Game Theory: Portal 2, Does Chell DIE?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 авг 2020
- Special thanks to Raycon for sponsoring this episode!
Go to buyraycon.com/matpat for 15% off your order!
The endings of the Portal games are iconic and not just because of the songs. Portal 2's portal to space sticks in my mind. How did Chell survive being flung out into space? That seems impossible! Loyal Theorists, I need answers and I will not stop until I get them! Get into your space suits as we find out what it's really like to die in space and if Chell should be DEAD!
Don't forget to Subscribe to Food Theory! ► bit.ly/2CdCooV
Find the game here ► store.steampowered.com/app/40...
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/MatPat
Get yourself some Theory Wear!! ► creatorink.co/theorywear1
SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
Hang out with us on GTLive! ► bit.ly/1LkSBnz
#Portal #Portal2 #Puzzle #Impossible #PolePuzzle #Meme #Glados #Chell #HardestPuzzle #MatPat #Theory #GameTheory
More THEORIES:
FNAF, The FINAL Timeline ►► bit.ly/2MlHYFe
FNAF, The Monster We MISSED! ►► • Game Theory: FNAF, The...
FNAF This Theory Changes Everything ► bit.ly/2JUQUn6
FNAF, You Were Meant To Lose ► • Game Theory: FNAF, You...
FNAF 6, No More Secrets ► bit.ly/2LVCq4u
Credits:Writers: Matthew Patrick and Justin Kuiper
Editors: Forrest Lee, Dan "Cybert" Seibert, and Pedro Freitas
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
Sources:
www.scientificamerican.com/ar...
www.scientificamerican.com/ar...
www.popularmechanics.com/flig... 
Игры
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
“And she can survive”
Devs: “Duh we did the science pfft”
@@slevinchannel7589 This has nothing to do at all with the science being discussed. Please be irrelevant to the conversation somewhere else.
@@dorn284 Can you really see no reason for me to share this?
I don't care about your conversation. It's not the point.
But if you want, you can incorporate it or other things in your conversation.
Slevin Channel where did your first message go
@@nathanholyland9493 gone, reduced to atoms.
i mean, its valve its not that surprising
matt- **proves something is 100% right, without a single "but"**
me- *"Somethings wrong, i can feel it."*
FNAF theory incoming.
Yeah
The temperature?
*BUT* HEY THAT'S JUST A THEORY....A *GAME* THEORY
how did spongebob learn to speak? ruclips.net/video/qn_g0Lp4PEI/видео.html
They did say the reason Chell wasn't an ideal test subject was that she was a stubborn subject who refuses to give up. She is sure as hell wasn't going to stop being that way on the moon.
I love how glados actually saves chell instead of letting her die
"I used to want you dead, but now I only want you gone..."
-GLaDOS
She's her daughter after all. (lore)
@@yalikejazz7250 Baby level theory. Real theory is that wheatley isn't actually a moron
Without chell, there won't be any testing after all.
@@ashethedestroyer5114 giga theory is the moron theory: everyone involved is a moron
This actually raises the idea of creating a portal at the bottom of the ocean and then creating one on the moon so the water flows in, boils on the moon, and creates a proto-atmosphere.
XKCD actually did the math for something similar (portal at the bottom of the ocean, portal on Mars)
Someone show this to Elon
Your a cool dude
the only problem is the energy use for the portal,if we get past that, terraforming mars using salt water is very viable
@@truepinkcheetah3239 how is Elon gonna make a portal gun 😂
You can tell MatPat is really getting used to being a dad with that Blue's Clues pun.
OMG 😆 lol that’s such a good pun tho
He can finally unleash all his dad jokes
Wait.... He's as dad?
Overlifer 99 seriously?
Yep!
2 additional points to consider in your calculation. Chell is sort of in the slipstream of Wheatly, so as he is a sphere, she might actually be pulled towards him thanks to Mr. Magnus and his effects which could partially explain how Chell has such monstrous grip strength in these insanely high wind speeds.
Your pressure difference assumed that the room is at sea level. Depending on where the shack is when she is ejected in the end of the game she could be a few miles under that level... increasing the pressure and hence also increasing the face ripping airspeeds significantly.
I think the main control chamber is close to the surface like in portal 1. Maybe 100m below ground max.
@@dadudeme Well, since you could see the moon right from the chamber, yes it's right at the surface. Why you are a few miles under the surface underground after, either GLaDOS moved the chamber or she has multiple chambers. I'd say she has more than one chamber because of how different Wheatley's chamber looks to GLaDOS' chamber.
This can be calculated by the elevator speed at the end, also consider that air is being pumped into the facility given its depth so it likely won't be that much denser than the depth level if it can be avoided.
The only problem I had with this scene was wheatley flowing into space, 407 m/s would not be enough to even get stuck on the moons orbit. So in the post credits scene he should be lying on the moons surface, not floating around.
mayby its right before he hits the ground
Wheatley is probably moving faster than that, after he is according to the laws of physics he should be building up energy plus the moons gravity is some 16.67 percent that of earth
Moon escape velocity is a measly 2.38 kms
So him entering moon orbit is actually much easier plus 2.38 mms is how fast you are to completely escape the moon
*2..38 kms
MatPat: Chell survives!
Me, a frequent watcher: *visible confusion*
XD me too
I know, that’s a first.
I don't think she would considering she was holding onto two metal bars while being blasted back at mach 1.2
@@zeta8108 It's the one time we thank Wheatley for having a big head
Didn’t portal 2 come out years ago?
The only thing I’m confused about now is how good Chell’s grip strength is
Get this man an answer matpat
sure the speed of the wind is high but that dosent mean she is being forced by all of it skydivers fall with ther whole body spralled out to create as much drag as possible chell is doing the exact opistie of that hence why she still holds on
mrcrawlyo also, wouldn’t Wheatly being between tha incoming air and Chell actually decrease the velocity at which it’s hitting her?
@@San-nj8fj yeah it would
But is she playing raid, the most innovasive mobile rpg?
3:02
Concrete is portalable. You can portal surfaces from before the moon dust. Moon dust is just also portalable and can be used to make walls portalable.
he does only say that it's a great portal conductor so other substances may still work
@@thaum3983 except for the metal that ones confirmed to not port
Heres a thing, THey just make a low vacuum room shoot a portal at the moon and then make a portal in that room, then gather the moon dust done!
Um... no? The white paint has moon dust in it, which lets you conduct portals on them. All the concrete and walls and everything you can portal in-game has that white paint stuff on it. The voice-line that mentions it plays in the OLD Aperture Labs, so they're probably still using that same paint for the portalable walls in the present day Aperture Labs as well.
@@lasercraft32 Portal 1 used bare concrete. That was serviceable. Everything else except moon dust is unreliable and may have unfortunate side effects.
3:35 The air spewing out is enough for the vibrations created by Wheatly to enter your ear holes and create discernable sounds that you register as Wheatly saying. "We're in space!" With a new medium that the vibrations can travel through, a sound can now be heard on the moon.
Yup. Of course this assumes he's loud enough to be heard over the rush of air flying past at over Mach 1.
@@atk05003 oh he's definitely loud enough
Bro ur overthinking it the holding of Wheatley is enough. You don’t even need the air.
@@danroyeliminating265 you do. vibrations dampen a lot when traveling through solid objects
Chell: survives glados, space, Wheatley, military turrets and explosions and finally gets back to earth
The combine: **hello there**
"If you knew what was going on out there, you'd be BEGGING to stay." - GlaDOS
Well, Portal 2 takes place a loooooong time after the Half Life series, so we have no idea if the Combine are still around.
@@ashleycat4 it's not specified when it takes place
@@ashleycat4 but yeah
@@ashleycat4 A is unconfirmed, B is currently accurate
Game Theory: makes video
Me: ok who is dying today? (watches video)
Me: Huh.
Game theory needs tea portals ruclips.net/video/Kscsc5lCr9Y/видео.html
Yes, but what about her arms? Can she hold on when faced with 1,000mph winds?
.
Something's wrong i can feel it
@@thedotgiver2820 .
"This is one small step for man..."
(in the distance)
"Hold on! Tighter!!! GRAB ME GRAB ME GRAB ME GRAB MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEeee...."
"Houston, pick me up, i'm scared"
Wheatly's chassis also probably provided a buffer between her and the full force of the air rushing past her...not a large buffer...but probably enough to bring the speed closer to that specified "Safe" Wind Speed Zone.
the amount of wind hitting Chell's face could have possibly been reduced, at least slightly, by having wheatly in the way taking the full brunt of those forces.
now the question is how that wire that was holding wheatley and chell managed to hold them without being cut
@@Btterswt_gn Fututre tech might be that strong
Yeah that’s what i think
@@Btterswt_gn It's a really thick cable
@@Btterswt_gn it is a really thick cable so it's still possible
Another thing that would help is that Wheatley is taking the brunt of the wind so Chell would be fine
Yes finally
Someone noticed
That is true, but don’t forget that Wheatley is a sphere, wind goes around objects- So yeah, it does help, but still
thiss
Wheatley isn't nearly large enough to be a sufficient wind shield. Go stand in a wind tunnel with a metal ball in front of your face and you'll still feel most of the wind force
0:46 *"Crappy indie horror games"*
Lmao, i remember when Tiny Build were BEGGING Matpat on Twitter to notice their show
Matpats savage yet sad reply
3:08 Fun fact: "Portalable" is what the Valve devs did while making the game. I've used Source to make a Portal 2 mod before, and there was a texture called "nodraw_portalable"
the perpetual testing initiative is a real thing too
A Game theory episode where the protagonist doesn't die
me: something is wrong i can feel it
Just a feeling ive got
Fnaf protagonists: 👁👄👁
Strawberry Jam they do technically die though
It's a bad omen
I can feel a part 2 coming
There is one thing he didn’t cover that was on the back of my mind, could she actually hold on with that much pressure pushing against her?
matpat : *doesn't ruin my childhood*
me : "Impossible."
I was so surprised at the end of the video. I was sure there was going to be a "But!", but then there was only 2 minutes od ad.
He has been putting out some really low effort videos lately, think about the old stuff with the advanced maths versus the stuff in this video, the information he includes in this video is a basic google search away and required no thought.
same reaction
Sanseï no mat pat is doing that do us
Steve Hills “The old game theory was better!” you say. Geez, everyone nowadays is thinking that. I understand that you enjoyed the old ones better. So did I. But it’s an unrealistic standard to expect that the sequels will stand up to the originals. Star Wars, Indiana Jones, Star Trek, Jurassic Park, Lord Of The Rings, Harry Potter, Superhero franchises, Doctor Who, Back to the Future, TV shows, and even RUclipsrs. This list goes on. Nearly everyone could agree that in one of these categories, the original was better. But expecting that the new stuff will satisfy you just as much, is unfair and unrealistic. The new stuff can still be good, but nostalgia will make you like the original more nearly every time. I understand where you’re coming from. I’ve been watching this channel from the beginning, but every time a new FNAF video appears in my recommended, I think, “Aww $H!T, here we go again.” I’m tired of them. But to complain about how the old stuff was better all the time is just annoying at this point because it’s a poor way to think about things you could easily enjoy. Now I’m not saying you have to like it, you’re obviously entitled to your opinion, I’m not denying that. I’m just saying don’t let nostalgia destroy your ability to enjoy new content. I do feel where you’re coming from, but I just think you need to at least consider what I’m saying. But again, you’re entitled to your opinion so you can completely disregard my words if you like. Free will and all. God bless and see ya fellow OG theorist.
well chell has one hell of a story to tell
..wait that wasn't even intentional.
LL
based pfp
Would Chell's arms be able to bear the amount of force they have to deal with? Keeping in mind that Wheatley being in the way of the air could help.
I mean she can survive multiple gunshots and regenerate at a surprisingly fast rate.
@@genotheskeleton6258 they're less so gunshots and more so bullets being lobbed at her since there is no barrel or chamber in the turrets, just kinda being pelted at through air pressure.
@@sebbakunot to mention the fact that the turrets canonically don’t even actually shoot. They’re spring powered so they can fire the whole bullet. 60% more bullet per bullet.
I couldn’t stop laughing at the segue to the sponsor.
“Chell doesn’t have to worry about her bluetooth earbuds getting ripped out of her ears due to the vacuum of space! Huzzah!”
Me in my head: What the heck is a seg-you
Me: *looks it up*
Me: I THOUGHT IT WAS SEGWAY. WDYM ITS SEGUE!?!?
My life is over, i cant spell, goodbye cruel world.
E25 earbuds are built cheap and are WAYYY too bass heavy. They are like the Raid Shadow Legends of earbuds.
@@khouryward1646 Segway (the company) is why you've been conditioned to misspell segue. Most people know what "segue" means from hearing it used casually by English or Speech teachers, but they also don't have much reason to ever use (or spell) the word. When Segway started showing up in the news, it associated that spelling with the word people hadn't had a reason previously to care how it was spelled.
@@Turdinator300 beats but smaller is how i like to describe them
You also have to take into account that Wheatley was blocking the wind with his giant face.
He's not that big tho. I'd say he's about the size of a basketball, maybe smaller
Yeah I was about to comment that.
Anton Tarvo But at the angle Chell is probably at(looks like almost perpendicular to Wheatley’s eye) Wheatley would still cover quite a bit of her body.
www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/dragsphere.html
drag of a sphere
@@teal_ninja2846 👏
I thought this video would be about whether the wheat field was actually meant as a metaphor for "Elysium" or Heaven, implying that Chell was killed either in space or by those 4 turrets,
9:14 delta P, when it's got you, it's got you. (insert crab.mp4)
The wind wasn't just blowing straight at her, she was kind of protected by Wheatley.
This is a pretty good detail to take into account. Wheatley's body while he was still connected to the system would also have deflected the loose objects coming through, protecting Chell from being struck by stuff getting sucked out.
Yeah your kinda right...
thats true although wheatley should have died the pressure should have broken apart at least the back of him because of all the pressure
There is also the fact that it would be the initial pressure, the room itself is not completely sealed, there's a giant hole in the ceiling, but it won't be a constant gradient, and the giant robotic arm... Yeah, I'm more worried about debris.
im gonna seem dumb put remember the infinite falling to gain momentum quickly using portals? yea chell survives that so im not surprised that she can surprise the wing speed pressure on her in space
I’m still curious how accurate Chell has to be to get the portal several feet from Apollo 11
@@KhrisWithK if ur saying there should be more tech on the moon when chell portals up, you are wrong. Society ended basically during portal 1 due to the combine invading earth, Half life and portal are in the same universe you know.
@@KhrisWithK combine invaded earth sometimes in portal 1 meaning you wont be seeing humn colonization on mars or the moon
@@jutlan854 he means the moon landing site from before the invaded earth apollo 11 its were the flag is
Wouldn't be Apollo 11 as you can see the lunar roving vehicle which was only present on Apollo 15-17
@@NizioCole well still how thats peer luck
8:01
Tardigrade: Are you challenging me?
7:52 tardigrade: am i a joke to you
Also she’s so close to wheatly he’s probably drafting her a little so she’s not getting all 910 to the face
You've got a point there.
Yup
True
Matpat missed a piece of valid evidence.
@@generalartist420 Same conclusion though
Just had a walk of shame through the steam store and bought portal 2
go make some games what are you doing here
ha ha yes
Lmao how did you get here
Oh. Hey.
Poor dami
03:38 She was touching the robot when it was speaking; bone conduction speakers 🔊 are a thing. So, yes she could hear in space because the sound was being conducted through her.
Always found it funny when I would intentionally place the blue portal under wheatley and the orange one on the moon, only for it to change colors
Pathetic. I placed the orange portal both under Wheatley and on the moon.
@@LeventButSpeedrunning wait a minute thats illegal
I guess everyone forgot about Game Theory's 10th anniversary is today
That's just the channel's anniversary (and it would actually be the 11th, not 10th), Game Theory didn't start until April 18th 2011, with a trailer for the show released 4 days prior on April 14th. Before that, it's all MatPat's singing/acting auditions, which are equal parts impressive, cringy, and adorable.
Still, happy belated channelversary, MatPat!
yes
how did spongebob learn to speak? ruclips.net/video/qn_g0Lp4PEI/видео.html
@@bridgettegross4110 wait the 18th is my birthday, what-
Dafuq and mat pat didn’t say it
“Here are the test results. You are a horrible person.”
Me who took a math test yesterday: *audible confusion*
They could tell you cheated.
@@druhu4590 our science teacher did the big brain move against cheaters:make the exame much longer (more questions,longer questions) the faster you can answer questions the better youll do on the test,which englobed THE WHOLE YEAR.It was a massacre,I passed although I had 40%,we only had 1hour and a half.
They weren't even testing for that, but that's the results T_T xD
Abby has 12 chocolate bars. Andy gives her 8. What does Abby have now?
D I A B E T E S
@@JiMMy-xd8nu Ugh. I hate that testing strategy. It creates needless stress on students and produces a bunch of wasted time spent grading to wherever a student randomly got. It's far better to just randomize the question order a few times and shuffle the printed tests so students can't predict if the people around them have the same questions they do. You then just put a mark on the paper somewhere to indicate which random version it is so you can still grade it quickly.
People have been using this strategy since computers used punch cards. You can even have it randomly give a set number of questions out of a larger pool of questions so any 2 people aren't likely to have the same questions at all (most standardized tests do this in batch form so you can't know the questions year over year). At this point, you could set it up with pre-printed student names at the top of the page, put in your student's name and have the computer show you exactly what answers that student should have given (or what key points you are expecting to see if it's essay form).
8:09 that monkey in space was named ham. Miss ya ham.
I have my own theory...
I don't think that Chell is at the surface at the end of the game, hear me out. If you remember, She shot a portal on the moon. When is the moon visible? At night. And only around 15 minutes later its day time at the surface. Although, maybe some time passed during the two events since everything appears fixed. This is just a speculation but I like the idea.
She did fell unconscious. Probably a few hours passed since then
That wheat field surrounding the small metal shack was not real, it was a Holodeck-like simulation. According to leaked beta footage from Portal 3, the wheat field will disappear and we'll see that Chell is actually back in the relaxation vault. Then she gets woken up for some more testing.
@Mazzlɘ There isn't. I made it up for the lolz!
@@InventorZahranmenace
@LASPORTS13 weird way to spell chad
In the wise words of Cave Jonson
“Science isn’t about why, it’s about why not!”
*W h y n o t c h e l l s u r v i v e?*
EXPLOSIVE LEMONS!
Why not I have good pc that can run csgo at 60fps?
Albert Einstein one said "Science is just refinement of every day thinking"
i think
Cyberpunk 2077 graphics downgrade that we expect. New gameplay leaqued ruclips.net/video/Szh92guMlaI/видео.html
"[This theory] TOTALLY CHANGES the ending!" ... "so yeah, chell survives and everything checks out"
The only explantion I can think of is that he changed the script part way through. I doubt I'd intentionally bait us THAT hard.
As in the perception/understanding belief of the ending
Of course your comment is at the top meaning I click on the video it gets spoiled
@@euanmcdougall1917 Yeahh but it still didn't though..
Yea we got baited
I’m at 4:11 but in regards to hearing sound in space- this comes from my pea sized brain, they’re simultaneously in space and earth, air is rushing into space giving them a medium in which they can hear sound? That being said, how she didn’t get ripped to shreds or how the portal didn’t lead to some catastrophical event (I can’t even speak hypotheticals because Idrk how it all works, but surely opening a portal to the moon would cause some problem) is beyond me.
COUNTER THEORY: before this scene in the game GLaDOS says that she makes artificial air and the air might have a factor that lets Chell survive
"It turns out ground up moon rocks are pure poison. I am deathly ill."
Moon dust is _very_ fine and has sharp edges because of lack of air erosion. Inhaling it would cut your lungs bloody.
how did spongebob learn to speak? ruclips.net/video/qn_g0Lp4PEI/видео.html
Ignore my searches
@@H1Y28 stop advertising, nobody cares
@@H1Y28 wha?
I feel bad for Blue Shirt Guy. He’s been through many many episodes of abuse.
I think it's a shutterstock image, please don't feel bad for good editing skills
Deborah Amos it’s a joke lol???
@@deborahamos5401 r/wooosh
True
He is like Arthur from this RUclips video
11:40 to add onto this, Wheatley is covering most of Chell's face. He might not be specialized protective equipment but hey, it's something!
3:45 i mean~ air is flying trought the portal too so...
9:35
Wheatley is shielding Chell's face slightly, she's in his slipstream. That should stop the wind tearing her skin off.
How about the skin on her arms?
@@jordanholloman5907 The air is rushing past her arms in parallel, and so the friction created should be pretty much negligible.
I was thinking there may be some other factors restricting the flow of air since aside from the hole in the ceiling they are inside a fairly solid building in a room that can probably become air tight under normal conditions. Even more so than that is the size of the portal which further restricts the amount of air that can flow at once. The question is whether those restrictions are enough to throw Mat's number off.
@@grn1 No? That has nothing to do with pressure differentials.
@@kingacrisius There is a limit to the amount of air that can physically move through a space of a given size (we control the pressure coming out of a high pressure source like a tank by restricting the physical size of the gap through which the air flows). My question is whether the amount of air that can actually flow through the portal is lower than the number Mat got using pressure differentials which (presumably) assumed that the air flow is unrestricted.
Me: Alright alright what's the twist thi-
Mat: But hey...-
Me: WHAT THAT'S IT?
Yeah i think the part where he specified where she died was cut because it wasn't right, thats why there are some strange things in the video, also look at the thumbnail, that was supposed to be the oeiginal video.
i am not sure whether this would affect this vid but glados says "Here's an interesting fact: you're not breathing real air. It's too expensive to pump this far down. We just take carbon dioxide out of a room, freshen it up a little, and pump it back in. So you'll be breathing the same room full of air for the rest of your life. I thought that was interesting."
Slevin Channel. That’s a link to a video about Netflix. What does that have to do with a Portal 2?
@@CaitlynWemyss it depends on what "freshen it up a little" means
Daniel basically means turning carbon dioxide into breathable oxygen. It’s basically artificial air that is actually air.
For the wind thing, there's also Wheatley blocking lots of the air that would otherwise hit Chells face
3:50 I think Chell can breathe the air back in aperture through the portal as you can see the rushing air in that scene
is that a spoiler for the video
No, she doesn't die because of the *POWER OF THE PROTAGONIST*
:) But is she the protagonist?
Perpetual Writing
Yep
@@firestarr5812 What about the guy that was saving Chell from literally EVERYTHING
@@wegumaji4730 Is that fully canon tho
plot armor
Chell: doesn’t let go while having Mach 1.2 air speeds pushed at her
Matpat: WhAt AbOuT hEr BrEaThInG
Considering she’s holding onto Wheatley who’s in front of her, he could be taking the blunt force of that while she’s maybe experiencing 200 mph winds (that’s not a rough estimate, just an uneducated guess), but at the same time I saw another comment saying 300-something mph can rip up asphalt so I really have no clue
the Mach 1.2 air speeds are pushing Wheatley too... so it doesn't matter. With physics, it is all about relative speeds. Relative to the sun, we are orbiting at 67,000 mph... so a coffee cup in your hand is moving at 67,000 mph! Yet you still hold it.
@@aliquida7132 ok but what about the air blasting past her? Would that not tear her skin? Also it does not matter that “it’s pushing Wheatley” as well since they technically aren’t moving it’s the air that is moving
@@TrueApexMusic
The issue above was "doesn't let go", which I'm assuming refers to letting go of Wheatley. Relative to her, Wheatley is moving the exact same speed, so there is no reason to "let go".
The wind? That's an different question. The wind would be about Mach 1 (air speed going into a vacuum throttles at that speed), which is 767 mph. The fastest test on a human was 570 mph when a guy flew an aircraft with the canopy removed. He survived without any injury... can't say what would have happened in this scenario though.
@@aliquida7132 I got a better question actually. How strong is the damn cable holding Wheatley attached ? I mean it doesn't seem that thick tbh.
Since Wheatly is a decently sized sphere, I think that Chell is in a sizeable wind slipstream, thus she has to worry more about the lack of air than about the brutal wind going straight into her face.
10:24 I see someone followed the energy particle explosion Blender tutorial.
“What? There’s no twist?! What.. does she explode? Is it a lore thing?! Is that IT?!”
“That’s just a theory.... a GAME THEORY.”
“T H A T ‘ S I T ? !”
The twist is that the rapid decompression of the air wood cool the air so rapidly that it would freeze chell solid
Just like the Freddy Krueger episode, the twist is that there IS no twist.
Did he not say at the beginning that there’s one big difference that would change the end of the game?? Am I confused??
Strangely enough, the point about losing consciousness still fits well. She does seem to do so upon being pulled in.
Why would she be unconscious?
@@viktorpettersson6899 she could lose consciousness from the pressure screwing her brain over through blocking arteries, she could lose consciousness from the air blow maybe, or she could lose consciousness through traumatic experiences, all 3 seems possible.
@@viktorpettersson6899 The facility was running out of air due to it being pulled out into space for 30 seconds
she did loose her consciousness tho. She is pulled back in by Glados, sees Glados picking up her head, and then wakes up, to some robots, and Glados.
@@gwendolynsnyder463 that’s literally what the comment you replied to said
12:08 im prety sure glados said at one point that she somehow went to the surface and saw a group of humans
I think that was a lie
The most unrealistic part is actually her being able to grab onto Wheatley in the first place. In real life the wind speed would be so high that even if you managed to grab onto him, your hand would immediately be wrenched away by the high wind speed. It would be like falling off a building and trying to grab onto a windowsill halfway down
game theory: makes a video about portal
me: oh finally portal lore will be appreciated
game theory: uhh actually everything happened just as the game shows you, but yknow thats just a theory
Yeah. I was disappointed. He said it completely changed the ending but literally nothing changed.
You can still theorize how they closed the portal without the portal gun
That's how a lot of his "theories" have been recently. Just restating canon events with clickbait titles.
Mat : "I never want to go into space"
*In the distance*
Mark : "SPACE IS SO COOOOOOL SO COOOOOOL-"
OH IT'S SO PRETTY! so pretty!
SSSSSSPPPPPPPPPPPPPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACCCCCCCCCCCCEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
*mY CoMpUtEr cAnT hAnDlE tHe ReNdErInG!!!!*
SPACE!
Ok someone who uses scp profile
Ooh! Aerospace Engineering student here! I can contribute! I did the math!
One part that was left out which plays a HUGE roll in the forces she experiences is the DENSITY of the air hitting her. Your math is correct if she were in some test tube like NACA, or in earth's atmosphere, but she ISN'T on Earth, she's on the moon! Sure she's bombarded by 1atm pressure difference (technically even more since she's deep underground), but when you have a huge pressure gradient like this you also have a huge change in the density of the air.
I did the math (it was actually a lot of fun!), and it turns out that the density of the airflow on the moon in her situation would be about 33% that of the air density on Earth. This would mean that the forces she is getting hit by is approximately 1/3 that of the cited experiments. So instead of feeling like she's being hit by a whopping 910 mph wind, due to the density of the airflow dropping so much, it would feel like she was being hit by about 303 mph winds, which ends up being much more manageable, and even below those extreme test situations.
Thank you so fricking much for making me love this cutscene again. Wasn't a big fan of it since it seemed so unbelievable but now that that's cleared out, I can go out and love the game again.
Also, Wheatley would be blocking some of the wind rushing into Chell’s face, so she would be experiencing a slightly lower wind speed than if he wasn’t there.
problem with that is.... Whitley is round. so he would not as much "block" the wind as just redirect it around it. Round/spherical/cylindrical objects dont block wind, they just let the wind flow around them..
so while the speed would be ever so sligthly lower, it would not change anything
@@weberman173no, even if it IS spherical, it does still make a significant enough pressure difference on the other side. Don't believe me, then explain how a hair dryer can lift a ping pong ball in a very stable manner both vertically AND horizontally, without taking into consideration the force exerted by the air pressure difference.
@@weberman173 Wheatley would definitely make a slipstream, and probably one big enough for Chell to fit in. In fact, he'd be making a sonic boom, and as long as Chell stays inside of the cone created by that sonic boom, she'd be fine. Although now moon gravity is an issue...
At least, that's what my physics intution says. I could be wrong. I'm not smart. I'm not a scientist (well, I am, but let's ignore that, since I'm not a physicist). I'm not a doctor. I'm not even a fulltime employee (of Aperture Science, at least).
and he was literally holding chell from drifting into space
Maybe true tho…
Nah Game Theories motto is “Ruining Childhoods Since 2011”
Oops I meant to put 2010 sorry
Mokarokas - yes now no og game theory fans will skin my hide
Actually, "Ruining Childhoods Since 2010" is the slogan, but you know, fair enough.
Well, see, now he's ruining your image of game theory ruining everything. It's actual super metamat.
incorrectdigit want me to delete it then?
11:55 here’s the real question
Would she survive that in those wind speeds FOR THAT LONG
And somehow carry a robot with her scrawny hands to not be ejected to space
Would her arms give out? How much force would she need to fight against for how long
"Spend the afternoon beating it"
-MatPat 2020
Came to the comment section just to see if anyone mentioned this :D
Chell didn't die. We can add this to the growing list of positives for 2020.
You have a list of positives?
@@jonathanwadey3213 you have a single positive?
@@Xx_Oleander_xX Yes: Chell didn't die
@@Xx_Oleander_xX Phineas and Ferb: Candace Against the Universe. There's a positive
how did spongebob learn to speak? ruclips.net/video/qn_g0Lp4PEI/видео.html
Person: "IMPOSSIBLE! A POSITIVE Game Theory episode?! I don't believe you!"
ME: "I'm serious dude! It actually happened! After all this time!"
At around 10:54 he put the orange portal in Africa when the game takes place in Flint, Michigan
Oh no😱
ill miss you...
we will…
@@riyadziyad9690we all will.
mattpad at the start of the video: "i will show you the real portal ending!"
mattpad at the end of the video: "i approve of everything"
....i feel lied to
It's still better than his blatant denial of canon:
ruclips.net/video/5yTxSxLHYl4/видео.html
M a t t p a d
The cake is a lie!
It’s mattpat
Mathew Patrick
i was the 420th like XD
"If Game Theory has a motto" don't tell me you've forgotten matt, it's "The smartest show in gaming"
yes and it ruined my appetite since he forgot it
Isn't that more of a slogan?
متبباخبارمنتتد
@@kylepietrusiewicz2749 a slogan is a type of motto, kyle.
@@lilsyrupshawty I love how you just had to include the "Kyle," at the end.
2:40 is the same place bro
That shape on screen when you talked about bloid boiling looks like something else.
"When getting sucked into space, should you be able to hear their voices?"
Good question - explosive decompression like that is _supposed_ to happen as the speed of sound in whatever medium is being decompressed.... _but_ the air is moving *towards* Chell, so it should be carrying the sounds _to_ her, not _away_ from her. It'd probably come down more to how much noise is made as air passes through a portal. And since we have no idea whether the edges of a portal experience the aeronautical/aeroelastic flutter that would generally cause the noise.... no-one knows.
My thoughts exactly.
I imagine you wouldnt be able to hear the sound of the space core after it was behind you though, as a minor addition. To use information from one of kyle hills videos, if air (or other medium) is travelling faster than the speed of sound in it then the sound wave just cant travel fast enough to even reach you, it just gets pulled backwards and away from you
Unless, there is already air on the moon.
You didn’t watch you whole thing did you?
@@lacoulas5556 At the time, no - but I do have more details in mine ;)
also, you should be able to hear weathly all the time, becouse, you are touching him.
i was at the start like: chell isnt in a Vacuum, the air from earth is still rushing out! i didnt consider the speed of it thou
Same
Portal is my favorite series, and I'm SO glad to hear this. Thank you for making this video!
What i am confused about is that how come in the ending of portal 2 chell leaves but there is nothing but her and the companion cube and NO CIVILIAZATION in sight so maybe she died of starvation/dehydration.
@@__keys Um okay
There could still be civilisation, but given this takes place after the combine invasion there probably isn’t much of it left
It’s a field, dude. It’s probably land bought by aperture to build under, explaining why the only thing visible is the little elevator thing.
@@SnootDog Ah, true. What I would like is Gordon freeman discovering Chell and they drive back to the resistance base.
MatOS: Scott, lets see your test results.”A horrible person”. That is what it said,”A horrible person”. We weren’t even testing for that!
Scott:*sniffs* all for the cake man.
CHIG CHIG BUNGUS
Don't let this distract you from the fact that I am the ugliest RUclipsr worldwide. I also smell like 100 de*d orangutans and have two hot hot hot girlfriends as you can see on my highly stimulating channel. Greetings, dear chi
@@AxxLAfriku shut up bot
2012:
MatPat: This video game character is actually dead!!!
Audience: OMG What?!?!?! This is insane!
2020:
MatPat: This video game character wouldn't die!
Audience: OMG What?!?!?! This is crazy!
so basically, matpat and the viewers have changed but actually they haven't...?
these are confusing times
@@marleycadotte9630 yes. XD
welcome to 2020
Character development.
I was thinking that!
Confus
So chell can’t hear the robots, not because there is no air, but because there is so much air all she can hear is very loud “FWUBAFWUBAFWUBA”
Just finished it and despite everything I still love Wheatley, and I do want him to come back
Matpat: proved something craxy is actually likely.
Me: impossible.
I'm waiting for a theory of Fall Guys about "how the colored beans are in a survival horror game"
Lel
I wish
I just barley got first reply by 3 seconds XD
Or there imprisoned on a terrible planet
But the devs did say there just a race on a GameShow planet with no origin they just appear in existence and live to win
Probably one of my favorite theories. I actually learned a lot, and from one of my favorite games too!
When Chel was hanging on to Wheatly in space, we could hear the sound because she was in a cone of air. That air cone would have had the same pressure as the air on earth (maybe a bit lower) - that being also the reason she survived.
All sponsors to gamers: Use wireless ear buds
All Gamers: Uses headphones
Mobile players: but w-
Every gamer: We said Gamers
@Ashura D_Fox there are two kinds of mobile games, the ones that are good and have a PC/console equivalent, and the ones that are terrible and have a browser equivalent.
@@wta1518 that's true, too bad most mobile games are the latter.
Yes, this is so true 😂
I mean, how can you use wireless headphones for gaming? Not sure how these works, but bluetooth ones have a little delay of sound transmition for any obstacles that may be present.
There is also the factor where wheatly is blocking a lot of the wind and so she would be experiencing less of the side effects matpat talked about
g1 4 lyfe. #BleedPurple
@@avw5kt he's not very spherical, he's a bit longer than wider and that counts a lot when dealing with extreme speed
Cyberpunk 2077 graphics downgrade that we expect. New gameplay leaqued ruclips.net/video/Szh92guMlaI/видео.html
how did spongebob learn to speak? ruclips.net/video/qn_g0Lp4PEI/видео.html
now i'm imagining wheatly getting ripped apart from the wind....
it's beautiful
There is no way that she would be able to hold on to Wheatley in supersonic winds
well, she held a propably pretty heavy portal gun for multiple hours straight. I dont think shes weak
we also forgot to take into account that when wheatly and chel were in space wheatly was actually blocking the primary airflow from hitting chel directly dispersing it and causing chel to have less air flow hit her. most likely down to the 700-600kph
"With one big difference that completely changes the ending"
"Go figure that a game all about solving science puzzles actually adheres to real world science in one of its most extreme and unbelievable cutscenes"
So what was the supposed *big difference* that *completely changes the ending* ??? I mean, it got it all right, unless Chell got some dust in her eyes maybe, that sure would have made things awkward...
He forgot a lots of other details too
I am glad i ain t alone
the debris getting sucked out of the portal would likely put bullet holes through her body unless she has a mile thick plot armor
@@Shon_- I would say that if that's the case, then the big twist is chell being (probably) infused with robot parts. That's the only solution that explains how she is able to stand, walk and move her head during the ending.
This is what you call a 'filler episode'.
That Explains why Chell is always mute, She just can't hear everyone over the music coming form her Raycon Ear Buds
thank you samnonator, very cool
Yeah, she's listening to the OST the entire game.
nah she mute because she choked on a raycon earbud
The bass is too loud so she can't hear anything
two things to consider with that strong wind in her face:
1. she isn't at the portal itself, but a meter/yard from it, so the pressure&wind already started to dissipate quite a bit
2. she has wheatley in front of her breaking the wind into a turbulent slower flow of air
so maybe the wind isn't much slower than 407 m/s (910 mph), but probably under 389 m/s (870 mph) i'd think
...unless you already accounted for both, on which i'd press x to doubt
Chell, just vibin to her beats while being sucked into space:. i see this as an absolute win
Impressive that this actually is survivable
Impressive that scientists had to have seen a person or multiple exploding in space to know all this stuff
He covers everything but how Chell would be able to hold on with that much wind force, even if she is capable of surviving the 28 seconds.
@@DaCat650 you mean that much drag. That's the correct term.
@@tori2046 what? what are you talking about? no one exploded in space. no one was exposed to the vacuum of space intentionally or unintentionally
@@mastershooter64 No but during the experiments the whole bloating thing would have to have been seen and witnessed to know that it would happen-
“Crappy indie horror games. Looking at you, Hello Neighbor.” Oh god here comes the flood of 9-year olds
Here come the bastards
lmao
tbf hes not wrong.... it had potential but just went... nowhere...
thats what they get after spamming him on twitter lmao
Oh wow hello neighbor... when I was younger I was for some reason obsessed with the alpha and betas-
new theory i came up with: maybe in portal 2 chell is in the future. i think this because during portal stories: MEL when Virgil tells you to type target list it says: GLAdos, Mel. but at the end, it also shows: Chell. and Virgil said to mel (you dont wanna be around when glados awakes.). so thats why i think that more theories i think of soon will soon be added!
6:40 same