RANKING TAYLOR SWIFT'S EX-BOYFRIENDS AFTER RED (TAYLOR'S VERSION) **with receipts**

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 июн 2024
  • hello my children...here I am, ranking Taylor swift's ex boyfriends after all too well the short film. this was highly requested so here you go. if you don't like my opinion....that's fine....but if you're RUDE you will be BLOCKED. anyway don't forget to ring that bell, I post teasers and take requests in the community tab which is so fun for me. love my little bell ringers. ok bye see you in the next one!! xx
    MY SOCIALS:
    Twitter: / tsfolklore
    Instagram: / hourihandsome
    PODCAST SOCIALS:
    Listen: anchor.fm/the-evolution-of-a-...
    Twitter: / tswiftpodcast
    Instagram: / tswiftpodcast
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 120

  • @lillyan1740
    @lillyan1740 2 года назад +347

    I normally don’t comment in videos but please do a video on John Mayer. I was too young to comprehend all of the monstrosity that went down. Also I love your videos!

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +149

      omg on its way bestie...I need to dunk on that little gremlin

    • @xiyanna
      @xiyanna 2 года назад +9

      @@theswiftologist omg yesss, notifs on awaiting the searing exposé

    • @IlyRecordare
      @IlyRecordare Год назад +4

      Yes! I want this video to happen

    • @MermaidCore_
      @MermaidCore_ Год назад +4

      Love this idea!!! Is it still on the list? Also, a breakdown of the songs that you think are about each one…

    • @um7239
      @um7239 7 месяцев назад

      He’s a borderline pedophille because Taylor was just over 18 since you know she was 19 and like Zach always says she mentally ages slowly so like yeah physically she was a legal adult but she was still a minor mentally and 19’s not that old obviously

  • @maggiemeyers3998
    @maggiemeyers3998 2 года назад +118

    At first I was all "oh no baby what is you doing??" but now I've thought about it more and you know what? Jake Gyllenhaal REALLY is the archetypal Taylor Swift ex. We're still thinking about that scarf 10 years later. Red is personal and vulnerable and painfully honest in a way that 1989 (while brilliant) isn't. Bestie, you're right and you should say it.
    I am outing myself as a Hiddleswift shipper here but I'm hoping there are some real bangers about Tom in the Rep vault. The gift to the world that is Getaway Car CANNOT be a one-off, right?!

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +54

      hiddleswift shippers have rights and they should be able to speak their minds. this is a safe space

    • @ainaubeda5975
      @ainaubeda5975 2 года назад +10

      Tbh I'm also a ship them. I consider myself the child of a divorce, so I tend to say sorry every time that I proceed to listen to Getaway Car, which is not an small amount of times tbf

  • @gelifilms
    @gelifilms 2 года назад +148

    I was really surprised when I realized you were going to put Jake as the best ex but then the points you raised were actually really convincing, and I have no choice but to agree because it's true. It's true that Jake Gyllenhaal brought out this raw, honest artistry in Taylor which created RED and All Too Well, and it's true that he and Maggie have been respectful and silent about the whole issue! So yep, I have to say, this ranking was really a realistic and well-thought out one! 💖

  • @rloyBB
    @rloyBB 2 года назад +51

    LOL you killed me with these: "Stock man" and "Who thought that a man like that could inspire work like this" HAHAHA

  • @didinau
    @didinau 2 года назад +61

    First time when I heard Dear John I got goosebumps. Creepy feeling, very weird vibe. Just thinking about their relationship dynamic makes me uncomfortable.
    He just creeps me out.

  • @arcade1580
    @arcade1580 2 года назад +84

    Absolutely agree on the list, but I feel that your ranking is gonna change once 1989 TV is released. The secret message story that she created for 1989 is so interesting and heartbreaking, she never did something like that for any of her album. That album lead to her personal and professional growth both. And above all, In Haylor's case, we got to hear 'hit' songs from both perspective! not just Taylor's.
    Also In terms of content and entertainment, Haylor content basically never ended since the time they dated. Every year we get something which reignited Haylor conversation. 2012- They dated on-off that year, pics, videos are super cute, In 2013- The iconic IKYWT VMA 2013 speech by Taylor, their award shows interactions were fun to watch. In 2014- 1989 was released and " I love you by Alex and sierra, a song co written by Harry was also released ( the song is 100% hinting at Taylor because of number 13 in it) In 2015- Made in the AM by 1D was released with song 'Perfect' In 2016- Harry wrote 22's lyrics for his bday, which became most retweeted tweet of the year. In 2017- Harry released 'Two Ghosts' and spoke so highly about Taylor in his rolling stone interview and supported her (indirectly) during her lowest time. in 2018- Harry again teased '22' lyrics in concert and broke headlines, In 2019 - Harry released Fineline on her 30th bday. In 2021- They Met again. I mean that's a good amount of content both music and entertainment.

    • @_tiaaa._2
      @_tiaaa._2 Год назад +2

      Yesss i agree (although i love them both, im not biased)

  • @miacmiacmia
    @miacmiacmia Год назад +18

    i used to be oblivious to what taylor was clinging onto on her relationship with jake but then i read somewhere he booked the whole theatre so that they could see tangled together alone and…

    • @taeminislove
      @taeminislove 10 месяцев назад +3

      Whaaat? Was this confirmed? Where did you read that?

  • @mac8827
    @mac8827 2 года назад +58

    Honestly, John Mayer's response scares me lol I feel like he is going to bitch and whine once Dear John (Taylor's Version) is released again. Since some fans can be extreme with sending him hate messages. And based on his recent response to a fan sending him hate, I feel like he is going to paint Taylor in a bad light because of those fans. (Great Video by the way!)
    Video Suggestion: more ASMR content! Please!

  • @disgustedrn4215
    @disgustedrn4215 2 года назад +29

    Some swifties really piss me off because every swiftie is different and we have our own opinions. Yes I don't stand behind everything you've said, but I understand that people have different views and opinions and I respect that and I respect you for not being a fake person and actually giving a full analysis and conclusion. Respect

  • @makennaburton259
    @makennaburton259 2 года назад +63

    Have binged literally all your videos. So impressed with this content, your effort and research. You're a phenomenal orator! Keep going!!
    Also high key would love more ASMR content, it was so good!

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +8

      THANK YOU SO MUCH! You know, other people have asked too...might have to do it for them + to annoy the haters

  • @pickledcucumber8693
    @pickledcucumber8693 2 года назад +36

    Given how much he has hurt Taylor swift and just how much of a prick he is, I’m glad you put John Mayer last

  • @redSaichie
    @redSaichie Год назад +7

    New Sub here! I've been binging you videos for a week now 😆I just find your honesty so refreshing! You are not afraid of loving Taylor and yet can still clearly see her flaws and say the things you don't like about her or about the things she does. I'm so looking forward to watching you react to Midnights on Oct. 21st, I have so much anticipation for that album. Keep on shining Queen!

  • @miakirsch
    @miakirsch 2 года назад +24

    tom hiddleston is forever my fav ex they were so hot together and we got getaway car

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +6

      honestly the candids were worth it alone

    • @stargazer3677
      @stargazer3677 Год назад +1

      You do realize Getaway Car is a slam at Tom? The story is about leaving two guys, Calvin and Tom.

  • @Chris-uq5vl
    @Chris-uq5vl 2 года назад +3

    leaving a like before watching the video, and that's on periodt!

  • @rightwhereyouleftme__
    @rightwhereyouleftme__ 2 года назад +18

    The Tom Hiddleston description has me dying 🤣

  • @mathey5558
    @mathey5558 2 года назад +1

    Love ur videos!

  • @betty_taylor13
    @betty_taylor13 Год назад +11

    A video analysis on Taylor & John Meyer would be great.
    Also, where would you rank Joe Alwyn in the wake of their relationship ending? Or is it too soon? If you're ranking on content the ex inspired, Joe would be interesting bc he's been her muse across several albums with three of those albums (Reputation, Lover & Midnights) predominately referencing him. I watched your video specifically addressing the break-up which was great.

    • @alvafairchild13
      @alvafairchild13 Год назад +2

      Well should at least wait until she breaks up with Matty Healy first should be sometime before the next album but after sntv

  • @Hannah_jo25
    @Hannah_jo25 Год назад +4

    Coming back to this video after Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve is an experience.

  • @weihanwang
    @weihanwang 2 года назад +2

    A bit far-fetched, but Middleton did inspire the "I love ts" shirt in the LWYMMD mv. When you talked about Conan Kennedy, the first thing that popped into my mind was The Last Great American Dynasty.

  • @Synesthesia_n_Sugar
    @Synesthesia_n_Sugar 8 месяцев назад +3

    I think it may be time for a do-over of this video soon. Joe Alwyn (and Matty if you consider that a relationship) are in the past, Taylor is seemingly not friends with Joe Jonas anymore because of the divorce, and we'll probably get some Harry tea on the 1989 vaults

  • @cleoloi6181
    @cleoloi6181 Год назад +3

    as someone who loved haylor, if i had been asked to rank her exes before watching this, i wouldve definitely put harry at number one. but you made POINTS💅 and i never thought about it that way,, so i'd kinda agree with ur ranking now (and of course im a red > 1989 stan so same the "harry inspired 1989" argument wouldnt sway me either)

  • @CarolineStrunk-ld4ri
    @CarolineStrunk-ld4ri 8 месяцев назад

    I love your channel

  • @loriann3867
    @loriann3867 7 месяцев назад

    Hello. Been following you for a while but just watched this video. Wondering if you have changed your ranking since 1989 TV? Those vault tracks combined with songs like Out of the Woods and many more, make it tough to choose between Harry and Jake. Peace. 🤗

  • @afroallura3791
    @afroallura3791 2 года назад +14

    You made several points! Despite everything…Jake inspired her best work.

  • @harshitakannan9555
    @harshitakannan9555 8 дней назад

    Babe we need you to do this re ranking video again including the turkey and ratty. Ooh also I wanna know where harry would be in the ranking after 1989 vault tracks and also when songs like the 1 and question are abt a certain rat and not him.

  • @aloneinmidnight
    @aloneinmidnight 2 года назад +16

    wait that's some tea; you think if this was a movie is about taylor lautner??? it makes sense!

  • @KyleOgilvie1
    @KyleOgilvie1 2 года назад +11

    Am I the only one who thinks Better Man isn't about Jake but instead is about John M**er? In her songs about John, she seems to mention running and that's a common motif in Better Man as well.
    In Better Man: 'The bravest thing I ever did was run'
    In Dear John: 'Run as fast you can'

    • @the3rdquark
      @the3rdquark 2 года назад +1

      Not to mention “the bravest thing I ever did was RUN” - RUN has the same melody as JOHN in Dear John! And “it was always on your terms, I wait on every careless word, hoping they might turn sweet again” also recapitulates the themes of Dear John!

    • @elenagerhardy2636
      @elenagerhardy2636 2 года назад +8

      I think Taylor’s drawn parallels between John and Jake, but I think Better Man is about Jake. The line ‘you would’ve been the one if you were a better man’ reads Jake. Also, the accusation of ‘talking down to me’ is echoed in songs like Begin Again, ATW10 and WANEGBT.

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +4

      y'all are really onto something on this day!

  • @valeriamarrerodiaz1731
    @valeriamarrerodiaz1731 Год назад

    love uuuuuu this is so filling

  • @disneyjunkie19
    @disneyjunkie19 2 года назад +2

    When I heard you were doing this video I half expected it to be ten seconds long with you just going “NOPE I stand by my points”. Thrilled to have more than that. XD

  • @mk21718
    @mk21718 6 месяцев назад

    I would love to hear where you'd rank the heirloom turkey!

  • @JessicaNicoleFaust
    @JessicaNicoleFaust 2 года назад +3

    This is iconic🙌 and I completely agree

  • @MichaelWest1996
    @MichaelWest1996 2 года назад +20

    I love that you actually are a true fan who is willing to talk about her negative characteristics and actions. She’s a great songwriter and musician, but she’s not perfect.

  • @gitzieisreading
    @gitzieisreading Год назад +6

    ya know, i don't love jake gyllenhaal because i think their age difference was icky, but i completely agree with your thoughts on him. he has allowed her to create so much content, and he has been relatively respectful. go jake lol!

  • @canoe2455
    @canoe2455 2 года назад +16

    I knew jake is her best boyfriend since the first time I heard Red aka the heartbreak masterpiece!!! Finally someone speaks about that truth, love your ranking.

  • @jasminearija6009
    @jasminearija6009 Год назад +1

    I hope you update it again now that joe has become an ex 😢... Love your content!

  • @shanegriffin6637
    @shanegriffin6637 2 года назад +4

    Wait I had no idea you went to a secret session!? That’s awesome! Your so lucky.

  • @carrie-us
    @carrie-us 5 месяцев назад

    Thank you algorithm for putting this on my recommendeds ❤️💃

  • @poojaahuja3934
    @poojaahuja3934 4 месяца назад

    Should I watch that movie?
    Have u done video ranking the movies she acted in?
    Do u have any recommendations?

  • @crystal-chan6239
    @crystal-chan6239 Год назад +1

    Also I knew that Better Then Revenge was about him but Last Kiss and Holly Ground where also about joe?

  • @Claudia26245
    @Claudia26245 Год назад +1

    Ok so now I NEED you to talk about the Katy vs Taylor beef, I know we have moved in from this but I would really love to know your opinion ✨

  • @justincera1770
    @justincera1770 2 года назад +5

    Dear John >> All Too Well (Original) 😬🤐

  • @charleneae
    @charleneae 2 года назад +35

    excuse me ma'am but jake🚩outranked harry?!😫✋🏼i'm sorry it sounds wrong after the masterpiece that is 1989🥵 i mean all too well and red tv rocked my world but miss jake still screwed young taylors head, kept her like a secret, and didnt attend her birthday. while harry brought taylor to his parents' home on her birthday, gave us the ultimate new york love affair, served mutual respect at every opportunity, gave iconic candids and videos, and produced musical parallels🤠 taylor's only complaint about miss harry was that he's a bad driver while all too well gave us a full list of jake's 🚩🚩🚩🚩
    jake: she's a beautiful girl
    harry: “She doesn’t need me to tell her they’re great. They’re great songs … It’s the most amazing unspoken dialogue ever.”
    case closed.

    • @charleneae
      @charleneae 2 года назад +14

      also harry: if somebody has to do that, I think it’s like flattering. Even if the song isn’t that flattering, you’ve still spent time on it and, ultimately, using Taylor as an example, she’s a great songwriter.

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +17

      I hear your points....but still !!! Jake gave us better material. as a red stan the 1989 argument will never convince me

    • @catharticmemefairy2088
      @catharticmemefairy2088 2 года назад +20

      @@theswiftologist my opinion is that jake is only good for content. that’s it. harrys good for content and as a person imo. looks at two ghosts by harry, great song and it’s so complimentary. he respects her, he appreciates her. she respects him and she supports him so definitely a better relationship and also great content!

    • @kevinandrews1422
      @kevinandrews1422 Год назад +2

      Red kinda gave alot more variety than 1989. There were songs with different emotions than the mostly fun & happy sounding songs in 1989.
      Like Taylor said, The color Red resembles emotions that are very intense on both good and bad sides.

  • @FrancesBaconandEggs
    @FrancesBaconandEggs 11 месяцев назад +1

    I WOULD ask you to update this but god knows what (who) she’s going to do in the next few weeks 😂

  • @pinkmenace6836
    @pinkmenace6836 6 дней назад

    We need an update 😭

  • @zoeykroening5394
    @zoeykroening5394 2 года назад

    I have my pitchfork READY!

  • @drewveflin2842
    @drewveflin2842 2 года назад +4

    red carpet look video?¿ i just have to know what you think about THAT black dress

  • @dylphil99
    @dylphil99 2 года назад +3

    Is 2015 coming up on the podcast soon???

  • @didinau
    @didinau 2 года назад +14

    Yeah, John Mayer is just...yikes.
    He was fine af, but his personality just ruined everything for me.
    People say he changed though but I don't know

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +10

      NOOOO HE WAS NOT FINE. never fine af. always looked like he just got done dumpster diving for a banana peel

    • @didinau
      @didinau 2 года назад +1

      @@theswiftologist to each their own I guess 😅 he looked handsome when he was younger

    • @michealrhodes974
      @michealrhodes974 2 года назад +2

      @@theswiftologist the shade....the shade of it all

  • @xoapadani
    @xoapadani 2 года назад

    I’d watch the John Mayer video as well

  • @CruellaDeVentiChino
    @CruellaDeVentiChino Год назад +13

    Jake Gyllenhaal was a bad boyfriend, John Mayer is a bad man. I think that's the major difference between the two.

    • @nikkiknack
      @nikkiknack 7 месяцев назад

      solid distinction!

  • @berryrl9
    @berryrl9 2 года назад +13

    Oh c'mon! Harry Styles will be no.1 again to you when she rerecords 1989 lol

  • @morgandavis1527
    @morgandavis1527 Год назад +5

    I’m personally offended harry isn’t number one 😭

  • @shwetapandit2143
    @shwetapandit2143 Год назад +1

    Rank them again after 1989 TV 😋

  • @pghtaylorsversion
    @pghtaylorsversion 8 месяцев назад

    I am soooo curious to know where Joe would go in this line up now.......!

  • @shelleygoodwin6371
    @shelleygoodwin6371 11 месяцев назад

    I feel like all too well TV has some more scathing lines in it, and it's the fact that she didn't even need to try to be scathing all she needed to do was speak the truth such as, his lovers stay her age.. I think his actions in how he treated her and their relationship and just the fact that he seems to date younger women reflect VERY poorly on him, but I don't think he's overall a bad person and him refusing to speak on it is probably the best way he could possibly deal with or respond to her songs and media gossip.

  • @christymcmichael9748
    @christymcmichael9748 6 месяцев назад

    omg how dare u have smart, eloquent, and succinct opinions on this relevant topic!!! ur def not a real swiftie obviously…. lol hope the sarcasm was detected - the bloomberg article was a great moment in this video, i’d love if she would be prolific outside of songwriting but also be prolific with her wealth and status maybe

  • @yorkshiregirl992
    @yorkshiregirl992 2 месяца назад

    You are such a smart cookie. I'm roughly 40 years older than you, and I am amazed by your wisdom. You are an old soul (and I mean that in the best possible way). It is clear to me that Jake is a decent guy, although maybe wasn't the best choice for Taylor back then. Talk of gaslighting and grooming is so juvenile and not rooted in real life.

  • @lilmisslizzyc
    @lilmisslizzyc Год назад +2

    you know what? honestly Jake at number one is fair.

  • @mohithas960
    @mohithas960 2 года назад

    @Swiftologist, who do you think is worst: Calvin Harris or John Meyer??

  • @lizzieg133
    @lizzieg133 2 года назад +2

    is better man about jake or john ?

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  2 года назад +2

      U know it is really up for debate....I'm personally 50/50 on that

  • @AmetafJohora
    @AmetafJohora Год назад +1

    thinking abt how taylor made a whole bunch of songs abt joe alwyn and we're just like we do not see it lmfaoo

    • @AmetafJohora
      @AmetafJohora Год назад +1

      this is a joke for legal purposes i am a lover album stan too

  • @theblvckdog
    @theblvckdog 6 месяцев назад

    6:42 the funny part is begin again was actually written in 2011 and EHC was written in may 2012 (two months before she even met conor) so she actually didn’t write any songs about him (yup she wanted us to think both songs r abt him and gaslighted us) meanwhile calvin has bejeweled and high infidelity 😂

    • @theswiftologist
      @theswiftologist  6 месяцев назад

      We know that begin again was about will from parachute though that was never a CK song

  • @xndrjt
    @xndrjt 2 года назад +13

    hear me out..
    *Dear John 10 Minutes (Taylor’s Version)* + Short Film

  • @X0XillusionistX0X
    @X0XillusionistX0X 2 месяца назад

    Yes John Mayer roast 🎉😂

  • @taeminislove
    @taeminislove 10 месяцев назад

    To me, Taylor Lautner is the best ex in terms of how she was treated HOWEVER, we really gotta applaud Jake for not going crazy/berserk with all the bullshit he got after the release of ATW 10 minute version. I feel like he unfortunately got a lot more roasted than John, even. Which, to me, wasn't something he deserved after 10 years lol. And idk, I feel like if Jake was just THAT horrible, I don't think we would've gotten a song like "I almost do" out of that relationship. I feel like he was just neglectful and didn't feel as strongly as Taylor did- or at least he was too late in expressing it.

  • @cgygflkj
    @cgygflkj 2 года назад +3

    I mean I would never put JG in #1 probably because I like 1989 more than Red 😳 and either way the 10 min music video made me suuuuuupper uncomfortable and gave me predator vibes. So HS for the win.

    • @kevinandrews1422
      @kevinandrews1422 Год назад +1

      But there were beautiful moments in the music video too. Like the scenes "Are you for real?", Getting lost upstate, Dancing round the kitchen to the refrigerator light, Doing crossword puzzles in bed etc...

  • @justincera1770
    @justincera1770 2 года назад

    Calvin for me is the worst

  • @finleypawrker8551
    @finleypawrker8551 4 месяца назад

    I know everyone likes to clown on Calvin. But objectively he wasn’t out of Taylor’s league at the time dated. He was one of the biggest music producers in the 2010s - produced rhianas 2 most streamed songs and has more monthly listeners than harry styles today. He’s Taylor’s richest ex by far prob why he pushed back after the break up bc he could afford it. Also, she cheated on him in a public fashion so don’t really blame him for taking his opportunity to clap back.

  • @poojaahuja3934
    @poojaahuja3934 4 месяца назад

    U should not do that to anyone u were dating....it proves the opposite of what you are trying to prove.

  • @deeb733
    @deeb733 2 года назад +4

    i mean i never liked jake gyllenhaal
    but he gave us some ✨beautiful✨ musical content
    he just rubbed me the wrong way
    and then atw ten min version

  • @percyweasley9301
    @percyweasley9301 2 года назад

    *You are not a real Swifty if you are going to rank her boyfriends etc. Respect her and their privacy. It's wrong to scrutinize someon's lovers like this.🙄😑🙏🙏

  • @pmprajwalmaheshwari8046
    @pmprajwalmaheshwari8046 2 года назад +1

    If Taylor Swift did this thing i would probably consider watching
    But you just put your views about a thing which you or literally anyone else ( apart from swift )have literally 0 idea of whats true or false

    • @elenagerhardy2636
      @elenagerhardy2636 2 года назад +7

      I think the creator is pretty clear that we don’t know what happened behind closed doors, and is doing a ranking based on publicly available content (what, if anything, Swift’s exes said about her publicly after their respective break ups and the quality of songs that are linked to each ex. I’m not really seeing what the issue is with this video. If you don’t want to listen to Taylor Swift commentary from someone other than Taylor herself, you might be on the wrong channel.