The "No Compulsion in Islam" Lie
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 сен 2018
- Muslims keep telling me there is no compulsion in Islam.
Patreon: / apostateprophet
Paypal: www.paypal.me/apostateprophet
Twitter: / apostateridvan
Facebook: / theapostateprophet
Minds: www.minds.com/apostateprophet
Bitchute: www.bitchute.com/channel/apos... (auto-upload)
References:
No compulsion verse: quran.com/2/256
Abrogation verse: quran.com/2/106
Three choices for nonbelievers: muflihun.com/muslim/19/4294
Abrogation of peace by Ibn Kathir: www.qtafsir.com/index.php?opti...
Jizyah verse: quran.com/9/29
Ibn Khaldun about Islamic nature of aggression: ia801908.us.archive.org/7/ite... (page 303)
Mohammed declares to fight all nonbelievers: muflihun.com/bukhari/8/387
Ruling on apostates: quranx.com/Hadith/Bukhari/USC...
Intro & Outro Visual + Music, made by Egyptian Atheist ( / @egyptianatheist )
There is no compulsion in islam*
*Terms and conditions apply
@Zack Smith well, the most obvious one is you're not allowed to leave once you're in (penalty for apostasy is death), and the dzimmi system, where nonmuslims are required to pay to be allowed to exist (the choices are convert, pay, or die)
Very funny! No moneyback guarantee, I can assure you.
Another case of the conditional unconditional...
Zack Smith Either provide the quotes, or shut the fuck up. We all know you are full of shit, but it might be fun to watch your kind fail, yet again
@@shoaibfarooq1587 Then prove him wrong
No compulsion in Islam is when muhammad was in mecca with no power or army at his hand
Exactly--the first part of the Quran is all puppies and rainbows when Mohammad was trying to gain followers the old fashioned way. After he got run out of Mecca, his true colors, that of the Arab caravan raider and slaver, came out and the Quran got a lot bloodier. By Muslims' own admission, these later verses take precedence over the earlier ones.
sri krishna why did he forgive the pagans who tried to kill him and his followers when he entered Mecca ? No man will ever do something like that..
Hassan Ahmed
But he forced all of them to convert to Islam. That was his main point - to covert everyone to Islam. All fights were to this end which he achieved , so there was no need to kill everyone. However he did not spare some selected people who had criticised his teachings.
Actually this is a pattern in Islam set by Prophet Muhammad. When you are weak and in minority then apply earlier revealed peaceful verses like there is no compulsion in religion but when you are strong and in majority then go for the kill by applying later violent verses. This pattern has never changed since the 7th century.
@@Hattori604 Muhammad was fucked Allah Rasool ...a myth
"We don't need Islam just the way we don't need slavery or human sacrifice." Good comparisons.
We need Islam to stop people from doing stupid things
@@justaguy3538 Nice joke 🤣🤣🤣
@@saneeshkaithathara4241 you mean apostate, yeah his a joke
@@justaguy3538 yes, barbaric people need rules if you're civilised you won't need them
@@azanuan9185 If that's your definition of "civilized" then there's no civilized person in this world, we're all barbarians, we all do stupid things, we all have enough evil to do bad things to others unless something stops us, we all get lost and need something to get us back on the road, we're humans
Muslim means 'submission to Allah'. But the real meaning is "submission the brain/ intellect to Allah" & following without brain.😁😁😁
"Subjugation" is a better way of saying it.
😂😂😂
I'm sick too AP. But getting better. "No one can be forced into Islam" hahahahah! Tell that to India, N. Africa and any other Nation Islam has conqured.
Yep. That's why I made the "only an idiot..." statement. :)
Hope you get better soon.
Warrior Linda Clark,, India is not fully conquered by Muslims.. Muslims are only 14.4% of Indian population.
Warrior Linda Clark : Or to the women and girls abducted by Boko Haram in northern Nigeria over the last few years and have been forcibly converted, forcibly covered, raped and have been having children in captivity for their captors. And also Leah Shuaribu, the only secondary school girl not returned from the Dapchi abduction for her refusal to convert to Islam from Christianity. And to the five or so other school girls who died from 'fear' in the hands of the abductor.
May the same kind of peace visited upon all these innocent people be upon Mohammed forever. Amen.
@@carolinebee7951 Correct.
Apostate Prophet Thanks honey. Trouble with being old is coughing makes for frequent leaks....hahahahaha! I know...TMI eh?
एक ही नारा एक ही नाम
Stay away from Islam
This is how my people converted to Islam by force
What people are Those?
yjhv y the Bengali
My indian people too.
For over a thousand years the religion of peace butchered it's way across three continents including the Islamic invasion of the Indian subcontinent which resulted in the biggest genocide in history with over 80 MILLION butchered by the Islamic pigs.
Mr Khan goes into great detail, warning its a bit rapey.
"Islamic Jihad: A Legacy of Forced Conversion, Imperialism and Slavery"
M. A.. Khan
www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwj1zo252ZjaAhVLLcAKHalDAB0QFggpMAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fguruprasad.net%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2016%2F03%2Fislamic-jihad-legacy-of-forced-conversion-imperialism-slavery.pdf&usg=AOvVaw1BDz0qvodbeANmW1SSPhQ4
In my country, there's a new law the allows the muslim areas to practice sharia law, is this worrying enough?
wow
Jewie Snew - that is totally terrifying!!
What country is it?
@@aarush3603 probably my country Lebanon
Possibly the UK. This is the de facto situation if not entirely de jure. Yet.
History:
"It's not compulsion,
it's called a sword."
Brother, I hope your channel continues to grow. You have been more informative and CLEAR on the contradictions of the religion and how bad it truly is . I always refer people curious about Islam to your channel so they can get a clear picture. Keep up the great work and never back down from those who try to intimidate or oppress your videos.
Thank you a lot for your support. :)
Apostate Prophet Certainly! much deserved, and much appreciated with all you've shown us and continue to do. :)
@Keksi who is a liar?
Check out David Wood.
ruclips.net/video/DbsejG--znc/видео.html
Take care. We only have one apostate prophet !
May he forever seal up the mouth of Muhammad. O seal over Muhammad, arise!
I can only say Thanks 😊
+النصر بن الحارس
Because Mother Mary also covered her hairs.......Matter is not covering their hair or not......Matter is female genital mutilation, using them for child breeding machines, Chpt 3 verse 34 "strike your womens if they don't obey"...........These r the problems.
Hasen Rose wow I love muslimahs 😍😍😍😍😍😘😘😘😘😘
HAL 9000 I love muslim women and it's halal for me .Stop me if you can.💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
Going by your hijab it looks like you're still in an area where that cult is in control. I hope you can escape if that's the case.
Salem Nazareni Whether someone called mary covered her hair or not doesn't matter, it is up to you what you want to wear, but none of that either proves or could be cited as any kind of evidence that some sort of god exists. So just wearing clothes because some other people do isn't any sort of reason.
God Bless all Apostates. It is not easy to leave Islam and live.
Thank you for your kindness🙏
You should probably use different wording than ‘God Bless’, most people who have left a religion are atheists
@@hmalik5232 Non existent god bless then
@@consciouspresence5880No.
That shows what kind of religion it is
great work! thx a lot for doing it! greetings from ex-muslim from Russia
Молодец! Надеюсь что ты не единственный..
Wong Li Hello! my friend! He is a fundamental Suni muslim. He takes everything in Quran seriously. I think he is too lazy to read to leave Islam.
Mr danger plz do not marry him... Otherwise your life will be like hell.. do not be fooled by love.. if he really love you then he will never tell you or force you to change your religion for him.. god bless you 😊
Russia has Muslims ? I didn't know
randomnizer Target 2 Crack more than you imagine. Each Friday there are plenty of polices on guard around mosques to prevent violence and torr cause thousands of Muslims go there praying but hijack all the Main Streets.
Mafia=islam. Protection money, join and can't leave, capo did tutti capi (boss of all bosses allah), expand into all areas of society. Do as I say not as I do. What a great system.......
correct: there is no other "system/group" than the "mafia" and "islam", where you are killed because of leaving "the system".
@@scp3178 How about cults？
I grew up in a Muslim missionary home in the Middle East and my youngest brother who grew up in the States is arguing with me about what I was taught in my Islamic studies back home. He refuses to believe that Islam teaches hate. The American Muslims are not true Muslims and my youngest brother is the perfect example. I feel bad for him because he’s lost between two worlds. He’s really struggling with his identity. He’s abandoned Islam but because our parents are still Muslim, he doesn’t want to accept that they practice a hateful religion. It’s so sad.
Is he ismaili?
Just ask him to read Quran. There are 123 hateful verses in Quran.
@@rayrwyr save your country and demographic changes.
@@greyngreyer5 he's probably just an American leftist who fell for the Islamophobia narrative
I had a rough couple of weeks, but here I am again. There is a lot of work to do, and I will be doing more and more. Thanks for your continuous support!
Here's the link to the German channel: ruclips.net/user/ApostateProphetDE
Sidenote: I will be live on David Wood's channel tomorrow at 7PM EST. Make sure to join. This time it will be mainly me talking. :)
Btw.: Sorry for the little goof in the middle of the video. :)
You're doing great
Apostate Prophet.. Plzz have a live chat with Allah..!!
Apostate Prophet - lol I was having a debate with a Muslim who was arguing this on the comments section on another vid of yours when u uploaded this one
You are really very brave. Stay strong and healthy .Take enough rest.
ruclips.net/video/95DpcudTlMc/видео.html
A.P please watch this video
Allah: there is no compulsion in Islam.
also Allah: it's compulsory to pray and fast.
🤷
Now they will come in new surah...... Surah AK47 😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂 haha
@@shoaibfarooq1587 muslims just prove whatever they want by chosing the meaning they want to understand.
@@shoaibfarooq1587 I do want to understand and know the truth. Part of knowing the truth also means knowing the lies and falsehoods. That’s why I study Islam. Because I need to know the lies that so many believe as truth.
Thank you for being bold and strong enough to tell the truth about Islam, which is basically convert or die or perhaps live to be a slave or be lucky enough to be able to pay the jizya.
The Myth of The Andalusian Paradise; Muslims, Christians and Jews under Islamic Rule in Medieval Spain, Dario Fernandez-Morera.
Are you joking year 1066 the muslims kill all the jews in granada@@apatheiaconvivium8002
I’m so glad your back, I’ve been wondering if you were ok
I have been very busy, had other struggles and was sick. I'm better now. Thank you!
Nick Parker
I know exactly what you mean. I get anxious when I don't see or hear from ex-muslims for a while too. Especially people that speak out forcefully like Anni Cyrus
I think you should also open a channel in Turkish because there is a revival of Islam in Turkey and not all Turkish people know a lot about islam like arabs do, also not to mention most of them don't speak English because bana ne Ingilizler Türkçeyi öğrensin 😂
Greetings from a Syrian ex-muslim who study in Turkey 😅👋
The Vegan middle eastern Sounds like an awesome idea
Just be careful, don’t get arrested
@@propergander8509 I am openly ex-muslim and it is legal in Turkey because it's still a secular country to certain extent and I'm done with pretending to be a muslim.
Thank you for ur interest :)
@@newstart1983
Yes having peace of mind is so much better than pretending and living a false life...so many do not have the luxury of living a life true to their beliefs......and ur a vegan tooo 👍👍👍
I'm thinking of it but leaving it to a time with more possibilities and a bigger reach. I'm also still to emotion-charged regarding Turkey. I want to do it in the future.
Thank you and take care of yourself. It's a weird country. :)
@Zack Smith watch this channel's videos and also there is sheikh ismail his chanbel's name is " Don'tConvert2Islsm" he's a Canadian convert to islam then he left it and explains why watch him please to know what islam is then decide.
You're amazing AP. Truly a breath of fresh air. God bless you!
Thank you, Linda. I appreciate it. :)
KHAZAR SLAYER You sure are an excellent EXAMPLE of Muhammad. Well done. So, when was the last time you killed a non Muslim? You should be good at Mo's favorite pastime.
dont bless him with god..
donate some dollaaaa
Excellent as always :)
Those 4 words are my favourite to comment on. It is the height of irony that this is the most oft-quoted phrase because Islam is ALL ABOUT COMPULSION !!!!!..... what you wear, how and when you pray, what you must or must not eat or drink etc etc etc...ad nauseum
Isn't it 'ad nauseam'?
Just stop
Why does everyone hate Islam....
"No compulsion" and "you have your religion and I have mine" ..
both basically mean "mind your own business" or "take a hike"
Muhammad was massively out numbered in "Mecca" and was practising a little :
"do not be friends with unbelievers unless it is to guard yourself against them"
The verse has ZERO spiritual value
And we see Muhammad's true colours after the migration to Medina
and this is the context in which we should see these shitty verses
"No compulsion" applied to Jews whose mothers made a pact with YHWH to raise them Jewish in exchange for them surviving childhood. Muhammad invented the verse to nullify their commitment to YHWH so they could be expected to accept Islam. Take a look at Ibn Kathir tafsir for 2:256.
Can you just clear the misconception in muslim minds that predictions about arrival of a prophet(prophet after jesus) mentioned in holy books isn't about Mohammad because my muslim friends and known ones always say this whenever I talk to them about the corruption in Islam and Mohammad. They give false references so just to prove that any such predictions were for Mohammad,just make a video so that many more like me can prove them wrong and bring them back on track. Love & support from 🇮🇳
I'll come to it soon. :) Thank you!
@@ApostateProphet Just Say a hello to David Wood From my side. I'll go crazy if you'll do so.....cause you guys are like my idols and I have been watching you guys like a crazy chap and advocating popularising your saying amongst people. So please can you just do this much.
Rajesh Kumar Mishra arent you supposed to be worshiping a cow man?
Shukria O you bloody ruscal hypocrite rice bag converted
@@shukria485 Cow, man? Cow man?
People like you should advice western governments. Your a top bloke. Much respect from Yorkshire. Keep it up.
@Hishām Mālik He can just think for him self.
I think you have the best youtube channel. You are Super informative, absolutely needed in combating this Islamic ideology of death.
I found you trough some comments of other youtubers praising you, they were right.
Oh, by the way, I think you have way more subscribers than what the youtube count shows.
RUclips is doing some veiled censorship.
Thank you! I don't know what RUclips's problem is. I suspect rather a technical issue that RUclips doesn't bother enough to fix.
you are welcome. Get well soon!
Shoib get a RUclips channel Islam has bad things admit it . More than Christians I believe
@@shoaibfarooq1587 You are the fake one here. That's the problem with most muslims. They always counteract the truth even when they know it's the fact. It's all in your hadith and quran. The fact can also be witnessed all over the world. Admit the prevalent fact and stop the illogical rebut.
I always thought that Allah was just another name for God. I'm so glad I found this channel. Learning so much from you. Please keep up the great job you are doing.
Allah is another word for the English capital-g "God". Arab Christians also call him that.
Abrahamic religions are derived from violent ideologies. Look at the Book of Joshua and Judges and the Quran.
Thank you for sharing. Hope you recover fully from sickness. Looking forward to tomorrow’s program with D Wood
This reminds me of yesterday: preacher said, "There's no compulsion in Islam," three minutes of further elucidation of the topic proceed, and he got off-topic because of a series of deliberately asked questions by one of my friends and I (we're both ex-muslims) and preached about the 'history and greatness' of Islam and how we, as Muslims (I recall closing my eyes and smiling after he said that), have to be proud of our religion and how it spread and I quote, "They have worked so hard to eliminate the filth of the pagans and non-believers, and they spread the religion to all parts of Mecca. Allah, with all his greatness and forgiveness (ha! I could barely hold in my laugh at that point), gave the pagans a chance to convert to Islam despite their persistence, but they didn't go along and so he ordered to kill them. Oh! How wise. (Ironic)."
Another case when he was explaining how Abu Baker (Mohammed's best homie) dealt with all the people who left Islam after the death of the prophet by killing them if they didn't reconvert.
Very contradictory if you ask me. I wonder if Mohammed perhaps had a change of heart after he gained power. Nah, that can't be it
I have heard of people converting and being killed anyway.
You are truly a blessing to humanity you don't know the impact and value of what you're doing
Apostate Prophet, serious truths! Love and Peace!
@Karim Temri Like the judaism in part, and christianity in a larger way, it was borrowed/copied from, a truly horrible, egomaniacal death cult. And the god of all three isn't worth fearing or worshipping. The prophets of that little volcano god would be condemned as war criminals by today's less primitive peoples. All the 'holy books', more like wholly fables, had everything wrong. Dates, places, biology and cosmology. Literally everything. All revelations were just convenient for the 'prophets', or the priesthood to gain and maintain their power over those they ruled. If you actually read the ancient texts, you realize it was conceived by humans because of the errors, contradictions and stupidity of the god. All powerful, yet couldn't defeat iron chariots? All knowing, yet couldn't forsee anything. And if so, then couldn't have.free will as his future is set. And all loving or merciful yet just? A loving and just god would never send anyone to eternal punishment. Ever! Love and Peace
once you get in you cant get out (alive). just like mafia.
"There is no compulsion in religion", is islam dictating to others. But that is not what is meant. It means, “you don't ask a slave to work”. If lesser people look like they are not serving the Umah (mzlm men and only mzlm men) willingly, giving Jizya with a smile, etc. then they get one of allah’s curses (exile, mutilation and death). A fundamental principle to izlm is not found in written form. To get a full understanding you have to look at how they behave (rape, pillage, parasitism). Listening to them incessantly cite the quran and hadiths is a massive red herring. The real 3 pillars of izlm are, quran, hadiths and silence (see wiki for Kitman and taqqia doctrine).
I've seen a few of your videos now, they're brilliant. You got a new sub.
Thank you for all your effort AP. Love your work!
Relatively new sub here. Been watching david wood for years now. I love your channel!! You are very intelligent, and we need to learn from people like you!
Just shared this! Great work!!🙏🇬🇧💒
Excellent initiative to include all the online references to the verses you quote. Really helps to get educated. Keep up the good work bro!
Female genital mutilation (FGM) महिला जननांग कर्तन स्त्रियों का खतना ruclips.net/video/dMSCTeTFf84/видео.html
Is Mecca the birthplace of Islam ??(Part 1) क्या मक्का इस्लाम का जन्मस्थान है ?? ruclips.net/video/e2x44K2FXH0/видео.html
Salam bro! Another great video of yours! Keep doing your great job! Might the power of humanity always protect you! ;-)
Is it just me, or are your videos getting better each time you make one? Well put together, well presented and thoroughly engaging!
"Islam does not have forceful conversions"
"Tell that to 400M Indians living in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh who's ancestors were forcefully converted but who thinks that they were 'reverted' muslims and their ancestors were forced and faced atrocities everyday before conversion"
I'm sorry you were sick, but I'm glad to hear that you've recovered.
Excellent information. Thank you 😊
Thank you for enlightening us on the verses of Islam and also the various scholars who interpret the verses, there by laying to rest doubts that may arise from some of the viewers.
Get well soon AP! Praying for your healing in Christ's name! And yes, you have fans in Africa. Kenya to be exact. 😊
A lovely and detailed example of Islam's superiority complex is found in the foul Pact of Umar.
And, AP, I'm glad you're on the road to recovery; your videos are addictive.
They say that these all quranic verses against non muslim are revealed in battle ground is this right?
Not entirely. 9:5 was revealed during a time of uncertainty about relations between Muslims and polytheists, but it doesn't even make a difference. All Islamic scholars agreed that it is a general statement.
9:29 wasn't in reference to a specific battle at all, but it appeared when a possible battle with Christians was talked about. Again, the verse is a clear and general order, so it would be irrelevant even if it had been "revealed" during war time.
Apostate Prophet , love you man, loved your work. love from india
Let's not forget, Islam is in a permanent state of war, so anything goes.
@Akon Ali lmao fuck off pedophile worshipper
So much respect for you my brother. You have balls of steel. Keep speaking the truth
Your hair is always on point.
You the ultimate prophet 😁🤚🏻
KHAZAR SLAYER: wow...im seing soo many peaceful wrds frm a rapist here..
oh sorry what can v xpect frm a guy who considers a RAPIST (Allah) as his God right?
When the voiceless speak, many scream 'blasphemy'....
hey.....nee2....is evrything ok???
Female genital mutilation (FGM) महिला जननांग कर्तन स्त्रियों का खतना ruclips.net/video/dMSCTeTFf84/видео.html
Is Mecca the birthplace of Islam ??(Part 1) क्या मक्का इस्लाम का जन्मस्थान है ?? ruclips.net/video/e2x44K2FXH0/видео.html
Zack Smith So you were born free and then chose to become a slave? Natural selection at work
Hello AP. Was Jizyah still required in countries where Jews lived just before the establishment of Israel by the United Nations?
Yes, right up until the Jews liberated Israel from Islamic rule, non-believers had to pay the jizyah and suffer under Jim Crowe style oppression. Brigitte Gabriel has an excellent lecture on this topic. Look for her lecture titled: "1400 years of Islamic history in 5 minutes".
Great to see you back! I hope you feel better soon.
No wonder. I use to watch your videos everyday . God bless you brother. Keep going.
I
Steal
Lie
And
Murder
Islam clearly states what are it's intentions. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us.
Yes but liberals in the west don’t believe them?
Nice background.Get well soon,sir. What is your name,by the way ?
Hallo, could you do a serie about all the people who mohammed murded oder the conquest he did. Because it is difficult for me when i talk with muslims. I want to show them concret people killing or conquest from Mohammed. by the way i am from Germany !!!
I appreciate your commitment to save humanity from Islam 🙏🏻🙏🏻
You made me confuse. I read quran without understanding it thank you mate ✌️ for making me understand in depth
I’m new here but I appreciate your intellectual insight on this topic so that I may better formulate an argument when dealing with others thank you
Keep going!!!
Thanks for this ongoing series. The world needs your voice explaining what Islam really is, and you do an excellent job.
God bless you brother and thank you for the tools we need to fight the enemy!
Love it! Thank you for your work and I also enjoy your humor! Islam is an unkind and barbaric thing, not a religion, that’s for sure! You’ve always done an awesome job explaining Islam, thank you!
And they say Jews and Christians lived with them in peace. They had a different status and were subjugated and humiliated. Not anybody’s idea of peace.
Thank you for your service to God. You are keeping your aunt’s spirit alive in everything youre doing.
Suggestion: make a video on triple talak and halal(most non-sensical concept of Islam. Tell us more like why do the men have beard only in that particular pattern?, Why the "compulsory" circumcision of penis?,etc.
let's not forget FGM!
Female genital mutilation (FGM) महिला जननांग कर्तन स्त्रियों का खतना ruclips.net/video/dMSCTeTFf84/видео.html
Is Mecca the birthplace of Islam ??(Part 1) क्या मक्का इस्लाम का जन्मस्थान है ?? ruclips.net/video/e2x44K2FXH0/видео.html
Another fantastic and informative video. Get well soon brother! :)
This is kind of weird but I just clicked on your German Channel link. Now I speak German like a 4th grader since I learned it from my Opa and didn't get an opportunity to speak with anyone else besides him. He last set foot in Germany in 1944 and died in 2005. So my vocabulary kind of sucks and I have troubles understanding most Germans. However, I seem to understand your German completely. Just the way you speak I guess. Just thought I'd throw that out there.
If Sharia forbids criticizing Islam, then I think that says it all.
You are a real Prophet not that peodo mo ham mad
Your stupidity is very bright, please worship your laptop or smartphone.
Kind sir, please watch your mouth for those kinds of words. Anyone can see this comment and they may not be someone who will willingly nod and go on with it. I'm not saying an insult just a warning. Their are types of radical islams who would not hesitate to track you and kill you in the name of god. do please be careful.
It is just a warning, do please don't mind of my very long comment. Have a gracious day
@@anomitymask4853 that's exactly what they want to achieve, for people to fear them and silenced everyone, not me, I can only die once, if it is to set you and coming generations free, it worth it. That's what Jesus did for mankind
Great work. Subscribed.
Great information...🙏🏽
I have watched 90% of your videos and very much impressed.
Thank you for continuing to tell the FACTS about Islam...I say fact over truth cause what's true to me can be called a lie by another. You're one of bravest people on RUclips please don't stop...thanks again for your work
Great video, AP! ……. Thank you! :)
always amazed to see you...thnx for your effort
May the all-powerful Buddhist God Kuan Yin bless you for the great work you are doing on behalf of all of humanity....
Thank you, Apostate Prophet, for yet another strong episode.
You know, there is a way that "There is no compulsion in religion" is true regardless of whether Islam or any other religion uses force to make people conform to religious law and practice, and that is in the realm of spiritual *belief*. To be truly religious is to truly believe. You can't force that. You can force outward conformity, but if a person is going through the motions but inwardly cursing the religion and the bastards who are forcing him into a fake way (for him) of life just to survive, you can't say that he's a believer. You can't force a mind, hence you can't compel religion - not genuine religious belief.
Clearly neither Muhammad nor those Muslims who carried on after him had a problem with forcing conformity to Islamic rule, and they had to know that many would eventually convert in order to escape the extra burdens of the dhimmi system or, in the case of non-People of the Book, to avoid death. In that sense there is definitely compulsion in Islam because those kinds of conversions happen not out of real belief but out of a desire to keep alive or because a dhimmi can no longer bear the harsh rules of survival under Islamic rule. But those conversions can never be true conversions in the spiritual sense.
Could it be that "There is no compulsion in religion" was meant as an *observation* of the nature of belief, as above, rather than as a directive?
I LOVE your channel
Keep doing A good job
Hello mate would you be able to make a video on Ma'alim fi al-Tariq by Sayyid Qutb? I've heard Maajid Nawaz mentioning it as a pivotal work on modern jihadism.
I weep for the freedom of my planet every time i discover as of this early occasion of its outstanding experiment that corruption continues to be imputed to many members of the House of Representatives, while the civil rights of the people have been bartered for promises of office.
You never disappoint me Apostate Prophet when it comes to your videos. You always get right straight to the point when it comes to Islam. So thanks for your insightful videos they help give me a better understanding of what being a Muslim is like and when they follow Islam and Mohammed's teachings. Cheers! 😊👍🇨🇦 🇺🇸 🍻
Your series of videos needs to have translations in all the important languages, including Arabic, Urdu, Farsi, Bengali, Malay, Turkish, etc.
Schön, dass du endlich auch deutsche Videos machst. Ich freue mich darauf!!
The word 'Mafia' is of Arabic origin.
Your courage is admirable
Keep well. Sending you healing energies
Excellent show as usual. Thanks
Get well soon!!
And as allways.. thank you sooo very much for sharing your knowledge
This is a brave man,and could be murdered at any time. Christ protect him and open his eyes to the truth!
Moin Apostate Prophet,
hast du schonmal mit dem Gedanken gespielt deinen Videos deutsche oder türkische Untertitel hinzuzufügen?
But wait cause im confused can you please address this issue please --> Many will say those later verses are in the context of war so they don't actually mean to kill the disbelievers, its just during war when that was being said
Seems Western European Governments chose #2 and accepted dhimmi status on behalf of their people and pay the jizyah in the form of welfare benefits, free access to their daughters and preferential treatment under the law.
Sad but true.
No
@@ofimportance5458 No what?
3:33
The Naughty Prophet, is that you 😏
What does that mean? Jizya, I know, but why it is naughty?
optimus Transformer
Because it resembles the english slang term „jizz“ soundwise, which means … you know what I mean …
There's no jiz, like jizyah! The English slang term comes from the jizyah ( to deliver the "load"). The Jew got the yellow star and the dhimmi got the blue belt, after they paid jizyah. Arar Akhbar!
I love ur bluntness and attitude. Carry on
"Jiziya" it always feels so dirty saying this word and reminds me smell of … never mind 😂🙃🤣