Burma: First Military Coup d'Etat - Cold War DOCUMENTARY
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024
- Our historical documentary series on the history of the Cold War continues with a video on Burma, as we discuss the history of the country after its independence and how the first military coup d'etat happened.
Taiwan Under the Kuomintang Dictatorship: • Taiwan Under the Kuomi...
What Happened to the German and Japanese POWs?: • What Happened to the G...
Operation Paperclip: • Operation Paperclip - ...
German Expulsions: • German Expulsions Afte...
Soviet Education System: • Soviet Education Syste...
How Khrushchev Fed the Soviet People: • How Khrushchev Fed the...
Novocherkassk Massacre 1962: • Novocherkassk Massacre...
Soviet Tourism: • Soviet Tourism: How di...
Soviet Passport System: New Serfdom or Reform?: • Soviet Passport System...
Kaliningrad: How Russia Got a Stronghold in Europe: • Kaliningrad: How Russi...
How the Soviets Won the Early Space Race: • How the Soviets Won th...
Soviet Television and Radio: • Soviet Television and ...
Top-5 Myths About the Soviet Union: • Top-5 Myths About the ...
Support us on Patreon: / thecoldwar
RUclips membership / @thecoldwartv
✔ Merch store ► teespring.com/...
✔ Patreon ► / thecoldwar
✔ Facebook ► / thecoldwartv
✔ Instagram ► / thecoldwartv
#ColdWar #Burma #Coup
You know, if you're going to encourage people to watch the first part if they missed it, it'd be nice if a link was provided in the description.
Same, I was looking for it in the description too!
ruclips.net/video/QbH20WpTOxc/видео.html Here it is friends!
You’re owed nothing in this life.
Nice to finally see a video on cold war era Burma, people mostly overlook this country.
It's a part 2.
You’re right, even you yourself did overlook it by saying “finally see a video” while it’s the 2nd episode on the series
Thanks for sharing this wonderful historical coverage about Burma 🇲🇲
When you have such a big time gap between 2 videos like this it would be nice if the first part was more visibly linked in the video.
The Cold War, can you please make a video on the history of Burma during the entirety of Ne Win's reign.
Myanmar is such an amazing country! We were there in November 2019, just months before the military took over again.
Not so amazing now...
Very interesting
David is so brilliant and zealous. Documents and Information about Burma are uneasy to access. 😊
Thanks
Please do a video on mao hundred flowers campaign and 1959 Lebanon crisis
Fair point of view & presentation David. Most people think post-colonial economy of Burma was golden shining in those times. I wonder, honestly, hope you gonna do a video about BSPP era of Burma ( 1962-1988 ), also based on reliable & fair data. Thank u.
Comrade, when will you have a discord im really interested in taking with you about the BSPP era in Burma
would love to join
@@theranredguardist1949
You downplayed the U Nu government's success and overexaggerated the success of Ne Win's caretaker government, perhaps due to the limited sources in the English language. The caretaker government's rule was not a joyous occasion in Myanmar's history and remained the catalyst for decades-long suffering.
This
True he said like people were happy under Ne won't government
Was it AFPFL regime any batter than Caretaker Government? I don't really think so.
they were though for a period
@@kaungpyaephyoe8182
Another great video! My week consists of waiting for new videos from the cold war, kings and generals and the intel report!
This video’s examination of the civilian governments of Burma during the early Cold War period provides more context and perspective on the policy choices of the more recent civilian government in Burma.
Lol, "civilian governments".
You should make a video on how Soviet government worked and was organized
The caretaker government has some similarities with S Korea’s Park Chung Hee 60s/70s government. Of course we know that as in 2023 one country is very much Asia’s backwater, the other is Asia’s powerhouse with people enjoying freedom and democracy.
Good analogy. One had a military that knew when to step aside, the other, well...
Korea is single ethnic Myanmar is multi ethnic. Ethnic Burmas may as well let minorities get independence or keep the junta
@@user-qwertyuiopasdfghj They sure should let them get independence.
Where did film footage associated with narrative of KMT arrival in Burma?
I really appricate your effort in making this video. But there are some mistakes in this video, like in one photo, you said Thakin Tin but it's actually Thakin Than Tun, the president of CPB. And I suppose you get a bit confused with Red Flag Communist led by Thakin Soe with CPB.
Hi, do you guys have a reading list?
Burmese Karen: I want to speak to your prime minister!
As a karen (ethnicity not the blonde woman)
I sure do
Knowledge is power that’s why the regime want to keep the population illiterate to hold their power. David could you also deep dive on the people call Chin in Burma? There are minority known as Thado or Kuki some residing in India and some remains in Burma due to the partisan boundary drawn by British in 2WW. Will be much appreciated ✌🏻👍🏻🇺🇸
nice
Hopefully, my people, the Dai will one day be able to prosper in Burma.
Myanmar has always been a fiction, different peoples with their own visions forcibly held together by the government of the central plains. As much as colonialism was a disaster in some cases like Burma, Palestine, Sudan and Western Sahara how decolonialize was allowed to happen was just as great of one.
Anyone knows what the movie that battle was in?
Burma was obviously a very troubled place after WWII.
Burma should have parted ways. Its a forced union.
Surely neighboring countries would pick each small new state off one by one?
Also, surely the small states would fight among each other over boundaries and resources? 🤔
@@James_BAlert Personally I'm thinking of a USSR form of breakup. Not too much border issues, until last year of course. Still, its better than what Burma has went through.
@@James_BAlert No? Still doesn't justify paternalist domination of one nation over others. There is a reason why countries don't fight each other all the time over borders, once they're settled, they're settled. Like Austria-Hungary, multinational countries don't work.
Yes exactly its history both before, during and after British rule prove that. Unfortunately the world readily accepted the fiction. I cannot see how Burma will ever see peace until it is disassembled.
The apology of autocracy was kinda low, to be frank, lots of burmese people suffered by the brutality of the military as it tends to do.
My country Myanmar is always under the cycles of Military coup :(
You used the wrong photo of Thakhin Tin. The photo you used was Thakhin Than Htun who was the leader of Burmese Communist Party at that time.
So, the military Tadmadaw has been played a lot of the government's decision, even when Ne Win, the dictator of Myanmar, ruled the country
Same goes during the democracy era (2011-2021) when Aung Saan Suu Kyi became the President of Myanmar
The military power had to be reduced greatly
Aung San Suu Kyi didn't become president because of 2008 constitution of Myanmar. Former military generals made that constitution and added 59(f) which prevents Aung San Suu Kyi from becoming president. They did it on purpose. The reason is Aung San Suu Kyi is wife of foreigner and mother of foreigners. Instead of becoming president, she became state counsellor which is kinda equal with prime minister role. There were three presidents during 2011-2021. From 2011-2015, U Thein Sein, former general was president. He became president through the election which is held in 2011. However, according of evidence, that election was fraud. In 2012, the govt made by-election, and Aung San Suu Kyi became member of parliament. In 2015 election, NLD party which is led by Aung San Suu Kyi won the election with landslide. However, due to 2008 constitution, Aung San Suu Kyi cannot become president so U Htin Kyaw became president during 2015-2018. In 2018, he resigned and U Win Myint became president of Myanmar. According to 2008 constitution, 25% of parliament is controlled by one man, commander-in-chief, Min Aung Hlaing as he appointed 25% of military representatives to parliament. To changed 2008 constitution, it needs approval of 76% of parliament members which means without agreement of commander-in-chief, it cannot be changed. Therefore, Aung San Suu Kyi wasn't president of Burma.
@@linnthithtoo6464 Oh, didn't know that part
But then is the 2021 coup also related with the 2008 constitution itself? Because it's a bit strange for them suddenly re-arrest Aung Saan Suu Kyi again
@@SiPakRubah Military said that 2021 coup is not coup it is like caretaker govt just like in 1958-1960. However it was coup. According to 2008 constitution, president can only removed by parliament. However, they removed president U Win Myint and elected their person. For military, they would do everything to ensure their wealthy and security not for people of Myanmar but for themselves. So it isn't strange for them to re-arrest Aung San Suu Kyi. During 2011-2015 they created religious crisis between Buddhists and Muslim in Meiktila. I was victim of that. They assassinated U Ko Ni who was advisor of Aung San Suu Kyi and U Ko Ni is expert in 2008 constitution and he also created "state counsellor" for Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. Thus, military seems him as a threat to them.
@@linnthithtoo6464 I pray that your Tadmadaw is pure from the devils in it, and wish your country became a better ones, and hope war is a thing in the past for you, amin
@@SiPakRubah Thank u. And also our govt NUG is also preparing to apologise Rohingya for what military did to them. They should not deserve it. And thank u for your support.
The Karen insurgency is the official holder of the Guiness Book of World Records title for the world's longest-running military conflict (65 years and counting)
Hope you do 1971 war India Pakistan and Great power involvement
Did you do one on Brazil?
Can't find it
👍👏
If you have lived in Yangon, as I have for almost 10 years, you will see that the significance of the dog problem is very serious.
Because of dogs everywhere there are very few cats. Because of that mice and rats are prolific. The people refuse to kill any of these.
Thus diseases that don't exist anymore in the rest of the world are still prolific. If you stay, you will face many young and healthy friends facing surprising deaths that could have been avoided.
Burma is so confusing to understand 😵💫
အရေးတော်ပုံအောင်ရမည်
Really shows that despite the trouble created by KNU and the Mons for no apparent reason, Myanmar still held on. Hope we can resolve the ethnic tensions which exist for no good reason. An independent Karen or Mon state will just be similar to small African states, poor and chaos.
finally someone said it 👏
Lol these ethnic people are way more suffering under the rule of Burmese. They didn’t have right and freedom to use their identity, culture and language. Everything aspects is dominance by Burmese.
Burma/ Myanmar need a federal state with respect for all ethnicity and religion. The military should be banned from politics.
Free Burma Myanmar ✊💯💯☯️ #PDF
Burma is next to my home. Very hardworking,honest and peaceful people. Chinese intervention for a colony to reach warm waters.
What!!!?
What is that third sentence supposed to mean? No superpower intervention can be good.
Disinformation much
Our people has been so accustom to practicing politics with the mean of force or violence from the beginning. That seem like the only way we know how to practice politics. Because of these tendency we have fallen into meaningless chaos since 1948 instead of making sure our policies can serve people. The delusional leaders lead their people to play strongmen politics with other groups further polarization the already chaotic situation left by the colonial powers. It is time to see that these people are using the same technique used by the colonial to divide the populace for their own selfish agenda. It is time for the people of Myanmar to be educated in history to realize what really went wrong to find the solution for current crisis. It is also sad to see that we are repeating the same pattern due to the fact that every leaders including ethnic groups tend to twist history to their own agenda to further create distance between communities and create mistrust.
1 Asean.
I think myanmar should be ruled by joined military civil government as i don't see any other way to remain stable also build most important infrastructure to increase economy sand reduce insurgency sort of china method
the instability is the military's doing and the refusal to let minority nations get their independence for the sake of keeping abstract colonial borders the same. There is no such thing as a joint "military-civil" government, the ones with the guns have the power, the civilian ones obey and cannot say no. Look at Sudan.
@@Game_Hero You may have become another Yugoslavia in South East Asia. The relationship between Rebel groups are unstable, even if the Tatmadaw were defeated what stops the rest of the ethnic rebel groups from turning their sights on one another. Stuff like that happens in Afghanistan and former Yugoslavia, I still think a federal gov is the best choice but ethnic groups need to solve their own issues before that is an option.
@@thitran1362 The Yugoslav wars are over. Croatia, Slovenia, Montenegro and North Macedonia are doing just fine now, some didn't even have need wars to be independant. The way to solve issues is independence, purely and simply, a federal government is just an excuse for the dominating nation to exploit others under some "union of equals" rhethoric even if one nation will inevitably have the lion's share and others, the shorter ends of the stick, one language, the lingua franca and not others. If you don't want to give back your independence, don't hold it back to others.
Spoken like someone without empathy who believes might makes right. Myanmar is an artificial state of former slavers and their victims much like Sudan which has just begun its own process of disintegration into more organic entities.
true indeed. we have to change the way we practice our politics in a mean of violence and force@@thitran1362
Misinformed a lot about Ne win's government,very disappointed.
Silly man, you said the have to watch the 1st video, but didn't say where or how.