BMW v Mercedes v Audi v Volvo: BEST premium SUV review
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июн 2024
- If you’re in the market for a high-end plug-in hybrid SUV, which should you go for - a Mercedes GLC, BMW X3, Audi Q5 or Volvo XC60? Well, Mat’s got his hands on each one, and he’s about to put them all head-to-head to find out which is the #1 plug-in hybrid SUV you can get your hands on!
So let’s see how they all compare. Starting with the Volvo, it’s one of the oldest cars here - but it can still keep up with these more modern plug-in hybrids! Since 2017 it’s only had a couple of minor updates made to the design and interior, but it still has a classy design, with chrome trim on the outside helping it to stand out. The interior is pretty minimalist, although controlling most features through the touchscreen infotainment system can be a bit annoying. It also has new digital dials, but they’re a bit bland.
The XC60 is powered by a 2-litre turbo petrol engine and an electric motor, the T8 is the most powerful car in this line-up, being able to produce 455hp. An entry-level XC60 will set you back £47,650.
Next up we have the Audi Q5. It may come with exceedingly obvious fake exhaust pipes, but it’s still one of the best-looking cars here. Just like the Volvo it comes with chrome trim on the outside, and all-in-all it looks pretty smart. The interior is well built as well, with soft-touch materials found throughout the cabin. Thankfully it comes with physical buttons for the climate control, and the digital dials are probably the best in this entire line-up.
The Audi Q5 is equipped with a 2-litre turbo petrol engine & an electric motor, and this 50 TFSI e edition can produce 299hp. The Audi Q5 range is the most affordable, too, with it coming in at a price of £46,785.
Next up it’s the BMW. Up front, it comes with a pretty huge grille (which will come as no surprise to our BMW fanboys & girls), but we think it makes it’s all a bit much. After all, it’s only a family-friendly SUV, so it could perhaps do with being toned down a bit. Thankfully the quality of the cabin more than makes up for this, with high-quality materials found throughout, and a pretty high-tech infotainment screen which can be controlled with a dial on the centre console.
The X3 is powered by a 2-litre turbo petrol and an electric motor, but it’s the least powerful hybrid here, with the xDrive 30e only able to produce 292hp. The BMW X3 range kicks off at £47,295.
Then finally we have the newest car in this line-up, the Mercedes GLC. Just like the Audi it has super prominent fake exhausts, but we still think it’s one of the best-looking cars here. It has a great side profile, and the elements of chrome trim and the running boards along the side enhance the look. It’s a positive story on the inside, too, with a large infotainment screen in the centre of the dash and a large digital dial display. You’ll find soft-touch materials throughout the cabin as well.
It’s powered by a (you guessed it…) 2-litre turbo petrol with an electric motor, and these combine to produce 320hp. It’ll come as no surprise that the GLC is also the most expensive car here, being the newest, with the range starting from £52,880.
But which do you think is the best - will the all-new GLC come out on top? Or does the classic XC60 stand a chance? You’ll need to stick with Mat and see for yourself!
Chapters
00:00 Intro
00:23 Price
01:15 Design
03:45 Interior
07:17 Back Seats
11:30 Boot
13:47 Power
14:43 0-60mph
16:34 Volvo XC60 Driving
18:31 Audi Q5 Driving
21:13 BMW X3 Driving
23:59 Mercedes GLC Driving
27:04 Verdict
Sell your car with carwow: bit.ly/Buy-Sell-WOW 
Авто/Мото
For the Q5, it aren't exhausts but HDMI ports!
Yes 😍
Cheap ones at that probably snap off first B-road you're on. Abysmal reliability on all of these heaps even the Volvo is unreliable now.
@@bigduphusaj162 the reliability is also worse than Subaru 360.
@@bigduphusaj162 Huh? Volvos are really reliable
😂
The collision detection at least in my XC40 Recharge only triggers when you're going head on against an obstacle in front of you and I believe it takes into account your steering angle, that's why it didn't trigger. It knew at that angle you wouldn't collide with the truck otherwise it'll trigger at every corner.
XC40 and Mercedes Q5 for me are the most superior SUVs.
None of these are the best. The Tesla Model Y is actually the best. Too bad y’all didn’t include it since you are clearly paid buy these brands to include their cars. Tesla doesn’t pay for this garbage advertising. The sales #’s speak for themselves. Model Y was the best selling car in the entire world in Q1 of 2023.
@@purwantiallan5089 Q5 isnt mercedes tho, it's audi
@@9770G The meatriding is crazy
@Paul no? maybe cos u cant afford them.
I would go for the xc60 simply because of its sleek and unique design both interior and exterior and premium built quality with no hard plastics .Also the drive and performance seems superbly aided by the plush and luxurious cabins .
I’ve had the BMW X3 M40D for the last 3 years, should have changed it this year but I’ve kept it. 0 to 60 in 4.8 s, 42mpg on a long run, decent luggage space and I still like it as much as the day i got it👌
BMW 🇩🇪🌟💯💪👍👏💯😎
Nice. Keep it Bayerisch.
damn that m40d drives like a dream, can’t really get bored with it, have fun using it !
Wow! That is what i want to buy next ;)
I have the iX3 M Sport Pro which isn't quite as fast as the M40D, but more responsive due to electric power, and super smooth and comfortable like an S Class. The best thing is that it comes fully loaded - Head up display, adaptive suspension, 20" wheels, pano sunroof etc - all as standard. Stupendous car
I would take the XC60 in White with Black trim and Black wheels!
One of your best videos because of the balance, the logical and timely transitions and all the valuable information! Even if it is 27min which is not exactly RUclips trend, is justified covering 4 great competitor cars addressing a big potential market segment!
Saying this as a PHEV owner, the Mercedes is seriously impressive purely because of its EV range. 130km of electric range (probably 110km-ish in the real world) is amazing for a PHEV.
Mandatory in Germany now. To be considered a real PHEV, the cars need to have at least a 20+kw battery and more than 100km electric only range. So expect new models from Audi and BMW with the same stats
What year and model mercedes?
Volvo it is for me. Even though it was released some 6 years ago, it still is the best looking out of the bunch. Overall, an excellent package.
The Volvo is actually the most boring looking! Sorry Bro.
@@colors6692 "boring looking isn't a thing, its a Scandinavian design meaning its meant to be simplistic not boring.
U must be blind
@@colors6692 simplistic, not boring
@@colors6692no bro it's the safest one. Volvo cars are amazing
love and support from South Africa 🇿🇦
SA MY GEEEEWEEE❤
Cape Town in the house!!
Bloemfontain in the house🎆
Johannesburg in the house 🎉❤
@@albertmaneveld9731 awe🙏
The volvo xc60 is pretty
I was waiting for this one!! Have x3 but thinking to change, thank you!!
Love you, Mat Watson, been watching since 3million subs from Ghana.
Funny you mention the lack of a driver mode button in the XC60, years previous to 2021 (I think that’s the correct year) had this as a roller button
XC60 imo has 23 bhp more than XC40. The XC40 only had 218bhp.
@@purwantiallan5089 ok
@@purwantiallan5089 XC60 has more than 400bhp. so it's more than 23 from XC40
@@purwantiallan5089 how is that an opinion? its a fact...
It's a family SUV who cares about horsepower get an XC90
I’ve been using my xc90 PHEV for couple of years and still love it.
What a in-depth review! No one else compares to Matt for the details.
Those details are as insane as ever.
Mate, still the best new car review channel, love the honesty. I'd have the Volvo
Just bought an Q5 55tfsi E. Added horsepower really makes the car come alive. Unfortunately choose the adaptive air suspension and it is back at the dealer again
i love dealerships!
Can't get them new in the UK currently 😢
almanya ya da hollanda gurbetçisin değil mi
@@scottyuk not even possible in Ireland either.
@@minigiant8998 realistically getting them may took a few hundreds of dollars.
We have a 2021 GLC 300. It is powered by gas only. We are very pleased with the overall performance and design of the vehicle. Ours is loaded with every option available from Mercedes which made it a little pricey. We owned a 2019 model previously without many options. After having a more base model, the loaded model is a pleasure to own. We have owned 3 Mercedes SUV models. Very pleased with their quality, design and performance.
Back to back tests are so much better than individual reviews IMO - easier for Mat to make direct comparisons and better for consumers picking a new car. Mat's cynicism about PHEVs is misplaced though, I live in London and all the PHEVs near me seem to be plugged in.
I’d take the Volvo, I like it’s relatively understated looks and to me the interior feels much more restful and pleasant than the others. Though I’d prefer a V60 to the XC.
i'd take the glc, but in black just because its more comfortable and sportier
We had a v60 t6. Good car. we have a polestar now
Just changed to a XC60 T8 Polestar Eng. Had a V60 T5 polestar. Got to say the V60 was a stunning car ... the tech is another level if fully trimmed. Very quick and ace handling. All in a luxury setting. Not sure why I changed ... but the T8 PE is stunning.
didn't ask
Boring
Really enjoyed watching a good old skool Carwow video, as much I enjoy the drag races etc. I started watching the channel due to videos like this one.
school*
Surprised the Volvo didn’t rank higher. It’s an unbelievably nice car.
Для меня Volvo на 1 месте... XC 60 the best
Enjoy Watching You All The Way From South Africa 🇿🇦
Always good videos 😊
Considering the price, I’d take the Q5. Well built and spacious, yet more comfortable then the others. Also a lot quicker then expected.
It's a no-brainer, I'd do the same
Agreed. Couldn't live with fake exhausts though so have ordered a Sportback 😂
Tesla Model Y around the same price as well 🤔
@@Arpedk🤢🤮
@@Arpedk It can be an option ,but also depends where you live.For a grocery hauler can do the job as good as the others
Thumbs up for this comparison video: Mercedes GLA vs BMW X1 vs Audi Q3 vs Volvo XC40.
That volvo looks absolutely beautiful ❤
average China design
@@TSundergroundnah, it looks the best among this group.
And theres nothing bad about Chinese designs recently, they're leagues better than European and American designs
@@sillimilli3802 i know BMW is also Chinese design but is way better Volvo is for 60+YO
@@TSunderground tf you mean Chinese design pfff, yes a chinese company owns it, but it is still the same Volvo from sweden, just like it was when it was owned by american Ford
@@Conceptcreator the same Volvo from Sweden? With all the defects and bugs that it have and the owners said that, hell no this is not the same Volvo even like previous owner of the company, first XC90 was ethalon this new gens are even not little close
Now that I’ve seen Bender’s face on the Mercedes’s rear seats I just can’t unsee it 😂❤ quite cute though
Great review! Please do X5 vs GLE vs Q7 vs XC90 next! 💪💪💪
Good review Matt and I agree, the GLC for me please due to it's electric range and quality feel, just wish the exhausts were real !
X3 G01 all day everyday, it has the best interior right now because the next gen X3 will be all screen and no buttons. The current X3 has a good mix of buttons and the touchscreen.
Also the performance however less power/torque it has will always be fun to drive! Not to forget the B58 40i 6cyl available in the X3, which the poor Merc doesn’t get any longer !
Can’t believe the GLC PHEV is almost 2.3 tons !!
Any idea, when the next x3(2024), will roll out
Fax fax fax
@@varshadityasamala302august 2024 production starts
I agree entirely with you... I would choose the cars in the same order. I am quite happy with my current plug-in hybrid. But for sure in a few years I'll change it with one of those from the 2nd hand market, probably the Mercedes GLC300e. The Lexus NX plug-in hybrid is missing from the comparison and it's as good as the Audi in my opinion.
I miss these kinds of Comparo Test from Carwow! Soild Video as always!
These are as solid as ever.
I'll take the Volvo, seat comfort at its best.
I love my Volvo. The most comfortable of all that I owned. I also love the Mercedes to. But wouldn’t give up a Volvo
Volvo all the way, it's so minimalistic and I care about the safety of my family. :-)
It would not be superfluous to note that the Volvo battery is located in the central tunnel between the front passengers and has an independent all-wheel drive system. The gasoline engine drives only the front wheels, while the rear wheels are connected only to the electric motor. This has both its pros and cons. But this is a significant difference from other cars in which the electric motor is located along with the gearbox.
For sure Volvo XC60, cause I own one 😄
I'd chose the Volvo anytime. It's just sleek, and seat comfort is what really matters, especially on long trips. Interior is just beautifully blend together, and I prefer it over any of these cars.
Volovos safety is also unmatched. But then, I might be biased because I'm Volvo owner. 😅
VOLVO XC60 💚
As an Audi Owner i'd probably go with the Audi simply because of 10+ Years of Great Experience both regarding Reliability and Service.
Also did you Guys film that near a Swamp? So many Insects, not that i mind! Was fun to see if Matt will be bothered by them or not haha
Prost & Cheers from Berchtesgaden in the Bavarian Alps
Prost zurück aus dem Achental
Seavus aus Serbien, bald sind ma wieder in Berchtesgaden, wunderbares Ort! Und natürlich wird nur Audi gefahren weil es einfach klasse ist! Prost! 🍻
love the review, clear and detail
I love everything about the merc other than the chrome strips to the left and right of the badge at the front
To think that the XC60 is as fast as an 2002 RS6 is crazy. Would certainly feel flabbergasted when driving the RS6 and having a XC60 accelerate as fast as me.
Because your rs6 is 21 years old bro 😂
honestly it’s prob faster
@@charles_.l Thankfully not, espacially after 140 the Volvo dies and after 180 it stops. Imagine driving from Hamburg to Salzburg and not being able to go faster than 180...
Not in corners
@@miguelnavarrodonadios6067 Actually the RS6 is and has never been a "corners" car.. It is an Autobahn missile, but that is it. ;)
best content from mat as always!
Matt Watson still the best.
Excellent review and comparison Mat!😸
Wow, what an incredibly informative review!
BMW X3 and Volvo XC60 😍❣️
Nice video. watched videos in 2020. noticed the price changes in these three years. inflated so much..
Greed
Worse made but more expensive. Let's just see how long this era of junk finance express cars sell for😂 they are already pulling stunts and twisting the car sales figures so they know people are walking away.
@@bigduphusaj162 I bet it's a scheme launched by the government to convert people to public transport.
I bought a glc becuase of this video! Thanks for helping me choose!
Excellent review, thanks )
You should probably do the Dyno test on them ❤
Do dyno test also on some of the exotics and sport bikes.
Was choosing between all these and leaning towards Q5, but after test driving all of them bought Audi A4 Allroad.
Hi Matt, having looked in detail at three out of the four SUVs (no experience with the Volvo) I can second you ranking Mercedes - Audi -BMW. One area you did not cover, but which is important is the charging speed.
The Mercedes comes with 11kW AC charging as standard, which means that you can charge back to about 100% when you go 2 hours shopping or do a 2 hour customer visit. WLTP range 119-130km depending on options. You can even upgrade to 50kW DC charging, which turns the GLC to an ALMOST electrical car which is a good option in countries where the charging infrastructure is not well developed (my impression was that this applies e.g. to the UK, but also many parts of Southern or Eastern Europe). Admittedly, the car does not make sense in the Nordics, Benelux, Germany etc. where the range extending ICE is simply not needed anymore.
The Audi charges with 7.4 kW AC, but does not have a fast charging option. WLTP range 56-62km depending on options. I guess it delivers what is typical for PHEVs in that price range with respect to charging and range.
The BMW charges with veeeeeery slow 3.7 kW AC. WLTP range 51-55km depending on options. Admittedly this was still acceptable back when the X3 was introduced, it is anachronistic by today's standards.
Thamks for the details
The “stick of truth” throw war is hilarious 😂
All the best to everyone
Our local Mercedes dealer tried to scam us out of a $1,000 lost key when we bought a used car from them. Lied to our face, and then wanted to argue about it. We walked away, and bought a Volvo XC60 B5 Ultimate with the HUD. Very happy with it.
Not for long you're not.
I'll take the Q5
Me too.
I'll take the glc and xc60
That stick dropping in the frame was perfect timing before you even said it we already know what time it is lol
Great video! I do think you missed an opportunity to test something many potential buyers of phev always wonder about as the manufacturer never are straightforward. That is, testing how they drive in ev mode only. Can it they be "locked" in ev mode to prevent the engine from turning on, and if so what is the real world performance during highway driving. Some are very enimic in ev mode which is why the engine always turns on but to many, that defeats the point of a phev. I have not found one that can do this well and I will not make the move to phev until then. Full electric is not for me either due to infrastructure limitations where I am.
You've raised a quite important issue, and I'm interested in gaining an insight on this as I and my wife are contemplating going for one of these...currently with more preference for the GCL
Hi Carwow
Could you pit a Mazda CX-60 PHEV up against some or all of these cars please?
I’ve just purchased one and would love to see your thoughts on where it sits up against these cars as I believe it’s better looking and has better interior quality and functionality than some if not all of the cars in this review.
Cheers guys 🙂🤞🏼
Stuck between the GlC and Q5 they are both such great cars I’d tie them for first place
At least here in Germany, the old Q5 as featured in this video is no longer available for ordering. A new one will be coming soon.
It was a fun comparison to watch even though I don’t really see the point comparing 3 old models to a one which is brand new.
The Volvo does have that problem with the back doors being part of the wheel housing which unfortunately has meant for a lot of owners that it doesn’t keep tight enough and let in dirt and dust into the back seat. A shame really. The car is absolutely perfect for me in all aspects.
We had that issue when we got the car from the showroom floor. My guess is that it stood there for some time and the seals got a bit dry. I put some silicone spray on them and it's not had the issue since!
@@KnallenN good for you! I’m just a bit suspicious of that body feature on cars. I don’t think it looks good, and it has the obvious flaw of making the door sensitive to wear and potentially causing rust issues.
I have an xc60 and there is an official Volvo wheel arch liner thing that you can add if you really want. I have as I live in a muddy area and no mud gets through any more. Not an expensive part either to buy from Volvo so yes it can be an issue, but also an easy and cheap solution exists 👍🏻
Where is the Lexus nx and Jaguar f pace and Land Rover Discovery Sport and Genesis GV70 and Alfa Romeo Stelvio and Maserati Grecale and DS7 and Porsche Macan and Mazda CX60
I'm literally choosing which one to buy between these 4, great timing 👍
I'd consider the 2023 BMW X1 as from a tech perspective e.g. I'd argue it's more of a competitor to the GLC and rest than the current X3. It also grew in all dimensions
sad
@@theoteddy9665 jealousy is strong feeling my friend
I recommend the glc, it will age nicely and last long in terms of design
get a Macan
Hey Matt my best congratulations, following you from Mexico, could you film a full review about 2024 BMW X5 50e?? I’m interested to get one, and i really love your reviews, hope see it soon, my best regards
Great review. Will you ever review the Subaru Forester I’d like to get your thoughts
Can u make a video on a xtra long wheel base Mercedes Vclass 8 seater or a Mercedes Vito Tourer 9 seater Lwb please❤
Volvo XC60 💪🏻🤘🏻👋🏻
Need a drag race of all these cars
Love and support from Namibia 🇳🇦
None of the best, just comes down to brand preference at this point.
We knew that the winner will be the GLC way before starting the video 🙃
Yes he is mercedes boy
Because mercedes is the best
Mercedes makes better all round cars
Ugly Mercedes without exhaust, only Audi is worse in this comparison
Because it is the newest model - the others (or some of them) will at least equal the Merc once the new models arrive - just comes down to when you want to change your car..
Love and support from Kenya 🇰🇪
Are you guys going to test the mazda cx60? Waiting for the review on youtube. Maybe a comparison, like this video?
The person off camera just casually firing the stick of truth back a few times at Matt after getting hit in the face had me 😂
Would chose the x3 any day
BMW 🇩🇪💯👏👍💪🌟😎
Could you make a video that explains the petrol plug in hybrids, types of chargers, and mileage breakdown? Unless you already have...
Why are the cars in the Thumbnails always in a different color than in the videos lately?
Would’ve liked to have seen the Land Rover Discovery Sport included in the group test
I’ve got a disco sport, wouldn’t make it without breaking down
Hello,
I purchased a GLC 400e with the AMG Premium package on January 26, 2023. After two months, I experienced issues with the transmission controllers. In fact, the gearbox repeatedly failed at high speeds, especially above 160 kilometers per hour, causing significant stress and concern for my own safety and that of my family while driving on the highway. This serious risk of an accident has put me and my family in danger.
After four attempts to diagnose the problem by Mercedes, starting from June 21, my vehicle has been at the Mercedes service center in Aschaffenburg, Germany. However, unfortunately, they do not have the necessary parts for the repair, and I am forced to wait until July 31. Undoubtedly, this lengthy delay has left me extremely dissatisfied and angry with Mercedes.
Until today, despite sending multiple emails to Mercedes and filling out their form, they have not made any contact or taken any actions to address my concerns and seek my satisfaction.
Brilliant review
I owned the launch Ghibli and loved it because I grounded myself on what it was. This trofeo knows that it is and will be an excellent buy in 2025 with depreciation. An $80k less than 15k miles maintained Trofeo will be hard to beat.
It's amazing how much technology has evolved over the past generation. Not the price though, they are very expensive, but I guess technology doesn't come cheap.
Technologies always costed thousand of dollars for that.
Evolved? Mate a dual clutch gearbox is from a 1970s tractor, tractors are on 6 clutch 50+speed power shift gearboxes nowadays.. and the only other thing that's changed is tyre tech has got better to allow for a much faster 60ft. The rest of the tech is junk, laggy screens instead of interior and they are becoming less aerodynamic 😂 I mean a Vauxhall Carlton from 30yr ago has lower drag Co-eff. Suspension wise they run cars stiffer now with diabolically bad dampening and rebound that confuses them over bumps, cambers & potholes. Not really sure where the hike in Tech is when motorbikes have 6 axis systems that can even prevent highsides they and have much faster electronic polling so can react a lot faster and speed up or slow down the engine way way faster as there's no internal weight in the engine. These current car engines as still lethargic as it gets on rpm change so you won't break any handling or roadholding records while the car is weight transitioning all over the place to compensate for the lazy engines. Porsche have done probably the best job as they kept the smaller 6 block and lightened it up internally so it was more responsive, the results paid off but they are a long long way from being at motorcycle engine tech levels. Lorries have better engine and gearbox tech than cars by several decades so please 🙏 don't over hype these disposable junk heaps they need to sort the build quality out for a start, they fall apart in months modern cars.
@@bigduphusaj162 you forgot about abs-brakes, led-headlights, direct injection, bio-fuel engines and many other things :D and besides, there are other cars in this world than suv:s regarding drag: the mercedes eqs is a good example :)
I remember how just recently Mercedes had electric motor added to its combustion cars only nominally, for taxes/fees benefits. They only added 20 horse powers, which was laughable. And now they are making real hybrids.
@@wga4139 but then again, those features nowadays comes at a price
I think you really understated the performance difference.
The Volvo is proper fast compared to significantly sportier vehicles, has great ev range, and is driveable in ev only mode. Others are just boring to drive in EV.
I don't think it's much of a contest for anyone who wants a smooth, powerful, fun, roomy suv. Volvo is the first choice. 😊
Thanks Matt.. I’m having the Audi Q5… lovely car
Maybe it was the camera angle, but on the drive, it looked like the B=pillar in the Merc could be a bit of a visibility block. It seemed to be level with your head, not behind you.
the glc is the bessst!!!
i must say that BMW look does it for me😍
BMW 🇩🇪🌟👏💯💪👍😎
the Color on that Glc is so nice
I have the Audi Q5 55 PHEV with 362hp. Lots of fun to drive!!!
If you care about seat comfort and own safety, you can not go wrong with the Volvo.
What happened to your GT3 RS?
Only if Genesis GV70 and Porsche Macan were in the comparison too. The only drawback is both have a waiting period of 10+ months.
I was looking at each of these cars and could not make my mind up.
Do the drag race with 4 of them, it will be massively interesting and highly watched content!!!
I feel it would be very anticlimactic. Volvo would shoot off ahead followed by the Audi being followed really closely by the Mercedes leaving the bmw behind with its lower power output.
Mercedes😍 then the Audi is my 2nd choice
Please compare Merc V-Class, VW Caravelle and Staria Luxury next time.
Interesting comparison
Can you test and compare the mazda cx60 please??. It's been out a while now but no video?
thank u forcthe review, i think the volvo and audi surpriced me the most
would love to see this test with the new 2023/4 X3!
The model in this test is the newest X3 currently available. The next X3 will likely come end of 24 oder beginning of 25.
@@jola6175 thought it would come early 2023! Interesting that BMW seems to do something similar to Mercedes - start innovating bottom-up!
@@jola6175 the X3 2nd gen possibly gonna launch in April 2025.
@@BellaBenny1337 perhaps we may just wait and see.
@@jola6175 the ICE x3 should come in 2024, however theres a global fully-electric version that will be built on new dedicated ev platform that should debut in 2025. Interesting to see how it will turn out.