The one clip that you comment on where his voice sounds very, very different from his usual sound is not actually him singing live, it's the studio version of the song (More Than This) that the one direction official channel (i think) put over actual live footage of the band singing the song on tour, and I've always been very confused as to why the original maker of this compilation put it in the video. As you say, the production team on the song probably did a lot of stuff to his voice to make him sound "younger", as was the case with a lot of zayn's studio vocals during his time in the group, which he has stated since leaving; they would tweak his voice until it sounded as "Pop" as possible, which is a real shame when you know what his voice actually sounds like live. Every past member of 1D sounds extremely different, but Zayn really was always in a league of his own, and that is just stating facts (he sang the high notes because his voice was the only voice that allowed for that kind of range and power). I think he still has the possibility to grow technically of course, but his raw natural talent and the extreme power of his voice is already enough to sing circles around pretty much whatever you give to him. I would be really interested to hear your thoughts on how his voice has grown through the years, so definitely check out hs newer stuff. Concerning the other 1D boys, I'd recommend checking out Harry Styles, his voice was always my second favourite, not to mention his and Zayn's vocals go beautifully together, but that's a different story (and I've nerded out enough as it is lol). Great video!
Tristan Paredes yes please, I commented on the video of you comparing Demi & Camila asking you to check out Harry Styles. Whether it be his transformation from 1D to now, or just his new stuff actually has pretty incredible vocals. I do believe Zayn stood out more because he was given the higher notes since he had the stronger voice but to me that didn't challenge the others. Harry has an amazing voice & great vocals as well. PLEASE DO A VIDEO ON HIM!!! 💕😍
I agree with you on some aspects of this but you should really listen to Liam and Harry's high notes. (Liam is a big one. I believe the only reason he didn't get all those high notes was that when the band first started Liam's voice was the most reliable so he ending up starting most of one directions song and then having Harry carry them through most of the choruses) but Zayn was definitely a big voice within his time in One Direction as he brought the rock and edgy sound to the band. Liam definitely has the range for Zayn's notes, I just think he struggles with keeping power in his voice.
Zayns voice is especially beautiful when he adds little inflections to it that make it sound like a traditional pakistani raag, like the end of dusk till dawn
Whenever Zayn is appreciated for anything it makes me so happy that he is getting what he deserves. And also you should check out Liam, Louis, Niall and Harry too. All of them are individually so different and unique vocally .
they all have great voices but zayn's voice always stood out to me and i realized it was bc his voice is so full. like,,, his vocals are so powerful and stable. it amazes me when he goes from his very masculine vocals to super high-pitch notes. i mean... HOW??
he was like "he‘s just sitting there..." and i can proudly say that i‘m not the only directioner who thought "oh well have you ever seen a 1D concert? they fall, they jump, they have waterfights, the sit around, read or eat while performing, they google how to twerk, they make human pyramids and dress up as hotdogs and bananas"
He wasn't saying it in a bad way tho... He was saying that Zayn is so relaxed and able to hit those high notes so effortlesley whilst sitting there. He's not saying Zayns not doing anything.
Yes, Zayn has always stood out, vocally. His voice is so powerful, strong and absolutely beautiful. Although I was upset when he left the band, as soon as his album came out, I was like, "BEST DECISION EVER". He is better as a solo artist, and I like being able to just focus on him when he sings. I love Zayn soooo much. Not only is he a good singer, but he's definitely model quality.😍😍😍❤❤❤❤
@@celinecasaux7199 technically I think his voice is stronger than H's. Harry tends to strain a lot, and his range is in fact smalled than Z's. But sound wise - it's a personal taste.
Honestly, I agree, I cried when he left 😂 but his style was INSANELY different than what 1D was putting out and it didn’t allow him to show what he could do Harry is beautifully talented in his own way, they’re stronger in different ways, and have hella different styles I wouldn’t compare them too much, although Zayn does have a wider range for sure
Zayn Malik is my most favourite singer ever. I have been following his journey since 2010 it’s been 8 years and I will follow him till the end cause I genuinely love this guy. I just told my parents my grades and my dad wanted better but I was still feeling a bit broken but watching this video has just made me happy. Just the thought of him makes me happy and feel better but I want to thank u for making this video cause I love ur videos and this is like my most favourite video of urs. Thank you.
I'd be interested in seeing you react to Harry styles because he gets a lot of hype, but I'm wondering what you'd think from a technical singing point of view?
definitely think you should react to harry!!! also it would be great if you could react to Sigrid, her voice is amazing. she can literally belt out her singles and it sounds exactly like the studio version. and my last suggestion would be greyson chance :)
I think Harry is my favorite vocalist to come out of 1D because his voice and the style of music he’s pursuing fits him so well?? But I’ve always adored the hell out of Zayns voice because it’s so clear and crisp sounding
Hannah Parsons I love Zayn and I definitely think he has an amazing voice in terms of high notes and whatnot but I reckon Liam has a better voice vocally. If you guys see and concentrate on how he keeps and carries the group while they all sing you’d be astonished. Don’t forget that he did do some Zayn’s high notes when he left and sang his parts.
@@malikisbae6875 yes ofc i get your point but this person was just pointing out how cute louis was looking at zayn?? what‘s wrong with that. both deserve attention.
@@almah.m.8188 No, that comment was not pointing out how cute Louis was _looking at Zayn_ , it was about how cute Louis is. And while I agree, it's still not about him. Let it be about only Zayn when it is actually about him.
That’s why I said at the beginning of their careers I feel like people on RUclips see one part and ready to be like no no no what about this person I clearly said when the first started. I never said I didn’t like the others voices nor did I say everyone’s solo music wasn’t good, I just said that in the beginning he had the strongest voice have a strong voice has nothing to do with the music others are coming out with
Tyler Beauty when they first started? You mean x factor right? Im not a huge fan but from what I can remember at x factor was that basically Harry and Liam carried them through the competition.... Zayn only began to shine in 2012... this is just what I think since I did not notice Zayn a lot in x factor.
NoInspirationFor SomeDecentName if that's true... It was because Simin thought they were the most marketable Only... Especially seeing as Liam sucks the Hardest now.. next to the one with a baby who is a non factor completely
DEFINITELY PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF MUSIC check out Louis Tomlinson's notes and actually mainly just his voice in general because its so unique people never appreciate it as he is a Male singer with a naturally high voice (he literally carried all their choruses and tied them all in if you look up 1D with his voice edited out it sounds so wrong)
People overlook him because his voice isn't as powerful as the others. The one song where I do appreciate his voice is in, "No Control". His voice is good, but not as good as the rest, as a whole though they sound good all together. If you take your time to listen to them individually he would be 4th vocally. In 5th place would be Niall. 3rd would be Liam. 2nd would be Harry. And 1st would be the best voice in One Direction, Zayn Malik.
PerhapsFuckOffIsTooKind yeah, harry is more of an emotional singer than a technical one. doesn't make his voice any less pleasant or beautiful. plus, There aren't any recent and good compilations of his best vocal moments (especially during his tour), so i agree with you.
yes I feel like Louis is so so underappreciated!!! during the 1d days I LIVED for every louis solo like a girl desperate for water in the middle of a drought
Delisha I’ve been a 1d Stan for 7 years, and I know that louis has a very LIMITED vocal range aaahahahaha he can hit the notes in his range really well, but he can’t hit low notes or high notes lol I still love him tho
Willow Agreed! I love him and Niall but let’s be honest, Zayn, Harry and Liam were carrying their weight. Vocally, they were the least talented which is why they barely ever sang. This isn’t hate, because I loved 1D but it’s just facts.
Zayn has a really smooth and gentle voice, and especially in Steal My Girl, you can tell those parts were made for him. It just doesn’t sound *good* with Liam singing it (no hate to Liam). Also, in some of these clips, I can tell he has performance anxiety. Just the way he’s standing, holding his mike, and his facial expressions
I wouldn't say it doesn't sound good, but as it wasn't made for Liam it's just not the same and sounds different, and of course we're used to zayn, so...
@@xD-rv8cs gosh I wrote this just 2 months after becoming a directioner That’s crazy I can’t even remember the beginning of it all starting for me But yeah it did sound good, it sounded great because by all means Liam sounds great singing anything, but it was made for Zayn and just don’t sound as good as when Z sang it
Yes you should check out his latest release Entertainer. Love that track. I feel Zayn has very good control, during live performances I've almost never seen him falter (there are very few live performances of his solo project). And he's very consistent as well, his live sounds incredibly identical to the studio recordings. Although I have almost no knowledge about technique, I still always felt like he sings with ease, even in the higher register. He never seems to strain. Like you noticed, he'll just be sitting/standing all chill and hitting all these notes with not much visible strain. And his runs always sound smooth (he isn't really doing anything crazy though). His live performance of It's You (title: ZAYN - iT’s YoU Live on the Honda Stage at the iHeartRadio Theater NY) is worth checking out as well. 😊
DUH you need to check eveything zayn ! 1. Dusk till dawn 2. Let me 3. Entertainer 4. Trampoline (with shaed) 5. Common Gah there are so many good songs I cant decide!
If it's about high notes my opinion is : 1 Zayn 2 Harry 3 Liam 4 Louis 5 Niall No hate it's my opinion. Edit : Again, it's my opinion based on what I've heard. But if I have to choose between them, Niall is my fave.
You should honestly react to all five of them. Zayn has the most emotional voice, I think he’s amazing but Liam Payne is probably the best technical singer in the band. Harry Styles has a really beautiful voice (rock edge to it). I find Niall Horan’s voice to be the most soothing. I’ve always thought that Louis Tomlinson’s voice was very interesting and unique. (I’m kinda obsessed with it) I don’t really know how to explain it 🤔 his voice sounds high and I don’t know if it’s the right word to use but also kinda polished. I find him carrying the choruses in many 1D songs. It’s weird because some people love his voice but others can’t stand it and don’t think he can sing at all.
liam can hit those high notes too but idk why i always loved zayns more maybe it was because liam’s were so perfect and clean and zayns were more like akdpdlwkdkeis
Liam has a very wide range indeed, but their coaches in One Direction always put Zayn on the high notes and Liam in the middles/lows, that's why you don't hear him hitting crazy notes even though he's capable of doing it.
He’s a really good vocalist but I prefer the voice of Harry personally, I think they are all super talented in their way, they are not good for the same things
also Mah-lick (or Muh-lick depending on where ur from with the british accent lol) not Muh-leek, but this dude is adorable and was so nice in his review that i'm not even mad lol
Some of Zayn's singles are really good I recommend Dusk till Dawn, Let Me, and I Don't Want to Live Forever. I would also recommend listening to Liam Payne and Harry Styles they both have evolved and some of their singles have really great vocals. They have all gone into different pathways though, especially Harry Styles.
Would love to hear your opinion on Liam. Though I don't love his solo work, I do think he has a lot of potential as well. His singing to me sounds solid and he has a very warm sound, being able to reach low as well as very high notes. Unfortunately his voice doesn't stand out as much with a very unique tone as Harry's or Zayn's Love Zayn and Niall's songs after One Direction the most! Especially Zayn has this very recognizable warm, soulful, sexy sound which is great for hiphop/ R&B, and with his new songs he is experimenting with soul and funk as well (sounds like he is influenced by Prince and MJ, a bit similar to the Weeknd). Niall made a good choice going for his singer/songwriter style with pop-rock and country influences mixed in. His voice sounds much stronger and more stable now than in the band. I think all the boys made great choices going into different genres and directions (pun intended) suitable to their voices and singing style.
"Unfortunately his voice doesn't stand out as much with a very unique tone as Harry's or Zayn's", god, I 100% agree with this, I've said the exact same thing before. If you're comparing vocal tones in that band, Liam's would rank lowest simply because the other 3 (or 4, if you're counting Zayn) have very distinct tones. I also think that that is the reason Liam's vocals remain underrrated, even to this day.
I agree with everything you have to say about Liam sans the last line of the first paragraph. I think his voice would be extremely recognisable if he didn't present songs that sound like every other pop artist out there. This guy's voice is crazy versatile, and if he went into a genre that could show that off (I would love for him to do some jazz, but I don't think that's going to happen 😭) his voice would be a lot more distinct.
@@katelynn117_ I have the feeling(/hope) on his album will be a lot of ballads and slow songs. Maybe he just wants to explore styles he never tried in the band and wants to make himself a name in the industry before he releases the whole album. Singer always make their singles blend in with the other popular music. But his voice is really recognizable. It's just a really clean, smooth sound.
@@amelie5835 That could very well be the case. I'm just a little disheartened because he was the entire reason I ever started listening to the band in the first place. The amount of control he has with his voice is so rare in his particular industry, and it's frustrating not hearing it be used.
I personally think you just should react to One Direction's best vocals. Like, I would want to se what you think of all of their individual vocals rather than just one of them. (Also, Liam has the best vocal range in my opinion.)
Liam has the highest vocal range, but what makes Zayn better in my opinion is that he can hold it longer and because of that it's more powerful. Liam has trouble holding his range which is what gets him down. If he would work on that, he would be the white version of Jason Derulo.
Liam can’t hit very many low notes lol. I think harry can hit the lowest, zayn can do the highest, nialls pretty much in the middle, and Louis has very limited range lol rip
My fave thing right now is a video of the boys singing c'mon c'mon zayns voice really stands out also they turned it into a meme that says "when it's a group project but your graded individually". And totally check out Harry Styles his music is very different from the other guys, but as he has grown his voice has become totally different from his 1D days
When I went see him live in 2014 he sounded really bright and sweet more than he does from tv or radio. He's amazing though i was shocked his voice sounded that different.
Harry is a good artist but not a good live performer ..... His live performances are so weak .... Zayn's vocals a very powerful because he has very high vocal range & has a good control on his voice ....... I like Harry but in terms of vocals he failed many times
Honestly one of the most incredible things about One Direction is how well they fit together in every way, in terms of personality and vocality. Zayn has fantastic high notes and riffs, but he's much quieter personality-wise. Niall has a much brighter personality and brought the musical cred of playing guitar, but his voice was more unpolished early on. Liam was hard-working and determined, and his voice might be one of the most versatile I've ever heard -- fantastic falsettos, beautiful bass notes, and an incredible ability to adapt and improvise -- but as valuable as his drive was he was almost too serious sometimes. Harry also has a vibrant personality, so charismatic, and he's a fantastic all-around singer, but he was too young and too sensitive to make it alone. Louis' voice is not as technically polished, but it's so unique, and he's so good at projecting emotion when he sings so you feel every word. Plus he's so bright and friendly and funny that he draws people in and makes them want to see more. He's the leader, the glue that holds them together. He does goofy or childish things sometimes, so he can look a bit irresponsible despite being the oldest, but he's actually so mature and always looks out for all of them. Also I'm sure no one can tell who my favourite is because I'm totally not biased nope I love them all equally (just some are more equal than others)
He needs to get away from 1 Direction. A little jealousy and a lot of gay stuff going on in that group! They messed up their group with all that plus everyone wants to be the leader!
There are many Zayn's best live vocals here Tristan, you should check them, they are much better than this and you can see Zayn's like I would or It's You live performances. For me, he is/was the best vocalist in 1D and I'm really happy that you start to react of him. Love Zayn and you xx
I will always believe that Zayn outshined the rest of One Direction. People hate me for saying it, but it doesn’t mean I love any of the other boys any less. I just think he deserved way better from the beginning had he been a little more confident in himself.
TuccTownLaydii I totally agree with you. He had the best voice in One Direction by far. So when he went solo I was upset at first, but when his album came out, I was like, "BEST DECISION EVER"!
Zayn always did all the high notes in the band, while Harry did all the chorus. Liam was more of the rapper as always, while Louis and Niall were always almost in the background which little solos on some songs.
The one clip that you comment on where his voice sounds very, very different from his usual sound is not actually him singing live, it's the studio version of the song (More Than This) that the one direction official channel (i think) put over actual live footage of the band singing the song on tour, and I've always been very confused as to why the original maker of this compilation put it in the video. As you say, the production team on the song probably did a lot of stuff to his voice to make him sound "younger", as was the case with a lot of zayn's studio vocals during his time in the group, which he has stated since leaving; they would tweak his voice until it sounded as "Pop" as possible, which is a real shame when you know what his voice actually sounds like live.
Every past member of 1D sounds extremely different, but Zayn really was always in a league of his own, and that is just stating facts (he sang the high notes because his voice was the only voice that allowed for that kind of range and power). I think he still has the possibility to grow technically of course, but his raw natural talent and the extreme power of his voice is already enough to sing circles around pretty much whatever you give to him. I would be really interested to hear your thoughts on how his voice has grown through the years, so definitely check out hs newer stuff. Concerning the other 1D boys, I'd recommend checking out Harry Styles, his voice was always my second favourite, not to mention his and Zayn's vocals go beautifully together, but that's a different story (and I've nerded out enough as it is lol). Great video!
interesting!!!
Tristan Paredes yes please, I commented on the video of you comparing Demi & Camila asking you to check out Harry Styles. Whether it be his transformation from 1D to now, or just his new stuff actually has pretty incredible vocals. I do believe Zayn stood out more because he was given the higher notes since he had the stronger voice but to me that didn't challenge the others. Harry has an amazing voice & great vocals as well. PLEASE DO A VIDEO ON HIM!!! 💕😍
They should be listening zayn's singing in live version
I agree with you on some aspects of this but you should really listen to Liam and Harry's high notes. (Liam is a big one. I believe the only reason he didn't get all those high notes was that when the band first started Liam's voice was the most reliable so he ending up starting most of one directions song and then having Harry carry them through most of the choruses) but Zayn was definitely a big voice within his time in One Direction as he brought the rock and edgy sound to the band. Liam definitely has the range for Zayn's notes, I just think he struggles with keeping power in his voice.
this comment is LIFE, thanks
“He’s just sitting there” lmfao that’s my favorite thing about Zayn he doesn’t have to strain or even try too hard
he does strain sometimes like Harry, Zayn has more high voice with his high notes, meanwhile Harry has a lot of range and unique voice, I prefer Harry
angela martirosyan i love both but harry has not a very wide vocal range like zayn has but his voice is definitely beautiful too
angela martirosyan Harry is a B-List vocalist while Zayn is an A-List vocalist. That means vocally, Zayn will always be better than him.
angela martirosyan its always harry harry and harry. Why cant you guys be happy for zayn cuz hes good
angela martirosyan why do you have to bring him up?
when he hits that high note in “you and i” i get chills every time
same
Who doesnt
Omg same
Who doesn't actually 😂
You and I gets chills 🤧😏
Tristan smiling through the whole video because he cannot deny Zayn is crazy good looking
zainabhussainZM08 me too honestly
😂
is he gay?
@@YK-ky2cs please explain how can he BE Islam?😂
Islam is a religion just like Christianity.
@@YK-ky2cs 😂 😂 I don't think him being part of Islam has anything to do with his genetic looks
Zayns voice is especially beautiful when he adds little inflections to it that make it sound like a traditional pakistani raag, like the end of dusk till dawn
Mariam Ali I thought I was the only one who noticed that at the end of Dusk Till Dawn!! You’re right though like, his voice is great
I didn't noticed 😮💘
Its not Pakistani its basically Indian
I agree
It's Not Pakistani Raag.., It's INDIAN Raag. He love Bollywood and Indian Songs. And always talk about it.
Are we just gonna ignore the fact he said Zayn Maleek instead of Malik
we will just ignore it and act as if it never happened or a war will take place in the comment
lol i was searching through the comments to see if anyone mentioned thats hahaha
If I didn’t find a comment like this I was going to say something 😂
It can be Maleek because in arabic you pronounce it like that or it’s either pronounced marlik
Exactly lmaoosnndjx
The You & I high note literally makes me forget how to breathe
same
Same
@@lisa-qu2kj yes ash
same
0:53-0:59 that’s what you hear when you arrive in heaven 🤤
Which song is that???
@@manvi9831You and I
Listen to that with full volume on headset
ikr-
😅😅 so truee
Those British and Pakistani genes tho.. Mixed and produced that beautiful boy..
He is not mixed?
@@fluffyjimin5612 yes he's mixed cause a british white mom and a pakistani dad
I agree
ikrrr
@@fluffyjimin5612 he is
"his voice has definitely improved not that he was ever bad" preach 🙌👊
Whenever Zayn is appreciated for anything it makes me so happy that he is getting what he deserves. And also you should check out Liam, Louis, Niall and Harry too. All of them are individually so different and unique vocally .
I agree!
Btw, love your profile pic lol
I'd really love to see some Niall content. He had has some really great vocals both in 1D and solo.
harry , niall , louis are not that special.
@@moizabdul5384 Harry is
Liam has the best vocals after Zayn
they all have great voices but zayn's voice always stood out to me and i realized it was bc his voice is so full. like,,, his vocals are so powerful and stable. it amazes me when he goes from his very masculine vocals to super high-pitch notes. i mean... HOW??
homeboy looks so mesmerised with zayn. the way he smiles at zayn and his “woooo.” same. 😂😂
Ikr 😂 but then again I can't blame him 😂
he was like "he‘s just sitting there..." and i can proudly say that i‘m not the only directioner who thought "oh well have you ever seen a 1D concert? they fall, they jump, they have waterfights, the sit around, read or eat while performing, they google how to twerk, they make human pyramids and dress up as hotdogs and bananas"
So sad that I wasn’t able to be in their concerts...
Me too
He wasn't saying it in a bad way tho... He was saying that Zayn is so relaxed and able to hit those high notes so effortlesley whilst sitting there. He's not saying Zayns not doing anything.
@@maymunaraj8511 i know xD
@@lolos.9570 Okay😆
Yes, Zayn has always stood out, vocally. His voice is so powerful, strong and absolutely beautiful. Although I was upset when he left the band, as soon as his album came out, I was like, "BEST DECISION EVER". He is better as a solo artist, and I like being able to just focus on him when he sings. I love Zayn soooo much. Not only is he a good singer, but he's definitely model quality.😍😍😍❤❤❤❤
truee❤💯💯
I honestly think that zayn is as talented as harry
Celine Casaux he’s better than harry
@@celinecasaux7199 technically I think his voice is stronger than H's. Harry tends to strain a lot, and his range is in fact smalled than Z's. But sound wise - it's a personal taste.
Honestly, I agree, I cried when he left 😂 but his style was INSANELY different than what 1D was putting out and it didn’t allow him to show what he could do
Harry is beautifully talented in his own way, they’re stronger in different ways, and have hella different styles I wouldn’t compare them too much, although Zayn does have a wider range for sure
React to my little Irish baby, Niall. Him and Louis were always under appreciated.
YEEEEAH
People always talks about Tommy, but Niall was very underappreciated too.
I'm so proud of his actual thing ❤❤
Yass thank you
...yes, because they can't hold a candle to Zayn, Harry or Liam.
NIALLLLL HORAN
Yea
*Admit* *it* *he* *is* *amaZAYN*
VERONICA MALIK WILL YOU MARRY ME😩⁉️
@@os5988 NO ME
"Zayn Maleeeek" 😂
Ikr😂 I died
Hamna and Momina as soon as he said his name I stopped and went to the comments 🤦🏾♂️
Jayy Boone me too 😂
it's Malik
Yelani Samaratunga She is saying Maleek because that's the way Tristan said it
Please listen to Zayn solo like “it’s you” live he’s really good there.
React to Icarus Falls! Zayn's new album! 😅
STREAM ICARUS FALLS
Gouthami Shivaprakash yassss
My God. Please do a reaction on it!!!
Yes that would be great
Yesss
Zayn is insanely talented and beautiful. PERIOD. ❤
Zayn Malik is my most favourite singer ever. I have been following his journey since 2010 it’s been 8 years and I will follow him till the end cause I genuinely love this guy. I just told my parents my grades and my dad wanted better but I was still feeling a bit broken but watching this video has just made me happy. Just the thought of him makes me happy and feel better but I want to thank u for making this video cause I love ur videos and this is like my most favourite video of urs. Thank you.
I'd be interested in seeing you react to Harry styles because he gets a lot of hype, but I'm wondering what you'd think from a technical singing point of view?
YES
That's my husband
Sophie Wilson I love the fuck out of Harry’s voice but apparently on a technical level his technique is really unhealthy and bad :(
ruclips.net/video/B4pCX7M6qbM/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/JB6ovp0qeMA/видео.html
Some good videos of harrys vocals to react to.
Sophie Wilson yeah
this should be called "vocal coach falls in love with zayn malik for 7 minutes and 7 seconds"
i’m sad you didn’t react to him singing “it’s you” live, that is just incredible😭
Kimberly Esparza I know this comment is kinda old but I was thinking the same thing 😭
react to harrys best vocals! Im curious what your take on raspy vocals are
Presley Luis raspy and belty! His album is rock n roll and it’s awesome!
Presley Luis Same!!
Presley Luis he did react. Harry IS AWESOME
Please react to Harry Styles - Sign of the Times at the Graham Norton Show!!
Perrie Styles oh god I love ur channel haha
I LOVE YOUR CHANNEL
also, Ever Since New York on SNL last year, that one was really cool
Perrie Styles mixer and directioner 😘💋❤️❤️😍
Perrie Styles love your channel
You should react to 14 times zayn's vocals got me shook
Yeah I thought so too 😂
Yes!!!!
Yessssss
SnowFlake exactly 🙌🏻😍
definitely think you should react to harry!!!
also it would be great if you could react to Sigrid, her voice is amazing. she can literally belt out her singles and it sounds exactly like the studio version. and my last suggestion would be greyson chance :)
This video was *amazayn*
I love you
lmfao waiting for someone else to say it
lol I liked your comment because we have the same profile picture 😂
Mafer Zegarra just fabolouis!
I understand that refrence
Zayn Maaaalik. Not Maleeek.
Meaning is the same
@@mehdyelabidine8921 But the pronunciation is different
@@lisarayew.1714 : you are right Malek means Angel, Malik means king or sultan , a monarque... Salut!
It’s not even Maaalik. It’s more like ‘Muh-lick’
@@HPisAWESOME22 I've never heard anyone pronounce it like that
I think Harry is my favorite vocalist to come out of 1D because his voice and the style of music he’s pursuing fits him so well?? But I’ve always adored the hell out of Zayns voice because it’s so clear and crisp sounding
Bri Schneider I’m late, but I 100% agree
Yes same here very true
exactly! my favorite person ever is harry and his voice is just WAW but like zayn's voice is amazing i've always loved his high notes
Harry is a nice entertainer but notes!? ZAYN❤️
Zayn is the best
3:36 me every single time i watch zayn
Rania SAME, he’s an actual god
What's the song befour that ?
@@abrilorozko9987 man in the mirror by Michael Jackson
I thought zayn was always the strongest vocalist in one direction
Hannah Parsons he is in fact is
I agree
Technically Liam is a little better. But they're both amazing.
Jules M Liam can go very high but Zayn has the best control over his vocals which makes him a better vocalist
Hannah Parsons I love Zayn and I definitely think he has an amazing voice in terms of high notes and whatnot but I reckon Liam has a better voice vocally. If you guys see and concentrate on how he keeps and carries the group while they all sing you’d be astonished. Don’t forget that he did do some Zayn’s high notes when he left and sang his parts.
5:32
Okay but can we admire how cute Louis is? Thank you
This is a video about Zayn... ? Can we keep it about just Zayn for this video? Thank you.
@@malikisbae6875 shut up?
@@almah.m.8188 Why tf? As I said, it's about Zayn. Keep it about him for once
@@malikisbae6875 yes ofc i get your point but this person was just pointing out how cute louis was looking at zayn?? what‘s wrong with that. both deserve attention.
@@almah.m.8188 No, that comment was not pointing out how cute Louis was _looking at Zayn_ , it was about how cute Louis is. And while I agree, it's still not about him. Let it be about only Zayn when it is actually about him.
Tristen: Zayn Maleek
me: Malik.. its Malik
Do his actual songs. His solo career
The song its you has the best high note, literally.
zainabhussainZM08 sHe?
@@BeanSneaksPH yep oh my gawwddd and dusk till dawn UGH NAME A SONG WITHOUT HIS PERFECT ANGELIC HIGH NOTESSS
He barely do live so hard to judge you know
Honestly Zayn to me was the only one who was strong enough to be solo when he first audition for Xfactor. Please react to his new single it’s amazing
I thought the same but the other boys a bringen some good music out like harry with sign of the times and Niall with this town and so on.
That’s why I said at the beginning of their careers I feel like people on RUclips see one part and ready to be like no no no what about this person I clearly said when the first started. I never said I didn’t like the others voices nor did I say everyone’s solo music wasn’t good, I just said that in the beginning he had the strongest voice have a strong voice has nothing to do with the music others are coming out with
Tyler Beauty when they first started? You mean x factor right? Im not a huge fan but from what I can remember at x factor was that basically Harry and Liam carried them through the competition.... Zayn only began to shine in 2012... this is just what I think since I did not notice Zayn a lot in x factor.
NoInspirationFor SomeDecentName if that's true... It was because Simin thought they were the most marketable Only... Especially seeing as Liam sucks the Hardest now.. next to the one with a baby who is a non factor completely
Yessss please react to more of his singles and live performances
DEFINITELY PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF MUSIC check out Louis Tomlinson's notes and actually mainly just his voice in general because its so unique people never appreciate it as he is a Male singer with a naturally high voice (he literally carried all their choruses and tied them all in if you look up 1D with his voice edited out it sounds so wrong)
His voice is weak and thin as fuck?
Harrison Nguyen you are brave for replying something so wrong I'll give you that
People overlook him because his voice isn't as powerful as the others. The one song where I do appreciate his voice is in, "No Control". His voice is good, but not as good as the rest, as a whole though they sound good all together. If you take your time to listen to them individually he would be 4th vocally. In 5th place would be Niall. 3rd would be Liam. 2nd would be Harry. And 1st would be the best voice in One Direction, Zayn Malik.
Harrison Nguyen Right? I’m like, damn are we even talking about the same guy anymore? Lol
That dude cant sing.. Stop making him relevant.
PLEASEEE REACT TO "A WHOLE NEW WORLD " ZAYN AND ZHAVIAA!! its from aladinn!!
Reacted
@@tarannumkhan7539 🤦🏻♂️🤕🤦🏻♂️
You should react to Harry styles singing Sign of the times, especially after the bridge
V Schwarz Yes!!
Yaas! ruclips.net/video/Y8R-zl7SDUU/видео.html or ruclips.net/video/fc1xsOr9Zek/видео.html
V Schwarz he puts so much emotion into it but from a technical standpoint he’s got a really bad damaging technique so I don’t want him to react 😭
PerhapsFuckOffIsTooKind
yeah, harry is more of an emotional singer than a technical one. doesn't make his voice any less pleasant or beautiful. plus, There aren't any recent and good compilations of his best vocal moments (especially during his tour), so i agree with you.
PerhapsFuckOffIsTooKind lol that's WHY I want him to react to it because I want to know how he can improve
React to Louis Tomlinson, the most underappreciated member of One Direction. Hisvoice literally sounds like an angel, it's so unique.
yes I feel like Louis is so so underappreciated!!! during the 1d days I LIVED for every louis solo like a girl desperate for water in the middle of a drought
Delisha I’ve been a 1d Stan for 7 years, and I know that louis has a very LIMITED vocal range aaahahahaha he can hit the notes in his range really well, but he can’t hit low notes or high notes lol I still love him tho
Willow Agreed! I love him and Niall but let’s be honest, Zayn, Harry and Liam were carrying their weight. Vocally, they were the least talented which is why they barely ever sang. This isn’t hate, because I loved 1D but it’s just facts.
Delisha and that's the tea sis
But his voice is so cute. Give him a chance you guys 😂
I want someone to look at me like the way Tristan looks at Zayn
Bianca Lozano check out how he looks at Brendon. It makes Zayn look like just a teenage crush. (Love him btw)
Zayn has a really smooth and gentle voice, and especially in Steal My Girl, you can tell those parts were made for him. It just doesn’t sound *good* with Liam singing it (no hate to Liam).
Also, in some of these clips, I can tell he has performance anxiety. Just the way he’s standing, holding his mike, and his facial expressions
I wouldn't say it doesn't sound good, but as it wasn't made for Liam it's just not the same and sounds different, and of course we're used to zayn, so...
@@xD-rv8cs gosh I wrote this just 2 months after becoming a directioner
That’s crazy I can’t even remember the beginning of it all starting for me
But yeah it did sound good, it sounded great because by all means Liam sounds great singing anything, but it was made for Zayn and just don’t sound as good as when Z sang it
@@everythingevelyn3159 agreed!
Yes you should check out his latest release Entertainer. Love that track.
I feel Zayn has very good control, during live performances I've almost never seen him falter (there are very few live performances of his solo project). And he's very consistent as well, his live sounds incredibly identical to the studio recordings. Although I have almost no knowledge about technique, I still always felt like he sings with ease, even in the higher register. He never seems to strain. Like you noticed, he'll just be sitting/standing all chill and hitting all these notes with not much visible strain. And his runs always sound smooth (he isn't really doing anything crazy though). His live performance of It's You (title:
ZAYN - iT’s YoU Live on the Honda Stage at the iHeartRadio Theater NY) is worth checking out as well. 😊
Harry styles is really good too his solo album was fire 🔥
If he didn't already, he needs to react to I don't wanna live forever but the acoustic version by Zayn
NAME HERE this
2:17 everytime i freaking see that video i always get shook
Harry Styles is an excellent singer as well. Niall Horan has a good voice, too.
mcyruslowe lol watch this then ruclips.net/video/fc1xsOr9Zek/видео.html
I wouldn't call him excellent. Because I think technically and vocally Liam and Niall are much better than Harry.
Liam and louis too
johnnystir but Zayn the best, don't fight me
They are good and best but in this battle zayn won for sure :)
Check out Dusk to Dawn by Zayn x SIA. It's incredible!
Zayn's high note in Dusk to Dawn!
it would be awesome if you reacted to all of the members of 1d, but you could do Harry Styles next ☺
DUH you need to check eveything zayn !
1. Dusk till dawn
2. Let me
3. Entertainer
4. Trampoline (with shaed)
5. Common
Gah there are so many good songs I cant decide!
If it's about high notes my opinion is :
1 Zayn
2 Harry
3 Liam
4 Louis
5 Niall
No hate it's my opinion.
Edit : Again, it's my opinion based on what I've heard. But if I have to choose between them, Niall is my fave.
I'm sorry what? His voice isn't heavy at all! Harry and zayn's voices are much heavy than his
XpLiciTz II no she's right Nial voice is low range but high
XpLiciTz II zayn voice is high range but low
Lordu yes true you explained it better than me
Niall could do a high note before Louis. Louis’ voice is far too raspy.
You should honestly react to all five of them.
Zayn has the most emotional voice, I think he’s amazing but Liam Payne is probably the best technical singer in the band. Harry Styles has a really beautiful voice (rock edge to it). I find Niall Horan’s voice to be the most soothing.
I’ve always thought that Louis Tomlinson’s voice was very interesting and unique. (I’m kinda obsessed with it) I don’t really know how to explain it 🤔 his voice sounds high and I don’t know if it’s the right word to use but also kinda polished. I find him carrying the choruses in many 1D songs. It’s weird because some people love his voice but others can’t stand it and don’t think he can sing at all.
Yes! Please react all of them
Louis can't sing bruh 😂
Andy Biersack you prove my point 🤔😊
personally Nialls voice is definitely the best!
I love LT's voice but I think it's just weak/underdeveloped. I think it sounds very pure & clean. Sweet & polished are good terms also.
i miss 1d ☹️
Nadine Bustamante same
Same :c
niall’s my fav but zayn definitely has the best voice. he has a lot of control over his voice❤️
React to Harry styles react to Harry styles his voice kills me
liam can hit those high notes too but idk why i always loved zayns more maybe it was because liam’s were so perfect and clean and zayns were more like akdpdlwkdkeis
that literally made no sense but like i know exactly hat you mean
Liam can do but he cant hit like zayn...Zayn hits perfectly he is legends not all mans can do that..
same.
Liam has a very wide range indeed, but their coaches in One Direction always put Zayn on the high notes and Liam in the middles/lows, that's why you don't hear him hitting crazy notes even though he's capable of doing it.
Liam is a good singer but u can't compare to zayn....Zayn is in another level dude...he cannot be compared to any 1D members
Zayn was 100% the most talented (and still is)
In my OPINION
He’s a really good vocalist but I prefer the voice of Harry personally, I think they are all super talented in their way, they are not good for the same things
periodt
Yeah, I do also prefer Harry's voice.. so husky and smooth at the same time. And I love his songs. But Zayn is surely very talented too..
As a singer, I agree but I think he’s not as talented of a songwriter as Niall and Harry
I love harry singing voice but some of his high notes seems like he tries too hard... love him anyway
No male singer can beat Zayn high notes
AND THAT’S A FACT
Um Mitch from pentatonic?
Bruno Mars
No Zayn is just the best
Uhh I donno Paul McCartney , Freddie ,MJ,JC Chasez, Brendon Urie,Mitch Grassi , Bruno , Adam Lambert ,Dimash
True
“Makes him sound a lot younger”... that’s because he was younger
How I miss the good old times...
Mafer Zegarra IFKRR T_T
TRISTAN ITS ZAYN QUICK CHANGE IT BEFORE THE DIRECTIONERS COME FOR YOU
susie oh, we are already coming for him
we already came
susie we’re already here
I already came for him 😂😂😂
also Mah-lick (or Muh-lick depending on where ur from with the british accent lol) not Muh-leek, but this dude is adorable and was so nice in his review that i'm not even mad lol
5:56 have you heard Drag me down, Harry's note there is really powerful
I would recommend you to listen his album. It's an actual piece of art.
you should do little mix vocals they are the biggest girl group and they are all amazing singer and they have won a brit
biggest girl group in the uk
yes!!!!
Hailee Anisa YES YES LITTLE MIX
Hailee Anisa I’m so glad you said that because I was about be like ughh they barely even topped any charts in the U.S lol
Tyler Beauty had two in the top 6 most successful girl group tours of all time and two of the best pure sales albums of the generation ...
Some of Zayn's singles are really good I recommend Dusk till Dawn, Let Me, and I Don't Want to Live Forever. I would also recommend listening to Liam Payne and Harry Styles they both have evolved and some of their singles have really great vocals. They have all gone into different pathways though, especially Harry Styles.
Zayn’s voice is rare and amazing I don’t think nobody can hit it like he does true king Zayn 👑❤️🔥
I love you for reacting to this.
Now react to Harry Styles and Liam Payne's best vocals.
Would love to hear your opinion on Liam. Though I don't love his solo work, I do think he has a lot of potential as well. His singing to me sounds solid and he has a very warm sound, being able to reach low as well as very high notes. Unfortunately his voice doesn't stand out as much with a very unique tone as Harry's or Zayn's
Love Zayn and Niall's songs after One Direction the most! Especially Zayn has this very recognizable warm, soulful, sexy sound which is great for hiphop/ R&B, and with his new songs he is experimenting with soul and funk as well (sounds like he is influenced by Prince and MJ, a bit similar to the Weeknd).
Niall made a good choice going for his singer/songwriter style with pop-rock and country influences mixed in. His voice sounds much stronger and more stable now than in the band. I think all the boys made great choices going into different genres and directions (pun intended) suitable to their voices and singing style.
"Unfortunately his voice doesn't stand out as much with a very unique tone as Harry's or Zayn's", god, I 100% agree with this, I've said the exact same thing before. If you're comparing vocal tones in that band, Liam's would rank lowest simply because the other 3 (or 4, if you're counting Zayn) have very distinct tones. I also think that that is the reason Liam's vocals remain underrrated, even to this day.
I agree with everything you have to say about Liam sans the last line of the first paragraph. I think his voice would be extremely recognisable if he didn't present songs that sound like every other pop artist out there.
This guy's voice is crazy versatile, and if he went into a genre that could show that off (I would love for him to do some jazz, but I don't think that's going to happen 😭) his voice would be a lot more distinct.
@@katelynn117_ I have the feeling(/hope) on his album will be a lot of ballads and slow songs. Maybe he just wants to explore styles he never tried in the band and wants to make himself a name in the industry before he releases the whole album. Singer always make their singles blend in with the other popular music. But his voice is really recognizable. It's just a really clean, smooth sound.
@@amelie5835 That could very well be the case. I'm just a little disheartened because he was the entire reason I ever started listening to the band in the first place. The amount of control he has with his voice is so rare in his particular industry, and it's frustrating not hearing it be used.
This is taking me back and I'm not sure whether it's a good or bad thing
you’re literally me when i listen to zayn sing lmao
Lol me too
I personally think you just should react to One Direction's best vocals. Like, I would want to se what you think of all of their individual vocals rather than just one of them. (Also, Liam has the best vocal range in my opinion.)
multifandom ; Liam really does
Liam has the highest vocal range, but what makes Zayn better in my opinion is that he can hold it longer and because of that it's more powerful. Liam has trouble holding his range which is what gets him down. If he would work on that, he would be the white version of Jason Derulo.
multifandom ; Liams voice is so underrated :(
Liam can’t hit very many low notes lol. I think harry can hit the lowest, zayn can do the highest, nialls pretty much in the middle, and Louis has very limited range lol rip
multifandom ; Oh yeah that sweet Baritone, I prefer hearing Liam sing in his natural range, like back in the day when he sang Cry Me a River.
My fave thing right now is a video of the boys singing c'mon c'mon zayns voice really stands out also they turned it into a meme that says "when it's a group project but your graded individually". And totally check out Harry Styles his music is very different from the other guys, but as he has grown his voice has become totally different from his 1D days
Misspelled his first name and mispronounced his last name. They're gonna come for you Tristan. Run!
Michael Lewis actually many people pronounce his last name like that including directioners.
he actually pronounced his last name better than most of the fans who anglicize it lol
Pansexual Christian but the proper pronunciation is Mah-Lick
I’m coming for him but not in the way you’re implying 😂
Carla Chriistiine that's disgusting.
When I went see him live in 2014 he sounded really bright and sweet more than he does from tv or radio. He's amazing though i was shocked his voice sounded that different.
You should react to Harry Styles, but focused on his solo work!!!!
Also you should react to Zayn's solo work too, since this was all One Direction!
Nikki yes exactly!
Harry styles best live vocals too🌻
Harry Styles is a motherfucker infront of Zayn
ANANJAN DE no one asked
ANANJAN DE we been knew that harry is into older women anyway so sit down
Yesss
Harry is a good artist but not a good live performer ..... His live performances are so weak .... Zayn's vocals a very powerful because he has very high vocal range & has a good control on his voice ....... I like Harry but in terms of vocals he failed many times
Tristan looks like he's in love with Zayn, and frankly, dear, so am I.
Need another zayn video but with his most recent performances like his performance on Jimmy Fallon
React to harry styles pleeeease!
You should react to Liam's vocals! I feel like he's so underrated, but he's really good (he has the best vocals IMO).
Harry Styles solo stuff I really like (Sign of the Times)
Pls react to more clips with Zayn because he has a good like really really good voice!
Please React next to Little Mix Best High Notes or Little Mix Queens of Acapella 💓
Honestly one of the most incredible things about One Direction is how well they fit together in every way, in terms of personality and vocality. Zayn has fantastic high notes and riffs, but he's much quieter personality-wise. Niall has a much brighter personality and brought the musical cred of playing guitar, but his voice was more unpolished early on. Liam was hard-working and determined, and his voice might be one of the most versatile I've ever heard -- fantastic falsettos, beautiful bass notes, and an incredible ability to adapt and improvise -- but as valuable as his drive was he was almost too serious sometimes. Harry also has a vibrant personality, so charismatic, and he's a fantastic all-around singer, but he was too young and too sensitive to make it alone. Louis' voice is not as technically polished, but it's so unique, and he's so good at projecting emotion when he sings so you feel every word. Plus he's so bright and friendly and funny that he draws people in and makes them want to see more. He's the leader, the glue that holds them together. He does goofy or childish things sometimes, so he can look a bit irresponsible despite being the oldest, but he's actually so mature and always looks out for all of them.
Also I'm sure no one can tell who my favourite is because I'm totally not biased nope I love them all equally (just some are more equal than others)
AnnikaOakinnA Louis :)
He needs to get away from 1 Direction. A little jealousy and a lot of gay stuff going on in that group! They messed up their group with all that plus everyone wants to be the leader!
1D will always be the best band in the world
6:16 : the whole fandom 😭❤
There are many Zayn's best live vocals here Tristan, you should check them, they are much better than this and you can see Zayn's like I would or It's You live performances. For me, he is/was the best vocalist in 1D and I'm really happy that you start to react of him. Love Zayn and you xx
Please react to Little Mix - Best Live Vocals
yes please
yeessss
Yasssss
Perrie Styles I always see you everywhere since im a Mixer and i love ur vids
Perrie Styles YES PLEASE
I’ve never been like a HUGE fan of One Direction? But Zayn is SOOO good 😍
This You & i Note Killed me 😍
Liam payne best vocals!!! He has amazing falsettos
Omg yess
Yes
react to 1D's (as a whole) best live vocals. That'll be amazayn
Emily Singh amazayn 😂
Emily Singh fabolouis
Brendon Urie's high note compilation!!!! /// Ariana Grande's best live vocals!!!! Both are among the best singers of this generation!
He's done a Brendon Urie/Panic! At the Disco compilation!! Same with Ariana I think!!
Sure, fair enough he's done Brendon, but we can we ever have enough of Mr Urie? With Ariana, he has yet to do a best live vocals video though.
Zayn was the best in the band and even solo he's still the best... His voice is heaven
liam also has a phenomenal voice that i feel like was sometimes overshadowed when he was in 1d
I will always believe that Zayn outshined the rest of One Direction. People hate me for saying it, but it doesn’t mean I love any of the other boys any less. I just think he deserved way better from the beginning had he been a little more confident in himself.
TuccTownLaydii I totally agree with you. He had the best voice in One Direction by far. So when he went solo I was upset at first, but when his album came out, I was like, "BEST DECISION EVER"!
Zayn always did all the high notes in the band, while Harry did all the chorus.
Liam was more of the rapper as always, while Louis and Niall were always almost in the background which little solos on some songs.
dude focus on all of them they all sound unique and good in their own way AAH I LOVE ZAYYN THOO