Experts Debunk GOP's Attempts To 'Cancel' Critical Race Theory
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 июл 2024
- Many GOP leaders’ attempts to deny American’s racist history are debunked by experts in conversation with Jonathan Capehart. These experts explain how facing our nation’s original sins will make America stronger.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersRUclips
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#Race #TheSundayShow #MSNBC
“Only a fool would let their enemy teach their children.” -- Malcom X
Very solid quote, model Malcolm X was Radical he had some great ideas.
@Sara Mill So what? We know that many of the democrats are racist too, except they will accept criticism about it, unlike the republicans who only want Blacks who speak their same racist narrative and support legislation that is against their own interests. Black republicans be over there like, "Ma massa bedern' yorn'!" foh!
@Sara Mill It did for some schools, the national guard had to be there. Look up who made it a jungle....
correct.
How’s that working out for blacks as a whole ? Denouncing education has done wonders hasn’t it ?
I will never tell my son he’s a victim nor will I tell him he can’t succeed because of the color of his skin!
I tend to think for any loved one, it's better not to let them think of themselves as a victim, even when they in fact are. Like - take a look at your cards, take a moment if you need to cry, then get busy doing the best you can.
That's not what Critical Race Theory is, your brain must be incapable of understanding nuance
@@armani3762 That's exactly what CRT is
@@armani3762 Actually its the basis of critical race theory. Many of the lesson plans are publicly available I encourage you to go read some of it..
@@ryaandnice But they are NOT victims. That's the issue here. kids are being fed this race determinism. If you are black then you are perpetually under the thumb of all white people and you will NEVER be allowed to do anything. If you say you don't see yourself or your life like this you have "internalized racism". If your white, your very existence is somehow traumatizing to all of your other classmates, Your opinions are violent and racist ALWAYS and you will NEVER be able to not be a monster and can never be a true friend.
Critical race theory is horrific
the fall of usa is before your eyes.
Ask yourself why Robin Diangelo hasn’t accepted Aayan Hirsi’s challenge to debate her ideas or why Ibram Kendi hasn’t accepted Coleman Hughes’s offer to debate.
CRT 'theorists' simply pass of everything as 'White Supremacy'. Empirical evidence= White supremacy, The Scientific Method =White Supremacy, debating your position=white supremacy.
Kendi is a sick racists who is also a communist. So, we are listening to these people who hate the U.S.
As professor Henry Clark said, “I debate my equal and teach the rest”
Coleman is an articulate young man but he is not an expert in this field, if he is willing to study in the field and produce a scholarship then He’ll be in the equal footing to debate with professors Kandi. With Hirsi! Who is her? She nothing but an opportunist… she has no credentials other than recycling other people’s talking points. Dr. Diangelo has not business of standing next to her. She is nobody
Don't raise your children to be victims. Otherwise one day they will truly become one.
@Larinda Nomikos I can guide my children what they need to know.
So why are the white people acting like victims of CRT?
teaching them history doesnt mean they wont be accountable for their own actions, just that their actions fit into a system. chil.
@@sguardian870 Because it's perpetuating racism in future generations that impacts all humans. Us vs. Them. CRT requires that "whites" must be the new "them". Nazis referred to "them" as "Jews" about 80 years ago. The Nazis thought they were the winning team when they made many the same simplified claims that CRT "experts" have done, and they thought everyone else was wrong. The only way they could get others to agree was by causing a war. Ultimately, you don't have to be a victim before you realize something is wrong.
@@viconiusvortex4999 except that isn't what it is about. It is about systems
*Discrimination and Disparities, by Thomas Sowell*
Great book, he explains where all this "inequity" between races comes from.
If he explains where it comes from and you know where it comes from then you must want it to be there, but knowing how Sowell talks he most likely blames discrimination on the target.
@@jamberry8026
If I am a physician, and I find an explanation to why some patinets respond worse to treatment.
Do i want them to be like that?
Sowell does not endorse CRT.
@@jamberry8026 Read more Prof Sowell.
@@shamsheerg7519Truth frightens you and you love the brainwash that helps you feel better about your ignorance.
Parents are resisting this crap. And they seem to be winning.
well, facebook is watching you, maybe robinhood outage for them i guess?
@Larinda Nomikos The truth? Do you even know what you're talking about?
@@veeseez7857 Do you know what YOU are talking about?
Good.
I hope so. CRT is a racist, Neo-Marxist ideological platform. There are a significant number of American racists who are pushing this ideology, and it will take a whole lot more people to take a stand if this hatred is going to be called out for what it is.
CRT is old, but now everyone is all of a sudden assuming it's something out of nowhere. We are doomed as a country
out of the ivory tower and in the to ether
Propaganda
Must be nice living on the plantation.
If by experts you mean experts at lying, then yes.
"Experts"...
😂🤣😂🤣
Expert propagandists.
@Larinda Nomikos
There is nothing educated in making an argument that goes against facts.
@Larinda Nomikos The irony of you talking about someone not being educated while defending critical race theory. Lmao
@Larinda Nomikos It's a theory, not a fact. Google it
@@malasc12 what matters is the person. Not their race.
Experts?
I think not.
Experts 😉
Yes. Do you...not know what that means?
@@magdelanax2122 yeah people that get paid to spew nonsense on live television
They are trying to keep us apart. We are stronger together
@Ernest Khalimov I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask for scientific evidence that CTR works before I can believe you
@Ernest Khalimov I'm serious show me proof it works because I've looked into and couldn't find any evidence because I was interested on how it's going to stop racism because if it does then I would be more than happy to support it.
@Ernest Khalimov just trying to have a civil discussion but apparently you can't. Your not helping your cause just by throwing insults just because someone has a different point of view.
@Ernest Khalimov besides CRT is just going to cause a further divide by basically teaching young people all white people are inherently racist.
I think it's better to teach people the be more racially color blind than teaching white people are the problem.
@Ernest Khalimov no there’s black people on the first results on RUclips when you search it lol I’m willing to bet your white and over weight
Like a slew of other theories, this one is designed for the weak-minded.
It isn't just the GOP that opposes it. Anyone who cares about the mental health and well being of children should oppose it.
You could be right, I'm still undecided on this.
Thats the thing though. I don't take my young children to civil rights and slave museums, simply because of the gruesomeness. But Im also careful not to raise them ignoring their history which ties very closely to the present. History explains certain situations to them that would otherwise baffle them or make them blame themselves for racists encounters. Also CRT WILL NOT be taught to children. It's a graduate law school course, people take something and run miles with it.
I like how none of the people on this panel understand that they are going to be made fun of by historians 10 years from now.
@Larinda Nomikos
Wow!
Someone takes their MSNBC viewing far, far, far too seriously.
Larinda; I was not specifically talking about the people on this panel. I was talking about the people who are supporting a theory (THEORY: an unproved assumption) rather than using actual history to talk about history. The people on this panel are included among them, and are completely oblivious to the fact that a decade from now, we'll be talking about them in the same way that people talk about flat earthers.
@Ernest Khalimov
Riiiiight.
Because arguing that the US went to war with the British simply to preserve slavery is in the same realm of truth to you as someone yelling racist slogans at a woman?
The great thing about this Ernest is that people will have forgotten who you are by the time Critical Race Theory (an unproven assumption) is laughed at by people in the future.
@Ernest Khalimov
If by "tangent" you mean "explaining to you what critical race theory says"?
suuuuuure.
@Ernest Khalimov Check out Robin DiAngelo's "White Fragility". He is a CLASSIC example of how many of them get bent out of shape when confronted with the truth of how unexceptional they are.
@@QuatMan take a look at Mike McWhorter’s position on and discoveries in “black fragility”. I think you’ll be even more critical of critical race theory
how come there is not much racial diversity in critical race theory? where are the Hispanic, Asian, etc representatives?
Probably because they weren't slaves, targets of Jim Crow or atleast not to the same degree.
You really didn't think about what you are asking and what the answer could be, did you?
The people in this video are not CRT scholars. Actual CRT scholars would be folks like Kimberle Crenshaw, Richard Delgado, and Mari Matsuda. Look up LatCrit, AsianCrit, DesiCrit, etc.
You mean, your racist past; not my racist past. Don't put that on me and others.
Lol
The problem is not learning about our racist past. Its boiling down the issues to the present by that racist past.
From the time I was a small child i never associated any difference in appearance to anything other than appearance. The only differences within the human race is cultural. These many cultural differences stem from self imposed / geographic isolation or linguistic differences. We need to take what is best from all our cultures here in America and make them an American way of life. Teach it in school rather than this subversive anti truth called critical race theory.
Let's all play nice in the sand box. Take race off of every form in the US and see what happens.
@@nursesheilafnp9473 sounds great to me Sheila.
If there is any doubt that racism and historical ignorance are alive and well in the 21st, all one has to do is take a look at the comments entered here.
Thanks to each and every one of them, the problem being discussed by the panel is completely validated.
I am 6min through this video and I haven’t heard anything about critical race theory except it’s Origins.
You didn't hear it because you're slow.
0:38
Because it's nonsense, illogical & irrational...and they all KNOW it.
ANGELA DAVIS got her PhD under one of the founders of ^CRITICAL THEORY his name was Herbert Marcuse. They will tell you nothing to worry about and a Trojan Horse is just a horse: CRT is being installed in some form in 3500 public school district K thru 12 in my opinion that is child abuse. All race theories are racist and wrong and playing word redefinition games is just cunning leftist subterfuge. This is an anti American revolution. MLK had the right message it is even a LIE to claim the USA is systemically racist.
@@mohammedmassaquoi3444 and you’re woke!
@@D_M_S_4 actually I just pay attention
I grew up in the 60s a REAL civil rights movement this is not a serious movement..
I disagree it’s telling the truth on how this country I serve for was built on racism and the Europeans that came here don’t want their off spring to know how this country was built on our backs .
@@brianhightower7768 C R T is one man DR kedi"s version of history.. this country was built on freedom n liberty. .what country would you like to live in . .if this is the racist country you claim why are millions of people wanting in..?
@@brianhightower7768 the black man has more opportunities today then ever before .
@@brianhightower7768 you have to back 200 yrs to prove your point. let work on the next 200yrs.
The 3/5ths compromise part is true. That's part of the importance of telling the whole story why critical race theory is important. I'm an advocate for the critical race theory and the 3/5th's compromise was done to prevent white southern plantation owners from having an overwhelming majority by being able to count each of their slaves as another vote for who they voted for. Slaves were still used for their vote with the 3/5th's compromise, but they did not count as high as they would and the south still had a slight advantage WITH the compromise.
and, let me guess, is this on 1619 when USA wasnt even been created yet?
Ok. How does that effect me today?
@@freeindeed8416 shhhh, he might have slave at home.
"I'm an advocate for the critical race theory " -- Good for you! Most normal people do not support do not support it. You are either a bigot or are just plain ignorant.
@@renaldiroekanto789 no this happened well after 1619.. you’re an example of why people need to learn about American history.
RACE HUSTLING PAYS WELL
@Larinda Nomikos
You're getting paid?
@Larinda Nomikos Trolling is when you say something you don't believe or care about solely to get a rise out of people. Calling CRT what it is isn't 'trolling'.
@Larinda Nomikos demonizing white people simply for being white is not mlk dream. This clown already showed his bigotry with a white women adopting a black child. You should be ashamed with pushing this division in this country.
@Larinda Nomikos Pushing racial division with CRT has no place in our American society.
I love how people think that using the word "debunked" make them win an argument.
Debunked can surely call a lie a lie
@@gregb1374 the lie is that racism is the core American value
“Experts”lol that’s the propaganda’s favorite word
There is a principal
which is proof against all information,
which is proof against all arguments,
which cannot fail to keep man in
everlasting ignorance;
that principal is -
Contempt prior to investigation !”
― HERBERT SPENCER
Actually, it's the generalized "they" followed by "us" as in "that's what THEY want you to believe", and "everybody knows They are not like US."
What they really mean is "advocates"
Anyone can be an "expert" or "activist" these days.
@@justincook181 "activist" nowadays is a synonym for "useless person"
E. Pluribus Unum, out of many one. Stop it with trying to divide us, we are on to your malarkey.
Who's Fox?
"Experts"
The strongest chains ever made, are the ones we build in our minds...
nah, its good if its brainwashed
Then why are black and brown children pushed into segregated communities? Why do black and brown children land in lower rated school districts which receive less funding ? These are not the works of invisible mind chains...your tone deaf comment justifies the fact that CRT is much needed in schools.
@@jibarabicha4853 I Cannot speak to the redlining of Black and Brown people into low income communities for the last 60 years... School systems are majority funded through real estate taxes. Low tax bases mean little money for schools. Federal assistance is always held up for partisan reasoning. This issue is not strictly a color issue. Southern Red States with majority white populations also suffer from lack of funding and poor education. It's systemic.
@@jibarabicha4853 Cool story bro
@@jibarabicha4853 I can agree with you that kids get put in horrible schools which cause decline in their development. I used to work in one of those schools and saw smart black kids go to waste cause the leftist woke ideology rather not punish bad kids and sacrifice good kids for the sake of equity. All kids were being taught 2 grades lower to cater to the bottom without having to flunk them.
However who is against school choice which would easily solve this. And which party just happens to get money from school unions. How easily would this be fixed if parents could choose which schools their taxes funded with vouchers. Also it's bad to give funding based on tax. It puts a disadvantage for the low income. However much of the money that goes to public school is wasted. About 80 dollars per kid per day.
These people all look and sound so oppressed, so tragic.
You’re being sarcastic, right?
@@beanman8907 Of course he is. Do those people act held back & silenced to you?
@@1w598 you never know. I’ve seen stupider defenses to things like this.
Do you know what oppressed means?
@@beanman8907 yes, sarcasm
We should accept the fact that some people love to live in their ignorance. That's what they say Ignorance is Bliss.
When the ignorant is attacking our children you don’t except it. Would you want your 6 year old child giving blow jobs and it’s fine with the government.
What chapter in this curriculum teaches about what 100% adherence to 100% democrat run urban core dystopian conditions of crime, poverty, decrepit housing conditions, no jobs, etc, democrats created for their Black voters?
Is this a game of how many lies you can fit coherently in a sentence?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! YOU ARE HILARIOUS! 🤣😂🤣😂🤮
@@rainbeauxunicorn5237 if they were “lies” you would have easily dismantled the, and pointed out to others they were, yet your freneticism to say “something” in reply, but saying nothing, actually validated my comment as 100% accurate, didn’t it?
@@sydnidowney3598 thanks.. Try the veal!
@@luntershaptopfukinov6413 Still HILARIOUS. 😝
And somehow its okay to teach that it was necessery to commit genocide against the natives in school.
Over half the south enslaved, with children worked to death and a life expectancy of 24... no wonder they want to forget.
"America is so racist" says black two term US President.
He ought to know. McConnell made sure that no legislation would pass during Obama's presidency. Yeah he knowd
@@izzyfloresactor Except for his first two years.
“Experts” lmfao
Victimism experts
There is a principal
which is proof against all information,
which is proof against all arguments,
which cannot fail to keep man in
everlasting ignorance;
that principal is -
Contempt prior to investigation !”
― HERBERT SPENCER
ikr the title of this video made me laugh honestly
@xursx a lot of childish behavior always. However the past 4 years have been like living in a country that has been made into a 3 ring circus. Unfortunately, this has EXPOSED AN EXTREME MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS. OH, art was already present and always has been. Trump gave the green light to PUT “ issues” under the FORD LED HEADLIGHTS. IGNORANCE front and center. The people who are attempting to unite and clean up the steaming pile of horse s&&( trump left behind, as he has his entire life. For others to clean up, Those people cleaning up behind the badly in need of mental health care , SHOULD GO FULL SPEED AHEAD AND smash this utter house of delusional self entitled CLOWNS , he left behind after his reign of malignant narcissistic man child temper tantrum.
CRT claims there is still systemic racism but can't point out any laws that allow discrimination based on race.
That's because it's based on standpoint epistemology and social constructivism.
All disparities are caused by society, the people who created society can only make laws and narratives that benefit themselves. Hence everything is racist, even liberal society itself.
It's complete bs tho.
it is not about laws. it is about actions. For example when a bank refuses to loan a black man a home that is in a white neighborhood. or when a real estate agent refuses to show a black man house in a white neighborhood.
We don’t believe this or want this in our country.
lmao!
In Germany & France it is a criminal offence to deny the holocaust; NEVER AGAIN, those that do not learn the lesson of history are destined to repeat it.
FFS, we already learn America's history ever. single. year. in K-12. That's not what Critical Race Theory is.
Should never build on a weak foundation of lies and hate... anything you try to construct on such a flimsy platform will inevitably collapse.
You mean the lie that Trump won?
When college, writing a paper on this era, got me sent to the Dean's office 2!
Where did you go to College? I am stunned by this.
@@sionnachmacbradaigh1010 The grammar (or lack of), or the getting sent to office for writing on this?
@@feedyourmind6713 Mainly the latter, but the former makes me the think the trip to the Dean's office might have been for something other than enlightened politics.
*Misleading Title* ... This video gives four opinions and perspectives on race relations and histroy. It does *not* "debunk" GOP criticism of critical race theory at all; it barely discusses CRT.
One minute left and have not heard a single word about "critical race theory".......the reason for that is obvious.
it's call history
Do you believe we should shelter our children from the absolute truth regarding the ugly racial history of our country?
I remember being a kid and hearing the BS in school, trying to talk to the other kids and not understanding how they didn't see through the lies?!?! It seemed so obvious to me, I had a really hard time being in class with kids that bought into the insanity that slave traders were helping free slaves from their misery! What?!?!
Who would believe that foolishness?
Where did YOU go to school?
All through my years in public schools we were taught about the evils of slavery and the inhumane treatment of the slaves. We cannot go back and change history nor should it be hidden. Among those mistreated as well as the Black race, were the Asians and worse of all were the American Indians who we massacred and cheated out of their land and natural resources as well as their children were taken away from them. If you check out many other countries, you will find not much difference concerning their treatment of past slave races. We should be teaching tolerance and inclusion without putting a guilt trip on any particular race. Based on past history separating out a person based on the color of their skin is about as racists as you can get. Remember how the American Japanese were treated during WW2, and that Chinese could not own land. We were taught in our U.S. History classes all about our countries past. CRT is as divisive as you can get and as well as racists.
Why are these people allowed on our screens? I get sick looking at them
It seems that in popular discourse critical race theory is like quantum mechanics, in that if you think you understand it clearly you don't.
I've studied quantum mechanics and i think you're correct.
Prof. Kendi, given the obvious disagreements among Black scholars like Glenn Loury & John McWhorter among others, a debate is urgently required ... MSNBC set it!!
LOL imagine MSNBC allowing dissenting opinions
YES PLEASE
@@theinternets4292 True; however, one never truly knows LOL
Who else thinks that the like/dislike is fake based on the comments?
hard to say, this is MSNBC. I'd imagine most viewers purchase Robin Diangelo's book
Funny how they say kendi isn't a CRT teacher
Kendi has been challenged to a formal discussion by actual scholars who think his ideas are absolute garbage, and how did he respond? Not by accepting and letting the truth put detractors of his nonsense to rest, no, he ran with his tail between his legs. Apparently when black scholars point out that CRT is inherently flawed, suddenly the CRT proponents dont have much to say. Now Kendi is trying to put distance between himself and CRT claiming he doesnt talk about or teach it. Hes an actual joke..
So as a Native I guess I'm supposed to feel like a victim? I don't. Does that make me racist?
I think you are, yes. Don't let them get to your kids.
Any legitimate CRT gate keeper will say you have "false consciousness" Then you be made to attend intensive diversity equity and inclusion classes, until your consciousness is raised, then you become awakened to your "true" self or woke. Or you could tell them to F off.
No, you are not to feel a victim, nothing was ever done to you or your people that you should feel victimized about.
ANGELA DAVIS got her PhD under one of the founders of ^CRITICAL THEORY his name was Herbert Marcuse. They will tell you nothing to worry about and a Trojan Horse is just a horse: CRT is being installed in some form in 3500 public school district K thru 12 in my opinion that is child abuse. All race theories are racist and wrong and playing word redefinition games is just cunning leftist subterfuge. This is an anti American revolution. MLK had the right message it is even a LIE to claim the USA is systemically racist.
No. CRT does not label individuals. What it does is examines how race has been a factor in the laws, policies, and culture in this country. What it might mean that if you are a white person there are some advantages you have benefited from because of your race. The study does not label or judge individuals.
No one needs to apologize for something their ancestors did. If you have a problem with that, then you need to do a reality check.
No apologies are expected....Just stop lying about it!!!!
@@daydreamerz well if you’re a democrat then technically you’re historically the party of the klan so maybe YOU should be paying reparations?
@@xursssulaxx Yep that's right let's teach the racist history of the democratic party and how their policies have held the black people in poverty. But then how could they point and say look over there is a Nazi.
@@daydreamerz Garbage logic. When the Romans pay reparations to the Thracians, then we can talk about corrections. Myopic!
@@daydreamerz Then it’s in the past. Your grandfathers (and by this point it would be great-great-great grandfathers for many people) have little to do with you as a human being. It was a bad thing that happened in the past that we can’t change or make right. You can’t right the wrongs of the past you can’t only prepare for the future.
Enter "The Experts": The priesthood of the modern world. Ignore the facts or burn at the stake
ANGELA DAVIS got her PhD under one of the founders of ^CRITICAL THEORY his name was Herbert Marcuse. They will tell you nothing to worry about and a Trojan Horse is just a horse: CRT is being installed in some form in 3500 public school district K thru 12 in my opinion that is child abuse. All race theories are racist and wrong and playing word redefinition games is just cunning leftist subterfuge. This is an anti American revolution. MLK had the right message it is even a LIE to claim the USA is systemically racist.
@@mplaw77 MLK wrote about how the USA is systemically racist lol
Yes!!
The only way forward is exactly what he said, which is teach the real history of the USA!
Here in Germany i have chatted with people from Berlin (north) to Freiburg (South) and here the history that was is taught, reparations have and are still being made, reconstruction is on going due to updating everything to 2021 standards (constant infrastructure upgrades).
These things were not and have not been done in the USA in regards to slavery, regarding the full history of the USA! This is the reason so many people do not know about the terrorism that a lot of Americans to this day live through on a daily basis, they do not know or acknowledge the systematic racist system that is the US system.
In order to change this system, in order for the USA to make the American 'dream' a reality, in order for the country to move forward for all citizens this knowledge needs to be taught to everyone.
This is what the Republicans are fighting against because without ignorant people there would be no racists and without racism there would be no republican party.
Racists tell you how you are racist.
What form of oppression is worse in modern times than low expectation?
Encouraging people to riot, loot, be violent, vandalize, and harass & terrorize people who don't look like you.
where exactly is the blm money going to?
"We need to tell the whole history of America and not just part of it." They then proceed to say the word slavery 1,000 times...
You can draw a ling from Slavery to now. Sorry
@@rogue-ish5713 You can draw a line from reading comprehension to your statement.
Teach your children the truth about your history. Never let them forget what your ancestors went through. Prepare them for the world that they live in and pray.
So instead of teaching kids not to see color as the defining characteristic of who they are, we want to do the opposite?
CRT apologist: “CRT is an advanced theoretical framework of legal analysis.”
Also CRT apologist: “CRT is teaching accurate history.”
Well, which one is it? And should it be taught in schools because schools should teach accurate history, right? These people either don’t know what they’re defending or they’re lying.
How are those things mutually exclusive?
You cannot look at history through the lens of it's laws and their impact on the populations under them?
seems like a 'no-brainer'.
Exactly. They are liars.
@@RJCHOICE He didn't say they were mutually exclusive. He implied they were not. CRT is not merely an advanced theoretical framework, as apologists claim. It includes practical application of the "theory" and that includes teaching its highly biased version of history. So they are lying when they claim CRT cannot be taught in public schools. It's obviously _meant_ to be taught in public schools and restructure the education system. It began as a rejection of the idea that Brown v Board was enough to solve the black education problem.
@@donjindra it doesn’t teach a biased view of history. It views that the way history is currently being taught is white and American apologia, and it true hides racial oppression and inequality. Whether that’s redlining, prison industrial complex, over policing, laws effecting races disproportionately, and much, much more. And something I see with people critiquing CRT, is they deny the existence of oppression or inequity, inequality, racial disparities, they fail to actually understand that CRT is descriptive, and therefore fall into what can be considered right wing apologia. And your point about it being taught in public schools is borderline stupid, why you may ask. Because CRT is a legal framework which is taught in law school.
@@yusukesmokes2398 "It views that the way history is currently being taught is white and American apologia, and it true hides racial oppression and inequality. "
That and everything that follows is flagrant bias.
CRT is not simply a legal framework. The paragraph you just wrote contradicts that. You advocates should stop lying about that. It's extremely easy to google 'CRT in education.' Doing so reveals a long history of CRT being promulgated throughout the education field. I don't know why you think the public will accept the blatant lie that CRT is a legal theory that's too advance for children. CRT is simple stuff. A 6 year old understands the basic principles.
No one here can say why Critical Race Theory is racist, they just say its racist, and someone said Critical Race Theory teaches hate. SMH
Only one who wants this is a
Chinesemarrionetts
That defense of the 3/5ths rule is completely twisted 🥨
Amazing what hate can breed, to purposefully twist history and lie like that...
@@SeaofRed79 Like claiming the Zombie MAGApocalypse never really happened, or that Antifa and BLM did it.
@@TooBadThatDidntKillMe exactly
You don't get denialism without nihilism. As life-long conservative Bill Kristol astutely pointed out, the Republican party has embraced nihilism. Republicans denying systemic racism; Republicans still labeling COVID-19 a "hoax;" Republicans still refusing to wear masks or social distance after over half-a-million American fatalities from COVID-19; Congressional Republicans obstructing a COVID-19 stimulus bill certain to pass just to delay vital and urgently needed relief to Americans desperate for help; not one Congressional Republican in either chamber voting for the badly needed stimulus bill; Republican governors dropping mask mandates and all restrictions on businesses, heedless of rising case counts in their states and deadly new variants of the virus; and Republican leaders continuing to push the Big Lie that the 2020 Presidential election was stolen without evidence and in disregard of plentiful evidence and facts to the contrary, even AFTER their Big Lie incited a terrorist attack by a mindless Republican mob against the nation's Capitol in insurrection against the government, attempting to overturn a legitimate election, sieging, storming, sizing, sacking, defiling, defacing and disgracing America's citadel of, and temple to, democracy; and now Republicans attempting history revisionism with the January 6 insurrection--these are all prime examples of nihilism.
So you’d prefer the slave states had more power by being able to pick and choose when to treat slaves as people?
When is Dr. Kendi going to step up and debate John McWhorter and have his butt whooped? Oh that's right.....never.
he's a LIGHTWEIGHT.
Tell me again how maths are racist.
LOL "experts"
they are "qualified".
Yes, steeping ourselves in self-hate and guilt over things we didn't take part in for our entire lives is surely healthy for the population.
I always tell the truth to my kids.
That slavery has been practiced by everyone and some continue to do so.
Does that mean that slavery is a non issue....because so many cultures practiced it?
@@sydnidowney3598
No, it means that slavery that still exists in Africa, the Middle East, etc should be met with greater force.
Wouldn’t you agree?
Just a big tool for division and chaos. But I guess only a few of us see that.
Three of the four people on this panel are intelligent, successful people who happen to be of recent African heritage. I certainly don't think that being African American seems to have kept any of them from achieving amazing success. This sort of turning any argument into a supposed desire to hold African American people down is NOT what conservative and quite frankly liberal people, of all ages are trying to do. People are waking up to this billion dollar grievance industry and refusing to be shut down by accusations of prejudice supposedly held by white people secretly. I'm not a conservative, but we can't intelligently talk about problems as fellow Americans if people are too afraid to say anything critical about a very radical ideology. This is a multi billion dollar industry but the one trick of shaming people isn't working anymore. So people on the left are being lied to that conservatives don't acknowledge our very checkered past. These are tactics not good faith arguments.
The problem is vaguely gelatinous because one often encounters self-righteous denial upon trying to seriously discuss the issues. This phenomena is not unlike Kevin McCarthy’s recent claim that “no one” is denying the legitimacy of Biden’s elevation.
On the other hand, a "theory" that holds that all white people either admit they are racist then they are racist, or if they deny they are racist that is ever more proof they are. The logical outcome is easy; all white people are racist. This is to any reasonable person, an insane criteria to apply to all of America much less school kids, but the "progressive" movement has cloaked this divisiveness in so many virtuous words, that people like you have been brainwashed into thinking this is all perfectly sound. Really think through what CRT says. Every white person you have ever known is hopelessly racist. Is that really what you believe??
@@ryaandnice
Ryan.... for purpose of illustration, I;would like to shift the context away from racism. Let’s talk about sin. The church says that all people are sinners. But perhaps we could find people who are not sinners by simply asking people whether or not they are sinners .... just as you suggest we can identify racists by asking whether or not someone is a racist? Then, you find non sinners ( non racists)among the people who say they do not sin? (Are not racists)? Is Jesus or the church saying that everyone is as evil as Charles Manson anymore than we are saying that every racist is Hitler?
On the other hand, what are you saying? Are you saying that if you are not Charles Manson.... then you are not a sinner?
What I am sayings is that.... like sin... I think we all have racist inclinations... just like we all have sinful inclinations. And, that we should make conscious efforts to reduce the impact of these inclinations on our life and the lives of those around us
I think that being a racist is an unfortunately normal part of being human. But recognizing that racism is pervasive is not saying that everyone is no different than Adolf Hitler.
@@MrArdytube Ardy, thanks for putting in a meaningful response. I'd counter argue a few things. Consider the fact that you had to compare CRT to a religious/spiritual worldview that is not at all a part of public or private policy making. You wouldn't catch an HR department in America talking about how everyone needs to admit they are a sinner. And yet here we are changing policy and law in every facet of life in something which is essentially an article of faith.
Second, but related, we've drifted from the meaningful to the hypothetical. If we applied such a broad definition to other social factors we could say that there is "systemic greed" or "systemic laziness" or "systemic violence" or "systemic ignorance" - and yet because the neo-marxists lost the battle for class warfare in the 60's and switched to race warfare to compensate, here we are talking about race, because that is how the marxists can divide us. In short, degree and extent matter. Racism is not America's biggest problem, and it's not even black Americans biggest problem - you could put drug addiction, failing public school systems, widespread destruction of the family unit based on incarceration (again drugs) and government programs that incentivize *not* forming a family way way in front of racist white people as bigger problems.
3rd, to support your "well, you are probably at least a little racist, and why not think about that awhile" position, you are ignoring what's really happening out there in the wild. People are being intimidated, fired, shamed, canceled - people are being sent to lite brainwashing sessions by their HR departments and fired otherwise. In public schools white kids are being taught they have inherited the sin of slavers, and teachers are being taught they are "black spirit killers". This is all well documented. Many leaks are available. Only mainstream media isn't covering because it doesn't fit the narrative. But at this point, anyone who doesn't see that this is a highly discriminatory, divisive and actually racist movement in practice, just doesn't want to see it. Don't trust me. Look for the info. It's all out there.
@@ryaandnice very well written. you can write an article with your writing. your reasoning is rationale too. but if you live in USA, you would get screened by color nowadays?
@@renaldiroekanto789 Thank you for the fine compliment Renaldi. I would answer yes. I would point to the rise of quotas in corporate America - for a certain position there must be a certain percentage of certain race/skin color regardless of the candidate pool - and I would point to instances like the governor of Chicago, who openly states she will only give interviews to black or brown reporters and will not to white reporters. I am saddened by this, but more saddened that Americans who are center politically are not speaking up and taking a stand. Americans are very conditioned to the social shame of being labeled a racist. It's a powerful force to stay quiet even in the face of this obvious evil.
You'll notice Ardy is gone. He won't reply. It is hard to change your mind, even when you know you are wrong. Take care.
I totally agree that the whole history of America should be taught.
I’ve met too many people who actually believe that the US was some beacon of justice that never committed a single war crime or atrocity throughout history.
The education system in the US is terrible as it is even without the complete whitewashing of history.
I’ve met leftists who truly believe slavery is a uniquely white or American phenomenon.
No one believes that. We are taught that our forefathers went to Africa and plucked people from the continent like dandelions, rather than the truth that white people simply took advantage of an existing, robust African slave trade. We are taught that our forefathers murdered an entire race in cold blood (Native Americans) just to sate their unique, Caucasoid, genetic predisposition to evil when in reality 90% of Native Americans were dead by 1650 from disease. We are never taught about the Barbary Pirates, even though they are the reason we have the US Marine Corp. Anything that endangers the idea that only white people are capable of evil is scrubbed from the history books, and yet people still complain about history being "white washed" which shows the left's anti-white hatred is insatiable and bottomless.
@@Dennis-nc3vw Whitewashing - noun:
a deliberate attempt to conceal unpleasant or incriminating facts about a person or organization in order to protect their reputation.
It’s not just about white people just because it has the word “white” in it lmao
@@Dennis-nc3vw Who brought the disease that wiped out the Native Americans, eh? Now, look at what is being done to Asian Americans, started by the white Republicans calling covid a kung-flu. Disgusting, white Republicans.
@@tarmynastyr White people, but how is it genocide if it's accidental? How could the Europeans possibly know they carried diseases the Indians were immune to until after they started dying. Also, look at what is being done to Asian Americans? You seriously want to go there. Tell me, what to cities are all the attacks against Asians happening in? And what is the skin color of 80% of the perpetrators?
Which racist laws? Which racist policies?
The title was misleading.
People with common sense after watching this: “Lol what?”
Are some K-12 or college schools actually omitting America's history of slavery from thier history lessons?
Can any high school students or parents of them ask and respond please. Thanks.
American public schools HAVE BEEN TAUGHT LIES since day one.
absolutely not and i have a question what does teaching kids about slavery do?
We need need to be teaching math, science, REAL history, ect. I juts got asked how I got the stupid idea that critical RACE THEORY, THEORIZES on the COLOR of someones SKIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I simply said how can somebody theorize on a subject of nobody's control.
My middle & high school were taught about slavery,& it’s evils(late 80s& 90s) in 8th grade, my white history teacher had us watch all the Roots movies,& it had a profound impact on me at a young age,& I’m incredibly grateful I learned about it.
@@zeej80 THATS cool. Still a movie is not accurate REAL LIFE HISTORY. I remember watching that mini series??? At home. It made me physically ill.
Every time he says "Dr. Kendi" educated folks chuckle.....sure. lol
The problem with CRT is that is devoid of any facts. If you actually do any research into any of the claims you will find they are blatantly false, and every historian and even writers of those times indicate every aspect of their idea is false.
It does not matter if it is a racist and divisive ideology every point they try to use to validate the idea is false and easily proven false.
@@user-ol7bt4wp1j That is correct.
The worst part is, they are using the exact same words, just changed who the enemy was.
This is the most evil game played by either side right now. It’s kind of sick.
Find one person on the right for CRT. You cannot.
@@FreeJulianAssange23 they want to get their racist base riled up.
@@progKansas I grew up as a Democrat being told vote for us cause the other side just happens to be racist and dumb. I'm ashamed that I fell for that obvious lie. Feel stupid believing that for 30 years.
It's painful to let go of an ideology you believed to be true for so long. But it was truth vs believing in a lie for political loyalty. Painful but easy choice. I then realized how easily we can be controlled regardless of intelligence.
@@alejandromartin8347 then why minorities have harder time to vote?
@@progKansas I'm a minority. Have never seen that. But what can be proven is that much of the media narrative are false. Cops are not after blacks and you can show that with 8th grade math. Schools shootings are not an issue in the US. Easily proven if you would like I can show the math and logic.
Also not sure how it's harder for minorities to vote.
"EXPERTS" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Fantastic discussion on America's past. Let's have more like this.
Critical race theory is move racism from the right to the left, instead of getting rid of racism.
Very important video. It makes clear how important history is to understand why America is what it is today. The truth must be told to get a better society.
@general patton We are in a war on the truth. As long as the big lie lives on, the insurrection hasn't ended.
@general patton Mitch McConnell said: "There is no question, none, that President Trump is practically and morally responsible for provoking the events of the day''. And McConnell said: ''Jan 6. was an intensifying crescendo of conspiracy theories orchestrated by an outgoing president who seemed determined to either overturn the voters' decision or else torch our institutions on the way out.''
Yes it really important to teach kids that the revolutionary war was about slavery. Even if the Brits didn't end slavery themselves until 1833. 50 years after the was over. That what the 1619 project says. Yeah this isn't about History.
@@GraphicdesignforFree What does January 6 have to do with CRT?
@@freeindeed8416 When the truth isn't told this will all happen again and America may lose democracy.
Its not education, its ideological conditioning
Liars
Experts in what? Propaganda?
In this “panel of experts” I couldn’t find one “expert” so many educated people and none with an actual education.
Critical Race Theory…
believes racism is present in every aspect of life, every relationship, and every interaction and therefore has its advocates look for it everywhere
relies upon “interest convergence” (white people only give black people opportunities and freedoms when it is also in their own interests) and therefore doesn’t trust any attempt to make racism better
is against free societies and wants to dismantle them and replace them with something its advocates control
only treats race issues as “socially constructed groups,” so there are no individuals in Critical Race Theory
believes science, reason, and evidence are a “white” way of knowing and that storytelling and lived experience are a “black” alternative, which hurts everyone, especially black people
rejects all potential alternatives, like colorblindness, as forms of racism, making itself the only allowable game in town (which is totalitarian)
acts like anyone who disagrees with it must do so for racist and white supremacist reasons, even if those people are black (which is also totalitarian)
cannot be satisfied, so it becomes a kind of activist black hole that threatens to destroy everything it is introduced into
So copy and paste somehow makes you an expert?! Haha! Give me a massive break!
@@user-qr5bz2pq7v but is he wrong tho? Look it up yourself.
@@kross2143 of course he’s wrong. All these republicans running around talking about how CRT promotes bigotry and racism. Dude, the founding fathers owned slaves!! So that tells me that anything and everything they came up with was laced with racism, which in case you didn’t know, is when a group of people seek to own and control all the businesses, the land, the mineral and capital resources, the privileges all at the expense of a weaker race of people. That’s racism and that’s exactly what happened in America. What’s wrong with teaching that if that’s what actually happened?!
@@user-qr5bz2pq7v what he included are the actual teachings of CRT. Nobody said we shouldn’t teach and speak out against the racist parts of our history or any actual racism that exists. You can’t see a problem with teaching all white people that not only are they racist, but there’s nothing they can do about it, they’ll always be racist no matter what? The belief that black and brown people can’t ever be racist because of an oppressed/oppressor structure that has always and will always exist is also bogus. The teaching that black and brown people are being held back and will never get ahead because of an unfair system that is intentionally being upheld against them is also bogus. How do you think any of that is helpful to POC? It offers a worldview that we’re perpetually stuck in the time of slavery and no progress has been or can be made other than to demonize people because of their skin color. It actually sounds like revenge to me to get back at those in the past by punishing their ancestors for something they had no part in. Or to blame everyone because of their skin color for every perceived slight or act of racism you feel has ever been done to the black community by whites. Do you see people as individuals or just caricatures?
@@kross2143 so what you’re saying is let’s forget about the real past and let’s just all focus on what lies ahead right? What you’re saying is to teach the real, raw and unfiltered version of the history is this country would only serve to demonize an entire group of people that have worked hard to right the wrongs of their ancestors right? What you’re saying is there never was a system put in place by whites to subject an entire race of black people into a social construct where the majority would win and the minority (blacks) would lose? Is that what you’re saying K Ross? If it is what you’re trying to say, then CRT is needed more than I ever thought because you’re living in a bubble. Wake up man because everything I’ve just described has happened to black folks in America. Maybe you and many others want to gloss over it and say Can’t we all just get along. No, we want the world (including our children) to know what our real history is. Not this whitewashed version that we get in our classes today. Tell the truth!
Sad that black fathers have to have a talk with their sons when they start driving to explain that they need to assume the police will assume the worst about them .
You assume there's a father in the house... look at the statistics.
@@muddywater4505 lol
The most likely cause, if the data is correct, is (implicit) bias, not dyed-in-wool racism. We are not mind readers, we can only look at the collective behavior (words and actions) after the fact, to address the issue. The police are in a very unfortunate circumstance to (at times) make life and death decisions in a split second. We all have these biases, including the police.
As a dark skinned Hispanic, I didn’t need my father to warn me, I know, when it comes to police, my skin color is a factor (right or wrong), even when pulled over by someone darker than me. If the cops have an overriding bias...it’s to go home alive at the end of their shift.
@@muddywater4505 Affirmative. The welfare systems of LBJ's Great Society have done more to increase generational poverty and long term government dependence across all races.
@@muddywater4505 while statistically true, don’t assume a true parental adult cannot be a father figure. And no I’m not talking about talkum hex
Thank God I don't have any kids
You should try to look at a bigger picture of human history: slavery was never about race, it was about economic value. Racism was just a cultural consequence of one race slavering a different one.
"Racism isn't dead, it's on life support- being kept alive by politicians, race hustlers and people that get a sense of superiority by denouncing others as racist. " - Thomas Sowell
We are not mind readers, we can only look at the collective behavior (words and actions) after the fact, to address any possible bias, prejudice, bigotry, racism, etc.
There is really very little known racists in the USA. The KKK is a good example, of dyed-in-the-wool racism.
Sowell is the bomb.
Why would you not include someone who is opposed to critical race theory on this panel? Why would anyone just believe that the opposition to CRT/CRS is debunked when you don't let those ppl explain their position?
Didnt Hitler demand critical race theory be taught in schools too.
You mean the National “SOCIALIST” Workers Party? You are right.
ban it.
You should be “experts” in quotation marks.
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character--Martin Luther King, Jr.
I wonder if you have the faintest idea why he said that or what it means 🤔
@@LisaBeergutHolst Please tell me.
Read Dr. King's book, WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE: CHAOS OF COMMUNITY? See if you can grasp what he means when he says that racism has become a STRUCTURAL PART of American culture and a way of life. You might be shocked to find him advocating what would today be called "reparations" in his 1964 book, WHY WE CAN'T WAIT. Or listen to King's speech in RUclips, which I believe is called "Three Evils of Society."
@@befirmbefair6674 "America is still a racist country. Now however unpleasant that sounds, it is the truth. And we will never solve the problem of racism until there is a recognition of the fact that racism still stands at the center of so much of our nation" -- Martin Luther King, Jr., "The Other America", 1968
@@LisaBeergutHolst 100% relevant.
"If you stick a knife in my back 9 inches and pull it out 6 inches, that's not progress. If you pull it all the way out, that's not progress. Progress is healing the wound that the blow made. They haven't pulled the knife out; they won't even admit that it's there." -Malcolm X
Critical Race theory is not about history. Books such as White Fragility are not history books. They do reference history, but referencing history is not the same thing as teaching history. This entire debate is filled with lies on both sides of this stupid debate.
They really think we're that stupid.