Help share this video around either on social media or with contacts you know who can promote it further. Bob, Alex, and I put a lot of time and effort into this project and we would love it if our work played a role in making sure the 150th anniversary of the disaster is not forgotten. Thank you!
Excellent content, really interesting and informative! And also, it is really nice to listen to a documentary with subtle music playing in the background. I I find documentaries, almost unlistenable and unwatchable when they have music that is so loud that it distracts from the actual narration……yours is the perfect volume.
It’s crazy how just a handful of people and sometimes one person can make better documentaries than large companies ever could dream of. All of your work is excellent and only getting better.
I dont mean to take away from their heroism, but this is often the case for people who live near the sea. It is done, because they know how much the sea can take, and if all seamen did it, they themselves would be extended the same heroism. It is putting your hope in one another.
And most seamen do this. They are forced to by law, but usually they do it because they know the same will be done for their sons and nephews and fathers. I have grown up near the North sea, and every village has at least one monument remembering the dead. Often there would be so many sunk boats, they would have no choice but to make one big monument. But you would see a pattern jn it. For some crewmen their death date was the same, and the crewmen of each boat their family name was also often the same. As a kid this left a big impression on me. I would look at my dad and would fsll silent knowing that that was also the same thing a lot of sons did when their lives were lost. Maybe the last thing.
@@amethyst1826 that would of been a problem, but then lying to the captain instead of just outright telling him he wasn’t being truthful about the amount left. The captain might of been using to much coal but the tragedy was entirely the effect of the other guys actions
Not to mention Metcalf's hubris in dismissing the caution about coming in too fast and too close to the dangerous parts of Halifax. I wonder what went through the men's minds during the destruction; one who realized he should have listened, and the other knowing they never needed to be there in the first place.
The fact that they rescued 400 people from that apparently hopeless situation is an incredible testament to the skill, bravery and determination of those islanders.
I'm 53 years old, born & raised in Nova Scotia, less then 3 hours away & I never heard of this accident until now. Never taught to us in school. Thanks for this video. Great job.
@@macysondheim It's not his responsibility. I live near Belfast and I don't expect everyone in Northern Ireland to know every single detail about Titanic, a tragedy that happened after this one in the video. Not to mention the fact he's watching this video contradicts your whole statement.
As a Nova Scotian, it's difficult to believe anyone survived that night. The currents and riptides carry people off the slick granite to their doom every year. To be that close to the shore, a false hope, must have caused so many deaths.
I feel like the captain was dealing with a terrible crew. He was being lied about the amount of coal up to the point that someone thought unnecessarily diverting the ship from its course was preferable to recognizing their deceit. He was also not woken up when he requested it. A captain is still one person and he couldn't do everything, he depended on his crew.
Poor Rosa, she just gave birth to her newborn child only to lose her over the edge to the sea. And then to be separated from her husband and left in the rigging, tied down, watching in horror and despair as the ship sunk deeper and deeper. RIP to her and everyone lost that night.
I know, I was thinking, I think she nearly lost the will to fight after that baby was swept away. I can’t even imagine the pain she must have felt while up in that mast.
It's not the first documentary I listen to about the SS Atlantic, however it has to be the most detailed and compassionate one. I feel so sad for the lost persons, people like Rosa who likely went through the pains of childbirth and being a new mother, to losing everything in a single hour, even her life. The rescuers were outstanding people as well, and the efforts they pulled while not having much themselves is a great example of humanity.
I live in Halifax, and the number of graves we have from well known ship wrecks always somehow surprises the tourists. The Atlantic is a treacherous ocean at the best of times, and we're often the closest port. This is fantastically done - thank you for all of your hard work and research.
I thought women had blubber like seals, allowing them to live longer in cold water than men. Or is this just modern women who get fat on processes foods? In this case the women were in a disadvantageous location on the ship, but I think the survival results would have been different if women had superior cold water capabilities as do seals. Though I remember modern stories of sinkings and boat capsizes where only the women survived. And I know my sisters and nieces enjoy far colder water than I can.
Just happened to come across this last night and I'm watching again. So sad but so interesting... I'd love to see a doc about the descendents of survivors, if any, stayed in the area..
In 1851 my great-grandfather (then 12 years old), his sister, and their mom and dad made the voyage from County Donegal, Ireland, to New York City, fleeing the famine and turmoil in their homeland. They undoubtedly traveled in steerage, and documentaries like this help me to visualize just a bit of what they must have experienced during the long crossing. I enjoy your dignified and unsensational videos packed with history. Thank you!
It was a slow genocide over a number of years. Perpetuated by the Crown and the Merchant/Mercantile class. Essentially parasites in my opinion. Also following Malthusian dogma too. Look it up.
The compassion of these people in the tiny island settlements for the the stranded survivors of this terrible tragedy is enough to bring one to tears. They had so little to spare, yet they gave all they could to them.
Not like they had much choice. Those survivors would have just pillaged and stolen from their houses if they didn't open their doors. They did not even get compensated for having all their food storage drained by those men.
@@cocogoat1111That doesn’t change the fact that they *did* willingly open their doors to those people, and that it came from a place of human compassion. They also didn’t *have* to risk their own lives to save the survivors still aboard the ship and on the rock. Not everything needs to be so doom and gloom, especially when related to a tragedy like this. Take the good where you can find it. Why you insist on seeing it from a negative angle, I will never understand.
@@cocogoat1111you're underestimating the good of Canadians. Eastern Canadians like Nova Scotians are some of the most humble and kind people that are about community. I'm proud I am born and raised in Canada and I grew up nowhere near the coast! Good people do what's right if they can. We still have those qualities even if you don't often see it..
It's no choice. They said that the man and his sons were fisherman or some other ocean profession. If someone needs help at sea and you can help, you help. It could be you or your kid one day.
@@imahumanperson361I think it is the good of Christians. All of these people were deeply religious and even if some were Catholic and some Protestant, they were united by their belief in God Almighty. Not only the charity of the locals is amazing, but the international charity that came flowing in from all over. Private charity can do so much in a high trust society of God fearing people. You would not have such open giving in today's world, sadly.
I'm 60 years old. I was born in Liverpool and, in the 1960s, the docks aside the River Mersey were my playground, especially the Princes Landing Stage, the Pier Head, and the Albert and Canning Docks. Even as a young child, I was fascinated by tales of the SS Atlantic. Thank you for this excellent documentary.
@@mdouteymedia tends to show us a very distilled cross section of humanity. I think this is a testament to the fact that despite how the world might look when you read or watch the news, your average fellow human would help you out if they could.
It's pretty typical of maritime towns. These sorts of incidents are very common and they have to perform rescues pretty regularly. Less common now, and more professionalized, but it still happens.
It makes me terribly sad that the man who worked for years to bring a good life to the woman he loves just to lose her in such a horrific way. And to make it worse, he couldn't even be granted a proper sentimental item to remember her by because of the horrible greed of people who looked at the tragedy as profit to be gained.
I didn't know what you meant at first because I read the comments before watching the whole documentary. Now that I watched it all, what that man must have gone through afterward, gnaws on me. It's so tragically sad beyond words. The whole tragedy is the worst I have ever heard. We got to know this husbands story, but there must be so many other men who lost their wives, sisters, daughters and so on, not even one woman lived. So many that lived, I even though they physically survived, their lives ended that day. 😢
Strange that we criticize heavily the young inner city looters who take advantage of a bad situation like a black man bring shot by police. But back in 1873 they were even worse examples.
I'm sure that's something that was with her in her final hours, strapped to the rigging. Death may have felt like a release. I can't even imagine the agony. And her poor husband, watching helplessly from the shore... what a nightmare.
I've never gotten emotional while watching a shipwreck documentary, but the story of William and Annie Glenfield made me ugly cry. I cannot imagine what Willaim felt that night and what he must have felt for the rest of his life. I can only pray that if there is an afterlife, William and Annie have been reunited at last in peace.
Jesus very clearly said "marriage ends at death." Why are so many people calling Jesus a liar? No reuniting in the afterlife. That is fiction & was repeated multiple times. Read Matthew. It is amazing how supposedly religious people simply change the Bible's words.
" My Wife painted that sign" , " I flew to California to fact-check my story". Tell me you have a great passion for this story without telling me you have a great passion for this story? .... God Bless You Brother, you put your heart and soul into this.
Fun fact: Dinner is actually what you call the largest meal of the day, which traditionally was taken in the middle of the day. Supper is what you call the last meal if the day. That is why some older people will still call lunch dinner, and dinner supper.
Yes this used to be the case in Australia too. My grandparents would call lunch "dinner" and what we now call dinner, they called "tea". Older people still say tea but I don't know any younger people who do. "supper" being a snack before bed which we still use. We still call the lunctime feast at Christmas "Christmas dinner". Lunch should be a bigger meal than dinner I think, you don't need all that energy so late in the day but my family and most people I know eat dinner as the biggest meal. Late too, at 7 or 8. I often don't eat dinner at all coz by then I'm too tired to care about food
@@ceasarwright7567 Is that Canadian French? I learned a bit of French as a kid and I remember it being petit-dejuner (breakfast), dejuner (lunch), diner (dinner), and souper (supper, before bed)
@@ceasarwright7567 Awesome that's kinda like how in Australia people used to say breakfast (or brekky)/dinner/tea whereas I think Americans have long said breakfast/lunch/dinner (Australian English has gradually become more and more like American English because we have more American influence than English influence nowadays). Nowadays we say breakfast (or brekky in speech)/lunch/dinner. I went to school with someone from Quebec, he couldn't speak much English when he first arrived but then after a couple of years he sounded almost 100% Australian. Is Quebecoise French as different from Parisian French as American English is from, say, Australian English? I don't speak French but I can kind of hear the difference in accents between Canada and France, Canadian French sounds more relaxed or something. But I can hear the differences in the many Mandarin accents people have from different areas of China very clearly, for example, people native to Beijing sound completely different from people near Shanghai esepcially if they are older (I am referring to Mandarin and not local "dialects" of China - which are actually completely different languages). I really want to go to Canada one day, it seems like a wonderful country. The Canadians I've met have been really easy to get along with, for some reason Canadians and Australians seem to have alot in common even though there aren't many Canadians here.
I made it out to the SS Atlantic museum this summer and I bought Bob's books and he signed both of them. The people there were so friendly and I had a great experience.
What heroes the villagers were. And the survivors who worked tirelessly to save their fellow travellers. Thank you, Mr. Chaulk and Part Timer Explorer for the effort done to remember their heroic deeds.
Boy I really wish Foxley would have just admitted he was underreporting and they were good to head to NY... This is a tragic but fascinating tale! Well done again Tom.
They were cutting it really close, I could see many people making that same call. Remember even if it hadn't all gone to shit they would still have taken a hit to their reputation for having to divert so it's not like that decision was completely in his favor. I thought him not waking the captain was a worse call cause he would have known the danger of not seeing the lighthouse when they were supposed to.
it seems a common denominator in many of these tragedies nearly always ends up being someone who does not take accountability and lies about SOMETHING. metcalf should have awoken his captain as well.
@@christopherboxford9556 In fairness steaming for NA would not have resulted in them slamming into rocks. If they hadn't made it all the way they still at least could have been towed back.
But yes it's true. This was a cumulation of mistakes not just one person is wholly responsible imo. Like in so many distasters there's a lot of contributing factors.
Man I couldn't imagine being on a ship like that in that storm. Forget about the whole sinking part. Just trying to traverse the ship, in the dark, being thrown around from the waves, being seasick, slipping on puke on every floor and level from hundreds of people. What a nightmare that had to have been.
That's how every seaside community responded to wrecks, there's something beautiful about the solidarity among people in maritime communities. From the outer banks life saving stations "we are ordered to row out, whether we return or not"
This was so beautifully done... It literally almost made me tear up several times... The baby washed away, Rosa, Annie... All hit my soul hard. Rest in peace everyone lost.
Once the ship hit rock, I could feel the cold through your excellent writing. This video was so well done-the writing, the clarity of the narrator’s speech, the graphics, music, and script. You warned us it could be terribly sad, and it was, but so appealing for all its moments of humanity. Thank you.
It's like the mountain climbing videos. Just when I swear things couldnt be any more miserable- I remember that it's all happening in the freezing cold.
Bob has to be happy to see a young man like you sharing his documentation of these events in modern ways so new generations will know of these tales and never forget the losses we have suffered for progress.
I really hope you make more visualizations of these old fashioned wrecks. You got me into shipbuilding, ship history, old time history, money exchange rates and global trade patterns. Tons of really cool rabbit holes, just because you were able to close the gap between a boring rusty book, and a nice and understandable visual for the new generation. Thank you good sir!
This is worse than the Titanic because this was such an avoidable, painful, and pointless loss of life. Most infuriating is Metcalf ignoring the 1 sailor on the ship familiar with this area, based on the story I doubt the captain would of been so stupid too.
@StevieSeagalthe Engineer couldn't have foreseen this, and was at the very least doing what he felt was best for the ship. Metcalf, on the other hand, was deliberately insubordinate and dismissive of the dangers. If any one person is to blame, it's him.
No one ever talks about the Wilhelm Gustloff torpedoed in WW2 with a loss of life close to 10,000 people . Think about that number .....that's just unimaginable
@@slinky_malinki5330 Allegedly. It was convenient for the captain that Metcalfe died in the disaster and couldn’t give his own testimony. After all, the captain’s career would have been ruined had he for example told Metcalfe not to wake him until they saw the lighthouse. That small detail about Metcalfe not waking him at 2:40 or 3 AM suddenly redirects all the blame on Metcalfe and all that is remembered is the hero captain organizing the survivors.
I watch a ton of content on RUclips, an unhealthy amount in fact. What you’re doing here is right up at the top with the very best creators out there. This was award worthy stuff. Truly outstanding. Thank you and keep up the wonderful videos!
@ Time To Wake Up. I am with you on that. Been bed bound for the last four months. Constantly watching RUclips, films and series. Good to have it all the same. 👍
@@jerryoconnor-ps8bb i have also been pretty much bedridden (mono, the original covid) for about 2 months now, and looking at least another month of it...... wishing you the best, and i hope you feel better soon. i would say sending "good energy" or whatever but i have no energy to send, hope you understand (haha).. it really sucks being housebound or bedbound, but good long form content like this is truly a life saver.
Unless you have been in a storm on the ocean you can't imagine just how powerful the waves are!!! I went through 2 hurricanes in the Navy and I thought both times that we weren't going to make it!!! The waves threw my ship around like it was nothing!!!
I crossed the atlantic as a kid on a mershantship that my father was the captain of. Antwerpen to New York. We hit the outskirts of a storm midway, and your absolutely right. It was terrifying.. (also same time of the year.. marsh-april )
I experienced a bad storm at sea. 30+ foot swells. I have not gone out to sea since. Nor will I ever go again. The ocean is truely terrifying when its angry.
Today, April 1, 2023 marks exactly 150 years since White Star Line's SS Atlantic sank with a great loss of life after having struck a rock. RIP to all those who lost their lives during the sinking of SS Atlantic on April 1, 1873. May they never be forgotten.
@46:20 this made me cry, the sheer humanity of one man just wanting to reassure these terrified people that they weren't alone out there and that they were coming :(
Such a terrible tragedy and the fact that all the women onboard died and only one child survived makes this disaster even more heartbreaking. May all those lost in the sinking rest in peace and may they never be forgotten.
@@jgs1703 But women and children needed special treatment during disasters for the very reason in this video. Children are of course weaker than adults, and women of the time were often encumbered with their heavier clothing.
@@average.6079 Plus women and children at the time were less likely to know how to swim, so men had a better chance of survival if they had to go into the water.
😢 this is Ray here from Australia you done a very good job of telling this story but very sad all them people had to lose their lives so thank you and keep up to the work Ray really enjoyed thank you
So much is made of the Titanic disaster(and rightly so)but I have never heard of this sad event before. This video is 100% engaging and so respectful. Definitely a thumbs up from me and subscription....I have also shared multiple times.
Right. We only hear about the Titanic. But there are a lot others. And many of them have sunk. Which is ironic to me cause why everytime there is a large ship made, that supposed to be some awe and beauty to behold and encounter, just sinks taking 1000s of people with it? Why? It's like the Twin Towers. Such a beauty to behold, all while the government knew they were going to come down one day!
It reminds me of the event in the second world war where only days after the Dunkirk disaster, there was another disaster which hit the British. It was at the French port of Nazaire , where German dive bombers hit an ocean liner the Lancastrian sinking it and causing the deaths of over 6'000 evacuees mostly soldiers but also families. That is more than twice the losses on the Titanic.
Such a sad part of history. Wonderful , story telling, amazing animation. I sat with my fingers gripping my pillow because of the reality of the animation and how your words made me feel the cold water, nausea from the waves and frustration and fear of the passengers. Thank you Tom, Alex,Levis and team.
I absolutely love how you superimpose an old photo of a location over video of that same location in the present day. No other documentaries do that.- and it's simply brilliant! Love these videos- everything from Part Time Explorer is always top-notch quality
That was horrific. I appreciate the sensitivity in the telling of this, and the simplicity. You allow the account speak for itself without the overwhelming, dramatic production in most documentaries out there.
The entire story of the SS Atlantic is just heart-breaking. I remember seeing your original video during the Thing when I just queued up enough videos to cover an entire day, but the extra insight this adds just makes it hit even harder. That guy who wouldn't leave until he found his wife's body just crushed me. I don't know what I would've done in his situation if my other half was lost in such a way, and then people looted their luggage. :/
Absolutely stellar work! The effort that went into this is remarkable, I cannot think of a better produced maritime documentary from the top of my head.
Your documentaries are among the best I’ve ever seen. I can’t imagine how much work you and your team put into producing just one video. Kudos to all of you! 🎉 Your narration is perfect. In some videos done by others, either the narrator speaks too quickly, or they opt for a computerized voice, which I can’t stand! How very cool that your wife painted the sign above the entrance to that museum!
After your initial warning, I almost didn’t continue. Man, I’m glad I watched. Part way through, I answered a call of nature, got up, shivered, exclaimed out loud, “This is exciting!” Yes, it is tragic, full of dangerous errors, but your video is just outstanding. Will look for others. Thanks for the excellence !!
Never heard of this disaster until I watched this, thanks a lot for uploading and for the detailed commentary! The story of William and Annie Glenfield (1:02:57) is particularly heartbreaking and all this could have been avoided by the engineer taming his ego and being truthful.
Bro i grew up in a maritime communitty and I know how devastating a wreck effects the communitty, this is heart breaking, you have me in tears, thank you for telling this story
Good that you covered this story. So much is written and said about the Titanic but so many other ships have sunk . Many ships in the thousands have sunk on the Great Lakes but very little is ever told about them .
I’m absolutely enthralled with your videos. So much information and about ships I had never even heard of. Thank you for bringing history to light and those of us that had no idea any of these things had happened!
What an unbelievable channel! The content quality on here just keeps on getting better and better. And anything and everything on the SS Atlantic on here is so extremely well done
This gentleman is an excellent story teller. He is concise and very well researched. I have heard his voice on a few other sea documentaries, and it is a really easy voice to remember. I knew nothing about this wreck before, and I am now kind of well educated on it. It is primarily due to his very well made and very tragic tale.Thank you for the upload sir!
Tom, it is one of the most amazing documentaries I had ever seen. Your narrative along with visuals is as incredible as it gets! Congratulations and thanks are in order!
I saw your first Documentary about Atlantic. I keep rolling it many many time while doing my job on my own studio and never get bored of it. your story telling on this documentary is top notch. one of the best on this platform. Well done, Sir.
the real kicker is if they'd arrived safely to Halifax, they'd have probably discovered the coal was higher than had been reported anyway when they filled it.
@@vectravi2008 I'll tell you how - The captain pulled that story out of his ass to cover for his senseless use of coal throughout the journey, despite the engineer's warnings.
So many singular decisions that could've made this incident so much less tragic. It really stands as an example of how even seemingly innocent mistakes or small choices can lead to horrific outcomes.
@@Strider91Yes, and to listen to advice given by a person (Quartermaster)/people familiar with that area, particularly given that area was notoriously dangerous.
Very much like the titanic, so many small but bad decisions/happenings. I think is shows that as much as we want ONE thing to go wrong, so that we can avoid things like this in the future, most disasters are caused by a series of dominoes. Who knows if taking out that one factor may have changed everything.
I'm so glad RUclips decided to recommend your channel to me today. I absolutely love anything maritime and aviation related so I'm not sure why I didn't find you sooner. Anyway, I love how detailed, objective and well-researched your vidoes are. I can't wait to watch more when I get more time. Just finished your video about the Arctic disaster.
He just got 1 more 😂👍but yes I agree. Unfortunatly wery few ppl want quality informasion and facts about the world, science or history. They want gossip, football, superstition and cheap laughs... (in my humble opinion..)
This was a really well made and moving documentary. Thanks to you, your production team, and of course Mr Chaulk for sharing the tragic story of the Atlantic.
Quit making me at a loss for words, man! ;) The production quality, the narration, the animations, the interviews, the information, the animations, the on-location filming, the animations, the information overall, the animations, everything…it’s all perfect. No other term available. Just perfect!
I just happened on this video and couldn't stop watching it right through to the end. What a great job Thomas has done! His narration is flawless and the way the tragedy is laid out so compellingly that it brings tears to my eyes as if it just happened. Thank you for the education, Thomas.
I’ve gotta say, the rescue effort actually touched me. I love when people showcase their humanity in times of crisis like this. It’s genuinely beautiful how resilient we are in the face of disaster.
An excellent documentary. I have a grandson born in Halifax and his brother born in Belfast, both now in Canada, so it meant something special to me. I visited the Titanic museum in Halifax, but don't recall the Atlantic exhibition, sadly. Thank you for telling this sad, but stirring story.
You did an outstanding job telling the story of the SS Atlantic. Its quite rare to find documentaries with this much quality poured into them. Keep up the great work!
First video I have seen of yours and I immediately subscribed! I LOVE historical documentaries and ship wrecks fascinate me (despite almost drowning as a young kid and who rarely gets in the water over 35 years later still!) I was terrified of going on a cruise about 8 years ago anyway and am so happy I never searched up cruise ship wrecks before that!
New subscriber. I watched this and your wonderful retelling of the Artic. It's 4:30 am and I'm still enthralled.Compassionately and excellently told. Vivid recreations. I cried about the babies born then lost. Heroic tale too. My grandparents came the same way same time but thankfully made it. Amazing!!❤
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Help share this video around either on social media or with contacts you know who can promote it further. Bob, Alex, and I put a lot of time and effort into this project and we would love it if our work played a role in making sure the 150th anniversary of the disaster is not forgotten. Thank you!
Excellent
Excellent content, really interesting and informative! And also, it is really nice to listen to a documentary with subtle music playing in the background. I I find documentaries, almost unlistenable and unwatchable when they have music that is so loud that it distracts from the actual narration……yours is the perfect volume.
*shared*
I will do so, thanks again guys.
Cuz everything is owned by Blackrock cuz their buddies bought a license to print their own money in 1913. Welcome to the Suck!
It’s crazy how just a handful of people and sometimes one person can make better documentaries than large companies ever could dream of. All of your work is excellent and only getting better.
Thank you very much!
'large companies' are too concerned about input from focus groups, I agree Cody, this is an exceptional piece of work...
I totally agree w you. I don't even watch any tv anymore just stream😊
Titanic rip😢😢
👍🏻👍🏻
All of the people who participated in the rescue were absolute hard men. An 11 year old kid rowing across a rough sea in the early morning?! Nuts!
EDDIE!MULLENS!
In the roughest tides on Earth during a huge storm 🤯
Absolute madlads, hats off to them all
That kid was more man than most so called men alive today.
Yeah because they had Fathers and were molded into men at a early age. No nagging wife yet, so rowing into rough seas would be preferable.
The bravery if the locals who risked their lives to rescue strangers is a testament to the best of human nature. So touching.
And the looting is testament to the worst of human nature
Well said.
Made me get teared up. So brave.
I dont mean to take away from their heroism, but this is often the case for people who live near the sea. It is done, because they know how much the sea can take, and if all seamen did it, they themselves would be extended the same heroism. It is putting your hope in one another.
And most seamen do this. They are forced to by law, but usually they do it because they know the same will be done for their sons and nephews and fathers. I have grown up near the North sea, and every village has at least one monument remembering the dead. Often there would be so many sunk boats, they would have no choice but to make one big monument. But you would see a pattern jn it. For some crewmen their death date was the same, and the crewmen of each boat their family name was also often the same. As a kid this left a big impression on me. I would look at my dad and would fsll silent knowing that that was also the same thing a lot of sons did when their lives were lost. Maybe the last thing.
The fact that this whole tragedy could have been avoided if just one man was truthful with his captain…
AND the captain, who was happy to use lots of coal to go full steam ahead!!
@@amethyst1826 that would of been a problem, but then lying to the captain instead of just outright telling him he wasn’t being truthful about the amount left. The captain might of been using to much coal but the tragedy was entirely the effect of the other guys actions
Not to mention Metcalf's hubris in dismissing the caution about coming in too fast and too close to the dangerous parts of Halifax. I wonder what went through the men's minds during the destruction; one who realized he should have listened, and the other knowing they never needed to be there in the first place.
Even worse he ignored captain's orders.
IF he woke him up, even just 12 minutes earlier, the disaster could have still be avoided.
Should've seen hte Arctic
"My wife painted that sign"
I think that's simply wonderful, both in the service of the museum and the recognition of your thoughtful spouse.
The fact that they rescued 400 people from that apparently hopeless situation is an incredible testament to the skill, bravery and determination of those islanders.
I'm 53 years old, born & raised in Nova Scotia, less then 3 hours away & I never heard of this accident until now. Never taught to us in school. Thanks for this video. Great job.
Well surely you've heard of the Halifax explosion?
@@macysondheim It's not his responsibility. I live near Belfast and I don't expect everyone in Northern Ireland to know every single detail about Titanic, a tragedy that happened after this one in the video. Not to mention the fact he's watching this video contradicts your whole statement.
@@amaritineenthusiast whatever
@@macysondheim The second you get an actual response you just say "Whatever"
@@macysondheim Yes, but it should have been taught at school with field visits about local culture
As a Nova Scotian, it's difficult to believe anyone survived that night. The currents and riptides carry people off the slick granite to their doom every year. To be that close to the shore, a false hope, must have caused so many deaths.
It must have been so safe looking in the water that some might have jumped off in to the water
Terence bay still is a fishing village, it was a bunch of community members who went out in their boats to save those souls
I don’t even know what I just said😅
Knowing that they never had to go to Nova Scotia but because one man's lies they went to their deaths makes this a horrific preventable tragedy.
@@jbug13158one man’s lies and another’s pride.
I feel like the captain was dealing with a terrible crew. He was being lied about the amount of coal up to the point that someone thought unnecessarily diverting the ship from its course was preferable to recognizing their deceit. He was also not woken up when he requested it. A captain is still one person and he couldn't do everything, he depended on his crew.
Capt had a lead foot too dude
A terrible crew is usually the result of terrible leadership.
Not always.
@@matthewchampion5483 Not "always". But near enough always, and it always plays a role.
@@joeyjojo5986 He did say 'wake me up at 3'
I absolutely love these detailed videos, telling stories rarely known. Absolutely brilliant video overall!
Totally agree, they're better than many mainstream documentary channels
Ayyee! Another awesome RUclipsr! Love Bright Sun Films and Part Time Explorer! ❤ truly hidden gems
your videos are really good too.
I’ve binged a few.
Vividly told , so cold and sad .
Nice seeing you here mr. Williams
Poor Rosa, she just gave birth to her newborn child only to lose her over the edge to the sea. And then to be separated from her husband and left in the rigging, tied down, watching in horror and despair as the ship sunk deeper and deeper. RIP to her and everyone lost that night.
I know, I was thinking, I think she nearly lost the will to fight after that baby was swept away. I can’t even imagine the pain she must have felt while up in that mast.
See: Problem of Evil; God.
I,ll second that. RIP Rosa.
@@skylarsjoberg9618 Its so sad. Life can be cruel. RIP Rosa.
😢😢
It's not the first documentary I listen to about the SS Atlantic, however it has to be the most detailed and compassionate one. I feel so sad for the lost persons, people like Rosa who likely went through the pains of childbirth and being a new mother, to losing everything in a single hour, even her life. The rescuers were outstanding people as well, and the efforts they pulled while not having much themselves is a great example of humanity.
He crushes it without fiction. The truth is often more compelling, as his videos clearly show.
@StevieSeagalWhich part was fiction... I'll wait.
I live in Halifax, and the number of graves we have from well known ship wrecks always somehow surprises the tourists. The Atlantic is a treacherous ocean at the best of times, and we're often the closest port. This is fantastically done - thank you for all of your hard work and research.
I thought women had blubber like seals, allowing them to live longer in cold water than men. Or is this just modern women who get fat on processes foods? In this case the women were in a disadvantageous location on the ship, but I think the survival results would have been different if women had superior cold water capabilities as do seals. Though I remember modern stories of sinkings and boat capsizes where only the women survived. And I know my sisters and nieces enjoy far colder water than I can.
@@alan6832with all sincerity dude what the actual fuck
@@alan6832what r u even talking about lmao
@@alan6832r/nothowgirlswork
@@alan6832 that sounds like a way out theory, like about as far as Mars
This is one of the finest maritime documentaries I've ever seen. Congratulations, Tom, and a big shout-out to Alex for his incredible work!
You should check Ocean liner design channel.
👍🏻👍🏻
True
@@tonywang7461lo
Just happened to come across this last night and I'm watching again. So sad but so interesting... I'd love to see a doc about the descendents of survivors, if any, stayed in the area..
In 1851 my great-grandfather (then 12 years old), his sister, and their mom and dad made the voyage from County Donegal, Ireland, to New York City, fleeing the famine and turmoil in their homeland. They undoubtedly traveled in steerage, and documentaries like this help me to visualize just a bit of what they must have experienced during the long crossing. I enjoy your dignified and unsensational videos packed with history. Thank you!
It was a slow genocide over a number of years. Perpetuated by the Crown and the Merchant/Mercantile class. Essentially parasites in my opinion. Also following Malthusian dogma too. Look it up.
I like that, "dignified and unsensational". Well said! The videos here really are classy! 👍🏼
Dear old Donegal. You MUST visit if you haven't yet.
I had a great grandfather come from Sicily to NY and Ireland to NJ and I think the same thing. Omg. The fact we were born was a design, not chance.
So the guy that caused and allowed the accident was the one who survived and got to island again?
The compassion of these people in the tiny island settlements for the the stranded survivors of this terrible tragedy is enough to bring one to tears. They had so little to spare, yet they gave all they could to them.
Not like they had much choice. Those survivors would have just pillaged and stolen from their houses if they didn't open their doors. They did not even get compensated for having all their food storage drained by those men.
@@cocogoat1111That doesn’t change the fact that they *did* willingly open their doors to those people, and that it came from a place of human compassion. They also didn’t *have* to risk their own lives to save the survivors still aboard the ship and on the rock. Not everything needs to be so doom and gloom, especially when related to a tragedy like this. Take the good where you can find it. Why you insist on seeing it from a negative angle, I will never understand.
@@cocogoat1111you're underestimating the good of Canadians. Eastern Canadians like Nova Scotians are some of the most humble and kind people that are about community. I'm proud I am born and raised in Canada and I grew up nowhere near the coast! Good people do what's right if they can. We still have those qualities even if you don't often see it..
It's no choice. They said that the man and his sons were fisherman or some other ocean profession. If someone needs help at sea and you can help, you help. It could be you or your kid one day.
@@imahumanperson361I think it is the good of Christians. All of these people were deeply religious and even if some were Catholic and some Protestant, they were united by their belief in God Almighty. Not only the charity of the locals is amazing, but the international charity that came flowing in from all over. Private charity can do so much in a high trust society of God fearing people. You would not have such open giving in today's world, sadly.
I'm 60 years old. I was born in Liverpool and, in the 1960s, the docks aside the River Mersey were my playground, especially the Princes Landing Stage, the Pier Head, and the Albert and Canning Docks. Even as a young child, I was fascinated by tales of the SS Atlantic. Thank you for this excellent documentary.
The most legendary thing about this is the town who rallied into action as fast as they could, almost brings a tear to my eye
and it’s always the poor simple ones.
@@mdouteymedia tends to show us a very distilled cross section of humanity. I think this is a testament to the fact that despite how the world might look when you read or watch the news, your average fellow human would help you out if they could.
It's pretty typical of maritime towns. These sorts of incidents are very common and they have to perform rescues pretty regularly. Less common now, and more professionalized, but it still happens.
It makes me terribly sad that the man who worked for years to bring a good life to the woman he loves just to lose her in such a horrific way. And to make it worse, he couldn't even be granted a proper sentimental item to remember her by because of the horrible greed of people who looked at the tragedy as profit to be gained.
Such a sad ending for the newlywedded gentleman and of course his Bride. They was almost here 😞
and to think that the descendants of these robbers are still alive somewhere really upsets me. Truly disgusting lineage
I didn't know what you meant at first because I read the comments before watching the whole documentary. Now that I watched it all, what that man must have gone through afterward, gnaws on me. It's so tragically sad beyond words. The whole tragedy is the worst I have ever heard. We got to know this husbands story, but there must be so many other men who lost their wives, sisters, daughters and so on, not even one woman lived. So many that lived, I even though they physically survived, their lives ended that day. 😢
@@caezero2072 Every single human is a descendant of saints and sinners. Progeny never get a choice in the actions of 100's of generations before them.
Strange that we criticize heavily the young inner city looters who take advantage of a bad situation like a black man bring shot by police. But back in 1873 they were even worse examples.
The woman who had her baby snatched out of her arms by a wave. That made my blood run cold. Especially as a parent.
Can’t even imagine.
You must be new here in America 🇺🇸🥴
@@Kera-i1twhat does that even mean?.. we get our baby’s snatched from our arms in America?
I'm sure that's something that was with her in her final hours, strapped to the rigging. Death may have felt like a release. I can't even imagine the agony. And her poor husband, watching helplessly from the shore... what a nightmare.
What does that comment mean. Please explain as I dont get it at all@@Kera-i1t
I thought those were two different women?
I've never gotten emotional while watching a shipwreck documentary, but the story of William and Annie Glenfield made me ugly cry. I cannot imagine what Willaim felt that night and what he must have felt for the rest of his life. I can only pray that if there is an afterlife, William and Annie have been reunited at last in peace.
Jesus very clearly said "marriage ends at death." Why are so many people calling Jesus a liar? No reuniting in the afterlife. That is fiction & was repeated multiple times. Read Matthew. It is amazing how supposedly religious people simply change the Bible's words.
maybe its the comfort people get from believing they will be reunited with loved ones @@Henry-fk7cq
@@Henry-fk7cqnot everyone prays to your God
@@Henry-fk7cqjust because a marriage is over doesn't mean that can't be reunited. What an ugly comment you made.
@@Henry-fk7cq You poor fool.🙄
" My Wife painted that sign" , " I flew to California to fact-check my story". Tell me you have a great passion for this story without telling me you have a great passion for this story? .... God Bless You Brother, you put your heart and soul into this.
The White Star Line either had the worst luck or hired the most incompetent people to be found on the seven seas.
Profit was the aim..... Purely greed.
Never forget, when your life relies on equipment, that it was produced under budget by the lowest bidder.
@@christynorman7288Ismay again. We seem to continue to learn nothing even in 2023
@@christynorman7288 greed? WSL was revolutionary in its treatment of its passengers and safety
Man just needs to be reminded from time to time that the sea is superior in every way.
Fun fact: Dinner is actually what you call the largest meal of the day, which traditionally was taken in the middle of the day. Supper is what you call the last meal if the day. That is why some older people will still call lunch dinner, and dinner supper.
In French ...diner ..lunch ...souper ...supper
Yes this used to be the case in Australia too. My grandparents would call lunch "dinner" and what we now call dinner, they called "tea". Older people still say tea but I don't know any younger people who do. "supper" being a snack before bed which we still use. We still call the lunctime feast at Christmas "Christmas dinner". Lunch should be a bigger meal than dinner I think, you don't need all that energy so late in the day but my family and most people I know eat dinner as the biggest meal. Late too, at 7 or 8. I often don't eat dinner at all coz by then I'm too tired to care about food
@@ceasarwright7567 Is that Canadian French? I learned a bit of French as a kid and I remember it being petit-dejuner (breakfast), dejuner (lunch), diner (dinner), and souper (supper, before bed)
@@Kateyangyuqing Umm good question ! Im from Quebec so Yes thats Quebecois french :-)
@@ceasarwright7567 Awesome that's kinda like how in Australia people used to say breakfast (or brekky)/dinner/tea whereas I think Americans have long said breakfast/lunch/dinner (Australian English has gradually become more and more like American English because we have more American influence than English influence nowadays). Nowadays we say breakfast (or brekky in speech)/lunch/dinner. I went to school with someone from Quebec, he couldn't speak much English when he first arrived but then after a couple of years he sounded almost 100% Australian. Is Quebecoise French as different from Parisian French as American English is from, say, Australian English? I don't speak French but I can kind of hear the difference in accents between Canada and France, Canadian French sounds more relaxed or something. But I can hear the differences in the many Mandarin accents people have from different areas of China very clearly, for example, people native to Beijing sound completely different from people near Shanghai esepcially if they are older (I am referring to Mandarin and not local "dialects" of China - which are actually completely different languages). I really want to go to Canada one day, it seems like a wonderful country. The Canadians I've met have been really easy to get along with, for some reason Canadians and Australians seem to have alot in common even though there aren't many Canadians here.
It wasn't Metcalfe's job to decide if the captain needed more sleep or not. If the captain tells you to wake him at a certain time do it.
And do not sabotage his backup alarm, too .. all those precautions let me think the captain may already have had his reservations about Metcalfe.
Exactly
Literally! He should have woken him when he said!
I made it out to the SS Atlantic museum this summer and I bought Bob's books and he signed both of them. The people there were so friendly and I had a great experience.
What heroes the villagers were. And the survivors who worked tirelessly to save their fellow travellers.
Thank you, Mr. Chaulk and Part Timer Explorer for the effort done to remember their heroic deeds.
Everyone on that ship had dreams, a destiny, a family and a reason to live, I hope all lost souls rest in peace, beautiful documentary.
All because of one man's decision too: Metcalf.
@@jebbroham1776 exactly, that motherfucker
@@jebbroham1776he died as he lived.
Boy I really wish Foxley would have just admitted he was underreporting and they were good to head to NY... This is a tragic but fascinating tale! Well done again Tom.
They were cutting it really close, I could see many people making that same call. Remember even if it hadn't all gone to shit they would still have taken a hit to their reputation for having to divert so it's not like that decision was completely in his favor. I thought him not waking the captain was a worse call cause he would have known the danger of not seeing the lighthouse when they were supposed to.
@@christopherboxford9556 That's what I thought as well. If we are to blame one person here, it's Metcalf.
it seems a common denominator in many of these tragedies nearly always ends up being someone who does not take accountability and lies about SOMETHING. metcalf should have awoken his captain as well.
@@christopherboxford9556 In fairness steaming for NA would not have resulted in them slamming into rocks. If they hadn't made it all the way they still at least could have been towed back.
But yes it's true. This was a cumulation of mistakes not just one person is wholly responsible imo. Like in so many distasters there's a lot of contributing factors.
What a harrowing tale 😣 I didn’t expect to be so pulled in. Thank you for putting the time and effort into sharing this story with us.
Man I couldn't imagine being on a ship like that in that storm. Forget about the whole sinking part. Just trying to traverse the ship, in the dark, being thrown around from the waves, being seasick, slipping on puke on every floor and level from hundreds of people. What a nightmare that had to have been.
That's how every seaside community responded to wrecks, there's something beautiful about the solidarity among people in maritime communities. From the outer banks life saving stations "we are ordered to row out, whether we return or not"
Ew
This documentary fills in so much history for me. My great-grandfather was a survivor.
My 2nd great grandfather was also a survivor-he was the ship’s painter :)
This was so beautifully done... It literally almost made me tear up several times... The baby washed away, Rosa, Annie... All hit my soul hard. Rest in peace everyone lost.
the humanity you show towards these hugely tragic stories is truly remarkable
Agreed
Once the ship hit rock, I could feel the cold through your excellent writing.
This video was so well done-the writing, the clarity of the narrator’s speech, the graphics, music, and script. You warned us it could be terribly sad, and it was, but so appealing for all its moments of humanity.
Thank you.
It's like the mountain climbing videos. Just when I swear things couldnt be any more miserable- I remember that it's all happening in the freezing cold.
This is a huge tragedy in my opinion and I wish well for the relatives of the Atlantic survivors, also amazing documentary!
Bob has to be happy to see a young man like you sharing his documentation of these events in modern ways so new generations will know of these tales and never forget the losses we have suffered for progress.
Just purchased Mr. Chaulk's book. It's nice to be able to support someone who keeps stories like this alive.
I really hope you make more visualizations of these old fashioned wrecks. You got me into shipbuilding, ship history, old time history, money exchange rates and global trade patterns. Tons of really cool rabbit holes, just because you were able to close the gap between a boring rusty book, and a nice and understandable visual for the new generation. Thank you good sir!
This is worse than the Titanic because this was such an avoidable, painful, and pointless loss of life. Most infuriating is Metcalf ignoring the 1 sailor on the ship familiar with this area, based on the story I doubt the captain would of been so stupid too.
@StevieSeagalthe Engineer couldn't have foreseen this, and was at the very least doing what he felt was best for the ship. Metcalf, on the other hand, was deliberately insubordinate and dismissive of the dangers. If any one person is to blame, it's him.
Not to mention, ignored multiple orders from his captain to wake him in time.
@@Soundwave3591Why does there only have to be 1?...
No one ever talks about the Wilhelm Gustloff torpedoed in WW2 with a loss of life close to 10,000 people . Think about that number .....that's just unimaginable
@@slinky_malinki5330
Allegedly. It was convenient for the captain that Metcalfe died in the disaster and couldn’t give his own testimony. After all, the captain’s career would have been ruined had he for example told Metcalfe not to wake him until they saw the lighthouse. That small detail about Metcalfe not waking him at 2:40 or 3 AM suddenly redirects all the blame on Metcalfe and all that is remembered is the hero captain organizing the survivors.
I watch a ton of content on RUclips, an unhealthy amount in fact. What you’re doing here is right up at the top with the very best creators out there. This was award worthy stuff. Truly outstanding. Thank you and keep up the wonderful videos!
I TOTALLY AGREE!!!!!
@ Time To Wake Up. I am with you on that. Been bed bound for the last four months. Constantly watching RUclips, films and series. Good to have it all the same. 👍
100%
@@jerryoconnor-ps8bb i have also been pretty much bedridden (mono, the original covid) for about 2 months now, and looking at least another month of it......
wishing you the best, and i hope you feel better soon. i would say sending "good energy" or whatever but i have no energy to send, hope you understand (haha)..
it really sucks being housebound or bedbound, but good long form content like this is truly a life saver.
@@musicobsessive123 Thank you! I hope that you recover soon and get back to normality.
My 6 year old requested this video earlier. He loves this video and likes to watch it as often as he can. We thank you for making great content!
Unless you have been in a storm on the ocean you can't imagine just how powerful the waves are!!!
I went through 2 hurricanes in the Navy and I thought both times that we weren't going to make it!!!
The waves threw my ship around like it was nothing!!!
That’s why I volunteered for Submarines. We just go under all shit!
I too experienced the furry of the ocean while in the North Atlantic while in the the navy. Terrifying doesn’t give it a satisfactory adjective.
I crossed the atlantic as a kid on a mershantship that my father was the captain of. Antwerpen to New York.
We hit the outskirts of a storm midway, and your absolutely right. It was terrifying.. (also same time of the year.. marsh-april )
I experienced a bad storm at sea. 30+ foot swells. I have not gone out to sea since. Nor will I ever go again. The ocean is truely terrifying when its angry.
5:51: That would suck if you had the bunk right next to the shitter on a trans Atlantic voyage.
Today, April 1, 2023 marks exactly 150 years since White Star Line's SS Atlantic sank with a great loss of life after having struck a rock.
RIP to all those who lost their lives during the sinking of SS Atlantic on April 1, 1873.
May they never be forgotten.
When you think you are having a hard day, think of poor Rosa Bateman. Brilliant documentary, I love these stories.
The reverend was so brave and showed true leadership in getting the men to go back out to rescue those last few
@46:20 this made me cry, the sheer humanity of one man just wanting to reassure these terrified people that they weren't alone out there and that they were coming :(
What a terrible tragedy. Thank you for this awesome, thorough coverage.
Such a terrible tragedy and the fact that all the women onboard died and only one child survived makes this disaster even more heartbreaking.
May all those lost in the sinking rest in peace and may they never be forgotten.
Imagine the childhood trauma that kid had to live with.
Men are just as important as women.
@@jgs1703 people of your sort were tried and hanged once they swam to shore in more civilized times
@@jgs1703 But women and children needed special treatment during disasters for the very reason in this video.
Children are of course weaker than adults, and women of the time were often encumbered with their heavier clothing.
@@average.6079 Plus women and children at the time were less likely to know how to swim, so men had a better chance of survival if they had to go into the water.
The CGI are meticulous and brilliant. Obviously the engine helped but the artist's work cannot be understated!
😢 this is Ray here from Australia you done a very good job of telling this story but very sad all them people had to lose their lives so thank you and keep up to the work Ray really enjoyed thank you
So much is made of the Titanic disaster(and rightly so)but I have never heard of this sad event before. This video is 100% engaging and so respectful.
Definitely a thumbs up from me and subscription....I have also shared multiple times.
Right. We only hear about the Titanic. But there are a lot others. And many of them have sunk. Which is ironic to me cause why everytime there is a large ship made, that supposed to be some awe and beauty to behold and encounter, just sinks taking 1000s of people with it? Why? It's like the Twin Towers. Such a beauty to behold, all while the government knew they were going to come down one day!
It reminds me of the event in the second world war where only days after the Dunkirk disaster, there was another disaster which hit the British. It was at the French port of Nazaire , where German dive bombers hit an ocean liner the Lancastrian sinking it and causing the deaths of over 6'000 evacuees mostly soldiers but also families. That is more than twice the losses on the Titanic.
I know, why don't these get their own films like Titanic
@@mandia469 To be fair, Olympic (Titanic’s sister of the exact same size) did have a full career. She was scrapped in 1935.
Such a sad part of history. Wonderful , story telling, amazing animation. I sat with my fingers gripping my pillow because of the reality of the animation and how your words made me feel the cold water, nausea from the waves and frustration and fear of the passengers. Thank you Tom, Alex,Levis and team.
I absolutely love how you superimpose an old photo of a location over video of that same location in the present day. No other documentaries do that.- and it's simply brilliant! Love these videos- everything from Part Time Explorer is always top-notch quality
Incredible graphics. You're a wonderful storyteller Tom. Thanks for preserving the memory of the souls lost on this significant aniversary.
That was horrific. I appreciate the sensitivity in the telling of this, and the simplicity. You allow the account speak for itself without the overwhelming, dramatic production in most documentaries out there.
The entire story of the SS Atlantic is just heart-breaking. I remember seeing your original video during the Thing when I just queued up enough videos to cover an entire day, but the extra insight this adds just makes it hit even harder. That guy who wouldn't leave until he found his wife's body just crushed me. I don't know what I would've done in his situation if my other half was lost in such a way, and then people looted their luggage. :/
Taking a second to express how grateful I am for these videos. You're a wonderful content creator. Never change brother, never change.
Absolutely beautifully told. What a sad story. You really gave so much respect to the victims.
Incredible work on this, thank you for producing these - the quality is incredible - better than what you get commercially these days.
Thank you very much!
Absolutely stellar work! The effort that went into this is remarkable, I cannot think of a better produced maritime documentary from the top of my head.
Your documentaries are among the best I’ve ever seen. I can’t imagine how much work you and your team put into producing just one video. Kudos to all of you! 🎉
Your narration is perfect. In some videos done by others, either the narrator speaks too quickly, or they opt for a computerized voice, which I can’t stand!
How very cool that your wife painted the sign above the entrance to that museum!
I'm glad you enjoyed this and always happy to hear that our work is appreciated. Thanks for the kind words and the super thanks!
@@PartTimeExplorer Don't women usually outlast men in cold water due to seal like fat layer? or did that emerge with processed food?
After your initial warning, I almost didn’t continue. Man, I’m glad I watched. Part way through, I answered a call of nature, got up, shivered, exclaimed out loud, “This is exciting!” Yes, it is tragic, full of dangerous errors, but your video is just outstanding. Will look for others. Thanks for the excellence !!
Amazing documentary!
No sensationalism, no overdramatic cut and music. Just calmly told story. With proper visualization.
I like that.
Never heard of this disaster until I watched this, thanks a lot for uploading and for the detailed commentary! The story of William and Annie Glenfield (1:02:57) is particularly heartbreaking and all this could have been avoided by the engineer taming his ego and being truthful.
Many a people lost their lives throughout history over men's grandiose egos!
Ah yes the human ego. Until we figure out ttthe taming of it we are all doomed to repeat folly continuously.
Bro i grew up in a maritime communitty and I know how devastating a wreck effects the communitty, this is heart breaking, you have me in tears, thank you for telling this story
Good that you covered this story. So much is written and said about the Titanic but so many other ships have sunk . Many ships in the thousands have sunk on the Great Lakes but very little is ever told about them .
I can’t believe how well done this video is. One of the best I’ve seen . I’ve learned so much. Thank you for this. Excellent work!
I’m absolutely enthralled with your videos. So much information and about ships I had never even heard of. Thank you for bringing history to light and those of us that had no idea any of these things had happened!
What an unbelievable channel! The content quality on here just keeps on getting better and better. And anything and everything on the SS Atlantic on here is so extremely well done
This gentleman is an excellent story teller. He is concise and very well researched. I have heard his voice on a few other sea documentaries, and it is a really easy voice to remember. I knew nothing about this wreck before, and I am now kind of well educated on it. It is primarily due to his very well made and very tragic tale.Thank you for the upload sir!
Thanks!
Thank you!
Tom, it is one of the most amazing documentaries I had ever seen. Your narrative along with visuals is as incredible as it gets! Congratulations and thanks are in order!
I saw your first Documentary about Atlantic. I keep rolling it many many time while doing my job on my own studio and never get bored of it. your story telling on this documentary is top notch. one of the best on this platform.
Well done, Sir.
What an amazing job you do in your videos! I’m never going to get any work done since finding this channel.
the real kicker is if they'd arrived safely to Halifax, they'd have probably discovered the coal was higher than had been reported anyway when they filled it.
and someone was going to get fired
@@JerryOlsen exactly. The risk was absolutely not worth it.
Does anyone know how the full story of the extra coal reserves were finally revealed?
The worst part of the entire thing is the misreport of coal killed all those people
@@vectravi2008 I'll tell you how - The captain pulled that story out of his ass to cover for his senseless use of coal throughout the journey, despite the engineer's warnings.
This was absolutely fantastic. Horrific disaster, but very well told. Thank you. ❤ from Canada
So many singular decisions that could've made this incident so much less tragic.
It really stands as an example of how even seemingly innocent mistakes or small choices can lead to horrific outcomes.
Its also a healthy reminder, that if your captain gives you an order. . . You follow it. Because otherwise, people die.
It wouldn’t have even happened at all if it wasn’t for the chief engineer guy.
@@Strider91Yes, and to listen to advice given by a person (Quartermaster)/people familiar with that area, particularly given that area was notoriously dangerous.
Very much like the titanic, so many small but bad decisions/happenings.
I think is shows that as much as we want ONE thing to go wrong, so that we can avoid things like this in the future, most disasters are caused by a series of dominoes. Who knows if taking out that one factor may have changed everything.
This is one of the best maritime disaster documentaries I've ever watched...and I've watched a lot! Amazing production. Well done.
I'm so glad RUclips decided to recommend your channel to me today. I absolutely love anything maritime and aviation related so I'm not sure why I didn't find you sooner. Anyway, I love how detailed, objective and well-researched your vidoes are. I can't wait to watch more when I get more time. Just finished your video about the Arctic disaster.
Amazing work. I was a huge fan of the first documentary, but this one blows it out of the water. Animations look great. Keep up the good work
This dude needs way more subs, he deserves it.
He just got 1 more 😂👍but yes I agree.
Unfortunatly wery few ppl want quality informasion and facts about the world, science or history.
They want gossip, football, superstition and cheap laughs... (in my humble opinion..)
share share share!
This was a really well made and moving documentary. Thanks to you, your production team, and of course Mr Chaulk for sharing the tragic story of the Atlantic.
Thank you for an absolutely stellar video. Wonderful storytelling-narration and imagery, just right. An overall fantastic presentation. Congrats!
Thank you very much!
There are very few who can tell a story like you do. And no repetitive use of images to fill the time. One of my favourite YT channels!
You do a terrific job researching these accounts and giving an in-depth explanation of the moment-by-moment action. Bravo Sir!
Sir this episode is so horrific and yet needs to be told, and Sir you have done an excellent job indeed, thank you!!!🙏😢⚓❣️
Indeed!!! 🧡it!
Compliments on the dapper attire! This is a superbly detailed documentary on this tragic wreck. The supporting imagery contributed much to the tale.
I want to tank you for your effort of telling this story as actually as possible. Your story telling is awesome...thank you
Quit making me at a loss for words, man! ;)
The production quality, the narration, the animations, the interviews, the information, the animations, the on-location filming, the animations, the information overall, the animations, everything…it’s all perfect. No other term available. Just perfect!
I just happened on this video and couldn't stop watching it right through to the end. What a great job Thomas has done! His narration is flawless and the way the tragedy is laid out so compellingly that it brings tears to my eyes as if it just happened. Thank you for the education, Thomas.
I’ve gotta say, the rescue effort actually touched me. I love when people showcase their humanity in times of crisis like this. It’s genuinely beautiful how resilient we are in the face of disaster.
This long-forgotten ship is forgotten no more. I have had enough learning about Titanic now I want to learn more about this ship thanks to you.
Your documentaries are incredible. Thank you for sharing your passion.
Thank you very much!
Wow you did an amazing job with this documentary. I felt like I was there and it was terrifying. Thank you for telling their stories ❤.
An excellent documentary. I have a grandson born in Halifax and his brother born in Belfast, both now in Canada, so it meant something special to me. I visited the Titanic museum in Halifax, but don't recall the Atlantic exhibition, sadly. Thank you for telling this sad, but stirring story.
You did an outstanding job telling the story of the SS Atlantic. Its quite rare to find documentaries with this much quality poured into them. Keep up the great work!
First video I have seen of yours and I immediately subscribed! I LOVE historical documentaries and ship wrecks fascinate me (despite almost drowning as a young kid and who rarely gets in the water over 35 years later still!) I was terrified of going on a cruise about 8 years ago anyway and am so happy I never searched up cruise ship wrecks before that!
New subscriber. I watched this and your wonderful retelling of the Artic. It's 4:30 am and I'm still enthralled.Compassionately and excellently told. Vivid recreations. I cried about the babies born then lost. Heroic tale too. My grandparents came the same way same time but thankfully made it. Amazing!!❤