如果香港想善用Lyman，應該係香港呢個市場去expand演藝行業同廣納才能，而唔係本末倒置，諗點塞入「跳唱青春偶像」框架。Lyman今集講「唔知點樣既表演先會被香港接受」，聽到心痛😢😢好想同Lyman講：如果你覺得自己想做既performing arts「好似not fitting in」，可能意味住 you are bringing something new and unique to this city 🔥以往《造星》通常只有「班素人真係未夠水平」既問題，而唔係調返轉，「出現一位已超越比賽水平同流行類別既表演者，係咪仲應該用現有娛樂圈框框去evaluate」既情況。幾場完全唔同氣質既表演已經證明Lyman係「以跳舞同演技說故事既artist」，不只是跳緊個殼既dancer，練多少少中文，話唔定可以喺香港帶起舞台劇 / 音樂劇 as 電視節目既潮流 (我會想睇囉！) 講遠少少，香港如果想同亞洲其他文化市場睇齊，唔應該只係「抄」，而係應該廣納才能，然後睇下點樣撞出獨特質地既文化產物。楊紫瓊都係當年黎左香港先發展成第一打女，演藝路 is full of surprises and being different is part of the path. Lyman 加油，believe in yourself and your imperfections. Beyond this one TV contest, there are many HK audience who would appreciate you. 期待你 lead 香港史上第一齣廣東話版Hamilton (or any drama) 🔥🔥🔥
睇到訪問先知Lyman有咁大壓力😢，之前宣佈賽果都見到Lyman好淡定，但講真面對一次又一次嘅落敗，的確會打沉自信心，仲會懷疑自己，我只想講之前嘅評判不屬於我，大家都見到你地嘅表演係精彩❤ 睇到呢個內心爭扎嘅Lyman，最尾spotlight 打落黎，得返Lyman一個人，件白色西裝外套有一邊掉落黎，看似唔齊整，但又為呢個表演，增添幾分凌亂，更加突顯出內心嘅忐忑不安、焦慮、疑惑，有好多不安嘅情緒，其實唔只Lyman，好多大人都慣左將自己負面情緒收埋，唔想人地擔心，如果自己處理唔到就爆煲啦😢好多謝Lyman願意向觀眾展示呢一面，作為觀眾嘅我睇完之後都有好多感受❤ 好欣賞Lyman答點解唔唱歌個part，與其不斷猜度評審想要啲咩，鍾意點樣嘅表演而去迎合佢哋，倒不如聽從內心嘅意向，做回最原始嘅Lyman❤❤❤ 另外，要俾返creadit Cho Lewis , 今次個改編好正啊！循序漸進，音樂一入個激昴位，配合埋隻舞，真係成個人投入哂個表演，多謝你呀！❤❤❤
Lyman is so charm even not presenting a charming outlook in this piece! Very impressed by all your performances! All look different but you did really good! Support you to be the champion!
Hey Lyman🍇, Don’t know if you can see this comment, but I just wanna thank you for bringing yourself into Hong Kong. As a theatre kid who love singing and watching performing arts. You have no idea how glad I am to see that someone like you introducing this kind of performances into the mainstream (I’ve watched all of your performances in the show and I love them!). You really are a talented and sincere artist, please stay true to yourself and keep on doing what you feel right. I’m sure in no time you’ll be seen and appreciated by many more people! Grape seed 🍇 (Apologies for my English if I’ve made any mistakes, it’s not my first language🙈)
Seeing Lyman's growth from the beginning with his bright smile and personality to the uncertainty he expresses in the recent interview is really saddening. :( Just really appreciate him for being a giver and always giving his best in all his performances! We all see it as the audience! And really agree that rather than trying to find approval and trying to fit in, in a change of perspective, he's actually bringing something new to the hk audience and opening up untouched grounds in the hk entertainment industry (which explains why there's such a struggle and difficulty). A very touching piece here, so thank you Lyman for not giving up and still giving your all in this competition! 加油呀! ❤🔥
Lyman, you are a brillant shining star❤😊. I totally agree with you in your interview, no one has any idea in this competition about the criteria in judging each performance. It’s all depends on the judges’ personal preferences at that moment. 😢
評判的提問都不完全挑機，可當作比貼士，10強戰或者試吓跳唱，例如用師兄們那首Rumours-全英文+Rap跳唱元素，怎樣呈現香印版本重編這首團歌，置身當中做C位怎樣跳唱，Rap. 展現香印式solo，不同新的面向。純舉例，不一定用尼首歌-原版12人不夠好。亦不是做什麼X X 2.0! 唱歌未必輸，唱歌較好參賽者都無留低。
有一位評審話你唔唱歌… 真係好笑…. Lyman please be persistent on what you believe is right for you. Showcasing your strength and expressing your believes can be in many forms. I hope you won’t become a member of 男團… but the HK market is so superficial. You need a bigger stage.
Lyman 咁多個表演，沒有一個重覆，他膽地挑戰香港觀眾習慣的魚蛋文化，提昇大家的藝術水平，你做到了，多謝你Lyman 👍
當你好放咁去表演，啲人就叫你要收斂啲；當你好乖咁收斂時，啲人又話你唔夠open；當你以高超技巧完成比賽，啲人又話你缺乏感情；當你好有感情咁跳舞，啲人又問你點解唔唱歌；相信我，當Lyman真係唱歌，啲人又會問佢點解唔做自己最擅長嘅跳舞！所以呢，評判幾易做，導師幾易做呢，隨便up下就叫比意見，聽完呢啲所謂評語，想唔迷失都幾難，如果內心唔夠強大，真係人都癲！
造星啲評判不嬲都亂嚟，由造星1已經係咁😂😂😂
搵嘢講來證明自己用評判有料
其實有些人也只唱不跳啦，有些人也只rap 不唱，根本冇問題
超級認同
@@MikTes111最經典係個評判問參賽者點解個名叫Oscar咁普通, 咁都講得出口真係佢唔尷尬睇嘅都覺得尷尬
如果香港想善用Lyman，應該係香港呢個市場去expand演藝行業同廣納才能，而唔係本末倒置，諗點塞入「跳唱青春偶像」框架。Lyman今集講「唔知點樣既表演先會被香港接受」，聽到心痛😢😢好想同Lyman講：如果你覺得自己想做既performing arts「好似not fitting in」，可能意味住 you are bringing something new and unique to this city 🔥以往《造星》通常只有「班素人真係未夠水平」既問題，而唔係調返轉，「出現一位已超越比賽水平同流行類別既表演者，係咪仲應該用現有娛樂圈框框去evaluate」既情況。幾場完全唔同氣質既表演已經證明Lyman係「以跳舞同演技說故事既artist」，不只是跳緊個殼既dancer，練多少少中文，話唔定可以喺香港帶起舞台劇 / 音樂劇 as 電視節目既潮流 (我會想睇囉！)
講遠少少，香港如果想同亞洲其他文化市場睇齊，唔應該只係「抄」，而係應該廣納才能，然後睇下點樣撞出獨特質地既文化產物。楊紫瓊都係當年黎左香港先發展成第一打女，演藝路 is full of surprises and being different is part of the path.
Lyman 加油，believe in yourself and your imperfections. Beyond this one TV contest, there are many HK audience who would appreciate you. 期待你 lead 香港史上第一齣廣東話版Hamilton (or any drama) 🔥🔥🔥
造星2都有oscar跳contemporary, 但造星2個時未接受到呢類舞台表演。真係阿祖帶起左。
加埋oscar個種藝術性未做到雅俗共賞, Lyman由99強跳latin, 已經唔係傳統latin, 出神入化, 完全兩種層次。
幾季都有人唱musical/ opera入到圍, 但就跳唔出個框框, 美國James Cordon都係唱opera出身, 但佢用到種技巧去pop music 唱carpool karaoke, 又帶到musical 入流行文化。呢D真係游刃有餘
你說得真對，香港暫時仍未有如Lyman這個層次的藝術表演者，但可惜的是目前表演界仍然由一些老海鮮們佔據著，這些人未必會接受新事物，故此Lyman才會有這種擔憂．。但請Lyman不要氣餒，你的表演已經超越所有的人，懂得欣賞和珍惜你的觀眾只會越來越多，加油呀！香港真的需要你來帶動一個全新和更高層次的表演藝術！❤❤❤
@@chanchanchu4630 其實佢咁多場表演我覺得算連接藝術同主流(冇足夠技術基礎同star quality係好難的)，睇返佢跳男團式”Shhhhh…”同外國真係唔算另類嘅雌雄同體”B.A.D.”表演，我又唔會覺得Lyman只跳high art contemporary或者傳統拉丁，可能只係呢一集嘅舞種先比較令人聯想Oscar?
暫時嚟講，我覺得Lyman可塑性係高，可跳可演，綜藝都可以（特別係做關於中英語言文化差異笑位嘅節目）。
@CalodyMusic 之前有幾場表演都有contemporary 元素
B.A.D.係外國係唔算另類，就算musical 都算係主流
但香港唱Musical 就唔算主流
都唔止Oscar, 往屆都有參賽者係跳拉丁舞，佢地就真係傳統拉丁搬上台，當年tigar 都係咁。但就咁跳Latin 感覺唔似舞台表演。
Lyman 呢方面做得好好。
我覺得Lyman 演出的造星作品都是恰到好處，沒有用過多力度去演，Lyman 請你不要氣餒，香港觀眾是喜歡你的表演。希望你可以造星V後成功出道。我們期待看你更多的作品，無論是唱歌、跳舞、男團、甚至是演員。加油🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻
香港觀眾多謝你，多謝你
睇到Lyman內心真緻高質演出，佢吡最誠意的演出給我們，唔係我地要睇乜嘢。好開心Lyman 打開香港演藝市場另一度門，相信香港能容納雅俗共賞的表演，只是舊有的市場思維太注重利益而忽略了心靈養份的重要
Lyman 有種吸力.
表情收放自如，舉手投足都係充滿張力，非常坦白嘅作品，演出令人動容
音樂劇和舞台劇會好適合你! 💙😎 You a superstar! 🌟
lyman係可以自己搞團 做音樂劇 舞台劇 藝術表演
今年造星5真係太好睇啦👏👏👏
雖然viutv 宣傳又唔多，真係全靠今年參賽者嘅高素質＆努力， 至於Lyman 真係好正，每次演出都係好perfect 👏👏👏希望viutv 唔好淨係識利用班參賽者啦！
Lyman❤You are Star🌟!Bravo! 你是屬於舞台!藝術感滿分💯! 靚仔!人品好!表情豐富!有內涵,高貴,藝術氣質!Amazing!可以投資開個舞台劇,主角是Lyman,或開香港版電影 ’舞出真我Step Up’Movie
我都有諗過呀，Lady Gaga果套a star is born都好正，雖然唔係真係lady gaga的故事，但完全係為她度身訂造，超正呀！
現時 dancers 係一直被忽視，但其實觀眾係會欣賞舞蹈。當MV出咗之後，我哋都強烈要求有DV, 即係話跳舞係有市場嘅。 Mirror 嘅所謂下弦，個個都跳舞好叻，唱歌冇咁叻，其實ViuTV 係可以同佢哋，製作舞蹈表演嘅RUclips videos, 冇需要佢哋唱歌， 粉絲都一樣會loop dance videos. 希望 Lyman 嘅出現，會改變 ViuTV 只重視唱歌，忽視跳舞嘅心態。
你嘅表演實在超班
睇到訪問先知Lyman有咁大壓力😢，之前宣佈賽果都見到Lyman好淡定，但講真面對一次又一次嘅落敗，的確會打沉自信心，仲會懷疑自己，我只想講之前嘅評判不屬於我，大家都見到你地嘅表演係精彩❤
睇到呢個內心爭扎嘅Lyman，最尾spotlight 打落黎，得返Lyman一個人，件白色西裝外套有一邊掉落黎，看似唔齊整，但又為呢個表演，增添幾分凌亂，更加突顯出內心嘅忐忑不安、焦慮、疑惑，有好多不安嘅情緒，其實唔只Lyman，好多大人都慣左將自己負面情緒收埋，唔想人地擔心，如果自己處理唔到就爆煲啦😢好多謝Lyman願意向觀眾展示呢一面，作為觀眾嘅我睇完之後都有好多感受❤
好欣賞Lyman答點解唔唱歌個part，與其不斷猜度評審想要啲咩，鍾意點樣嘅表演而去迎合佢哋，倒不如聽從內心嘅意向，做回最原始嘅Lyman❤❤❤
另外，要俾返creadit Cho Lewis , 今次個改編好正啊！循序漸進，音樂一入個激昴位，配合埋隻舞，真係成個人投入哂個表演，多謝你呀！❤❤❤
每集都不其然只注視你😂
That’s true. 就算唔係佢表演都會搵佢坐咗喺邊, totally 入哂坑
有佢份表演嘅片我都睇咗超過30次...每次都好努力想「睇埋」其他人，但係最後都淨係睇到佢😹
Lyman 🎉❤
你能夠面對自己內心，表演好好，好有個性，歌曲改編版好正，令造星更加精彩，多謝Lyman！好期待再睇你表演❣️
Lyman令個比賽層次升級咗！已經再唔係啲咩韓仔丶mc模仿大賽
Lyman is so charm even not presenting a charming outlook in this piece! Very impressed by all your performances! All look different but you did really good! Support you to be the champion!
Hey Lyman🍇,
Don’t know if you can see this comment, but I just wanna thank you for bringing yourself into Hong Kong.
As a theatre kid who love singing and watching performing arts. You have no idea how glad I am to see that someone like you introducing this kind of performances into the mainstream (I’ve watched all of your performances in the show and I love them!).
You really are a talented and sincere artist, please stay true to yourself and keep on doing what you feel right. I’m sure in no time you’ll be seen and appreciated by many more people!
Grape seed 🍇
(Apologies for my English if I’ve made any mistakes, it’s not my first language🙈)
Seeing Lyman's growth from the beginning with his bright smile and personality to the uncertainty he expresses in the recent interview is really saddening. :( Just really appreciate him for being a giver and always giving his best in all his performances! We all see it as the audience! And really agree that rather than trying to find approval and trying to fit in, in a change of perspective, he's actually bringing something new to the hk audience and opening up untouched grounds in the hk entertainment industry (which explains why there's such a struggle and difficulty). A very touching piece here, so thank you Lyman for not giving up and still giving your all in this competition! 加油呀! ❤🔥
"It's OK not to be OK!"
Lyman, thank you for your master piece!
Lyman is a real artist！！！
Lyman 表演超曬班
His performance is level up audience taste at the same time. Not only just promote young, handsome face......Lyman performance is piece of art.
造星2都有oscar跳contemporary, 但造星2個時未接受到呢類舞台表演。真係阿祖帶起左。觀眾都有進步既
加埋oscar個種藝術性未做到雅俗共賞, Lyman由99強跳latin, 已經唔係傳統latin, 出神入化, 完全兩種層次。
幾季都有人唱musical/ opera入到圍, 但就跳唔出個框框, 美國James Cordon都係唱opera出身, 但佢用到種技巧去pop music 唱carpool karaoke, 又帶到musical 入流行文化。呢D真係游刃有餘
佢已經係星
返嚟開個master class 教行內D人都仲得
勁過哂D導師 - 隨隊百老𣾀，又贏咁多比賽
又talk 得又跳得又靚仔又最佳老師
鏡仔有勁敵
Charm❤❤呢d先叫charm.
Lyman齋跳舞已經好吸引, 一樣表達到message🙌🏻🙌🏻
Lyman, you are a brillant shining star❤😊.
I totally agree with you in your interview, no one has any idea in this competition about the criteria in judging each performance. It’s all depends on the judges’ personal preferences at that moment. 😢
Lyman 表演好精彩，我又要loop 好多次睇❤️❤️❤️
He is super star. Love to see his performance.
the level of artistry damn (exceeds this TV show) respect
real performer. will he become an international star?
Thank you Lyman. Be yourself! ❤
Excellent!just Lyman can dancing like this
🎉🎉🎉勁呀
謝謝❣️
Lyman, it's a great great great performance!!! love it love it love it!!!!
Lyman,voted for you❤
enjoy yr show on 7／16
You shine, Lyman.
Lyman❤
會投Lyman一票
❤❤
It‘s an art piece！Those we might see in Apa.
So touching! Great performance!
❤❤❤❤❤跳得太好❤❤❤❤❤
Hey! ViuTV, 舞蹈和音樂不只是盲目跟隨流行文化去做一些Rap 和HipHop，去把觀眾都擠到滯晒！然後感到厭倦和捨棄！舞蹈表演藝術其實可以更高更好睇！Don’t just follow your bias to judge!
真係收放自如
👍👍👍👍👍❤️😘
bro wth i dun usu watch these shows but this is actually amazing 睇好佢
估唔到佢會跳contemporary, 以為佢會跳latin風格既舞
但又跳得好
心水❤
好好睇
Can @Viu share the rehearsal full stage performance, really want to watch the whole stage to feel the tension and watch the whole design!
評判的提問都不完全挑機，可當作比貼士，10強戰或者試吓跳唱，例如用師兄們那首Rumours-全英文+Rap跳唱元素，怎樣呈現香印版本重編這首團歌，置身當中做C位怎樣跳唱，Rap. 展現香印式solo，不同新的面向。純舉例，不一定用尼首歌-原版12人不夠好。亦不是做什麼X X 2.0! 唱歌未必輸，唱歌較好參賽者都無留低。
有一位評審話你唔唱歌… 真係好笑…. Lyman please be persistent on what you believe is right for you. Showcasing your strength and expressing your believes can be in many forms. I hope you won’t become a member of 男團… but the HK market is so superficial. You need a bigger stage.
本人覺得Lyman的級數是高過某些評判，睇到都覺得尷尬。😅
無睇哂造星5，就咁睇個表演覺得佢有啲似造星2 Oscar Li果個vibe，藝術家氣質。但香港娛樂圈文化容吾容納到佢真係好難講，香港大眾樂迷品味太狹窄。其實造星2同造星3都有啲好正嘅artist 出咗道都未紅到，anyway good luck to him
已經over 總決賽水準
佢不如去参加哥哥节目，大把机会发挥😄
呢啲舞原來都幾好睇，不過都係有啲唔慣
個人鍾意由1:49呢度開始啲舞步，好好睇呀有美感，唔只睇上身係連同下身、全身嘅動作一齊睇，而且下下食beats (Lyman's dance musicality超強)👍表情都可以睇埋，慢慢一格格一格格用眼用耳朵去欣賞個performance再去解構背後想表達嘅內容，唔係就咁速食
請埋啲未夠水平嘅人去做評判、導師，唉