I believe that DogDay used to be the mysterious scientist Dr White, who after being caught by Sawer while trying to save the children turned him into DogDay and then had him ripped in half after rejecting the Prototype's control by helping Poppy and was either left to rot in the Playhouse or left as food for the other bigger bodies
I agree. Dogday's true identity as Dr. White does make more sense. When you play the green vhs tape in Chapter 3, you can hear Dr. White's voice as he converses with Ms. Brooks. Dogday and Dr. White sound very much alike. Dogday's voice is a little deeper, but that could be due to old age. So I very much agree with this theory.
@@this_is_my_username200 If you haven't already noticed that when DogDay talks his voice isn't a fully organic voice like Ms Delight's it sounds like it's coming from a mechanical voice box (like robots use) this is noticeable until the mini Critters climb inside him then you can hear him gargling on his own blood as his vocal chords and other remaining organic parts get eaten before being turned into a zombie puppeted by the mini critters who are controlled by the Prototype (notice the white eyes that are very similar to CatNap's) which become visible as the corrupt DogDay who previously didn't have them as he was either free from the Prototype's control or still fighting it
I think that dogday was a child wanting to be a part of the bigger bodies initiative and when he did he met catnap and very much after that the hour of joy started and catnap and the prototype killed the smiling critters apart from dogday becouse I think that catnap was jealous that he wasn’t the leader so he tormented him
I believe that Dog day used to be the mysterious Dr white, who after being caught by Sawer while trying to save the children turned him into Dog day and then had for real life that's is so awesome.
Everyone is theorizing on Dogday being Dr. Sawyer or Dr. White, but what about Samuel Lee? Dogday could be that orphan since Samuel Lee is the only named orphan other than Theodore Grambell who we know got turned into Catnap, and other than Catnap, Dogday is the last of the smiling critters. I believe Samuel Lee is Dogday.
Sawyer makes comments about how pleased he is with Catnap’s behaviour and the difficulty of the procedure, considering Experiment 1188 was in 1991 and the Pierre video you’re using as a reference was in 1994 (Theo’s third year as a Bigger Body) the timeline doesn’t match up if we assume that all of the smiling critters were made in consecutive order
Dogday was clearly made first as he’s the main character, not to mention smaller than Catnap. While Catnap was made first by MobGames as he was based off of the purple guy, in universe it makes sense that Dogday would’ve been the one who was made first as Dogs can smile very wide, almost like the smiling critters do. Thus the idea for the smiling critters would’ve spawned from one of the designer’s dogs. Plus most of the smiling critters are domestic animals.
I only saw people comment about it in some others videos. I think, the things that go against the theory are that vhs of Leith Pierre talking to Catnap on his fourth year as Bigger Body, kind of implies that the doctor was out recently and mentions about Dogday and Pickpiggy like they have been there for a long time, meaning he was still working when Dogday was made, and the one about Bron says that the other experiments can notice when one of them is an adult, never looked like Dogday was outcasted from others in the past.
You know, I think the most tragic thing about DogDay is that he’s the most marketable character in the entire game to both boys and girls but they can’t sell him as a toy like they did with monster Catnap because he’s been sliced in half and is all gory looking. If they wanted to sell him as a toy, they’d have to fix him up. They can’t bring him back in a flashback either because DogDay never knew the player like the other toys did since he’s introduced like he’s never met the player. Every time I hear anything about Poppy Playtime, a lot of kids and adults mostly point to monster DogDay being their favorite character and wanting a toy of him. Heck, I’d buy him the second he comes on the market.
Why would they sell a bigger body? This isn't the DogDay toy but his Bigger body version that was meant to be used as a worker in the playcare. His toy counterpart is 100% good to be sold.
@@ITzaMii_ VHS tapes are never animated and when they are, they’re live action. Plus now that the player is no longer in PlayCare, it makes no sense for DogDay to suddenly show up in a video that isn’t featured in PlayCare. It’s a massive loss at the end of the day. Maybe Etsy would come up with something cool. I’ve seen the things fans have made.
I think that Dogday is more than likely a child we haven’t heard of yet, or an employee who volunteered, but none of the others who were turned knew who he was. Makes sense as to why he was accepted by the others. And I also think that this isn’t the first time Dogday has been put through this body hijack thing. So he might still be alive.
It’s clear Dogday is aware of the body hijack thing because it happened to both Bubba and Kicken first and whatever other toy was placed down there. Also if Dogday was a child, why does he sound so old like he’s in his 40s? He doesn’t hit me as someone who’s in his twenties or even teens. He’s the oldest sounding character we’ve met thus far.
@@CamdenKaneakaNeptunesdaughter They’re not kids anymore dude! They’re for the most part adults! They just grew up differently! Catnap was a kid which is why he grew so large. The main reason they use children for the bigger bodies is so when they become adults, they’ll grow much larger. Dogday seems to be the size of an adult so he most likely was already an adult when he was turned into a mascot.
The voice actor isn't exactly a solid proof. The radio voice has the same actor as well, and Miss Delight, the Counselor and the cutouts of Hoppy Hopscotch, CraftyCorn and Bobby Bearhug are all voiced by Avalon Delaney.
I don't think Sawyer is Dogday. Think about it the man is a sociopath. Taking sick pleaser in seeing pain inflicted on others. They are characterized by their inability to feel remorse for their actions, according to the info I found on Google. So this couldn't be Sawyer unless they managed to wipe his mind. Making him start on a blank slate mentally.
First of all, what you are thinking of is called a psychopath. Sociopaths are in fact capable of feeling remorse for their actions but are still blind to said actions. Harley was just an overly ambitious man who cared about the wrong things and the wrong people. If anything, Leith Pierre is a clear cut psychopath. Secondly, you shouldn’t be basing your info about psychology on what you find on the internet. Thats no different than people who self diagnose themselves on what info they find on TikTok.
When Thomas was turned into Bron he lost his memory, he couldn’t recall who he was, MattPat theorised that if adults are turned into toys they lose their memories, also the toys can sense whether you a tortured child or an adult thats why they attacked Bron int the VHS tape
@@TadashiStar-dd5ed They tortured Dogday though. It’s most likely these “heretics” were actually just adults they went after. Children get a quick death while adults get a slowly, painful death.
Wasnt there a vhs tape where theo and pierre interview with him mentioning is usually sawyer who do it and at that time mention the other bigger body smiling vritters are still around base on catnap not socializing with the other critters. Doesnt this mean aroujd the time, dog day is made while sawyer is still alive
@@canineatnight6026 You actually have a point there... I suppose most of us wanted in some way for Dogday to deserve what happened to him because during his death scene we weren't appalled or horrified, we were sad. Completely different than Mommy Long Legs which was epic. The only issue is, we as the audience felt she deserved it and it felt so cathartic, we completely overlooked our own brutality. Kind of crazy many of us got worked up over what is essentially someone forced to be a furry.
I don’t think dogday is Harley Sawyer bc in project playtime when you hear Sawyer he sounds like he has an accent same thing with poppy and Stella Stella has an accent
My theory is that dogday was a child but since the hiur of joy was like, 20 years ago and he was basically chained up after the hour of joy, than the child in dogday must have grown up, explaining his adult voice
My headcanon is that the DogDay we see isn’t the original one that was made; perhaps the original one died trying to escape the factory or started to act up around the kids? And so, obviously, the company needed a replacement, but had no good enough orphans ready. So, in a frantic hurry, Leith forced Harley into being the test subject for the new DogDay. Catnap (Theodore) then found out who DogDay really was, and cut his legs off and left him to suffer alone as revenge for what he did to the orphans. It’s just my headcanon, but it makes at least some sense to me
Dogday sounds too old to have been a child experiment - and I'm not talking about his voice, I'm meaning the way he actually constructs sentences; he's far more eloquent than any of the other experiments that are confirmed to have originally been children. At the very least he was a teenager - but adult employee who saw too much or disagreed with the goings-on in the factory is my best bet.
My personnal opionionis that he's Samuel Lee. If u dont know who Sam is let me explain. In one of the vhs tapes in Chapter 3 we learn that a boy named Samuel Lee was chosen by Dr. White for experiments. On his 'leaving' one of the take carers (not Ms. Harper), told the orphans to say bye to him for his lasr day. I dunno if he really is him but it's 'Just a theory'.
It’s very likely that DogDay is still alive, I mean why would MOB use a beloved character and give no information about him whatsoever then kill him off right away. DogDay was definitely an important character to the lore and they didn’t give any information on who he actually was before he was experimented on, he could appear again in Ch.4.
I believe that dog day used to be a kid and a friend of Theo think about it, why would the doc be friends with a kid that's also going to be an experiment like Theo Theo is catnap for people who don't know, and dog day is a friend of cat nap dog day said "we" tried to fight it I think that since cat nap is under control of the prototype I think before he got controlled, tried to fight "it" with dog day, I mean that's what friends do? dog day got tortured because he tried fighting the prototype
While he would be 21 by the time the game takes place, don’t think it’d be the former. Catnap/Theo was seven when he was turned, and four years later, he’d still only be 11 in the interview tape and he had a deep as hell voice. It was mentioned that his voice box had issues, though.
Even though the conscious for the Critters came from kids, their minds do grow, the scientists might of picked up on this this resulting in further experiments, I also think CatNap & DogDay knew each other when they were human
I think chapter 4 will take place in a hidden chamber where the orphans were prepared for experiements. I think they only used central nerves,brain and some key parts of the body to make toys rather than the whole body.
I have my opinions on this theory, but even putting that aside, this theory is flawed in my opinion because: A: DogDay and Sawyer sharing the same voice actor is interesting, but it's also a stretch. I mean, by that logic the Councilor is Bobby BearHug, Hoppy Hopscotch, CraftyCorn and Miss Delight all at the same time. B: this theory is completely debunked by the tape shown in this video. In it, Leith Pierre speaks about the Doctor's disappearance as if it's recent. However, in that same tape, he mentioned that it was being recorded during Theo's 4th year in CatNap's body and that CatNap and all the other Smiling Critters - including DogDay who is directly mentioned by name - were all added into Playcare at the same time. Therefore, if the bigger body DogDay was created and added into Playcare 4 years before Dr Sawyer went missing, it is impossible for Swayer to be DogDay. Finally, this is more of a personal opinion, but I hate this theory because if it is true, it completely ruins the DogDay encounter. The scene is meant to be horrific and to show the player how evil CatNap is by torturing him. However, if DogDay is Dr Sawyer - the man behind the Bigger Bodies Initiative who directly caused all the suffering of the children in Playcare and the BBI victims, then this scene completely changes. Now it's cathartic to see him suffer the same fate as his victims - like Willaim Afron getting himself spring-locked - and his suffering is kind of deserved. One of the many reasons DogDay is my favourite character in the game is because despite how much agony he's put through, he still wants the player, someone he just met, to escape. He even begs the player NOT to save him. Even if he's lost all the positivity and wholesomeness of his cartoon counterpart, he's still kept his selfless. Nothing against you or anyone who believes this theory, I just both don't believe it and don't like it.
The reason why I love dogday and I am a fanboy😂 1.he is a leader 2.he is positive sweet and nice 3.his colours match my personality orange yellow match me 4.he is important to the story with catnap a d that's it yeah he is still sweet and nice and I don't care.
Im pretty sure the reason dog days legs were cut off and he was left in the cell was because he tried to tell everyone they have to escape and catnap and the prototype didnt like that so they cut off his legs and kept him alive as a form of torture and in his cardboard cut out when hes screaming he can hear his legs being cut off and falling to the ground and guess what that happens right after he tells us to leave and how we cant stay here and the reason he screams so long is because he never died he was tortured meaning their was nothing making him to stop screaming also their is no way that Harley is dog day because in the same tape we hear that catnap wasn’t really getting along with the children at first but the ALL of the other critters were and it is also stated in the same tape that it has been 4 years since catnap became well catnap which means that the rest of the critters including dog day have been there for 4 years as well and since Harley would usually have the sessions with catnap there’s no way hes dog day if dog day already existed while Harley was alive
5:29 This makes a really good point. I knew there had to be something really wrong with the fact that Dr. Sawyer was “out.” I think that Laith, having the horrible business he did, would say that to cover up something more serious. I would also believe that it was a punishment for him after what he did to the orphans. With a punishment like that, he would see the errors of his ways but he would also know that it was too late to make things right. This might seem a little far fetched, but I would like to believe that’s why DogDay was so concerned for the player and warning them to leave immediately. Maybe Sawyer recognized the player as an old employee, and he grew concerned they would befall the same fate. Whether this is true or not, this is an interesting theory!
Why does dogday know poppys out if we got her out of the box, she was technically with us until she was with kissy missy, hes obviously confident in poppy but when did he see poppy was out?, poppy told us not to go to where dogday was. Yet she knows the position hes in...how?.. shes knows its bad in there....how? Like this is so confusing. She knew enough to warn us but not help dogday. She knew enough not to go in there herself and yet understood how dangerous it was? LIKE MAAM PICK UR STORY cuz if u were out getting kissy missy after following us for forever why did dogday know you were out of your box?
Well I believe as kids catnap and Dogday were the best of friends Dogday (as a kid) showed catnap (as a kid) around his new home the playcare, later catnap found out about dogdays bigger body’s experiment and wanted to escape with the prototype after catnaps incident and was turned into catnap, and he and Dogday they were reunited and helping the kids in playcare, but Catnap started acting strange and Dogday noticed this, Catnap tried to make the rest of his critter friends follow prototype but Dogday stopped them and turned his head away from catnap and left, Catnap was filled with sadness and anger at the loss of a friend and they he didn’t follow prototype, so after the hour of joy, catnap went searching for Dogday and eventually cornered him in the playhouse and that’s he and prototype started severing his legs and started to tie him up in his jail cell, the catnap had the rest of the critters in jail and took some away and killed some right in front of Dogdays face, knowing and telling him he failed as a leader. (That’s my theory on what happened to Dogday)
I know this is a bit old but it can't be Harley Sawyer since we know he was still working on the catnap experiment until he was "out" which I believe he did get put into a toy, but not catnap. That or he just stayed alive during the hour of joy
I don’t know who but I think dog day is a doctor from the factory because in chapter one we return to save the staff and in dog days monologue he says that we’ve come to them and we never mentioned saving any toys so he must be staff
Playtime Mysteries I have a really good theory about who sent the letter to the Player ?? I took 5 days to work on it and Its really good Can I sell it to you??
I actually also have a theory, when dogday gets consume by the critters, white pupils appear, like catnaps, catnap also has stitches, could catnap been good first then forced to do this by the prototype, the same thing probably happend to him, the critters are controlling catnaps body, so the main villan of chapter 3 was the mini critters, catnap was probably good.
makes sense. the start of the games story-line, was us returning to the factory to save our coworkers (mommy longlegs confirmed we worked at the factory) and dog-day saying 'you've come to save us, nothing left to save', THEN we have poppy showing us the tape that shows what happened at the hour of joy...everyone is gone. nothing is left to save. Also, at no point was it even hinted that we returned to the factory to save the children. If anything from the book that was released. we honestly don't care about them, only the people we worked with. feel guilty? yes, enough to help the children by putting them out of their misery? maybe... I think you are right. Dog-day is someone who worked at the factory, and poppy is probably considered a traitor due to her helping them. its basically factory staff vs the factory victims. We've been shown they (the toys) don't take like those who volunteered to be turned (or it could be the children don't like adults-which is completely understandable).
3:29 in picky piggy’s cut out, most of her lines are about eating things that are made of what the other are made out of like one says “ seared elephant” and another “ flayed unicorn”
Sawyer can't be dog day, we know how the other bigger bodies responded to when Thomas was made into bron he was rejected and hated by the others because he was made from one of the staff members so dog day being Harley Sawyer would make it so he would be killed before we got to see him. I am sure that they would recognize that dog day is their "creator" and would most definitely tear him apart limb by limb.
It's not standing up at all: -Dogday is leader with strong influence Prototype loves him and wanted to corrupt him Except it didn't work even when catnap tried by torturing -Dogday is split in two because catnap tortured her and they gave the other part to the little fluffy
Im SO GLAD someone FINALLY made a theory about this, Dr Sawyer is my FAVOURITE character in Poppy Playtime and he never gets any recognition NO ONE knows him or the lore which is so sad 😭
The bigger body experiment (BBE) was not exclusive to children. Dog Day (DD) shows advanced cognitive awareness and lacks the explosive emotional lashing out seen in toys that I believe are children like Huggy, CatNap, Kissy, Bobby Bear, Bunzo Bunny, PJ Pugapiller, the stuffed feral toys, and the children stuck in the cardboard cutouts to voice the characters. To me, he's an adult. Similar to Poppy, Mommy Long Legs, and Mrs. Delight. He is calculating, and though mutilated, he makes an avid point to butter the player up by addressing them as "Angel" while calling CatNap a "thing, while promptly directing him to his cause. I feel he went out of his way to tell the player not to look for the other smiling critters in an attempt to hide the truth. By saying, "he is the last of the critters," when we know CatNap is walking around living and breathing and one is confirmed m.i.a, that raises alarm bells. You feel sorry for him due to his current state. Who's to say he wasn't a...bad dog (I couldn't help myself, I'm sorry). Only when you read the manual do you discover the treatment of Bobby Bearhug (a child); who's to say we won't see the others alive and barely clinging to life? He and Poppy have the same deceptive methods; both got caught, one was set free, and one was torn in half. I believe the BBE took many victims, including babies, infants, children, teens, and adults. I also don't believe that the Prototype was Elliot. I believe it was an older teen used for the experiment, who is bitter and is trying to make the wrongs right, like an older brother protecting his siblings. The adults underestimated the kid, realized their mistake, and took younger, more malleable children instead to avoid a Proto 2. When Braun (the scientist) was turned, they took steps to keep him safe. When children are turned, all the gloves are off; who cares! I don't believe he (Proto) intended to have the children eat the scientists. I believe this was an undocumented side effect, that the toys were repressing when they were under the eyes of their "caretakers," who would punish them if they were defective. But after the hour of joy, I believe the veil was lifted, so to speak, and they no longer needed to repress this instinct/impulse. As DD mentioned, "they eat to fill the emptiness." How would he know that? Based on how the critters reacted to him, he can't speak to them? They loathe him. He must have the same symptoms as the others. That manual also mentioned that the critters didn't get along. If adults are mixed into the smiling critter's bunch, some who might have experimented on them, there will be discontent.
I think Dogday lied to us, he said he's the last of the smiling critters, but when we meet Dogday, Catnap was still alive and Catnap is one of the smiling critters too. So, what do you think
Unless, if what he meant to say was being the last one to be made, like he is the youngest of the siblings ( if smiling critters were family ).😅 Could be another explanation.
If he was Sawyer, then who is in the chapter 1 tape at the end of chapter 1? When we hear the Catnap tape, The Hour of Joy isn't heard in the background like the chapter 1 tape. The person in the chapter 1 tape I believe is confirmed to be Harley, so he cant be Dogday. Correct me if I'm wrong.
I feel like the smiling critters are basically furrys, think about it, theres a zip on dogday that could mean a human is inside, although if my theory is true then this must be crazy 🤣
@@AndreiSimonOlete That was NEVER confirmed by the developers. Where did you get that information? Are you a kid or something? How old are you? The fact that Dogday was likely to be an employee when he was made into a bigger body makes more sense. Dogday is smarter than Mommy Long Legs, whose Mommy Long Legs is already acting like an adult, which makes Dogday an adult. You're just acting like you're smarter than me.
You don’t have to add the captions bro, 90% of the names are incorrect; It says “Tauktae” instead of “Dogday” like literally just type out the captions yourself or don’t use captions
I believe that DogDay used to be the mysterious scientist Dr White, who after being caught by Sawer while trying to save the children turned him into DogDay and then had him ripped in half after rejecting the Prototype's control by helping Poppy and was either left to rot in the Playhouse or left as food for the other bigger bodies
I agree. Dogday's true identity as Dr. White does make more sense. When you play the green vhs tape in Chapter 3, you can hear Dr. White's voice as he converses with Ms. Brooks. Dogday and Dr. White sound very much alike. Dogday's voice is a little deeper, but that could be due to old age. So I very much agree with this theory.
@@this_is_my_username200 If you haven't already noticed that when DogDay talks his voice isn't a fully organic voice like Ms Delight's it sounds like it's coming from a mechanical voice box (like robots use) this is noticeable until the mini Critters climb inside him then you can hear him gargling on his own blood as his vocal chords and other remaining organic parts get eaten before being turned into a zombie puppeted by the mini critters who are controlled by the Prototype (notice the white eyes that are very similar to CatNap's) which become visible as the corrupt DogDay who previously didn't have them as he was either free from the Prototype's control or still fighting it
I think that dogday was a child wanting to be a part of the bigger bodies initiative and when he did he met catnap and very much after that the hour of joy started and catnap and the prototype killed the smiling critters apart from dogday becouse I think that catnap was jealous that he wasn’t the leader so he tormented him
Hes not Dr White hes Dr Sawyer 😔
I believe that Dog day used to be the mysterious Dr white, who after being caught by Sawer while trying to save the children turned him into Dog day and then had for real life that's is so awesome.
Everyone is theorizing on Dogday being Dr. Sawyer or Dr. White, but what about Samuel Lee? Dogday could be that orphan since Samuel Lee is the only named orphan other than Theodore Grambell who we know got turned into Catnap, and other than Catnap, Dogday is the last of the smiling critters. I believe Samuel Lee is Dogday.
😮
Sawyer makes comments about how pleased he is with Catnap’s behaviour and the difficulty of the procedure, considering Experiment 1188 was in 1991 and the Pierre video you’re using as a reference was in 1994 (Theo’s third year as a Bigger Body) the timeline doesn’t match up if we assume that all of the smiling critters were made in consecutive order
4 years, not 3 years
Dogday was clearly made first as he’s the main character, not to mention smaller than Catnap. While Catnap was made first by MobGames as he was based off of the purple guy, in universe it makes sense that Dogday would’ve been the one who was made first as Dogs can smile very wide, almost like the smiling critters do. Thus the idea for the smiling critters would’ve spawned from one of the designer’s dogs. Plus most of the smiling critters are domestic animals.
I only saw people comment about it in some others videos. I think, the things that go against the theory are that vhs of Leith Pierre talking to Catnap on his fourth year as Bigger Body, kind of implies that the doctor was out recently and mentions about Dogday and Pickpiggy like they have been there for a long time, meaning he was still working when Dogday was made, and the one about Bron says that the other experiments can notice when one of them is an adult, never looked like Dogday was outcasted from others in the past.
DUDE, I LOVE YOU. YOU'RE SMART
You know, I think the most tragic thing about DogDay is that he’s the most marketable character in the entire game to both boys and girls but they can’t sell him as a toy like they did with monster Catnap because he’s been sliced in half and is all gory looking. If they wanted to sell him as a toy, they’d have to fix him up. They can’t bring him back in a flashback either because DogDay never knew the player like the other toys did since he’s introduced like he’s never met the player. Every time I hear anything about Poppy Playtime, a lot of kids and adults mostly point to monster DogDay being their favorite character and wanting a toy of him. Heck, I’d buy him the second he comes on the market.
Why would they sell a bigger body? This isn't the DogDay toy but his Bigger body version that was meant to be used as a worker in the playcare. His toy counterpart is 100% good to be sold.
@@Redmirax So I'm guessing you somehow aren't aware of the merch for this game by MobGames or completely misunderstood what I had said.
Can't they just have a VHS Tape showing fixed DogDay in a later chapter?
@@ITzaMii_ VHS tapes are never animated and when they are, they’re live action. Plus now that the player is no longer in PlayCare, it makes no sense for DogDay to suddenly show up in a video that isn’t featured in PlayCare. It’s a massive loss at the end of the day. Maybe Etsy would come up with something cool. I’ve seen the things fans have made.
I think that Dogday is more than likely a child we haven’t heard of yet, or an employee who volunteered, but none of the others who were turned knew who he was.
Makes sense as to why he was accepted by the others.
And I also think that this isn’t the first time Dogday has been put through this body hijack thing. So he might still be alive.
It’s clear Dogday is aware of the body hijack thing because it happened to both Bubba and Kicken first and whatever other toy was placed down there.
Also if Dogday was a child, why does he sound so old like he’s in his 40s? He doesn’t hit me as someone who’s in his twenties or even teens. He’s the oldest sounding character we’ve met thus far.
@@MATAX5its a voice box
@@BaconsBestInRoblox Why would they want him to sound like he's forty then? Why would it sound so coherent after the voice box was already messed up?
@@MATAX5 so they have a harder time being their actual kid selves.
@@CamdenKaneakaNeptunesdaughter They’re not kids anymore dude! They’re for the most part adults! They just grew up differently! Catnap was a kid which is why he grew so large. The main reason they use children for the bigger bodies is so when they become adults, they’ll grow much larger. Dogday seems to be the size of an adult so he most likely was already an adult when he was turned into a mascot.
The voice actor isn't exactly a solid proof. The radio voice has the same actor as well, and
Miss Delight, the Counselor and the cutouts of Hoppy Hopscotch, CraftyCorn and Bobby Bearhug are all voiced by Avalon Delaney.
I don't think Sawyer is Dogday. Think about it the man is a sociopath. Taking sick pleaser in seeing pain inflicted on others. They are characterized by their inability to feel remorse for their actions, according to the info I found on Google. So this couldn't be Sawyer unless they managed to wipe his mind. Making him start on a blank slate mentally.
First of all, what you are thinking of is called a psychopath. Sociopaths are in fact capable of feeling remorse for their actions but are still blind to said actions. Harley was just an overly ambitious man who cared about the wrong things and the wrong people. If anything, Leith Pierre is a clear cut psychopath.
Secondly, you shouldn’t be basing your info about psychology on what you find on the internet. Thats no different than people who self diagnose themselves on what info they find on TikTok.
When Thomas was turned into Bron he lost his memory, he couldn’t recall who he was, MattPat theorised that if adults are turned into toys they lose their memories, also the toys can sense whether you a tortured child or an adult thats why they attacked Bron int the VHS tape
@@TadashiStar-dd5ed They tortured Dogday though. It’s most likely these “heretics” were actually just adults they went after. Children get a quick death while adults get a slowly, painful death.
Wasnt there a vhs tape where theo and pierre interview with him mentioning is usually sawyer who do it and at that time mention the other bigger body smiling vritters are still around base on catnap not socializing with the other critters. Doesnt this mean aroujd the time, dog day is made while sawyer is still alive
@@canineatnight6026 You actually have a point there... I suppose most of us wanted in some way for Dogday to deserve what happened to him because during his death scene we weren't appalled or horrified, we were sad. Completely different than Mommy Long Legs which was epic. The only issue is, we as the audience felt she deserved it and it felt so cathartic, we completely overlooked our own brutality. Kind of crazy many of us got worked up over what is essentially someone forced to be a furry.
0:20 hey! I’m tauktae! Fetch! Go! Go! As far as you can!
… why are you..just standing there?
I don’t think dogday is Harley Sawyer bc in project playtime when you hear Sawyer he sounds like he has an accent same thing with poppy and Stella Stella has an accent
My theory is that dogday was a child but since the hiur of joy was like, 20 years ago and he was basically chained up after the hour of joy, than the child in dogday must have grown up, explaining his adult voice
My headcanon is that the DogDay we see isn’t the original one that was made; perhaps the original one died trying to escape the factory or started to act up around the kids? And so, obviously, the company needed a replacement, but had no good enough orphans ready. So, in a frantic hurry, Leith forced Harley into being the test subject for the new DogDay. Catnap (Theodore) then found out who DogDay really was, and cut his legs off and left him to suffer alone as revenge for what he did to the orphans. It’s just my headcanon, but it makes at least some sense to me
Dogday sounds too old to have been a child experiment - and I'm not talking about his voice, I'm meaning the way he actually constructs sentences; he's far more eloquent than any of the other experiments that are confirmed to have originally been children. At the very least he was a teenager - but adult employee who saw too much or disagreed with the goings-on in the factory is my best bet.
That is a good point a worker that saw way to much
My personnal opionionis that he's Samuel Lee. If u dont know who Sam is let me explain. In one of the vhs tapes in Chapter 3 we learn that a boy named Samuel Lee was chosen by Dr. White for experiments. On his 'leaving' one of the take carers (not Ms. Harper), told the orphans to say bye to him for his lasr day. I dunno if he really is him but it's 'Just a theory'.
It’s very likely that DogDay is still alive, I mean why would MOB use a beloved character and give no information about him whatsoever then kill him off right away. DogDay was definitely an important character to the lore and they didn’t give any information on who he actually was before he was experimented on, he could appear again in Ch.4.
It wil be very dark if dogday ended up being a child
I doubt anyone except for the orphans are kids by this point. DogDay is most likely an adult just like Mommy LongLegs was.
Dude, the whole game is dark. Have you even played?
@@funnymoron He’s probably a little kid, leave him alone.
@@MATAX5mommy long legs was a child actually
Marie Payne
@@Sushi_Slushie Well we all grow up! We can’t stay children forever!
I believe that dog day used to be a kid and a friend of Theo think about it, why would the doc be friends with a kid that's also going to be an experiment like Theo
Theo is catnap for people who don't know, and dog day is a friend of cat nap dog day said "we" tried to fight it I think that since cat nap is under control of the prototype I think before he got controlled, tried to fight "it" with dog day, I mean that's what friends do? dog day got tortured because he tried fighting the prototype
I’m pretty sure DogDay is just a child who has aged into an adult which is why his voice is deep or his voice box thing is just meant to be like that.
While he would be 21 by the time the game takes place, don’t think it’d be the former. Catnap/Theo was seven when he was turned, and four years later, he’d still only be 11 in the interview tape and he had a deep as hell voice. It was mentioned that his voice box had issues, though.
Kinda makes sense, since catnap's voice is really deep
Even though the conscious for the Critters came from kids, their minds do grow, the scientists might of picked up on this this resulting in further experiments, I also think CatNap & DogDay knew each other when they were human
@@drockman92 oh yeah
I think chapter 4 will take place in a hidden chamber where the orphans were prepared for experiements. I think they only used central nerves,brain and some key parts of the body to make toys rather than the whole body.
I have my opinions on this theory, but even putting that aside, this theory is flawed in my opinion because:
A: DogDay and Sawyer sharing the same voice actor is interesting, but it's also a stretch. I mean, by that logic the Councilor is Bobby BearHug, Hoppy Hopscotch, CraftyCorn and Miss Delight all at the same time.
B: this theory is completely debunked by the tape shown in this video. In it, Leith Pierre speaks about the Doctor's disappearance as if it's recent. However, in that same tape, he mentioned that it was being recorded during Theo's 4th year in CatNap's body and that CatNap and all the other Smiling Critters - including DogDay who is directly mentioned by name - were all added into Playcare at the same time. Therefore, if the bigger body DogDay was created and added into Playcare 4 years before Dr Sawyer went missing, it is impossible for Swayer to be DogDay.
Finally, this is more of a personal opinion, but I hate this theory because if it is true, it completely ruins the DogDay encounter. The scene is meant to be horrific and to show the player how evil CatNap is by torturing him. However, if DogDay is Dr Sawyer - the man behind the Bigger Bodies Initiative who directly caused all the suffering of the children in Playcare and the BBI victims, then this scene completely changes. Now it's cathartic to see him suffer the same fate as his victims - like Willaim Afron getting himself spring-locked - and his suffering is kind of deserved.
One of the many reasons DogDay is my favourite character in the game is because despite how much agony he's put through, he still wants the player, someone he just met, to escape. He even begs the player NOT to save him. Even if he's lost all the positivity and wholesomeness of his cartoon counterpart, he's still kept his selfless.
Nothing against you or anyone who believes this theory, I just both don't believe it and don't like it.
Thank you for pointing out the the rest of the info in the tape, Some People don't pay attention
The reason why I love dogday and I am a fanboy😂
1.he is a leader
2.he is positive sweet and nice
3.his colours match my personality orange yellow match me
4.he is important to the story with catnap
a d that's it yeah he is still sweet and nice and I don't care.
0:19 the captions say tauktae 🤣
🤣🤣
is teh captions by AI?
you can tell by his voice hes not a kid when you listen to the show version of him he sounds like a kid but real life he sounds a like a grown man
I believe dogday is rich, and I think bobby is ollie thats just my theory...ya know ITS JUST A GAME THEROY! great vid btw
Im pretty sure the reason dog days legs were cut off and he was left in the cell was because he tried to tell everyone they have to escape and catnap and the prototype didnt like that so they cut off his legs and kept him alive as a form of torture and in his cardboard cut out when hes screaming he can hear his legs being cut off and falling to the ground and guess what that happens right after he tells us to leave and how we cant stay here and the reason he screams so long is because he never died he was tortured meaning their was nothing making him to stop screaming also their is no way that Harley is dog day because in the same tape we hear that catnap wasn’t really getting along with the children at first but the ALL of the other critters were and it is also stated in the same tape that it has been 4 years since catnap became well catnap which means that the rest of the critters including dog day have been there for 4 years as well and since Harley would usually have the sessions with catnap there’s no way hes dog day if dog day already existed while Harley was alive
5:29
This makes a really good point. I knew there had to be something really wrong with the fact that Dr. Sawyer was “out.” I think that Laith, having the horrible business he did, would say that to cover up something more serious. I would also believe that it was a punishment for him after what he did to the orphans. With a punishment like that, he would see the errors of his ways but he would also know that it was too late to make things right. This might seem a little far fetched, but I would like to believe that’s why DogDay was so concerned for the player and warning them to leave immediately. Maybe Sawyer recognized the player as an old employee, and he grew concerned they would befall the same fate. Whether this is true or not, this is an interesting theory!
"We rejected a toy named: Tauktae"
Why does dogday know poppys out if we got her out of the box, she was technically with us until she was with kissy missy, hes obviously confident in poppy but when did he see poppy was out?, poppy told us not to go to where dogday was. Yet she knows the position hes in...how?.. shes knows its bad in there....how? Like this is so confusing. She knew enough to warn us but not help dogday. She knew enough not to go in there herself and yet understood how dangerous it was? LIKE MAAM PICK UR STORY cuz if u were out getting kissy missy after following us for forever why did dogday know you were out of your box?
Maybe Catnap told him?
@@funnymoronWhy would Catnap tell him? Man this is going to be another life is strange situation where there’s a lot of plot holes.
@@funnymoron why tf would catnap tell him if they were already devoted to the prototype at that point
Dang this is a nice theroy
ong
Well I believe as kids catnap and Dogday were the best of friends Dogday (as a kid) showed catnap (as a kid) around his new home the playcare, later catnap found out about dogdays bigger body’s experiment and wanted to escape with the prototype after catnaps incident and was turned into catnap, and he and Dogday they were reunited and helping the kids in playcare, but Catnap started acting strange and Dogday noticed this, Catnap tried to make the rest of his critter friends follow prototype but Dogday stopped them and turned his head away from catnap and left, Catnap was filled with sadness and anger at the loss of a friend and they he didn’t follow prototype, so after the hour of joy, catnap went searching for Dogday and eventually cornered him in the playhouse and that’s he and prototype started severing his legs and started to tie him up in his jail cell, the catnap had the rest of the critters in jail and took some away and killed some right in front of Dogdays face, knowing and telling him he failed as a leader. (That’s my theory on what happened to Dogday)
Um... I don't know. But Catnap and Dogday were NEVER friends. The fact that Catnap doesn't get along with any of the smiling critters in Playcare.
0:06 *up in the air* 😭
I know this is a bit old but it can't be Harley Sawyer since we know he was still working on the catnap experiment until he was "out" which I believe he did get put into a toy, but not catnap. That or he just stayed alive during the hour of joy
I don’t know who but I think dog day is a doctor from the factory because in chapter one we return to save the staff and in dog days monologue he says that we’ve come to them and we never mentioned saving any toys so he must be staff
Playtime Mysteries I have a really good theory about who sent the letter to the Player ?? I took 5 days to work on it
and Its really good
Can I sell it to you??
Wait, theories can be sold?
@@Jadiem-py3hc i guess so
I actually also have a theory, when dogday gets consume by the critters, white pupils appear, like catnaps, catnap also has stitches, could catnap been good first then forced to do this by the prototype, the same thing probably happend to him, the critters are controlling catnaps body, so the main villan of chapter 3 was the mini critters, catnap was probably good.
Fr
makes sense. the start of the games story-line, was us returning to the factory to save our coworkers (mommy longlegs confirmed we worked at the factory) and dog-day saying 'you've come to save us, nothing left to save', THEN we have poppy showing us the tape that shows what happened at the hour of joy...everyone is gone. nothing is left to save.
Also, at no point was it even hinted that we returned to the factory to save the children. If anything from the book that was released. we honestly don't care about them, only the people we worked with. feel guilty? yes, enough to help the children by putting them out of their misery? maybe...
I think you are right. Dog-day is someone who worked at the factory, and poppy is probably considered a traitor due to her helping them. its basically factory staff vs the factory victims.
We've been shown they (the toys) don't take like those who volunteered to be turned (or it could be the children don't like adults-which is completely understandable).
3:29 in picky piggy’s cut out, most of her lines are about eating things that are made of what the other are made out of like one says “ seared elephant” and another “ flayed unicorn”
Ooh,she and catnap killed alot. I looked at all the critters. Bobby was a valtine exlcusive.
Sawyer can't be dog day, we know how the other bigger bodies responded to when Thomas was made into bron he was rejected and hated by the others because he was made from one of the staff members so dog day being Harley Sawyer would make it so he would be killed before we got to see him. I am sure that they would recognize that dog day is their "creator" and would most definitely tear him apart limb by limb.
I still think dogday is my favourite smiling critter 😊
Ahh yes love tauktae
It's not standing up at all:
-Dogday is leader with strong influence Prototype loves him and wanted to corrupt him
Except it didn't work even when catnap tried by torturing
-Dogday is split in two because catnap tortured her and they gave the other part to the little fluffy
On adults it doesn't work, we see it with the prototype and the toy in the cassette (I'm trying not to spoil too much)
I think dogday is Rick from the vhs tape in the caves
Honestly,make more sense
Im SO GLAD someone FINALLY made a theory about this, Dr Sawyer is my FAVOURITE character in Poppy Playtime and he never gets any recognition NO ONE knows him or the lore which is so sad 😭
The bigger body experiment (BBE) was not exclusive to children. Dog Day (DD) shows advanced cognitive awareness and lacks the explosive emotional lashing out seen in toys that I believe are children like Huggy, CatNap, Kissy, Bobby Bear, Bunzo Bunny, PJ Pugapiller, the stuffed feral toys, and the children stuck in the cardboard cutouts to voice the characters.
To me, he's an adult. Similar to Poppy, Mommy Long Legs, and Mrs. Delight. He is calculating, and though mutilated, he makes an avid point to butter the player up by addressing them as "Angel" while calling CatNap a "thing, while promptly directing him to his cause. I feel he went out of his way to tell the player not to look for the other smiling critters in an attempt to hide the truth. By saying, "he is the last of the critters," when we know CatNap is walking around living and breathing and one is confirmed m.i.a, that raises alarm bells. You feel sorry for him due to his current state. Who's to say he wasn't a...bad dog (I couldn't help myself, I'm sorry). Only when you read the manual do you discover the treatment of Bobby Bearhug (a child); who's to say we won't see the others alive and barely clinging to life? He and Poppy have the same deceptive methods; both got caught, one was set free, and one was torn in half.
I believe the BBE took many victims, including babies, infants, children, teens, and adults. I also don't believe that the Prototype was Elliot. I believe it was an older teen used for the experiment, who is bitter and is trying to make the wrongs right, like an older brother protecting his siblings. The adults underestimated the kid, realized their mistake, and took younger, more malleable children instead to avoid a Proto 2. When Braun (the scientist) was turned, they took steps to keep him safe. When children are turned, all the gloves are off; who cares!
I don't believe he (Proto) intended to have the children eat the scientists. I believe this was an undocumented side effect, that the toys were repressing when they were under the eyes of their "caretakers," who would punish them if they were defective. But after the hour of joy, I believe the veil was lifted, so to speak, and they no longer needed to repress this instinct/impulse. As DD mentioned, "they eat to fill the emptiness." How would he know that? Based on how the critters reacted to him, he can't speak to them? They loathe him. He must have the same symptoms as the others. That manual also mentioned that the critters didn't get along. If adults are mixed into the smiling critter's bunch, some who might have experimented on them, there will be discontent.
But, Mommy Long Legs was an orphan called Marie Payne.
Dogday was a scientist
frikadele🥩
Well, I don't think dogday would have rmb his past life despite keeping the same personality, if u get what I mean...😮
the caption kept saying tauktae instead of dogday
😂😂😂
When will mob game give us more thing poppy playtime
I think Dogday lied to us, he said he's the last of the smiling critters, but when we meet Dogday, Catnap was still alive and Catnap is one of the smiling critters too. So, what do you think
Um... I think he meant the smiling critters excluding Catnap since Catnap is just an outcast of the smiling critters.
@@alvintroyverdadero3390 Maybe you're right 👍
Unless, if what he meant to say was being the last one to be made, like he is the youngest of the siblings ( if smiling critters were family ).😅 Could be another explanation.
The smiling critter is a huge family. Especially in the cartoon universe. Catnap and Bobby killed so many of them
Tauktae 💀
I saw a video somewhere on RUclips where u can save dogday. There might be different endings in poppy play time.
Its not Tauktae its DogDay silly 🙃😜
This is intresting
"tauktae"
If he was Sawyer, then who is in the chapter 1 tape at the end of chapter 1? When we hear the Catnap tape, The Hour of Joy isn't heard in the background like the chapter 1 tape. The person in the chapter 1 tape I believe is confirmed to be Harley, so he cant be Dogday. Correct me if I'm wrong.
h e l l o t h e r e
6:47 SIMULAR TO BRAUN😂
“Takutay”
DogDay ❌
Tauktae ✅
I feel like the smiling critters are basically furrys, think about it, theres a zip on dogday that could mean a human is inside, although if my theory is true then this must be crazy 🤣
You missed bobby bear hug
Yeah I don't think he's a child either I think he might be one of the doctors
I think experiment1322 is dog day
voice: DogDay
text: Tauktae
NOOOO THEY HAD TO SAY IT!!! DOGDAY IS NOT HARLEY SAWYER!!! POPPY IS NOT STELLA GREYBER!!!
*or however Stella Greyber is spelled
0 :19 Tauktae
Prototype could be dogday like think about it catnap WAS tanken over by dogday
0:19 Tauktae💀
6:13 Artaficial Pasate from a fraud of a god, all due to the path that we trod.
It’s poppy playtime, not poppy’s playtime
Huh
44 minutes!
3:28 the fake vid 💀
Hi
Who is “ *Tauktae* “ 💀
His real name is Danny
You're just making up stories that are never confirmed by the devs.
@@alvintroyverdadero3390 just pay ATTENTION! That's his real name as a kid if your so hard to understand what shall I do😌😐😴
@@AndreiSimonOlete That was NEVER confirmed by the developers. Where did you get that information? Are you a kid or something? How old are you? The fact that Dogday was likely to be an employee when he was made into a bigger body makes more sense. Dogday is smarter than Mommy Long Legs, whose Mommy Long Legs is already acting like an adult, which makes Dogday an adult. You're just acting like you're smarter than me.
You don’t have to add the captions bro, 90% of the names are incorrect; It says “Tauktae” instead of “Dogday” like literally just type out the captions yourself or don’t use captions
Does this make dogday black? 5:16
He can be any color since the Doctor is white he is voiced by the same person as dogday
A day his voice is hot
Pls pin this comment
😊
Add a comment
Are a yes a no ar a rzler
You liar 😢