Godox AD200 Alternatives Neewer Q200 Geekoto GT200 Neewer Q3 off camera flash photography review

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии •

  • @daveinportland
    @daveinportland 11 дней назад +7

    Dispensing knowledge like a rapid fire PEZ dispenser. Thank you sir.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +3

      pew pew pew

    • @_HMCB_
      @_HMCB_ 11 дней назад +1

      😂

    • @elram2649
      @elram2649 9 дней назад +1

      This made me smile! 😊

  • @aeonsnarfus
    @aeonsnarfus 2 дня назад +1

    Team Godox for one X3 to rule them all. AD600 + AD200

  • @captainbear6188
    @captainbear6188 11 дней назад +7

    I love the energy and enthusiasm Markus has; every video is entertaining while being educational.

  • @wilfri14
    @wilfri14 11 дней назад +6

    I just got the new ad200 pro 2 and now I'm watching all you tutorials videos about the speed light, thanks dude you're the man

  • @Prismavision_tech_outpost
    @Prismavision_tech_outpost 2 дня назад

    Thanks, Markus for making such a good content in every video you make including the quality! It sticks out! I always like your enthusiast and energy. I just gave you a series of thumbs-up for the last seven videos.😅
    Greetings from Sweden !🎉

  • @ciarakelleyphotography
    @ciarakelleyphotography 11 дней назад +3

    Markus I love you. I have the gvm 200w (rebranded geekoto) and I just tried it with my nano godox trigger and it worked! I haven't been using that flash because I hated the trigger it came with. You're a lifesaver.

  • @cinhudson1
    @cinhudson1 6 дней назад

    Dude! I love it when you do these videos! I learn so much. Thanks!

  • @markintosh13
    @markintosh13 11 дней назад +1

    Love the quantum connector - but also like the Godox mount on the AD300. So I combined the two, so now I can mount Godox mount softboxes like the AD-S65 and 85 on my AD200 and AD360 strobes

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      You don't even need an adapter like that with these ruclips.net/video/WeFt5FkWXfU/видео.html

  • @kenrickhadley4499
    @kenrickhadley4499 11 дней назад

    Markus, you are having to much fun. The good thing is that we learn about lights and photography for every budget. I love that you don't say, chase the latest and sometimes not so greatest. Thanks.

  • @genejoanen
    @genejoanen 11 дней назад +1

    Can't have too many! Choices are great. Q200 is tempting.

  • @Elmalevoasesor
    @Elmalevoasesor 11 дней назад +4

    First comment, spectacular content as always ❤

  • @wolfgangk1
    @wolfgangk1 11 дней назад +3

    Thanks Markus...

  • @Hennequing
    @Hennequing 11 дней назад +1

    Awesome nugget of information as always!

  • @sergiooliveira4351
    @sergiooliveira4351 10 дней назад

    The problem is radio triggers systems! Great videos, great channel!!!

  • @ChargedPulsar
    @ChargedPulsar 11 дней назад +1

    This video adresses just what i was looking for, thank you!

  • @NeilHadynNicholson
    @NeilHadynNicholson 11 дней назад +1

    The Godox also has a round head attachment that makes beautiful light as well.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      The AD200 round head H200R is actually dimmer than an AD100! I tested it in another video. Might as well use a smaller lighter AD100 in that case. And remember, the reason I like the Q200 is the colors are better than the AD200

  • @desmondmasikhwa1700
    @desmondmasikhwa1700 10 дней назад

    I actually bought a Visico2/Neewer Vision 2. It's basically an AD200 that already comes with a removable magnetic round head (So Godox round head accessories work perfectly). And it's cheaper than even an AD100pro. It was so good, I went back and picked up another one. When you remove the round head, the bulb is exposed for optimal effectiveness with softboxes.

  • @georgehenry3384
    @georgehenry3384 11 дней назад +1

    Thanks Markus! Awesome tips!!!

  • @aleksandrtroshin2238
    @aleksandrtroshin2238 11 дней назад

    Your videos are the best training videos about travel+family photo. Markus, did you think about to share your experience about photo composition for travel portraits? You already have at least three, where you traveled to Europe and then to a mountain, then to a nice island. You showed position of flash stands and effect of reflectors and soft boxes. Those was great lessons for me and I repeat it with good success. However I am still bad in photo composition. I do read some literature and it helps. Would be great if you shared your experience with photo compositions too, becase your explanations are so easy to understand and also very practical. And most of all you have a lot of experience in outdoor portrait photography, which others don't have.

  • @lawrencescofield7575
    @lawrencescofield7575 11 дней назад

    Could use one of the ad200 with the softboxes and new adapter..Great video thank you Markus

  • @nmelcam1
    @nmelcam1 11 дней назад

    Hi Mark, the Yongnuo YN200 also has the same {Quantum} adapter as the Godox, but it does not have an interchangeable head. Years ago I was deciding between them but eventually went with Godox because of the compatibility with almost all the Godox line of strobes 🙂

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      Good choice. They stopped making the YN200 and it has a more bluish color anyway

  • @dominicwroblewski5832
    @dominicwroblewski5832 11 дней назад +1

    The front of the Q200 looks to be the same size as some of the older budget studio strobes that can use what is called a "universal" mount. You can get barn doors and gel holders for it at a very low cost.

  • @earlekimel7771
    @earlekimel7771 11 дней назад

    Thanks! It answers some of my questions on the Neewer Q200.

  • @AndrewDaughtry
    @AndrewDaughtry 11 дней назад

    Great review. Markus. At first I wondered why you didn't mention the Yongnuo YN200 in your review until I checked its current price on Amazon, almost $500 bucks is outrageous

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +2

      They don't make those anymore. Plus they run a bit blue

    • @AndrewDaughtry
      @AndrewDaughtry 11 дней назад

      @MarkusPix I still have one and managed to find a replacement battery about a year ago on Alibaba. Still, I like it because it is a bare bulb only with that same mount as the AD200.

  • @Elvis_Pond5
    @Elvis_Pond5 11 дней назад +2

    YOU LIGHT 🕯️ UP MY LIFE
    LYRICS 🎵🎶
    So many nights I'd sit by my window Waiting for someone to sing me his song So many dreams I kept deep inside me Alone in the dark but now you've come along [Chorus] And you light up my life You give me hope to carry on You light up my days and fill my nights with song Rollin' at sea, adrift on the water Could it be finally I'm turnin' for home? Finally a chance to say "Hey, I love you" Never again to be all alone [Chorus] 'cause you, you light up my life You give me hope to carry on You light up my days and fill my nights with song It can't be wrong When it feels so right 'cause you? you light up my life

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      Uh oh, Elvis is getting lonely and desperate 😅

    • @Elvis_Pond5
      @Elvis_Pond5 11 дней назад +2

      @MarkusPix just thinking about a good song for one of your short lighting videos

  • @benoittissier58
    @benoittissier58 11 дней назад +1

    Perfect timing ! I'm looking for a strobe for sports. I plan to use it in HSS and I'm wondering if the AD200 could produce small bursts (3 pics at 6 FPS) and at what power. Any hint ?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +2

      The Godox AD200 can perform High-Speed Sync (HSS) and is capable of firing in burst modes. However, its ability to maintain consistent output over multiple frames at 6 frames per second (FPS) depends on several factors:
      Power Setting: Lower power settings allow for faster recycle times. At reduced power levels, the AD200 can keep up with higher FPS rates.
      Battery Charge: A fully charged battery ensures optimal performance and faster recycling.
      Ambient Temperature: Extreme temperatures can affect battery efficiency and recycle times.
      Assuming the sports are outdoors in bright sunlight, you'd need full power, where the recycle time is approximately 1.8 seconds, making it unsuitable for high-speed continuous shooting. You'd need a more powerful flash like a 600

  • @Jim32167
    @Jim32167 9 дней назад

    Hi Markus, great comparison! Have you looked into Geekoto GT250?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  9 дней назад

      yes, I'll show it in an upcoming video comparing other Geekoto flashes

  • @Premier-Media-Group
    @Premier-Media-Group 11 дней назад

    perfect timing for me...thank you!

  • @herlambangtanosefren2350
    @herlambangtanosefren2350 10 дней назад

    Great info

  • @RMD2U
    @RMD2U 10 дней назад

    I would love to know how the AD200 Roundhead (maybe the AD100 also), compares to the Q200's color quality specifically. Both have diffused glass.
    Thanks to your previous video we know the AD100 is brighter because of the zoom functionality.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  10 дней назад

      The round head for the AD200 i dimmer than the AD100! and the color isn't that great. I gave mine away.

  • @PapaBruno
    @PapaBruno 11 дней назад +1

    3:25 That rubbery texture in several years: 🫠

  • @bn5fg
    @bn5fg 11 дней назад +2

    Hello, Markus! Please hear me out: I think you can push the AD200 even harder into this new SMDV adapter! The rubber might tear a bit, but you'll get better light! As for the Neewer Q200, I think you can replace it with the H200R head for the AD200. It has the same frosted, non-Fresnel design with nice illumination, plus the H200R includes notches for attaching the AK-R21 projector or silicone diffusers.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +3

      The AD200 round head H200R is actually dimmer than an AD100! I tested it in another video. Might as well use a smaller lighter AD100 in that case. And remember, the reason I like the Q200 is the colors are better than the AD200

    • @bn5fg
      @bn5fg 11 дней назад +1

      ​@@MarkusPix I generally agree-I mostly use the AD100 when I need a round head, probably about 95% of the time. On the other hand, the H200R is still very useful for gobo projection (like the AK-R21), snoots, and other hard-light, artistic effects. Its heavy frost diffuser and large reflector/lamp provide very even illumination(compared to AD100 which fails to fully illuminate it's head), and the center-axis LED is fantastic for pre-visualizing projections compared to the AD100, which has a weaker, off-centered LED. This flexibility is a major advantage of the AD200: you can switch from a barebulb head to an 'artistic' head in about 10 seconds. Also, the H200R actually produces a bit more light-about 0.3 stops more, even with the frost, I'd estimate-but the AD100 tends to perform better in unmodified tests due to its stronger hotspot and Fresnel focusing ability. In modifiers, they’re likely comparable, but as I mentioned, most of the time, the H200R just isn’t worth the extra weight.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +2

      If you aim the AHD200 at someone and take a meterreading, it's considerably less light than if you aim an AD100 at someone and take a meter reading. I showed this in another video.

    • @bn5fg
      @bn5fg 11 дней назад

      ​@@MarkusPix the AD100 will lose to a cheap TT685ii at maximum zoom in this kind of test. Doesn’t make the TT685 a better light, I guess.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  9 дней назад

      Lol sounds like you really want to not like the AD100, did someone throw one at you in a bar fight or something? 😆 Sorry but a TT685ii couldn't even be half a bright. Remember the AD100 has zoom also 😜

  • @_HMCB_
    @_HMCB_ 11 дней назад

    This video is so awesome. 🤌🏽 the AD200 just seems to tick off so many checkboxes in one product. It was and continues to be what other manufacturers wish they’d designed. I need to buy a few.

  • @babyscreams6343
    @babyscreams6343 11 дней назад

    Markuspix: making Sundays better. Markus’ videos might not be FDA-approved, but only because they have not run clinical trials - I’m pretty sure he is an effective anti-depressant.

  • @harambesminion9266
    @harambesminion9266 11 дней назад

    Woot woot! AD200’s have gone down to $199.99 on sale on Amazon btw. I know yall don’t need the AD200 Pro and Pro II but I personally upgraded to the Pro II bcuz I don’t have a bunch of flashes already. Still growing my flash/strobe collection. Loving the Pro II bcuz of the modeling lamp upgrades. Sucks I can’t use the modeling lamp with the bulb reflector dish with the Pro II still does the job regardless!

    • @RandomUnknownFact
      @RandomUnknownFact 11 дней назад

      Where are you seeing them for $200 when i look they still are $299 on Amazon

  • @kennethnielsen3864
    @kennethnielsen3864 11 дней назад

    Thanks for sharing.

  • @summitphotoandfilm
    @summitphotoandfilm 10 дней назад

    Love your videos. I just did a test at home based on what I see in your videos. I tested the Godox v1 pro, ad300, and ad600 all on their highest outputs. My results were that the v1 and ad300 had the same output, and the ad600 was not much better (less than 1 stop). Hoping that you could help clarify why this is happening, because honestly it seems like the ad600 (or the ad300) is not worth having and that maybe I should try Neewer or something else. Have you experienced similar results?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  10 дней назад

      The 300 is dim but the 600 is definitely powerful. Make sure HSS is off and you are using a good reflector (not just a bare bulb) ruclips.net/video/o8bdbLW2gAs/видео.html

  • @chiokehart-kelly3481
    @chiokehart-kelly3481 11 дней назад

    Thank you

  • @petervives7033
    @petervives7033 11 дней назад

    Thanks for the info very useful!! Quick question, will the Neewer Q200 mount on a Angler 24" Fastbox, like my AD 100?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      It will fit but it's actually a bit smaller so it's kinda loose in there so you'd have to wrap some rubber tape around the head or something for a snug fit.

    • @petervives7033
      @petervives7033 10 дней назад

      @@MarkusPix Thanks for your reply! Debating if I want to invest in this light, would like to use the modifiers I have on hand. Thanks for all your videos, instructional and reviews, great info, great teacher. Pete

  • @eternaleden3014
    @eternaleden3014 11 дней назад

    Geekoto!!! Hai!

  • @akhyarrayhka4048
    @akhyarrayhka4048 11 дней назад

    nice alternative

  • @nicksmall428
    @nicksmall428 11 дней назад +4

    Subscribed not that long ago...love your straight to point, logical and not over the top technology explainations unlike some channels. Whats best though is your passion for it all 👍

  • @gicknardner
    @gicknardner 11 дней назад

    I have the Q3 to double as a portable flash and a fill light. I cannot compare it to any of these others but I have been disappointed with how quickly it overheats. Even with no modifiers on it and set to a low output like 1/16 or 1/32, if you are shooting somewhat quickly in a studio setting it overheats and at that point it is pretty much done. It takes like 30 to 60 minutes to cool down, otherwise you have to wait like 20 seconds between shots.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      That's my least favorite one of the bunch

  • @coleargue7194
    @coleargue7194 11 дней назад

    Thanks for this. I just got my q200. Will it work in the flip softbox? Is the outside diameter the same as the ad100?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      Great question! It will fit, but the diameter is actually a bit SMALLER than an AD100, so you'd have to wrap some rubber tape around the head to make it a bit wider and fit snugly.

    • @coleargue7194
      @coleargue7194 11 дней назад

      @@MarkusPix Thank you sir!

  • @MileyonDisney
    @MileyonDisney 11 дней назад +4

    Thanks for another helpful video, Markus (and Cara - we know you're behind the camera, though we prefer you in front of it - woo-hoo!). Seriously - Cara could be on the cover of FIT magazine. Markus could do Surf World, or whatever magazine surfer dudes read. When I first saw you, I thought maybe your parents were Hollywood lawyers, and you just spent your time at the ocean - 20-something surfer dude. Sorry I was so wrong. I'll say it again - people really should watch your amazing "Who Am I" video. WOW!

  • @davidbrophy3521
    @davidbrophy3521 10 дней назад

    What are the Neewer Triggers and receivers like? Are they reliable?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  10 дней назад

      yes, just like Godox triggers. Receivers are built into the flashes

  • @JerryWoo96
    @JerryWoo96 11 дней назад +1

    There's also the yn200 from yongnuo!

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      Yes but they don't make it anymore and it has a slightly bluish color cast from what I've seen and heard.

    • @marcinmrzyglocki
      @marcinmrzyglocki 11 дней назад

      Bummer, even a brief summary would have been nice, as many products mentioned on the channel are not available as new anyway, moreover, YN200 has the perk of a permanent bulb instead of fresnel.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  9 дней назад +1

      Not sure where you live, but here in USA I can get all 4 of the lights in this video as new. I know because I just did

    • @marcinmrzyglocki
      @marcinmrzyglocki 8 дней назад

      @@MarkusPix not these, I just remember many cases of "this isn't made anymore, but is so cool I have to show it!"

  • @JC-xs4ye
    @JC-xs4ye 9 дней назад

    I think neewer q200 and geekoto gt250 can use ad100 connector for flip softbox - I have used the same magnet modifier for neewer z1 & geekoto gt250

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  9 дней назад +1

      The Q200 fits in the flip, but it's smaller, so you'd have to wrap tape around the head to make it snug.

  • @paristo
    @paristo 7 дней назад

    The S-bracket is great if you have studio or you have place to keep it in-house easily available for your C-stands and such anyways. Good for remote on-site photography as well, where you spend half- or full day in shoot like example business or school photography is about.
    But for travel purposes? No go. That is just not purpose for all Godox fanboys who think S-brackets are great overall. It is just like C-stands vs light stands vs everything else, different purposes.

  • @ThePandaPhotographer
    @ThePandaPhotographer 11 дней назад +2

    Be careful with the neewer Q3 - loves to overheat fast. I made over 8 videos about it and some modifiers
    10:59 Q3 doesn't need an S- bracket. It comes with 1/4 mounting handle that can be mounted on light stands without the S bracket
    11:49 I have video on modifiers here ruclips.net/video/-cuzTKSU7kI/видео.html or ruclips.net/video/Q2xoIcYVscc/видео.html

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      The S-bracket is for mounting softboxes onto the flash

  • @saucelove
    @saucelove 11 дней назад

    Is there white balance control with these lights? I may have missed that on this video. I own the AD100 & 200

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      Nothing you can control on your own (these are flashes, not LED video lights). If you mean color consistency, they are quite consistent.

  • @jiancarloulloaart
    @jiancarloulloaart 11 дней назад +1

    Hola Markus, as always, thank you for compiling the information, testing the gear, and sharing the results.
    I have a couple of Q3s for quite some time and they have been great to me. I even made a more compacted foam box to travel with them and those flashes have been every place I go. I'm glad to know you give a thumbs up to the Q200. I have been thinking to add another light for headshot work and feels like that one will be a good addition.
    Saludos!

  • @jhenry248
    @jhenry248 11 дней назад

    Do you know if the SMDV AD 200/200pro adapter compatible with the Angler Fastbox? Thanks in advance.

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      Fabulous question! Yes it is !!! 👌💃 🎉

  • @geralgeral8109
    @geralgeral8109 8 дней назад

    Works similar Neewer Q3 like a Godox AD200?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  8 дней назад

      Yes but it overheats quickly

  • @TheSunnySuttons
    @TheSunnySuttons 10 дней назад

  • @BoReynolds
    @BoReynolds 11 дней назад

    Is there a big difference between the AD200 and the Pro? Probably a dumb question but I found a Pro on Marketplace for $200

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      not much. the readout's a little brighter (not much) and I think it has more flash levels (it already had enough for me)

    • @marcinmrzyglocki
      @marcinmrzyglocki 11 дней назад

      It has supposedly also more stable white balance - less variation between consecutive shots. Hard to be noticed outside high level product work.

  • @GVNKyo
    @GVNKyo 11 дней назад

    Can Neewer Q200 be triggered with Godox X2T ?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      No, it requires a Neewer trigger. The Gekkoto Q200 can be triggered with a Godox Xpro trigger.

  • @drgolfjim
    @drgolfjim 11 дней назад

    Are you giving away any lights?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      Yes soon for the holiday giveaway

  • @WAPhoto
    @WAPhoto 11 дней назад

    Westcott FJ200?

  • @krzpob
    @krzpob 11 дней назад

    For godox you can buy round head

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад

      The AD200 round head H200R is actually dimmer than an AD100! I tested it in another video. Might as well use a smaller lighter AD100 in that case. And remember, the reason I like the Q200 is the colors are better than the AD200

  • @phuong.tography
    @phuong.tography 11 дней назад

    So helpful ❤❤ thank you Markus

  • @TerryWindell
    @TerryWindell 11 дней назад

    Be careful with that "nice rubbery feel" on the Neewer Q3 over a couple of years that coating degrades into sticky, slimy goo. It's the same stuff GoPro used to use.

  • @ared18t
    @ared18t 11 дней назад

    Me Hearing Markus Trash talk my S2 brackets
    😢

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  11 дней назад +1

      Lol, they work great and it's not an issue if you don't have to hike with them for miles 🏃

  • @ggeimer
    @ggeimer 11 дней назад

    that rubbery texture turns into sticky-buttons gooey tar in ten years.

  • @averageguy1261
    @averageguy1261 10 дней назад

    Neewer Q3 for $50, is it legit?

    • @MarkusPix
      @MarkusPix  9 дней назад +1

      Might be. The Q3 is the worst of the bunch. People are saying it overheats and the rubber becomes gooey after a few years

  • @rhalfik
    @rhalfik 11 дней назад

    Neewer isn't exactly known for longevity...