The Truth about Bayern Munich Controversial Offside Goal

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 май 2024
  • #football #soccer #shorts #bayern #bayernmunich #offside #realmadrid
    In this video we will make deep analysis about the Bayern Munich controversial offside goal, in the match real Madrid vs Bayern Munich, Bayern Munich vs real Madrid champions league. you will see if it was truly a goal or not and wether the referees or officials where right with their decision.
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 300

  • @napoleonpazi8167
    @napoleonpazi8167 18 дней назад +59

    The offside line you got there is totally wrong 😂😂 you have no idea what offside is and you go ahead and make a video out of it

    • @CJSteib
      @CJSteib 16 дней назад +3

      He even said that bayern had the knockdown but it was real madrid who headed it... clearly. Obviously the bayern players were involved so theyd be offsides anyway, but he managed to get so much wrong in a 1 minute analysis

    • @marikosbrando
      @marikosbrando 15 дней назад +2

      ​@CJSteib mazroui was the targets of that pass he was onside that pass what is headed back went to Müller it was a clear goal and he is right nevertheless he said wrong stuff as well bayern got robbed again as usual

    • @CJSteib
      @CJSteib 15 дней назад +2

      @@marikosbrando No I'm a liverpool fan and was rooting for Bayern, but that wasn't a goal... the offsides line in this clip is incorrect.

    • @tarekcrash9512
      @tarekcrash9512 15 дней назад +2

      Soo it wasn't a goal huh are you sure .? It because you don't know anything about that match huh ​@@CJSteib

    • @bakerlefdaoui6801
      @bakerlefdaoui6801 15 дней назад +2

      Does he actualy know that knees count for offsides? It's pretty clear that Mazraoui's knee is offside compared to rudiger's leg/shoulder. Since Deligt forced the movement of Rudiger towards him instead of covering Mazraoui who is supposedly onside, he influenced the action while offside. In both cases it is an offside, and that's why referee stopped the game. When you don't influence the action whatsoever, that's when the offside is considered passive and doesn't count.

  • @prishyan8918
    @prishyan8918 18 дней назад +3

    Real Madrid is the biggest club in the world, though in high stakes champions league matches, the referee mistakes are always on their side, kinda bizzare...

  • @mikele4242
    @mikele4242 19 дней назад +26

    For my analysis both Bayern players was offside, but let`s say Mazraoui wasn`t, still De Ligt move his body toward the ball and affecting the Real defenders and affecting the play so it doesn`t really matters if he didn`t touch the ball it`s till offside. It`s really school book offside, learn the rules. I hate Real Madrid but still it was offside, and a huge mistake by the reff not to let the play continue and than let the VAR decide if it was offside or not.

    • @geistakageist2932
      @geistakageist2932 19 дней назад +4

      Just because De Ligt is there doesn't automatically mean he is involved with the play. he doesn't jump for the ball or touch a defender... he doesn't affect the first phase of play

    • @abdulmarshooque7868
      @abdulmarshooque7868 18 дней назад +2

      @@geistakageist2932yea. That's what happened with Camavinga’s goal against Atletico and Gerard Moreno’s goal against Barca. Rudiger and Sorloth never touched the ball but, interfered the game play. Same as De ligt. So it's clear off side. The call is right.

    • @ulical
      @ulical 18 дней назад +2

      Best explanation so far of this play. De Ligt and Mazraoui were right next to each other when the ball was passed forward. Who's to say that the passer wasn't aiming for him?

    • @post_pone_ma_loan2031
      @post_pone_ma_loan2031 16 дней назад +1

      But De Ligt didn’t interfere whatsoever.

    • @post_pone_ma_loan2031
      @post_pone_ma_loan2031 16 дней назад +1

      @@ulicalDe Ligt didn’t go for the ball

  • @justaprankj7339
    @justaprankj7339 19 дней назад +36

    Wrong analysis... This angle isn´t really the offside angle VAR is checking and Mazraoui is offside with his knee actually by looking at the real angle VAR is taking. Due to the fact that Mazraoui is interefering in the game it is called passive offside so it can be whistled of course. Due to the fact the referee whistled the goalkeeper from Madrid stopped playing. The goal is not allowed which is the right decision.

    • @Tajckfkdbd
      @Tajckfkdbd 19 дней назад

      Mazraoui didn't even touch the ball, unless he has an invisible body part.

    • @holyroller9112
      @holyroller9112 19 дней назад +3

      It cannot be whistled. The referee must not stop play in a situation like this.

    • @justaprankj7339
      @justaprankj7339 18 дней назад

      @@Tajckfkdbd Passive offside…

    • @justaprankj7339
      @justaprankj7339 18 дней назад

      @@holyroller9112 It can be whistled of course but must not be whistled.

    • @Tajckfkdbd
      @Tajckfkdbd 18 дней назад

      @@justaprankj7339 Not Even

  • @oalo2001
    @oalo2001 19 дней назад +45

    Not my opinion. Mazraui's knee was offside.

    • @jackkelly6251
      @jackkelly6251 19 дней назад

      Even though Rudiger’s foot is playing him on?

    • @Tajckfkdbd
      @Tajckfkdbd 19 дней назад

      mazraoui didnt even touch the ball unless he has an invisible body part

    • @RIPped
      @RIPped 19 дней назад +8

      @@Tajckfkdbd he made an attempt to win the ball that Ferland Mendy headed, for the offside rule that is enough as he's intervening in the play

    • @lajosnekorosi3047
      @lajosnekorosi3047 18 дней назад

      If you look closer, you can see that De Ligt’s knee is in the same position or even farther ahead.

    • @DaniloSilva-lk6kq
      @DaniloSilva-lk6kq 18 дней назад +2

      @@Tajckfkdbdgo learn football then comment on the internet

  • @nemo_ng
    @nemo_ng 5 дней назад +1

    The goalie stood still after the whistle

  • @thinkmister8934
    @thinkmister8934 19 дней назад +2

    Hey guys ! When you play against Real Madrid, you must expect such things coming the referees. It's not the fist time that it happens.

  • @Gregoses
    @Gregoses 19 дней назад +30

    mazraoui never even touched the ball

    • @wa57s577
      @wa57s577 19 дней назад +15

      He doesn't have to. He went up with the defender which is enough intervention.

    • @marcoleone4289
      @marcoleone4289 19 дней назад +3

      😂😂Ai REF, BETTER TAKE OVER NOW FR ☠️

  • @tomaskosan5406
    @tomaskosan5406 19 дней назад +127

    Lunin would save it..

  • @ebrimamanneh5772
    @ebrimamanneh5772 19 дней назад +25

    Not a goal the whistle is already blow before the ball goes in and the players paused

    • @Tajckfkdbd
      @Tajckfkdbd 19 дней назад

      no they didnt they tried blocking the shot

    • @mrupisan014
      @mrupisan014 19 дней назад

      @@Tajckfkdbdit was heard on tv the referee blew the whistle and the players stopped, mili tried blocking it out of instiinct but the ref blew the whistle first.

    • @Yesnt0073
      @Yesnt0073 18 дней назад

      Then please tell me why on earth the whistle was blown?

    • @mrupisan014
      @mrupisan014 18 дней назад

      @@Yesnt0073 human error.

    • @prodapas3321
      @prodapas3321 18 дней назад

      Yes the problem is not that the defenders stopped the problem is that the referee blew the whistle too early.

  • @masahirukouta21
    @masahirukouta21 6 дней назад

    no matter how i look, both players are offside....

  • @dot2187
    @dot2187 13 часов назад

    After Barcelona died..now Madrid make son of UEFA... I see every match Munchen meet Madrid in Champions league a long time ago in Ronaldo era with Madrid Munchen always disadvantaged referee...

  • @DanielDavid-gg6pb
    @DanielDavid-gg6pb 4 дня назад

    Lunin didn't move after hearing the whistle

  • @hamedmoosaei9288
    @hamedmoosaei9288 19 дней назад +1

    There are several points here! Firstly, the calculated duration for extra time needs to be considered. Shouldn't the referee have blown the final whistle earlier? But regarding this offside moment, until the offside line is accurately drawn in 3D, we can't discuss whether Mazraoui's knee was offside or not. However, if he is offside, it doesn't matter whether he touched the ball or not! The pressure he applied to the Real Madrid's player (Mendy) has effected the game, so it could be offside even if he doesn't touch the ball!
    It is necessary to point out that according to the precise text book of the VAR rules, the assistant referee should only delay raising the flag when the attacker in the offside-suspected position makes contact with the ball. Otherwise, they can raise the flag immediately. This means that the assistant referee's performance was exactly in line with the rules, but it would have been better if the referee had waited a bit before blowing the whistle.

    • @jonnybarron1518
      @jonnybarron1518 4 дня назад

      Why would the ref blow the whistle when 8 minutes was the ball out and Madrid wasting time to get back at Bayern for wasting time after Davies scored

  • @tddarmaone2770
    @tddarmaone2770 12 дней назад

    Both of them is absolutely offside, they leg in front of rudiger.

  • @Pedro-fr8tz
    @Pedro-fr8tz 18 дней назад +1

    The header pass back was not from Nasser but from Real Madrid player Mendi number 23. The pass was to Nasser he was onsite and never touches de ball. What a massive error this was.

  • @JuanPablo12323
    @JuanPablo12323 11 дней назад +1

    Saka laughing 😃

  • @francograpelli3060
    @francograpelli3060 13 дней назад

    Both Bayern players Mazraoui and De Ligt were offside. The rule says you shall wait till the chance is over. That was exactly when the Madrid defender headed the ball back into the field. Ergo the flag and whistle were exactly conform with the rules. A goal after a whistle never can be regular.
    and c

  • @kakarot180
    @kakarot180 19 дней назад +12

    It's offside because ... Although Mazraoui was onside but De Ligt was offside and he created a challenge which caused an interference.,..So by rule's it's offside

    • @jackkelly6251
      @jackkelly6251 19 дней назад +1

      Where is this challenge that de ligt made? He didn’t challenge anything?

    • @jarrettpeeples9745
      @jarrettpeeples9745 19 дней назад +2

      He gets on the direct path between the ball and Rüdiger, a nearby defender. That is interference and triggers an offsides.
      And that is before you even consider that these still frames definitely make it look like Mazraoui was offsides too anyways.

    • @CoffeeGameMovie
      @CoffeeGameMovie 18 дней назад

      Absolutely this! Offical wiki says: The officials must judge if the player without the ball is involved in the play in some way - for example, by challenging for the ball or, say, obstructing the goalkeeper's vision. In that case, the player would be judged offside despite not having touched the ball. - De Ligt attacked the situation, he tried to get the ball when it was lobbed from the midfield, so he was in offside, this is objectively the offical statement.

    • @kYnTso
      @kYnTso 18 дней назад

      @@CoffeeGameMovie Technically they should have allowed the play continue and let the VAR do the judgement to avoid a situation like this right now where everyone makes up theyr own truth and narrative. Not saying ur wrong but people will and can argue for days about the "challenging for the ball" part. I could imagine that Lunin would had saved it but still (Real and the fans wont care) but people will call them cheaters (to be fair they have had several "cheating" moments before so nothing new).

  • @United4ever1
    @United4ever1 15 дней назад +10

    Get lost, I'm not a Real Madrid fan and At first, I thought Mendy was the one who passed the ball to de ligt. But If it's Mazzraoui THAT'S A CLEAR OFFSIDE!! He was in front of Rüdiger too Before the ball was crossed !

  • @farabiiim2272
    @farabiiim2272 14 дней назад

    1. Offside position
    It is not an offence to be in an offside position.
    A player is in an offside position if:
    any part of the head, body or feet is in the opponents’ half (excluding the halfway line) and
    any part of the head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent
    The hands and arms of all players, including the goalkeepers, are not considered. For the purposes of determining offside, the upper boundary of the arm is in line with the bottom of the armpit.
    A player is not in an offside position if level with the:
    second-last opponent or
    last two opponents
    2. Offside offence
    A player in an offside position at the moment the ball is played or touched* by a team-mate is only penalised on becoming involved in active play by:
    interfering with play by playing or touching a ball passed or touched by a team-mate or
    interfering with an opponent by:
    preventing an opponent from playing or being able to play the ball by clearly obstructing the opponent’s line of vision or
    challenging an opponent for the ball or
    clearly attempting to play a ball which is close when this action impacts on an opponent or
    making an obvious action which clearly impacts on the ability of an opponent to play the ball
    *The first point of contact of the 'play' or 'touch' of the ball should be used
    or
    gaining an advantage by playing the ball or interfering with an opponent when it has:
    rebounded or been deflected off the goalpost, crossbar or an opponent
    been deliberately saved by any opponent
    A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately played* the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent.
    *‘Deliberate play’ (excluding deliberate handball) is when a player has control of the ball with the possibility of:
    passing the ball to a team-mate;
    gaining possession of the ball; or
    clearing the ball (e.g. by kicking or heading it)
    If the pass, attempt to gain possession or clearance by the player in control of the ball is inaccurate or unsuccessful, this does not negate the fact that the player ‘deliberately played’ the ball.
    The following criteria should be used, as appropriate, as indicators that a player was in control of the ball and, as a result, can be considered to have ‘deliberately played’ the ball:
    The ball travelled from distance and the player had a clear view of it
    The ball was not moving quickly
    The direction of the ball was not unexpected
    The player had time to coordinate their body movement, i.e. it was not a case of instinctive stretching or jumping, or a movement that achieved limited
    contact/control
    A ball moving on the ground is easier to play than a ball in the air
    A ‘save’ is when a player stops, or attempts to stop, a ball which is going into or very close to the goal with any part of the body except the hands/arms (unless the goalkeeper within the penalty area).
    In situations where:
    a player moving from, or standing in, an offside position is in the way of an opponent and interferes with the movement of the opponent towards the ball this is an offside offence if it impacts on the ability of the opponent to play or challenge for the ball; if the player moves into the way of an opponent and impedes the opponent's progress (e.g blocks the opponent) the offence should be penalised under Law 12
    a player in an offside position is moving towards the ball with the intention of playing the ball and is fouled before playing or attempting to play the ball, or challenging an opponent for the ball, the foul is penalised as it has occurred before the offside offence
    an offence is committed against a player in an offside position who is already playing or attempting to play the ball, or challenging an opponent for the ball, the offside offence is penalised as it has occurred before the foul challenge
    It'is clear offside

  • @MounirEnglish
    @MounirEnglish 16 дней назад +2

    Both player were involved in the attack . They were next to each other .If one of them is offside . Then its an offside . Learn the rules . Then make a video

  • @quickseiseb9593
    @quickseiseb9593 13 дней назад

    Go report to the nearest police station

  • @erannaier4258
    @erannaier4258 12 дней назад

    That's why education is necessary

  • @MKMK-xo9lo
    @MKMK-xo9lo 16 дней назад +4

    Real was lucky as so often… if Neuer doesn’t do that horrible mistake 2 min b4 the end it would be a all German final

    • @sarkozikrisztian6037
      @sarkozikrisztian6037 13 дней назад +3

      Yup and if my grandmother had wheels she would have been a bike

  • @jonnybarron1518
    @jonnybarron1518 4 дня назад

    YOU CAN CLEARLY SEE MENDY HEADS THE BALL TO MULLER, MAZROUI is not the one who headed it. Are you blind? And even if mazroui headed it he looks onside anyways

  • @Bibivarte
    @Bibivarte 19 дней назад +1

    whether real players stopped playing after the whistle or not , bayern players still hand the chance to make something out of it if the play was still on , madrid fans are too overconfidently sure their players will defend , i doubt it after what alphonso davies just did to rudier

  • @Flyerviitorul92
    @Flyerviitorul92 17 дней назад

    If the referee hadn't blown the whistle, the RMD players wouldn't have stopped. I am sorry, but all judges are calling this a foul, but in fact, the RMD players stopped all at once and byern scored against static objects

  • @flipflap87000
    @flipflap87000 16 дней назад

    Le second but du Real est hors jeu

  • @losttravellerLTTL
    @losttravellerLTTL 18 дней назад +1

    Madrid players stopped playing. lunin was just stood and watched. bayer can only score if Madrid players stop playing

  • @Ramses060784
    @Ramses060784 14 дней назад

    The other participated in the game therefore there's influence, offside

  • @user-ek8em6lh5f
    @user-ek8em6lh5f 12 дней назад

    real madrid did the same like always . no wonder its called bribe madrid

  • @inked9655
    @inked9655 18 дней назад

    Bro to be honest both players are active in the play when the pass starts and its on air both players are chasing it so its definitely offside even if the ball went to mazraoui.

  • @Michaelrastegar
    @Michaelrastegar 19 дней назад +1

    why??? They have var and upwards of 20 cameras 📸 and 4 referees. I hate football cheating. referees and FIFA should accept playing Real Madrid vs Bayern Munich again
    And
    Don't say cry more 😂 I'm serious 😅 I love football my heart

    • @invasion8318
      @invasion8318 18 дней назад

      it was offside though, he made a controversial decision but a correct one

    • @Michaelrastegar
      @Michaelrastegar 12 дней назад

      @@invasion8318 I don't know man we should watch real Madrid vs bvb

  • @AbdoulkaderTheHero
    @AbdoulkaderTheHero 4 дня назад

    We saw everything over there ( live and replies ), there is no question that the whistle was on propose but it's not over ..

  • @wongynutz
    @wongynutz 18 дней назад

    There’s a lot of what ifs:
    What if the flag didn’t go up? Things could have turned out differently. The whistle wouldn’t have blown, and the defenders and the keeper would have reacted differently. Hence, who knows what could have happened.

  • @piecia911
    @piecia911 18 дней назад

    Clear offside

  • @Berrynyc
    @Berrynyc 19 дней назад +1

    I'm not sure who is crying more, barca fans or bayern fans.
    Game stopped, that's why they scored. Lunin would save that but before that it might been a penalty.

    • @holyroller9112
      @holyroller9112 19 дней назад

      But the game shouldn't have been stopped. What if the game was stopped right before Joselu's second goal? Who would be crying then?

    • @Berrynyc
      @Berrynyc 18 дней назад

      @holyroller9112 they checked the var and he scored while it was a play. Bayer scored after the whistle. Bayer had many chances during the play and they did not shot on target. So you cannot say it was a goal.

  • @DominatersYT
    @DominatersYT 17 дней назад

    Lunin would have saved it but he stopped when the ref blew the whistle

  • @IASP17
    @IASP17 18 дней назад

    to me, its an offside. they were both running side by side when the ball was crossed into THEIR direction. claiming that the ball was clearly crossed to Mazraoui is not true. de Ligt was going for the ball too. its an offside.

  • @jasonwolfe1318
    @jasonwolfe1318 День назад

    May have well drawn a circle lol

  • @SOMAKGHOSH-ye2gj
    @SOMAKGHOSH-ye2gj 16 дней назад

    Clearly the referee murdered BM and in exchange for some hefty rewards from RM management

  • @MikeSmds123
    @MikeSmds123 19 дней назад

    offside; the hands and arms are not considered, but the end of the sleeve of the player's shirt. furthermore, the goalie and defenders made an evident pause before the shot, which refutes the argument that it would have been a guaranteed goal.

  • @JesusChristISTHEONETRUEGOD
    @JesusChristISTHEONETRUEGOD 14 дней назад +1

    Typical Real Madrid corruption.

  • @rmzidann
    @rmzidann 17 дней назад

    WRONG, wrong and WRONG again. Mazroui’s right knee, right shoulder and possibly his head are offside by less than 1 foot.

  • @WillCamx
    @WillCamx 19 дней назад

    A striker can be yards offside and the linesmen refuse to raise their flags but it goes up instantly on this occasion and the ref blows at once.
    Something stinks here.

    • @lajosnekorosi3047
      @lajosnekorosi3047 18 дней назад

      What if they wanted to save some time - which would mean favoring Bayern?

    • @emmanuelnhabay3708
      @emmanuelnhabay3708 18 дней назад

      ​@@lajosnekorosi3047this is the most logical explanation to what occured on Wednesday night at the Bernabeu. The referee added 5 extra minutes just to help Bayern Munich, but they'll not mention that aspect of the game.

  • @abdulbasith8821
    @abdulbasith8821 18 дней назад

    It's clean offside

  • @88wojtek1
    @88wojtek1 17 дней назад

    De Ligt who was offside took part in the action, engaged defenders and shot the goal. How this could be correct?

  • @gioc.1908
    @gioc.1908 17 дней назад

    Why don't we have clips from VAR? So dissatisfying..

    • @Journeytomonetization-ko9yq
      @Journeytomonetization-ko9yq  17 дней назад

      The time I made this video there was no VAR update. It was just an early look out. But check on my channel there is an updated video with VAR clips

    • @abdallahayman9802
      @abdallahayman9802 17 дней назад

      Because this play did not even go to VAR at all and was never checked, it is not even an incident, it is not a "disallowed goal". The whistle was blown way before the shot occurred.

  • @asilkhr7337
    @asilkhr7337 18 дней назад

    ref should not have blown the whistle. the attack should have played on then var would decide if it was valid, and the players would have defended so it may not have been a goal. either way referees mistake cost bayern a chance for a goal.

    • @emmanuelnhabay3708
      @emmanuelnhabay3708 18 дней назад

      So what can you say about the 5 minutes added extra minutes to the official 9 minutes?

  • @CoffeeGameMovie
    @CoffeeGameMovie 18 дней назад +2

    The offical rule, what u can find in any football related wikis says this: "The officials must judge if the player without the ball is involved in the play in some way - for example, by challenging for the ball or, say, obstructing the goalkeeper's vision. In that case, the player would be judged offside despite not having touched the ball." - so as De Ligt absolutely was involved in the attack, as he attacked the ball, moved to its direction while it was in the air, he was in offside. The referee made the right decision objectively.

  • @Hechaldo
    @Hechaldo 13 дней назад +3

    Clear offside, mate. De Ligt was in the offside position when the ball was passed towards him and Musiala. Since the ball was heading his way (doesn't matter if he didn't touch the ball) he is considered to be interfering with the play as he is. Also, the rules state if the defender intercepts the ball that was heading towards a player(s) in a offside position (Rudiger got to the ball first) the linesmen must raise his flag. Everything was by the book. Yes, the main referee could've not blown the whistle since it was a close call, but if he hadn't the Madrid players wouldn't have stopped playing and De Ligt would not get a free shot on goal. Football is easy when you know the rules.

  • @KrintAm
    @KrintAm 16 дней назад

    The thing is, the player who touched it after the pass wasnt even mazraoui, if u look closely it was mendy who touched the ball (real madrid player), and the first bayern player who touched it was muller who was clearly not offside

    • @jontelcif6
      @jontelcif6 15 дней назад

      The player who was off side was running to try to catch the ball when the pass was thrown. That's enough to determine it was offside. He didn't ha e to touch the ball.

    • @KrintAm
      @KrintAm 15 дней назад

      @@jontelcif6oh mb

  • @Ahmedahmed-mi8dr
    @Ahmedahmed-mi8dr 18 дней назад

    the goal keeper would have saved it easily if the referee didn't whistle. so you can't call it a goal besides the referee should have ended the game at minute 9 or even 11 which is two minute prior to this incident

  • @NissinAlvoR
    @NissinAlvoR 13 дней назад

    Muller offside

  • @IbnAdam-yy8qu
    @IbnAdam-yy8qu 13 дней назад

    Stupid white line .😂 First line was correct second one was stupid.. before talk about goal. Talk about add time first

  • @paulkarami
    @paulkarami 18 дней назад

    Are knees or lower body not consider for oxides? I think knee was offside however a var review would have been nice. Lastly the whistle stoped the game and he still had to score it. I dont think it would have been an easy goal. Much respect to both team and fans. Two big teams.

  • @hajoxvalodik
    @hajoxvalodik 18 дней назад

    they shoot the gool after whistle and Loonin just stoped acting . after whistle it doesnt depent offside or not the gool has to be cancelled

  • @xElleRyuzaki
    @xElleRyuzaki 19 дней назад

    1-Mazraoui's knee is NOT ON LINE with antonio rudiger
    2- If the ref didn't blow the whistle lunin ( or any other goalie, even bad ones) would have easily stop that soft shot
    You all need to stop crying, specially if you support messi/argentina with that famous 1 penalty/game WC

  • @emmanuelnhabay3708
    @emmanuelnhabay3708 18 дней назад

    It is good you said according to your analysis. It was unfortunate the referee and his officials made a premature call. You cannot actually prove whether Masroui was offside or not because De Leigt was closer to him and the latter's offside was obvious. The match officials brought this upon themselves because there was no need for the game to have extended to that time. The game should've ended after the 99th minutes which was a sufficient added time. Why did De Ligt interfered with the play? Do you think Madrid's defenders and goalkeeper could've stood there and watch De Ligt take a shot? Common let's not downplay the fact that Real Madrid deserved to qualify for the finals.

  • @raptorek01
    @raptorek01 14 дней назад

    Offside ofc,, dosent of deffender doesnt make a line

  • @zombiie64
    @zombiie64 18 дней назад

    It was not however madrid players stopped playing because of the whistle, so even if the play continue what guarantees it was going to be a goal?

  • @ricardohenraath3227
    @ricardohenraath3227 19 дней назад

    The knee was offside that is a shooting leg just zoom on the foot placement of rudiger this is offside only with centimetres but offside is offside but the ref could atleast check the var

  • @danielsanalytics4400
    @danielsanalytics4400 16 дней назад

    His Knee is obviously offside

  • @ricardocarnauba
    @ricardocarnauba 18 дней назад

    I'd bet Lunin would defend it.

  • @SantiagoS-mz4zz
    @SantiagoS-mz4zz 16 дней назад

    You should draw parallel lines to the penalty area line.

  • @licas63
    @licas63 13 дней назад

    Does it Fucking matter anymore?

  • @19Lotus67
    @19Lotus67 16 дней назад

    the offsides rule is bollox. body parts are offside? laughable garbage.

  • @user-hx9kd9nw8j
    @user-hx9kd9nw8j 17 дней назад

    Real madrid is always favored , they won't have won nore than r champions league without assistance from officials

  • @henningschaaf1790
    @henningschaaf1790 19 дней назад +1

    Offside from de Ligt. Correct call but to early I agree.

    • @geistakageist2932
      @geistakageist2932 19 дней назад

      he has no effect in the 1st phase of play. He doesn't jump to try get the ball or touch or bump a defender. players can be off if they don't attempt to play or interfere

  • @pz4642
    @pz4642 19 дней назад

    just because he went onside it sti counts as offside because de ligt decided to go back doesn't mean the pass wasnt to him but yea imo you shouldn't call that prematurely but his feet was barely offside

  • @lajosnekorosi3047
    @lajosnekorosi3047 18 дней назад

    If you zoom in your picture, you can see, that the knee of De Ligt is as far ahead as Mazraui’s and your white line is far from parallel. So it was a clear offside.according to your video.

  • @ilechukwuonyedika5919
    @ilechukwuonyedika5919 19 дней назад

    He was attacking the ball

  • @gurbi
    @gurbi 15 дней назад

    Vamos Real, vamos Marciniak

  • @adamres33
    @adamres33 18 дней назад

    Masraoui was offside as well

  • @amadfreez8898
    @amadfreez8898 17 дней назад

    stop calling it an offside goal..its not even a goal when the game already stop by ref. easy

  • @respectiseverything4808
    @respectiseverything4808 16 дней назад

    Not offside

  • @user-ll4op4wk8c
    @user-ll4op4wk8c 19 дней назад

    Bayern player right knee is offside then he interfered… everyone is clueless and so stupid

    • @geistakageist2932
      @geistakageist2932 18 дней назад

      u are clueless... current rules, for a few years, is that unclear offside is not flagged by the linesman. if a goal occurs then var reviews. love or hate var, it's one of its main purpose to check tight offside/onside when goals are scored. U would know this if u watch any european football the last few years. dummy

  • @vojtasujan2383
    @vojtasujan2383 18 дней назад

    nice ,,analysis,, made from 6yo barsa fan, but offside line is drawn from the shoulder not fingertips, and also it should hold the same angle as grass strips, not the oposite 😂

  • @237gospel
    @237gospel 18 дней назад

    Reasons for Ai Referee

  • @Zero_120
    @Zero_120 19 дней назад

    Well what can we do as always real Madrid pays refree in champion leagues...

  • @sandeepsooryaprakash9215
    @sandeepsooryaprakash9215 18 дней назад

    Lol.. how do you know ball was played to mazaroui.. it was just a hopeful long ball played towards reals box… and header was from real defender mendy and then the whistle blew and madrid players stopped playing and de ligt scored a goal… this was not a goal at all… get a life 🫢

  • @koski707
    @koski707 16 дней назад

    You have no idea about football rules and you make a video about it 🤣

  • @anilwithblessing8452
    @anilwithblessing8452 18 дней назад

    Yes its not an offside after i watched so many clips,because when the ball passed through it was madrid player headed the ball not bayern player,,so how is that possible to give an offside?am confused

  • @arturocontreras1905
    @arturocontreras1905 19 дней назад

    Mendy heads the ball

  • @shodaka
    @shodaka 19 дней назад

    De ligt was near and in front of mazraoui when the ball was in the air so it’s an off side even if mazraoui touch the ball first.

  • @francescorenna
    @francescorenna 19 дней назад +3

    We will never know if the goalkeeper would have taken the ball as he stopped moving. The linesman made the mistake, the referee correctly stopped the game, so we will never know.

    • @holyroller9112
      @holyroller9112 19 дней назад +3

      Actually the referee has the option to not stop the game.

    • @filipbielak8584
      @filipbielak8584 18 дней назад

      ​@@holyroller9112 when linesman has said that it was offside the reffere is supposed to blow the whistle and stop the game

  • @yarmelenkomr7378
    @yarmelenkomr7378 11 дней назад

    Someones are still crying? OMG

  • @Fabreezzo
    @Fabreezzo 19 дней назад

    Noussair was still off regardless

  • @youtuger
    @youtuger 19 дней назад +2

    Never heard of passive offside when you interfere with the game? If you are actively involved in the play when you are offside, you will be punished for offside since you are still in the game. Look up Messi offside trap and compare De Ligt play and Messi. Messi is not involved in the play and doesn't take defenders attention but here Rudiger was closing De Ligt and thus, it's a clear involvement in the play.
    Second thing, after whistle it doesn't matter what you do. It doesn't count if you score. Bellingham scored a winning goal vs Valencia this season but the goal didn't stand because the ref was whistling to end the game on 98th minute even though Real was crossing the ball to goal area. You cannot score a goal after whistle and then complain why it doesn't stand

    • @geistakageist2932
      @geistakageist2932 18 дней назад

      well thats just not true is it. De Ligt is free to move anywhere on the pitch as long as he doesn't attempt to get the ball, block or nudge another player. It's not on him what Rudiger does.

    • @youtuger
      @youtuger 18 дней назад

      @@geistakageist2932 no, he cannot move anywhere and distract defenders even though he doesn’t touch the ball. It all depends, if you’re offside, try not to interfere with the play. Look up Messi’s offside trap and compare De Ligt and Messi actions

    • @geistakageist2932
      @geistakageist2932 18 дней назад

      @@youtuger there are goals all the time where a attacking player looks way offside but has nothing to do with the goal. As long as that player doesn't effect the keepers sight of the shot the goal stands

  • @remek5758
    @remek5758 19 дней назад

    the players stooped defending when it whistle was blown, the goal would not be scored 😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ERNESTYAW-xj8bg
    @ERNESTYAW-xj8bg 14 дней назад

    Go and take the goal. Barcelona fan like you.

  • @nitayhen3973
    @nitayhen3973 19 дней назад +2

    1. Real's players stopped playing when the whistle was blown.
    2. De Ligt was offside, and since his presence there affected the play, it should be ruled out as offside for interfering with the play.
    3. Why is no one talking about how the referee added **9 minutes**, and then an additional 3 (Bayern scored in the 112th minute), when there were nearly no injuries or VAR checks?
    4. People saying Real Madrid (Florentino Perez) bribe referees, why would he bribe ANY high profile referee when just ONE can get him in jail for years?

    • @cescosa4404
      @cescosa4404 19 дней назад +1

      1. Only lunin who was off his line stopped rudiger (should have been sent off) and militao both tried to block it.
      2. de ligt didn’t interfere as the ball was nowhere near rudiger or militao and it was mendy who got it anyway
      3. After the var check for the second goal and the extensive celebrations every time a Bayern player thought about tackling the Madrid player with the ball they would go down holding their leg and they kept kicking it out of bounds to waste time which ended up adding more to the stoppage time.
      4. Simple he wants to win and also it was so obvious they were bribed rudiger literally picked Kane off his feet and threw him he also pushed Kane in his upper back and head using his arms to stop Kane from crossing it into the box whilst Bayern were on a breakaway/counter. Nacho literally grabbed kimmich by the throat darth Vader type shi and threw him to the floor which should have been a straight red as a matter of fact that move is banned in the ufc and would result in a punishment of some sort (likely a points deduction) but for Real Madrid no card whatsoever which let’s be real if it was any other team apart from Barcelona that’s a straight red meaning Real Madrid would have had 0 cbs playing during the latter half of the second half and because rudiger got the assist they wouldn’t have took the lead

    • @nitayhen3973
      @nitayhen3973 19 дней назад

      @@cescosa4404 nah rudiger clearly stopped you're tripping, and there's no point arguing here because it wasn't a valid goal since the play was stopped 3 seconds before the goal, we will never know.

    • @cescosa4404
      @cescosa4404 19 дней назад

      @@nitayhen3973 look at it he moves towards de ligt. You would make a great ref btw because you fit the check list ✅
      You’re blind
      You’re deaf
      You wanna be a ref

    • @nitayhen3973
      @nitayhen3973 19 дней назад

      @@cescosa4404 u keep crying about it still? damn

    • @cescosa4404
      @cescosa4404 19 дней назад

      @@nitayhen3973 and there we go you said the thing. You just proved me right all you moronic Madrid fans have no response it’s crazy how I just did a 10-8 round on you

  • @bismarkicel5719
    @bismarkicel5719 17 дней назад +2

    Mazraoui himself was offside too. Just look at his knee. The line you drew was inaccurate. Secondly the chances of them scoring if the whistle hadn't gone was so slim.

  • @BiGoSOFFICIAL
    @BiGoSOFFICIAL 19 дней назад +5

    Fake video. Offside line is to rudigers foot not his hand. 100% offside in this situation and stop crying

    • @dmw798
      @dmw798 18 дней назад

      no shit we've established that. still not offside. real madrid are a dirty team and you're a plastic fan

    • @arkaniflamme9455
      @arkaniflamme9455 17 дней назад +1

      That`s what he`s saying, just whatch the video. The line is at his foot.

  • @jonathantaylor179
    @jonathantaylor179 19 дней назад

    This analysis isnt var so its just to blurry for me to tell. Also Lunin gave up and dint attempt to stop it

  • @Balnius
    @Balnius 19 дней назад +7

    The line is to Rudigers right foot not his hand

    • @dmw798
      @dmw798 18 дней назад

      no shit we've established that

  • @user-cx4ll4rj1t
    @user-cx4ll4rj1t 19 дней назад +9

    100% incorrect call at the time - it may be offside but new rules for 2 or 3 years is to allow play to continue and if necessary VAR will sort it out. Linesman called it and ref supported him.............. and they say corruption no longer exists in football................ either the officials are clueless or they cheated here. Would it have been a goal - who knows....

    • @Journeytomonetization-ko9yq
      @Journeytomonetization-ko9yq  19 дней назад +2

      If you recall thats what the Same referees did to real Madrid. They had to wait real Madrid score, then blew the whistle for foul. But why didn't they do the same to Bayern

    • @youtuger
      @youtuger 19 дней назад

      @@Journeytomonetization-ko9yq take off your tinfoil hats guys. The ref should've let it play yes but he whistled after the first touch and he thought the ball was cleared. De Ligt was already in passive offside and involved in active play taking Rudiger's attention.
      In the game vs Valencia Real suffered stupid ref's decision to end the game one second away when Bellingham scored a winning goal. Because anything after whistle doesn't stand.
      It's not a question where goal stands or not. It's technically cannot be counted after whistle and var cannot review it.
      I agree it was strange decision and a clear mistake by ref but would they really score if no whistle and real players were fully focused and concentrated? And also, it was 3.5 mins after extra 9 additional minutes of the game. I don't see you complaining for that

    • @arkaniflamme9455
      @arkaniflamme9455 17 дней назад

      ​@@youtuger The ref gave extra time due to new interruptions. The opposite is true: I'am always complaining when the ref sticks to the official time no matter what happened.

  • @leifc6639
    @leifc6639 19 дней назад

    You're contredicting yourself... you say that when the ball is crossed, both players chase it. And later you say that the ball wasn't passed to De Ligt. But clearly De Ligt went for the ball, but let it go once he saw he couldn't reach it. But he interfered the play, so he counts to the offside. And by the way, the other player might also be offaide. Need to use better quality images and a thinner line to make a real assessment.

  • @kev5142
    @kev5142 19 дней назад +1

    It doesn’t matter. We have seen cases in which just making the run is considered playing for the ball. Using that logic, de ligh made the run thus playing for the ball