Michael Jackson, Janet Jackson - Scream (Official Video)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 окт 2009
- “Scream” by Michael Jackson with Janet Jackson
Listen to Michael Jackson: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_listenYD
The “Scream” single and short film paired Michael Jackson and Janet Jackson for the first time. The highly stylized black and white short film set a Guinness World Record for the most expensive short film ever made and earned a record 11 MTV Video Music Award nominations.
Subscribe to the official Michael Jackson RUclips Channel: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/subscri...
Watch more Michael Jackson videos: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_listen...
Follow Michael Jackson:
Facebook: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_follow...
Twitter: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_follow...
Instagram: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_follow...
Website: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_follow...
Spotify: MichaelJackson.lnk.to/_follow...
Chorus:
Stop pressurin' me
Just stop pressurin' me
Stop pressurin' me
Make me wanna scream
Stop pressurin' me
Just stop pressurin' me
Stop pressurin' me
Make you just wanna scream
#MichaelJackson #Scream #HIStory 
Видеоклипы
![Jason Aldean - Should've Been A Cowboy [Toby Keith Tribute] (Live from the 59th ACM Awards)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-B4nR-CgMVA/mqdefault.jpg)
The coolest sibling video EVER.
And most expensive. $7,000,000
@@PaperRaines whhhat 7M
@@EvensDz7 nah it was 7
Yes...love it
takes sharing toys to another level
Michael collaborating with his baby sister is EVERYTHING
Kghgegvy
@@toujanirayen5196QUE
si
re
canon
Salmmicahem,❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤,todolove,❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
& it’s sweet of her to feel like she didn’t wanna coattail ride him & be his shadow, even tho he swore it wasn’t like that 🥀
It's March 2024, let's see how many legends are listening to this incredible Michael Jackson song😌
Me
i am
At this moment right now and watching Janet Jackson tribute to her brother Michael (Scream) performance… over over over again… just totally Epic video and tribute performance ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤just doesn’t gets old… better and better❤❤❤❤02/12/2024
me me me. I'm a LEGEND!!!
Izi ✋️
People criticized MJ for spending so much money on a music video. Those people are dumb. Art never dies. Thank you Michael!
Only haters criticize greatness.
RIGHT!! This was the first certified $1 MILLION video...🤗🤗
@@ultramaleXwell said bro
So....... , 🌞❤️😀
Bro if i had MJ money you bet your ASS i'd be making the most insane art imaginable.
That dance breakdown is literally the coolest thing I've ever seen and its wild that's it's a brother and sister doing it!!
Nothing can beat this breakdown honestly💯
Yes!!!
Glenn O'Connor you’re dumb
Yep yep
@@glennoconnor1130 No he's not, Get tf off his videos✌🏽
Michael & Janet only having one song together is the biggest crime in history
And never performed live 😢
I love there sister and brother bond
Wished they did more together ☹️💕
@@dashaershova4673 janet did but they put a screen behing janet of micheal
I agree but they were both free spirits they did there own thing and this is only possible cause michael wanted to do a song with Janet
Anyone in 2024?
Right here
me 😍
Me 🩷
Who isn't my man
Me today, tomorrow and Forever
its year 3024 who is still a big MJ fan 😆
I like your funny words Arab man
Me
wait what i thought its 2024
@@user_bigboyhe just joking 😂😂
Juan
I don"t think people understand, two of the MOST iconic artist in the world are in this video. On top of that they are siblings. This moment can never duplicated.
Janet was absolutely incredible. But MJ was off the scale in terms of iconicness and popularity, he’s equal to Elvis and the Beatles, if not even higher than them
Not really. She is nothing next to him my opionion. On her own she is all right. Loved her in apprentice
@@kaelajoyce8050 hmm, his music hasn’t aged as well
@@kaelajoyce8050 Michael Jackson definitely has Elvis beat in terms of both popularity and icons
@@Olly_2024_ I think MJ is bigger than Elvis and The Beatles. Im from latinoamerica and u just born here knowing MJ. The other two don't have that big of a presence mainly because they didn't even tour on this side of the world, meanwhile MJ is known all over the world.
Who is just randomly having a michael jackson marathon
Me
This aint random. This was premeditated!!!
moi lol
Ohmg me too! 🤘😍
Wow I’m loving that you posted this because this is exactly what I’m doing.
I just left Janet's concert and she performed this song. It's crazy how much her voice has matured. She sounds so much like Michael now
His arm around her neck in the first couple scenes, is just so beautiful. Its giving, '"I got you little sis"". Miss and luv you King of pop
For me, it's her at the end, holding him and staring defiantly at the camera
The moment you realize this duo was a force to be reckoned with. A shame they didn't make any more music together. Loved their dance sequence.
Sequence is amazing, it's sooooo gooood
Perfeito
yEAH
They were a force and then some. I came back to this very video thinking how they would of destroyed the game if they made more music with choreograph like this!
Thatpart.
Fun Fact: Michael stated... after he heard the final recording of this song, and heard how Fierce Janet sounded , he had to go in and re-record his vocals.
That gave me chills lol! Mike said “wait a damn minute 🤔” ☺️❤️
@@sunnymane LOL...Right I love the fact he always acknowledged his sisters talent, and loved dancing to her music.
@@m.g.3842 I've read Katherine's book My family the Jacksons and she mentioned a few times how proud and happy Michael was for Janet and he told her that.
@@kristuti1 wow never knew that. Thanks for sharing!
Hell he taught her everything which was dope
Man I miss him! My absolute favorite singer of all time!!! The ONE and ONLY Michael Jackson! There will never be anyone who can be him or come close to being as great as he was and still is, lived by millions all over the world. I don't care about his past and, whether it be true or not concerning the rumors and accusations. No way and fame will always attract money hungry people looking for money and a piece of you. The world's greatest singer!! Left us far too soon. I still listen to his music daily!!!
A LEGEND up their with ELVIS. After watching a documentary on Janet Jackson (Stan) and the meaning and relevance behind Janet supporting his brother in the creation of this song! Damn such a powerful song.
Saw Janet in Manila last night & she did this live with Michael on screen. AMAZING
Show me a more iconic sibling duo. This collab is legendary.
Agreed
L.,lĺkkk
The Carpenters.
Robin and Barry Gibb.
Ray and Dave Davies of The Kinks
Donny and Marie Osmond.
Chris and Rich Robinson of The Black Crowes.
@@Hellwyck no
No disrespect to the above,but seriously?
No other bro/sis solo combo has ever existed at this level. Genius. Gives chills.
l think Jimmy and Kristy McNichol are a pretty close second. Sure l do.
@@punchline43 not in the urban category.
Donnie and Marie? 😂😂😂😂
Absolutely true one hundred percent. Definitely agree with you about that one totally agree.😊✌✌
not since ur mom and ur dad concieved u hhahahahhqhqhqhqhq lol jk
28 years later, if you’re watching this, you’re a legend.
Thank you!
Thank you…
No YOU'RE a Legend!
The older I get, the more I appreciate Michael's talent. How does he go from wanting to Heal the World to spittin' so angry?! His smooth dancing skills, too, like butter be helping him glide...
I feel so bad for Janet, too. Both she and her brother with their gentle natures and immense talent, both done dirty in different ways by opportunists. How tf is it that this woman had an established career since childhood then one troll of a man comes along, exposes her breast on national television, and her career is over just like that? Tf man! #JusticeForJanet
That incident inspired RUclips to be created, it may have cost Janet Jackson her career, but it created RUclips which gave us a platform to listen to all their songs on free of charge.
watching Janet's documentary this weekend and seeing Michael and Janet writing this in Mike's bedroom....just blew my mind at the evolution of this song. Regardless of what the industry tried to do with pitting them against each other, even at this video shoot, I was always remember this song/video as a moment of triumph and true family love and support!!!!! #ScreamForever!!!!
Yessir
I really didn’t like that they tried to pit them against each other.
Yeah omg I came here from the documentary
Same I was very little but had no idea this was a reaction to what he was going thru. It did feel dark with their screaming and makeup. Now I know why.
And how he went into the studio and went right to work nailing it!! There will never be another Michael Joseph Jackson 👑
This man had such a hard life but still had the most beautiful smile in the world!
Viktoria Ghalumyan Yes he did!! I LOVE his smile! 😍😍
Viktoria Ghalumyan and teeth
He really had a very beautiful smile
Absolutely 😍😍😍
true, so true
It was a blessing to see them collaborate together. I love the way the share that brother and sister love. We miss u Michael. Rest in heaven King
God bless your soul Michael. The raw anger and energy you bring in this song along with Janet is second to none. LEGEND
Name a more iconic brother and sister duo. I'll wait.
Danielle Dixon D.W and Arthur
the carpenters still love the jacksons =)
+ Danielle Dixon Richard and Karen Carpenter.
Danielle Dixon no one
Jack and jill
The choreography was insane
And the editing 🤩
From other planet
Hell yes it is ✊🤘 it has a nice rock vibe to it too
It worth much longer
2:36
One of THE BEST brother & sister collaborations EVER!
Nobody!!!!!! I repeat….NOBODY will EVER capture our heart like Michael Jackson!!!!! My #1 FOREVER!!!!!! The BEST SIBLING video EVER!!!!!! He’s TRULY MISSED!!!!!!! She’s DEFINITELY the definition of stand by your bro!!!!!!!
As an adult, when you listen to Michael’s discography, you realize why he’ll always be the greatest music artist off all-time.
as a child, can't agree more
Absolutely! Everything about him and his gift is unparalleled.
No maybe in future there will be someone better then the current and the past
Yep
I am 13 I listened to micheal when I was 4 and as a 13 year old I agree with you
THIS DANCE BETWEEN MICHEAL AND JANET IS STILL ICONICCC
Im
You ain't lyin!!
FR
Yerrrp
Of course
Man. The words to this song told us everything we are finding out now. RIP Michael ❤
Anyone else in 2024🤷
As a teen I didn't understand this song. Now as an adult, the message is clear, this world is corrupt and the pressure is everywhere.
Yes. And the moment he exposed that in the music industry they went after him.
Its about their father’s abuse
Yup
@@Evans808 not really, no
@@TyeArtisik how so?
3:18 those dance moves they do together look soooooooo badass.
that slide is EVERYTHING... i watch their vids over and over to try to figure out the choreography and my mind cannot fully compute, let alone my body. Practice and muscle memory do not explain it all.
@Ann __ i love mj ❤❤ and his sis ❤❤
@Ann __ are you blind, it was at the same time...
Ik their dances c:
ngl they look kinda whack by todays standards
April 7, 2024 Michael is still King. Princess Janet, we love you both.
Janet is Michaels mirror. They’re so in sync
MTV, this right here is what made you relevant, not a repeat of teen pregnancy reality shows.. Take several seats!!!!!
The video provides several .
🙌🏾🙌🏾
Facts!
That's right, i don't understand why the Tv praise the young girls that are pregnant at 15/16 years old.
I find it sad and too bad.
MTV takes inspiration from The View now.
Michael Jackson. The only singer who screams without hurting your ears
Michael actually did do the scream in the song
@@adenchapman3071 it wasn’t even loud
Completely agree...I like his screaming and wen other singers scream loud it usually is a cringe part for my ears
@@meramail 💪👍
I love micheal but that intro hurted my HECKING EARS 👂🏻
How much I love this song and the duet that brought together two sisters, Michael and Janet. They were wonderful. ❤❤❤❤
The Brother and Sister dance break though!❤❤❤
This video is way before it’s time. I really don’t think that people at the time actually realized how epic it was to have Michael and Janet together in this. Once in a lifetime.
I think they realized. I think the message behind the song is what deserves more recognition. The MJ was tortured by the media is beyond messed up.
From what I’ve seen, this was definitely a big event then. Janet was at the height of her career and MJ was MJ of course, and they were siblings no less.
This song was written out of anger. He was exhausted with the media, false allegations, and the bs. He didn’t deserve it at all.
How beautiful is it that Janet stuck by him when no one else was there when he needed the support.
Who’s watching the Dangerous Tour btw?😭❤️🩹🤙🏽🔥🎵🏆
I still love them both. We are a generation who was lucky to have them both
Janet showed just how much of a badass she was by holding her own alongside her King of Pop brother in this song. They both killed this, but she slayed it!!! I especially loved her look and acting/mannerisms in the video!!!
Not to mention _her_ lyrics.
Well. I think they both slayed it! ❤❤
I so agree
@@darrellmoore5349 I appreciate you. Like if you are an Mj fan
👇
You can tell me I'm wrong...then you better prove you're right, they're selling out souls but I care about mine. 💯🤘❤🔥
Coolest artist ever
Michaels music will never get old I can listen to his songs over and over and feel the same about them R.I.P king of pop
This is absolutely the best brother and sister dance scene ever
Tell that to Ross and Monica Geller
@@aniaamz3602 😂
Exactly
Lol, yeah after 2 million takes🤣
To me it's look like a sister & sister video 😂
Ok but is anyone going to talk about how this music video is so well done and ahead of its timeeeee?! just wow
Right? You would never think it's from 1995.
they were playing ping pong...
Release this in 2005 and it could still fit in... This song is way ahead of 1995
This music video costed $7 million dollars to make lmao what's why it looks so good
Watch the Thriller video, talk about ahead of it's time!
THIS SONG IS SO UNDERRATED 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
One of the best dance sequences!!! EVER! ❤ Random MJ marathon, March 2024! MJ FOREVER!❤🎉
This is sooooooo iconic, it’s 2020 and I’m still shooked to the ground
Why are you shooked to the ground? Wtf? Why bro? I mean yeah after so many years the video is still pretty intense and strange but I mean it is kinda weird to me too. I donno, the world is still pretty crazy as it is regardless. But Mike? He's pretty much always been weird but sexy too.😎😘💜🤔
I saw it when it first came out, and I'm still shook...it's called 100% pure talent.
Janet Jackson is an Icon
we're DOOMED!!!DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMEDD!!!!!
It's so good it should be illegal
Fun fact: This is the most expensive music video of all time
Fun fact: 3:08: Jeff Bezos with an important statement.
It’s 7 million dollars he dished out 10 million
Today you coulda filmed it with tik tok
@@Wrenchturner300 no you couldn’t
NOOOOOO WAY
My world is Screaming Mike 🗣️ 🌎
Congratulations on 30 million subscribers, this content is worthy of 300 million subscribers, because Michael Jackson is the god of the voice
Along with "They Don't Care About Us," there's a Michael Jackson song for what's going on in the world today.
earth song?
@@winifergarcia9386 YES
ruclips.net/video/XBK7jKpK1sc/видео.html
@@rosethxr Keep the Faith, is quite relevant.
Yeah he tried to warn us about a Lot of things. Truly ahead of his time and there will Never be another
This the only song they did together. And it’s brilliant.
ETA: thanks for the thumbs up!
technically not, as janet helped produce/ sing the backing track to P.Y.T From Michael's Hit Album Thriller
Your ears don't work
@@onesong2001 No yours need to be cleaned with all the chemicals this world has produce.
@@thabisokhumalo6516 You're a clone.
@@onesong2001 Your parents are 😘
Love you Michael Jackson 😊😊😊
This is ART.
Michael is amazing but DAMN I forget how well Janet can dance. So much talent in their family it's insane.
It's hereditary for sure ☺
BooBoo Magoo you are righr
octoberapple Really? That’s crazy cause she killed it in her videos. I guess she compared herself to Michael.
my dad almost danced fr her
@@Mss_Wick Even MJ himself was often shy and self-deprecating about his dancing skills, at least based on what I saw in his interview with Oprah. Just humble people, A combination of their crazy parents and naturally having good hearts. That and I think they've got a perfectionist gene that runs in the family, lol.
Michael is pissed off and baby sister Janet has his back, I love this
she sure did! lolz 🤍
They look so good getting their point across. Janet stretching at the Barre then they embark on side by side
massive moves. Brilliant.
Best and truest comment
✨👌💯
Song sounds like it’s about their dad.
😢😢THE SCREAM BEFORE DANCING TOGETHER HITS HARD EVERY TIME..EVEN FELT THE SAME WHEN SEEING HER IN CONCERT LAST SEPTEMBER ❤💪🏽💯💯👏👏👏
I want Michael Jackson to be alive again
I miss Michael Jackson, he's definitely THE GREATEST ARTIST of all times. He was gone way too soon. I love him!
Same here
Ithink its JRR Tolkien
JErriah
Yo también lo extraño tanto que ya empiezo a creer que no murió. Lo vi una vez en Dangerous tour en Argentina. Pero mí primer casette fue triller.
lol.
This brother-sister collaboration is musical artistry at its finest.
White Bear true
Long Live The King 👑
I remember the entire world on the edge of our seats waiting for the world premiere of this video and when it hit it did not disappoint. I remember dancing in the living room with my sister and mom during the world premiere of this 😂
I hate that people are trying to compare Chris Brown to Michael! There will NEVER be another Michael!
Exactly I feel the same
Jeffrey H there will never be another no one
Chris Brown is just a fan of MJ
Jeffrey H so true
@@bluecashmire yep, and thats ok...
To this day, their dance breakdown still gives me chills.
Same
It's the best part of the song.
Me too they are so pretty
Em Pac I only wish it was longer! It still gives me chills. Every single time I watch this video, I have to watch the dance sequence at least 4 times: one I watch both of them, then I watch Michael, then Janet, then I watch it one more time! lol they is not, nor will there EVER be artists like this again! I literally feel blessed that I was there in my prime when this music came out, and now my teenage children LOVE IT! I’m a proud mom I showed them right!! 😂
Em Pac same
MAN ,this was and still is the coolest thing ever ..
And I recognize Michael previest masterpieces .but to see him with his little sister is awesome.
I love this Duo in this song.
you know when Michael Jackson starts cussing ("Stop Fuckin' With Me), you know he's 100% dead ass serious about whatever he's mad about/talking about hahaha
INJUSTICE-YES
Your so right! Michael never cussed! I heard that about him. Great observation!
FACTS!!! My favorite part of the song!!
STFU
He was talking about the haters
Don't worry, you are not the only one who listens to this masterpiece in 2024
yeah i know right
Yeah right here
Yeah I'm too.. 😅😅
This song is pathetic
@@onesong2001 You've ranted at many comments here. Nobody's listening to you & you come across as immature and pathetic. Go to a fan page about Prince and be in the company of those sugars. MJ's videos are not for you. We don't want to read your drivels and delusions.
It's April 2024, let's see how many legends are listening to this incredible Michael Jackson song
Music 🎵 = Michael Jackson ❤
This is the strongest and clearest I’ve ever heard Janet’s vocals. The pain and strength of her words broke thru on this song.
Facts!
Try listening to Black Cat.
big bro mjj pushed here till she couldnt push no more . if u woring mjj and u shit aint good he aint working u
Actually it was MJ who wanted to re-record his vocals after hearing how strong her vocals were. Jimmy Jam shared that in an interview a while back. It was a competition between the two.
@@sointoxicated that why the song is soo dope . how i wished mjj was alive . i wished trump was kabut and mjj was live
Katherine Jackson really gave birth to two of the greatest legends in the entire history of music
Womb of gold!!!
She birthed a dynasty.
What's the point of this comment? If they hadn't been pushed so hard and not loved so little they wouldn't have been as successful as this.
@@suziezurfreiheit6825 Who hurt you at home?
That comment simply to praise a mother. What's wrong with that?
She is not good as him, WE Can t compare at all, no Jackson could exist without Michael Jackson succes. He is unique.
I love the Jackson’s they all have talent that’s rare for a family Michael Jacksin RIP
The song does not get old over time
This looks like it could have been released this year. Timeless.
yeah it was ahead of its time because everyone thought that well see flying cars in 2000s
was the most expensive video of its time and it actually has characters from Asian anime dragon ball in it so its cool even today . mj was always ahead of his time did everyone see smooth criminal made in the eighties but still way ahead of the times.
@@123terricam it was so well done
true that. was thinking the exact same
It really doesnt 😂
Fun fact: this is the most expensive music video ever made in the music industry, Michael Jackson spent over 7 millions dollars for this music video.
Didn't melanie Martinez spend 7 mil for her movie and album
Yeah they had to build an actual space ship to shoot it outside the planet.
@@ewceniza90 LOL. But the fuct is, that 20 years later it still kicks ass
@@ariyanahamilton6424movie but this is a mv
i heard it 8 to 10 mil
So much message in one MV. Thanks for speaking truth, Michael.
Right on!
Nobody, and I mean nobody moves like the GOAT, Michael Jackson~
It's been 26 years since this video was released and it still looks futuristic as hell.
Exactly
ikr!
Absolutely 🤟🏽
That's because MJ was always ahead of his time. He set trends. There are performers coming out every day who use his dance moves with no idea where they came from. Say what you will about MJ, but he was one of the few performers that you can legitimately call an artist. He perfected his craft, and will forever be an icon for that.
@@emismommy01 The 🐐❗️
The King ❤❤❤❤❤❤
The coolest sibling duo ever
Why can't quarantine look more like this? Life is so unfair.
LOL
😂😂😂
Jose Quiles quarantine in here lamo
He was wealthy
IT can
Imagine being that talented - and your brother is Michael Jackson. Janet doesn't get the credit she deserves as a solo artist.
Whippy99 yes she does, Janet is the second most female artist of the 90’s behind Mariah
Whippy99 that's wat I'm saying
Are you KIDDING ME with that bullshit?? Those two adored each other dont sit there and make Janet out like she's suffered. She's just as famous as her brother as they BOTH worked their asses off to get where they are. Its not like Micheal Jackson was handed ANYTHING, so you really need to sit down and shut up. You have NO idea what your talking about when it comes to either of them.
Janet is the female version of MJ. She’s on the same level as him. You have no idea, what your talking about @Whippy99!
@@blackcattheultimatemoonwal4935 Same level of talent/skills or popularity?
The dance break is ICONIC
It’s February 29 2024 and here I am , we miss u man
THE GOAT!
The part where they dance together will ALWAYS be my favorite 💙
same!! its so iconic
I always imagine the two poking fun at each other. Like a long awaited holiday reunion of loving siblings. "You need to be on point!"
Then "no NO ... YOU need to be on point!!!!". Clearly Janet loved her troubled brother Mike. And Janet loved him unconditionally. RIP Michael Jackson an entertainer eternally. And Janet we/I love you always.
Mine 2
I watch this MV over and over to watch that particular part.
Me too
I just can't believe that this music video was released in 1995 !!! So modern AF
I was just thinking the Kardashian sisters dress rhis way..And people think they are fashion icons..😂
It was and still is the most expensive music video in history
It cost like 8 or 9 millions of dollars
@@odbass1497 7 only
shahad alsanea There is anime in it.
This song and video is the it! 💯
Wow, hail the king!
Twins. I don't care. They look alike. I love both. Happy Birthday Michael Jackson. Rest In Peace.
Ok... This is a secret don't tell no one their siblings
@Miya Deshae who doesn’t know they’re siblings?!?!
@Andire I know I’m just saying, I’m not a person to be woooshed if you ask me.
@Jaylen Tyerian look at them on the younger age. They actually always look alike.
He had a skin disease so it was a must to go under operations and the pepsi commercial made it worst when he got burned and he fixed his nose other than that they actually look alike but him and latoya look alike more
Why is this video looks like it's just release today?
MJ is timeless.
Because it is just so good!!!!
@@TheDinoKitteh I did not know that one.
Its like 25 years old i think
When this came out in 1995, the special effects were incredible... now you can make them on a phone.
@@BillAnt well technology evolved
Raw as hell. Iconic.
No cause they really ate this up
no fr
When they dance together it is so. Damn. Satisfying.
yep
Yes!
Best.moment.ever
2021 and Beyond. 😊
Yeah 😭
@@suckyourmom. yes
I don't know how I got here, but I'm glad that I came.
Always
I'm making non racist sunglasses that are all the same color so when you look out of them everyone looks the same color🤓 purple is purple 💜💜
I’m so happy that Micheal and Janet had a chance to perform together 😊
This song shocked me as a kid... MJ was this hero, and then this video came out and it was dark, gritty, almost an "edgy" version of MJ. This song ended up being my favorite MJ because of the realness, and frustration in his voice. Instead of the King of Pop singing, this is Michael Jackson singing.
10\10
(Also Michael says a no-no word 🤣)
I wish Michael and Janet performed scream live together.
YES
My sister said that she is scared Michael Jackson
@@majutoswedi4478 why is she
That Is So Awesome!! 😃😄😃😄😍🥰😍🥰🤗🤗
@@majutoswedi4478 why is she?