@KeyHitt enough is enough is absolute garbage it's horrible and has no reason to kill his sisters..also I'm not sure there is remakes for enough is enough..
Vibingleafs version of this creepypasta is incredible! He gave squidward after the red mist have a personality. He wasn’t just a goofy looking soulless version of squidward, he was afraid of what he saw. And I love that he traced squidwards reaction to the hash slinging slasher in the video. Adds a nice touch!
@@unoriginalperson72 it's probably not there to shove the "suicide isnt the way to go" message to our face but just to show spongebob and patrick's reaction to the situation. But yeah I can kinda see where you're coming from
Red Mist Retake was a masterpiece. The story, the part were Spongebob and Patrick care about Squidward was depressing and heartbreaking. VibingLeaf is the chosen one who carried the creepypasta community.
@@PigPigGamer I'm confused on the cons part. You said for the cons that none of the video is a work of art. Also, it had bad grammer which makes me even more confused.
Vibing Leaf's remake represents that red mist is legit suicidal thoughts and not just some random squidward png looking creepy, also the monster thing squidward sees might be like a figment of his imagination and is the embodyment of suicide. Also squidward hears spongebob's scream after he passed because the last sense you will lose is hearing and touch so it makes sense.
As someone who almost committed, VibingLeaf’s ending really got to me, it made me think “if I was gone, could the people that loved me truly move on?” I honestly almost cried at that part
Every squidwards suicide story in a nutshell: Hyper realistic eyes Edit:so the picture with the mickey mouse looking corpse at the end of red mist re-take is actually supposed to represent 4 entities. Squidward red mist Mickey mouse Dead Bart The greiving(gumball creepypasta)
Another thing about the VibingLeaf retake, in the last scene Patrick just completely forgets the things he told Spongebob to make him feel better about Squidward's death, fitting with the running gag in the show where Patrick says something smart and just immediately forgets what he said, only this time its a bit more serious.
The Scottish fish is only in Red Mist, not Squidward's Suicide. Red Mist is basically a version of the creepy pasta that is intended to provide more context for everything that's happening.
that "scottish fish" is actually Andrew Skinner. According to the creepypasta, Andrew is the serial k¡ller who took the children photo and also created the Red mist and squidward su¡cide tapes.
I kinda remember something about this. Back in 2014-2015, there was an edited version of Red Mist, it goes almost the same as the original, until Squidward's death. After Squidward's death, there's a mockup where Squidward is kinda going to heaven, but then everything goes terrible and he falls to hell. The heaven animation was probably stolen from another place and it looked like Squidward was just put in there. After that, Squidward wakes up in the hospital, and then he looks at his friends who were all around him, but then he realizes his friends have totally blank eyes and no mouth. That scene was taken from the episode he laughs his ass off then ends up hospitalized. A couple years later I tried to find the video again but it got erased and then I lost the link :(
vibingleaf definitely deserved to be in S tier, he can turn literally ANY creepypasta (he even did this man and herobrine) into a horrifying video, and actually make it good
Y'know, at this point, you could make "VibingLeaf" the highest tier on the list and nobody would argue about it. The guy's able to take scary stories about lost episodes and hyper-realistic eyes and blood, and twist it into something legitimately scary.
@@nathanjames141 He already did that before Red Mist, go into his "Doomed.Mp4" playlist. The story isn't really like Sonic.exe though, it's something completely original.
Red Mist pros and cons moments 7:20 Remake 1 10:36 Remake 2 12:53 Remake 3 18:25 Remake 4 21:51 Remake 5 Remake 6 is just pamtri and does not have pros and cons 28:58 Remake 7 31:43 Remake 8 36:43 Remake 9 39:41 Remake 10
For some context on pamtri’s remake, it was one of the many low budget animations that are meant to be funny rather than serious, which is why it looked like that
What’s sad is that most of the retakes get most stuff wrong, such as squidward having a pistol instead of a shotgun (because he uses a shotgun in the story) or are just really bad. But vibing leaf’s is just really good
Im gonna start a thread explaining why it’s probably the best retake we have for red mist. -it actually gives personality to the characters and the characters are actually more in-character, like how spongebob and patrick grieve squidward’s death in the end -I’m guessing that the entity that scared squidward is supposed to be the voices that tell him to “do it” in the original creepypasta -whenever squidward fails his concert, I like how the world around him turns black, as if squidward came to the thought that everyone abandoned him, and he’s alone -it was already addressed in this video, but I like how the animation is frame by frame as if it’s unfinished -it actually looks like the art style in season 4 kinda, because squidward’s suicide is a replacement of fear of a krabby patty, which is season 4 episode 1 There is so much more I can address, but I don’t have enough time, congrats vibingleaf
im generally not a fan of vibingleaf's vids but their retake is without a doubt the best one, and only because it keeps the real-life murder scenes besides those I find the ending part to be corny (doesn't fit the original story, and retake or not it's still kinda cheesy)
What I really like about vibingleaf's take is their version of the face. It usually is depicted as a blank expression but here Squidward's brow is furrowed and the red in his eyes is used sparingly. It's unnervingly human. More than looking as if becoming something possessed, he looks genuinely sad.
I remember as a kid, I was terrified of Red Mist and had literal nightmares for months after seeing it, and now I'm watching this to get over my stupid fear. Wish me luck!
@DanielSantosDeLima-fe4dx it's better, I still have that innate fear, but it's much more muted, and that's literally bc I watched this video like 100 times lol
Vibingleaf might be the only remake that didn’t treat it that way. In the end if the video, SpongeBob and Patrick’s conversation shows how heartbreaking suicide can be.
@@Spinyedits tbh the only thing that scares me about creepypasta is just the images. Like the one of sonic.exe scared me so bad I could not sleep for a year while squidward picture also scared me but only for a week and as I grew up now all the pics just don't do it for me anymore.
What I think is great is that the creepypasta became so popular that even the animators of SpongeBob and Nickelodeon themselves added the red mist as a little reference during an actual episode. Which is hilarious to think about. I'm actually kind of surprised they even did it in the first place
@@Team_bloxers After it aired originally. Airings after the first one had the scene removed and replaced with a Baby Squidward... which after watching Quiet on Set just seems... off to me.
if i remember correctly, the red mist retake is probably the most accurate to the story as well. Since it does include the pictures of the supposed dead kids that would randomly appear for a couple of frames during the story. which doesn't seem to be the case for any of the other remakes. idk maybe i'm mixing it up with another old creepypasta.
No, you had it right. The dead children would cut in between static and Squidward crying frames. I understand why this factor isn't on RUclips videos, It's just that it was a part of the original story and for some reason its so forgettable.
@@Zkid_101 I believe I remember some video narrating the Red Mist creepypasta actually mentioning the dead children from a few years ago! It mentioned like 2 kids dead on a carpet with their eyeballs pulled out.
I think I saw the red mist retake that you liked so much (the one with SpongeBob and Patrick talking after squidward sad fate) and I thought it was very said but I love how it’s included the part of Patrick and SpongeBob talking to help the viewer understand how everything concluded and how SpongeBob reacted
I remember seeing a version of the Red Mist on RUclips that had pictures of dead children that would flash for a fraction of a second. It was so fast that you couldn't them out at first. I only discovered that they were uncensored images of dead children after trying very hard to pause the video at the right time. I remember these images flashing by the end of the video in the part between infamous red eyed squidward in the hall image and the part where he shoots himself. I was a young kid when I found that version of the video and its been more than a decade since I've seen it. EDIT: The pictures I'm taking about were most likely edits and not real images. Still very unsettling.
8:15 *This is actually just a Squidward text to speech voice, like with the first remake.* 9:08 *Squidward gets hit in the face by a glass bottle coming at him at about 100 mph and dies* 32:14
GOD I used to be HORRIFIED of these videos when I was younger 😭 Honestly I love this video and you should definitely continue the series! ^^ Your personality doesn’t seem forced like most videos I have seen recently and I definitely think this is enjoyable content! :D
The episode was made between 2003, 2004, 2005, & 2006. Leland Skinner mentions that his brother Andrew Skinner, (the creator of Squidward’s Suicide) made 5 tapes with creepy cartoons on them, the ones involving Spongebob were: “SuicideSquidward” (It was sent to Florida in late 2003 under the name: Madison Richards,) “Squidwards Suicide” (the famous one from the Creepypasta) It was sent to California in late 2004, and the third one: “Red Mist” (the one involving the Scottish Fish, that has the voice that says; “The Red Mist Is Coming” in it) Which was sent to the Canadian Branch of Nick Studios in April/May of 2006. I have the ‘Red Mist’ version of Squidwards Suicide recorded on a DVD, I posted it on my channel.
I always liked to interpret Red Mist as having been created (In the universe where the episode exists) as a screwed up joke. Red mist retake feels like someone wanted to go off script and make thier own different episode
Ye, I remember the Scottish fish appearing and disappearing from each version of the story. I remember even a version where it claims the episode was created by a Scottish person that disappeared after the investigation and the fish was a self-insert, but I was never able to find this version again.
At this point I think vibingleaf is the reason the creepypasta based off childhood is alive and well. If im being serious right now i left the fandom and then this guy showed up and I rejoined immediately. that guys a legend
Dude you deserve every single subscriber and views you get, you're an amazing new content creator and your stuff genuinely seems that it was put effort into. your doing an amazing job please keep it up!
Great video, the only thing is that there was one notable video not included on this list that scared me the most as a kid, I can’t find it but it was fully animated and had Radiohead for some reason(???), despite that, great video, gave me a lil bit of nostalgia to when creepypastas used to terrify little me
Vibinleafs version depicts what would have been just Squidward being sad for a night and sleeping it off. I believe it was really the most that drove him to end himself.
And the best part about the re take for me is that the iconic red mist image is much different from the original image, he actually made his own version of the image.
the fact that he seemed so happy about a video getting 3k views and thinking gettin 100 likes is some far off hard to reach goal and seeing this one with 69k views and nearly 6k likes is kinda heart warming
I'm gonna be honest here: While I met you last year and knew you for more of your other content (mainly geometry dash, lol), I am personally loving this content change, and I feel that you're seriously in your element when covering this kind of stuff. Would love to see a full series come out of this (assuming there isn't one going on already, of course) as it is very much entertaining.
It’s so nice to see that his goal was 100 likes and now he has 36k. It’s so wholesome when you get to see a RUclipsr have such low goals just to get a huge impact.
i think the reason why that less colorful one had the scene where squidward just keeps staring is because they edited a clip out poorly, i rmemeber seeing a version of the video that had actual gore scenes, or atleast very realistic looking gore, so the person who reuploaded it edited it out cheaply
btw i don't mean the like one frame scenes, there was a whole sequence of someone taking pics of the bodies, and i think it had production song "The Mob" over it
i partially found the footage, its narrated over but its exactly how i remembered it visualwise very big nsfl warning just in case for the bodies but "El suicidio de calamardo La verdadera historia", 5:26
I'd actually like to see you rank every Sonic.EXE remake/retake/reimagining out there. It would be a LOT of effort, and very different from normal due to the fact that you have to describe games along with videos (And some Sonic.EXE videos are series), but I think that it could be really fun and cool! Also, if you don’t put Needlem0use in The Best tier I will break into your house and make you feel unsafe (For legal reasons, this is a joke)
I read the story there's no scottish fish, and in the story it's supposed to have have pictures of dead kids, and when the wind part come on there's a voice that tells squidward to "do it"
The only you have readen is squidward's s*icide, wich is the original creepypasta. The one with the scottish fish is "Red mist" wich is "fanmade remaster"
I love how in VibingLeaf’s remake Squidward starts hallucinating and seeing these entitys from what I would assume,the red mist.And instead of a sad and depressing ending,Patrick helps Spongebob get through the death of Squidward.
I did actually talk to the creator for red mist retake vibing leaf if you see this you've been the GOAT when it comes to making these remakes so far (also when it came to making VHS Sonic at the time at first he was just a VHS Sans sonic variant now He's just sonic.exe but if the "hyper realistic" eyes were done more better and his body horror was taken a lot more of a Phantom twist to it as well as a more intense look to it)
Amazing video!!! This tier list video inspired me to write a Red Mist Retake Pasta (still deciding where I'm going to post it.) Keep up the great work!
I remember the actual image being in an episode in the first season where there were a bunch of doors and I think squidward opens one and that shows for about a second, then he closes it. Its since been removed for it being too scary for little kids, even though I was 10 or 11 at the time and I'm 13 now so it must have either been removed recently or it was an old recording of the episode on prime video.
Everyone is talkin about vibingleaf and im here for because i also love the retake but im just floored that you included the fuckin video where the guy shows his little cousins or whatever the old red mist video that he transfered to a fucking vhs tape. I revisit that shit more than the actual video
I kinda like how found footage 7 has poor quality voice acting. Like, according to the story, the tape was apparently put together an hour before the crew watched it and made by a single person, so I can imagine the whole thing would have horrible quality from animation, voice acting, sound effects, probably even artwork. Kinda gives it an uncanny vibe.
You know The concert scene is Reused from The Not so good "SquidBob TenticlePants" Episode. Thus The Animation is somehow different whenever it switches to a season 1 and 5 Episode.
You kind of need to appreciate how people make Red Mist remakes like this. I was trying to make one, and in the footage where Squidward played in the concert, I tried finding something accurate to it, and the one that was accurate was "Squidbob Tentaclepants." I tried finding footage of it using a streaming website, but it was hard to find, mainly because the website that hosted Spongebob had the episodes not organized. I don't know why.
Honestly, if you’re familiar with Pamtri’s work his take on Red Mist is actually one of his more unnerving videos. I’d recommend his Dying for Pie video as well if you want something a little heavier
PigPigGamer, you've done it again. This video was one of the best RUclips videos of my entire life. I watched this on my TV yesterday and I loved it. Good luck on the Max and Ruby 0004 video.
it's so nice seeing the beginning of this video bragging about 4k views and 200 likes and this video has over 1 million views. i'm so happy for you. i can't imagine how happy that must have made you :^)
The loud noise in the scene where squidward is staring into the screen is an actual song called Torn Into Pieces by the German noise band called Genocide Organ. The song was recorded in 1985.
One thing I could ask, If possible, Is if you could maybe make a pastebin link with every Video you reviewed in order so we can go watch any of them quickly, that would be a great addition for future tiering videos!
Another day, another VibingLeaf W. Edit: Also, I feel bad for that kid that was watching Red Mist. That’s definitely some childhood trauma to process in the future.
Quite surprised there isn't the Andywilson92 version and the Jose Luis Moren version (iirc, the Jose Luise Moren version does contain the dead children that the others except Vibingleaf leaves out). Overall, it's nice to see which adaptations got scenes right and wrong
I would always be fascinated by remakes of lost episode pastas on RUclips little me always enjoyed them. I always wanted to make my takes on these kind of pastas maybe I'll do one one day if I ever get into animation
100 likes in literally 20 minutes, you guys are CRAZY. Max and Ruby 0004 ranking video soon
You literally got 400 in under an Hour-
LoL
you should rate every Enough Is Enough remake its scary, Enough Is Enough is a loud house lost episode
@KeyHitt enough is enough is absolute garbage it's horrible and has no reason to kill his sisters..also I'm not sure there is remakes for enough is enough..
I like onions
Vibingleafs version of this creepypasta is incredible! He gave squidward after the red mist have a personality. He wasn’t just a goofy looking soulless version of squidward, he was afraid of what he saw. And I love that he traced squidwards reaction to the hash slinging slasher in the video. Adds a nice touch!
Not a big fan of the sappy ending like yeah I get it life is worth living and suicide isn't an answer but it's whatever
@@unoriginalperson72 it's probably not there to shove the "suicide isnt the way to go" message to our face but just to show spongebob and patrick's reaction to the situation. But yeah I can kinda see where you're coming from
Nah it’s more he’s terrified
Vibingleaf’s retakes are pretty dang good
VibingLeaf the goat
vibingleaf's remake is both horrifying and heart breaking. shows that spongebob and patrick actually care for squidward.
That very much great if best one
i saw that one btw
They miss having fun and when squidward shouts
Balls
@@real_youtubeuser no
Red Mist Retake was a masterpiece. The story, the part were Spongebob and Patrick care about Squidward was depressing and heartbreaking. VibingLeaf is the chosen one who carried the creepypasta community.
I cant wait for Dead Bart Retake to come out, I’ll rank dead Bart videos as soon as that comes out
@@PigPigGamer can you do every the grieving retake?
@@PigPigGamer I'm confused on the cons part. You said for the cons that none of the video is a work of art. Also, it had bad grammer which makes me even more confused.
@@PigPigGamer can you react to my red mist happy ending video (aka green mist)
@@PigPigGamer well you gotta do the grieving ranking first
Vibing Leaf's remake represents that red mist is legit suicidal thoughts and not just some random squidward png looking creepy, also the monster thing squidward sees might be like a figment of his imagination and is the embodyment of suicide. Also squidward hears spongebob's scream after he passed because the last sense you will lose is hearing and touch so it makes sense.
As someone who almost committed, VibingLeaf’s ending really got to me, it made me think “if I was gone, could the people that loved me truly move on?” I honestly almost cried at that part
hope your doing better now ml
@@kkeojyeos Thank you! I am in a much better place now!
@@justpeachyyyyy thats amazing to hear! ❤️❤️
@@justpeachyyyyyjust remember ur loved :D
i felt that tho, litterally what i thought when i was about to
Every squidwards suicide story in a nutshell:
Hyper realistic eyes
Edit:so the picture with the mickey mouse looking corpse at the end of red mist re-take is actually supposed to represent 4 entities.
Squidward red mist
Mickey mouse
Dead Bart
The greiving(gumball creepypasta)
They haven't seen the ps5
They needed it horribly bad
Which 4 entities?
So suicide mouse dead bart And grieving Nicole Are actually victims that red mist squidward kill
@red míst squidward suicide mouse dead bart And grieving Nicole
Another thing about the VibingLeaf retake, in the last scene Patrick just completely forgets the things he told Spongebob to make him feel better about Squidward's death, fitting with the running gag in the show where Patrick says something smart and just immediately forgets what he said, only this time its a bit more serious.
The Scottish fish is only in Red Mist, not Squidward's Suicide. Red Mist is basically a version of the creepy pasta that is intended to provide more context for everything that's happening.
Plus red mist didn’t have any music at the title card sooooooo
Wait they are different I didn't know😂😅
Did any of you see the actual episode cause I did
@nikkipisterzi7435 listen up young buck💯. I suggest you yap that nonsense at another place or get this piece combo simpleton💀☝️
that "scottish fish" is actually Andrew Skinner. According to the creepypasta, Andrew is the serial k¡ller who took the children photo and also created the Red mist and squidward su¡cide tapes.
I kinda remember something about this.
Back in 2014-2015, there was an edited version of Red Mist, it goes almost the same as the original, until Squidward's death.
After Squidward's death, there's a mockup where Squidward is kinda going to heaven, but then everything goes terrible and he falls to hell. The heaven animation was probably stolen from another place and it looked like Squidward was just put in there.
After that, Squidward wakes up in the hospital, and then he looks at his friends who were all around him, but then he realizes his friends have totally blank eyes and no mouth. That scene was taken from the episode he laughs his ass off then ends up hospitalized.
A couple years later I tried to find the video again but it got erased and then I lost the link :(
ruclips.net/video/qdaumTClR0Y/видео.html
Knew this sounded familiar.
@@declanhenshaw1598bruh.
Isn't that the ending of a YTP of Squid's Day Off where Squidward injects a syringe in his neck before hand?
Isn’t that completely different creepypasta called faceless?
Spingebill experiences a horrifying NDE
20:33 bro has the mario star equipped
Underrated
LMAO
vibingleaf definitely deserved to be in S tier, he can turn literally ANY creepypasta (he even did this man and herobrine) into a horrifying video, and actually make it good
@Rhok T(in a heavy Southern accent) i donuo man i guess life's just just not fair sometimes 🤠
@rhokt9195 he did, i was just saying it deserved the rating it got
He made Jeff the Killer actually terrifying
No joke
Yes
666 Likes
Y'know, at this point, you could make "VibingLeaf" the highest tier on the list and nobody would argue about it. The guy's able to take scary stories about lost episodes and hyper-realistic eyes and blood, and twist it into something legitimately scary.
VibingLeaf could probably make "THEN WHO WAS PHONE?" horrifying
dude could fix sonic.exe💀
And his making a fnaf retake, that is also a game.
@@nathanjames141 He already did that before Red Mist, go into his "Doomed.Mp4" playlist. The story isn't really like Sonic.exe though, it's something completely original.
@@morshulinton4112 I can see them doing that as a type of April Fool's day video
Red Mist pros and cons moments
7:20 Remake 1
10:36 Remake 2
12:53 Remake 3
18:25 Remake 4
21:51 Remake 5
Remake 6 is just pamtri and does not have pros and cons
28:58 Remake 7
31:43 Remake 8
36:43 Remake 9
39:41 Remake 10
I thought this took a lot of effort, good job
@@rohnanatkinson2600 thank you
You know I love how remake 6 is the only remake to have neither pros or cons
Remake 6 should be in the best tier list
Cuz the video is tighter than bark on a tree
1 is that yesod exists and he can beat almost any enemy in library of ruina and imo is just better
For some context on pamtri’s remake, it was one of the many low budget animations that are meant to be funny rather than serious, which is why it looked like that
Yeah, and I love pamtris videos for that lol
What’s sad is that most of the retakes get most stuff wrong, such as squidward having a pistol instead of a shotgun (because he uses a shotgun in the story) or are just really bad. But vibing leaf’s is just really good
Im gonna start a thread explaining why it’s probably the best retake we have for red mist.
-it actually gives personality to the characters and the characters are actually more in-character, like how spongebob and patrick grieve squidward’s death in the end
-I’m guessing that the entity that scared squidward is supposed to be the voices that tell him to “do it” in the original creepypasta
-whenever squidward fails his concert, I like how the world around him turns black, as if squidward came to the thought that everyone abandoned him, and he’s alone
-it was already addressed in this video, but I like how the animation is frame by frame as if it’s unfinished
-it actually looks like the art style in season 4 kinda, because squidward’s suicide is a replacement of fear of a krabby patty, which is season 4 episode 1
There is so much more I can address, but I don’t have enough time, congrats vibingleaf
im generally not a fan of vibingleaf's vids but their retake is without a doubt the best one, and only because it keeps the real-life murder scenes
besides those I find the ending part to be corny (doesn't fit the original story, and retake or not it's still kinda cheesy)
@@analyticCioccolata the reason why it has the ending speech is because the retake is his interpretation on the story, but I see where you’re going
I accidentally disliked this comment oops
@@cornstarch5920 nah it’s fine
The red mist picture used to downright terrify me and looking back I have no idea why
DONT ASK
DONT ASK WHO JOE MAMA IS
@@Disbanded9998 why are you like this
@@calthegreatest sorry i thought the image was funny
Same bruh
I remember being scared of slender the eight pages now looking at it makes me laugh,i mean literally look at the slender model 💀
What I really like about vibingleaf's take is their version of the face. It usually is depicted as a blank expression but here Squidward's brow is furrowed and the red in his eyes is used sparingly. It's unnervingly human. More than looking as if becoming something possessed, he looks genuinely sad.
I remember as a kid, I was terrified of Red Mist and had literal nightmares for months after seeing it, and now I'm watching this to get over my stupid fear. Wish me luck!
@DanielSantosDeLima-fe4dx it's better, I still have that innate fear, but it's much more muted, and that's literally bc I watched this video like 100 times lol
Lmaoo I used to be terrified of that Squidward image
That's weird Im a kid and after a day I got over it
I see you. When i was a kid, I would NOT go anywhere dark or else Red Mist Sqiudward would catch me. lol so stupid
@@PinnedComparisonsYTLiterally the most accurate description of the weird "Creepypasta character in my house" scenarios my brain imagines
I question why so many creepy pastas treat suicide as a creepy and mysterious thing, when it's a really sad thing that many people deal with
It makes it relatable.
yeah, they kinda do lol
yeah i hate it, treating it like an "edgy" or "creepy" thing is disrespectful as hell
Vibingleaf might be the only remake that didn’t treat it that way. In the end if the video, SpongeBob and Patrick’s conversation shows how heartbreaking suicide can be.
i really miss being genuinely scared of these creepypastas. Like Sonic.Exe, Red Mist, Jeff The Killer, Slender, and so on.
It was fun.
Don't forget Suicide Mouse, Dead Bart, and The Grieving.
the only creepypastas to ever scare me were, red mist, Bootleg spongebob, max and ruby 004 and the godzilla one
@@Spinyedits tbh the only thing that scares me about creepypasta is just the images. Like the one of sonic.exe scared me so bad I could not sleep for a year while squidward picture also scared me but only for a week and as I grew up now all the pics just don't do it for me anymore.
@@fishkingoftheaquarium7605 its the music for me
FACTS
I remember when Red Mist started to gain popularity again and all the remakes came out, but holy hell VibingLeaf’s is amazing.
Right as you said "Also, guess what?" at 11:08 i got a Little Caeser's ad advertising some kind of breadstick pizza.
Excellent video, by the way!
"Also, guess what- *BREAD STICKS*"
31:03 Squidward's eyes look like burnt onion rings
What I think is great is that the creepypasta became so popular that even the animators of SpongeBob and Nickelodeon themselves added the red mist as a little reference during an actual episode. Which is hilarious to think about. I'm actually kind of surprised they even did it in the first place
They removed it though
@@Team_bloxers After it aired originally. Airings after the first one had the scene removed and replaced with a Baby Squidward... which after watching Quiet on Set just seems... off to me.
@@MinecartWithTNT ye
Honestly this series makes me wanna make my own original lost episode creepypasta
Go for it! I’d love to see it
whatever you do.
here's some of the things that were done before
SpongeBob (duh)
mickey
the simpsons
there's more
@@Cigitrip my little pony
Max and Ruby
Pokémon
(Just to add on to specifics)
@@Sp3ctralI gumball,
bfdi,
SML
teen titans go
And i think loud house Had one too
17:28 “Patrick’s got his back. he’s gonna get through it” - 💀💀
OH GOD I JUST REALISED 💀
OH MY GOD I JUST REALIZED
¿?
WAIT A MINUTE
Huh?
if i remember correctly, the red mist retake is probably the most accurate to the story as well. Since it does include the pictures of the supposed dead kids that would randomly appear for a couple of frames during the story. which doesn't seem to be the case for any of the other remakes. idk maybe i'm mixing it up with another old creepypasta.
No, you had it right. The dead children would cut in between static and Squidward crying frames. I understand why this factor isn't on RUclips videos, It's just that it was a part of the original story and for some reason its so forgettable.
@@Zkid_101 I believe I remember some video narrating the Red Mist creepypasta actually mentioning the dead children from a few years ago! It mentioned like 2 kids dead on a carpet with their eyeballs pulled out.
@@ayonimator3433 MARIO (rom hack) moment
@@frannielmartinez Damn
@@Zkid_101 it's because it's too graphic for RUclips which is why it never shows up in other remakes.
I think I saw the red mist retake that you liked so much (the one with SpongeBob and Patrick talking after squidward sad fate) and I thought it was very said but I love how it’s included the part of Patrick and SpongeBob talking to help the viewer understand how everything concluded and how SpongeBob reacted
How it feels to chew 5-gum 20:45
This comment its so underrated😂
Brooo
@@The-Epic-clone-royal-flowerwhat
Squidward really bought them RGB gaming eyes 💀💀💀
Yes he's such a gamer
g a m I n g
l e g e n d
I remember seeing a version of the Red Mist on RUclips that had pictures of dead children that would flash for a fraction of a second. It was so fast that you couldn't them out at first. I only discovered that they were uncensored images of dead children after trying very hard to pause the video at the right time. I remember these images flashing by the end of the video in the part between infamous red eyed squidward in the hall image and the part where he shoots himself. I was a young kid when I found that version of the video and its been more than a decade since I've seen it.
EDIT:
The pictures I'm taking about were most likely edits and not real images. Still very unsettling.
holy shit dude.. makes me wonder why the fuck they would have that.. would it be real, or would it not? it's just weird.
@@cinnoman.Iirc it was in the original story to have the image of the children appear.
Yeah it's the one at 18:44 I think
I watched it w my bro and we saw those images, no idea how it's on YT
Luigi was Mario there too but the 5th one is the most bloodiest
@@xX_IGAMELIKEAB0SS_Xx it's still on youtube??
8:16 squidward: will you knock it off? I have a concert tonight!
Spongebob: No-
I love that part.
Analogue horror has the potential to make a lot of lost episode creepypastas a lot scarier
ARG and analog horror
8:15 *This is actually just a Squidward text to speech voice, like with the first remake.*
9:08 *Squidward gets hit in the face by a glass bottle coming at him at about 100 mph and dies*
32:14
i did think red mist was a bit goofy, but that vibingleaf one was actually a breath of fresh air from the rest.
GOD I used to be HORRIFIED of these videos when I was younger 😭
Honestly I love this video and you should definitely continue the series! ^^ Your personality doesn’t seem forced like most videos I have seen recently and I definitely think this is enjoyable content! :D
I saw the rainbow one and couldn’t sleep lmao
When i learned to sleep on my own i was so happy. then i saw red mist and i couldn't sleep anymore lmaoo.
@@PinnedComparisonsYT same brother
Yessss, I agree sooooooo much! ^^ also, I love your Profile picture, Sayori, both her and Yuri are my Favourite DDLC Characters~ :)
The episode was made between 2003, 2004, 2005, & 2006. Leland Skinner mentions that his brother Andrew Skinner, (the creator of Squidward’s Suicide) made 5 tapes with creepy cartoons on them, the ones involving Spongebob were: “SuicideSquidward” (It was sent to Florida in late 2003 under the name: Madison Richards,) “Squidwards Suicide” (the famous one from the Creepypasta) It was sent to California in late 2004, and the third one: “Red Mist” (the one involving the Scottish Fish, that has the voice that says; “The Red Mist Is Coming” in it) Which was sent to the Canadian Branch of Nick Studios in April/May of 2006. I have the ‘Red Mist’ version of Squidwards Suicide recorded on a DVD, I posted it on my channel.
the fog is coming the fog is coming the fog is coming
I always liked to interpret Red Mist as having been created (In the universe where the episode exists) as a screwed up joke. Red mist retake feels like someone wanted to go off script and make thier own different episode
At 26:21 I can make out a couple words Spongebob said. I think he said "Ok Squidward. We're sorry we bothered you."
16:12 the entity is like a physical manifestation of his own misery
17:32 i think it was VibingLeaf foreshadowing their next creepypasta remakes
Ye, I remember the Scottish fish appearing and disappearing from each version of the story.
I remember even a version where it claims the episode was created by a Scottish person that disappeared after the investigation and the fish was a self-insert, but I was never able to find this version again.
if the video was created by a different person… THEN HOW DID THEY GET THE VOICE ACTING RIGHT!?
At this point I think vibingleaf is the reason the creepypasta based off childhood is alive and well. If im being serious right now i left the fandom and then this guy showed up and I rejoined immediately. that guys a legend
Amazing, keep up the good work!, I see so much potential in this channel in the future!
i love watching this creepypasta commentary and tier list style, i really hope this is a series
Dude you deserve every single subscriber and views you get, you're an amazing new content creator and your stuff genuinely seems that it was put effort into. your doing an amazing job please keep it up!
Thanks :D
Great video, the only thing is that there was one notable video not included on this list that scared me the most as a kid, I can’t find it but it was fully animated and had Radiohead for some reason(???), despite that, great video, gave me a lil bit of nostalgia to when creepypastas used to terrify little me
Vibinleafs version depicts what would have been just Squidward being sad for a night and sleeping it off. I believe it was really the most that drove him to end himself.
And the best part about the re take for me is that the iconic red mist image is much different from the original image, he actually made his own version of the image.
the fact that he seemed so happy about a video getting 3k views and thinking gettin 100 likes is some far off hard to reach goal and seeing this one with 69k views and nearly 6k likes is kinda heart warming
I'm gonna be honest here:
While I met you last year and knew you for more of your other content (mainly geometry dash, lol), I am personally loving this content change, and I feel that you're seriously in your element when covering this kind of stuff. Would love to see a full series come out of this (assuming there isn't one going on already, of course) as it is very much entertaining.
why did the scottish "red mist is coming" guy look stoned as hell
It’s so nice to see that his goal was 100 likes and now he has 36k. It’s so wholesome when you get to see a RUclipsr have such low goals just to get a huge impact.
I like the fact you added a joke one! It broke up the mood and made it easier to take on the serious stuff!
i think the reason why that less colorful one had the scene where squidward just keeps staring is because they edited a clip out poorly, i rmemeber seeing a version of the video that had actual gore scenes, or atleast very realistic looking gore, so the person who reuploaded it edited it out cheaply
That could be it tbh
btw i don't mean the like one frame scenes, there was a whole sequence of someone taking pics of the bodies, and i think it had production song "The Mob" over it
i partially found the footage, its narrated over but its exactly how i remembered it visualwise
very big nsfl warning just in case for the bodies but
"El suicidio de calamardo La verdadera historia", 5:26
@@ecirtaeb_madit's in the thumbnail
I'd actually like to see you rank every Sonic.EXE remake/retake/reimagining out there. It would be a LOT of effort, and very different from normal due to the fact that you have to describe games along with videos (And some Sonic.EXE videos are series), but I think that it could be really fun and cool!
Also, if you don’t put Needlem0use in The Best tier I will break into your house and make you feel unsafe (For legal reasons, this is a joke)
Kind of wish SpongeBob in random land was on the list as a joke
LOL
they deleted that scene
@@epicgamerkid909 they just replaced the red mist squidward head with a picture of baby squidward
23:06 a smooth criminal
I read the story there's no scottish fish, and in the story it's supposed to have have pictures of dead kids, and when the wind part come on there's a voice that tells squidward to "do it"
The only you have readen is squidward's s*icide, wich is the original creepypasta. The one with the scottish fish is "Red mist" wich is "fanmade remaster"
I love these types of videos, DONT STOP
Vibing leaf has a moment like
"The red mist is coming"
Felt like
"The fog is coming"
I love how in VibingLeaf’s remake Squidward starts hallucinating and seeing these entitys from what I would assume,the red mist.And instead of a sad and depressing ending,Patrick helps Spongebob get through the death of Squidward.
I've never heard of the Scottish fish before this vid, but I've heard this story tons of times.
24:23 is the best moment
This creepypasta used to scare me as a kid
To be fair, the original writing had pretty horrific images described. Id think so, anyway
Me too, same with Dead Bart. (And that's what makes them my two favorite Creepypastas)
Me ? Mario.Exe :(
@@greenlobster The original was mildly concerning since it had literally dead and borderline CP images from what I heard.
@@RetroDubs yeah thats it, thanks. now that i think about it why didnt i just read it lol.
30:40 Squid got coffee eyes!
I did actually talk to the creator for red mist retake vibing leaf if you see this you've been the GOAT when it comes to making these remakes so far (also when it came to making VHS Sonic at the time at first he was just a VHS Sans sonic variant now He's just sonic.exe but if the "hyper realistic" eyes were done more better and his body horror was taken a lot more of a Phantom twist to it as well as a more intense look to it)
3:08 that part got me rolling on the floor
Amazing video!!! This tier list video inspired me to write a Red Mist Retake Pasta (still deciding where I'm going to post it.) Keep up the great work!
I still remember when you did those old gd videos years back. Great job! Pigpig
I remember the actual image being in an episode in the first season where there were a bunch of doors and I think squidward opens one and that shows for about a second, then he closes it. Its since been removed for it being too scary for little kids, even though I was 10 or 11 at the time and I'm 13 now so it must have either been removed recently or it was an old recording of the episode on prime video.
The name of that episode is spongebob in randomland and i think it's from 10th or 11th season
24:48 that video was uploaded on my 3rd birthday fun fact
MaR0004 is my favorite creepypasta, I'd love to see you do that (even though theres like barely any remakes of it)
Everyone is talkin about vibingleaf and im here for because i also love the retake but im just floored that you included the fuckin video where the guy shows his little cousins or whatever the old red mist video that he transfered to a fucking vhs tape. I revisit that shit more than the actual video
I kinda like how found footage 7 has poor quality voice acting. Like, according to the story, the tape was apparently put together an hour before the crew watched it and made by a single person, so I can imagine the whole thing would have horrible quality from animation, voice acting, sound effects, probably even artwork.
Kinda gives it an uncanny vibe.
I didn't even know there were THIS many remakes! 😂
Squidward's Suicide is one of the most well known creepypasta's of all time. That's why it has so much remakes.
It’s only 10
love these videos! hope you can keep them up at your pace!
Thanks! I’m aiming to release maybe like one per week? I’ll see what I can do
You know The concert scene is Reused from The Not so good "SquidBob TenticlePants" Episode. Thus The Animation is somehow different whenever it switches to a season 1 and 5 Episode.
i thought you said testiclepants for a second
@@extremelyuncool lmao testicle
THE PAMTRI ONE LMFAO
Dude that one has it's own lore
You kind of need to appreciate how people make Red Mist remakes like this. I was trying to make one, and in the footage where Squidward played in the concert, I tried finding something accurate to it, and the one that was accurate was "Squidbob Tentaclepants." I tried finding footage of it using a streaming website, but it was hard to find, mainly because the website that hosted Spongebob had the episodes not organized. I don't know why.
Honestly, if you’re familiar with Pamtri’s work his take on Red Mist is actually one of his more unnerving videos. I’d recommend his Dying for Pie video as well if you want something a little heavier
PigPigGamer, you've done it again. This video was one of the best RUclips videos of my entire life. I watched this on my TV yesterday and I loved it. Good luck on the Max and Ruby 0004 video.
You have a new sub. You get straight to the point of the video unlike MANY youtubers!
it's so nice seeing the beginning of this video bragging about 4k views and 200 likes and this video has over 1 million views. i'm so happy for you. i can't imagine how happy that must have made you :^)
The loud noise in the scene where squidward is staring into the screen is an actual song called Torn Into Pieces by the German noise band called Genocide Organ. The song was recorded in 1985.
One thing I could ask, If possible, Is if you could maybe make a pastebin link with every Video you reviewed in order so we can go watch any of them quickly, that would be a great addition for future tiering videos!
I’ll do that for next video :)
Another day, another VibingLeaf W.
Edit: Also, I feel bad for that kid that was watching Red Mist. That’s definitely some childhood trauma to process in the future.
It’s crazy to think that kid is an adult now LOL
@@PigPigGamer yoooo I just realized so he'll be 21 this year
Quite surprised there isn't the Andywilson92 version and the Jose Luis Moren version (iirc, the Jose Luise Moren version does contain the dead children that the others except Vibingleaf leaves out). Overall, it's nice to see which adaptations got scenes right and wrong
17:06 thats a reference to faceless
Two creepypastas in one 😂
Is that the legendary colour fixer?
Now We Just Need A Dead Bart Ranking Video And We’ll Have The Holy Trinity!
And we'll get the four horseman if he does The Grieving.
Wait till vibingleaf makes Dead Bart remake first.
we need to wait for vibing leaf!
@@rebirthe7397 can’t forget cupcakes either
nice to see an up and coming youtuber, wish you the best
Thanks!
I would always be fascinated by remakes of lost episode pastas on RUclips little me always enjoyed them. I always wanted to make my takes on these kind of pastas maybe I'll do one one day if I ever get into animation
red mist? like the legendary color fixer kali also known as gebura from the hit games lobootomy corporatio-
Bait used to be believ-
1:26 THIS video has half MILLION views man
8:26 That’s definitely an impression. Take it from me, a certified Online Comment SpongeBob Historian.
29:41 god i feel like this scene is supposed to be in a ytp
@bfdifirey69 OH MY FUCKING GOD
Candle Cove could probably be really fun for this kind of ranking video!
I wanna do that and Happy Appy at some point
“Were watching spongebob” best line yet too ever exist
Bro that curve on the bottle throw, that guy must have been a fucking god of baseball