Thanks a ton Brother, means a lot🙏🌹 Please check my channel, u will get more unknown stories videos and my singing videos too there, hope u will like them too❤️🌹
बेहतरीन शोध अशोक जी। वैसे इस धुन की एक आठवीं बहन भी है। गाने के बोल हैं “ किसका रस्ता देखे , ऐ दिल ऐ सौदाई “ फ़िल्म - जोशीला। शायद पंचम दा इस धुन के जादू से उम्र भर नहीं निकल पाये। 👍
You have a very nice singing voice with sur. Thanks for the new info about Chaplin. I did not knew he composed his movie music too, and composed that well!
Glad you enjoyed it!! Thanks a ton🙏🌹I have a bengali album from HMV - Neon er alo, if possible listen to it, u will get it the net, Spotify etc. Apart from that in my channel I hv uploaded many hindi song too, shunle bhalo lagbe asha korchi🙏
आपका चैनल तो एक गोल्डमाइन है। आज ही पहला मुलाकात हुया, और सबस्क्राइबर बनकर बड़ा आनन्द लगा। मेरा ताउ जी भी बम्बई मे परिचालक थे, स्ट्रीट सिंखर, उँचे लोग, येहुदी कि लड़की - शायद आप पहचान लिये है
Very interesting. I had always associated the Limelight theme with Pallabini go sancharini and Zindagi hai kya, but had not connected it with a favourite song Tum meri zindagi mein. Thanks for highlighting this.
वाह अशोक जी! संगीत प्रेमियों के लिए आप के द्वारा बड़ी ही रोचक जानकारी साक्ष्यों के साथ पेश की गई है। बहुत अच्छा लगा। आशा है भविष्य में भी आप ऐसे ही रोचक कार्यक्रम प्रस्तुत करते रहेंगें। Best wishes❤
Badhiya 👌Ashok ji. I liked rather loved your episode which is of a different mode. . Hope you will continue your such efforts laying emphasis on such unique topics Thanks 🙏 😊
Nice video...thanks Ek ajnabi haseena...also has similarities. Pancham does talk about such variations in a video using an example of Agar Tum Na Hote, Sagar Kinare etc.
Charlie's said 'eternally' song is THE ORIGINAL. Those who are commenting otherwise are wrong. It is no way Tchaikovsky. Charlie is the only person in the history of film making who wrote, directed, acted, and scored a motion picture.
Nice video. One small correction. Chaplin ko lifetime achievement ka Oscar dea gaya tha like Our Legend Satyajit Roy, kisi particular dhun ke lie nahin.
No, most of the people are wrong abt it.....posting wiki quote Chaplin received three Academy Awards: an Honorary Award for "versatility and genius in acting, writing, directing, and producing The Circus" in 1929,[188] a second Honorary Award for "the incalculable effect he has had in making motion pictures the art form of this century" in 1972,[347] and a Best Score award in 1973 for Limelight (shared with Ray Rasch and Larry Russell).[434]
Excellent. Initially I thought that you will miss the Bengali numbers and I'll mention those. But you are a Bengali yourself and no Bengali music lover can afford to miss Pallabini go sancharini and Ki kore janle tumi. Honestly I had no idea about the Tamil version. Great job.👍
@AshokTheFunkaar.. Great job! Inspired songs.. the list is long 😂 What is interesting to note is your excellent singing.. seem to be a good Bengali singer singing the evergreen old SL number of Dwijen Mukherjee ‘Pallabini Go Sancharini’!👌
Thank u so much bro for those encouraging words, means a lot bro🙏🌹 Yes, my band Probashi got launched by HMV Saregama in 2006, Album name Neon-er Alo.....having two albums....u can listen to my songs in Spotify, just search Ashok Ghosh in google🙏 U can listen to some of my hindi songs in my channel too
Nice information & observation, can you please find the original guitarist who played the prelude/intro of song pal pal dil ke pass composed by kalyanji anandji from film Blackmail
Zindagi Hai Kya Sun Meri Jaan I Mohammed Rafi | Bollywood Classic Hit Song | Dev Anand I Maya 1961 ruclips.net/video/1TnZdEdvfHo/видео.html Tried to sing this awesome song, hope u like it🙏
Great analysis!! One thing I would like to say that greatest entertainer The Charlie Chaplin was awarded Oscar in the year 2972 for life time achievement n he also got Oscar for music much earlier year. Please verify. Thanks
Thanks Bro🙏 as per my record and whatever info I got from the Net, Charlie Chaplin got Oscar for Lime Light Title music in the year 1973 after the movie reopened in 1972 in Los Angeles
I won't call these 'copying'. No way. As only one musical phrase was taken, then the composer took the liberty to give a spin to develop that phrase into a full song by adding 3 or 4 'tuks', composing prelude, interludes, orchestration etc etc..... Hear Salil da's Pallabini go or Itna na mujhse etc. Even for that matter, Salil da's masterly adaptation to compose Dil Tadap Tadap ke from Madhumati. The original Polish song was very slow and not much variation. But Salil da made this into a sparkling diamond by giving his own touch.. However, an excellent job done well, Ashok 👌🏻 Keep on doing your good work.
Some tunes influence composers too deep to come out. Even Chaplin was not the original composer of this one. However, such tunes remain virgin forever ❤. I like Amit Sadhna duet very much.
Many many thanks Ashok ji for your very nice interesting information about the famous comedy star Charlie Chaplin also is very fine music creator.
So nice of you bro, means a lot, thanks a ton🙏🌹
V informative and great editing Ashok.
Tnx a bunch Mohita for ur support and encouragement🙏😊🌹🌹
No 8 - "Kiska raasta dekhein..." by Kishore Kumar
Thanks for this great information. Ghosh da, you sing very well - you should do this more often.
Thanks a ton Brother, means a lot🙏🌹
Please check my channel, u will get more unknown stories videos and my singing videos too there, hope u will like them too❤️🌹
Chaplin himself copied .this tune.....Tchaikovsky "a piano concerto no 1
Thank You For Your Very Importan Informetion.... 🙏🙏🙏
Thanks a ton🙏❤️
बेहतरीन शोध अशोक जी। वैसे इस धुन की एक आठवीं बहन भी है। गाने के बोल हैं “ किसका रस्ता देखे , ऐ दिल ऐ सौदाई “ फ़िल्म - जोशीला। शायद पंचम दा इस धुन के जादू से उम्र भर नहीं निकल पाये। 👍
Shukriya ji🙏sahi kaha apne👍
Bahaut bariya information sir him bhi music se related hai kya aapke saath kam kar sakta hun mera naam bhi Saurav Ghosh hai
You are really great, sir. Really laudable effort! Kudos!
Thanks a million bro🙏😍🌹
Excellent discussion Dada 🎉💝💐🙏
Shuktiya🙏😍🌹
You have a very nice singing voice with sur. Thanks for the new info about Chaplin. I did not knew he composed his movie music too, and composed that well!
Glad you enjoyed it!! Thanks a ton🙏🌹I have a bengali album from HMV - Neon er alo, if possible listen to it, u will get it the net, Spotify etc. Apart from that in my channel I hv uploaded many hindi song too, shunle bhalo lagbe asha korchi🙏
Bhai aapki voice aur singing style Hemant Da ke jaisa hai...👌👌
Shukriya dil se bhai🙏❤️🌹
Nice information.thank u.salute for Charlie Chaplin.
Thanks to u dost🙏
Thanks Ashokbhai. Quite an eye opener. I never knew this. I have been listening to Indian films songs for nearly seventy years....Amrit from UK
Thanks a bunch brother, means a lot🙏🌹
I appreciate your efforts. Its excellent. Keep it on....best wishes...
Shukriya dil se brother🙏❤️
I came to your channel by chance, my lucky chance..Really enjoyed it. I also liked your singing.
No, its my lucky day☺️thanks a bunch, means a lot🙏☺️🌹 mere channel mein aur bhi bohut sare acche videos hain, waqt mila tou dekhiyega🙏
आपका चैनल तो एक गोल्डमाइन है। आज ही पहला मुलाकात हुया, और सबस्क्राइबर बनकर बड़ा आनन्द लगा।
मेरा ताउ जी भी बम्बई मे परिचालक थे, स्ट्रीट सिंखर, उँचे लोग, येहुदी कि लड़की - शायद आप पहचान लिये है
Shukriya dost, aisehi sath dete rahiyega🙏🌹
Samajh nahi paa raha hun, kripaya bata dijiye, janna chahunga🙏
Nice informative post ; amazed to listen so many Indian songs , based on title music tune of Charlie Chaplain’s Limelight
Shukriya Dost🙏
Take a bow sir....brilliant information. Supremely authentic. Thanks for this video.
So nice of you!! Thats a ton Bro, means a lot🙏🌹
Very interesting. I had always associated the Limelight theme with Pallabini go sancharini and Zindagi hai kya, but had not connected it with a favourite song Tum meri zindagi mein. Thanks for highlighting this.
It's completely my pleasure only, thanks a ton Brother🙏❤️
Very nice presentation. Lots of research, done all alone... 😮
Subscribed!👍
Thanks a bunch bro, means a lot🙏🌹
Great information.
Thanks a bunch🙏🌹
Amazing information. Many of us did not know this. Thanks 👍🙏
Shukriya dost🙏🌹
Extremely interesting and you sing extremely well. Look forward to watching your videos available on RUclips
Oh I m so happy to know that Bro❤️Thanks a ton🙏🌹U can check my channel, I hv uploaded many songs sung by me🙏☺️
वाह!! धन्यवाद सर..फिल्मी संगीत के बारे में, शानदार और ज्ञान वर्धक वीडियो है.🙏
Shukriya Sirji🙏🌹aur bhi aise videos hain mere channel mein, waqt mila tou dekhiyega aur doston mein share bhi kijiyega🙏❤️
Well dome .... very interesting @ Ashok Ghosh ... you sing very well too !!
Thanks a ton Indranath babu, means a lot🙏🌹
If u got time, please watch my other unknown stories and singing videos too in my channel🙏
Thank you very much. It's a very nice and interesting. Appreciating the dedicated efforts ..
Thanks to u for appreciating my efforts and for encouragement too, means a lot🙏🌹
WOW!!! You have done so much research! Great job 👍👍👍
Thanks a bunch for ur appreciation, means a lot🙏🌹
Good video clip. Surprised to know so many copies of the original version.
Thanks a bunch🙏🌹
Very well presented video. I liked the to the point presentation and very factual video.
Glad you liked it! Thanks a bunch🙏🌹
Waah.. bahot badhiya jankaari ❤❤
Shukriya dil se🙏🌹
❤Bahut hi badhiya jankari ❤
Shukriya dil se🙏🌹
वाह अशोक जी!
संगीत प्रेमियों के लिए आप के द्वारा बड़ी ही रोचक जानकारी साक्ष्यों के साथ पेश की गई है। बहुत अच्छा लगा। आशा है भविष्य में भी आप ऐसे ही रोचक कार्यक्रम प्रस्तुत करते रहेंगें। Best wishes❤
Shukriya dil se🙏🌹
Wah Sahab Aap Ne to kamal kar Diye Bahut Achha Laga Yeh Kisse Sunkar
Bohut bohut shukriya Bhai ji🙏🌹
So interesting Ashok .. Waah
Tnx a ton for watching, support and encouraging comments🙏🌹🌺
Thanks ashok g for giving such beautiful memories of great Chaplin my icon ❤️ 💖 ♥️ 💕 💗
Shukriya ji🙏🌹waise Chaplin ji kiske icon nahi they❤️
Your efforts are appreciated and amazing
Thanks a ton🙏🌹
Very interesting and great research work. 🙏🏼
Glad you enjoyed it! Thanks a bunch brother🙏🌹
Great research work Dada!!!!
Thanks a ton brother
🙏🌹
Well done, Ghosh'da. Keep it up.
Thanks a bunch bro, means a lot🙏☺️🌹 mere channel mein aur bhi bohut sare acche videos hain, waqt mila tou dekhiyega🙏
Wow Ghosh babu so much of research. Thanks for sharing 😇💕👌👌👌
Thanks to u Anitha ji for listening, support and for those encouraging comments☺️🌹🌺
Badhiya 👌Ashok ji. I liked rather loved your episode which is of a different mode. . Hope you will continue your such efforts laying emphasis on such unique topics Thanks 🙏 😊
Thanks a ton Bro for the appreciation and encouragement, will try to keep up ur expectations🙏😍🌹
What a fantastic and intricate findings !!
Regards from Kolkata.
Oshesh Dhonnobad, means a lot🙏🌹
Nice video...thanks
Ek ajnabi haseena...also has similarities. Pancham does talk about such variations in a video using an example of Agar Tum Na Hote, Sagar Kinare etc.
Thanks to u too🙏
Good job sir stay blessed🙏
Shukriya dost🙏🌹
You have given precious information. Thanks. Your voice is also very nice!!
So nice of you, means a lot, thanks🙏🌹
Bahut accha laga ❤ Thank you 😊
Thanks to u too for ur appreciation🙏🌹
Woow Ashok Da, Got your Channel with rare information about this tone. Subscribed it.
Ohhhh so glad to know that!! Thank u so much, means a lot🙏😍🌹
Great research work 🌻🙏🏼❤️
Thanks for watching and for ur continuous support😍🌹🌺
Another one but a little concealed. Oh meri Sapno ki saudaagath...Mujhe aisi jagah lay jaa......
Brilliant job Dada! Your research is superb! I shall mail you soon. Myself an ad & Docu maker.
Sure bro, thanks for ur appreciation, means a lot🙏🌹
Namaskar Sir Super super super super super super super Excellent Big Like Video God bless you👌💯💯💯👍 8:43
So nice of you brother, means a lot, thanks🙏❤️🌹
Hats off to your Research and Hardwork.
Thanks a tom bro for ur appreciation and encouragement, means a lot🙏🌹
You habe great voice. 👌
Shukriya dost, means a lot🙏🌹
Very informative video. Thank you.
Glad u liked it, thanks a bunch for that🙏🌹
Dada bahut mahanase banaye mankhus ho gaye apke awaj bhi sundar hain.
Shukriya bhai ji, aapne bhi ye sab kahkar meri mehnat ko safal kar diya aur mera dil khush kar diya, god bless🙏🌹
Good research done sir.
Shukriya dost🙏🌹
Excellent work sir👍👍
Shukriya dost🙏🌹
Salute to you sir for such a high passion for your music 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Thank u so much brother for ur appreciation, means a lot🙏❤️
Charlie's said 'eternally' song is THE ORIGINAL. Those who are commenting otherwise are wrong. It is no way Tchaikovsky. Charlie is the only person in the history of film making who wrote, directed, acted, and scored a motion picture.
Khub valo laglo,apnar gaowa gaangulo chamatkar.
Oshonkho dhonnobad🙏🌹channel ey amar gaoya kichu gaan ache, shomoy pele shunben🙏
Nice video. One small correction. Chaplin ko lifetime achievement ka Oscar dea gaya tha like Our Legend Satyajit Roy, kisi particular dhun ke lie nahin.
No, most of the people are wrong abt it.....posting wiki quote
Chaplin received three Academy Awards: an Honorary Award for "versatility and genius in acting, writing, directing, and producing The Circus" in 1929,[188] a second Honorary Award for "the incalculable effect he has had in making motion pictures the art form of this century" in 1972,[347] and a Best Score award in 1973 for Limelight (shared with Ray Rasch and Larry Russell).[434]
Very good information 🎉👍👍😊
शुक्रिया दोस्त🙏❤️
बहुत सुंदर सृजनात्मक प्रस्तुति 🎉🎉❤
शुक्रिया दोस्त🙏❤️
❤❤❤❤❤ very beautiful ❤️❤️❤️❤️ God bless you Jai mata di vande Mataram ❤❤❤❤❤
Shukriya Dost, jai mata di🙏❤️🌹
You are very sincere and dedicated.. Keep doing this good work. 🎉
Thank you so much for those encouraging words, means a lot🙏🌹
Excellent information about this thanks 🙏.
So nice of you, thanks a bunch🙏🌹
Kiska rasta dekhe ye Dil soudai...ye bhi is dhun se milta hai
Well researched..
Shukriya dost, means a lot🙏🌹
Good information.. thanks a lot..
Glad you liked it, thanks a ton🙏
Excellent. Initially I thought that you will miss the Bengali numbers and I'll mention those. But you are a Bengali yourself and no Bengali music lover can afford to miss Pallabini go sancharini and Ki kore janle tumi. Honestly I had no idea about the Tamil version. Great job.👍
Thank u so much for the appreciation and encouragement, means a lot🙏🌹 Yes, being a Bengali myself, how can I miss those beautiful songs❤️
@AshokTheFunkaar.. Great job! Inspired songs.. the list is long 😂
What is interesting to note is your excellent singing.. seem to be a good Bengali singer singing the evergreen old SL number of Dwijen Mukherjee ‘Pallabini Go Sancharini’!👌
Thank u so much bro for those encouraging words, means a lot bro🙏🌹
Yes, my band Probashi got launched by HMV Saregama in 2006, Album name Neon-er Alo.....having two albums....u can listen to my songs in Spotify, just search Ashok Ghosh in google🙏
U can listen to some of my hindi songs in my channel too
Nice information & observation, can you please find the original guitarist who played the prelude/intro of song pal pal dil ke pass composed by kalyanji anandji from film Blackmail
Shukriya dost for ur appreciation🙏🌹 I will surely try to find out, but normally in that period Bhupender ji use to play all major guiter pieces
Very interesting musical story ! Will hear the full Rafi version in your voice some day
Ohhh would love to do that😍Rafi saheb's version is one of my fav❤️Thx a bunch Rahul for ur encouraging comments, means a lot😍🌹🌺
I have already sang this song that u can hear in my channel🙏❤️
Zindagi Hai Kya Sun Meri Jaan I Mohammed Rafi | Bollywood Classic Hit Song | Dev Anand I Maya 1961
ruclips.net/video/1TnZdEdvfHo/видео.html
Tried to sing this awesome song, hope u like it🙏
Hank you for this sweet informations.
Thanks to u for liking and appreciating it🙏🌹
Commendable research Dada !
Thanks a ton Bhai for ur appreciation, means a lot🙏🌹
Wonderful information sir 👏
Shukriya Sir ji🙏🌹
Ekbar Ek American music composer ne Naushad sb ko kaha tha pahle hindustan se hindustani music ata tha avi to sirf hamara gana ata hai
Never knew these things. Very informative.
Thanks for appreciating my efforts🙏🌹
Very nice information
Shukriya dost🙏🌹channel mein aur bhi aise informative videos hain, time mila tou dekhiyega🙏
Thank you very much 👍
Thanks a ton🙏🌹
Great analysis!!
One thing I would like to say that greatest entertainer The Charlie Chaplin was awarded Oscar in the year 2972 for life time achievement n he also got Oscar for music much earlier year.
Please verify.
Thanks
Thanks Bro🙏 as per my record and whatever info I got from the Net, Charlie Chaplin got Oscar for Lime Light Title music in the year 1973 after the movie reopened in 1972 in Los Angeles
Bahut kuchh sikhneko mila❤🙏
Shukriya dil se🙏❤️
Excellent 👍
Many thanks🙏
There is one more version of this tune in hindi "pyaar ke bani mey from movie "sau crore" released in 1991
Aap bahut acha bolte hain❤
Ohhh so sweet of u, thanks a bunch, means a lot🙏☺️🌹 mere channel mein aur bhi bohut sare acche videos hain, waqt mila tou dekhiyega🙏
Nice information
Thanks a ton🙏🌹
Nice information dada. Bengal and Bengalis are endowed with musical talents which is unparalleled in India.
Thank u so much🙏🌹
Your voice is also very strong 💪 u r also a very good singer ❤️
So nice of u, thanks a bunch🙏🌹if u get time, please listen to my Golden Bollywood Melodies - in my channel podcast/playlist🙏
I won't call these 'copying'. No way.
As only one musical phrase was taken, then the composer took the liberty to give a spin to develop that phrase into a full song by adding 3 or 4 'tuks', composing prelude, interludes, orchestration etc etc..... Hear Salil da's Pallabini go or Itna na mujhse etc. Even for that matter, Salil da's masterly adaptation to compose Dil Tadap Tadap ke from Madhumati. The original Polish song was very slow and not much variation. But Salil da made this into a sparkling diamond by giving his own touch..
However, an excellent job done well, Ashok 👌🏻
Keep on doing your good work.
Fully agree with ur observations bro, thank u so much for ur appreciation🙏🌹
Please show a similar video on French-Arabic song "Ya Mustapha ya Mustapha".
Sure, its already in my list☺️thanks a ton brother🙏❤️
Sure, its already in my list☺️thanks a ton brother🙏❤️
You have great voice.
Thanks a bunch bro🙏🌹
Awesome post
Thanks a bunch for ur appreciation, means a lot🙏☺️🌹
Keep it up, Sir 👍
Thank you Bro, I will surely try🙏🌹
Very good research Mr Ghosh.
Thank u ...
Thanks to u for appreciating my efforts, means a lot Sir🙏🌹
Thank you sir, to know....
So nice of you, thanks a ton🙏🌹
You are very talented sir.... ❤
Shukriya dost, means a lot🙏❤️🌹
बहुत शानदार जानकारी
शुक्रिया दिल से🙏❤️
Nice research work. Also consider other versions as mentioned in the comments, and finally, from where Charli Chaplin himself was inspired!!!
I will surely try bro🙏
Some tunes influence composers too deep to come out. Even Chaplin was not the original composer of this one. However, such tunes remain virgin forever ❤. I like Amit Sadhna duet very much.
Agreed👍