There was a patriots writer whose name is Mike Giardi who said all offseason that team was bad during training camp and was gonna be bad and got roasted for it
He wasn’t the only one. The guys on First Things First thought the Pats had a talent depleted roster and were gonna be bad this year. But idk if anyone thought they would be this bad. Similar to Sean Payton, it looks like the Pats players are quitting on Bill because they don’t like his old school coaching style.
EXACTLY! he has a below .500 record without brady as well. I'm not a brady fan I'll give him his flowers for the career he had. That being said he made Bill better. It's hard to argue against it
@@officialchoccypophe’s the one that went out and chose to sign those players, Kraft just signs the checks. Belichick isn’t signing anyone he doesn’t want on his team.
@@vitorpeck4458there’s a salary cap that Bill is also in charge of managing. That way no team can truly go out and just sign anyone at any price without some type of consequence. The Rams are paying the consequence these last few years. They won that one Super Bowl and overpaid a ton of players, most of whom are no longer on the team at all. BB has never done that to the extent the Rams did (or with the level of talent the Rams had had) but he still wound up having a team this bad anyway.
I like what Joy said because it’s true while Bill didn’t have a GM for so long it was known that he and Brady went back on forth on a lot. Especially game planning. I recall from one of the documentaries that they would be doing that for a cool minute all the time.
I'm a patriots fan and I'm honestly to the point that I feel sorry for BB. I'm not mad. I'm not frustrated. I legitimately feel bad for the man because he is deconstructing his own legacy.
I hear exactly what you're saying. Bill is a different dude given his background. He was raised differently than the culture around the current time's. I never saw him as a narcissist, more of a hardliner and business comes first and don't rest on your laurels approach. Obviously he's not of the fame type so it comes off differently with him. As of the last few year's he's struggled though.
Yet he wasn’t taken until the 6th round by Belichick who won the first three Super Bowls with Tom Brady being a game manager while winning with defense and special teams
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m Stop lying. No GAME MANAGER HAS THREE GAME WINNING DRIVES IN THREE SUPER BOWLS! None. Peyton Manning doesn't have THREE GAME WINNING DRIVES in his WHOLE PLAYOFF CAREER. Brady did that as "game manager" even though LITERALLY NO QB in history, even Mahomes, has THREE game winning drives in his first THREE Super Bowls and racked up more 4th quarter comebacks in the playoffs his first 4 seasons as a starter than Manning and Brees did in their entire playoff CAREERS. Brady threw for 350+ yards, 3tds, a 4th Q comeback and the GW Drive in the 2003 Superbowl vs a top 10 defense in Carolina while his defense pooped the bed giving up 30 points to Delhomme. He LED the NFL in TD Passes in 2002 without a single pro bowl or all pro pass catcher. NO QB IN NFL HISTORY has ever done that post- NFL-AFL Merger. You guys just hate the GOAT. He MADE Belichick. Bill is CRIMINALLY OVERRATED.
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m1. Brady was never a game manager. Both defense and offense of the 2001 Oats was exact same in rankings escept the offense had no weapons. 2. Yes he was a 6th round pick. Draft mistakes happen all the time. Scrubs like Trey Lance go 3 overall
I say this for almost 4 years now, Bellichick is no more than an over-glorified Defensive coordinator,... his strength was on defense yes, but on offense and offensive drafting he is so bad, for 2 decades he had the privilege of having the greatest Quarterback ever in Tom Brady that could over and over again cover his mistake, took a mostly mid player and raise them to be the best that they could be
I think Joy Taylor said it the best here. He is the gm and a coach. In the past, it worked. But now the game has changed, and you don't have those key inputs anymore. The system that worked for 20 years is broken. The only one to blame is BB himself at this point. Not that he's a horrible coach or whatever people want to say about him. But he's trying to do too much by himself at this point. Props to Joy cause honestly on this panel it's like she's the only one who has a reasonable take on this.
Same thing happened to Tom Landry. Was great for a long time, Staubach retires then went through purgatory in the 80s until Jerry bought the Cowboys and put Landry out of his misery.
Since i became a football fan (NYG) the Patriots were always the top dogs, best of the best, like Joy said "for 20 YRS" Even when other teams won it, they were still in the mix. The game HAS changed, but Bills style hasn't. Doesn't work anymore.
It took Brady maximum 3 years to become a Top 3 QB. In 2002 he led the league in TDs and in 2003 he was runner-up for the MVP. Then from 2006 onward, with the exception of a season or two, he's been playing at an MVP level pretty much every year. On top of that, Brady mostly credited the mindset and work ethic he got from college and Charlie Weiss (his OC at the time) for his development. I say this because people give Belichick too much credit when it comes to Brady's development; Belichick is not great offensively
Reminder: All 3 SB's that Tom Brady lost were due to the New England defense. Yes, even the Eagles loss, because Brady threw for 500 yards. Malcolm Butler only missed 2 games that season too - once at the beginning of the season and the SB. Conveniently enough, those were the only 2 games where NE had given up 40+ points 👀
Didn’t Tom Brady have the football last in the Super Bowl vs the Eagles? Plus didn’t they win the Super Bowl the next year with Tom Brady throwing a pick and Belichick defense holding the Rams offense to 3 points?
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m Goff sucks. Goff would've lost to the Chiefs if BRADY DIDNT PUT UP 30+ POINTS against the Chiefs while his DEFENSE was giving up a point per minute in the 2nd half (gave up like 30 points in the 2nd half). Brady WON the Super Bowl in 2018 - it was called the 2018 AFCCG. Brady won SIX SBs on SIX GAME WINNING DRIVES. Six. That's crazy.
Reminder: EVERY Superbowl that Tom Brady won had a controversial call that got ruled in his favor. The tuck rule raiders playoff game ring a bell? He NEVER without a controversial call/multiple controversial calls. The same thing is happening with Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs. They mostly win because of outrageous calls that get ruled in their favor in crucial moments. I'm a pats fan, but I'm calling it for what it is. AT LEAST 80 percent of Brady's career was the refs...
Belichick has never been as good as so many has said. Before Brady he was average, after Brady he's average at best. You can argue about this if you want just look up his record. When he was with the Giants as their DC he had LT and they won a lot.
He won Super Bowl as a Defensive Coordinator, plus when he was head coach with the Browns he won them their first playoff win in 1996 then he won the first 3 super bowls when Tom Brady was a game manager
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m1. Brady was never a game manager. Watch the tape not the stats 2. He failed the Browns. They made 3 AFC Champiomship games just before he got there. Ran them to the ground 3. Me and you could have coached those Giants defenses to do something. They were that stacked.
Tom Brady NEVER won without a controversial/multiple controversial calls getting ruled in his favor. The Superbowl he won with the Bucs had some of the most biased/sketchy officiating I've ever seen. Same thing with the NFC championship game against the Packers. Guess who benefited from all of the sketchy/biased officiating? Yep, Tom Brady and the Bucs.
I been saying it's not the Patriot's way but it was the Brady way. Them winning and now losing, what's the common denominator: Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr.! 🐐
But Belichick was a losing head coach in the early 1990s and then in 2000 year before Brady took over that was old school NfL he wast still a losing think it all just comes down with or without Brady with him and his entire coaching tree
@Mrtev215 but New England was winning with a bunch of #2's with Brady, he just made you have to cover everything. That what San Francisco does very well
@@mauricewells7838Brady was the coach on the field, a legitimate Field General , he allowed Belicheck to focus solely on DEFENSE , That was the Original Agreement per say; Brady commander on field on Offense with no name talent most of his career but would make OTHER GUYS TALENTED with his generalship commander way of taking the field and playing the game, remember Bill was spending those 1st rounders for yrs on the defense and couldn't draft a decent receiver to save his life 😅, but yes , he has fallen to down back to earth 🌎 he didn't properly prep this out and it's stinging him now , he should have made a big move a year ago in my estimation.
When you are a legend,an all time great.It’s hard to really tarnish your legend….initially.This is blight for Bill.If he would have just retired when Brady left(and I’m not saying he should have) it would have been way less damaging
Kraft needs to hire a real GM and not let Bellicheck pick any offensive skill players again ever. O lineman and defensive players yea he can pick them but WRs RBs TEs NO! But yea right now is ALL on Belicheck because he is the HC and the GM. No one else to blame. Buck stops with him. Kraft needs to fire Belicheck as the GM and hire a real one. And hire a DC to at least work with Belicheck.
How did all of the OC do when they didn't have TB12. Tom was the coach,GM, and OC. Players on offense and defense took less to play with TB12. He would put fear in the offensive players that didn't perform. For 20 years, Bill didn't have to work hard. Now this is reality. Bill is either rusty or tired. Either one isn't good.
There was a pass that Mahomes completed this weekend, that only he could have possibly completed; falling down, almost on his back 30+ yards down the field....catch! They win. Without those kinds of plays here and there, you have a great team, that becomes very average. That was Brady for all those years, in his own non-athletic way, as we know Brady is not Mahomes etc...but he more than made up for that with his other skills. Mac has almost nothing, or developed very little so far. It's actually quite incredible we're here.
@@VanquishedAgainRight, not to mention I’ve seen a lot of QBs make throws like Mahomes made a lot of other QBs have made the same plays or similar that Pat has made. The NFL just overhypes everything he does sometimes.
Yeah but at the same time BB out it on the Rams for two of those SuperBowls. They came in as the leagues top offences and the Pats came away with 20-17 and 13-3 wins. Pats also lost the 2007 SB, scoring 14 when they averaged 37 a game. It all comes out in the wash is what im saying.
@@moses9647 Nah. BOTH of those games required BRADY to pull of GAME WINNING DRIVES IN BOTH OF THOSE GAMES. The 99/00 Tampa Bay Bucs held the GREATEST SHOW ON TURF to 11 points but only scored 6 points so nobody talks about them. If they had Brady, they would've won but paradoxically people like you would be bringing up their defense even though they are never mentioned since they ultimately didnt win. BRADY wouldve won 9 SBs with another HC. Maybe more.
@@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 be fr man. In 2001, the patriots had 2 TD passes that whole run, with one from Brady. Special teams and defence was the deciding factor throughout. In 2018, Brady went for a whopping 0 TDs and 1 INT. On the flip side, the Rams were held to 260 net yards and 3 points. Yes the defence biffed it with the Eagles and Brady solo squadded it against the Falcons. But the vaunted Patriots offence was manhandled both times against the Giants too. Point being it all levels out. Sometimes the defence won it, sometimes they lost it. Sometimes the offence won it, sometimes they lost it.
@@moses9647 Dude, be REAL, without Brady Belichick gets FIRED in 2001 and the subsequent drivel you wrote would be, in that event, IRRELEVANT. Also without the Tuck Rule game in which Brady threw for over 300 yards in the pouring snow, THERE IS NO SUPE BOWL. And Oakland was a top 4 team in the NFL that season with MVP Gannon. The Rams were a joke because GOFF was a joke, the REAL Super Bowl in 2018 was clearly the 2018 AFCCG where BRADY'S ARM CARRIED A BAD DEFENSIVE PERFORMANCE. Belichick's DEFENSE gave up 30 points in the 2nd half, ONE POINT PER MINUTE, and guess what they STILL WON because Brady put up THREE STRAIGHT SCORING DRIVES vs Mahomes. The first, and thus far only QB, to do that to Mahomes and Reid in a playoff game - score on three straight drives in 4th quarter and OT. Brady was 4/4 on 3rd down - absolutely MONEY. And the REASON the "defense" played such a prominent role in 2018 is because BELICHICK, the garbage GM he has ALWAYS been, left the Patriots offense in TATTERS: Edelman, leading the NFL IN DROPS for the 3rd (or 4th) time; WASHED UP GRONK nowhere near the top 6 TE's in any of the major stats; Phillip Dorsett? LOL; Sonny Michel? Mediocre; NOBODY BUT BRADY is winning a SB with that offense when his DEFENSE is giving up THIRTY POINTS IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE AFC CHAMPIONSHIOP GAME. In fact, just to DRIVE HOME how dumb your argument is: NO QB has ever won a game in which his team's defense gave up 30 points in the 2nd half. Never happened before EXCEPT FOR TOM BRADY. Lemme guess, coincidence? BEFORE Brady, on an EXCELLENT Browns team (top 8 win % of ALL NFL teams in the 80s, go look it up), Bill was GARBAGE. He rode Parcells, Lawrence Taylor, Harry Carson, Banks, FOUR HOFers, coattails to an over-inflated reputation as a defensive coordinator. After the DEBACLE in Cleveland, he went 5-13 IN NEW ENGLAND with a Pro Bowl QB in Bledsoe (who Parcells took to the Super Bowl). Brady SAVED HIS JOB. He then MISSED the playoffs in the ONLY SEASON in which Brady got hurt for the entirety in the heart of the dynasty on a team that went 16-0 the previous year. And then AFTER Brady New England looks JUST LIKE the trash Belichick Browns of the 90s: TERRIBLE Offense, overrated defense, bad coaching, nepotism run amok, ambiguity as to who is the playcaller/coordinator, general power politics. Coincidence? 79 - 91 without Brady. 0 (ZERO) Division titles in ELEVEN YEARS without Brady. ZERO. And you're trying to tell me some rubbish INTIMATING that Brady wasn't INTEGRAL to every single ring they won lol. 2001 = NO BRADY = NO RINGS. That offense was so GARBAGE they were 27th in DVOA with Bledsoe and became a top 15 Offensive team by DVOA with Brady (and a top 10 scoring offense with Brady, when they were a bottom 10 scoring offense with Bledsoe). FACTS.
Michael Irvin explained it so perfectly Bill was able to beat teams that had talent with systems but now that teams have systems and talent it’s still going to be hard to beat them because they have both now
Joy you are rewriting history You need to look at Brady’s stats once he got to play after the starting QB got wrecked. TB12 was always great and clutch and he just continues to improve. They win a super bowl the first or second year that he started full time
“Last week against the cowboys you scored 3 points it was your worst loss ever, this week you said you know what we can do better than that you scored 0” - James Jones
My only push back to the panel is... Don't forget he lost all his player personnel. He lost his player development team. When you're getting depleted making your staff, some people isn't easy to replace. So his coaching staff was important
It was always 👑Brady, he took less money to build the team the defense had less time on the field because the offense was so effective it was always brady. belichick was just smart enough to recognize the talent and give him a shot after bledsoe went down😎
LOL. He did not give Brady a shot after Bledsoe went down, - Bledsoe could not play, so Brady had to. If Brady didn't do anything, he would have been sat right back down later. As soon as Brady took the field, he was able to EASILY move the ball down the field with the same exact team that Bledsoe had! That alone showed you that it was the QB!
@@togelz It was a no-brainer to let Brady keep the job - Bledsoe had an arm and was not bad, but the guy could not move the ball up the field. When Bill saw how EASILY Brady move it up the field and they had a losing record, it was clear who needed to keep the job. That game is on YT, so just go watch and see the differences. So Bill choosing the obvious does not make him a guru, or else they would have picked Brady sooner instead of just picking him because they had a pick!
I don’t feel sorry for Belichik in the least. The way he treated Tom was pathetic and inexcusable. He talked to the man like he alone was the reason they had 6 together. Belichik’s record without Tom Brady is 26-29. Brady has another ring in Tampa. Problem solved
Well that's Belichick's record post-Brady. Don't forget his record pre-Brady (Belichick's seasons in Cleveland, his 1st season with the Pats and the first 2 games of his 2nd season with the Pats)
Belichick should have nothing do with anything offense. Time to look for a new GM, and look for prospects for a young, sharp OC who could become the HC.
Their only win was against the Jets. I don't know how they pulled that off. If they played the Jets now, it would be a completely different result. If the Panthers played the Pats I think Carolina would win. It would be a morbidly interesting matchup
The defenses masterclass he put on against the bills when he was with the giants they were underdogs. He stopped 49ers in 90s from 3 with Montana, rice etc. performances against “the greatest show on turf” in early 2000s or the last Super Bowl vs the rams where they stopped a high scoring offense and limited them to 3 points.
HE HAD LAWRENCE TAYLOR, stop being an intellectual simpleton. The 85 Bears and the 86 Bears would've smoked the Niners too. Belichick had TAYLOR, Banks, CARSON. THREE BONAFIDE HOFERS regardless of what team they played for. The REAL reason the Giants beat the Bills who LOST THREE OTHER SUPER BOWLS TO GUYS WHO WERE NOT NAMED BELICHICK. Bill had the GOAT defensive player, his DVOA as a head coach on DEFENSE in NE - is 13th in DVOA Defense. Belichick is NOT the greatest defensive mind. That's just hype. No Brady = he gets fired
You just proved that it's all about the talent of the players. The reason why people would be excited if he went to a better team is because he can coach great players, but he can't make average players good. In other words, Bill was never a great coach, he just had great players who rallied behind Brady and other vets in spite of Bill's stubborn and assholish ways. Multiple players have said they wanted to join the Pats to play with Brady. ZERO players have said they wanted to go play for Bill. Most of them hate Bill.
I think the general consensus is retirement. Bill getting another chance would mean more losing cause no team with a winning culture is firing their head coach
@@sonikspeed19bill is an excellent coach. But he’s not a good GM. That was covered up with Tom because he was the ultimate force multiplier. But now we can see bill clearly on his own. Excellent coach, bad GM. And if he’s bad at one half it doesn’t matter he good he is at the other.
The Patriots won the division in 11 consecutive seasons from 2009-19 and won it in 17/18 seasons with Brady under center. Under Bill Belichick, the Patriots have failed to win the AFC East just 6 times. The 2020, 2021, and 2022 seasons marked the 1st time under him that they went 3 seasons without winning the division. They've also missed the playoffs in 2 of the last 3 years and haven't won a playoff game since 2018. 1.) Bill Belichick has a worse record without Tom Brady, 81-94 (.462%), (.464% in NE) than Rex Ryan an average coach, 61-66 (.480%) 2)Belichick made the playoffs just 22 percent of the time without Tom Brady and he is 1-2 in those games.(The latest an embarrassing 47-17 beat down at the hands of Josh Allen and the Bills) Bill Belichick has a career winning percentage of .462 in 11 seasons of coaching without Tom Brady. Coaches with a higher career winning percentages than Belichick without Brady: Bill O'Brien: .520 Jeff Fisher: .512 Rex Ryan: .480 Lovie Smith: .479 Joe Philbin: .463 Some other notable coaches with winning percentages higher than Belichick without Brady: Steve Mariuuci: .518 Buddy Ryan: .500 Jack Del Rio: .497 Wayne Fontes: .496 Mike Tice: .492 Dave Wannstedt: .485 Jim Mora: .484 Norv Turner: .483 Ted Marcibroda: .470 Bill Belichick in 11 seasons of coaching without Tom Brady: 81-94 Record 42-44 at Home 31-68 vs .500 teams (16-39 w/NE) 55-73 w/1st Round Picks at QB 67-79 w/Pro Bowl QBs 7 losing seasons. 0 Superbowls. 0 conference titles. 0 division titles. 1 playoff win.(29 years ago) How do you explain this? 🧐 Bill Belichick with Tom Brady: 249-75. 77% win percentage Patriots since 2000 At Gillette Stadium Tom Brady starts: 134-23 (.854) Other QB starts: 19-19 (.500) When Allowing 17+ Points Tom Brady starts: 118-73 (.618) Other QB starts: 16-45 (.262) When allowing 24+ points Tom Brady starts: 56-61 .479 win% 126 higher than 2nd place Since Brady left: 2-24 .008 win% 2nd lowest in that span BB with Tom Brady: Averaged 28 PPG BB with every other QB: Averaged 18 PPG At home vs AFC East since 2001 with Tom Brady: (47-5, .904) w/o Tom Brady: (6-9, .400) Bill Belichick when opponent scores 30+ points With Brady: 15-27 Without Brady: 0-25 The Patriots with Mac Jones are now 0-14 whenever an opponent scores 25+ points Pats since 2000 against teams that made the playoffs With Brady: 89-42 (.679) 4 W/o Brady: 10-25 (.286) If PHI, MIA, DAL, and NO all make the playoffs this season, it would move that to 10-29 Since 2000, the Patriots have now lost more home games without Tom Brady starting at QB (25) than they did with Brady starting at QB (24) W/ Brady: 141-24 (.855) W/o Brady: 22-25 (.468) (Includes the playoffs) 2000 Patriots (with Drew Bledsoe): 5-11 record 25th in PPG 17th in pass offense DVOA 21st in offensive DVOA 23rd in offensive EPA/play 2001 Patriots (with Tom Brady) 14-3 record, Super Bowl champs 6th in PPG 10th in pass offense DVOA 11th in offensive DVOA 10th in off EPA/play Patriots were 5-13 in BB and Drew Bledsoe's first 18 games together(that's the same record as the Colts started with Peyton Manning in Indianapolis). Patriots were 15-3 in BB and Brady's first 18 games together. Games started by Brady in those games in 2001 the Patriots offense averaged 26.6 PPG which would've been second in the NFL in scoring offense that season behind only the greatest show on turf Rams who led the league in scoring averaging 31.4 PPG. In his 6 years as a head coach before 2001, BB had never had a top 10 ranked scoring offense. The Patriots offense was ranked 25th in ppg scored in 2000 with Bledsoe(4x pro bowler) as the QB. In 2001, Brady's first year as the starter, the Patriots were ranked 6th in scoring offense. Belichick’s “system” 2001: 6 PPG increase with Brady 2008: 11 PPG decrease without Brady 2016: 10 PPG increase with Brady 2020: 6 PPG decrease without Brady Maybe BB is a "system coach." 🐸☕️
Each year is different and each team is different. The patriots passed on D-Hop. Their FA signings this year made no sense to me. I think if we are going to lay the blame at Belichick for anything it’s the GM moves. They have no o-line. Their best players on defense are injured. The run game has been completely absent and you have a QB that is trying to overcompensate.
What? IDIOTS were saying it was ALL the "system" and Brady cant win without Belichick's system. Now what? Belichick is a terrible human being and an overrated coach who has done NOTHING, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING, as a HC without THE GOAT.
Oc and dc left while Brady was there and they still won so that's not an excuse. Edleman is a product of Brady gronk is the goat but stayed hurt and Brady still won without so that's not an excuse Gilmore we still won a Superbowl without him
Kraft was a fool to keep Belichick and push Tom Brady out the door. He should have told Bill we are keeping Tom and go all in for another Super Bowl or two. If Bill didn't like it Kraft at the time could have shown him the door and promoted Josh McDaniels to head coach. They would have been better off with that for the last three years then Bill Belichick and a wasted year with Cam Newton and now several more with Mac Jones. Also Belichick's ego cost the Patriots some Super Bowls over the years. It's time for Bill to go! Thank you for your service now go get your precious personal winning record somewhere else! We don't pay players for past performance in New England so why should we do that for Bill Belichick?
Patriots need to get rid of Belichick after this season. Bring in Jason Licht as the gm and Josh Mcdaniels as the new Head Coach. Brady only put up with Belichick for all those years because of those 2.
I’m over the tom Brady left and won in Tampa. Tampa was an all star team lol. Stop it now. The year he retired no one talks how he looked with half that squad.
If Bill wants to turn this thing around he needs to get rid of Mac Jones and have a GM come in and give him talent. He needs a REAL OC for his offense so he can stick to the defense. The defense is so bad because the offense ain’t helping him at all. We can’t act like Bill’s defense wasn’t integral to MULTIPLE of those Super Bowl wins and seasons. We can’t rewrite history because of what we are seeing now. He’s struggling because he’s taking on too much and it’s time to move on.
Joy saying he developed because of Bill is ridiculous. It’s like saying Carr developed because of Brady who had to play him because it was his only option to win. Bill had Kosar, Testaverde, Bledsoe and Newton. Each a #1 overall draft. Which of them did Bill develop?
COACHING IS A GREATER RESPONSIBILITY THAN QB ; ESPECIALLY WHEN COACHING PLAYS AND PICKING PLAYERS; HOW A TEAM COUCH AND RECRUIT IS KEY TO SUCCESS IN HISTORY !
You guys came hauntingly close, almost touching on the crux of the issue: coaches are never the deciding factor in winning games. They may mess things up badly and lose games, but even the best laid out plan can only be executed by players. Coaches stepping onto the field are flagged, remember? While coaches may lose games, they can never win games. Only players do.
Andy has a ton of power but he definitely takes a lot of what Veach has to say into consideration. But I think Veach likely makes the final call on defense but I can assure you if Andy doesn’t want an offensive draft pick Veach isn’t picking that guy. Veach was also not the GM when Mahomes was picked he was a director of personnel. But yeah he lobbied for Mahomes and Andy listened. But if it was a battle between them Andy probably wins.
Belichick needs to get in check or leave me to step up recruiting and pay those guys. If not, they're going to destroy your own legacy. Your legacy is there. But I'm just saying come on Bill. William tightened up. Enlighten up. Last but least I am watching this show as much as I can. Everybody on this show is on point. Shout out to Miss Taylor! You're the most beautiful lady on all of the sports shows intelligent first right along with beauty.
Settle down everybody, do you really think that he doesn't prepare his players? It's the players who play the game. Patriots were in those first two against eagles and dolphins. Last two just looked real bad. Nobody is firing bill, he will let the kraft's know when he's retiring. Tom was a massive part of that machine back in the good ol' years!
Such a clown take. Y’all act like Brady was a superstar those first two rings. Y’all act like the last Pats ring Bill didn’t hold the highest scoring offense in the league to 3 points while only scoring what…13 points
The Patriots dynasty fell apart when Tom Brady threw an interception against The Titans in a playoff game back in 2019. Since then, the flashing signs for a dynasty stopped flashing and went blank.
Bill is the Only guy left from the 2 decades dynasty and many great player left and the main guy the goat left. Kraft needs to take the gm and decisions away from bill he’s coaching way is outdated. It’s not like you can win elite defense and elite run game anymore it’s not the early 2000s. It’s a quarterbacks league now.
Tom Brady the goat ain’t the only one that left hall of fame players left scouts and coaches left he’s literally the only guy left from the dynasty with kids and an average roster in which he deserves blame for.
Check out the What’s Wright? with Nick Wright podcast: sprtspod.fox/WhatsWright_YT
Chuck Noll, Tom Landry,Don Shula,doesn’t matter the coach.when the all time great player or players leave. The coaches become average.
Joy 💣🔥💣🔥💣🔥
There was a patriots writer whose name is Mike Giardi who said all offseason that team was bad during training camp and was gonna be bad and got roasted for it
He wasn’t the only one. The guys on First Things First thought the Pats had a talent depleted roster and were gonna be bad this year. But idk if anyone thought they would be this bad. Similar to Sean Payton, it looks like the Pats players are quitting on Bill because they don’t like his old school coaching style.
Belichick is both the Head Coach and the General Manager, so who else can be blamed???
Well, has anybody asked if this is the best roster he can pay for? Maybe the Kraft's pocket is not deep enough to pay for what Bill actually want.
EXACTLY! he has a below .500 record without brady as well. I'm not a brady fan I'll give him his flowers for the career he had. That being said he made Bill better. It's hard to argue against it
@@vitorpeck4458he overpaid for talent and there's a salary cap. Don't blame Kraft for Bill's failure
@@officialchoccypophe’s the one that went out and chose to sign those players, Kraft just signs the checks. Belichick isn’t signing anyone he doesn’t want on his team.
@@vitorpeck4458there’s a salary cap that Bill is also in charge of managing. That way no team can truly go out and just sign anyone at any price without some type of consequence. The Rams are paying the consequence these last few years. They won that one Super Bowl and overpaid a ton of players, most of whom are no longer on the team at all. BB has never done that to the extent the Rams did (or with the level of talent the Rams had had) but he still wound up having a team this bad anyway.
I like what Joy said because it’s true while Bill didn’t have a GM for so long it was known that he and Brady went back on forth on a lot. Especially game planning. I recall from one of the documentaries that they would be doing that for a cool minute all the time.
I'm a patriots fan and I'm honestly to the point that I feel sorry for BB. I'm not mad. I'm not frustrated. I legitimately feel bad for the man because he is deconstructing his own legacy.
I never feel sorry for egotistical narcissists. Same thing is happening with Sean Payton.
@@clarkkent1521yea bill was pretty unlikable when he was on top. Feel sorry? Nahhhhh
I hear exactly what you're saying. Bill is a different dude given his background. He was raised differently than the culture around the current time's. I never saw him as a narcissist, more of a hardliner and business comes first and don't rest on your laurels approach. Obviously he's not of the fame type so it comes off differently with him. As of the last few year's he's struggled though.
U feel sorry! I'm a Patriots fan and I don't feel sorry for him! He's getting EXACTLY what he deserves!
Bill traded it all to chase the all time win record.
As a saints fan I’m like so ready for our next game because our win have been drowned out by the patriots drama.
Yea, nobody gave u guys credit haha
They never gave the Saints credit, they be hating.
Nobody cares about the saints. If y’all win next week it will be the same thing or you won’t be talked about at all.
@@WGAGENCY did I ask for your opinion? Oh okay that’s right WHODAT!
@@ngken1012 But we smoked them HaHa
People forget Brady was a winner before Belichick (Michigan) during Belichick (Pats) after Belichick (Bucs)
true, won Orange Bowl with Michigan Wolverines and 7th Super Bowl with The Buccs
Yet he wasn’t taken until the 6th round by Belichick who won the first three Super Bowls with Tom Brady being a game manager while winning with defense and special teams
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m Stop lying. No GAME MANAGER HAS THREE GAME WINNING DRIVES IN THREE SUPER BOWLS! None. Peyton Manning doesn't have THREE GAME WINNING DRIVES in his WHOLE PLAYOFF CAREER.
Brady did that as "game manager" even though LITERALLY NO QB in history, even Mahomes, has THREE game winning drives in his first THREE Super Bowls and racked up more 4th quarter comebacks in the playoffs his first 4 seasons as a starter than Manning and Brees did in their entire playoff CAREERS.
Brady threw for 350+ yards, 3tds, a 4th Q comeback and the GW Drive in the 2003 Superbowl vs a top 10 defense in Carolina while his defense pooped the bed giving up 30 points to Delhomme.
He LED the NFL in TD Passes in 2002 without a single pro bowl or all pro pass catcher. NO QB IN NFL HISTORY has ever done that post- NFL-AFL Merger.
You guys just hate the GOAT. He MADE Belichick. Bill is CRIMINALLY OVERRATED.
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m1. Brady was never a game manager. Both defense and offense of the 2001 Oats was exact same in rankings escept the offense had no weapons.
2. Yes he was a 6th round pick. Draft mistakes happen all the time. Scrubs like Trey Lance go 3 overall
Yes, But Brock Purdy was the last.
I say this for almost 4 years now, Bellichick is no more than an over-glorified Defensive coordinator,... his strength was on defense yes, but on offense and offensive drafting he is so bad, for 2 decades he had the privilege of having the greatest Quarterback ever in Tom Brady that could over and over again cover his mistake, took a mostly mid player and raise them to be the best that they could be
I think Joy Taylor said it the best here. He is the gm and a coach. In the past, it worked. But now the game has changed, and you don't have those key inputs anymore. The system that worked for 20 years is broken. The only one to blame is BB himself at this point. Not that he's a horrible coach or whatever people want to say about him. But he's trying to do too much by himself at this point. Props to Joy cause honestly on this panel it's like she's the only one who has a reasonable take on this.
Dang acho is cooking👏😂😂
As a Patriots fan, this was one of the best patriots debates I’ve ever seen. Love it.
Same thing happened to Tom Landry. Was great for a long time, Staubach retires then went through purgatory in the 80s until Jerry bought the Cowboys and put Landry out of his misery.
This is a genuinely good show, I'll start watching regularly. I may or may not be late, but it really is good
Since i became a football fan (NYG) the Patriots were always the top dogs, best of the best, like Joy said "for 20 YRS" Even when other teams won it, they were still in the mix. The game HAS changed, but Bills style hasn't. Doesn't work anymore.
Look at Sean Payton without Drew, I was expecting the Broncos to be at least a playoff team and I’m a Saints fan btw
It took Brady maximum 3 years to become a Top 3 QB. In 2002 he led the league in TDs and in 2003 he was runner-up for the MVP. Then from 2006 onward, with the exception of a season or two, he's been playing at an MVP level pretty much every year. On top of that, Brady mostly credited the mindset and work ethic he got from college and Charlie Weiss (his OC at the time) for his development. I say this because people give Belichick too much credit when it comes to Brady's development; Belichick is not great offensively
excellent point Bradys dedication to constantly improving is all Brady however, Charlie Weiss was the other person involved in his constant improving
Reminder: All 3 SB's that Tom Brady lost were due to the New England defense. Yes, even the Eagles loss, because Brady threw for 500 yards. Malcolm Butler only missed 2 games that season too - once at the beginning of the season and the SB. Conveniently enough, those were the only 2 games where NE had given up 40+ points 👀
Didn’t Tom Brady have the football last in the Super Bowl vs the Eagles? Plus didn’t they win the Super Bowl the next year with Tom Brady throwing a pick and Belichick defense holding the Rams offense to 3 points?
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m Goff sucks. Goff would've lost to the Chiefs if BRADY DIDNT PUT UP 30+ POINTS against the Chiefs while his DEFENSE was giving up a point per minute in the 2nd half (gave up like 30 points in the 2nd half).
Brady WON the Super Bowl in 2018 - it was called the 2018 AFCCG.
Brady won SIX SBs on SIX GAME WINNING DRIVES.
Six. That's crazy.
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m same rams team that had a 50 pt shootout with KC
Reminder: EVERY Superbowl that Tom Brady won had a controversial call that got ruled in his favor. The tuck rule raiders playoff game ring a bell? He NEVER without a controversial call/multiple controversial calls. The same thing is happening with Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs. They mostly win because of outrageous calls that get ruled in their favor in crucial moments. I'm a pats fan, but I'm calling it for what it is. AT LEAST 80 percent of Brady's career was the refs...
@@williamreid6288 Not the topic of discussion.
Belichick has never been as good as so many has said. Before Brady he was average, after Brady he's average at best. You can argue about this if you want just look up his record. When he was with the Giants as their DC he had LT and they won a lot.
He won Super Bowl as a Defensive Coordinator, plus when he was head coach with the Browns he won them their first playoff win in 1996 then he won the first 3 super bowls when Tom Brady was a game manager
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m1. Brady was never a game manager. Watch the tape not the stats
2. He failed the Browns. They made 3 AFC Champiomship games just before he got there. Ran them to the ground
3. Me and you could have coached those Giants defenses to do something. They were that stacked.
Without Brady and cheating he is a terrible coach way below average coach.
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m tom Brady was more than a game manager clown.
Game managers don’t throw the ball on final drives of games
Tom Brady NEVER won without a controversial/multiple controversial calls getting ruled in his favor. The Superbowl he won with the Bucs had some of the most biased/sketchy officiating I've ever seen. Same thing with the NFC championship game against the Packers. Guess who benefited from all of the sketchy/biased officiating? Yep, Tom Brady and the Bucs.
I been saying it's not the Patriot's way but it was the Brady way. Them winning and now losing, what's the common denominator: Thomas Edward Patrick Brady Jr.! 🐐
The "Tom Brady way" was getting bailed out by the refs for over 20 years...
haha you got his whole government name?
@@pontiacGXPfan 🤣
@@williamreid6288 You're a clown.
Belichick the GM has hurt Belichick the HC.
I see what Joy’s trying to say, but… Belichick has been exposed. There’s no other way to slice it.
Shady deadass wrong for saying Batman💀🤣
I remember the moment in the game when Mac threw an incompletion and it raised his QBR 🤦🏽♂️
For 2.5 quarters he would have got a higher QBR if he'd spiked the ball every play
The game has passed him by, dude thinks you can still win playing early 2000s football.
Actually you can. Just look at the 49ers
@@mauricewells7838the 49ers have dynamic personnel though. New England is out here playing with a bunch of number 2s at the wr position
But Belichick was a losing head coach in the early 1990s and then in 2000 year before Brady took over that was old school NfL he wast still a losing think it all just comes down with or without Brady with him and his entire coaching tree
@Mrtev215 but New England was winning with a bunch of #2's with Brady, he just made you have to cover everything. That what San Francisco does very well
@@mauricewells7838Brady was the coach on the field, a legitimate Field General , he allowed Belicheck to focus solely on DEFENSE ,
That was the Original Agreement per say; Brady commander on field on Offense with no name talent most of his career but would make OTHER GUYS TALENTED with his generalship commander way of taking the field and playing the game, remember Bill was spending those 1st rounders for yrs on the defense and couldn't draft a decent receiver to save his life 😅, but yes , he has fallen to down back to earth 🌎 he didn't properly prep this out and it's stinging him now , he should have made a big move a year ago in my estimation.
It’s amazing that we got the clear truth about Brady, Belicheck, and Wilson at the same time. One was the GOAT and the other two were actual trash.
Joys right , even if you have final say having someone there can often result in different outcomes. Itt'll make you consider your positions.
yeah but that still on Bill for not having a GM lol he wants all the power
@@edgybravo4287That’s the problem because isn’t it the GM and scouting department job to draft and scout players?
@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m buddy Belichick is the GM lmao
When you are a legend,an all time great.It’s hard to really tarnish your legend….initially.This is blight for Bill.If he would have just retired when Brady left(and I’m not saying he should have) it would have been way less damaging
Kraft needs to hire a real GM and not let Bellicheck pick any offensive skill players again ever. O lineman and defensive players yea he can pick them but WRs RBs TEs NO! But yea right now is ALL on Belicheck because he is the HC and the GM. No one else to blame. Buck stops with him. Kraft needs to fire Belicheck as the GM and hire a real one. And hire a DC to at least work with Belicheck.
How did all of the OC do when they didn't have TB12. Tom was the coach,GM, and OC. Players on offense and defense took less to play with TB12. He would put fear in the offensive players that didn't perform. For 20 years, Bill didn't have to work hard.
Now this is reality. Bill is either rusty or tired. Either one isn't good.
There was a pass that Mahomes completed this weekend, that only he could have possibly completed; falling down, almost on his back 30+ yards down the field....catch! They win. Without those kinds of plays here and there, you have a great team, that becomes very average. That was Brady for all those years, in his own non-athletic way, as we know Brady is not Mahomes etc...but he more than made up for that with his other skills. Mac has almost nothing, or developed very little so far. It's actually quite incredible we're here.
Yea also the refs kinda helped a bit too
@@VanquishedAgainRight, not to mention I’ve seen a lot of QBs make throws like Mahomes made a lot of other QBs have made the same plays or similar that Pat has made. The NFL just overhypes everything he does sometimes.
"No brother, we got Tom Brady." Welp that about sums it up.
I feel bad for Tom Brady, I think he was good for more than 6 SBs and BB cost him a few. He probably should have won an even dozen.
at the very least he should've won 1 more against The Eagles, the benching of Malcolm Butler was straight up stupid, petty and cold
Yeah but at the same time BB out it on the Rams for two of those SuperBowls. They came in as the leagues top offences and the Pats came away with 20-17 and 13-3 wins. Pats also lost the 2007 SB, scoring 14 when they averaged 37 a game.
It all comes out in the wash is what im saying.
@@moses9647 Nah. BOTH of those games required BRADY to pull of GAME WINNING DRIVES IN BOTH OF THOSE GAMES.
The 99/00 Tampa Bay Bucs held the GREATEST SHOW ON TURF to 11 points but only scored 6 points so nobody talks about them. If they had Brady, they would've won but paradoxically people like you would be bringing up their defense even though they are never mentioned since they ultimately didnt win.
BRADY wouldve won 9 SBs with another HC. Maybe more.
@@feynmanschwingere_mc2270 be fr man. In 2001, the patriots had 2 TD passes that whole run, with one from Brady. Special teams and defence was the deciding factor throughout. In 2018, Brady went for a whopping 0 TDs and 1 INT. On the flip side, the Rams were held to 260 net yards and 3 points.
Yes the defence biffed it with the Eagles and Brady solo squadded it against the Falcons. But the vaunted Patriots offence was manhandled both times against the Giants too. Point being it all levels out. Sometimes the defence won it, sometimes they lost it. Sometimes the offence won it, sometimes they lost it.
@@moses9647 Dude, be REAL, without Brady Belichick gets FIRED in 2001 and the subsequent drivel you wrote would be, in that event, IRRELEVANT. Also without the Tuck Rule game in which Brady threw for over 300 yards in the pouring snow, THERE IS NO SUPE BOWL. And Oakland was a top 4 team in the NFL that season with MVP Gannon.
The Rams were a joke because GOFF was a joke, the REAL Super Bowl in 2018 was clearly the 2018 AFCCG where BRADY'S ARM CARRIED A BAD DEFENSIVE PERFORMANCE. Belichick's DEFENSE gave up 30 points in the 2nd half, ONE POINT PER MINUTE, and guess what they STILL WON because Brady put up THREE STRAIGHT SCORING DRIVES vs Mahomes. The first, and thus far only QB, to do that to Mahomes and Reid in a playoff game - score on three straight drives in 4th quarter and OT. Brady was 4/4 on 3rd down - absolutely MONEY.
And the REASON the "defense" played such a prominent role in 2018 is because BELICHICK, the garbage GM he has ALWAYS been, left the Patriots offense in TATTERS:
Edelman, leading the NFL IN DROPS for the 3rd (or 4th) time; WASHED UP GRONK nowhere near the top 6 TE's in any of the major stats; Phillip Dorsett? LOL; Sonny Michel? Mediocre;
NOBODY BUT BRADY is winning a SB with that offense when his DEFENSE is giving up THIRTY POINTS IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE AFC CHAMPIONSHIOP GAME.
In fact, just to DRIVE HOME how dumb your argument is:
NO QB has ever won a game in which his team's defense gave up 30 points in the 2nd half.
Never happened before EXCEPT FOR TOM BRADY. Lemme guess, coincidence?
BEFORE Brady, on an EXCELLENT Browns team (top 8 win % of ALL NFL teams in the 80s, go look it up), Bill was GARBAGE. He rode Parcells, Lawrence Taylor, Harry Carson, Banks, FOUR HOFers, coattails to an over-inflated reputation as a defensive coordinator. After the DEBACLE in Cleveland, he went 5-13 IN NEW ENGLAND with a Pro Bowl QB in Bledsoe (who Parcells took to the Super Bowl). Brady SAVED HIS JOB. He then MISSED the playoffs in the ONLY SEASON in which Brady got hurt for the entirety in the heart of the dynasty on a team that went 16-0 the previous year. And then AFTER Brady New England looks JUST LIKE the trash Belichick Browns of the 90s: TERRIBLE Offense, overrated defense, bad coaching, nepotism run amok, ambiguity as to who is the playcaller/coordinator, general power politics.
Coincidence? 79 - 91 without Brady. 0 (ZERO) Division titles in ELEVEN YEARS without Brady.
ZERO. And you're trying to tell me some rubbish INTIMATING that Brady wasn't INTEGRAL to every single ring they won lol.
2001 = NO BRADY = NO RINGS.
That offense was so GARBAGE they were 27th in DVOA with Bledsoe and became a top 15 Offensive team by DVOA with Brady (and a top 10 scoring offense with Brady, when they were a bottom 10 scoring offense with Bledsoe).
FACTS.
As a Jets fan I’m so happy is finally OVER for belicheat!
Shady not knowing the famous 'With great power comes great responsibility' quote coming from Spider-Man is just wild
I think what they’re saying is Belichick doesn’t have the collaboration to picking players like the other coaches/GMs do.
Michael Irvin explained it so perfectly Bill was able to beat teams that had talent with systems but now that teams have systems and talent it’s still going to be hard to beat them because they have both now
Joy you are rewriting history You need to look at Brady’s stats once he got to play after the starting QB got wrecked. TB12 was always great and clutch and he just continues to improve. They win a super bowl the first or second year that he started full time
“Last week against the cowboys you scored 3 points it was your worst loss ever, this week you said you know what we can do better than that you scored 0” - James Jones
My only push back to the panel is... Don't forget he lost all his player personnel. He lost his player development team. When you're getting depleted making your staff, some people isn't easy to replace. So his coaching staff was important
It was always 👑Brady, he took less money to build the team the defense had less time on the field because the offense was so effective it was always brady. belichick was just smart enough to recognize the talent and give him a shot after bledsoe went down😎
LOL. He did not give Brady a shot after Bledsoe went down, - Bledsoe could not play, so Brady had to. If Brady didn't do anything, he would have been sat right back down later. As soon as Brady took the field, he was able to EASILY move the ball down the field with the same exact team that Bledsoe had! That alone showed you that it was the QB!
@@HardCold-AlquanIs this sarcasm??
@@TYreLL0416 Ask the original commenter. Mine is the truth. This is how I know that you were too young to see it unfold before your eyes in real time.
maybe what you meant was Bellichick was smart enough to let Brady keep starting after Bledsoe healed
@@togelz It was a no-brainer to let Brady keep the job - Bledsoe had an arm and was not bad, but the guy could not move the ball up the field. When Bill saw how EASILY Brady move it up the field and they had a losing record, it was clear who needed to keep the job.
That game is on YT, so just go watch and see the differences. So Bill choosing the obvious does not make him a guru, or else they would have picked Brady sooner instead of just picking him because they had a pick!
Here’s my suggestion for the day. When Uncle Billy contract expires. Then u tell em that he isn’t getting extended. Period!
I agree with Joy on this one!
I don’t feel sorry for Belichik in the least. The way he treated Tom was pathetic and inexcusable. He talked to the man like he alone was the reason they had 6 together. Belichik’s record without Tom Brady is 26-29. Brady has another ring in Tampa. Problem solved
Well that's Belichick's record post-Brady. Don't forget his record pre-Brady (Belichick's seasons in Cleveland, his 1st season with the Pats and the first 2 games of his 2nd season with the Pats)
Belichick should have nothing do with anything offense. Time to look for a new GM, and look for prospects for a young, sharp OC who could become the HC.
If you’re going to have a defensive minded head coach make sure you have a proven OC
Their only win was against the Jets. I don't know how they pulled that off. If they played the Jets now, it would be a completely different result. If the Panthers played the Pats I think Carolina would win. It would be a morbidly interesting matchup
The defenses masterclass he put on against the bills when he was with the giants they were underdogs. He stopped 49ers in 90s from 3 with Montana, rice etc. performances against “the greatest show on turf” in early 2000s or the last Super Bowl vs the rams where they stopped a high scoring offense and limited them to 3 points.
Exactly!
But let LeSean and every Tom Brady tell it Belichick wasn’t sh** and was along for the ride with Brady
HE HAD LAWRENCE TAYLOR, stop being an intellectual simpleton.
The 85 Bears and the 86 Bears would've smoked the Niners too.
Belichick had TAYLOR, Banks, CARSON. THREE BONAFIDE HOFERS regardless of what team they played for. The REAL reason the Giants beat the Bills who LOST THREE OTHER SUPER BOWLS TO GUYS WHO WERE NOT NAMED BELICHICK.
Bill had the GOAT defensive player, his DVOA as a head coach on DEFENSE in NE - is 13th in DVOA Defense.
Belichick is NOT the greatest defensive mind. That's just hype.
No Brady = he gets fired
Since Brady left there is no one to fix Belichicks mistakes.
It's funny how the entire media wants him fired, but every pundit would sing praises for the team that hired him next.
That’s how the media works if he goes to a team like the chargers they will get Super Bowl faverouite tags etc.
You just proved that it's all about the talent of the players. The reason why people would be excited if he went to a better team is because he can coach great players, but he can't make average players good. In other words, Bill was never a great coach, he just had great players who rallied behind Brady and other vets in spite of Bill's stubborn and assholish ways. Multiple players have said they wanted to join the Pats to play with Brady. ZERO players have said they wanted to go play for Bill. Most of them hate Bill.
I think the general consensus is retirement. Bill getting another chance would mean more losing cause no team with a winning culture is firing their head coach
@@sonikspeed19 Not even you believe in this nonsense you just said.
@@sonikspeed19bill is an excellent coach. But he’s not a good GM. That was covered up with Tom because he was the ultimate force multiplier. But now we can see bill clearly on his own. Excellent coach, bad GM. And if he’s bad at one half it doesn’t matter he good he is at the other.
The Patriots won the division in 11 consecutive seasons from 2009-19 and won it in 17/18 seasons with Brady under center.
Under Bill Belichick, the Patriots have failed to win the AFC East just 6 times.
The 2020, 2021, and 2022 seasons marked the 1st time under him that they went 3 seasons without winning the division. They've also missed the playoffs in 2 of the last 3 years and haven't won a playoff game since 2018.
1.) Bill Belichick has a worse record without Tom Brady, 81-94 (.462%), (.464% in NE) than Rex Ryan an average coach, 61-66 (.480%)
2)Belichick made the playoffs just 22 percent of the time without Tom Brady and he is 1-2 in those games.(The latest an embarrassing 47-17 beat down at the hands of Josh Allen and the Bills)
Bill Belichick has a career winning percentage of .462 in 11 seasons of coaching without Tom Brady.
Coaches with a higher career winning percentages than Belichick without Brady:
Bill O'Brien: .520
Jeff Fisher: .512
Rex Ryan: .480
Lovie Smith: .479
Joe Philbin: .463
Some other notable coaches with winning percentages higher than Belichick without Brady:
Steve Mariuuci: .518
Buddy Ryan: .500
Jack Del Rio: .497
Wayne Fontes: .496
Mike Tice: .492
Dave Wannstedt: .485
Jim Mora: .484
Norv Turner: .483
Ted Marcibroda: .470
Bill Belichick in 11 seasons of coaching without Tom Brady:
81-94 Record
42-44 at Home
31-68 vs .500 teams (16-39 w/NE)
55-73 w/1st Round Picks at QB
67-79 w/Pro Bowl QBs
7 losing seasons.
0 Superbowls.
0 conference titles.
0 division titles.
1 playoff win.(29 years ago)
How do you explain this? 🧐
Bill Belichick with Tom Brady: 249-75. 77% win percentage
Patriots since 2000
At Gillette Stadium
Tom Brady starts: 134-23 (.854)
Other QB starts: 19-19 (.500)
When Allowing 17+ Points
Tom Brady starts: 118-73 (.618)
Other QB starts: 16-45 (.262)
When allowing 24+ points
Tom Brady starts: 56-61
.479 win% 126 higher than 2nd place
Since Brady left: 2-24
.008 win% 2nd lowest in that span
BB with Tom Brady: Averaged 28 PPG
BB with every other QB: Averaged 18 PPG
At home vs AFC East since 2001
with Tom Brady: (47-5, .904)
w/o Tom Brady: (6-9, .400)
Bill Belichick when opponent scores 30+ points
With Brady: 15-27
Without Brady: 0-25
The Patriots with Mac Jones are now 0-14 whenever an opponent scores 25+ points
Pats since 2000 against teams that made the playoffs
With Brady: 89-42 (.679)
4
W/o Brady: 10-25 (.286)
If PHI, MIA, DAL, and NO all make the playoffs this season, it would move that to 10-29
Since 2000, the Patriots have now lost more home games without Tom Brady starting at QB (25) than they did with Brady starting at QB (24)
W/ Brady: 141-24 (.855)
W/o Brady: 22-25 (.468)
(Includes the playoffs)
2000 Patriots (with Drew Bledsoe):
5-11 record
25th in PPG
17th in pass offense DVOA
21st in offensive DVOA
23rd in offensive EPA/play
2001 Patriots (with Tom Brady)
14-3 record, Super Bowl champs
6th in PPG
10th in pass offense DVOA
11th in offensive DVOA
10th in off EPA/play
Patriots were 5-13 in BB and Drew Bledsoe's first 18 games together(that's the same record as the Colts started with Peyton Manning in Indianapolis).
Patriots were 15-3 in BB and Brady's first 18 games together.
Games started by Brady in those games in 2001 the Patriots offense averaged 26.6 PPG which would've been second in the NFL in scoring offense that season behind only the greatest show on turf Rams who led the league in scoring averaging 31.4 PPG.
In his 6 years as a head coach before 2001, BB had never had a top 10 ranked scoring offense. The Patriots offense was ranked 25th in ppg scored in 2000 with Bledsoe(4x pro bowler) as the QB. In 2001, Brady's first year as the starter, the Patriots were ranked 6th in scoring offense.
Belichick’s “system”
2001: 6 PPG increase with Brady
2008: 11 PPG decrease without Brady
2016: 10 PPG increase with Brady
2020: 6 PPG decrease without Brady
Maybe BB is a "system coach." 🐸☕️
The Pats didn't get beat, they got blown up !!
Each year is different and each team is different. The patriots passed on D-Hop. Their FA signings this year made no sense to me. I think if we are going to lay the blame at Belichick for anything it’s the GM moves.
They have no o-line. Their best players on defense are injured. The run game has been completely absent and you have a QB that is trying to overcompensate.
The patriot way...
This is off topic but I just love the voice tone of joy. 😊
I got her number if you want it? No d*** pics tho. You interested?
Nothing wrong with that
Yes, all on Bill the GM.
You CAN'T give all the blame to a person in bad times if you're not willing to give all credit to them in good times.
This the one right here💯
He never got all the credit in the good times, Brady did.
@@YouReallyDontKnow that's actually kind of my point
What? IDIOTS were saying it was ALL the "system" and Brady cant win without Belichick's system. Now what?
Belichick is a terrible human being and an overrated coach who has done NOTHING, ABSOLUTELY NOTHING, as a HC without THE GOAT.
@@YouReallyDontKnowas he should have. He was a better version of Peyton Manning. Belichick is like a lesser Vic Fangio
I had no idea he was the head coach and GM… Jesus that explains so much
What if he’s taking for a QB in this draft?
I can’t imagine him being this terrible
2 decades of low picks and 6 superbowls and people are complaing that he cant coach
OC DC scout guys left Brady , gronk , Elelman , Gilmore etc.. left
Oc and dc left while Brady was there and they still won so that's not an excuse. Edleman is a product of Brady gronk is the goat but stayed hurt and Brady still won without so that's not an excuse Gilmore we still won a Superbowl without him
But isn't it Bill's job to replace or keep those players as GM?
@@ayoolou9392 you are right , but it's a lot of change in a short period.
The big three retired from the cowboys and it takes a while to recover.
Thank you !!! Comparing bellichick doesn’t belong in the same conversation with Shula. Shula won with different quarterbacks
Shady: it's Justin
Also Shady: it's not Mac Jones it's Belichick
Lesean mccoy, I am done with life and justin fields fault it's always justin fields fault I'm done.
Love love Bill belichick😊 players 😢
Kraft was a fool to keep Belichick and push Tom Brady out the door. He should have told Bill we are keeping Tom and go all in for another Super Bowl or two. If Bill didn't like it Kraft at the time could have shown him the door and promoted Josh McDaniels to head coach. They would have been better off with that for the last three years then Bill Belichick and a wasted year with Cam Newton and now several more with Mac Jones. Also Belichick's ego cost the Patriots some Super Bowls over the years. It's time for Bill to go! Thank you for your service now go get your precious personal winning record somewhere else! We don't pay players for past performance in New England so why should we do that for Bill Belichick?
Patriots need to get rid of Belichick after this season.
Bring in Jason Licht as the gm and Josh Mcdaniels as the new Head Coach. Brady only put up with Belichick for all those years because of those 2.
I’m over the tom Brady left and won in Tampa. Tampa was an all star team lol. Stop it now. The year he retired no one talks how he looked with half that squad.
ALWAYS KNEW TOM MADE THAT TEAM GO "PLAYERS MAKE PLAYS"
If Bill wants to turn this thing around he needs to get rid of Mac Jones and have a GM come in and give him talent. He needs a REAL OC for his offense so he can stick to the defense. The defense is so bad because the offense ain’t helping him at all.
We can’t act like Bill’s defense wasn’t integral to MULTIPLE of those Super Bowl wins and seasons. We can’t rewrite history because of what we are seeing now. He’s struggling because he’s taking on too much and it’s time to move on.
Belichick is below 500 without Tom Brady, enough said, get rid of him.
Joy saying he developed because of Bill is ridiculous. It’s like saying Carr developed because of Brady who had to play him because it was his only option to win. Bill had Kosar, Testaverde, Bledsoe and Newton. Each a #1 overall draft. Which of them did Bill develop?
COACHING IS A GREATER RESPONSIBILITY THAN QB ; ESPECIALLY WHEN COACHING PLAYS AND PICKING PLAYERS; HOW A TEAM COUCH AND RECRUIT IS KEY TO SUCCESS IN HISTORY !
Seeing four analysts tear Bill apart for 15 straight minutes is so euphoric.
You guys came hauntingly close, almost touching on the crux of the issue: coaches are never the deciding factor in winning games. They may mess things up badly and lose games, but even the best laid out plan can only be executed by players. Coaches stepping onto the field are flagged, remember? While coaches may lose games, they can never win games. Only players do.
Young Shady not playing with the charm.
Love Shady speaks the truth
Man. At the end of the day. Mac Jones is not good.
Andy has a ton of power but he definitely takes a lot of what Veach has to say into consideration. But I think Veach likely makes the final call on defense but I can assure you if Andy doesn’t want an offensive draft pick Veach isn’t picking that guy. Veach was also not the GM when Mahomes was picked he was a director of personnel. But yeah he lobbied for Mahomes and Andy listened. But if it was a battle between them Andy probably wins.
Ik, Andy is the GM there he even hand picked Veach from Philly.
now imagine Bill would have drafted Purdy as last pick. we would call him the goat trainer.
Purdy wouldn't be doing good with this horrible Patriots team.
Belichick needs to get in check or leave me to step up recruiting and pay those guys. If not, they're going to destroy your own legacy. Your legacy is there. But I'm just saying come on Bill. William tightened up. Enlighten up. Last but least I am watching this show as much as I can. Everybody on this show is on point. Shout out to Miss Taylor! You're the most beautiful lady on all of the sports shows intelligent first right along with beauty.
He will leave questions about his legacy - but he is still going into the Hall of Fame.
Wow! thing have gotten do BAD for New England, the NFL has officially renamed the team the PATSIES.
Their offense is trash, but their defense is beat up right now. They have lost a lot of starters, they are running like 4th string DBs
11 ppg is crazy 😂😂😂😂😂
Bill is a great coach and a TERRIBLE Gm. Nothing good comes when coaches ego's get so inflated that they think they can make all personnel decisions.
Joy is so fine😮💨😮💨
but you know Brady is at home with a villains smile watching all this.....
Joy is a gorgeous woman with a brain. Can't criticize that.
All my opps got beat by 30 and it’s not even halfway through the season 😂😂. FLY EAGLES FLY 🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Matt Jones is AWFUL !!!! I don't see impressive in him at all !!! Terrible how is he in the league...
It will get worse.
Settle down everybody, do you really think that he doesn't prepare his players? It's the players who play the game. Patriots were in those first two against eagles and dolphins. Last two just looked real bad. Nobody is firing bill, he will let the kraft's know when he's retiring. Tom was a massive part of that machine back in the good ol' years!
I bet Jerry Jones feels different about him getting the head coach job now 😂😂
Such a clown take. Y’all act like Brady was a superstar those first two rings. Y’all act like the last Pats ring Bill didn’t hold the highest scoring offense in the league to 3 points while only scoring what…13 points
Can y’all leave the Pats alone? I’m sick of y’all reminding me how bad my team is. Talk about the bears…please 😞
The Patriots dynasty fell apart when Tom Brady threw an interception against The Titans in a playoff game back in 2019.
Since then, the flashing signs for a dynasty stopped flashing and went blank.
@@AmirKhan-rh6jjbragging about beating the jets wow patriots fans are is at a all time low now
Shady with the ice on he think he’s with Cam and Ma$e
don’t let this distract you from the fact the saints won 34-0 .. we gone keep balling tho , time to give stroud his 1st career int
My boy shady said batman
Any other coach in the NFL would be fired by now. I'm sure it will be a painful decision to make but it is time.
You guys don’t think that New England could be tanking for the Caleb Williams sweepstakes?? 🤔 makes sense to me…
No it doesn’t
I guess any excuse helps to ease the pain!
Why is Acho shocked? Most people can't name 4 players on that roster.
Chuck Noll,Tom Landry,Don Shula,doesn’t matter.when the all times great player or players leave. The coaches become average
Every great coach has a great QB every bad coach has a bad QB very simple
Bill is the Only guy left from the 2 decades dynasty and many great player left and the main guy the goat left. Kraft needs to take the gm and decisions away from bill he’s coaching way is outdated. It’s not like you can win elite defense and elite run game anymore it’s not the early 2000s. It’s a quarterbacks league now.
Tom Brady the goat ain’t the only one that left hall of fame players left scouts and coaches left he’s literally the only guy left from the dynasty with kids and an average roster in which he deserves blame for.
Matthew Slater
They need to stop talking about Bill if all they’re going to do is diss him for 15 min straight. smh
Don't like how they didn't talk about NO