Deported from the USA | DW Documentary
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 июл 2024
- Married, a house, two kids, good jobs: the Escobars led a model life. Then Trump’s immigration policy took effect and José was deported. He had come to the United States as an undocumented minor. Now Rose is fighting to bring her husband back home.
Life without José isn’t easy. Rose has become the sole provider for her family. But she’s doing everything she can to bring her husband back home. He’s been deported to El Salvador, the country he fled years ago, because he saw no future for himself there. In the United States, he had become a model citizen. Now, his children only ever see him on Skype. But Rose has saved up enough money to pay for a trip to El Salvador. We accompany the family to this special reunion. A report by Oliver Sallet.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch high-class documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to DW Documentary:
/ @dwdocumentary
Our other RUclips channels:
DW Documental (in spanish): / dwdocumental
DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو: (in arabic): / dwdocarabia
For more documentaries visit also:
www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Instagram
/ dwdocumentary
Facebook:
/ dw.stories
DW netiquette policy: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
UPDATE: Houston , July 1, 2019 -- A 33-year-old father of two American-born children was allowed to return to the U.S. on Monday, two years after being deported to El Salvador during the first months of the Trump administration.
Jose Escobar was welcomed at Houston's Bush Intercontinental Airport by a group of supporters. He was accompanied by his wife, Rose, and their two children, Walter and Carmen, who had flown to El Salvador in June to visit him. They were in El Salvador when they got word that U.S. immigration authorities had approved waivers that would let him to return to the U.S. legally.
Congratulations to ESCOBAR family, mis paisanos, and to Rep. Al Green who fought DILIGENTLY for the reunification of this Beautyful family 👏👏👏
Thanks very much Ramni. DW correspondent Oliver Sallet has also confirmed Jose Escobar has returned to the USA.
Sallet has just told us the process to see Jose return to the USA had been going for a while "but it came as a big surprise for the family that it happened so quick. Essentially, they were able to take him back from the family vacation in El Salvador."
@@DWDocumentary woah I'm delightfully surprised that you guys actually read my comment ✌✌
@Eric Beller 😂😂😂 oh, so that's the secret, than✌lol.
But why? Just bullied your way into America. What about the thousands upon thousands waiting and doing it the proper way? I think if your allowed back to U.s. you should pay restitution for the legal immigrants doing it the right way. Hopefully that extends all the way to your older years of retirement
Getting married, having kids, and buying a house does not exempt anyone from the laws of the US !
There have been immigration amnesties in the US in comparable situations, which would be a sensible way to deal with well integrated, undocumented immigrants.
Also, your immigration laws suck for a whole host of reasons, which is part of the problem.
THIS GOOD NEWS WILL HURT YOUR RACIST PRIDE..Houston -- A 33-year-old father of two American-born children was allowed to return to the U.S. on Monday, two years after being deported to El Salvador during the first months of the Trump administration.
Jose Escobar was welcomed at Houston's Bush Intercontinental Airport by a group of supporters. He was accompanied by his wife, Rose, and their two children, Walter and Carmen, who had flown to El Salvador in June to visit him. They were in El Salvador when they got word that U.S. immigration authorities had approved waivers that would let him to return to the U.S. legally.
@@shrinkhh79 The United States takes in the more immigrants than any other country in the world.
No apologies are due.
@@AQuietNightfascinating what rationalizations people come up with to justify the kind of pointless cruelty you see in the video. also, yeah but actually many smaller countries take in a higher number relative to their ppl size.
@@shrinkhh79 Sorry, not interested in proportions. Year after year we take in more people through
the legal immigration system than all other countries. Maybe the world should demand their home
countries do better so people do not have to flee. Fix the problem at the source.
The easiest way to avoid this trouble is to not illegally entry the US!
You say it like it’s that easy.
1747CT It's exactly that easy, nobody is forcing them to illegally entry this country
That's the easy way to dismiss a complex situation like a stupid person.
CatzHoek It's not complex at all, they have zero legal status in this country, nations have the right to determine who gets to be a citizen. Open borders lost in 2016 and it will lose again in 2020
Every nation protects its sovereignty - including enforcing its borders. Americans should decide who is allowed to come here and stay and under what conditions. We have a process for people to come here legally but those who violate our laws and circumvent the legal process should be removed. They basically feel like they can break the law and be granted the same rights and privileges as Americans. Sorry. They must go...
USC Title 8 §1325. Improper entry by alien
(a) Improper time or place; avoidance of examination or inspection; misrepresentation and concealment of facts
Any alien who (1) enters or attempts to enter the United States at any time or place other than as designated by immigration officers, or (2) eludes examination or inspection by immigration officers, or (3) attempts to enter or obtains entry to the United States by a willfully false or misleading representation or the willful concealment of a material fact, shall, for the first commission of any such offense, be fined under title 18 or imprisoned not more than 6 months, or both, and, for a subsequent commission of any such offense, be fined under title 18, or imprisoned not more than 2 years, or both.
(b) Improper time or place; civil penalties
Any alien who is apprehended while entering (or attempting to enter) the United States at a time or place other than as designated by immigration officers shall be subject to a civil penalty of-
(1) at least $50 and not more than $250 for each such entry (or attempted entry); or
(2) twice the amount specified in paragraph (1) in the case of an alien who has been previously subject to a civil penalty under this subsection.
Civil penalties under this subsection are in addition to, and not in lieu of, any criminal or other civil penalties that may be imposed.
The question is: why had she not applied for a green card for him? She is a US citizen, they've been married for 10+ years!
Answer, he is convicted felon.
@@khadrtrudeau1662
4:30 "he did not have a criminal record" lawyer
@@Yahia08 No criminal record in the USA. Other than border jumping. lying and false papers. What about El Salvador? Learn lawyer speak.
@@khadrtrudeau1662
Thanks. But, I had assumed that HIS parents carried him over the borders, made the fake papers, etc. He is a DACA recipient.
@@Yahia08 " He is a DACA recipient." DACA is a executive order issued by The Messiah. It ended when "The One" left office.Today Trump is trying to use it as a bargaining chip.
How old was he when he came to the US? Why didn’t he apply for resident status when he got married? Unanswered questions in this report.
He was around 15 when he came to the US, I think. There is another documentary with this same exact family floating around on YT.
Why didn't he apply for legal status in the first place? Citizens have rights and obligations. Non citizens do not. If Rose is a US citizen, why can't Rose now get her husband in legally? People do that all the time. Did he break the law? Is he a criminal? There is something they're not telling us
Because Latinos are pretty stupid in general they thought once they arrived in USA means they are Americans
No One is stopping this family from moving to El Salvador where Husband and Father is a citizen. This family chooses to separate children from their father.
x2 exactly!
Yes, she needs to go back.
@@ElectricalExistence You European Americans need to go back, your racism is disgusting.
@@dominicprovido8037 So. the democrats crying about family separation.. since.... Its no big deal to the illegals... who cares. Why don't they sacrifice to teach children to respect our laws instead of teaching them to be criminals.
dominic provido ok, then they made their bed and now they have to lie in it.
maybe they shouldn't come illegally
That statement makes you a racist.
Like how yall and your people did! lolll
Maybe just maybe they should man up and do what your forefathers did to the natives and get their land back!
@Eric Beller Watch DW U.S history
@@khadrtrudeau1662 since when is that racist?
always emotions, apply legally...
Cmon do not enter illegally any country and also if you really missed him why dont you follow him. You need to respect the law! Im also immigrant and entered the country legally.
Go home.and make your nation better.
@@Bechooch they need qualified peoppe.inntheir own nation, we don't need them.
" why dont you follow him. " She would lose the government handouts for those children. Probably $2K a month per child. F him.
@@Bechooch " qualified " As in criminal. Their is a reason he can't get a green card.
@@khadrtrudeau1662 Does it make you mad that they aren't lazy American degenerates that live off of welfare while their country is in ruins? 😂
Any country can't be invaded illegally, there are laws and rules to be followed. It is like someone invading your house. If someone does it should face the consequences.
In America we shoot people who break into our homes.
How about taking some social responsibility and not put yourself in the position of being deported from your family?? There are three ways... #1.Come LEGALLY in the first place.. Sounds simple huh.... But far too many abused this privilege to the point that our government had to close its borders #2.. If you are illegally here in the first place.. GO HOME and try it again only the second time do it LEGALLY.... As much as you hope to get in on the social benefits .. there are "finite limitations" to how many people this society can provide for.. This is one of the reasons our nation limits the number of people that can legally immigrate.. This is also one of the reasons our government can't provide for its own citizens like Seniors, Veterans, and the homeless #3.. And this is the most disciplined application.. Don't have children in the first place if you are here illegally... You are the one putting the children you CLAIM to love in that position.. not society or government
THE RULE OF LAW! NO ONE IS ABOVE IT & PLAYING VICTIM DOESNT CHANGE A THING.
I have watched numerous documentaries of undocumented people coming into the US and they constantly keep using the same woman has anyone else noticed that?
Obama had the same policy.
It's been around since 1997 when Bill Clinton signed it.
Well I was a legal immigrant H4 to be exact I was my father's dependent he had an H1B Visa and it took us 10 years to get our green card and another 5 years to get my citizenship 2 years ago...
@Heather Larson well I left the Philippines when I was 8 so I dont have a choice
@Swae Ocean I am thanks...
Welcome, thank you, God bless you!
you did it legally welcome
@Surt AndvettssonYou certainly don't belong in America. Nasty personality, low IQ.
He should have gotten a green card when he got here! He just buried his head in the sand!🤔😴
She knew he was here ILLEGALLY so no sympathy for either of them, quit putting all the blame on Pres. Trump ,Obama and Bush also did deportations... she can always go to live with him ,I know if it were my Husband I'd be with him.
One for all and all for one if one member of the family is deported then if the rest of the family cared they’d join them you break up your own families.
I am curious as to how Rose as a hospital receptionist could afford to keep paying the mortgage, bills, etc since she is now the sole provider? That house looks very expensive!
Well I don't think that she's secretly pole dancing if that"s what you're implying. There are some people for who you immediately suspect that of but she doesn't seem to be one.
@@heatherfeather9951 , I was surprised to read your comment and how you came to the conclusion I was implying she must be a "Pole Dancer"! That thought never crossed my mind! I am genuinely curious as to how she is making ends meet without downsizing to a smaller house which would have made more sense under the circumstances. I am going to go out on a limb and assume that since she lives in Houston and works at a hospital, she probably works at MD Anderson Hospital and they must pay a lot better than the average county hospital!
José is probably sending them money from Mexico
WELFARE AND CARTEL MONEY..
@@heatherfeather9951 🤣
Why didn't they all go ? Why only the dad
Birth right citizenship. Trump was supposed to challenge this.
@@khadrtrudeau1662 Daddy sold you out. Another puppet that you fell hook, line, and sinker for...
@@chownful The choice was Hilary. She promised to destroy the United States. Got 68 million votes.
@@khadrtrudeau1662 He did , but democrats are opposing him in full force, while advocating for Open Borders and human trafficking. Anti-american democrats are America's worst enemy.
@@chownful STFU, anti-american democrat!
What about the kids separated from their parents when they’re put in prison? You don’t feel sympathy for them?
Only if they are brown.
Why doesn't he try to get in legally? Apparently he's had years
He could have a criminal record in El Salvador or America.
Stay in El Salvador with your husband
She is a U.S. citizen. She has a right to live in the U.S.
STAY THERE WITH YOU'RE HUSBAND
He was allowed in the U.S to live with his family. Cry.
No one will feel sorry for criminals
Criminals will, unfortunately criminals get to vote too.
It depends, doesn't it?
Many "conservatives" seem to feel a lot of sympathy for a vile murderer of little girls like Eddie Gallagher or a thug like Joe Arpaio whom Trump pardoned.
I on the other hand think that a pardon for someone who is a valuable member of his community and has an American family a pardon may very well be considered.
@@ElectricalExistence there are more good people than criminals
America is closed......Americans have had enough.
No look Cubans in Miami and now. Venezuela 🇻🇪 people
Stay in your own country and make it great. Fight and protest the corruption.
Stay in your own country lol
So sad......not.
They don't respect our laws and therefore US why should WE respect THEM?
kris guntner Your President doesn’t respect the law and you seem to be ok with that, so what are you saying ?
@@eckhardtfrost3815 Only someone truly arrogant makes such assumptions.
I'm CANADIAN and WE have these "poor innocent" people illegally flooding into OUR country from the u.s.
@@krisguntner4805 Liberals / Democrats are uncapable of self respect. Let alone abiding by the law.
Awwww, I’m supposed to feel bad why? Not a citizen, so TFB. Send them all back.
You are racist and ignorant!
@@egakuro6145Break the law, pay the price. There is nothing to stop Rose bringing her husband in UNLESS he has a criminal record either in America or his home country.
A family torn apart? Who's fault is that? What happened to their marriage vows: "Till death do you part?" I guess in their case a clause was added: "Unless you get deported."
Rose your Jose is never coming back to the U.S so get use to it..Idea move to El Salvador.
WHY WAS HE PICKED UP HE BROKE THE LAW
Send them packing.
"so he could come home" ?? Trump sent him home, to El Salvador.
Why is this news now since this has been going for years, even when Obama, Bush, and Bill Clinton were in office
America is a country built on laws .
He was a bum then and he is a bum now
Happy for you and your family. GOD BLESS!!
*You have to go back*
This congressman shouldn't even be in office he cares more about illegals than he does Americans .
It shows where his loyalty lies
I work in the deportation system in my country and I‘m very proud of it.
I heard a story of someone who was deported from Mexico to the US, truly tragic
I gotta admit she loved him but she she didn’t think of him when I was there
i cried during this cuz my gf may get sent away but i laughed at this
Hey rose tell him all about us when he was over there
good.
Marry legally.. Stay legally...
Don't come here. Problem solved.
any updates?
Do this illegal border jumping in Africa, and they keep you in jail for 20 years with hard labour, before they deport you! You Yanks are stupid!!!
It’s sad, but there’s laws, rules that are there for a reason. When you break these laws there are punishments. Rose could go live with him, there’s no rules again that. Don’t have. IMO 🙏😐
Here's the deal Donald Trump is so feebleminded physically inadequate that he gets pleasure out of causing this type of heart ache. I can't help but wonder if the fact that he is submissive subservient is genetic hereditary or simple generic learned behavior. Either way it is physically mentally spiritually useless to freely live and die in such a low quality manner. It is quite possible Trump is a combination of those two different worst-case scenarios. For he shows no appreciation towards the descendents of great ancient civilized nations. And he knows this. So in a attempt to compensate for this low ranking status his plan is to keep the mass majority overworked underpaid soft lazy out of shape over Fed under nourished with dirty low-paying jobs. At the same time making every situation as bad as he can for those who are already facing extreme challenges physically mentally financially socially emotionally. Now a dominant gentleman or lady that demonstrates high class sophistication which is a form of femininity at its finest. Knows the best way to stay on the top, is by keeping the bottom confidently rising in the most efficient way that is humanly possible for that type of leadership loyalty devotion will naturally allow each person's generation to become stronger smarter healthier happier better off physically mentally financially possibly spiritually then the previous generation. Opposed to what we have today people living dying having only used the smallest percentage of a fraction of the true potential they were first born with. Now thinks to dirty low-paying jobs messing up the fundamentals from coast-to-coast globally people are dying off to a diminished quality of life compared to the great ancient civilized nations. To my surprise even prehistoric people got a better spiritual kickback for their life than today's people. Especially today's American.
He was allowed to return to the USA on July 1 2019.
Houston -- A 33-year-old father of two American-born children was allowed to return to the U.S. on Monday, two years after being deported to El Salvador during the first months of the Trump administration.
Jose Escobar was welcomed at Houston's Bush Intercontinental Airport by a group of supporters. He was accompanied by his wife, Rose, and their two children, Walter and Carmen, who had flown to El Salvador in June to visit him. They were in El Salvador when they got word that U.S. immigration authorities had approved waivers that would let him to return to the U.S. legally.
Ramni Kings I don’t kiss my parents, freak!!
Atleast he get to talk to them, I cant talk to anybody
Murica 🇺🇸
All I Like is couples' HAIR .
Are we just gonna ignore that lady holding stuff with her head
Yo Jose I’m gonna talk to immigration officials so they can leave you in El Salvador so I can go take care of rose
He o ready came back to USA. He is happy 🙏🙏
I was Deported I made a video about it
Can't he migrate to the us legally?
Shouldnt the wife/mom be deported as well??
She is a citizen
@@howard19681 who cares, she was aiding and abetting an illegal for years, she doesnt deserve to be here either. Shes literally trying to help destroy America. She has to go.
@@ElectricalExistence idgaf
@@howard19681 if you dont care than you can get out too.
why not asking CITIZEN SHIP?
SEND THOSE ANCHORS TOO...
Living on stolen land talking a big game smh
He ain't missing. No he ain't.
He's where he belongs
LOCK THEM ALL UP!!!
Thats what the law should be
@@ElectricalExistence Agreed.
No one forced him to jump our borders, he deserved to be deported. Trump didn't break up his family, he did this to himself. If he had stayed in El Salvador his family would not have been broken up. He is responsible for his own actions.
The law is the law. Illegal is illegal the law doesnt have a sympathy clause. Just follow the laws and you wont have to be "in that situation ".
It all comes down to the culture of the country - the US (and I don't mean all Americans) has this thing about returning people no matter the circumstance. It's a process-driven, unemotional approach. Other countries would have selected a date and from that date moving forward, this is the process and that's it. Everyone else prior to the date, you're good because we have a heart and don't want to split up families, etc. For those who don't agree, I suggest that the Native Americans send everyone in the US who are not indigenous back to their mother country LOL. Exactly.
Tribesmen don't rule America , you naive democrat. And they didn't create America by the way. They fought a war and lost, deal with it.
ESCOBAR PABLOS BROTHER
that kid goes to my school
This guy is a criminal
Why she wants to remain in America with 2 kids WITHOUT HER HUSBAND THEIR FATHER is beyond words.. SHE DESERVES THE KARMA OF HAVING NO HUSBAND OR FATHER THERE.. A DIVORCE IS LOOMING☝🏿💯
I feel pity for the children
They deserve a lot worse
Why didn't the man try to legalize himself by getting a greencard through marriage? Is the woman an illegal alien as well?
The wife is legal but other people thought he was just marrying her for papers. He never asked for papers, but eventually when Trump got into office, it was far too late to get it handled.
@@TheReviewSpace I just don't buy that story. I think they decided that blowing their money on booze is more important than paying for the immigration filing fees. Hey at the end you always have Trump to blame for.
I'm from Argentina and I reside in the US undocumented. It's very hard and difficult because with this title comes alot of stigma that creates an intense hostile environment for us at times. But there are also great things here, this is why I started my immigration process after 35 years. I understand both sides and I have created a platform for those like me in order to break the stereotype as well as to advocate about doing things right if possible
who cares....
Bye bye Jose
A happy story to me
Get a real LAWYER!!!
Illegals gotta go b
Human tragedy by inhumanitarian policies
good propaganda!!!
The guy's son is going to become a member of the Border Patrol. He will want to catch his dad.
Having empathy is what makes us human. There are no humans in this comment section, only angry bots🤖🤖🤖
Take your empathy and invite a total stranger into your house. Let me know if your empathy saves you.
@@leskobrandon6950 Anti-american democrats advocating for third world foreigners before their own people. It can't get more treasonous than this.
America the Cruel.
This comment section shows just how egoistic, cruel and hearthless north americans can be.
This is how all normal feel about their homes. E.g. Mexicans don’t like illegal immigration to Mexico (you can ask and they’ll tell you), but they like illegal immigration to the US because 1) they benefit from it 2) they don’t give a fuck about the US. It’s not really their country so they’ll just take what they can get. That’s the most genuine egoism there is.
@@MortezaFC dont bother to explain... she s not gonna be able to understand that...
It’s disgusting to break up families like that. Other countries don’t rip parents away from children. It’s not his fault that he entered the US illegally and now he has 2 kids that depend on him. I’m glad they got to reunite.
It’s USA s fault should have kids citizenship even they were born in us That way they ll all b deported won’t be apart.
Great Doku 👍 Now its time to read the comments from triggered conservatives.
Predictably, basement-dwelling Trump worshippers have nothing to offer but the same old legalistic talking point and the occasional "shoot them!".
I thank you for uploading this video and for showing the story of what it’s like to lose a family member to an ignorant president like trump. God Bless you and now with the new president of El Salvador it will change. Glad to be Salvadoran.
BUSH AND OBAMA DID THE SAME THING, AND IF YOU CHECK YOU'LL SEE BIDEN WAS ALL FOR DEPORTATION!