She might be annoying but they had no business pulling up 3 deep especially if she didnt have the title and he pled guilty then claimed he did nothing. He should have fought that judgement if he was innocent. Yall are full of mess in these comments
Glad you understood that too bad the judge didn't. He should've remained calm rather than getting emotional on the bench. She probably wouldve admitted that if he wouldve asked her like the plaintiff was trying too before he started yelling.
I believe he didn’t hit her. I believe the 2 girl cousins did. And she should have been ordered to give him his title. The defendant is just being low down to him because she is mad she got beat up. 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️
???? She was assaulted???? And proved that she didn’t get the title until AFTER the assault. And I guarantee you any MAN who is willing to bring women to assault another woman is not above putting his own hands on her.
@@nataliemscrzysxycoolharris Noooo! I JUST commented the same thing! 🤣 You know he was definitely getting his licks in while his cousins were going to work.
@4CQueen Yes, but she was in a courtroom. In front of a judge. I've watched this show and seen many retelling stories of injustice and horror without behaving as she did. You can tell that this is her usual disposition. In fact, I'm inclined to believe the plaintiff about how the altercation started (though I'm sure he's lying about not kicking/ hitting her).
How is the defendant Acting a fool when she was the one assaulted? If anything, she's upset. He definitely went over there to beat her up. JM lacks empathy sometimes.
People have to pay attention Jm said he was going to let her act a fool if what she said him and cousins did was true "aggravated battery" assault her case was proven so yea she didn't cut up enough for me
He clearly admitted to breaking her TV. So he plead guilty to his part in that. The police did not see him put his hands on her that’s just what she told the police that happened. How does he see it as a fact?
I hate when judge does that! Dismiss a case because you’re in your feelings! The boy didn’t perjure himself! He said he never touched her. He could have been found guilty just for being there with the woman that did jump her. Give her the money for her injuries and make her give him his title. Simple!
Not unless he pleaded guilty as he said Plus he Said his whole family doesn't like her why bring 2 other family members over there that don't like her "just to talk"
The plaintiff made a bad decision in putting his vehicle in the defendant's name but the worst move that he made was to vandalize her home and assault her in the process. Assaulting someone is never the right thing to do. Never!
I am going to keep better track of when I agree with you. I am going to say this is #12 and go from there. What I mean is your comment is founded upon logic and empathy.
I honestly don't believe he touched her at all I truly feel that way but I also believe he took his girl cousins over their to fight her if she didn't give him the title he still wrong no doubt about it but atleast he didn't fight her himself and the defendant is going to have to learn theirs a time and place to act ignorant and Court is not the place shé could have easily lost her counter suit before the facts came out because I assumed she was lieíng from the start the way she was behaving smh
I don’t believe he assaulted her , I think she is irate and out of control and was jumped by the other two parties but it’s not believable he touched her.
It's messed up that the judge got emotional. Dude said he broke her TV. Paying for that makes sense. Pleading guilty to that makes sense. Why assume he's lying?
Did y'all hear the police report that said she was beaten & stomped; in front of her 10 year old child? I'm sure she sustained some head injuries from that.
If what she alleges happened to you, how calm would you be? Sincerely interested. I, personally, would stay calm in court (BUT IT WOULD BE ACT taking everything that I had to pull it off).
He didn't hit her. She was being sassy to thenother females, which descended into a fisticuffs. He pled guilty because he couldn't extricate himself from the brawl.
I don't believe he hit her or kicked her at all. She was acting like she was all so mad and hurt in court, but afterwards it was "I don't have no hard feelings, he's still like my brother". He probably only took the plea because when you facing possible time for a accusation, sometimes paying a little restitution sounds easier than fighting in court.
Did yall hear that the plaintiff plead guilty in the case? The defendant is animated but she is angry for a reason. She even proved that she didn't even have the title to give. Bringing people over to jump her is insane.
Just my opinion, but I think statements like that coming from a man about another man is so UNBECOMING. It reminds me of when a coworker (female) said during an argument that she handed her husband a sanitary napkin. I told her (right or wrong) that the act was one of the most disrespectful things I'd heard.
Y’all saying she need to pipe down , calm down blah blah blah . If I was close to someone and they pulled up with two other people to jump me in front of my kids all over a car title yeah I’d be hyped up too . She’s still traumatized and frustrated as well because of how scarring the situation was y’all are ditsy fr . She’s allowed her emotions FULLY
He didn't plead guilty for assault. As he mentioned he was never even charged with assault. He was charged and pleaded guilty to destroying her property
@@Xotdoydoydo no assault was proven. Also that logic makes 0 sense because even if he committed a crime it has nothing to do with her stealing his car. That's like saying if I got your car but week later you attack me I no longer have to fix your car. That's not how the law works
I actually believe him though 🤷🏽♀️. He pled guilty because even in front of Judge Mathis he admitted to breaking the TV, that’s why he pled guilty and had to pay $500. Judges don’t always get it right, just like juries don’t.
This comment is for the person who asked what this that and the 3rd mean. It means this that and the other. Instead of saying the other. He said the 3rd.
@@sereneamani1713 Sure it does, he completely through out the plaintiff's claim based on a false illegality Mathis calls "You perjured yourself", just to retaliate against him for whatever confrontation happened between him and the defendant. He's very biased in this case. The purpose of his claim was to be compensated as he never received the car title, but because Mathis doesn't like "women beaters", he created a reason to throw out his claim and grant the defendant her claim, even though the defendant never game him the title to the car and thus owed him for that. All and all, men raised by single black mothers tend to be the worse.
I believe he didn’t hit her with his hands or feet although he did break her tv I really don’t like judge Mathis most of the times. The female is angry at the wrong person and the young man still can’t drive his car SAD SITUATION ALL AROUND
Naaaah fuk all that I believe the plaintiff I also believed he didn't lay a finger on her but did in fact allow his cousins to and that's why the defendant said he was involved! JM b getting on my dam nerves sometimes.
Did he say "I got stuff to do. You got stuff to do. Da-da-doe, da-da-doe." 😑...
🤣 😂 I guess that's the equivalent of "blah dee blah".
Dang bro why even sue when you end up paying 😂
She might be annoying but they had no business pulling up 3 deep especially if she didnt have the title and he pled guilty then claimed he did nothing. He should have fought that judgement if he was innocent. Yall are full of mess in these comments
Exactly.
Right 🚋🚎🚃 ssa😂😂😂😂
Exactly
He didn’t put his hands on her. He did break that TV though lol!
@@idanilee3 Not his hands. Just his feet, lol.
Glad you understood that too bad the judge didn't. He should've remained calm rather than getting emotional on the bench. She probably wouldve admitted that if he wouldve asked her like the plaintiff was trying too before he started yelling.
She has no problem with him now that she has won though, smh.
I agree I dont think he assaulted her but I do believe he damaged her property
I believe he didn’t hit her. I believe the 2 girl cousins did. And she should have been ordered to give him his title. The defendant is just being low down to him because she is mad she got beat up. 🤷🏽♀️🤷🏽♀️
???? She was assaulted???? And proved that she didn’t get the title until AFTER the assault. And I guarantee you any MAN who is willing to bring women to assault another woman is not above putting his own hands on her.
I'm mad the plaintiff has his sleeves rolled up like that, lol!
Girl😂😂😂…
@ you laughing though lol
I'm mad she walked into court aggressively with a belt around her muffin top. She IS Not playing.
@@msarmstrong410 very hard😂😂😂…
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😂❤❤❤u
No you didn’t put your hands on her. You put your feet on her.
👀👀👀 I’m not there yet?!
@@nataliemscrzysxycoolharris Noooo! I JUST commented the same thing! 🤣
You know he was definitely getting his licks in while his cousins were going to work.
I can't stand people who are always on 10.
We can hear you just fine. You don't need to speak so loudly and aggressively.
I think that she was upset that she was assaulted in front of her child by the plaintiff, I'd be upset too.
@4CQueen Yes, but she was in a courtroom. In front of a judge.
I've watched this show and seen many retelling stories of injustice and horror without behaving as she did.
You can tell that this is her usual disposition. In fact, I'm inclined to believe the plaintiff about how the altercation started (though I'm sure he's lying about not kicking/ hitting her).
@@4CQueenThen, she should have initiated the suit; instead of, countersuing. Nonetheless, she prevailed, as she should have.
She was mad, she had a reason, and then she won.
How is the defendant Acting a fool when she was the one assaulted? If anything, she's upset. He definitely went over there to beat her up. JM lacks empathy sometimes.
People have to pay attention Jm said he was going to let her act a fool if what she said him and cousins did was true "aggravated battery" assault her case was proven so yea she didn't cut up enough for me
How does he not know a plea bargain means admitting guilt? I knew that when I was 10 years old watching Law and order 😂🤦🏽♂️
😂😂😂😂
She still traumatized. The way he was rubbing his elbows & hands together in a mischievous manner every time he spoke said all I need to know.
You have an ability that many don't possess. EMPATHY and INSIGHT
So he thought of her as a Sister? And beat her down 😲 wow SMH 😂
Shorty is mad aggressive.
I said the same thing
I’d be aggressive too if you jumped me and damaged my property, over something that I couldn’t even give you to begin with
@ I’m just saying she needs to pipe down a bit. That wasn’t the place to be acting a fool like JM said.
@@msarmstrong410pipe waaaaybdown!! 😂😂😂
She wanted to start her summation like tht do bad lmao
Damn She's Hella ANIMATED
Lol @ "Act a Fool"
She needs to calm down
She doesn’t have to associate with him cus she has kds with his brother…he should be ashamed putting his hands on that woman…
So his brother didn't step to him?
Probably because he didn’t touch her the 2 girl cousins did what they was suppose to do
He probably did they just didn’t discuss that…
He was probably guilty of destruction of property he literally admitted to breaking the tv has nothing to do with his girl cousins jumping on her
He brought them there🤔🤨🤨🤨
@ with what car.?!?!
He clearly admitted to breaking her TV. So he plead guilty to his part in that. The police did not see him put his hands on her that’s just what she told the police that happened. How does he see it as a fact?
Guilty by association duh his title yet he brought 2 girl cousins for what???? 🐦🐦⬛🦜🐣
6:36 that is HER statement....the police didn't see it
Um there def was a police statement
@@CarraThomas 😑.....the police wrote down HER statement. The police did not see him touch her
@@CarraThomas this is why I don't hang out with ppl often
@@MrLenroc82 ?? What's why, exactly?
@@sereneamani1713 cause yall slow
I hate when judge does that! Dismiss a case because you’re in your feelings! The boy didn’t perjure himself! He said he never touched her. He could have been found guilty just for being there with the woman that did jump her. Give her the money for her injuries and make her give him his title. Simple!
Shut up.
Not unless he pleaded guilty as he said
Plus he Said his whole family doesn't like her why bring 2 other family members over there that don't like her "just to talk"
He don't have rights to the child he's the UNCLE
The plaintiff made a bad decision in putting his vehicle in the defendant's name but the worst move that he made was to vandalize her home and assault her in the process. Assaulting someone is never the right thing to do. Never!
I am going to keep better track of when I agree with you. I am going to say this is #12 and go from there. What I mean is your comment is founded upon logic and empathy.
160th 😂😂😂😂🎉🎉🎉🎉
I honestly don't believe he touched her at all I truly feel that way but I also believe he took his girl cousins over their to fight her if she didn't give him the title he still wrong no doubt about it but atleast he didn't fight her himself and the defendant is going to have to learn theirs a time and place to act ignorant and Court is not the place shé could have easily lost her counter suit before the facts came out because I assumed she was lieíng from the start the way she was behaving smh
I know she's glad you were not the judge.
Too bad we're not the judge lol
She walked in like a linebacker 😂😂😂 too much masculine energy
Many don't realize how they exude feminine energy.
Sure did
The defendant was just emotional about the situation.
If she don’t have any problems with him why was she buck’n so hard 🤔
Because he came to her house with his cousins to jump her in front of her children and destroyed her property and she ended up with medical bills
She’s going with his brother, but he didn’t come in as a witness🤣
I don't believe he did that I'm sorry folks that disagree.
Don't be sorry that you're wrong. He really didn't deny it in any convincing way.
@sereneamani1713 let me find out u a fan 😂😂😂
I don’t believe he assaulted her , I think she is irate and out of control and was jumped by the other two parties but it’s not believable he touched her.
Listening to HIS testimony lends believability to her claim.
Plus she do t have a problem with him. She should if your acting traumatic telling the Judge your daughter is in therapy.
The defendant needs to calm down! This case is a hot mess! The plaintiff was way wrong for assaulting the defendant.
It's messed up that the judge got emotional. Dude said he broke her TV. Paying for that makes sense. Pleading guilty to that makes sense. Why assume he's lying?
bullshit case... basically just allowed her to steal his car
He wasn’t acting like a man. Oh well
And u a Custer too if u agree with him custer
Wouldn't have happened if he had handled it differently--like a mature man.
I don’t believe he hit her. All them hands was just coming but dang ,what will do with a car & no title? 😕
How you come up with that?
She so aggressive and mad... She talking in incomplete sentences lol Girl Calm Down 😒
Did y'all hear the police report that said she was beaten & stomped; in front of her 10 year old child? I'm sure she sustained some head injuries from that.
If what she alleges happened to you, how calm would you be? Sincerely interested. I, personally, would stay calm in court (BUT IT WOULD BE ACT taking everything that I had to pull it off).
He didn't hit her.
She was being sassy to thenother females, which descended into a fisticuffs.
He pled guilty because he couldn't extricate himself from the brawl.
Creative reasoning.
Yeah 💯 accurate they are living in Cazale, Port-Salut, Fond des Blanc, La Valley de Jacmel the list goes on ✍️👏
I don't believe he hit her or kicked her at all. She was acting like she was all so mad and hurt in court, but afterwards it was "I don't have no hard feelings, he's still like my brother". He probably only took the plea because when you facing possible time for a accusation, sometimes paying a little restitution sounds easier than fighting in court.
Did yall hear that the plaintiff plead guilty in the case? The defendant is animated but she is angry for a reason. She even proved that she didn't even have the title to give. Bringing people over to jump her is insane.
She finessed Judge Mathis SMH
No adrian knight in the comments section?
He's probably busy commenting on The People's Court episodes 😆
@@christinagordon4460 😂🤣😆
@@juniorstarks7494he’s above
He's here and made a decent comment.
OhGod... I'm not too clock off based on the comments sound like another annoying outcome based on JM mood
Based on logic and observation, IMO.
Congratulations twice!! Beautiful baby & thank God you finished your dissertation!! 🙏🏼✝️🤗💖🍾🎉🎉
Not saying it's right, but that's why they came over there.
😭
I dont believe he laid his hands on her. The public defender he had was trash, and he doesn't need to associate with her anymore.
He messed up comin dere 😩😭😭😭😭
😂
Now go sue the other two
How can he say " i believe your perjuring yourself". Not a judge but ondoubt judges can say " i think thats a lie" with no proof and say its perjury
That's an important part of what judges do. Make a judgement between the truth and a lie.
Judge Mathis is the only TV judge show I watch
6:36 Mathis on his period again
SMH 🤦♀️
Lmao!
Just my opinion, but I think statements like that coming from a man about another man is so UNBECOMING. It reminds me of when a coworker (female) said during an argument that she handed her husband a sanitary napkin. I told her (right or wrong) that the act was one of the most disrespectful things I'd heard.
@sereneamani1713 it's called for....the way he is acting
I'm innocent but I plead guilty to the crime🙄
Why the two of them so involved makes no sense
I'm here My Beloved Favorite Judge ***ASHAY ***
First it was him and three cousins and then it was just him??? I'm confused here!!!
No one man but three cousins
Now she need counciling 🤣🤣
Her baby needs counseling after her mother got jumped in front of her. If that is normal behavior to you, I'm sorry.
@nicholecarter5885 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤷♂️
@@Dshipp25 Your smiley faces indicate that you need COUNSELING and the HOMOPHONE workbook. I'm sure it's on Amazon
So he admit to breaking the t.v. and his cousin fighting her. So all three of yall causing destruction at her house over your title.
Someone stole 2 of my documents sent by the superior court. It was not my queens
Y’all saying she need to pipe down , calm down blah blah blah . If I was close to someone and they pulled up with two other people to jump me in front of my kids all over a car title yeah I’d be hyped up too . She’s still traumatized and frustrated as well because of how scarring the situation was y’all are ditsy fr . She’s allowed her emotions FULLY
He plead to the assault and it happened in attempt to get the car title so I am confused at JM biases its law. He committed a crime
He didn't plead guilty for assault. As he mentioned he was never even charged with assault. He was charged and pleaded guilty to destroying her property
@onemikenation2783 whatever it was he still committed a crime in the mist of an assault. That’s why no judgment was rendered
@@Xotdoydoydo no assault was proven. Also that logic makes 0 sense because even if he committed a crime it has nothing to do with her stealing his car.
That's like saying if I got your car but week later you attack me I no longer have to fix your car. That's not how the law works
Her children father should handle him
I actually believe him though 🤷🏽♀️. He pled guilty because even in front of Judge Mathis he admitted to breaking the TV, that’s why he pled guilty and had to pay $500. Judges don’t always get it right, just like juries don’t.
I dont think he touch her police report is most times what she said happened doesnt mean its True the police dont be there smh
This comment is for the person who asked what this that and the 3rd mean. It means this that and the other. Instead of saying the other. He said the 3rd.
can someone please tell me what this that and the third mean?
She needs a dictionary
😂😂😂mann what!!! Its so aggy
She was stomped and beaten by the plaintiff, we don't know what kind of damage was done to her cognitive and motor skills.
Don't we all?
He did
So who gets the car
Mathis is very biased, he thinks women are allowed to do as they please without any consequences.
She never had the title when they pulled on her. He’s a chump
@@brenttucker3933 You sound like a man raised by a single mother.
JM is biased in many areas, but this case doesn't prove your claim.
@@sereneamani1713 Sure it does, he completely through out the plaintiff's claim based on a false illegality Mathis calls "You perjured yourself", just to retaliate against him for whatever confrontation happened between him and the defendant. He's very biased in this case. The purpose of his claim was to be compensated as he never received the car title, but because Mathis doesn't like "women beaters", he created a reason to throw out his claim and grant the defendant her claim, even though the defendant never game him the title to the car and thus owed him for that.
All and all, men raised by single black mothers tend to be the worse.
I believe he didn’t hit her with his hands or feet although he did break her tv I really don’t like judge Mathis most of the times. The female is angry at the wrong person and the young man still can’t drive his car SAD SITUATION ALL AROUND
Like where is the kids father what he let that happen to his kids mother!
I wonder if she suing the cousins
That was Fast
Naaaah fuk all that I believe the plaintiff I also believed he didn't lay a finger on her but did in fact allow his cousins to and that's why the defendant said he was involved! JM b getting on my dam nerves sometimes.
Im 🥇
🥇
She still traumatized. The way he was rubbing his elbows & hands together in a mischievous manner every time he spoke said all I need to know.
💯