I live inthe United States and ive owned 17 or 18 boats of different sizes and power configurations many of which have used the Apha One I will say for the record they have been very reliable and most of all pretty trouble free yes the Dog clutch system is a little Clunky but replacement drives and / or parts are easy and inexpensive to be found all over a main Activity for many of my trailer able vessels has been Waterskiing and Wake boarding and I’ve alway loved and I love the Mercruiser 135 horsepower / Alpha One combination for fuel economy and power to weight ratio and that I can run all day on just a few gallons of fuel I have found that on every boat with that setup I’ve needed to play around with propellers to get the correct torque and speed so whenever I find a decent price on a Prop I buy it and Try them out on that vessel
My boat is a 32ft princess and used in coastal waters . Its not fast , its just reliable and with fuel costs in the UK so devastating , it makes sense to only have a boat that you can afford to run . Mine goes out every weekend more than any other boat in the Marina , My z drives are ENFIELD . They are as reliabkle as the sunrise , they are as cheap as chips , and they run on old Austin mini internals . The metal in the casing is top quality with no corosion and when I look at the mercury/Volvo /OMC units encrusted with crud , my old Enfields remain as new .
We have a 1989 Penn Yan 245 Contender with a Alpha one drive the only issue we’ve had with it was with the trim system that’s only because the guy owned it before us changed the trim fluid and didn’t do it right had air in the lines besides that it’s been a reliable outdrive
@@lenbrown9912 I have a 1987 OMC Cobra with a 4.3L myself! I purchased a boat in 1995 with cracked block! So I built a 4.3L to Marine Specs with a few performance upgrades as well as a Rochester Quadra jet! I also replaced my shift and throttle cables along with the lower shift cable, All cables were adjusted to the most recent specs! The boat ran perfect, But in the Spring of 2002 I noticed drive fluid slightly leaking from the prop shaft seals! So I disassembled the whole drive cleaned and inspected all parts before resealing the whole drive along with the updated clutch dog! I have never had any issues with my boat shifting after I installed and adjusted all of the cables in correctly in 1995, But after installing the updated clutch dog it is even easier! I am willing to bet that my boat shifts as good if not better than any new boat! OMC has had some issues in the beginning, But as long as it is set up and adjusted to all of the updated specs it will function better and last longer than any other comparable drive! The problems that occur with OMC Cobra’s are not due to the drives being crappy! The problems occur and drives fail when the cables and linkages are not adjusted correctly! Do not be afraid to purchase a boat just because it has an OMC stern drive! The only repair I have had to do to my drive in the last 34 years was replace the 2 prop seals and change the fluid and impeller every season, It was by choice that I resealed the whole unit! I live in New Jersey and my boat has been docked at a Marina in saltwater all Summer every Summer since I have owned it, And yes it gets hard use fishing offshore!
Great video and explanation. I have Mercruiser Alpha one gen1. Having trouble, on the unit or online finding information to locate the stern drive serial number. Must be hidden, but where? There is a tag for the engine but no sterndrive. Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks Don. Is the sterndrive antifouled? They have a serial number engraved on the port side. if you look at a brand new Alpha sterndrive, the serial is engraved just above the "Mercruiser" sticker on port side. If it's antifouled can be difficult to find, but you need to lightly sand that area and it will hopefully eventually show.
My '04 Volvo SX drive has been bulletproof and it's been abused. I beach it in the sand all the time and have hit a few rocks. She's never let me down.
I own a 2007 340 DA Sundancer. Both drives had to be rebuilt at around 200 hrs service. Not sure what exactly we did wrong, other than not pulling the drives every year and lubing the shafts. Maybe lack of use? During Covid, and with an empty Lake Powell, it didn't get used for 2 years. But, we usually only use the boat once a season for a couple weeks.
Hard to say. I would have asked the mechanic when they had it apart if they had any insight. 200 hours seems low. There is also possibility of impact damage at some point? Was oil regularly changed?
@@BoatBuy We were having problems shifting into reverse the last few years that we actually got to use the boat. That's why we had the drives pulled. It was due for gear oil change and prop shaft lube, anyway. Then they found water in the other drive!! Once it was all apart, they wanted over $30K to put it back together! We found another shop that did the work about 1/3 of that. So, we might have gotten scammed. We've owned the boat since 2010 and never had any prop strikes that I know of. I personally changed the drive oil in 2016, but hadn't since because we hardly used it (Covid and low Lake Powell levels). I've learned my lesson on that! Do it every year! My conclusion is the dry climate and storage off the water (but indoors) may have dried all the seals. Is that possible?
The Merc Bravo 1, 2 and 3 three all share the same upper gearcase and gimble housing the only difference is the lower gear case. The Bravo 1 is meant for higher performance applications and has the nose cone water pick up. The Bravo 2 has a a much larger lower gear case allowing for large diameter props for large heavy boats. The Bravo 3 has the dual counter rotating props. It's ideal for larger single engine boats and mid sized twin engine cruisers etc. The Alpha drive is perfectly fine for smaller boats and is economical but it is a bit crude in its shifting and prone to drive shaft failure if you get up above 250 hp or have them on a larger twin engine boat. The Bravo is not all that much more money and is so much nicer to use and way more durable. I would say unless you have a 4 cylinder or V6 boat go for the Bravo. Also watch pricing when shopping new boats because usually the alpha drive pricing includes aluminum propellers and Bravo 1 and 2 pricing usually includes stainless props so the difference in price may not be as big as it seems at first glance. A Bravo 2 is a pretty significant price jump but it has two stainless props per drive and the complicated driveshaft set up. They work really well just don't hot anything with it, its get pricey fast!!!
@@davidlarroc3900 Either a one or a three would be fine. I was told by a merc rep that if the boat is less than 5000lbs then you don't really notice the benefits of the three and not worth the extra money. Also depends on performance level of the boat. If the boat is a higher performance boat get a one if its more of a heavy cruising type boat get the 3
My mother-in-law had a Wellcraft V20 with an OMC 165 back in the mid 1970’s. Had some really poor water intakes on the out drive. She also wouldn’t let me run it over 2000rpm’s! So it would overheat every time, die and leave us stranded. I knew she was wrong but there was no arguing.
I bought a boat last year (Grew 245) with an OMC 225 and OMC 800 sterndrive... not sure if she's got any life left in her. The trailer cost more than the boat but she seems solid...🤞
Nobody can forget this piece of sh.. ... Small cable for shifting system like bicycle cable (not the same price ) lot of small shafts with small splines , double housing .you had to put oil on both (separate don't forget to put oil on the upper !!!) and the best of the best the coupling between the unit and the motor,and to complete the water pump service...poor O.M.C.
FYI, Maybe you should brush up on some of your sterndrives! On alot of models the shift interrupter works for both, It decreases stress and clunking going into gear as well as making it easier to come out of gear! I guess you are not as knowledgeable as you thought!
I should add mine was an 87 Mag 350 big block which for the first 2 years used the Alpha drive which quickly proved to be problematic and the Bravo 1 was developed for that engine package. Thats long gone now as in 2006 I repowered with a 496 Mag HO Bravo 1X package.
Gidday and thanks. Great vids. I'm thinking of buying a 38 cougar cat with IPS drives but have not heard much good about them. Wondering what your thoughts are?
Hey Carl, IPS are fine if they are kept away from the bottom, and properly maintained. If it’s more than 10 years old expect a re-seal at some point. The earlier ones had some issues with sealing rings corroding. Get the updates seal rope cutters. Get an oil sample when purchasing to see if water content. Otherwise you will love them, more efficient, easier to dock etc.
Hi, im looking at buying a Whittley with a Volvo Penta V6 200 G SX, Any issues with this set-up? or should I go the OB and forego the swim platform? I've had outboards before, and a shaft drive ski boat but never a SD.
@@mad-_-observer I would be happy with either because it's so new. Most engines/sterndrives will cause you trouble later down the track (10+ years) and will you still own it then? Volvo SX drive is a good proven setup - and I think on the Whittley boats having that extra swim platform is beneficial.
Maybe you should brush up on some of your sterndrives! On alot of models the shift interrupter works for both, It decreases stress and clunking going into gear as well as making it easier to come out of gear! I guess you are not as knowledgeable as you thought!
To answer your question Ron, it’s only to ease the pressure on the shift dogs or cone clutch, momentarily making it easier to shift into the neutral position. If you have ever shifted into neutral with a malfunctioning switch, it takes considerable more lever pressure to return to neutral. It would then suddenly snap to neutral possibly overshooting it, inadvertently engaging into the opposite gear. The reason it isn’t needed or even wanted when going into gear is because the sudden load on an idling engine could cause the engine to stall. On non cone clutch stern drives and most outboards, shifting into forward or reverse gear is a bit of a misnomer. You are technically engaging forward and reverse gears, but it is done by a dog clutch attached to the prop shaft that has both forward and reverse gears rotating in opposite directions. When you shift, the clutch dog engages the cogs cut into the back of the forward or reverse gear. Hope this helps
First of all Erik he wasn’t asking a question he was trying to correct a statement that was made in the video but he was wrong, Questions usually end with a question mark! The reason why I get so defensive is because I have been a Mechanic for over 25 years and I hate when people put false information in the comment section! Why don’t you try reading his comment again and try using your brain this time and you will see that it is not a question, You’re reading comprehension is just as bad as his mechanical abilities! As a shop owner I can not even guess how many customers have brought their vehicles in for repair but ended up costing them more because they thought they could fix it themselves after watching RUclips videos! The only person who is picking a fight is you, So now that is 2 times that you were wrong!
The TRS with the Borg-Warner transmission is rock solid. The Merc trans isn’t bad but it had a female jackshaft that was problematic. It’s been over a decade since I messed with one so do your research
Hello, Boatbuy! Very nice, but also a very diplomatic evaluation on the sterndrives in the video? 😉 A question from Norway here: What can you say about the Mercruiser Bravo 1x? It is connected to a 6LPA-STZP 315hp... (The boat is 26 ft 1700 kilos) This is a boat for sale, and I like the Yanmar better than the Mercruiser/Cummins 320 that most of those boats have as stock fitted... In advance; Thanks. 🙂
Hey Nordmore! Yes, Yanmar would be my pick over the Cummins in this case. They're more popular, reliable an easier to get parts for. Just make sure you check out the exhaust elbow as they often corrode and fail. Bravo 1X is fine, it's got water pickups on the front and is the more "speedy" version of the Bravo 2. Provided its an X drive it should be suitable for diesel.
@@BoatBuy Thank you for a good answer. 🙂 They are going for "corona-prices" yet, but price level must come down when they now start to open up for traveling again.
Currently have a Bravo II mated to 454 Merc large block. The Bravo II is a strong outdrive. Do you know if I can put a dual prop on this outdrive (if I change the lower part and attach to Bravo II) ?
I have seen people do this before but you will need to check ratios! You can do this by counting the teeth inside the gearbox to figure it out. If you're not careful you could have a ratio not suitable for your boat. Personally I think Bravo 2 is a more reliable sterndrive than the Bravo 3 duo-propellor.
I've replaced the three with the one..owners didn't have the money to replace the bravo 3, bravo gear ratio is in the lower unit, alphas gear ratio is in the upper unit..mercruiser blows away volvo ', plus can't get parts for cobras..use aftermarket crap on cobra it has no durability at all..
Bravo 2 was good to around 55 mph. Bravo 3...65 mph range. So if your boat is not approaching 55 mph you will not gain anything moving to the 3 IMO. I assume you have a heavy cruiser type boat, which the Bravo 2 was designed for.
@@ericbryant796 yes, I have a Bayliner Ciera (flybridge) 2858 with 454 Merc large block. I thought I would stick with bravo II. It’s very strong according to my mechanic. I don’t need to get on plane fast and I don’t need to go pass 55 mph. Would be nice to backup better and have more control around the docks. I was thinking perhaps thrusters would be an alternative to control my bow better.
@@BoatBuy Bit late now, but I had volvo dp drives with volvo 41 s in my charter boat. I worked them harder than any leisure boater ever would. Was under powered so ran them flat out everywhere. Never put a spanner on them, oil and filters every hundred hours, Mobil one in the leg . Traded them in every three years. I would buy that set up again tomorrow.
@@Graham19951 Yes, surprisingly there is a few charter boats around with similar setup. The Volvo sterndrives I would say can be better behind a diesel in some cases (depending on the model!).
My boat has the Alpha 1 stern drive. 5.7L V8 that’s tuned to roughly 400Hp. With a 21P stainless prop I can reach 55mph. What size, pitch, and type of prop would you recommend to go faster and be more efficient? Just subscribed.
Hey. I have a mercruiser 6.2 and when I push the throttle the engine hesitates for about 0.5 seconds and goes down about 50 to 100 RPM and then it accelerates normal. I dont have a beep alarm but i ordered a tec mate pro II that will come in a few days. Does anybody has a hint for me what i can look for? And I think it will not reach the top speed I had once before.
Replace the fuel filters...especially the small white disc filter at the bottom of the fuel filter housing...that one is often overlooked and will cause a fuel flow issue resulting in loss of top end speed.
@@ericbryant796 thank you very much. I ordered a fuel filter but I think I dont have this type of filter that You speak of. I have a stainless steel inline filter with pressure fittings on both ends right before the fuel pump. Dont know if it was ever changed. It is a 2003 6.2 mercruiser. And my boat has a Coolfuel System after the pump and water separator. But I think that this version of cool fuel doesnt have another filter but I'm not 100% sure. Thanks again for your hints and greetings from the V8Lounge in germany. US Boats are the best :)
@@V8Lounge The cool fuel system has 2 filters...the main metal cartridge and a small disc filter. That one is often overlooked even my Merc mechanics and parts dept. Sorry I don't have the P/N available but it sits below the main filter at the bottom of the housing. You'll need a needle nose plyers to remove it, its a white plastic disc with white (when new) filter media.
Hi there awesome vids👍 need your help asap please thinking of buying a 2006 Yamaha 90hp 2stroke did a compression test outcome was 95psi even on all 3 cylinders is this something to worry about or is it good? Going on a 5.8 aluminium boat. Much appreciated cheers mate.
As long as they’re all even it sounds normal. 95 seems low, but it could be the gauge. How many hours on the engine? Best to give it a test run if possible.
Sounds good to me. As long as all cylinders are no more than 10% off from highest to lowest. A couple pointers: Make sure engine temp remains constant throughout the test. ie dont start with a warm engine then take a beer break between holes. make sure ALL the spark plugs are out. Throttle in the wide open position Battery fully charged(I put on a battery charger) Crank until the needle no longer moves, usually 5-10 seconds
2 drives worth the cash, Bravo 1 & King Cobra, the remainder you can have, enjoy the maintenance to keep them working properly. For sheer reliability Speed Masters & IMCO regardless of torque output
You mean a 460 cubic inch? Depends on the HP output, but the Volvo 280 is relatively old drive. You'd just need to figure out how much HP they can handle, the engine behind it won't really matter.
Hey Edwin, Depends how many areas you break it down into. Generally there is sterndrive, transom assembly and engine, although you could say upper and lower, bellows, etc.
Not mentioned on here , but one I would not have free is a Yamaha outdrive. Bullet proof engines (Toyota landcruiser) but the Hydra drive will break you.
@@valefur72 I have to disagree with you. We fish with sterndrives commercialy. I used volvo, and with the stainless clutch they are very good , Some guys have the Mercruser and they seem ok. But the guys who bought the Yamaha hydra drive cant keep them running long enough to earn a living.. Yamaha outboards , bullet proof ive had about 15 but their sterndrives no way.
@@Graham19951 for sure the most reliable and popular outdrive is the Bravo 2. Simple and thought, they may have some leaking issues, but they never let you down. Volvo and Mercruiser have the monopoly in this sector and it's very difficult to make something good as they do...
I dont mean to be offtopic but does any of you know of a method to get back into an instagram account? I was stupid lost the password. I appreciate any tips you can offer me
@Kelvin Ameer i really appreciate your reply. I found the site thru google and im in the hacking process now. Seems to take quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
Good engine good drive. The 4.3 is just a Chevy 350 small block with 2 cylinders chopped off. Very good engines, and Alphas are very good drives. Just be gentle on acceleration, don't go WOT suddenly and your Alpha will last longer than the boat.
Only thing I’m adding is I’d never own any Volvo I/O. Something goes wrong, you will be reaching so deep in your pockets for money you’ll be touching your toes!
The alpha one drives which he speaks of also shut the engine off for a brief 2nd when you shift into gear to avoid mashing gears together which gives it a much safer shift
Actually that statement is false, The only problem with the OMC Cobras were the owners! My OMC Cobra is 35 years old and except for changing the fluid, impeller and anodes I had absolutely zero issues, In 2004 I decided to do a full teardown inspect and reseal just for preventative maintenance due to its age! I live in New Jersey and my boat is docked in salt water from June through September and gets used every weekend, Some weekends I may just take some friends out crabbing or to the sandbar swimming but usually I am no less than 25 miles offshore! I guarantee if you drove my boat you would think that it was drive by wire! When the OMC Cobra first came out they did have a few issues just like all the other drives did, Shortly after owners were sent letters for them to bring their boats to a OMC Service center to have the updated parts installed into their drives! I am repairing Cobras today that still do not have those updated parts installed despite it being 30 years later! Oh and by the way my motor is a modified 4.3L pushing 276hp on a dyno spinning a SS Prop!Anyone who claims that the OMC cobras are junk are clearly suffering from a lack of mechanical knowledge!
@@NeverEnoughPyro40 It is not a false statement, your experiences just differ from most. What boat and what engine is in front of your drive also matter a great deal. I have seen plenty of well maintained Cobra drives that have had small as well as large issues, but the point here is actually not the issues themselves. The problem lies in the fact that IF you get your hands on a Cobra, especially one with a questionable past, you are in a bad spot if you need parts.Yes you can get impellers and anodes, but you are screwed if you need gears or shafts as those have not been in production for 20 years or so. Overall the avoidance has little to do with the actual durability of the drive but everything to do with a lack of spare parts. Your drive is 35 years old, and at some point you will need to look at new internals. When that time comes, you will have a very hard time sourcing what you need. The problem simply also is that while that drive might live with a small 200-250 hp engine, those mated to larger engines, especially on heavy boats, are on borrowed time. It's not just idiot owners not taking care of things, when you buy a boat with a drive that is 30+ years old, you WILL more than likely have to do some more in-depth maintenance at some point. That goes for Mercruiser, Volvo Penta and Cobra drives. I know how to treat a drive and I know how to rebuild them with proper mesh etc. I see people who kill Bravo drives with 430 hp while I can make them live with 650 hp. I'm not saying Cobras are just "junk", I'm saying they are old drives that can extremely expensive because there is no support, and because it was never a good drive for bigger power boats, and they were not good at handling towing duties behind the family runabout where you also find a lot of them.
Not really correct. I ran a charter hardboat with a Volvo 260 drive. I hammered the crap out of it, but I changed the oils every 100 hours and used Mobil one in the leg. I did more each year than a sport boat would do in ten, and it was bullet proof. I will say I changed the engine and leg every three years, but it had a hard three years.
![Outboard vs Sterndrive [ Inboard Outboard vs outboard ] Which is Best? why? Inboard vs outboard](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SMcsnB8S5Ng/mqdefault.jpg)
How would you rate the Yamaha sterndrive that’s coupled with the landcruiser 4.2 turbo d
I live inthe United States and ive owned 17 or 18 boats of different sizes and power configurations many of which have used the Apha One I will say for the record they have been very reliable and most of all pretty trouble free yes the Dog clutch system is a little Clunky but replacement drives and / or parts are easy and inexpensive to be found all over a main Activity for many of my trailer able vessels has been Waterskiing and Wake boarding and I’ve alway loved and I love the Mercruiser 135 horsepower / Alpha One combination for fuel economy and power to weight ratio and that I can run all day on just a few gallons of fuel I have found that on every boat with that setup I’ve needed to play around with propellers to get the correct torque and speed so whenever I find a decent price on a Prop I buy it and Try them out on that vessel
I agree. I think Allphas are good because if one blows, you’re not out of pocket nearly as much as a Bravo!
My 1998 Volvo 5.7 GS is still in service. Runs great!
FWC since new.
My boat is a 32ft princess and used in coastal waters . Its not fast , its just reliable and with fuel costs in the UK so devastating , it makes sense to only have a boat that you can afford to run . Mine goes out every weekend more than any other boat in the Marina , My z drives are ENFIELD . They are as reliabkle as the sunrise , they are as cheap as chips , and they run on old Austin mini internals . The metal in the casing is top quality with no corosion and when I look at the mercury/Volvo /OMC units encrusted with crud , my old Enfields remain as new .
Good to hear Jonathan. Never heard of one of them over here but sounds great!
Really enjoy your channel. Great content. I often share it with my customers who are interested in buying a boat. Well done!
Thank you! 😀
We have a 1989 Penn Yan 245 Contender with a Alpha one drive the only issue we’ve had with it was with the trim system that’s only because the guy owned it before us changed the trim fluid and didn’t do it right had air in the lines besides that it’s been a reliable outdrive
Nice! Thanks! How do you tell if you have Generation 1 or 2 Alpha 1? How about how to determine the gear ratio?
As a 10 year boat mechanic. This was 100% true.
How about cobra omc? (4.3)
@@lenbrown9912 I have a 1987 OMC Cobra with a 4.3L myself! I purchased a boat in 1995 with cracked block! So I built a 4.3L to Marine Specs with a few performance upgrades as well as a Rochester Quadra jet! I also replaced my shift and throttle cables along with the lower shift cable, All cables were adjusted to the most recent specs! The boat ran perfect, But in the Spring of 2002 I noticed drive fluid slightly leaking from the prop shaft seals! So I disassembled the whole drive cleaned and inspected all parts before resealing the whole drive along with the updated clutch dog! I have never had any issues with my boat shifting after I installed and adjusted all of the cables in correctly in 1995, But after installing the updated clutch dog it is even easier! I am willing to bet that my boat shifts as good if not better than any new boat! OMC has had some issues in the beginning, But as long as it is set up and adjusted to all of the updated specs it will function better and last longer than any other comparable drive! The problems that occur with OMC Cobra’s are not due to the drives being crappy! The problems occur and drives fail when the cables and linkages are not adjusted correctly!
Do not be afraid to purchase a boat just because it has an OMC stern drive! The only repair I have had to do to my drive in the last 34 years was replace the 2 prop seals and change the fluid and impeller every season, It was by choice that I resealed the whole unit! I live in New Jersey and my boat has been docked at a Marina in saltwater all Summer every Summer since I have owned it, And yes it gets hard use fishing offshore!
Thank you!
@@lenbrown9912 the 4.3 is nothing wrong at all. But omc is not a good idea. Main thing is they have been out of business for almost 30 years now.
Great video and explanation. I have Mercruiser Alpha one gen1. Having trouble, on the unit or online finding information to locate the stern drive serial number. Must be hidden, but where? There is a tag for the engine but no sterndrive. Any help would be appreciated.
Thanks Don. Is the sterndrive antifouled? They have a serial number engraved on the port side. if you look at a brand new Alpha sterndrive, the serial is engraved just above the "Mercruiser" sticker on port side. If it's antifouled can be difficult to find, but you need to lightly sand that area and it will hopefully eventually show.
@@BoatBuy Thanks, found the s/n embossed underneath the decal on the starboard side of the outdrive. By the way, not sure what antifouled is??
@@donens9310 antifoul is what you paint on the bottom to stop barnacle growth.
My '04 Volvo SX drive has been bulletproof and it's been abused. I beach it in the sand all the time and have hit a few rocks. She's never let me down.
You run with a stainless steel prop or aluminum?
Good to hear you’ve enjoyed it and it’s been good!
I own a 2007 340 DA Sundancer. Both drives had to be rebuilt at around 200 hrs service. Not sure what exactly we did wrong, other than not pulling the drives every year and lubing the shafts. Maybe lack of use? During Covid, and with an empty Lake Powell, it didn't get used for 2 years. But, we usually only use the boat once a season for a couple weeks.
Hard to say. I would have asked the mechanic when they had it apart if they had any insight. 200 hours seems low. There is also possibility of impact damage at some point? Was oil regularly changed?
@@BoatBuy We were having problems shifting into reverse the last few years that we actually got to use the boat. That's why we had the drives pulled. It was due for gear oil change and prop shaft lube, anyway. Then they found water in the other drive!! Once it was all apart, they wanted over $30K to put it back together! We found another shop that did the work about 1/3 of that. So, we might have gotten scammed. We've owned the boat since 2010 and never had any prop strikes that I know of. I personally changed the drive oil in 2016, but hadn't since because we hardly used it (Covid and low Lake Powell levels). I've learned my lesson on that! Do it every year! My conclusion is the dry climate and storage off the water (but indoors) may have dried all the seals. Is that possible?
Yeah. It's pretty normal for 10+ year old seals to dry out unfortunately...
Yeah 30k is ridiculous, could buy two new legs for less...
The best stern drive is the one that is properly maintained
Except for an xdp lol, still a ticking time bomb.
Yes, maintenance is key!
Facts
What about the
SP CD trim
Volvo ?
I’m surprised omc cobra wasn’t mentioned
We don't really see them very often in Australia!
The Merc Bravo 1, 2 and 3 three all share the same upper gearcase and gimble housing the only difference is the lower gear case. The Bravo 1 is meant for higher performance applications and has the nose cone water pick up. The Bravo 2 has a a much larger lower gear case allowing for large diameter props for large heavy boats. The Bravo 3 has the dual counter rotating props. It's ideal for larger single engine boats and mid sized twin engine cruisers etc. The Alpha drive is perfectly fine for smaller boats and is economical but it is a bit crude in its shifting and prone to drive shaft failure if you get up above 250 hp or have them on a larger twin engine boat. The Bravo is not all that much more money and is so much nicer to use and way more durable. I would say unless you have a 4 cylinder or V6 boat go for the Bravo. Also watch pricing when shopping new boats because usually the alpha drive pricing includes aluminum propellers and Bravo 1 and 2 pricing usually includes stainless props so the difference in price may not be as big as it seems at first glance. A Bravo 2 is a pretty significant price jump but it has two stainless props per drive and the complicated driveshaft set up. They work really well just don't hot anything with it, its get pricey fast!!!
Yep! Over in Aus a Bravo drive alone is around 11k, and an Alpha about half (without a prop). If you hit something it gets expensive!
So which bravo would you recommend for 20' to 23' boat ?
@@davidlarroc3900 Either a one or a three would be fine. I was told by a merc rep that if the boat is less than 5000lbs then you don't really notice the benefits of the three and not worth the extra money. Also depends on performance level of the boat. If the boat is a higher performance boat get a one if its more of a heavy cruising type boat get the 3
Anyone remember the old OMC stringer drives? Trim was done with screw jacks on the front motor mounts.
My mother-in-law had a Wellcraft V20 with an OMC 165 back in the mid 1970’s. Had some really poor water intakes on the out drive. She also wouldn’t let me run it over 2000rpm’s! So it would overheat every time, die and leave us stranded. I knew she was wrong but there was no arguing.
I bought a boat last year (Grew 245) with an OMC 225 and OMC 800 sterndrive... not sure if she's got any life left in her. The trailer cost more than the boat but she seems solid...🤞
Hahaha
Great drive, turned like a dream. Stick a cotter pin in the shift convertor to remove shift cables-ahh the good old days.
Nobody can forget this piece of sh.. ... Small cable for shifting system like bicycle cable (not the same price ) lot of small shafts with small splines , double housing .you had to put oil on both (separate don't forget to put oil on the upper !!!) and the best of the best the coupling between the unit and the motor,and to complete the water pump service...poor O.M.C.
Does anyone know is it possable for a alpha 1 to slip or is that prop related?
Alpha 1 has a dog clutch so likely propellor or drive bush related.
Fyi the ignition interrupt switch only works when you shift OUT of gear, not when you shift into gear.
FYI, Maybe you should brush up on some of your sterndrives! On alot of models the shift interrupter works for both, It decreases stress and clunking going into gear as well as making it easier to come out of gear! I guess you are not as knowledgeable as you thought!
Correct, I picked up on that!
@@NeverEnoughPyro40 ok. Name them
Mine cut out shifting in and out. Just depends on the setup.
I should add mine was an 87 Mag 350 big block which for the first 2 years used the Alpha drive which quickly proved to be problematic and the Bravo 1 was developed for that engine package.
Thats long gone now as in 2006 I repowered with a 496 Mag HO Bravo 1X package.
Gidday and thanks. Great vids. I'm thinking of buying a 38 cougar cat with IPS drives but have not heard much good about them. Wondering what your thoughts are?
Hey Carl,
IPS are fine if they are kept away from the bottom, and properly maintained.
If it’s more than 10 years old expect a re-seal at some point. The earlier ones had some issues with sealing rings corroding.
Get the updates seal rope cutters.
Get an oil sample when purchasing to see if water content.
Otherwise you will love them, more efficient, easier to dock etc.
Hi, im looking at buying a Whittley with a Volvo Penta V6 200 G SX, Any issues with this set-up? or should I go the OB and forego the swim platform? I've had outboards before, and a shaft drive ski boat but never a SD.
What year model?
@@BoatBuy Hi thanks for replying, its a 2019 Cr2180 and there's OB version around the same money somewhere else Cairns i think.
@@mad-_-observer I would be happy with either because it's so new. Most engines/sterndrives will cause you trouble later down the track (10+ years) and will you still own it then? Volvo SX drive is a good proven setup - and I think on the Whittley boats having that extra swim platform is beneficial.
@@BoatBuy I agree, having that platform with a bbq and bait board is hard to go past. Thanks for the advice.
hello, please note the reason for the ignition cut is to be able to shift out of gear not to be able to shift into gear.
Maybe you should brush up on some of your sterndrives! On alot of models the shift interrupter works for both, It decreases stress and clunking going into gear as well as making it easier to come out of gear! I guess you are not as knowledgeable as you thought!
@@NeverEnoughPyro40 wtf is your problem? Dude was asking a question. If you want to pick a fight, pick a fight with me!
To answer your question Ron, it’s only to ease the pressure on the shift dogs or cone clutch, momentarily making it easier to shift into the neutral position. If you have ever shifted into neutral with a malfunctioning switch, it takes considerable more lever pressure to return to neutral. It would then suddenly snap to neutral possibly overshooting it, inadvertently engaging into the opposite gear.
The reason it isn’t needed or even wanted when going into gear is because the sudden load on an idling engine could cause the engine to stall.
On non cone clutch stern drives and most outboards, shifting into forward or reverse gear is a bit of a misnomer. You are technically engaging forward and reverse gears, but it is done by a dog clutch attached to the prop shaft that has both forward and reverse gears rotating in opposite directions. When you shift, the clutch dog engages the cogs cut into the back of the forward or reverse gear.
Hope this helps
First of all Erik he wasn’t asking a question he was trying to correct a statement that was made in the video but he was wrong, Questions usually end with a question mark! The reason why I get so defensive is because I have been a Mechanic for over 25 years and I hate when people put false information in the comment section! Why don’t you try reading his comment again and try using your brain this time and you will see that it is not a question, You’re reading comprehension is just as bad as his mechanical abilities! As a shop owner I can not even guess how many customers have brought their vehicles in for repair but ended up costing them more because they thought they could fix it themselves after watching RUclips videos! The only person who is picking a fight is you, So now that is 2 times that you were wrong!
I'd like to know your take on trs outdrives
The TRS with the Borg-Warner transmission is rock solid. The Merc trans isn’t bad but it had a female jackshaft that was problematic. It’s been over a decade since I messed with one so do your research
As Capt Slew said - rock solid but dated. Bit before my time, but they were superseded by the Bravo drives...
@@BoatBuy Don't owners of boats designed for stern drives have both jet drive and outboard options? if they just don't like stern drives?
@@alan6832 Not always. In some models they do, but would be a different mould for an outboard powered boat as opposed to sterndrive.
@@BoatBuy I see boats converted pretty often with bolt on transoms to mount the outboards.
Hello, Boatbuy!
Very nice, but also a very diplomatic evaluation on the sterndrives in the video? 😉
A question from Norway here:
What can you say about the Mercruiser Bravo 1x?
It is connected to a 6LPA-STZP 315hp...
(The boat is 26 ft 1700 kilos)
This is a boat for sale, and I like the Yanmar better than the Mercruiser/Cummins 320 that most of those boats have as stock fitted...
In advance; Thanks. 🙂
Hey Nordmore! Yes, Yanmar would be my pick over the Cummins in this case. They're more popular, reliable an easier to get parts for. Just make sure you check out the exhaust elbow as they often corrode and fail. Bravo 1X is fine, it's got water pickups on the front and is the more "speedy" version of the Bravo 2. Provided its an X drive it should be suitable for diesel.
@@BoatBuy
Thank you for a good answer. 🙂
They are going for "corona-prices" yet, but price level must come down when they now start to open up for traveling again.
i just bought a yanmar zt370 outdrive hope its good
Don’t worry about the bellows if you rip the drive off it will hang on by them lol
Nice! How you finding it?
Anyone know where to get a owners manual of a volvo penta sp drive???
Should be able to get owners manual on Volvo website with serial number
Currently have a Bravo II mated to 454 Merc large block. The Bravo II is a strong outdrive. Do you know if I can put a dual prop on this outdrive (if I change the lower part and attach to Bravo II) ?
I have seen people do this before but you will need to check ratios! You can do this by counting the teeth inside the gearbox to figure it out. If you're not careful you could have a ratio not suitable for your boat.
Personally I think Bravo 2 is a more reliable sterndrive than the Bravo 3 duo-propellor.
I've replaced the three with the one..owners didn't have the money to replace the bravo 3, bravo gear ratio is in the lower unit, alphas gear ratio is in the upper unit..mercruiser blows away volvo ', plus can't get parts for cobras..use aftermarket crap on cobra it has no durability at all..
@@bigjohn9536 interesting ,usually people are drawn to the bravo 3, not the bravo 1
Bravo 2 was good to around 55 mph. Bravo 3...65 mph range. So if your boat is not approaching 55 mph you will not gain anything moving to the 3 IMO. I assume you have a heavy cruiser type boat, which the Bravo 2 was designed for.
@@ericbryant796 yes, I have a Bayliner Ciera (flybridge) 2858 with 454 Merc large block. I thought I would stick with bravo II. It’s very strong according to my mechanic. I don’t need to get on plane fast and I don’t need to go pass 55 mph. Would be nice to backup better and have more control around the docks. I was thinking perhaps thrusters would be an alternative to control my bow better.
Do you prefer Volvo dp stern drive or Mercruiser bravo 3 on a 35 to 37ft inboard ? the better one's ?
I'd say a Volvo DP - but if you did get a Bravo 3 go for the X-drive.
@@BoatBuy Bit late now, but I had volvo dp drives with volvo 41 s in my charter boat. I worked them harder than any leisure boater ever would. Was under powered so ran them flat out everywhere. Never put a spanner on them, oil and filters every hundred hours, Mobil one in the leg . Traded them in every three years. I would buy that set up again tomorrow.
@@Graham19951 Yes, surprisingly there is a few charter boats around with similar setup. The Volvo sterndrives I would say can be better behind a diesel in some cases (depending on the model!).
My boat has the Alpha 1 stern drive. 5.7L V8 that’s tuned to roughly 400Hp. With a 21P stainless prop I can reach 55mph. What size, pitch, and type of prop would you recommend to go faster and be more efficient?
Just subscribed.
What RPM are you currently getting at full throttle?
There is always a trade off depending on if you pitch up or down.
What boat do you have? I’ve got an unmodified 5.7 mpi in a Haines signature 610bt and pull 95kph with a 19P prop.
Gen1 or gen2
@@BoatBuy 5500rpm.
@@horsehead8306 Edson Challenger GT. Another guy told me as well that he gets 60mph with a 19p prop.
Hey. I have a mercruiser 6.2 and when I push the throttle the engine hesitates for about 0.5 seconds and goes down about 50 to 100 RPM and then it accelerates normal. I dont have a beep alarm but i ordered a tec mate pro II that will come in a few days. Does anybody has a hint for me what i can look for? And I think it will not reach the top speed I had once before.
Replace the fuel filters...especially the small white disc filter at the bottom of the fuel filter housing...that one is often overlooked and will cause a fuel flow issue resulting in loss of top end speed.
@@ericbryant796 thank you very much. I ordered a fuel filter but I think I dont have this type of filter that You speak of. I have a stainless steel inline filter with pressure fittings on both ends right before the fuel pump. Dont know if it was ever changed.
It is a 2003 6.2 mercruiser.
And my boat has a Coolfuel System after the pump and water separator. But I think that this version of cool fuel doesnt have another filter but I'm not 100% sure.
Thanks again for your hints and greetings from the V8Lounge in germany.
US Boats are the best :)
If you have the cool fuel module it will have a filter, there is 3-4 8mm bolts holding it in from memory.
But sounds like a fuel issue.
@@V8Lounge The cool fuel system has 2 filters...the main metal cartridge and a small disc filter. That one is often overlooked even my Merc mechanics and parts dept. Sorry I don't have the P/N available but it sits below the main filter at the bottom of the housing. You'll need a needle nose plyers to remove it, its a white plastic disc with white (when new) filter media.
Hi there awesome vids👍 need your help asap please thinking of buying a 2006 Yamaha 90hp 2stroke did a compression test outcome was 95psi even on all 3 cylinders is this something to worry about or is it good? Going on a 5.8 aluminium boat. Much appreciated cheers mate.
As long as they’re all even it sounds normal. 95 seems low, but it could be the gauge. How many hours on the engine? Best to give it a test run if possible.
@@BoatBuy awesome mate thank you much appreciated! It's done 250hrs
Sounds good to me. As long as all cylinders are no more than 10% off from highest to lowest.
A couple pointers:
Make sure engine temp remains constant throughout the test. ie dont start with a warm engine then take a beer break between holes.
make sure ALL the spark plugs are out.
Throttle in the wide open position
Battery fully charged(I put on a battery charger)
Crank until the needle no longer moves, usually 5-10 seconds
2 drives worth the cash, Bravo 1 & King Cobra, the remainder you can have, enjoy the maintenance to keep them working properly. For sheer reliability Speed Masters & IMCO regardless of torque output
Nothing like having a drive with a cobra decal on it lol. V8 kings where good.
Yes I have had a good experience with Bravp 2 as well.
Excellent info and well presented/
Thanks Joe!
Which one do I avoid? The 6th? No bashing on the OMC Stringer huh?
OMC stringer isn’t real popular in Australia. Can’t really say!
@@BoatBuy Ah, that would explain it.
Okay this a serious question Volvo Penta 280 with ford 460 right now it has a 350 just wondering.
You mean a 460 cubic inch? Depends on the HP output, but the Volvo 280 is relatively old drive. You'd just need to figure out how much HP they can handle, the engine behind it won't really matter.
Hi, how many components in sterndrive? (1)engine (2)sterndrive case (3)upper & lower sterndrive. Thanks
Hey Edwin,
Depends how many areas you break it down into. Generally there is sterndrive, transom assembly and engine, although you could say upper and lower, bellows, etc.
@@BoatBuy 👏Thanks for your reply, between engine and sterndrive got cover....so how to call this component?
Not mentioned on here , but one I would not have free is a Yamaha outdrive. Bullet proof engines (Toyota landcruiser) but the Hydra drive will break you.
Yeah - thankfully we don't come across them often in Australia!
Yamaha sterndrives are made in Italy, by Selva Marine. They are good, but very rare.
@@valefur72 I have to disagree with you. We fish with sterndrives commercialy. I used volvo, and with the stainless clutch they are very good , Some guys have the Mercruser and they seem ok. But the guys who bought the Yamaha hydra drive cant keep them running long enough to earn a living.. Yamaha outboards , bullet proof ive had about 15 but their sterndrives no way.
@@Graham19951 for sure the most reliable and popular outdrive is the Bravo 2. Simple and thought, they may have some leaking issues, but they never let you down. Volvo and Mercruiser have the monopoly in this sector and it's very difficult to make something good as they do...
Btw Alpha ignition cut is to disengage, not to engage.
Copy!
ran ALFAS for 25 years nothing but trouble I Went outboard love it
How many Alphas did you go through in 25 years?
Very nicely explained.
Thank you!
What's the best way to clean salt spray off miscellaneous engine parts, etc-- after you've fixed the issue of a leaky seawater pump?
Usually wash it down with fresh water, dry it out and then spray some corrosion guard ASAP!
I have a 1995 chaparral with a Volvo penta dp
Nice!
Volvo DPSM all the way, I do all of them and that the one that never gives me a bad day
Not a bad option!
@@BoatBuy stern drives are the Devil lol, shafts all day
@@Deltarig Definitely wouldn't say no to a shaft drive!
awesome work mate, thank you!
I dont mean to be offtopic but does any of you know of a method to get back into an instagram account?
I was stupid lost the password. I appreciate any tips you can offer me
@Brennan Kohen Instablaster :)
@Kelvin Ameer i really appreciate your reply. I found the site thru google and im in the hacking process now.
Seems to take quite some time so I will get back to you later with my results.
Thank you!
I’ve got a mercruiser 4.3L with a alpha one stern drive 1995. All good? I hope
Good engine good drive. The 4.3 is just a Chevy 350 small block with 2 cylinders chopped off. Very good engines, and Alphas are very good drives. Just be gentle on acceleration, don't go WOT suddenly and your Alpha will last longer than the boat.
@@FeatheredDino awesome to hear. I live on the Great Lakes all fresh water
Yes the V6 and Alpha package is good.
By far the biggest problem sterndrive must surely be the BMW series 1. Surely?
😂😂
Konrad sterndrives ??
Don’t come across them over here!
VOLVO 290 WERE GOOD BULLIT PROOF IF SERVICED from GB
It's Volvo, of course it's bullet proof.
Yes, a good option!
As someone who worked on all VP stern drives, the XTP is a legitimate piece of garbage.
How many have you had to rebuild? ;-)
Just keep the bilge dry or the water will destroy the starter.
Absolutely agree.
Didn’t even have to click the video to know.... avoid OMC
Haha! Nothing about OMC in here 😅We’re in 2021
I have dp290 on my boat
Nice, how you finding it?
Its a good outdrive
Volvo penta power baby
Only thing I’m adding is I’d never own any Volvo I/O. Something goes wrong, you will be reaching so deep in your pockets for money you’ll be touching your toes!
Same situation with a mercruiser drive. Plan on $5000. To $9000. To fix the POS
The alpha one drives which he speaks of also shut the engine off for a brief 2nd when you shift into gear to avoid mashing gears together which gives it a much safer shift
It’s for disengagement of meshed gears (shifting out)
Yes, it’s for the dog clutch!
Also the Volvo DPH is very unreliable...
I've found the DPH to be one of the better options when it comes to sterndrives.
If there ever was a drive to avoid, it was the OMC Cobra drive.
Actually that statement is false, The only problem with the OMC Cobras were the owners! My OMC Cobra is 35 years old and except for changing the fluid, impeller and anodes I had absolutely zero issues, In 2004 I decided to do a full teardown inspect and reseal just for preventative maintenance due to its age! I live in New Jersey and my boat is docked in salt water from June through September and gets used every weekend, Some weekends I may just take some friends out crabbing or to the sandbar swimming but usually I am no less than 25 miles offshore! I guarantee if you drove my boat you would think that it was drive by wire! When the OMC Cobra first came out they did have a few issues just like all the other drives did, Shortly after owners were sent letters for them to bring their boats to a OMC Service center to have the updated parts installed into their drives! I am repairing Cobras today that still do not have those updated parts installed despite it being 30 years later! Oh and by the way my motor is a modified 4.3L pushing 276hp on a dyno spinning a SS Prop!Anyone who claims that the OMC cobras are junk are clearly suffering from a lack of mechanical knowledge!
@@NeverEnoughPyro40 It is not a false statement, your experiences just differ from most. What boat and what engine is in front of your drive also matter a great deal.
I have seen plenty of well maintained Cobra drives that have had small as well as large issues, but the point here is actually not the issues themselves. The problem lies in the fact that IF you get your hands on a Cobra, especially one with a questionable past, you are in a bad spot if you need parts.Yes you can get impellers and anodes, but you are screwed if you need gears or shafts as those have not been in production for 20 years or so. Overall the avoidance has little to do with the actual durability of the drive but everything to do with a lack of spare parts. Your drive is 35 years old, and at some point you will need to look at new internals. When that time comes, you will have a very hard time sourcing what you need.
The problem simply also is that while that drive might live with a small 200-250 hp engine, those mated to larger engines, especially on heavy boats, are on borrowed time. It's not just idiot owners not taking care of things, when you buy a boat with a drive that is 30+ years old, you WILL more than likely have to do some more in-depth maintenance at some point. That goes for Mercruiser, Volvo Penta and Cobra drives. I know how to treat a drive and I know how to rebuild them with proper mesh etc. I see people who kill Bravo drives with 430 hp while I can make them live with 650 hp. I'm not saying Cobras are just "junk", I'm saying they are old drives that can extremely expensive because there is no support, and because it was never a good drive for bigger power boats, and they were not good at handling towing duties behind the family runabout where you also find a lot of them.
We don’t really get them over in Australia!
Omc cobra
Don’t see too many of them over here!
Oi dan't understand what he's siaying Should work on es English. Sorry, love lymeys but work on it!
Sorry! I will practice my english for the next video!
Avoid all of them.
Not really correct. I ran a charter hardboat with a Volvo 260 drive. I hammered the crap out of it, but I changed the oils every 100 hours and used Mobil one in the leg. I did more each year than a sport boat would do in ten, and it was bullet proof. I will say I changed the engine and leg every three years, but it had a hard three years.
Not a fan eh? ;-)
Avoid stern drive of any brand ❗️❗️
Not a fan eh?
this is a joke right? volvo penta is the worst stern drive known to mankind they are trash!!!!
I don’t agree. Mine is smooth as silk and well maintained.
My Volvo Aquamatic 270 Is still going well, powered by a high speed turbo charged diesel. I think forty year of use may say something about quality.
My DP is much smoother shifting and reliable than of any of the multiple Mercruisers I have owned over the years.
thats awesome me and my dad had nothing but nightmares on both our tern drives it was terrible breaking down on vacations
My dp 290 is smooth and reliable
Great info. 🛥️🛥️🛥️🛥️
Thanks T!