Jeannie Carson--what a treat to be introduced to her here. So charming and lovely. So few brits speak as well anymore. And still alive as of Aug '24, with 96 years! (So used to "was" when I look up people from this show.) So many catty cathys here. So happy to say I love the ones these catty cathys hate, including Wally Cox!
@@johndonahue3162 that is a whole another field, I understand the amount of evidence nor am I defending him completely. I am just saying that in the eyes if the law he's nothing more than a suspect/witness. Everyone on that boat is equally guilty of having some part of the crime for different theories. As of now I just look at all the suspects are innocent until proven guilty.
Jeannie Carson is still living at age 94, as of January 2023. Her hairstyle was one of the few from the 1950s that would still look fashionable in the 21st century.
The Calyoso Song 7:40 Chorus: What's my line? What's my line? The panel, they guessed it right this time. What's my line? What's my line? The panel, they guessed it right this time. Now people come from far and wide, Their occupation they try to hide. The panel look 'em from head to toe, And ask them if it's "yes" or "no." Chorus Now John Daly is the moderator, He uses words from here to Gibraltar. Bennett Cerf, the book publisher, And a favorite women's club lecturer. Chorus Dorothy Kilgallen, a pretty redhead, Writes a Broadway column we have all read. Arlene Francis for intellect, Wears a sparkling diamond heart 'round her neck. Chorus
I just watched the first episode of Hey Jeannie! on TV, here in the UK, a couple of hours ago. Very charming and innocent. Delighted to discover that Jeannie Carson is alive and well at the age of 92. Sadly, her husband passed away 11 days ago, though. Terribly reminiscent of Queen Elizabeth and Prince Phillip. 🙏✨💟
I like watching the panel. Dorothy is sharp as a needle. I can see why she was such a good investigative reporter. Didn't know John Daly was a newscaster.
I had grandmotherly teachers, matronly teachers, plain teachers, stern teachers (one looked like she didn't want to teach anymore) and pretty teachers. I would not call any of my female teachers ugly. I had three teachers in third grade: one in NYC (Queens) and two in the suburbs after my family moved. All were on the younger side and I liked all of them as good teachers. The one in Queens was an attractive woman. The first one in the suburbs was very young, very sweet and very pretty. The day before Christmas vacation, she told us she wasn't going to be our teacher when we came back. I forget what term she used, but she was pregnant. The third teacher was young, but more on the plain side. But she had a dynamic personality and after a few weeks we forgot that we had had another teacher. And she had gotten such good results with the class that they moved her up to 4th grade with our class. She was one of the best teachers I ever had, and certainly the best I had at the grammar school level.
Lois Simmons ~ My teachers were very similar to yours. FYI...I always enjoy your comments. It’s obvious you were taught well because you think before you speak, you’re nonjudgmental and you phrase your comments very elegantly. I’m sure I’m not the only one that notices.
There was a Fay Targove born in the Bronx in 1931, if that is her, it would put her about 26 at the time of this broadcast. As of 12-18-18 she is still alive (87 yo) in Cape Coral, if that is her. PS58 is in the Bronx and it's address is 459 East 176th street Bronx, NY
Gary Zerr He's a plant in the audience every week to fill space when HE THINKS there's not much happening and so far, having been watching WML chronologically, he's done it about 37:658 times. Looking forward to him getting the push. USA viewers won't know this reference (I don't think) but his forced laugh is like a character called Mr Mackay from a classic UK 70s sitcom called 'Porridge'.
It seemed as if Arlene was the only panelist that was into the calypso music. Arlene was great on this show and every other show she did over the years.
What an interesting episode! Calypso trio reminded me of Frank Zappa quote, in which he says that at one short time people in 50s thought that rock n roll is dead and that calypso is a new thing. School teacher is just plain gorgeous. Last contestant had some eccentric quality about him, which panel also noticed and based their first questions on that. I understand from other comments that he had an injury, but he also has a vivid personality. It seems to me that he and Jeannie Carson would be interesting couple. And Miss Carson is so likeable and unusual. Like she is not from that time.
Arlene wore that diamond heart shaped pendent on every show. She may have been one of the first influencers since they became a rage - well maybe not diamond, but they were very popular.
Look for him in "Stars and Stripes Forever," a silly 1952 picture about John Philip Sousa. Wagner plays a young band member who invents the sousaphone. (Not historically accurate!) In Technicolor lighting and makeup at age 22, he looks about 17.
At 25:10, John says that the last contestant worked for the Internal Revenue Bureau. Habits do die hard: the organization had been renamed the Internal Revenue Service in 1953. Anyone watching later episodes will see another example of this phenomenon in the early 1960s: for a long time after zip codes were introduced, John would give the address for the show as New York 22, New York, instead of using the zip code.
Robert Wagner is one of my favorite actors of all time. I loved him in "Hart to Hart" (and I loved Stefanie Powers, too). And he was the gold standard for the lovable rogue in "Switch", "It Takes a Thief" and "NCIS". He was the perfect choice to play DiNozzo's (MIchael Weatherly's) father in NCIS (much better than picking Fred Astaire to play Wagner's father in "It Takes a Thief").
That teacher, like my teacher, Mrs. Santandrea, back in the late 1970's, helped me as a 12 year old at the time, through puberty. She was guilty of nothing, but I was convicted of every fantasy that I had indulged in regarding her.
Very unusual to allow a guest to perform like the calypso band did, but quite entertaining, actually. When the syndicated version of "What's My Line?" went into production, they frequently allowed guests to demonstrate their "line" as part of the entertainment.
Well, I guess it depends on what one counts as a "musical group." I presume you're thinking of the Salvation Army Band as the other. But there were also the two singing garbage collectors... John's well-known aversion to contestants performing probably had a lot to do with concern over losing control of the timing. In all of these instances, the "performance" was a preplanned event with a known duration, so that JCD could factor the length into his timing calculations.
@@michaelnivens6267 Very sadly, I just discovered that Jeannie's husband, Biff, passed away on 09/04/2021. They were married for 61 years, bless them. 🙏✨💟🌌💟✨🙏
would love to know more about the history of the Calypso Trio. Sad that they never cut a record or otherwise appeared on TV. Probably the racial barriers of the time . . .
RW was big friends with Betty Davis, her nickname for him was Beautiful. She got that right! He also very convincingly played terrible characters, such as the spoiled brother in The Mountain. He was worried about playing such a despicable role, and Spencer Tracy asked him if he were an actor or a mouse. Did not hurt his career at all.
Sara, I think he was in A kiss Before Dying also in which he played a thoroughly bad character. Matt Dillon was cast in his role later. I liked the Dillon pic better.
@@johndonahue3162 I have watched them all once and this is my second time around though the entire series. I haven't noticed his preference for skirts or dresses, so I just wondered if anyone had counted--skirts and dresses against "good causes," and financial background of the contestant--i.e. "come a long way at some expense for nothing." I just don't believe John was particularly "snarky," because those were "MY" days, too, (Dorothy was my mother's age.) It was flattering--a compliment--to hear a wolf whistle, not a put-down. Women's lib flipped the coin on all of this, which was great, had it actually accomplished equal pay for equal work, which it helped a bit, but not enough. On the other hand, it tended to destroy the sense of gallantry, which I detect among the panelists and John himself, but younger people now, seem to misinterpret this as "sexist" or otherwise inappropriate. I see it from the perspective of the times.
he flips extra cards when he feels that it would do some justice. i remember in one occasion he flipped all cards for two students who worked outdoors in summer holidays to earn some money, that was just the right act. He does it in such a way that it matches with the expectations of the viewer. That being said, the good looks helps in every aspect of life. But I'm sure John would still flip all cards even if the woman was not good looking.
Robert Wagner in his early luscious period. Oh my yes. A few years before he started his relationship with Natalie Wood, Robert as a particularly young man got a supporting-cast role in the 1953 Clifton Webb -- Barbara Stanwyck "Titanic." That film was not as historically accurate as the 1997 decaprio-winslet-cameron film, nor were its special effects on that massive scale, but the writing and the drama were of a high order. His character in 1953 "Titanic" may have inspired in some backhanded way the deCaprio role in the 1997 "Titanic." He and Stanwyck became good friends in that period.
A bit more than friends, if one can believe what one reads. And by the way, I enjoy your very informed and fascinating comments. A pleasure to read. Thank you.
Dorothy and Arlene dress in evening attire on the show. Very pretty. Course when attending a special event hard telling what they wore. Even the guests dressed in formal wear sometimes. More dressy than how people dress for weddings, funerals and church now.
I liked Jeannie on the panel, she seemed pretty dorky (which appeals to me) and had an aura of gamine and youthful freshness about her. I would have seated her next to Dorothy, though, not in the third spot next to Arlene, for more contrast. However, that old grandmotherly maxim does come to mind: A lady should never appear too eager! I think we might all underestimate how difficult being a panelist was, once you get a "yes" answer it can be hard to know where to go from there, especially when you're on the spot.
Johan Bengtsson Phyllis Newman?!? Really, Johan? I'm pretty shocked you think so badly of her on WML-- she's generally very popular. I don't agree on Victor Borge, either, but I know you're far from alone in that opinion. :)
What's My Line? I just think she is too much of everything; too happy, too giggly, too eager, too much alike Arlene. I can understand that she is/was very popular but the show needed an anthithesis of Arlene, not a copy.
Johan Bengtsson I agree with you on that, the show would have benefited from someone who was more of a contrast than Phyllis was, but that aside, I find her completely endearing. :)
When I was in the 5th and 6th grades "It Takes a Thief" was one of my favorite shows. However, I think the verdict is still out on what happened to Natalie Wood and I lived on Santa Catalina island for almost a year so when I think about living in Avalon it reminds me of Natalie Wood. I would like to think he had nothing to do with it as he was one of my favorites.
What sort of ear jewelry is Mrs. Targove wearing??? Are those multiple piercings? If so, that must've been very unusual for the 50s. I've never seen anything like it.
+maremacd I never saw anything like them, either. Having grown up in the 1950's I don't remember seeing any jewelry for the ears like that. The closest was some of the ear jewelry on Star Trek (TOS). This was the closest I could find by searching Google images for "1950's clip on earrings". wanelo.co/p/32149972/wiesner-earrings-joseph-wiesner-ny-clip-on-earrings-1950s-50s-mid-century-hollywood-aquamarine-crystal-rhinestones-art-deco-revival-wedding
Well spotted. There was a long history even by then of ear cuffs. Check out some of the things Lucille Ball would wear! But admittedly, this lady's jewellery is quite unique.
Officially 5'11" tall, or at least he was supposed to have been at one point. I think he was, judging by how he looked standing next to John Daly and Bennett Cerf, both of whom were 6'1" tall . But definitely not over 6 feet tall. Nothing wrong with 5'11" -- tall enough.
Развлечения![What's My Line? - Robert Wagner; Gordon MacRae [panel] (Nov 2, 1958)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6HvwXKZ3D_Y/mqdefault.jpg)
![What's My Line? - Robert Wagner; Gordon MacRae [panel] (Nov 2, 1958)](/img/tr.png)
![What's My Line? - Gale Storm; Robert Monkhouse [panel] (Nov 10, 1957)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/6S7vezUGa5k/mqdefault.jpg)
![What's My Line? - Dr. Norman Vincent Peale; Judy Holliday; Robert Preston [panel] (Mar 17, 1957)](/img/1.gif)
The Calypso Trio was sweet. :))
A good vibe!
Agree! ♥️
Jeannie Carson--what a treat to be introduced to her here. So charming and lovely. So few brits speak as well anymore. And still alive as of Aug '24, with 96 years! (So used to "was" when I look up people from this show.) So many catty cathys here. So happy to say I love the ones these catty cathys hate, including Wally Cox!
If they had recorded that song, it would have been a hit!
I've always thought Robert Wagner to be one of the most attractive men. Ever. That perfect bone structure and lovely smile. He's wonderful.
@@johndonahue3162 actually it never was known if he actually was a murderer, the case was never truly solved.
@@johndonahue3162 that is a whole another field, I understand the amount of evidence nor am I defending him completely. I am just saying that in the eyes if the law he's nothing more than a suspect/witness. Everyone on that boat is equally guilty of having some part of the crime for different theories. As of now I just look at all the suspects are innocent until proven guilty.
I would give it two likes just for the calypso band alone.
Loved the band I Loved their WML song!!
Jeannie Carson is still living at age 94, as of January 2023. Her hairstyle was one of the few from the 1950s that would still look fashionable in the 21st century.
Still living in January 2024 at the age of 95. So is Robert Wagner at the age of 93, almost 94.
She'll be 96 this coming May. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeannie_Carson
The Calyoso Song 7:40
Chorus:
What's my line?
What's my line?
The panel, they guessed it right this time.
What's my line?
What's my line?
The panel, they guessed it right this time.
Now people come from far and wide,
Their occupation they try to hide.
The panel look 'em from head to toe,
And ask them if it's "yes" or "no."
Chorus
Now John Daly is the moderator,
He uses words from here to Gibraltar.
Bennett Cerf, the book publisher,
And a favorite women's club lecturer.
Chorus
Dorothy Kilgallen, a pretty redhead,
Writes a Broadway column we have all read.
Arlene Francis for intellect,
Wears a sparkling diamond heart 'round her neck.
Chorus
Johan Bengtsson
Thanks for transcribing that -- what a fun song!
SaveThe TPC My pleasue! :) They should have used the song as a new signature tune. :)
Johan Bengtsson
Lol! Wouldn't that have been a big break for the trio!?
Johan Bengtsson - Thanks for transcribing. These guys were talented and fun contestants. :)
@@Beson-SE I appreciate it -- I had thought that he said that Bennett Cerf was a women's lecherer
The ladies on this Panel are uniquely gifted.
Technically, we all are. Arlene and Dorothy were well-known backbones of the show... wouldn't put Jeannie Carson anywhere on their level.
My 6th birthday. Little did I know I would see these wonderful shows when I emmigrated to this great country six years later.
Like how Bob Wagner kept changing voices. :)
I love watching the old programs because people used to dress up and were much more elegant than today
I will have that song in my head for quite a while, it was really good!
It was very catchy, loved it!
Jimmy Stewart said Wagners' impression was one of the best
The calypso guys were tops! Love them. Did you see how much the panel enjoyed them. The front one is fantastic. So calm and present
Good Jimmy Stewart impersonation.
This rock 'n roll movement!
Shocking!!
😁😁😁
James, it's still going strong 70 yrs later. Tks to Elvis and Fats and Little Richard and Jerry etc.
I just watched the first episode of Hey Jeannie! on TV, here in the UK, a couple of hours ago.
Very charming and innocent.
Delighted to discover that Jeannie Carson is alive and well at the age of 92.
Sadly, her husband passed away 11 days ago, though.
Terribly reminiscent of Queen Elizabeth and Prince Phillip.
🙏✨💟
I like the Whats my line song by the calypso trio.
Love the calypso group and Arlene's description.
I like watching the panel. Dorothy is sharp as a needle. I can see why she was such a good investigative reporter.
Didn't know John Daly was a newscaster.
Jeanine laid the groundwork for Dorothy with the teacher and Dorothy Is really good at taking notes
That band is perfect for my WML fix this evening!
I was 10 years old at the time, I did not have a teacher that beautiful.
+The Amish Umpire
Mine were all ugly..Period.
I had grandmotherly teachers, matronly teachers, plain teachers, stern teachers (one looked like she didn't want to teach anymore) and pretty teachers. I would not call any of my female teachers ugly.
I had three teachers in third grade: one in NYC (Queens) and two in the suburbs after my family moved. All were on the younger side and I liked all of them as good teachers. The one in Queens was an attractive woman. The first one in the suburbs was very young, very sweet and very pretty. The day before Christmas vacation, she told us she wasn't going to be our teacher when we came back. I forget what term she used, but she was pregnant.
The third teacher was young, but more on the plain side. But she had a dynamic personality and after a few weeks we forgot that we had had another teacher. And she had gotten such good results with the class that they moved her up to 4th grade with our class. She was one of the best teachers I ever had, and certainly the best I had at the grammar school level.
Lois Simmons ~ My teachers were very similar to yours.
FYI...I always enjoy your comments. It’s obvious you were taught well because you think before you speak, you’re nonjudgmental and you phrase your comments very elegantly. I’m sure I’m not the only one that notices.
I had a good looking teacher In the 3rd grade and another In the 4th but that was It -this one on WML 1957 Is a stunner
Love that Calyso trio! Brilliant! Now that song is in my head for the rest of the day lol.
I loved the band and the song...
Love Robert Wagner would love to have dinner with him!!! Legendary!!!!!
Perhaps dinner, but not onboard a boat.
@@igkoigko9950 Yeah LoL
@@igkoigko9950 - LOL That thought entered my mind too! 🤣🤣🤣
NCIS, I love everytime I see Robert on this show xxx
The Blonde Marilyn-esque teacher was so gracious and poised. What a lovely lady.
Jeannie Carson is still with us in 2023 at age 95
It was so gracious of John to flip the cards to $50. for that wonderful teacher!
Jeannie Carson is STILL ALIVE at the age of 90!
So is that scoundrel Wagner
And she is still alive in 2022 at 94.
She is still alive 2023
That song is just so adorable !
What a stunningly handsome man Robert Wagner really was. In Prince Valient omg
There was a Fay Targove born in the Bronx in 1931, if that is her, it would put her about 26 at the time of this broadcast. As of 12-18-18 she is still alive (87 yo) in Cape Coral, if that is her.
PS58 is in the Bronx and it's address is 459 East 176th street Bronx, NY
Could not see the school teacher looking anything at all like Jayne mansfield...Jayne was extremely pretty.
I can only imagine what has become of PS 58 since those days.
The ladies (2) on this panel are remarkable!
That oft-heard rather loud off stage laugh whenever Jeannie Carson (never heard of her, but very pretty) was nervously goofing up a bit was hilarious.
Gary Zerr He's a plant in the audience every week to fill space when HE THINKS there's not much happening and so far, having been watching WML chronologically, he's done it about 37:658 times. Looking forward to him getting the push.
USA viewers won't know this reference (I don't think) but his forced laugh is like a character called Mr Mackay from a classic UK 70s sitcom called 'Porridge'.
@@davidsanderson5918 - They always have them in the crowds to get the people started. I would rather have that than the "Canned" laughter. 😉
@@davidsanderson5918 He sounds like Ed McMahon when he would force himself to laugh at Johnny Carson's jokes.
It seemed as if Arlene was the only panelist that was into the calypso music. Arlene was great on this show and every other show she did over the years.
He was great in The Mountain and i think it came out in 1956.
He had some good movies and I thought he was great In " It Takes A Thief "- great TV show and , no , he did not kill his wife!
That was beautiful G Trio 💖💯💖💯💖💯...
What an interesting episode!
Calypso trio reminded me of Frank Zappa quote, in which he says that at one short time people in 50s thought that rock n roll is dead and that calypso is a new thing.
School teacher is just plain gorgeous.
Last contestant had some eccentric quality about him, which panel also noticed and based their first questions on that. I understand from other comments that he had an injury, but he also has a vivid personality. It seems to me that he and Jeannie Carson would be interesting couple.
And Miss Carson is so likeable and unusual. Like she is not from that time.
Arlene wore that diamond heart shaped pendent on every show. She may have been one of the first influencers since they became a rage - well maybe not diamond, but they were very popular.
A GREAT ACTOR
Jeannie Carson still with us as of now. 94. Wonderful! And Wagner!
That song was adorable !
Yay for the calypso band!
And I never knew that Robert Wagner had ever been young. :)
Look for him in "Stars and Stripes Forever," a silly 1952 picture about John Philip Sousa. Wagner plays a young band member who invents the sousaphone. (Not historically accurate!) In Technicolor lighting and makeup at age 22, he looks about 17.
hopicard Watch "The Jane Froman Story" to see a young Robert Wagner and hear some wonderful singing by Jane Froman herself. What a voice!
Sad.
For me he'll always be the American prisoner of war in the excellent 70s drama series 'Colditz'.
He was a beautiful man
At 25:10, John says that the last contestant worked for the Internal Revenue Bureau. Habits do die hard: the organization had been renamed the Internal Revenue Service in 1953. Anyone watching later episodes will see another example of this phenomenon in the early 1960s: for a long time after zip codes were introduced, John would give the address for the show as New York 22, New York, instead of using the zip code.
the song Is delightful
17:40 One of the rare mistakes by John Daly where he doesn't 'flip the card' on a 'No'.
Robert Wagner is one of my favorite actors of all time. I loved him in "Hart to Hart" (and I loved Stefanie Powers, too). And he was the gold standard for the lovable rogue in "Switch", "It Takes a Thief" and "NCIS". He was the perfect choice to play DiNozzo's (MIchael Weatherly's) father in NCIS (much better than picking Fred Astaire to play Wagner's father in "It Takes a Thief").
It Takes a Thief and Hart To Hart were two of my favorites! I have always admired RJ. Always charming and sophisticated.
@@johndonahue3162 If you mean Natalia Nikolaevna Zakharenko, she's dead, so hard to ask. Also, your statement is libelous.
@@johndonahue3162 Can you prove it, Mr. Lawyer?
@@johndonahue3162 I don't need a law course. I just need a verdict from a jury.
@@johndonahue3162 Doesn't matter. It's up to the jury. The truth be damned.
That teacher, like my teacher, Mrs. Santandrea, back in the late 1970's, helped me as a 12 year old at the time, through puberty. She was guilty of nothing, but I was convicted of every fantasy that I had indulged in regarding her.
Very unusual to allow a guest to perform like the calypso band did, but quite entertaining, actually. When the syndicated version of "What's My Line?" went into production, they frequently allowed guests to demonstrate their "line" as part of the entertainment.
Any Advertising is good
That changed in the 70's
That's a conga, John. :)
oh my....those hats
RE: first contestants. One of only two musical groups that ever performed on live WML I hope they got union scale.
Well, I guess it depends on what one counts as a "musical group." I presume you're thinking of the Salvation Army Band as the other. But there were also the two singing garbage collectors...
John's well-known aversion to contestants performing probably had a lot to do with concern over losing control of the timing. In all of these instances, the "performance" was a preplanned event with a known duration, so that JCD could factor the length into his timing calculations.
Jeannie Carson was born 23 May 1928 and of this date (5/18/17) she is still living
Still alive now in June 2020 at age 92.
her husband also
@@richatlarge462
Jeannie is still with us as of 20/04/2021, I am very happy to report.
@@michaelnivens6267
Very sadly, I just discovered that Jeannie's husband, Biff, passed away on 09/04/2021.
They were married for 61 years, bless them.
🙏✨💟🌌💟✨🙏
Still alive at 94 on 8-12-2022
would love to know more about the history of the Calypso Trio. Sad that they never cut a record or otherwise appeared on TV. Probably the racial barriers of the time . . .
I love it when a contestant doesn't know which way to face after signing in.
RW was big friends with Betty Davis, her nickname for him was Beautiful. She got that right! He also very convincingly played terrible characters, such as the spoiled brother in The Mountain. He was worried about playing such a despicable role, and Spencer Tracy asked him if he were an actor or a mouse. Did not hurt his career at all.
Bette not Betty Davis. She disliked the latter spelling and pronunciation of her name.
Sara, I think he was in A kiss Before Dying also in which he played a thoroughly bad character. Matt Dillon was cast in his role later. I liked the Dillon pic better.
I had never heard of Jeannie Carson before. She was nervous (I guess) but very attractive! :)
I never heard of her myself.
Strange, she appears very confident to me....quirky, kooky but quite calm. I like her!
9-18-22 and Robert Wagner is still very much with us!
But Natalie Wood isn't.
Jeannie Carson was a very pleasant guest panelist😊
John Daly certainly was more likely to flip all of the cards over if there was a beautiful woman involved!
@@johndonahue3162 Need documentation here. Source, perhaps?
@@johndonahue3162 I have watched them all once and this is my second time around though the entire series. I haven't noticed his preference for skirts or dresses, so I just wondered if anyone had counted--skirts and dresses against "good causes," and financial background of the contestant--i.e. "come a long way at some expense for nothing." I just don't believe John was particularly "snarky," because those were "MY" days, too, (Dorothy was my mother's age.) It was flattering--a compliment--to hear a wolf whistle, not a put-down. Women's lib flipped the coin on all of this, which was great, had it actually accomplished equal pay for equal work, which it helped a bit, but not enough. On the other hand, it tended to destroy the sense of gallantry, which I detect among the panelists and John himself, but younger people now, seem to misinterpret this as "sexist" or otherwise inappropriate. I see it from the perspective of the times.
he flips extra cards when he feels that it would do some justice. i remember in one occasion he flipped all cards for two students who worked outdoors in summer holidays to earn some money, that was just the right act. He does it in such a way that it matches with the expectations of the viewer. That being said, the good looks helps in every aspect of life. But I'm sure John would still flip all cards even if the woman was not good looking.
I think he was always very generous in giving people more than what they had actually "earned."
That band was pretty cool
Robert Wagner in his early luscious period. Oh my yes. A few years before he started his relationship with Natalie Wood, Robert as a particularly young man got a supporting-cast role in the 1953 Clifton Webb -- Barbara Stanwyck "Titanic." That film was not as historically accurate as the 1997 decaprio-winslet-cameron film, nor were its special effects on that massive scale, but the writing and the drama were of a high order. His character in 1953 "Titanic" may have inspired in some backhanded way the deCaprio role in the 1997 "Titanic." He and Stanwyck became good friends in that period.
"A Night to Remember" is the best Titanic film, by far.
A bit more than friends, if one can believe what one reads. And by the way, I enjoy your very informed and fascinating comments. A pleasure to read. Thank you.
A Night to Remember from 1958 which was based on a book was the best and most accurate of the movies.
@@cellom.9227 without a doubt, ma'am, like Tora X3's superiority to Pearl Harbor. PH and Titanic were Hollywood glitzy fictions, imo.
I love the class exuding from the panel. Try to get anybody dressed that well again.
The Calypso band was all that and a bag of plantain chips !
As of March 2, 2019, Robert Wagner is still alive.
And, still a murderer
@@allme2547 You risk a defamation lawsuit if Mr. Wagner can identify you.
Still alive as of January 2022!
Dorothy and Arlene dress in evening attire on the show. Very pretty. Course when attending a special event hard telling what they wore. Even the guests dressed in formal wear sometimes. More dressy than how people dress for weddings, funerals and church now.
mendel maybe There's nothing strange about it. Newsreaders wore tuxedos with bow-ties in the fifties just to read the news!
Isnt this Arlenes favorite dress that she wears on the show with some frequency that Martin Gabel referred to it being very expensive?
4:15 "is it long hair rather than pop music?" Huh? Oh that darn rock and roll music!!!
I liked Jeannie on the panel, she seemed pretty dorky (which appeals to me) and had an aura of gamine and youthful freshness about her. I would have seated her next to Dorothy, though, not in the third spot next to Arlene, for more contrast. However, that old grandmotherly maxim does come to mind: A lady should never appear too eager!
I think we might all underestimate how difficult being a panelist was, once you get a "yes" answer it can be hard to know where to go from there, especially when you're on the spot.
Dorothy K was so smart and quick
Jeannie Carson is on another planet here.
She was just a guest on the panel that night.
@@misspad7282 - Exactly...just that night....don't think they ever brought her back.
Robert Wagner, yes!
Jeannie has such a lovely speaking voice...
Nomination for the Panel From Heck: Jeannie Carson, Hal Block, Wally Cox . . . Nominations are still open.
I like this thread idea. I nominate Errol Flynn.
Victor Borge, Otto Preminger and Phyllis Newman.
Johan Bengtsson Phyllis Newman?!? Really, Johan? I'm pretty shocked you think so badly of her on WML-- she's generally very popular.
I don't agree on Victor Borge, either, but I know you're far from alone in that opinion. :)
What's My Line? I just think she is too much of everything; too happy, too giggly, too eager, too much alike Arlene. I can understand that she is/was very popular but the show needed an anthithesis of Arlene, not a copy.
Johan Bengtsson I agree with you on that, the show would have benefited from someone who was more of a contrast than Phyllis was, but that aside, I find her completely endearing. :)
As July 2020 Robert was still alive
Still Is I believe
8-12-2022 He is still alive at 92
Awesome, awesome all the way to Gibraltar!
When I was in the 5th and 6th grades "It Takes a Thief" was one of my favorite shows. However, I think the verdict is still out on what happened to Natalie Wood and I lived on Santa Catalina island for almost a year so when I think about living in Avalon it reminds me of Natalie Wood. I would like to think he had nothing to do with it as he was one of my favorites.
And a member of the 60 years later club. (almost.)
ロバートワグナーハンサム。素晴らしい。外国俳優で一番好きです。
1:52 - A foreshadowing of what Arlene would do in the syndicated WML perhaps?
I like his gable impersonation it's good to me in my opinion.
What sort of ear jewelry is Mrs. Targove wearing??? Are those multiple piercings? If so, that must've been very unusual for the 50s. I've never seen anything like it.
maremacd Clip-ons. Not piercings
+maremacd
I never saw anything like them, either. Having grown up in the 1950's I don't remember seeing any jewelry for the ears like that. The closest was some of the ear jewelry on Star Trek (TOS).
This was the closest I could find by searching Google images for "1950's clip on earrings".
wanelo.co/p/32149972/wiesner-earrings-joseph-wiesner-ny-clip-on-earrings-1950s-50s-mid-century-hollywood-aquamarine-crystal-rhinestones-art-deco-revival-wedding
Well spotted. There was a long history even by then of ear cuffs. Check out some of the things Lucille Ball would wear! But admittedly, this lady's jewellery is quite unique.
You can tell it's a clip on that goes up the ear.
Damn, Dorothy's smart!
I was hoping Bennett Cerf would have put on a Calypso hat.
Wagner was a poster-boy for Brylcreem
A little dab'll do ya! 😎
I am more of a Vitalis man.
Who checks if the contestants are still alive? I do for some strange reason.
I always have another window open to check! Hahahahaha
John loves to lead them " down the primrose path ."
I want to fly on one of these DC-7 flagships.
I did, and you don't.
Wow !!! - It's Tony Dinozzo's dad !!!
Love me some Wagner
That teacher certainly wasn't Miss Landers (the teacher from Leave it to Beaver).
The woman who played Miss Landers was an attractive woman.
+John Miller
Agreed. And I think "The Beave" had a crush on her for some time, and was heartbroken when she got married.
I thought Beaver's teachers ( the young ladies ) were both quite good looking
Robert Wagner over 6 foot? Um, no.
Officially 5'11" tall, or at least he was supposed to have been at one point. I think he was, judging by how he looked standing next to John Daly and Bennett Cerf, both of whom were 6'1" tall . But definitely not over 6 feet tall. Nothing wrong with 5'11" -- tall enough.
Why were the panelists allowed only one question each in the first game? The contestants weren't technically the "mystery guest".
Mrs. Targove looks a lot like Bette Middler
There’s a conceit about Wagner that kind of obscures his good looks.
He's forever painted as a shadowy figure due to you know what. This episode would have been funnier.
Yep he gives off that insufferable vibe.
I thought WML had the mayor of NY. He would have go booed for not doing enough to save 2 NYC baseball clubs..
Little did Wagner know he would be the father of Tony DiNozo, years later..
Really?
Nice hairstyle there Miss Targove. LOL.