Revolution on the frontier: did the Declaration of Independence matter out there?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024

Комментарии • 78

  • @FrontierTradingCompany
    @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +7

    If you enjoy my content, please consider supporting my channel on Patreon. Patrons receive special perks like early access to videos and opportunities to make it into the credits section at the end of my videos... www.patreon.com/FrontierTradingCompany

  • @jamesvatter5729
    @jamesvatter5729 3 года назад +12

    Great stuff! You summed up thousands of pages of historical reading. Well done.

  • @wyattgardner7999
    @wyattgardner7999 3 года назад +4

    Excellent history lessons. My family help settle Fort Harrod and are buried there. I grew up hearing stories that my Grandmother told me about the Fort and our family when I was a kid. You are a good storyteller of early American history; thanks

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      Very neat family connection! Thanks for watching, I appreciate the comment.

  • @JohnClarke808
    @JohnClarke808 3 года назад +8

    I'm glad I came across your channel. I've always been into the frontier and woodsman. I lost interest, now that I found the channel today I'm ready to get back into it. Thanks

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      Awesome, I'm happy I could help rekindle a passion. This is a great time period to learn about! Thanks for your comment.

  • @hammerhound168
    @hammerhound168 3 года назад +9

    Wow ! You have expanded my understanding of a almost forgotten segment of our history. TY.

  • @72buffaloman
    @72buffaloman 3 года назад +10

    Great stuff! Love the content and the format. In this crazy world just the fact that a young man like yourself is passionate about keeping important history alive is an awseome thing!

  • @landho4k330
    @landho4k330 3 года назад +5

    Very informative thanks

  • @randallledgerwood3949
    @randallledgerwood3949 3 года назад +5

    Just found! I am in BOwling green Ky , we’re are you located !

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      I was recently in BG, KY, for a rifle building class at WKU! You have a beautiful city. I live and film in Northwest Ohio.

  • @michalurbanful
    @michalurbanful 3 года назад +5

    I've just bumped into your channel and it's great. I really like watching this kind of historical/reenactmen stuff from the North American frontier. Keep up the good work. Regards from the Czech Republic.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +3

      Thank you! I believe you are only the second person to comment that they are not from the US. Great that you're watching and I appreciate the comment!

  • @michaeldunwoody3629
    @michaeldunwoody3629 3 года назад +5

    Fascinating! And I thought I was a student of History....

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      Haha, thank you for this comment. We are all students of history! The past informs the present, which impacts the future... I'm just happy to help share what I know of the past, in hopes that it will inspire a more thoughtful present, and ultimately yield a brighter future. Thanks for watching :)

  • @haroldconner2645
    @haroldconner2645 3 года назад +4

    Excellent!
    You could be a university history professor

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      Haha, thank you! I give it my best but I'm afraid I'm not quite that good!

  • @Tadicuslegion78
    @Tadicuslegion78 3 года назад +5

    A Couple weeks ago I finished Blood and Treasure: Daniel Boone and the Fight for America's First Frontier by Bob Drury and Tom Clavin. And then last year Frontier Rebels: The Fight for Independence in the American West, 1765-1776 by Patrick Spero. The general conclusion I take away is it really depending on location and who were the community leaders AND whether or not it was an area known for Indian conflict/unrest from the frontiersmen because of factor X whether because of squatters moving in on Indian land/crooked white merchants/bad land deals or Indians being the aggressors. And, again only having read these two books, it appears that the Frontier was its own war that just so happened to tie to the War for Independence because it was a messy guerilla war of frontiersmen vs Indians with the handful of British Regulars posted out west stuck in their forts so they gave generous incentives for the Indians to fight plus the tribes own grievances at the frontiersmen. And it looks like news from the East about the big events of the Revolution did eventually make it out west, usually weeks or months after BUT the frontiersmen were more concerned about all those tribes lurking out in the woods than an army of redcoats marching down the Wilderness Road

  • @sodapop9mm562
    @sodapop9mm562 3 года назад +4

    I am so happy that i have found this channel. This was just such wonderfully put together video!! Great job and thanks!

  • @ElMachoMucho
    @ElMachoMucho 2 года назад +4

    You deserve waaaaaaay more views

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  2 года назад +1

      Thanks! I'm humbled by the following I already have. I'm just creating the videos I would like to watch, and I'm happy to see others aligning with that vision.

  • @martinmeltzer2696
    @martinmeltzer2696 3 года назад +5

    Some of the militia that fought in Dunsmore's War, were, not long after, busy chasing him out of Virginia and onto a British warship in the Potomac! This was an informative overview of the Revolutionary War West of the Appalachians. George Rogers Clark's successful campaign in the region, enabled the Americans to maintain the slimmest of toeholds and influence with the local Tribes. (Although, the negotiations in Paris that ended the war... also had a lot to do with it, as well.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      Great tidbit about the militia from Dunmore's War! Seems like that was pretty common during the period. I guess things get pretty hectic with the various European powers, tribes, and colonists all interacting with one another!

    • @martinmeltzer2696
      @martinmeltzer2696 3 года назад +2

      @@FrontierTradingCompany Yeah! When you throw in the Spanish in Florida and Louisiana....all the way up to St. Louis, all of the Native Tribes... with their own objectives, AND the Colonists... that were not above using sharp elbows on their fellow Colonies (Pennsylvania was none to happy to have settlers from Connecticut come in and set up shop in what they considered to be their territory. New Hampshire would only participate if New York would renounce all claim to the Green Mountains, etc.. Then all of the newly minted States had to come to terms with the vague Colonial Charters that claimed dominion, "from Sea to Sea"! Things got real complicated, real quick!

  • @concretecowboy4212
    @concretecowboy4212 3 года назад +3

    👍💯🇺🇸

  • @a.z.6725
    @a.z.6725 3 года назад +3

    I just came across your videos. Being a history buff myself, I really appreciate your knowledge, especially about NW Ohio. I live in Toledo and was wandering about the area that you were camping in your videos. Was that public land, and if so, where? Great videos and knowledge. Keep it up!

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      Thank you! This is private land owned by the Boy Scouts of America (now Scouts BSA). I got my start at a scout camp and occasionally stop by and get out into the backcountry there to film. Great to have someone from the NW Ohio area on my channel, thanks for stopping by!

  • @generoush3823
    @generoush3823 3 года назад +3

    Read The Frontiersman about Simon Kenton, great book and it really goes over what was happening in the west during those turbulent years

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      It's one of my favorites! Appreciate the comment and great to see another fan of Eckert's work!

  • @juliebarnett9812
    @juliebarnett9812 3 года назад +4

    This is great work. I really enjoyed your video about the clothing of the time on the Frontier. I love your period-correct outfit. I'm sharing your channel to get you more followers. You're doing some good stuff.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      Thank you so much! Sharing the channel means a lot to me- I work hard to make sure my content has an opportunity to reach as many people as possible but I can only do so much. My goal is to spread a passion for 18th-century American history. Thank you for helping me fulfill my vision! Means a lot.

    • @juliebarnett9812
      @juliebarnett9812 3 года назад +1

      @@FrontierTradingCompany God be with you, brother.

  • @mikegrossberg8624
    @mikegrossberg8624 3 года назад +4

    Was the Mohawk Valley, in upper New York, considered "the frontier"?
    Thinking of the depredations there caused by Butler's Rangers and their indian allies

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      To my understanding it was- I believe about a third of the population in the Mohawk Valley were killed and another third fled or re-identified as Loyalists to avoid the fate of their neighbors... a rough place, for sure. I am making a note to try and incorporate some more NY history in a future video. Appreciate your comment!

    • @mikegrossberg8624
      @mikegrossberg8624 3 года назад +1

      @@FrontierTradingCompany I spent a couple of years re-enacting a civilian scout for a Butler's Rangers unit(I couldn't wear the brimless leather helmet that was regulation; I sunburn real easy, and needed to have my face protected)

    • @timcooke9933
      @timcooke9933 3 года назад +1

      There are a lot of definitions for the word “frontier.” My favorite is an area contested by two, or more, parties that is securely controlled by none. By that definition, the frontier was constantly moving; an amorphous zone that (in the case of the British colonies) moved westward as the coastal area was settled. To answer your question, at the time of the American War of Independence, I would consider the Mohawk Valley still the frontier. It was filling with more British and Dutch farmers, so it wasn’t long before the Indians had been pushed so far out that the area was no longer contested, and thus, no longer the “frontier.”

  • @MorgansRaiders23
    @MorgansRaiders23 3 года назад +4

    An outstanding presentation. It really underscores how convoluted the whole frontier was between the French and Indian War and all the way through the American Revolution. I have studied the 8th Pennsylvania a bit and their role in western Pennsylvania/ eastern Ohio, but never realized the many layers of conflict going on in the territory.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for watching and I appreciate your comment! Very convoluted out there indeed.

  • @tumbleweed6658
    @tumbleweed6658 3 года назад +4

    Very well done I love how you you put your focus on how the Native Peoples played in the American story of independence. Its sad how they were forced to pick sides when all any body really wants is to live in peace.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +1

      Thank you- very sad indeed. Much of the conflict along the frontier was instigated by British-backed Native tribes. The history of Native Americans is an absolutely crucial part of American history as a whole, but unfortunately it is often overshadowed by other events. Thanks for watching and I appreciate the comment!

    • @charlesmaximus9161
      @charlesmaximus9161 2 года назад +1

      @Tumbleweed66:
      With all due respect, it is a bit naive as well as anachronistic to impose postmodern notions of utopian egalitarianism onto peoples of the past, no matter their ethnic extraction. There were indeed peaceful “natives” (I was born on this continent as were my grandparents and theirs before them; am I not also “native”?). But there were also warring tribal nations and confederacies who ate, slept, and breathed perpetual conflict. The Mohawk, to give one example, were anything but peaceful. War wasn’t always conducted as revenge for previous acts of aggression. It could be, of course. But hostilities could also be impersonal and seemingly without justification.
      Modern folks, especially pompous, urban academics, seem to not want to accept this at all. They seem hellbent on reducing everything to this depthless comic bookesque crusade of the Indians fighting some kind of defensive racial war against the “greedy whites”. But real life is never that simple. People are complicated and conflict abounds whenever and wherever people take up space; ethnic distinctions, although significant, are rarely a sole factor.
      I might also add that the story of Euro-Indian relations in North America is not so accurate when seen through a purely racial lens. The Indians were as diverse and distinct from each other as Europeans, and they fought amongst each other far more frequently than against the French, British, Spanish, or Dutch.
      A Cayuga isn’t an Abenaki. A Seneca is not Arapaho. Even within tribal nations there is sometimes bitter rivalry; the northern and southern Cheyenne peoples literally hated each other to the core, despite being from the same tribal nation. I feel that this oversimplified take on their story allows for unnecessary politicisation, which is rather insulting and degrading to their people, as it would be for anyone.

  • @timwarnecke9889
    @timwarnecke9889 3 года назад +5

    Wonder if this is still taught in public schools?

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +3

      Wasn't taught in mine! Trying to preserve it in the best way I know how to. Can only hope that I am doing the history justice.

    • @WKUHilltopper
      @WKUHilltopper 3 года назад +1

      It was in my school, but that was nearly 5 decades ago. Simon Girty still had a bad rap. LOL

    • @juliebarnett9812
      @juliebarnett9812 3 года назад +1

      🤣🤣🤣 Was it ever?

    • @timwarnecke9889
      @timwarnecke9889 3 года назад

      @@juliebarnett9812 was in my school, but I'm old

    • @juliebarnett9812
      @juliebarnett9812 3 года назад +1

      @@timwarnecke9889 I'm no spring chicken, but the only education we received was a week studying the Pilgrims and Indians. It was like 4th grade and we SURE didn't discuss how the people felt about the Declaration of Independence.

  • @Real11BangBang
    @Real11BangBang 3 года назад +5

    Oh yeah it did.

  • @timelesstruth1181
    @timelesstruth1181 Год назад

    Well done!

  • @History_Coffee
    @History_Coffee 3 года назад +3

    Philadelphia, come for the history, stay because you got 15 parking tickets and your car was booted.

  • @robertgriffin9840
    @robertgriffin9840 2 года назад +1

    A wonderful presentation. My 4Xgrreat-grandfather fought in Col Crawford's army of 1782 and rwo years later sailed down the Ohio from Fort Pitt to the Wabash, then up that river to the White River, where the family holdings eventually grew into Decker, Indiana, just south of Post Vincent, today's Vincennes.

  • @lusolad
    @lusolad Год назад +1

    The history of everyday folk can be interesting. Thank you for talking about it.
    Maybe you could do other videos? On Logan, Kenton, or Boone.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  Год назад +1

      Oh, someday! I don’t have nearly the expertise to put together an original presentation on the lives of these names, but someday I will!

  • @mandoman3042
    @mandoman3042 2 года назад +1

    Thank you for teaching our History, unfortunately most Americans do not know their history.

  • @WyomingTraveler
    @WyomingTraveler 2 года назад +1

    A good historical overview, about a year ago I made a video on fort Harrod Kentucky. In your conversation about the Kentucky settlements I think you forgot to mention Bryan Station. The frontiersman also played a major role in the war in the east by their victory at Kings Mountain, South Carolina. Period

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  2 года назад +1

      Very true, thanks for pointing those out. This is a very, very broad overview, and I know I skipped a lot. You have given me some good topics for future videos, though, so I appreciate that!

    • @WyomingTraveler
      @WyomingTraveler 2 года назад

      @@FrontierTradingCompany i’m glad I gave you food for thought. I am very interested in the colonial frontier. Unfortunately being here in Wyoming there’s not much I can do in the way of colonial frontier videos except when I go east as I did at fort Harrod. I know you did the video on Colonel Crawford and I’m not sure how interested you are in colonial frontier history. But the over the mountain man at Kings Mountain is an interesting topic. They literally came out of nowhere defeated the British and then disappeared again. Son did however take part in the battle of Cowpens. Looking forward to more videos from you.

  • @charleslamica5123
    @charleslamica5123 2 года назад +5

    Please keep doing this good work. The history of the 18th century frontier is nearly forgotten today. This stuff is no longer taught in our schools. We've dumbed down our history classes, and in some cases, changed the history to fit modern social and political agendas. I enjoy that you present facts, without taking sides and without apologies. Your approach to history reminds me of the excellent books written by Allan Eckert.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  2 года назад +2

      Eckert's work "The Frontiersman" got me into this hobby years ago, so that is some very high praise. Thank you! More videos to come!

  • @drscharmer
    @drscharmer 3 месяца назад

    Awesome job! Please consider doing a video on the second siege of Ft Henry and the evidence supporting the legend of Betty Zane. Col Shepherd was the Commandant over Col Zane during this battle. Col Shepherd was also the original owner of my 1760 stone farmhouse in Shepherdstown WV.

  • @rebeccaback3287
    @rebeccaback3287 Год назад

    Excelente presentación! Glad that you take pride in our Constitution! David Back.

  • @charlesmaximus9161
    @charlesmaximus9161 2 года назад

    Well done! I love how you illustrate the social and political atmosphere of this period without trying to superimpose silly 21st century pseudo-academic “woke” politicisation onto this very specialised historical subject. You simply present the history as it happened and for that I admire your work. The Midwest, from what I can tell, seems to really value their regional history and takes great care to preserve it’s dignity.
    I live in southern New England, where conflicts like the Pequot War and the southern theatre of King Philip’s War happened. Unfortunately, our rich, regional history is swiftly being eroded away by pompous “woke” urbanites from Harvard, Amherst, etc. seeking to redefine these complicated territorial wars as some kind of oversimplified racial war between ethnic groups. Many a precious monument stands defenceless in their political crosshairs. Statues to colonial women like Hannah Dustin and monuments to the great Myles Standish, as well as other colonial folk heroes have all either been altered, removed, or are on the list and awaiting removal.
    Thankfully, there are a few obscurer ones that they have not yet discovered, and I only pray it stays that way until this absurd social trend of insanity passes. I wish you all the best and I thank you for upholding our story of the Ohio frontier! God bless you and yours.

  • @wadelomax7621
    @wadelomax7621 Год назад +1

    Can you bump your volume up some

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  Год назад

      I have learned a lot about audio since making this video and can promise better quality in the future! Thanks!

  • @anidaralopez5676
    @anidaralopez5676 3 года назад +4

    Maybe you are, but if not....you should be an American History teacher in public school.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  3 года назад +2

      I appreciate that, it means a lot. I am in college but I am not studying education!

  • @McGintyNHD
    @McGintyNHD 2 года назад +1

    There's a lot lacking here. The role of the Frontier in the AWI is significantly more active than you're giving it credit for. Parts of Virginia's frontier were the first to be willing to break away from the Crown, and the contributions made by frontiersman in the eastern theater starting in 1775 with the beeline March, were significant. You've also lost a lot of the nuance of the war in the west. In many ways the approach of the Americans, particularly virginians, was intensely antagonistic and expansionist.

    • @FrontierTradingCompany
      @FrontierTradingCompany  2 года назад +1

      Great points! Thanks for watching. Your comments sound well informed, and as an amateur college student looking for mentorship, I'd be happy to chat more via email if you feel that you could be a value-add for any future content. My address is emailfrontiertradingco@gmail.com.