This is the first show that Sutton Foster has played the leading Lady that I have ever missed because I suffered an injury that has restricted my ability to travel. She is one of the best Broadway ladies of the last 25 years.
Her vocals are beautiful. So pure and harmonious, brings peace and warmth to my heart. Everytime I hear this piece I don't know why I have a tear in my eye. They make a handsome couple. lol
1. She’s to old for this role,Marian is young not 47 2. She doesn’t have the right kind of voice for the role and they never should’ve hired her,she ruined my white night
Comparisons are ODIOUS. Ignore the nitpicky pedantry in the comments. Sutton is wonderful. She imbues every single word of every single lyric with genuine emotion, feeling, and meaning. And a delicate touch. Laying the stress at exactly the right place, exactly the right tone. Breathing at exactly the right spot. She alone makes me feel like I'm hearing a song I know all too well for the very first time and she sings it like she is feeling those words for the very first time. That's a true talent.
Sutton is a great actress. I saw her in her very first preview on Broadway in Millie. But no one compares to Rebecca Luker in this role and it's almost unfair to compare them. Luker was built for this role and, like Sutton in Millie, I also saw Luker in previews and in performance. I love, love, love Sutton, but sorry, no one compares to Luker. Also, tap doesn't belong in this show, it's just bizarre that they added it.
I was stoked to have found this and other recorded clips from their shows! What I'm wondering is why they never sing together (duet)? In other versions of this musical Harold and Marian sing the last part of the song together, but in this reprised version they don't. Anyone know why that is? Just curious.
Was this recorded 12/30? I was at that show. By any chance did you capture when Hugh and Sutton were laughing? I loved that part. That was so genuine and real. This has become one of my all time fave shows.
Am a great fan of Ms. Foster but I agree with many others that this is not the role for her. This role..and the voice that has to fill it, is a true soprano, as many who've done it in the past. I was hoping that they would have given it to Sierra Boggess, but her name does not play on Broadway as it does in London....yet. Laura Osnes is another who could've. Not going to begin about the hight disparity between High and Sutton and that I don't think that he was great, either, as a choice for Harold Hill. Oh well, next revival.
00:56 very confused by how she says “roses” at 1:05, sounds like she added an extra syllable? it’s not like that on the cast album so maybe I’m just hearing things lol anyone else hear what I’m hearing here?
No, she’s not Barbara Cook because she’s not boring, but Cook was a far better singer for this role. Rebecca Luker was magnificent as was Shirley Jones in the film.
Just way too much vibrato, to the point of being annoying and distracting from a sweet, beautiful song. Shirley Jones’ tops this, but Beatles’ version may just be the best of all.
Both Foster and Jackman are wonderful; two of the finest Theatre performers we have. But as a Theatre professional myself I must say that this is an illegal video. Your camera should never have been allowed in the theatre, and the performers and the show a great disservice by distributing this video.
Im aware that is illegal, and I posted these videos just after the show ended. Mostly for the people who couldn’t see the show. I would have loved to see a show that was playing in 2004, I was 1 year old at the time ahaha, and tbh I’m glad someone recorded it illegally and shared it on RUclips, that’s the only thing that made me see that show and I’m grateful for it, illegal or not. I wanna do the same thing for people who weren’t aware of this show and found out about it only after it ended, or for those who couldn’t go. 🫶
@@thecutehuey I appreciate your comment, Huey. You bring up the only validation for illegally recording live shows; being able to allow people to see incredible performances AFTER the show has closed. Unfortunately it's almost impossible to ensure that that's what is happening. As a working professional actor I have ample reason to fear that too much distribution of videos or films like these while a show is still running cut into the bottom line of all the performers and technicians and creators of the show. Too many people see a video of the show and think there's no longer a reason to go to the live show; and it closes; and I can't pay my rent.
I said that the show was over when I posted it, don’t you think I know what you said, I’m supporting hugh, I would never post videos when the show was still going. And I already wrote that in the other comments up there, try to read better next time
@@thecutehuey Sorry, Brother. I've looked everywhere and the first time you mention the show closing is in your reply to my comment. The first and only time. I'll happily read everything you write, but you've got to write it first.
I was expecting so much more from Sutton on this song. It was disappointing to hear her vocals very narrow, pop-ish, and closed sounding. I understand she’s more of a belter than a soprano but everything from her consonants to her using of phrasing did not help her cause. She’s a phenomenal actress and I’ve loved her for years, but this is by far not her best.
Google reports that there are approximately 3,904,727,342 females on Earth at present. Of those who can sing, most could do a better job with this lovely song than Ms. Foster does here. Strident, wobbly, flat--how did she get the gig?
She’s a wonderful performer, but totally wrong vocally for this part. Have you heard what she did to My White Knight because she couldn’t sing it as written? Both Meredith Willson and Barbara Cook must be spinning in their graves.
They actually didn’t mean to copy what they did in the past, is just different. If u saw the show, also Ya got trouble is slower compared to the original song. Why it has to be traditional lol?
congratulations for breaking the law and illegally videoing this performance and at the same time destroying the live experience of theatre for all those who were seated above, behind, and near you. just watch the movie.
@@thecutehuey your arrogance is just privilege that you don't deserve and I have complained in theatres before and gotten people thrown out for this criminal behavior (obviously you don't listen to the pre-show announcements and aren't really interested in the LIVE experience)
first of all there’s no way that a video makes you feel what you feel in the theater. Second I didn’t destroy Andy of the other people experiences. Third, I’m posting these videos here so that people who couldn’t go or those who didn’t know this show was playing, have the possibility to see it. I think there’s no loss, for the actors and the production itself, the show is over. I recorded these in April, and didn’t post because I knew it was still playing.
Nothing will ever top Shirley Jone's story about singing this in the film version while pregnant. She wasn't showing much, and kept her pregnancy quiet but when she hit the high notes,her baby, kicked Robert Preston on the bridge scene. He looked shocked and asked her after what happened. She explained that it was Patrick Cassidy who later starred in the Hill role on a tour . Show biz😊
This is the first show that Sutton Foster has played the leading Lady that I have ever missed because I suffered an injury that has restricted my ability to travel. She is one of the best Broadway ladies of the last 25 years.
So Sorry you could not make It. I agree with you about Sutton Foster. She is amazing.
In London last summer she was FABULOUS xxx❤
Anything goes @ the BARBICAN in London in ANYTHING GOES was the TOP xLondon 2022 Her tap dancing Was straight out of Broadway 🎭 NEW YORK 🇺🇸 NEW YORK x
This was the first show I got to see her in. I was up high in the corner of the balcony, but I'm so happy I was able to go.
Emphasis on 'was'.
They had the best chemistry on stage - flirty rather than lusty. I wish I'd been in the rehearsal room for this show.
Her vocals are beautiful. So pure and harmonious, brings peace and warmth to my heart. Everytime I hear this piece I don't know why I have a tear in my eye. They make a handsome couple. lol
You're all insane she's brilliant!!!! One of greats of Broadway!!!!!!
1. She’s to old for this role,Marian is young not 47 2. She doesn’t have the right kind of voice for the role and they never should’ve hired her,she ruined my white night
She’s literally one of the best
Comparisons are ODIOUS. Ignore the nitpicky pedantry in the comments. Sutton is wonderful. She imbues every single word of every single lyric with genuine emotion, feeling, and meaning. And a delicate touch. Laying the stress at exactly the right place, exactly the right tone. Breathing at exactly the right spot. She alone makes me feel like I'm hearing a song I know all too well for the very first time and she sings it like she is feeling those words for the very first time. That's a true talent.
Thanks for the upload ! Man I hope they filmed this one for release . Would love to see the whole thing.
Sutton is a great actress. I saw her in her very first preview on Broadway in Millie. But no one compares to Rebecca Luker in this role and it's almost unfair to compare them. Luker was built for this role and, like Sutton in Millie, I also saw Luker in previews and in performance. I love, love, love Sutton, but sorry, no one compares to Luker. Also, tap doesn't belong in this show, it's just bizarre that they added it.
The whooping and hollering when they kiss is ridiculous.
😂😂
I was stoked to have found this and other recorded clips from their shows! What I'm wondering is why they never sing together (duet)? In other versions of this musical Harold and Marian sing the last part of the song together, but in this reprised version they don't. Anyone know why that is? Just curious.
Brilliant Broadway staging. “Just stand there. Don’t move.”
Cannot watch without thinking of Robert Preston and Shirley Jones. No comparison.
Omg I’m so excited 😍thx for posting
New York’s Sutton Foster Amazing xx
Was this recorded 12/30? I was at that show. By any chance did you capture when Hugh and Sutton were laughing? I loved that part. That was so genuine and real. This has become one of my all time fave shows.
Heyyy yes I have! It was from 12/30! I’ll upload!
ruclips.net/video/il5KHWTLbwY/видео.html
Here it is!
@@thecutehuey Thank you. I love it!
They did at the 1/8 matinee as well, a couple of times.
I was "genuine and real" because they were/are having an affair. It's why Hugh got divorced from his wife.
Some of these comments are nit-picking and downright nasty.
Man I would have hated hearing the audience go WOOOH when they kissed - like it was a high school production or a sit com.
Am a great fan of Ms. Foster but I agree with many others that this is not the role for her. This role..and the voice that has to fill it, is a true soprano, as many who've done it in the past. I was hoping that they would have given it to Sierra Boggess, but her name does not play on Broadway as it does in London....yet. Laura Osnes is another who could've. Not going to begin about the hight disparity between High and Sutton and that I don't think that he was great, either, as a choice for Harold Hill. Oh well, next revival.
00:56 very confused by how she says “roses” at 1:05, sounds like she added an extra syllable? it’s not like that on the cast album so maybe I’m just hearing things lol anyone else hear what I’m hearing here?
She’s only singing two syllables. It’s just the ‘is’ sound that she is slightly distorting from ‘es’ that you are hearing
Love her, hate the wig.
Yea true
I he were kissing me ❤
She’s no Barbara Cook
There was and only will ever be one Barbara Cook.
She made it her own - 2022-2023 style! A badass! 😘
Tony Paradise: And she’s no Shirley Jones either! (And along with Cookie and Luker, Jones was superb.)
Nobody is. One of a kind. People suck, wouldn’t let her film.
No, she’s not Barbara Cook because she’s not boring, but Cook was a far better singer for this role. Rebecca Luker was magnificent as was Shirley Jones in the film.
Just way too much vibrato, to the point of being annoying and distracting from a sweet, beautiful song. Shirley Jones’ tops this, but Beatles’ version may just be the best of all.
The fell in love yalls ! Beautiful couple 😍
Both Foster and Jackman are wonderful; two of the finest Theatre performers we have. But as a Theatre professional myself I must say that this is an illegal video. Your camera should never have been allowed in the theatre, and the performers and the show a great disservice by distributing this video.
Im aware that is illegal, and I posted these videos just after the show ended. Mostly for the people who couldn’t see the show. I would have loved to see a show that was playing in 2004, I was 1 year old at the time ahaha, and tbh I’m glad someone recorded it illegally and shared it on RUclips, that’s the only thing that made me see that show and I’m grateful for it, illegal or not. I wanna do the same thing for people who weren’t aware of this show and found out about it only after it ended, or for those who couldn’t go. 🫶
@@thecutehuey I appreciate your comment, Huey. You bring up the only validation for illegally recording live shows; being able to allow people to see incredible performances AFTER the show has closed. Unfortunately it's almost impossible to ensure that that's what is happening. As a working professional actor I have ample reason to fear that too much distribution of videos or films like these while a show is still running cut into the bottom line of all the performers and technicians and creators of the show.
Too many people see a video of the show and think there's no longer a reason to go to the live show; and it closes; and I can't pay my rent.
I said that the show was over when I posted it, don’t you think I know what you said, I’m supporting hugh, I would never post videos when the show was still going. And I already wrote that in the other comments up there, try to read better next time
@@thecutehuey Sorry, Brother. I've looked everywhere and the first time you mention the show closing is in your reply to my comment. The first and only time. I'll happily read everything you write, but you've got to write it first.
I was expecting so much more from Sutton on this song. It was disappointing to hear her vocals very narrow, pop-ish, and closed sounding. I understand she’s more of a belter than a soprano but everything from her consonants to her using of phrasing did not help her cause. She’s a phenomenal actress and I’ve loved her for years, but this is by far not her best.
She had just had COVID. Cut her some slack.
Wow. She doesn't even TRY to hit the high note.
Google reports that there are approximately 3,904,727,342 females on Earth at present. Of those who can sing, most could do a better job with this lovely song than Ms. Foster does here. Strident, wobbly, flat--how did she get the gig?
Probably because she’s been nominated for every single broadway show she was part of. Maybe is your problem lol, fix your ears
She’s a wonderful performer, but totally wrong vocally for this part. Have you heard what she did to My White Knight because she couldn’t sing it as written? Both Meredith Willson and Barbara Cook must be spinning in their graves.
They actually didn’t mean to copy what they did in the past, is just different. If u saw the show, also Ya got trouble is slower compared to the original song. Why it has to be traditional lol?
@@thecutehuey Do you disagree with my assessment of her singing HERE?
I just don’t think is flat, and to be honest I just don’t know a lot about the old versions so I cannot compare her version with the original one🤷♀️
I like her personality, but she’s got no emotion in her face. Kind of bland. That goes for other musicals. Weird.
Are you kidding?????!!!!!😳
🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 so MISCAST!!!!
congratulations for breaking the law and illegally videoing this performance and at the same time destroying the live experience of theatre for all those who were seated above, behind, and near you. just watch the movie.
Nahh no one saw me😂😂 lol and now the show is over. I’m not destroying people experiences since they can’t go watch it live.
@@thecutehuey your arrogance is just privilege that you don't deserve and I have complained in theatres before and gotten people thrown out for this criminal behavior (obviously you don't listen to the pre-show announcements and aren't really interested in the LIVE experience)
first of all there’s no way that a video makes you feel what you feel in the theater. Second I didn’t destroy Andy of the other people experiences. Third, I’m posting these videos here so that people who couldn’t go or those who didn’t know this show was playing, have the possibility to see it. I think there’s no loss, for the actors and the production itself, the show is over. I recorded these in April, and didn’t post because I knew it was still playing.
She sings "there was love all around "' as if she were singing about Covid. No emotion and no chemistry.
bruh I cannot argue about what emotion you got listening to this because is subjective. But chemistry man, cannot say that they don’t have chemistry
Hugh & Sutton’s chemistry was electric in that theatre ⚡️🔥
Nothing will ever top Shirley Jone's story about singing this in the film version while pregnant. She wasn't showing much, and kept her pregnancy quiet but when she hit the high notes,her baby, kicked Robert Preston on the bridge scene. He looked shocked and asked her after what happened. She explained that it was Patrick Cassidy who later starred in the Hill role on a tour . Show biz😊