look at all the stories, it's implied that Kreacher forced himself on Emma. Emily is really the only one who wants to make up for her past mistakes. Freddy, or the Lawyer, stole Leo, or Hell Ember's wife. Emma, having lost her father sort of fell backwards into a recluse stage where she projected onto the Scarecrow as a fatherly figure, and her 'ideal man' one that could never leave her. Kreacher, wanted Emma, and aside from an implied rape, he began to mess with her mind even more by getting inside the Scarecrow and speaking to her. Emma already had developed disorders, and over time began to find solace in Emily, who accidentally killed Freddy's (Leo's) wife during an illegal surgery, an abortion. Freddy knew it was her, and the reason the two of them fled the scene was because Freddy is trying to lead her away to get her killed. Emma lights the Scarecrow on fire to lure Freddy away, and to get a subtle revenge on Kreacher. Emily goes to the manor to try and make up for what she did, which she actually never could forgive herself. The manor owner wants Emily and Emma to be together playing match maker if you will. In one of the maps during the game "White Sand Street Asylum", you can find writing on the wall, stating: “Lydia will stand by Lisa forever and ever.” Emily's name used to be Lydia Jones, and Emma's name used to be Lisa.
@@aqurial well look at this where was kreacher when he was missing? most probably the scarecrow that also explains those noises coming from the scarecrow in the end emma in the end she said that two ppl were not good enough one of 'em is scarecrow obviously. the other can't be emily cuz emma said she and emily will always be together so the other is kreacher, and so emma knowingly killed kreacher
@@nighthaunter5615 waite....what?!?! Emma killed him?! No no no that make no since right now! How can we play as him if he was death??????? Poor thief... Thief fans:(cry)
Wait, was it Thief's voice coming out of the suitcase? I have a very strong feeling that Emma might have just burnt the thief alive since it was likely he was inside of the suitcase and also she said before burning the scarecrow "I don't need neither of you." which indicates to two people
Kit Kat WTF how did fire leaved scars?! It should be burning marks and how did the thief escaped tho Emma said she would be waiting in front of the fire
I think we can draw many conclusions from Gardener's back story: 1.The manor's owner is some kind of Jigsaw figure and knows all of the survivor's dirty secrets 2. The reason why Emma becomes obsessed with scarecrow and then burns its that she projects his father's image on it. She discards it the same way her father tried to take his life. She has daddy issues and resents all men after her father's abandonment. 4. Emma knows that Kreacher is inside the Scarecrow and still plans to keep him alive for 10 years. She is planning to turn him into a mutilated living garden decoration. He will never escape or abandon her like her father did. 5. Notice how the Lawyer and Doctor run away together at the beginning of the game leaving Emma to fare for herself as they consider her a burden. Meanwhile Emma chases after Emily and then gives away her location by burning the scarecrow. Considering this was the last page of the diary obviously didn't escape.
@@aggelikicapsa6330 I don't think she thinks that Kreacher was speaking as the scarecrow when they were in the garden though, also when she talks to the suitcase, I don't think she was talking to Kreacher, even though Kreacher might be in there, she would never call Kreacher "Darling" Although she must know that Kreacher was inside of the suitcase along with the scarecrow, notice how she said "I need neither of you." which indicates to be for two people one is Mr scarecrow and another must be Kreacher. God, I just came up with many theories right now but the one I'm feeling might be the most real and at the same time scary is that Emma lost her mind (so that's why she thinks the scarecrow is talking) which drove her to do crazy things, one of them is that many players suspected her to be the one poisoning the food (In Emily's story I think) when she was holding a scissors in the garden, then the food was poisoned by the flower she talked about, no one would have had that knowledge apart from her and also why was she carrying the scissors then? Although that was not even in her story, does she even remembered what happened, and also the handrail bit too, how she knows more than she should "I heard SOMEONE falling" so she knows it's a person who falls. BY all these assumptions, if those accidents and the poisonings were her actions, I'm not surprised she might have actually burnt Kreacher... (Noooo he is my favorite character!) And she might not even know that she was doing those things, or at least, chosen not to write that on her diary.
Toxic Fox in the storyline though, Emma said that he disappeared right before the game started and we don’t see him at all throughout the gameplay so if we see him before that, he can still get inside of the scarecrow afterwards.
i think they’re equal on thief’s perspective, good side, he easily forgives. but the bad side, he gets violent easily for gardener, her good side is that she doesn’t hesitate to help everyone. bad side, she obsesses over emily and burnt the whole garden
Here's my general consensus on Emma and Emily's relationship. Though what Emma says about Emily is dubiously romantic, all things considered, Emma and Emily's relationship appears purely platonic. Part of her affection towards Emily and calling her an "angel" is how Emily is not only a nurse ( which people tend to refer to as angels ) but because generally, she is a good person. She helps people, and she's helped Emma stay safe from Pierson, therefore, protecting her. Not only that, but it's possible Emma might have remembered who Emily was, because Emily made a promise to cure Emma, so to have Emily be there for her, Emma's affection for her can be explained. However the intensity of her affection and fixation seems odd, but the thing is, Emily has gotten obsessed with other things before. I.e, the scarecrow.
Playing this game with your family in the room isn't a good idea... I've been questioned...many times...by a lot of people...while I was playing the game... God the sound these characters make...
I play it with my screen facing up if I’m playing it in front of my family if I don’t have headphones on, then they’ll just see I’m playing some game that totally isn’t kinda messed up
After see other survivor story, I think the thief is in scarecrow when emma burn it.... because he is not in the factory when the game begin. Emily and freddy said they don't see him too when game begin. Sorry for bad english..
This is because he was never like that. Emma was effed up and she saw things differently. Kreacher was actually trying to be nice and tried protecting her since he's her sole guardian but Emma having a bad mental state had her see something else.
Here's my theory. Not everyone in this mansion is sane. Most of these characters seems realistic, but could it be that the other characters such as the priestess and the explorer have gotten the toxins from the belladonna flowers and those powers that they got r a illusions/Hallucinations from their mind to make them think that they could do those things? If so, then the belladonna's toxins can be put into the food they eat. There's another diary that shows the host doing this. But this theory of mine has lots of holes in it. Let me know what u think guys.
Rain Zielon I think that the manor is a special place where can grant your wishes and the host knows everything. For example, the torch can make hunters feel dizzy. The robot can move like a human and it won’t be possible at that time. And the perfume can erase your time. It was used to forget the memory which Vera had killed her sister
Emma's psychosis is that she sees a scarecrow as being alive, she burns it later Her father's power is using puppets that he actually brings to life, using fire Coincidence?
Lady Sand Kreacher has a lot of mental illnesses, he had worst and never learned how to love, he was abused and always mistreated, he takes care of kids so they don’t suffer like he did, he might have bipolar or identity disorder, cause he changed his voice tune many times, he probably can’t control his emotions like me, he never killed anyone and he would never ruin a family’s life, he’s a caring guy with a bad disorder, people thought he was a pedophile, a rapist, and abused kids, which is 100% not true, those people who thought of that are awful, there are many evidence that he helped the kids by choice, he wasn’t forced to help them and he steals money just for them, he didn’t know about Gardner’s age, and plus she gets shipped with older men which is very concerning, and he would never rape anyone, he helps children and doesn’t like to hit people that much, yes he did hit Emma, but he backed off and left, it looked like that he was mad at himself for hitting her, and he was mad at Emily for “taking” Emma away from him, He could’ve hit her (which is a bad idea) but he didn’t, he left her alone and didn’t talk to her, but doctor called him a bad person, she knows him and I think the reason why she is calling him that so Emma won’t suspect that she was the one who killed Emma’s mom
@@masterv1987 so like Emma is obessed with Emily like emily is her senpai and the theif tries to take her away from the doctor but then she burns him alive.So its like a yandere thing going on 👌😂
4:53 I gotta love how Emily warns Emma about Kreacher being a perv, but also adds what's basically along the lines of "if you're into that stuff, then i ain't judging" Also, I don't think Kreacher was still in the scarecrow when it was burned alive. Notice the lack of struggling or screaming, despite the fact that you could hear his muffled voice when he was still in the suitcase. I think he managed to sneak out of the suitcase but left the scarecrow still inside when Emma went to look for Emily and Freddy.
Emma deffo knew Thief is inside scarecrow bc she says I hope you can see the pyre and pyre is literally a structure used for burning people in funerals.... so yh it’s definitely thief inside and she obviously knew he was inside
I thought that the last update got the story mode so I did it and got the dark skin for the gardener but then grizzly announced that you can now play the story mod in this update and I was shooked 😨
I think I actually understood everything with the story except one thing.. did the gardener know that thief was inside the scarecrow ? I mean her words at the beginning seemed like she didn't know he is there. Also maybe when she said "I don't need neither of you" she meant the scarecrow and her father ? Because she didn't ever need the thief am I right ?
I don't say Emma is gay, i Belive is more a obssess friendship? Or Emma see Emily as an "Angel" like; a pure and good person, but no like a romanantic interest ;-; and Emily is like 32, and Emma is much more young, plus: Emily see Emma as a little sister or something Like that, and if the "Emma x Emily" was a shipp, is a super toxic one (for the obssess of Emma) sooo, that's my theory xD
@@eyeball6168 Not really- Emily just cares for Emma and is trying to make up for her past mistakes. she in no way is a mother to Emma. And Emma does idolize Emily but O believe that's just thanks to all the traumas going on with her. Besides I would also idolize someone that has saved me multiple times from someone that has clearly abused you-
Unless Leo was absolutely sure that he killed Emily, I don’t think Emily died... Emily is canonically really smart and ambitious so if she became conscious again, she probably woulda came up with some plan or something.
I was wondering, why Mr. Pierson went missing?? When the game just begun, Emma is carrying/pushing that trunk with Mr. Skelkro inside but this time Mr. Skelkro moved inside, made a sound, and wanted to come out from that trunk? Does that mean, the reason why Mr. Pierson went missing is that, perhaps he tried to wear that scarecrow again to fool Emma? And by that time Emma took that scarecrow with her as their game begun? As Emily went missing and the lawyer is with her, Emma didn't have much choice but to draw the lawyer away to save Emily from him by burning Mr. Skelkro(with Mr. Pierson inside?)?Don't you guys think?? Anyway, the part where Emma burned Mr. Skelkro, he didn't move or even react when he knows that he's gonna get burn....this part confused me.
If Mr. Pierson was in the suitcase he would've suffocated a while before getting burned so he was either dead or unconscious when Emma burned the scarecrow with him inside
Out of all the people in this story, I think Emily is the only "good" person here. She's the only one willing to change and make up for her mistakes and also wanted to protect Emma from Kreacher. Freddy is just a horrible person overall; he's a liar, a backstabber, and also kind've a murderer because he lured Emily to her demise. I don't think Emma is a bad person at heart, but she is still crazy since she killed Kreacher, but that could be because of her mental illness. Finally, Kreacher is also crazy because he forced himself on Emma (note, she was one of the kids in his orphanage so that's even more messed up) but I think he probably ate some food spiked with Bella Donna and that might have messed with his head a bit because during the story, you can see him wheezing/laughing when he's idle
Okay at the 2nd one i kept getting discoverd finally i finished all of it By the why the voice actors did pretty good Edit:gardener is in love with doctor but i ship theif and gardener
Cj Kun he was in the scarecrow pretending to be it. Emma thought, or Lisa thought that the scarecrow was talking by itself. Thief was in the suitcase and is in the scarecrow... and she basically burned him alive.
@@ipiinsih3655 3 mainly reasons: 1. the sound. the sound in suitcase is absolutely belong to Thief. Because it's different from Chinese version. they use a new CV in English . 2. The Thief Diary( you can find it on RUclips)😏The Thief get into the scarecrow and try to hug Gardener. 3. The Gardener said" Darlings"
Mikado Mikaela he was an artist, he has many skins that said he was an artist, he painted so he can forget his past and painted for the kids that he takes care
@@intea_soul9839 Sorry for my English in this comment. Also thanks for telling me that. It's very interesting to see what the characters used to do or can do
So what I’ve gathered is that, I still don’t like lawyer. Emma is obsessed with Emily, Kreacher has an obsession with Emma and doesn’t react in a good way when he doesn’t get his way. So everything is messed up and this is why I’m starting to main hunter bc I don’t know their deduction stories
I never knew you could break that vase to get his attention. I did it when he was still right beside the door. When he turned around I just ran through the door
Idk if you already figured this out but whenever you play as Emma there’s tasks for you to do, such as open chests, hit the hunter, etc and once you play as her and you see no more objectives go into the notebook with the characters, click the gardener, and on the side of the right page there should be something called deduction target or something like that click the paper under it and start off with the gardeners diary, if you already knew all that, cool :}
If you slowmo the trailer the part when the detective is hallucinating about what happen to survivors. only thief escaped(well not sure bcz he didn't caught) while doctor and lawyer get caught white gardener dragging into somewhere (sorry for bad english)
Yea no, Emma kidnapped the thief to pretty much burn him she says I don’t need you and burned the scare crow plus in the suit case you can clearly hear the theif
“After all, in a sense, you’re also a part of me, right?” Wait wtf do you mean? Someone help me understand. Because I can only think of one thing and I refuse to believe that
reminder: Please do not ship emma x emily ,its very abusive and hinted at an age gap,doctor patient relationship, emily killed emmas mom and that its a unhealthy obsession.
I don't say Emma is gay, i Belive is more a obssess friendship? Or Emma see Emily as an "Angel" like; a pure and good person, but no like a romanantic interest ;-; and Emily is like 32, and Emma is much more young, plus: Emily see Emma as a little sister or something Like that, and if the "Emma x Emily" was a shipp, is a super toxic one (for the obssess of Emma) sooo, that's my _opinion_
Nice
Emily Dyer watch out Emily, Emma went crazy
Why Did She Call Me Little Angel?
@@sitikhatijah6360 i don't know :v maybe she likes you
I Think She LOVE Me
I love you DOCTOR
😁
Once you look at all the stories, it's implied that Kreacher forced himself on Emma. Emily is really the only one who wants to make up for her past mistakes. Freddy, or the Lawyer, stole Leo, or Hell Ember's wife. Emma, having lost her father sort of fell backwards into a recluse stage where she projected onto the Scarecrow as a fatherly figure, and her 'ideal man' one that could never leave her. Kreacher, wanted Emma, and aside from an implied rape, he began to mess with her mind even more by getting inside the Scarecrow and speaking to her. Emma already had developed disorders, and over time began to find solace in Emily, who accidentally killed Freddy's (Leo's) wife during an illegal surgery, an abortion. Freddy knew it was her, and the reason the two of them fled the scene was because Freddy is trying to lead her away to get her killed. Emma lights the Scarecrow on fire to lure Freddy away, and to get a subtle revenge on Kreacher. Emily goes to the manor to try and make up for what she did, which she actually never could forgive herself. The manor owner wants Emily and Emma to be together playing match maker if you will. In one of the maps during the game "White Sand Street Asylum", you can find writing on the wall, stating: “Lydia will stand by Lisa forever and ever.” Emily's name used to be Lydia Jones, and Emma's name used to be Lisa.
wow...just...wow
@@nighthaunter5615 I'm still confused could you tell me why Emma burned kreacher?? plz answer
@@aqurial well look at this
where was kreacher when he was missing? most probably the scarecrow
that also explains those noises coming from the scarecrow in the end
emma in the end she said that two ppl were not good enough one of 'em is scarecrow obviously. the other can't be emily cuz emma said she and emily will always be together
so the other is kreacher, and so emma knowingly killed kreacher
Ok....that make since...
@@nighthaunter5615 waite....what?!?! Emma killed him?! No no no that make no since right now! How can we play as him if he was death??????? Poor thief...
Thief fans:(cry)
I need this Manor to be a new map
Same here
Me too
But it cant sadly because all the chairs are supposed to go to the mannor
@@deltapix1836 I mean, there are already chairs going underground, so...
yeah but, it would be hell to be chased in.
Every time a survivor gets hit once, the sound they make sounds like porn
XD
Either the creator is horny or it's accidental XD
My mother suddenly took my phone cause she tjinks im watching it
Yeahh my father kept looking at my phone because of those weird noises
Yeah, they say “family friendly” but..
_ArE yOu SuRe AbOuT tHaT?_
Wait, was it Thief's voice coming out of the suitcase?
I have a very strong feeling that Emma might have just burnt the thief alive since it was likely he was inside of the suitcase and also she said before burning the scarecrow "I don't need neither of you." which indicates to two people
And those two being the Thief *and* the Scarecrow
Ohh that's why the thief suddenly disappeared
He didn't die but he got some scars or something like that after that
Kit Kat WTF how did fire leaved scars?! It should be burning marks and how did the thief escaped tho Emma said she would be waiting in front of the fire
Maybe she means the scarecrow and his father
I think we can draw many conclusions from Gardener's back story:
1.The manor's owner is some kind of Jigsaw figure and knows all of the survivor's dirty secrets
2. The reason why Emma becomes obsessed with scarecrow and then burns its that she projects his father's image on it. She discards it the same way her father tried to take his life. She has daddy issues and resents all men after her father's abandonment.
4. Emma knows that Kreacher is inside the Scarecrow and still plans to keep him alive for 10 years. She is planning to turn him into a mutilated living garden decoration. He will never escape or abandon her like her father did.
5. Notice how the Lawyer and Doctor run away together at the beginning of the game leaving Emma to fare for herself as they consider her a burden. Meanwhile Emma chases after Emily and then gives away her location by burning the scarecrow. Considering this was the last page of the diary obviously didn't escape.
No, the video showed us that the thief was looking at emma while she was talking to the scarecrow so the thief couldn't have been in the puppet.
@@aggelikicapsa6330 I don't think she thinks that Kreacher was speaking as the scarecrow when they were in the garden though, also when she talks to the suitcase, I don't think she was talking to Kreacher, even though Kreacher might be in there, she would never call Kreacher "Darling"
Although she must know that Kreacher was inside of the suitcase along with the scarecrow, notice how she said "I need neither of you." which indicates to be for two people one is Mr scarecrow and another must be Kreacher.
God, I just came up with many theories right now but the one I'm feeling might be the most real and at the same time scary is that Emma lost her mind (so that's why she thinks the scarecrow is talking) which drove her to do crazy things, one of them is that many players suspected her to be the one poisoning the food (In Emily's story I think) when she was holding a scissors in the garden, then the food was poisoned by the flower she talked about, no one would have had that knowledge apart from her and also why was she carrying the scissors then? Although that was not even in her story, does she even remembered what happened, and also the handrail bit too, how she knows more than she should "I heard SOMEONE falling" so she knows it's a person who falls.
BY all these assumptions, if those accidents and the poisonings were her actions, I'm not surprised she might have actually burnt Kreacher... (Noooo he is my favorite character!) And she might not even know that she was doing those things, or at least, chosen not to write that on her diary.
All the survivor died
If you look closely at identity v Trailer.
@@Medatreeme But... If Kreacher was inside the Scarecrow, then why are we saw him? That's what I don't understand... And what about the 10 years?
Toxic Fox in the storyline though, Emma said that he disappeared right before the game started and we don’t see him at all throughout the gameplay so if we see him before that, he can still get inside of the scarecrow afterwards.
13:32 ...literally ruined the thief for me....
Same..
same i uses to love him
Wait what was he trying to do
@@yourlocalanimesimp7393 TW!!!!!! ))) its heavily emplied kreacher r//ped her or attempted to.
@@averagevsrgfan ohh
*"AT LEAST I'M A MAN"*
Ya man got audacity to say that
I cracked the fuck up when he said this 😂
he said that because of the scarecrow right?
@@theoisdead4962 He might be talking about emily
@@noxiouschocolate9644 aah, because he thinks lisa and emily are dating?
I can’t tell who’s more suspicious, Thief or Gardner.
i think they’re equal
on thief’s perspective, good side, he easily forgives. but the bad side, he gets violent easily
for gardener, her good side is that she doesn’t hesitate to help everyone. bad side, she obsesses over emily and burnt the whole garden
The lawyer is the most suspicious one, he allways stayed in the shadows without letting everyone know he is suspicious
You should probably read all the diaries do find out, but idk. Haven't unlocked all of them yet.
@@mmieny So if you unlock all of them that would be enother diary?
Thief
emma woods, emma stones, emma metals..
emma watson
Emma tek
Emma chaimberlain
Emma swan
Emma diamond
Here's my general consensus on Emma and Emily's relationship. Though what Emma says about Emily is dubiously romantic, all things considered, Emma and Emily's relationship appears purely platonic. Part of her affection towards Emily and calling her an "angel" is how Emily is not only a nurse ( which people tend to refer to as angels ) but because generally, she is a good person. She helps people, and she's helped Emma stay safe from Pierson, therefore, protecting her. Not only that, but it's possible Emma might have remembered who Emily was, because Emily made a promise to cure Emma, so to have Emily be there for her, Emma's affection for her can be explained. However the intensity of her affection and fixation seems odd, but the thing is, Emily has gotten obsessed with other things before. I.e, the scarecrow.
Cure emma from what? I'm confused on that part
simple simplicity that’s the thing, we don’t know what exactly Emma needs to be cured from. It’s heavily implied that it’s from mental illness though.
Simply said, she likes her?
@@Tsukasaslover idk if it’s love it’s more like an obsession just like how she” loved” a scarecrow and burnt it later
@@ironii1599 Emily fried emmas brains (ETC) when she was young and ut made her go loony
Playing this game with your family in the room isn't a good idea... I've been questioned...many times...by a lot of people...while I was playing the game... God the sound these characters make...
I play it with my screen facing up if I’m playing it in front of my family if I don’t have headphones on, then they’ll just see I’m playing some game that totally isn’t kinda messed up
After see other survivor story, I think the thief is in scarecrow when emma burn it.... because he is not in the factory when the game begin. Emily and freddy said they don't see him too when game begin.
Sorry for bad english..
Satia Vathi he is.
Why does Mr Pierson never get the hint that Emma woods doesn’t like him
Sadly this resembles the real world, some men just dont understand boundaries and wont take no for an answer
He thinks that Emma likes him
But he found out that she doesn't so that's why he's acting like that right?
This is because he was never like that. Emma was effed up and she saw things differently. Kreacher was actually trying to be nice and tried protecting her since he's her sole guardian but Emma having a bad mental state had her see something else.
@@rhianv. No. It's a hallucination made by Emma, Kreacher was just trying to protect and waz being gentle to her in reality.
2:44
“Mr Pierson has become more violent...”
*agressive coughing in the background*
Here's my theory. Not everyone in this mansion is sane. Most of these characters seems realistic, but could it be that the other characters such as the priestess and the explorer have gotten the toxins from the belladonna flowers and those powers that they got r a illusions/Hallucinations from their mind to make them think that they could do those things? If so, then the belladonna's toxins can be put into the food they eat. There's another diary that shows the host doing this. But this theory of mine has lots of holes in it. Let me know what u think guys.
Rain Zielon this is debunked because the priestess and her brother Eli Clark both practiced some type of magic
@@UrScum well I already said that my theory has lots of holes in it. I expected someone to reply as soon as possible.
Rain Zielon I think that the manor is a special place where can grant your wishes and the host knows everything. For example, the torch can make hunters feel dizzy. The robot can move like a human and it won’t be possible at that time. And the perfume can erase your time. It was used to forget the memory which Vera had killed her sister
The priestess one ain’t true , she uses the holy key and that’s the thing that allows her to make portals
@@UrScum they're not related in any way
the one thing that bothers me during the voice lines is when they make noise bc of their standby motion 😔👊
Emma's psychosis is that she sees a scarecrow as being alive, she burns it later
Her father's power is using puppets that he actually brings to life, using fire
Coincidence?
ugh your mind 😩✨
Because that's their thing. Leo's birthday card, it's stated that he and Emma used to burn scarecrows in their freetime.
Wow, if Emma’s story is this F’ed up, I wonder what is in store for the others
Entologist: AHAHAHA I KILLED MY HUSBAND
Despite it all...I still like Kreacher. I need his side to see what happen. The Scarecrow and Kreacher seem to have the same voice going on.
Baby Don't Hurt me No More yea it’s because it is kreacher
Lady Sand Kreacher has a lot of mental illnesses, he had worst and never learned how to love, he was abused and always mistreated, he takes care of kids so they don’t suffer like he did, he might have bipolar or identity disorder, cause he changed his voice tune many times, he probably can’t control his emotions like me, he never killed anyone and he would never ruin a family’s life, he’s a caring guy with a bad disorder, people thought he was a pedophile, a rapist, and abused kids, which is 100% not true, those people who thought of that are awful, there are many evidence that he helped the kids by choice, he wasn’t forced to help them and he steals money just for them, he didn’t know about Gardner’s age, and plus she gets shipped with older men which is very concerning, and he would never rape anyone, he helps children and doesn’t like to hit people that much, yes he did hit Emma, but he backed off and left, it looked like that he was mad at himself for hitting her, and he was mad at Emily for “taking” Emma away from him, He could’ve hit her (which is a bad idea) but he didn’t, he left her alone and didn’t talk to her, but doctor called him a bad person, she knows him and I think the reason why she is calling him that so Emma won’t suspect that she was the one who killed Emma’s mom
Lady Sand I’ve read did thief’s side of the story he seems normal
@@lilfartboy1230 he got some disorder but he's a good guy
so did Emma burn Kreacher alive in her fourth diary?
R E J E C T E D
14:17 :*Gardener smiles*
Me : Are you afraid or not?
LoL
The gardeners voice sounds like Yandere-Chans voice
Lukfo 16 ik I thought like that
And the doctor is senpai😂
@@masterv1987 so like Emma is obessed with Emily like emily is her senpai and the theif tries to take her away from the doctor but then she burns him alive.So its like a yandere thing going on 👌😂
4:53 I gotta love how Emily warns Emma about Kreacher being a perv, but also adds what's basically along the lines of "if you're into that stuff, then i ain't judging"
Also, I don't think Kreacher was still in the scarecrow when it was burned alive. Notice the lack of struggling or screaming, despite the fact that you could hear his muffled voice when he was still in the suitcase. I think he managed to sneak out of the suitcase but left the scarecrow still inside when Emma went to look for Emily and Freddy.
You can hear screaming though...
I'd say there would've been way more stuffing in that scarecrow, which is why you can't hear him.
Gardener is too gay for Doctor.
I ship it!
I knew it that gardener likes doctor
Me too!
When the thief said ‘at least ı am a boy’ I screamed I SHIP EMMA AND DOCTORRRRRR(nurse)
When i found emma is gay i went like wut
Please call it Yuri
Emma deffo knew Thief is inside scarecrow bc she says I hope you can see the pyre and pyre is literally a structure used for burning people in funerals.... so yh it’s definitely thief inside and she obviously knew he was inside
I have a feeling the hell ember didn't exactly kill the gardener.
Exactly! Maybe Leo decided to let her out *(Probably by Dungeon)* since he would probably not like to hurt his own daughter.
So the detective received the letter from the hell ember, any clues of what happenend to him?
Hans Sandhu nope he did, if he didn’t then she would be alive and the game would have ended, but he just killed her
@@HelloThere-fg9hm he doesn't know that his own daughter and his old friend is in the game if so he would whoop Freddie's ass and hug gardener
@@intea_soul9839he didn't. Becoming hunter was his punishment for not writing diaries
"at least I'm a man" is he implying something ohohoho
What do you mean
?
I think he says that he is a human not a scarecrow
@@SpingyClink ✂️✂️ xD
@Mitski wh-
I thought that the last update got the story mode so I did it and got the dark skin for the gardener but then grizzly announced that you can now play the story mod in this update and I was shooked 😨
And the voice acting was in chinese! What is going on!?
I heard in an update announcement that they accidentally released it in the previous update, this update is the official release
I assume the Chinese language was there since they didn't have the English voices in the mode yet
Because that chinese content.
And this official from global
@@rabbitlunatic Oh okay thank you for telling me :)
I think I actually understood everything with the story except one thing.. did the gardener know that thief was inside the scarecrow ?
I mean her words at the beginning seemed like she didn't know he is there.
Also maybe when she said "I don't need neither of you" she meant the scarecrow and her father ? Because she didn't ever need the thief am I right ?
Can you explain what’s going on please?
I’m pretty confused right now
Im actually talking about emily and The scarecrow/kreacher. -emma
Welp. Now I have full confidence in writing my Doctor x Gardener fanfiction on Wattpad
It’s toxic
I don't say Emma is gay, i Belive is more a obssess friendship? Or Emma see Emily as an "Angel" like; a pure and good person, but no like a romanantic interest ;-; and Emily is like 32, and Emma is much more young, plus: Emily see Emma as a little sister or something Like that, and if the "Emma x Emily" was a shipp, is a super toxic one (for the obssess of Emma) sooo, that's my theory xD
@@ava4033 I'm new to identityv uhhh how is it toxic again/?
@@fishburger6363 Emily is a mother figure to Emma, and Emma is obsessed with Emily. It’s not a healthy dynamic
@@eyeball6168 Not really- Emily just cares for Emma and is trying to make up for her past mistakes. she in no way is a mother to Emma.
And Emma does idolize Emily but O believe that's just thanks to all the traumas going on with her. Besides I would also idolize someone that has saved me multiple times from someone that has clearly abused you-
Wait does Emma like Emily?
yeah of course.
That’s yurt right?
Yuri? Kind of XD I ship them
Yeah
highly likely😳😳
Sounds like the missing thief is struggling inside the scarecrow to be burned
This story makes it more chilling when you finally understand the whole story.
Thanks for uploading this! The plot of this game is the only thing keeping me attached to Identity V
same
Unless Leo was absolutely sure that he killed Emily, I don’t think Emily died... Emily is canonically really smart and ambitious so if she became conscious again, she probably woulda came up with some plan or something.
She's also weak and slow, she lost her syringe 💉 also The angel skin kinda suggests that she dead 💀 🍖
Gardener calling Emily her angel kinda made me happy, not gonna lie.
15:24 emma saying darling 🤰
fr fr
Thank you for the translate!
That's not translated that's in the global version
I got Caught by hell ember Everytime
WHY YOU HIT YOUR DAUGTHER
Same it’s so frustrating I’m struggling to pass it
Emma wood still live in the hood 😂
I was wondering, why Mr. Pierson went missing?? When the game just begun, Emma is carrying/pushing that trunk with Mr. Skelkro inside but this time Mr. Skelkro moved inside, made a sound, and wanted to come out from that trunk? Does that mean, the reason why Mr. Pierson went missing is that, perhaps he tried to wear that scarecrow again to fool Emma? And by that time Emma took that scarecrow with her as their game begun? As Emily went missing and the lawyer is with her, Emma didn't have much choice but to draw the lawyer away to save Emily from him by burning Mr. Skelkro(with Mr. Pierson inside?)?Don't you guys think?? Anyway, the part where Emma burned Mr. Skelkro, he didn't move or even react when he knows that he's gonna get burn....this part confused me.
If Mr. Pierson was in the suitcase he would've suffocated a while before getting burned so he was either dead or unconscious when Emma burned the scarecrow with him inside
@@user-bv5kx3jb5n oh i see thanks, made sense, ofc u get suffocate inside that trunk what am i even thinking.. 😅
Oh god, I just started playing the game yesterday and this is what I'm getting myself into
Out of all the people in this story, I think Emily is the only "good" person here. She's the only one willing to change and make up for her mistakes and also wanted to protect Emma from Kreacher. Freddy is just a horrible person overall; he's a liar, a backstabber, and also kind've a murderer because he lured Emily to her demise. I don't think Emma is a bad person at heart, but she is still crazy since she killed Kreacher, but that could be because of her mental illness. Finally, Kreacher is also crazy because he forced himself on Emma (note, she was one of the kids in his orphanage so that's even more messed up) but I think he probably ate some food spiked with Bella Donna and that might have messed with his head a bit because during the story, you can see him wheezing/laughing when he's idle
idk why gardener story is creepy and dark
I mean idv is still a horror game so
14:04 is the best part of da video
Fun fact: the theif from the Chinese version is actually called the "philanthropist" instead of the theif
Haha
Yeah, XD
Philanthropist thief
XD
Okay at the 2nd one i kept getting discoverd finally i finished all of it
By the why the voice actors did pretty good
Edit:gardener is in love with doctor but i ship theif and gardener
I ship gardener and the doctor XD
Thief x Gardener is a horrible fucking ship wth
@@charliebeukema5045 yeah I changed my mind I don't ship gardener and thief anymore
Theif: *You filthy villain*
Gardener X Doctor
It’s toxic
No 💖
Emma is still pure so go away thief qwq
Cj Kun she killed him
Cj Kun he was in the scarecrow pretending to be it. Emma thought, or Lisa thought that the scarecrow was talking by itself. Thief was in the suitcase and is in the scarecrow... and she basically burned him alive.
Wait a second... Did she hide a body in the scarecrow?
yes, the Thief.
@@aurorazero6215 how would you know it was the thief tho
Really thief?
@@1stSoldierGaming absolutely , but the Thief is alive.
@@ipiinsih3655 3 mainly reasons:
1. the sound. the sound in suitcase is absolutely belong to Thief. Because it's different from Chinese version. they use a new CV in English .
2. The Thief Diary( you can find it on RUclips)😏The Thief get into the scarecrow and try to hug Gardener.
3. The Gardener said" Darlings"
I like overanalyzing so I'm just having a blast theorizing about this
When Doc said that Thief had some hobbies my mind when into places it should never go
Mikado Mikaela he was an artist, he has many skins that said he was an artist, he painted so he can forget his past and painted for the kids that he takes care
@@intea_soul9839 Sorry for my English in this comment. Also thanks for telling me that. It's very interesting to see what the characters used to do or can do
Mikado Mikaela it’s okay my English is wack
@@intea_soul9839 thanks
First viewer :) can you make video full story doctor?
Bots Gaming The Doctor subplot is not even out yet
Coming soon
I will, wait until release
9:09 Emma woods is going stealth
Emma woods dlc confirmed for payday 2
So what I’ve gathered is that, I still don’t like lawyer.
Emma is obsessed with Emily, Kreacher has an obsession with Emma and doesn’t react in a good way when he doesn’t get his way.
So everything is messed up and this is why I’m starting to main hunter bc I don’t know their deduction stories
:o amazing
Connection: 16ms. Damn the movement are smooth!
But in online: 250ms-900ms. Lagged as @#$& xD lol.
Identity v is just crazyyyy love it
The scarecrow burned and remember the investigator back story he was found after a fire something maybe his inside there and he made those diary
Me: has to watch how to do the diary bc keeps on dying
The pages are missing because i saw an video that when she burned it the hunter noticed her and she got chased.
Literally this game is everyting.
The story is misterious and so intertesting.
kreacher: 🔥👁💧👄💧👁🔥
17:36 "This is Emily's syringe. The syringe is missing." Wut
as in, missing from Emily. it's worded a little weird
I believe that the thief is still alive and since the doctor isnt coming the gardner needs someone else to keep her company and not in a good way
Sad thing about that is theif is my main
thief: at least I'm a man
it means the gardener likes doctor
THE WAY HE HIT HER I CAN'T LMAOSHSKSJ
YEAH ME NEITHER BRO
I never knew you could break that vase to get his attention. I did it when he was still right beside the door. When he turned around I just ran through the door
LOL it took me 20 mins to get away with this method, i also didnt know that you can break the vase
Lol
Idk if can run through the door.
3J0H22A Gaming not literally hahahaha
she sounds like a yandere here ngl and i love it
"y-you refuse k-kreacher?!"
This is soo cool How did you do this😭😍 can someone explain cuz I had only been playing this game for a month
Idk if you already figured this out but whenever you play as Emma there’s tasks for you to do, such as open chests, hit the hunter, etc and once you play as her and you see no more objectives go into the notebook with the characters, click the gardener, and on the side of the right page there should be something called deduction target or something like that click the paper under it and start off with the gardeners diary, if you already knew all that, cool :}
Im so happy their is actually a love story 😭😭😭😭
I feel next it will be the doctors story then lawyer
This was so helpful because i cant even get past the first one 😅
"darlings" "neither of you" im starting to think it wasnt an accident
K never knew this story would be so interesting!
Thx
i remember the day i finished this, i was so happy to now my ex-main story.
If you slowmo the trailer the part when the detective is hallucinating about what happen to survivors. only thief escaped(well not sure bcz he didn't caught) while doctor
and lawyer get caught white gardener dragging into somewhere (sorry for bad english)
Yea no, Emma kidnapped the thief to pretty much burn him she says I don’t need you and burned the scare crow plus in the suit case you can clearly hear the theif
Emma knew thief was in the scarecrow so she burned him in it
Her eyes are wonderful we will be together soon the
R/niceguys
The game didn’t activate the sequence where Freddy comes down the stairs, so I was stuck in the first scene TT
Ok so Emma is 22 the doctor is 32 and the theif is 30 so are the people who are shipping Emma and emily making a legal ship or a illegal ship?
its legal, emma and emily are both adults
it’s legal, just a weird power imbalance.
They're both adults but it's a bit weird
I remember this place somewhere in resident evil were jill is the protagonist
Please forgive me for being dumb, but can you play this? Like, how do you play this in the actual game? Is it only available on RUclips?
“After all, in a sense, you’re also a part of me, right?”
Wait wtf do you mean? Someone help me understand. Because I can only think of one thing and I refuse to believe that
Im getting ripped tonight rip that
Im sorry darlings
Maybe what i need is neither of you
I hope you can see the pyre emily
reminder: Please do not ship emma x emily ,its very abusive and hinted at an age gap,doctor patient relationship, emily killed emmas mom and that its a unhealthy obsession.
the gardener's mouth scares me 😰 🤣
1:35
*hand clips through face*
I dind't notice there a deduxtion story now
Does someone knows how can I play this survivor’s stories in the game?
I think you have to complete all of the diary deductions of the corresponding characters
Kreacher is obviously trying to force himself onto Emma, poor girl. Rightfully so she burnt him to death.
Am I the only one who came here because they couldn't figure out how to get through a certain part? Just me? Okay
Woah... I like the yuri...♡
Wait second Emma like Emily ??
Soon
I ship it XD
@@masterv1987 it’s toxic
It’s toxic
I don't say Emma is gay, i Belive is more a obssess friendship? Or Emma see Emily as an "Angel" like; a pure and good person, but no like a romanantic interest ;-; and Emily is like 32, and Emma is much more young, plus: Emily see Emma as a little sister or something Like that, and if the "Emma x Emily" was a shipp, is a super toxic one (for the obssess of Emma) sooo, that's my _opinion_