Short answer: No. Longer answer: As long as Stormont exists in its current structure, there will always be a political crisis as there will always be the threat of collapse and the operation of Stormont itself does not guarantee that the many many issues facing Northern Ireland will be solved. Or in one word: Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
The thing is - the current structure is deliberate. Two years without a government might have been frustrating, but without power sharing you might actually have a war, which is obviously far worse.
@im_Carlislelet's be more specific - the politicians that profited from decades of conflict are not willing or able to fix them. Look how many convictions Sinn Fein ministers have, and how much money the DUP have skimmed off. With them in charge, things won't change.
@@alexpotts6520 as somebody living there this is nonsense 25+ years on. It is also unfair to parties would would want to form a coalition of the willing such as alliance + other parties. The fact ir. is some people want people to be living in fear and the DUP feeds on that for their support. The largest labour protest in NI history happen just before this announcement that should tell where the average person's patience is I don;t think it is coincidence.
@@paulthomas8262 Oh for sure there have been big issues with power sharing. But given that the current arrangement is the result of peace treaty, by messing with the arrangement you're surely risking the peace, right?
If it's not one, it'll be the other. It was Sinn Fein last time. I mean our Councils can't collapse like this, why do we put up with this system for Stormont?
Loyalists will just bring back the troubles to avoid that for a good while yet, need to be a few generations to avoid them being able to do any significant damage
@@frankoneill5675 yes, it is. Because if the EU need to be assured ever step of the way, then they are part of the negotiations especially given that all of this is contingent on EU treaties and deals
Yes, they knew negotiations were going on, but had no input, and at the end, apparently, neither the EU nor Ireland (and Ireland are kept fully informed re Protocol issues) knew the detail of what was agreed. Supposedly David Cameron phoned Maroš Šefčovič to inform him and the latter said they would study the details carefully. Tony Connelly said there are flexibilities open to the UK within the terms of the Framework regarding the green lane, once they don't harm the integrity of the SM. If the EU have any objections we'll hear in the next few days. Leo Varadkar said there were 'questions' regarding some aspects of trading arrangements but he didn't think there were any 'red flags'.
The EU and EU Parliament will examine and debate the proposals agreed between the DUP and the UK Government and if it is happy that the EU single market is not compromised it will give it's approval, if it is not happy which is unlikely then the proposal cannot be implemented. Do not forget the latest agreement between the UK Government and the DUP is just an add on to the Northern Irish Protocol of the TCA and the subsequent Windsor Framework which are themselves legally binding international agreements.
It's Northern Ireland. Stormont is in a state of perpetual political crisis by design, but as long as it keeps the crisis within the halls of Stormont and not out on the streets, then it's working as intended.
@@robert6106Nobody suggested they couldn’t. But if you act on those preferences you have to accept the consequences. The best part of a decade wasted trying to square the circle they helped create.
@@lightningstrike5024 *_Correction_* DUP: Can Northern Ireland actually be a proper part of the Union *_and_* force the Republic of Ireland to leave the EU market against their will for our convenience? Reality: Wtf!? *No* ! What the hell are you even talking about?! Jesus, you thought Farage and friends were being honest, didn't you?...
@@lightningstrike5024 Westminster won't let there be a land border with Ireland because they're old enough to remember the slaughter caused by a land border, yes. And don't kid yourself. The Troubles weren't a war, they were a _Civil War_ where combatants on both sides rained terrorist cruelty on each other's civilian population. Half the Irish here in Canada were people getting their children out of the blast zones of the indiscriminate Ulster Defense/ Irish Republican bombings.
@@Finnbobjimbob The British only got control over the regions of Israel/Palestine, Jordan, Iraq and Kuwait after the fall of the Ottoman Empire because they (and the French) allied Arab freedom fighters (with the promise of an independent united hashemite Arabia) and then betrayed them by carving up the regions for colonies, or "League of Nations Mandates". This is part of why countries like Iraq and Syria are so dysfunctional, their borders were not drawn to work as independent countries but to support British and French Imperialism.
I don't see that at all as it's power sharing. They are no closer to a United Ireland than the SNP is to getting gaining their independence. There's a long way to go.
Unionist population is now very old and shrinking rapidly. Nationalist population is very young and increasing at a breakneck speed. Do the maths. ==Irish Unity
@Cacbo774 Are actually trying to suggest that Loyalists don't have children while catholics breed like rabbits? 😅😅😅 Your logic and delusion is priceless.
"Closer" that implies it will happen, in the the last poll (2020, the height of the brexit crisis) only 27% of NI people said they would vote for independence. Now with the rise of migration from the UK and the rise of the "nones".. Good luck.
It probably never will be. Northern Ireland was only ever envisaged as a temporary solution to the problems of 1921. The solution lies, as acknowledged in the GFA, in relationships between the (at least) two communities that live there, relationships North- South and East- West. Much more work needs to be done to ensure an agreed peaceful outcome. Brexit has derailed the peace, but it must be got back on track.
@@PaulMuzik Just to clarify my man, not saying that there is animosity toward England, just that people that voted for Brexit and are now suffering the consequences are morons and should own up to the situation we're now in as a nation
Fella don't always believe in fiction especially what star trek, the north will be annexed into republic soon. But not because of some prediction from a fictional tv series
Sadly politics move too slowly, that prediction is basically doomed at this point. Although they also predicted it would happen by... "aggressive negotiations". So maybe, if shit REALLY gets bad in the UK for some reason, it could happen.
Nothing secret about it, it's the only long term way of keeping Northern Ireland in line with the rest of the UK without GB submitting to the same trade regulations as the Republic of Ireland. At that point they might as well just rejoin the EU, which obviously isn't happening any time soon.
The only ways you could logically avoid having either a land border on the island of Ireland or a sea border between parts of the UK would be if a) Ireland ALSO leaves the EU, forming a little two-country trading union with the UK instead, b) Northern Ireland leaves the UK and rejoins with Ireland, which stays in the EU, removing the need for a sea border, or c) the UK annexes Ireland, removing the need for a land border. Of course, there is the elusive option d) just not starting this clusterfuck in the first place, but clearly that had no takers. Since b) or d) weren’t on the table, either the unionists were thinking Ireland would join in on Brexit, or they were thinking they could force Ireland to join the UK down the road. …or they weren’t thinking at all, just acting on pure id like a toddler who wants to go outside but also refuses to wear pants. Which is probably the most likely scenario, all things considered.
It is going to kill the hardcore Unionist supports to see a SF politician as first Minister, this is the more historic of the whole situation as it will be the first time for a Nationalist to do so in the provinces history.
NI Unionists voting for Brexit is one of the greatest own-goals in all political history. Irish reunification is much closer to reality, Sinn Fein is in power, and all these oitcomes were very obvious and inevitable. Did they think the other 26 counties would vote to leave with them?! They voted for their own demise.
I would disagree, Sinn Fein may now have a first Minister in Stormont but the power sharing in Stormont will result in no greater a risk of reunification, Sinn Fein are only playing into their own rhetoric. There isn't really any difference between Sinn Fein being in power than the SNP running Scotland.
@@garagefridge8930 But there's a big difference here. At any point Northern Ireland can vote to rejoin the Republic, in which the UK just has to take the L if they do. There's no Scotland situation here where they have to plead and beg parliment for it. Sinn Fein will try their hardest to get that through, and, if they have enough momentum, will happen
Absolutely clueless I’m guessing you’re not from Northern Ireland!? The polls are showing a united ireland isn’t even close in fact they’ve widened recently Stop throwing around Sinn Fein IRA propaganda that keeps the stupid people under control A simple google search dis proves this stupid nationalist myth
@@tjclarke1892 They did and they do, what planet are you living on? In case you don't remember, Sinn Féin left the Executive because Foster refused to step down for the RHI scandal investigation and the DUP were reneging on legislation required by the Good Friday Agreement for Irish language recognition. Expecting transparency in a corruption investigation and demanding promised legislation from your forced coalition partner is a very different thing to this bizarre blackmail of the British government. Also, Sinn Féin MPs technically don't take a salary.
@@tjclarke1892 SF announced before what they intended to do. And because they never took the Westminster seats, they are not paid. Yes, they block these seats, but they are less upstructional than DUP.
Funny how it keeps getting skipped over by the BBC and too many other media outlets is the fact that the D.U.P. voted for brexit and without their support it would never have got over the line,it has always astonished me that they've been allowed to bleat,moan and complain about something they voted for.The sooner Ireland is reunified the better.
Interesting view. So ok it the highly unlikely event of Irish unification. If County Antrim and county Down vote in favour of staying in the union, and the British and Irish governments then come to some agreement where those counties remain with one foot in the UK, treated differently to the other 30 counties. By your logic the nationalist people in Antrim and Down will have nobody to blame but themselves because "they voted for it"
@9inchsnails829 as I grew up in England in the 1970's I was always told that the IRA,Sinn Fein and the Republican movement were the "bad guys",since the D.U.P. supported Johnson Brexit bollocksathon I have learned that the D.U.P. are the real criminals;lying,scheming,slimy Tories by another name. I despise the D.U.P. and anything that is the opposite of what they want is good by me,long live Ireland and may the Irish nation be as one!,bollocks to the D.U.P and all they stand for.
The Regressive Party AKA the DUP did not leave the Assembly because of any Brexit issues they left because Sinn Fein are in the First Minister position (even though both ministers are equals according to the law). They are like spoiled children refusing to participate because they werent picked first.
Yeah Sinn Fein Ira didn’t walk out did they? Or Sinn Fein Ira don’t threaten a return to violence if they don’t get what they want ? Ya daft sectarian bigot lol Clueless
Which country? The (hypothetical) country & island Ireland that was conquered by the UK, or the UK itself, which I thought NI is already & still a part of ?
A border between NI vs the rest of Britain has always been the only way to maintain the Good Friday Agreement, which will effectively separate NI's interest from UK and align them with the EU. But the Brexiters never thought of it
Don't believe in fiction It'll happen not through violence like patrick stewart said in that episode, it'll either the happen it was intended through a referendum or without one because stormount no longer works because of the DUP
What the UK should have done was to first have a referendum on whether to look into leaving the EU. Followed by a second referendum once they had a tentative deal on whether people wanted it or not. If they did this, the UK would still be in the EU right now.
You think the people who voted for Brexit would act rationally? No, they voted to leave the EU out of nationalistic motives. It's the same mindset of people who would have voted for the British Union of Fascists around Oswald Mosley.
From the EU is very funny seeing how brexit is still a thing in UK. Here is just a thing that happened some time ago, but the problems on the table nowadays are totally different. You really seams stucked in the past 😂😂
The DUP was always going to rejoin after 2 years as the running of the country would then be shared between the Irish and UK parliaments. This was part of the Good Friday Agreement. There was no way the DUP would let that happen. I'm glad they took a half-baked deal at the last minute rather than getting nothing.
@@tomgreene1843I agree the strike probably was the stick that shifted the DUP but the threat of Irish involvement in direct rule definitely had a bearing as well
@Minime163 It wasn't a "threat", it was a fact. Ireland will have a say in how the North is run in the event of direct rule. This must be so, since unionism lost its majority. We had three firsts in three years (1) a Nationalist first minister (2) census results showing that Catholics outnumber Protestants and (3) Sinn Fein winning the majority of council seats in the North, something not done by any party in the North since the 70s. But the reality of rule from Dublin is now fading... now we just need to get the North-South institutions up and running again.
yet, never been closer , unification was only @ 25% pre Brexit vote, now @ between 48/52% , DUP were warned about all this in 2015 , idiots@@alexpotts6520
You could add a zero to the end of that and it won't be settled, even if the decision was taken to have a border poll tomorrow. Sinn Fein know they can reliably gripe about a border poll, because it isn't close to happening. They have the most MEPs, but they don't have a majority of votes. If there was a border poll in NI they'd lose, without question, particularly if having a majority of the ELIGIBLE voters in favour one way or another was a condition, to avoid the clusterfuck that was Brexit. AFAIK there are no actual concrete rules for how a border poll should be conducted and woolly rules, at best, for what should trigger one. A knife-edge Brexit style referendum would trigger mass protests at best, a return to daily terrorism (both sides of the border) if not outright revolt in some areas, at worst. Currently, Ireland has a spiralling crime problem and is unfit to handle this level of social unrest. They can't even control their children. It would be ironic if Ireland required British soldiers on the streets to help police their state.
Best way to solve this is for the EU to cease to exist. The way things are going on the continent with the rise of the far right and protectionism, it looks like EU disintegration is on the horizon.
Kind of hilarious that you aren't mentioning how the DUP just doesn't want to be in government if they aren't the majority. It's not an accident that this is happening just when the nationalists would for the first time be the bigger group. It's a pathetic tantrum.
This is the astonishing elephant in the room. It was never about the protocol and the union. It was about keeping Catholics/nationalists/republicans from being the majority in a purposefully partitioned state to keep a royalist unionist protestant majority
I find it astonishing how few people are mentioning this, it’s so blatantly obvious this is the reason they refused to form a government and yet no one talks about it.
It’s DUP’s own fault. How could they have any ground crying over there!? I don’t get it. And I guess no others get it neither. You have chosen your own fate.
As a Canadian, I find this whole Northern Ireland and Ireland border being a crisis so bizarre. Canada and the US are separate countries, but I can just drive across the border and so on almost without any issues. Just a simple, "Hey, here's my passport" "Alright, cool. Have a good day." With a Nexus card, it's even faster. Just scan and you're through.
It’s not about driving your car across. It’s about goods. EU standards being subverted, smuggling etc. And because the USA and Canada are two completely different countries, that doesn’t reflect the Irish border either. It was created artificially a hundred years ago. It divides people’s farms, it divides towns and it divides families. Some people even have their house in both jurisdictions. Their kitchen is in Ireland but their bedroom is in Northern Ireland. People cross it every day going to work or going to buy groceries. And as soon as you implement checks on goods, you’re going to create a target. That target gets fortified and we’re back to square one.
@@krle7970There is no such thing as colonist in the 21st century. Self determination protects the right for people to remain in the territories they settled legally or illegally (before 1945). Kicking anybody out is a International Crime borderline war crime.
Ireland will be united by then, for sure. Scotland is 50-50. Wales is very unlikely. So the UK will probably still exist in some form. (But it might not be a monarchy by that point, so would presumably be called something else.)
@@alexpotts6520 Idk, when Wales sees everyone else peace out they might feel inclined to leave as well, hell, England might kick them out at this point because they would be a financial burden. I wonder what Queen Victoria would have to say if she saw this.
You should have read the agreement before you made the video. It isn't the end of Dynamic Alignment for NI, it is Dynamic Alignment for the whole UK now! Read the agreement where it says all new UK legislation will be scrutinised to ensure it doesn't conflict with NI (ie EU Single Market) legislation. And another point, the country which Northern Ireland shares a border with is called Ireland (see Article 4 of their constitution). The Republic of Ireland is a football team. Sloppy rushed out video yet again from TLDR.
😂😂😂 have you seen what's been happening in Germany, France or Belgium recently? The sooner the AFD takes Germany and Marine Le Pen runs France the better. We'll see what's left or your European "Union" then
Am I the only one to find it outrageous that the UK government has been negotiating with a minority Northern Ireland party? Is it any wonder that Catholic and Nationalist people feel discriminated against, not just in Northern Ireland but in the rest of the UK as well?
Not really. It's about finding the status quo, not about going too far in the opposite direction. I'm sure Sinn Fein are happy enough that the devolved parliament is returning.
@@alexpotts6520 hard to answer that. I don't believe the UK government should be at the DUP'S beck and call. They pulled it with May, with Johnson and now twice with Sunak. If they don't attend they shouldn't get paid!
A Nationalist First Minister will not wash well with ardent Unionists so Northern Ireland's political crisis will just roll on and on and on because in all future Assembly elections demographics will dictate a Nationalist First Minister, the Union between Northern Ireland and Great Britain is steadily growing weaker and as it does the Unionism will grow more militant. Troubled times ahead unfortunately which is a shame because Northern Ireland now enjoys a unique position as part of the EU internal market and part of the UK internal market.
Couldn’t agree more. Unionists should embrace NI’s new economic advantage it has over the Republic in any future referendum. Who knows? this deal might be the worst own goal for The Republic of Ireland and the EU. As NI will benefit from international investments and could steal business from the south.
@@cobzzy3878 Northern Ireland will hopefully of course receive international investment if things remain steady there but the Republic as you call it (Ireland is the official name) will continue to gain the vast amount of investment coming to the island because Ireland has decades of experience and pedigree in this area, Ireland has developed the necessary infrastructure, Ireland has the necessary education systems to support international investment, Ireland is politically and economically very stable and Ireland remains a core member of the EU. I do hope Northern Ireland develops at pace because it will make it's transition to the United Ireland easier when unification inevitably comes.
It is so great when you talk about matters that you actually understand cause they're close to you. Please stick to British politics and never again adventure yourselves into foreign political affairs where you're completely out of teach with the reality on the ground, nor you understand properly the historical context of the events and countries you're talking about.
We don't use the word fam over here and would say "that's shite" rather than that sucks. The DUP attempt to sound proper but their supported would sound more like "na mate, that's shite like"
@@MomMom4Cubs I wouldn't worry too much, people from here are more than used to ignorant comments and 70% of the country think that the DUP are backwards twats.
@@liamo6889 a lot of the are though 😂the DUP takes input from the LLC which is the spokesmen for loyalist paramilitaries. Loyalist paramilitaries are the ones who sell drugs in loyalist areas. Source: raised in loyalist areas. Bought my thrills from loyalist paramilitary members.
You already know damn well how this will all end. 5 years, 10 years, 20 years... this is not a matter of if, this is a matter of when. Let's unify this damn island into one country and be done with this, sorry unionist you can't make this last forever.
You can convince them it's inevitable but you can't convince them it's a good idea. Nationalists didn't give up when they were outnumbered, so you can hardly expect unionists to do the same.
Nationalists were not outnumbered, the British created NI to make them a minority on their own land. The unionists want to be British - they can always go live there.@@alexpotts6520
As an outsider looking in from the US, it really seems that the DUP wants to restart The Troubles. I readily admit that I likely don't know or have a full understanding of this, but their endgame seems to be to break the Good Friday agreement.
They never even supported the GFA in the first place, the DUP directly created several terrorist organisations but you never see mainstream voices discuss that in the same way they do about the IRA and SF.
They might plausibly want to (they did vote against it in 1998) but I don't know how they can when literally everyone else with a vested interest wants it to be maintained.
Northern Irish Unionists operated an apartheid state for most of 70 years locking Nationalist Irish out of any representation. Ardent Unionism has now been compelled to share power in Northern Ireland and they do not like it and will use every opportunity to undermine the structures of power sharing. Northern Ireland is changing with the demographic there rapidly moving towards Nationalism and unification with the rest of Ireland, ardent Unionism is powerless and frustrated with this inevitable process and this is what is largely responsible for the current difficulties.There are difficult years ahead hopefully these difficulties will not again manifest themselves into violence.
@@fitzstv8506Rubbish. Irish republicans reneged on the 1922 agreement and decided to steal back land. They did this by bringing terrorism to the streets of Northern Ireland to bully their way to power. They were no victims or freedom fighters, they were terrorists. They created Unionism. The Loyalists are not powerless, Stormont is power sharing so Sinn Fein have no more power than the DUP no matter what Mary Lou tries to portray. You are indulging in wishful thinking.
📝 Summary of Key Points: 📌 The political crisis in Northern Ireland was triggered by Brexit and the introduction of checks for goods under the Northern Ireland Protocol. 🧐 Sinn Féin emerged as the largest party in the May 2022 election, but the DUP continued to protest against the Northern Ireland Protocol. 🚀 A new deal has been agreed upon, including renaming the Green Lane to the UK internal markets Lane and reducing customs-related frictions for imports into Northern Ireland. 🚀 The deal may not satisfy the DUP's hardliners, as their demand for no checks in the Irish Sea conflicts with protecting the integrity of the EU's single market. 💡 Additional Insights and Observations: 💬 "The DUP deemed this framework unacceptable as it did not meet their seven tests." 📊 No specific data or statistics were mentioned in the video. 🌐 The video does not provide specific references or sources. 📣 Concluding Remarks: The political crisis in Northern Ireland, triggered by Brexit, has led to months of negotiations resulting in a new deal. While it is seen as a step in the right direction, the fundamental Brexit dilemma remains, and it is uncertain if the deal will satisfy the DUP's hardliners. The resolution of the political crisis is still uncertain, but there is hope that the deal will lead to the restoration of a functioning government in Northern Ireland. Generated using TalkBud
Not really, like it doesn't have a set definition so it could be anything from a province to a nation depending on how you view it. Its a constituent nation of the UK, so in that regard it's a nation, but in the UN it's not sovereign so in that regard it's not a nation. Its just about perspective and anyone who gets in a big fuss over it mustn't want an actual conversation or debate and just want to be an asshole so dont deserve respect.
The UK is a country made up of other countries. Its not problematic because the UK grandfathered it in to the rules. Now, downgrading it from being a country would problematic, and might risk the union..
You ask "Is Northern Ireland’s Political Crisis Finally Over?". The answer = NO. While there is a party in power that does not really want Northern Ireland to work as a principality of the United Kingdom then any plans will be defeated from the offset.
That's not why they pulled out of government. They pulled out of government because there was going to be a nationalist first minister and they are too bitter to accept it. Look at the timeline, it speaks for itself
NO ...there will always be an issue to bring down Stormont as presently structured. a march route , a language issue , a flag , the Pope, the republic government , the uk government, a new bank holiday'''....
I want to see the Sein Fein First Minister move NI more towards the Republic and eventually a united Ireland, and part of the EU. So where that leave the unionist bigots. Well they can all apply to resettle in England, or Rwanda which is a safer country.
The solution to being an oppressed minority is not to wait until you're the majority and then become the oppressor. Fortunately, Leo Varadkar is more sensible on this issue than you. He made some comments a couple of months ago about the dangers of Ulster unionists becoming second-class citizens in a United Ireland, and he's completely right.
@@alexpotts6520”Wa wa wa, I’ve been colonising Ireland for centuries and now my feelings are hurt because Irish people don’t like me now for some reason!”
@@bothi00 Forced resettlement to another country, especially of people who have lived somewhere their whole lives, is a very obvious form of oppression.
The DUP have played a terrible political game over the past 8 years. Voting for brexit and then refusing to compromise or work with Sinn Fein on power sharing has pushed NI residents further into reunification with ROI. I believe we will see a referendum on reunification within the next 10-20 years depending on how brexit plays out.
If Stormont can even stay open long enough to address the public sector workers not having any pay increases in 10 years. Health, Education and infrastructure budgets. The position of Vito needs to be removed from the assembly. Zero MLAs want this to happen , it is too good be true £150,000 / year once you diagree with your fellow politicians. Knowing the behavior of 90% of the MLAs expect a collapse in May 2024 for 2 years again! on full Pay!
Like, the thing is they're arseholes but the DUP really believe everything they say. They didn't do this to get a free holiday. They (wrongly) thought they were helping to save the union.
There is no Irish border. The Irish never put a border. There is a British border in Ireland. They can move it where they like but it's them who have the border. We the Irish don't want a border and never did.
I mean kudos for the teams involved in sorting this out to even get this far. Having a border with the EU without a border between RoI and the UK, is a paradox. One that should have been spotted way before the public was allowed to vote on Brexit.
People's memories are short. The Commission had already given the green light to there being no border at all, which is close to where we are now. That was negotiated on the initiative of then Taoiseach Enda Kenny. He began talks in Belfast immediately after Cameron announced the tabling of the referendum bill, long before the referendum result was known. The Commission agreed the no border position, because there is no other option that doesn't change Northern Ireland's constitutional status. Under the Good Friday Agreement, that can't happen without specific negotiation involving all parties to the GFA, including the guarantors, the EU and the US. The Commission issued a paper giving their reasoning. Briefly; NI is small only 1% the size of the EU economy, it is isolated from any major through EU trade routes by its geographic position, and the vast majority of trade between the UK and Ireland is in agricultural products, where the two governments have agreed a regulatory regime that was well policed and applied and was in excess not only of current EU regulations, but also in excess of any likely EU regulations in the future. This not obscure news at all. It was covered on all main news bulletins, including a complete explanation by the EU correspondent of the BBC, Katya Adler. There were vox pop interviews with people on the streets of Belfast. So the question is why wasn't this agreement simply wheeled out at the appropriate time? Varadkar's role is suspect, but there's nothing definitive to point to. However, if we look at the two major powers in Europe, we see Macron's "The British must be punished" and Merkel's "The British cannot be seen to gain". By the time Boris Johnson came along, with a clear mandate to "Get Brexit Done", they were determined to achieve these objectives, and Northern Ireland became the weapon they used. Johnson had no choice but to accept a lousy deal, leaving the mess to be sorted out later, which is exactly what has happened.
Because there are people living there who want to be part of the Union. What matters isn't the opinion of the landmass but the opinion of the people living there.
The people living here have the right for self determination and for a referendum on if we want to stay part of the UK or join Ireland. Although things have been moving towards a United Ireland passing, it's not quite there yet. Glad you get a chuckle out of complex political matters and the aftermath of civil conflict.
That didn't operate in 1921; in fact, the boundary of Northern Ireland was fixed at the largest possible area while still enclosing a Unionist " majority " in that area. No-one ever expected the minority within it, to persevere through the discrimination, to themselves become the majority.
@im_Carlisle it was set up as a country that was never expected to have a nationalist majority and only recently has that started to change. You may have been aware of that if you had done a little more reading. Northern Ireland also often gets better results at secondary level education than England so if you are calling Northern Irish stupid, I'm not sure what you think that makes the English...
The only sane way is to give NI back to Ireland - it is so obvious it should not need stating. An independent Scotland back in the EU is another no brainer!
Agreed. What is being presented in the video is but one more kick in the can down the logical road of a united Ireland. When will Westminster politics wake up to the fact that the age of empire is long dead 🤦
I mean, there's a world of difference between Northern Ireland and Scotland. Namely: - Northern Irish nationalism is about become part of a different state; Scottish nationalism is about building a new state from scratch, which is significantly harder. - Northern Ireland already has a process in place for how this would happen, set out in the Good Friday Agreement. Scotland doesn't, which is why there have been endless arguments about the legality of a second independence referendum called unilaterally by the Scottish government. - and most obviously, a United Ireland seems to be built on demographics which are trending inexorably in one direction; whereas Scottish independence is not like that, it's more of a "normal" political issue that waxes and wanes with public opinion (and specifically at the moment appears to be waning).
@@danielwebb8402 We see positive signs of an unreligious, unnationalistic future with a mentally healthier new generation of people which is much better educated, not least regarding science, environment and climate!
@@alexpotts6520 The thing that doesn't sit right with me though, is that Scotland voted to remain in the EU, and after the Brexit vote the call for Scottish independence was the largest is has been in decades, and there was a palpable majority for Scottish succession. The call for a reforendum was immense, but if was denied to the Scotts, since if it was given then, the result would've been obvious, which would've been detrimental to the rest of the UK. You're saying that it's waning again, and if that's true, what happened to self determination? It would be so insulting if a couple of years down the line, when all the permanent economic damage and divergence from the EU and subsequent 'forced' integration and alignment within the UK would have made Scottish independence/rejoining of the EU very difficult, for there to be an reforendum then, when the will/spirit of the people has simmered down, almost gone to sleep, by years of perpetuation. Maybe a bit too philosophical, but hopefully you get what I mean.
Sounds to me like all solutions lie outside of Northern Ireland. Right?? It’s a world where self-determination is but pretty words on a U.N. declaration.
Ulster says Nooo. There is no way to keep both sides happy with Brexit as it fundamentally conflicts with good Friday agreements and the goals of either entirely one side or various points of both. Idiocy
The only solution is to reunify all of Ireland as it's own sovereign state. As an English descended American I assure you, the Unionists in Ireland are also English Descended just like myself. We called them Red Coats back in the day. They can go back to where they came from and return the land of Ireland to the Irish.
Why don't you take your own advice and return the land to the indigenous American tribles hmmm?. English settlers were in Ireland long before the New World was even discovered so what's your excuse?
Imagine voting against trading with 27 countries as the DUP did? Imagine claiming the union with Britain is under threat by allowing trade with the EU? NI's position in the UK can only change if a majority of the population in NI vote to leave and join with the Republic of Ireland, a main tenet of the Good Friday Agreement, voted for by 95 per cent of the entire island of Ireland, thus the Republic giving up it's claim on the territory of NI. Good enough for the DUP? "NO!!" The DUP voted against the GFA and were routed in the referendum, also the people of NI voted against Brexit despite the DUP campaigning for a yes vote. So who do they represent? If they were being honest they want a return to the NI statelet set up in 1922, a Protestant State for a Protestant People, that was the statement then and that's why the DUP keep saying NO to everything. Now that they have said yes to power sharing with Sinn Fein Donaldson might end up the same as David Trimble who saw the writing on the wall for unionism and stuck his neck out only to be chopped off by rabid loyalists. The GFA stopped the violence, that wasn't good enough for them. Really they are dinosaurs denying the meteor ever fell on them and are an embarrassment to any real and pragmatic politics.
Funnily enough, they do literally deny that a meteor ever fell on the dinosaurs. Those fossils were just put there by God as a test of your faith, don't you know?
"Dinosaurs denying the meteor" is quite the analogy, considering the DUP quite literally do deny the dinosaurs, the meteor, and anything else more than 6000 years old.
Brexit is a gift that just keeps on giving. Our grandchildren will still laugh at the political crisis brexit created, since it will not end before 2077
It seems this deal allows NI to suffer the bad consequences (poor quality imports damaging local economy and decreasing quality of life) of the choices of a Westminster government where NI has little voice and no power. Sounds like a great plan to convince NI that it would be much better off as part of the Republic.
![DDG & G Herbo - Nosey [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/I9Ra0Zc2NlQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Cody Johnson - I'm Gonna Love You (with Carrie Underwood) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yy9PuYMU29g/mqdefault.jpg)
Short answer: No.
Longer answer: As long as Stormont exists in its current structure, there will always be a political crisis as there will always be the threat of collapse and the operation of Stormont itself does not guarantee that the many many issues facing Northern Ireland will be solved. Or in one word: Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
The thing is - the current structure is deliberate. Two years without a government might have been frustrating, but without power sharing you might actually have a war, which is obviously far worse.
@im_Carlislelet's be more specific - the politicians that profited from decades of conflict are not willing or able to fix them.
Look how many convictions Sinn Fein ministers have, and how much money the DUP have skimmed off. With them in charge, things won't change.
@@alexpotts6520 as somebody living there this is nonsense 25+ years on. It is also unfair to parties would would want to form a coalition of the willing such as alliance + other parties. The fact ir. is some people want people to be living in fear and the DUP feeds on that for their support. The largest labour protest in NI history happen just before this announcement that should tell where the average person's patience is I don;t think it is coincidence.
@@paulthomas8262 Oh for sure there have been big issues with power sharing. But given that the current arrangement is the result of peace treaty, by messing with the arrangement you're surely risking the peace, right?
If it's not one, it'll be the other. It was Sinn Fein last time.
I mean our Councils can't collapse like this, why do we put up with this system for Stormont?
I’ll believe it when I see it, the elephant in the unionist room is a Sinn Fein first minister, the writing is on the wall for a united Ireland .
Loyalists will just bring back the troubles to avoid that for a good while yet, need to be a few generations to avoid them being able to do any significant damage
The recent negotiations have not involved the EU, as the video suggests. They have been between the UK govt and the DUP.
No, the EU has been kept up to date with all of this
@@bothi00 Being kept up to date is not negotiaiting. The EU were not involved in the negotiations.
@@frankoneill5675 yes, it is. Because if the EU need to be assured ever step of the way, then they are part of the negotiations especially given that all of this is contingent on EU treaties and deals
Yes, they knew negotiations were going on, but had no input, and at the end, apparently, neither the EU nor Ireland (and Ireland are kept fully informed re Protocol issues) knew the detail of what was agreed. Supposedly David Cameron phoned Maroš Šefčovič to inform him and the latter said they would study the details carefully.
Tony Connelly said there are flexibilities open to the UK within the terms of the Framework regarding the green lane, once they don't harm the integrity of the SM. If the EU have any objections we'll hear in the next few days. Leo Varadkar said there were 'questions' regarding some aspects of trading arrangements but he didn't think there were any 'red flags'.
The EU and EU Parliament will examine and debate the proposals agreed between the DUP and the UK Government and if it is happy that the EU single market is not compromised it will give it's approval, if it is not happy which is unlikely then the proposal cannot be implemented. Do not forget the latest agreement between the UK Government and the DUP is just an add on to the Northern Irish Protocol of the TCA and the subsequent Windsor Framework which are themselves legally binding international agreements.
Ulster is Irish
Nope
Tiocfaidh ár lá
Brits out everyone else in.
@@lindalonergan7887I doubt folks who want unification are the sames who want limitless multicultural cosmopolitanism.
@@TheIrishLad06 some people have no breeding.
It's Northern Ireland. Stormont is in a state of perpetual political crisis by design, but as long as it keeps the crisis within the halls of Stormont and not out on the streets, then it's working as intended.
Therefore suggesting that a united Ireland is the only long term solution.
@Conal792 Absolutely not. That might be a solution acceptable to you but not everyone.
Say that to British Anguilla, they're fuming too they can't visit the rest of the EU Caribbean including it's best friend franco dutch saint Martin
@@CT99234
That or an independent country of Northern Ireland, that’s neither part of the UK nor of the Republic of Ireland
@@coyotelong4349would be a very weak and resource Poot nation, more so than Ireland
Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Unionists never thought of the consequences of Brexit and now they'll have to live with them.
The leopards ate their faces
How dare Unionist have a political preference
@@robert6106to say nothing of them having a two year tantrum and causing untold problems to the country they’re meant to be in charge of, eh?
@@robert6106 if they love england so much, maybe they should go there
@@robert6106Nobody suggested they couldn’t. But if you act on those preferences you have to accept the consequences. The best part of a decade wasted trying to square the circle they helped create.
DUP: We have seven simple requirements.
Requirement #3: Have our cake.
Requirement #5: Eat it too.
Dup: can northern ireland actually be a proper part of the union
Westminster: no
@@lightningstrike5024 *_Correction_*
DUP: Can Northern Ireland actually be a proper part of the Union *_and_* force the Republic of Ireland to leave the EU market against their will for our convenience?
Reality: Wtf!? *No* ! What the hell are you even talking about?! Jesus, you thought Farage and friends were being honest, didn't you?...
@@BoojumFed westminster wont let their be an eu land border because they unironically think it could start another war w/ ireland
@@lightningstrike5024 Westminster won't let there be a land border with Ireland because they're old enough to remember the slaughter caused by a land border, yes.
And don't kid yourself. The Troubles weren't a war, they were a _Civil War_ where combatants on both sides rained terrorist cruelty on each other's civilian population. Half the Irish here in Canada were people getting their children out of the blast zones of the indiscriminate Ulster Defense/ Irish Republican bombings.
@@BoojumFed terrorism is a problem for he police to solve, not bureaucracy that skerts around the sides of it. and its not 1916 anymore
The solution thus far has been for the British government to tell contradictory lies to all parties involved and hoping that no one calls them on it.
How very British (see also the Mandate for Palestine)
@@supersocashow3176What?
@@Finnbobjimbob The British only got control over the regions of Israel/Palestine, Jordan, Iraq and Kuwait after the fall of the Ottoman Empire because they (and the French) allied Arab freedom fighters (with the promise of an independent united hashemite Arabia) and then betrayed them by carving up the regions for colonies, or "League of Nations Mandates".
This is part of why countries like Iraq and Syria are so dysfunctional, their borders were not drawn to work as independent countries but to support British and French Imperialism.
@@smuu1996 The borders of Israel and Palestine were created by the UN. And last time I checked, there is an independent Arab nation.
@@supersocashow3176See also British dealings with India and China
DUP regretting that Brexit vote. They brought the Irish reunnification closer
I don't see that at all as it's power sharing. They are no closer to a United Ireland than the SNP is to getting gaining their independence. There's a long way to go.
Unionist population is now very old and shrinking rapidly. Nationalist population is very young and increasing at a breakneck speed. Do the maths. ==Irish Unity
@Cacbo774 Are actually trying to suggest that Loyalists don't have children while catholics breed like rabbits? 😅😅😅 Your logic and delusion is priceless.
"Closer" that implies it will happen, in the the last poll (2020, the height of the brexit crisis) only 27% of NI people said they would vote for independence. Now with the rise of migration from the UK and the rise of the "nones".. Good luck.
@NordieJ everyone knows irish people have more children than unionists, Northern ireland will inevitably reunite with ireland
Should of stopped their pay. It would of been fixed in a week.
Youre kidding, they get paid to not work?!?
@@Adamlemon1217 True, it's the most expensive daycare we all pay for.
Have, never of!
@@michaelmccarthy9411 people still understand what he's saying. It's a RUclips comment section FFS not school.
@@beltrofix7667 and it's a youtube comment not a c3, chill
Is Northern Ireland's Political Crisis over?"
As someone who has lived there all their life, no. No it is not.
Agreed indeed !
It will be a permanent political crisis until reunification finally happens.
Same here lad - Anguilla
It probably never will be. Northern Ireland was only ever envisaged as a temporary solution to the problems of 1921. The solution lies, as acknowledged in the GFA, in relationships between the (at least) two communities that live there, relationships North- South and East- West. Much more work needs to be done to ensure an agreed peaceful outcome. Brexit has derailed the peace, but it must be got back on track.
@@seandoherty925 Northern Ireland should be allowed to enjoy the same full "brexit benefits" as the rest of the UK, it would be all over next month.
DUP that voted for Brexit, you made your bed, now lie in it
Us irish don't hate England... we will do trade... It's money. No matter is it's North East, South or West.
@@PaulMuzik Just to clarify my man, not saying that there is animosity toward England, just that people that voted for Brexit and are now suffering the consequences are morons and should own up to the situation we're now in as a nation
Northern Ireland should just join Ireland, if only to make the 2024 Ireland Reunification said in Star Trek: The Next Generation happen.
Fella don't always believe in fiction especially what star trek, the north will be annexed into republic soon. But not because of some prediction from a fictional tv series
Never
Sadly politics move too slowly, that prediction is basically doomed at this point. Although they also predicted it would happen by... "aggressive negotiations". So maybe, if shit REALLY gets bad in the UK for some reason, it could happen.
*MOVIES DON'T PREDICT THE FUTURE*
It baffles me as to what the unionists expected from Brexit. They must secretly have been wanting a hard Northern Irish border. Surely.....
Nothing secret about it, it's the only long term way of keeping Northern Ireland in line with the rest of the UK without GB submitting to the same trade regulations as the Republic of Ireland. At that point they might as well just rejoin the EU, which obviously isn't happening any time soon.
The only ways you could logically avoid having either a land border on the island of Ireland or a sea border between parts of the UK would be if a) Ireland ALSO leaves the EU, forming a little two-country trading union with the UK instead, b) Northern Ireland leaves the UK and rejoins with Ireland, which stays in the EU, removing the need for a sea border, or c) the UK annexes Ireland, removing the need for a land border. Of course, there is the elusive option d) just not starting this clusterfuck in the first place, but clearly that had no takers.
Since b) or d) weren’t on the table, either the unionists were thinking Ireland would join in on Brexit, or they were thinking they could force Ireland to join the UK down the road.
…or they weren’t thinking at all, just acting on pure id like a toddler who wants to go outside but also refuses to wear pants. Which is probably the most likely scenario, all things considered.
@@CanonessEllinor Couldn't putting some type of customs checks between Ireland and continental Europe also be a solution? Option e I suppose
@@CanonessEllinor Annex the Republic??? There wouldn't be a brit safe anywhere on the Planet!🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@kevindevane6175Why would that be ? That seems like a threatening comment.
Until there is a united Ireland, this failed political entity will always be in crisis.
It is going to kill the hardcore Unionist supports to see a SF politician as first Minister, this is the more historic of the whole situation as it will be the first time for a Nationalist to do so in the provinces history.
It took a long time as when it was carve up for a 70% unionist majority ,
NI Unionists voting for Brexit is one of the greatest own-goals in all political history. Irish reunification is much closer to reality, Sinn Fein is in power, and all these oitcomes were very obvious and inevitable. Did they think the other 26 counties would vote to leave with them?! They voted for their own demise.
Self sabotage even Putin would be proud of.
Sinn Fein in power is useless if they have to collaborate with unionists and Westminster
I would disagree, Sinn Fein may now have a first Minister in Stormont but the power sharing in Stormont will result in no greater a risk of reunification, Sinn Fein are only playing into their own rhetoric. There isn't really any difference between Sinn Fein being in power than the SNP running Scotland.
@@garagefridge8930 But there's a big difference here. At any point Northern Ireland can vote to rejoin the Republic, in which the UK just has to take the L if they do. There's no Scotland situation here where they have to plead and beg parliment for it. Sinn Fein will try their hardest to get that through, and, if they have enough momentum, will happen
Absolutely clueless I’m guessing you’re not from Northern Ireland!?
The polls are showing a united ireland isn’t even close in fact they’ve widened recently
Stop throwing around Sinn Fein IRA propaganda that keeps the stupid people under control
A simple google search dis proves this stupid nationalist myth
Imagine you would refuse to work for 2 years and still get paid.
Those DUP guys are milking it
No one said anything when Sinn Fein did it for 3.
No one says anything when SF refuse to take their Westminster seats.
Yeah but to be fair that was also because of the massive scandal the DUP caused... And cost the tax payers £500 million to fix....
@@tjclarke1892
They did and they do, what planet are you living on?
In case you don't remember, Sinn Féin left the Executive because Foster refused to step down for the RHI scandal investigation and the DUP were reneging on legislation required by the Good Friday Agreement for Irish language recognition. Expecting transparency in a corruption investigation and demanding promised legislation from your forced coalition partner is a very different thing to this bizarre blackmail of the British government.
Also, Sinn Féin MPs technically don't take a salary.
@@tjclarke1892 SF announced before what they intended to do. And because they never took the Westminster seats, they are not paid. Yes, they block these seats, but they are less upstructional than DUP.
yes massive crisis ,but it seems life just carries on as normal, makes you wonder if politicians are the problem not the solution?
"Surprisingly a majority of unionists voted for Brexit!"
That sounds like it falls under the 'not fully thinking that through' umbrella 🤨
Funny how it keeps getting skipped over by the BBC and too many other media outlets is the fact that the D.U.P. voted for brexit and without their support it would never have got over the line,it has always astonished me that they've been allowed to bleat,moan and complain about something they voted for.The sooner Ireland is reunified the better.
Their vote was basically bought too. Wanted their cake and to eat it.
Exactly
And the dark money they received to pay for nationwide television ads in support of Brexit.
Interesting view.
So ok it the highly unlikely event of Irish unification. If County Antrim and county Down vote in favour of staying in the union, and the British and Irish governments then come to some agreement where those counties remain with one foot in the UK, treated differently to the other 30 counties.
By your logic the nationalist people in Antrim and Down will have nobody to blame but themselves because "they voted for it"
@9inchsnails829 as I grew up in England in the 1970's I was always told that the IRA,Sinn Fein and the Republican movement were the "bad guys",since the D.U.P. supported Johnson Brexit bollocksathon I have learned that the D.U.P. are the real criminals;lying,scheming,slimy Tories by another name. I despise the D.U.P. and anything that is the opposite of what they want is good by me,long live Ireland and may the Irish nation be as one!,bollocks to the D.U.P and all they stand for.
Once again please don't give Jamie Bryson any air time he has no mandate from the people of N.I
The Regressive Party AKA the DUP did not leave the Assembly because of any Brexit issues they left because Sinn Fein are in the First Minister position (even though both ministers are equals according to the law). They are like spoiled children refusing to participate because they werent picked first.
Wait till they realize the union wants no part of them
4:45 Reading the timeline of the live tweets is so funny.
With the DUP having dickie fits every so often I think it'll always be fractious.
Yeah Sinn Fein Ira didn’t walk out did they?
Or Sinn Fein Ira don’t threaten a return to violence if they don’t get what they want ?
Ya daft sectarian bigot lol
Clueless
"If you took NO out of the dictionary Ulster would have nothing to say"
The real solution is to reunite the country.
Which country? The (hypothetical) country & island Ireland that was conquered by the UK, or the UK itself, which I thought NI is already & still a part of ?
@@Apollorion It's a dumb statement that has no real meaning.
@@Apollorionspastic
@@Apollorionobviously Ireland
@@rusticpartyeditzWhy?
A border between NI vs the rest of Britain has always been the only way to maintain the Good Friday Agreement, which will effectively separate NI's interest from UK and align them with the EU. But the Brexiters never thought of it
worse than never thought of it, mocked all concerns about it as "project fear" 😬
Brexiteers not thinking something through? Nonsense!
Lolz, it is almost like Brexit meant LESS control over their own policies 😂😂😂😂. Is there ANY positive from Brexit?! I am yet to see any.
Boris said there would be a lot of benefits. He never lie, right?
Cue some vague response about 'sovereignty' ... 🤦♂️
There's been several benefits. Mostly within the EU
@@Aoskar95sure that's why they've had to cut their subsidies budgets because their second largest Contributer has left
@@MocatafamulusdeSetsovereignty isn't vague
There are less than 10 months to prove Star Trek TNG right.
Don't believe in fiction
It'll happen not through violence like patrick stewart said in that episode, it'll either the happen it was intended through a referendum or without one because stormount no longer works because of the DUP
Yes, Brexit. The gift that just keeps giving.
I bet you those DUP members who just decided
Not to go to work if they stopped getting paid might have changed their tune
What the UK should have done was to first have a referendum on whether to look into leaving the EU. Followed by a second referendum once they had a tentative deal on whether people wanted it or not. If they did this, the UK would still be in the EU right now.
You think the people who voted for Brexit would act rationally? No, they voted to leave the EU out of nationalistic motives. It's the same mindset of people who would have voted for the British Union of Fascists around Oswald Mosley.
Well a lot of people voted leave as a protest to the agrogance of the EU, not expecting it to actually get through.
@@stephencole9289 arrogance of the EU? the arrogance of the voters is what made them vote leave.
From the EU is very funny seeing how brexit is still a thing in UK. Here is just a thing that happened some time ago, but the problems on the table nowadays are totally different. You really seams stucked in the past 😂😂
DUP were like turkeys voting for Christmas!
The DUP was always going to rejoin after 2 years as the running of the country would then be shared between the Irish and UK parliaments. This was part of the Good Friday Agreement.
There was no way the DUP would let that happen. I'm glad they took a half-baked deal at the last minute rather than getting nothing.
I think the strike had a bearing ...remember the Ulster Workers strike ..??
@@tomgreene1843I agree the strike probably was the stick that shifted the DUP but the threat of Irish involvement in direct rule definitely had a bearing as well
@Minime163
It wasn't a "threat", it was a fact. Ireland will have a say in how the North is run in the event of direct rule. This must be so, since unionism lost its majority.
We had three firsts in three years (1) a Nationalist first minister (2) census results showing that Catholics outnumber Protestants and (3) Sinn Fein winning the majority of council seats in the North, something not done by any party in the North since the 70s.
But the reality of rule from Dublin is now fading... now we just need to get the North-South institutions up and running again.
@@Jcolbert123 I know that and you know that but that's exactly what unionist see Irish involvement in a direct rule scenario as.
Yes ...also the diminished Unionist influence west of the Bann and south of Lurgan added to N/S trade@@Minime163
Unionists helped unite Ireland, Arlene Foster especially so 🍿👀
They should build statues of Johnson and Farage in Ireland, the greatest figures in Irish history.
Honestly, they should just unite Ireland at this point
🤡
Who is "they"? The gift is entirely within the people of Northern Ireland, and it's not obvious that there is a majority in favour yet.
yet, never been closer , unification was only @ 25% pre Brexit vote, now @ between 48/52% , DUP were warned about all this in 2015 , idiots@@alexpotts6520
@@alexpotts6520 It is entirely in the hands of the people of Ireland, not only of the people of the Six Counties.
I agree. It's going to happen at some stage anyway. It's a changed place.
The Irish Reunification of 2024 may actually become a reality! (Star Trek reference)
No way! 😌
4:35 when mentioning Jamie Bryson it's always worth mentioning that he is the voice for the UVF.
Still waiting for that Irish Reunification of 2024
Who actually wants that basket case?
@@malahammerthe Irish, who else’s opinion on the subject matters?
To reunify implies that they've been unified in the past. They were a group of small kingdoms before England went over.
@@Sabhoh majority of people in Northern Ireland don't, only 33% of Northern Ireland identified as Irish in the last census
A little bit like the second comming.
Northern Ireland is one of the last British colonies.
The rest of Ireland abolished being a colony 100 years ago.
The crisis will be over once NI has unified with Ireland again. My guess is: about 5 years from now.
You could add a zero to the end of that and it won't be settled, even if the decision was taken to have a border poll tomorrow. Sinn Fein know they can reliably gripe about a border poll, because it isn't close to happening. They have the most MEPs, but they don't have a majority of votes. If there was a border poll in NI they'd lose, without question, particularly if having a majority of the ELIGIBLE voters in favour one way or another was a condition, to avoid the clusterfuck that was Brexit. AFAIK there are no actual concrete rules for how a border poll should be conducted and woolly rules, at best, for what should trigger one. A knife-edge Brexit style referendum would trigger mass protests at best, a return to daily terrorism (both sides of the border) if not outright revolt in some areas, at worst.
Currently, Ireland has a spiralling crime problem and is unfit to handle this level of social unrest. They can't even control their children. It would be ironic if Ireland required British soldiers on the streets to help police their state.
It will take a lot longer than five years, but I can see it happening eventually
The best way to have avoided this problem was for the UK not to have left the EU, the best way to solve this problem is for the UK to rejoin the EU
In the absence of any chance of UK-EU reunification, an Irish reunification would also completely solve this problem.
@@yavuzkoroglu7792 Both of those things happening would be quite nice
Depends if the people NI want that, also doesn't solve the UK-EU break-up@@yavuzkoroglu7792
Best way to solve this is for the EU to cease to exist. The way things are going on the continent with the rise of the far right and protectionism, it looks like EU disintegration is on the horizon.
@@cobzzy3878
Ignorant people from the U.K have been repeating that lie for nearly a decade now. 😂
DUP says "Yes"....hahahahahahhahahahah...no way....they will never work with Sinn Fein when SF are in charge.
Kind of hilarious that you aren't mentioning how the DUP just doesn't want to be in government if they aren't the majority. It's not an accident that this is happening just when the nationalists would for the first time be the bigger group.
It's a pathetic tantrum.
This is the astonishing elephant in the room.
It was never about the protocol and the union. It was about keeping Catholics/nationalists/republicans from being the majority in a purposefully partitioned state to keep a royalist unionist protestant majority
I find it astonishing how few people are mentioning this, it’s so blatantly obvious this is the reason they refused to form a government and yet no one talks about it.
@@bothi00I mean, the whole reason NI isn't the whole Ulster is because catholics would be the majority in that cenario.
this isnt mentioned because theres no evidence of it. if this was the problem, why did they go back in. this didnt go away?
@@megadwarf4714 oh man, you still think politicians are honest people that act in good faith and tell the truth. Bless you
This very issue was brought up time and time again before the Brexit vote - Project Fear it was called. This isn't over.
its very bad im glad i live across the border in the republic
It’s DUP’s own fault. How could they have any ground crying over there!? I don’t get it. And I guess no others get it neither. You have chosen your own fate.
As a Canadian, I find this whole Northern Ireland and Ireland border being a crisis so bizarre. Canada and the US are separate countries, but I can just drive across the border and so on almost without any issues. Just a simple, "Hey, here's my passport" "Alright, cool. Have a good day."
With a Nexus card, it's even faster. Just scan and you're through.
It’s not about driving your car across. It’s about goods. EU standards being subverted, smuggling etc. And because the USA and Canada are two completely different countries, that doesn’t reflect the Irish border either. It was created artificially a hundred years ago. It divides people’s farms, it divides towns and it divides families. Some people even have their house in both jurisdictions. Their kitchen is in Ireland but their bedroom is in Northern Ireland. People cross it every day going to work or going to buy groceries. And as soon as you implement checks on goods, you’re going to create a target. That target gets fortified and we’re back to square one.
The British imposed a border on Ireland. When they go, the problem is solved forever.
US Citizens didn't need a passport to visit Canada before George W Bush screwed it up.
A birth certificate sufficed.
@@Dreynomaybe they should just I don’t know unite into a single island and others who don’t like it (colonists) leave back to Scotland and England
@@krle7970There is no such thing as colonist in the 21st century.
Self determination protects the right for people to remain in the territories they settled legally or illegally (before 1945).
Kicking anybody out is a International Crime borderline war crime.
I predict that the UK won't be a country by 2100. It will just be good ol' England again.
Agree or disagree?
Ireland will be united by then, for sure. Scotland is 50-50. Wales is very unlikely. So the UK will probably still exist in some form. (But it might not be a monarchy by that point, so would presumably be called something else.)
@@alexpotts6520 Idk, when Wales sees everyone else peace out they might feel inclined to leave as well, hell, England might kick them out at this point because they would be a financial burden.
I wonder what Queen Victoria would have to say if she saw this.
If you don’t need a government for 2 years you can hardly call it a crisis
4:00 “Give the people of Northern Ireland a say in making the laws that govern them”
That sounds a lot like y’know… self governance
No. Just moving into a new phase of animosity where they get the money and the benefits but stay firmly in the 17th century.
We the people NORTH AND SOUTH DO NOT WANT THAT WHICH sinn fein offers PAR EXAMPLE the prescence of ISLAM. Very disturbing
It’s all the DUPs fault. 100%. Arlene to blame for not doing what she was paid to do in the first place
You should have read the agreement before you made the video. It isn't the end of Dynamic Alignment for NI, it is Dynamic Alignment for the whole UK now! Read the agreement where it says all new UK legislation will be scrutinised to ensure it doesn't conflict with NI (ie EU Single Market) legislation. And another point, the country which Northern Ireland shares a border with is called Ireland (see Article 4 of their constitution). The Republic of Ireland is a football team. Sloppy rushed out video yet again from TLDR.
“Brexit would strengthen the Union”. You’re right! The European Union😂
😂😂😂 have you seen what's been happening in Germany, France or Belgium recently? The sooner the AFD takes Germany and Marine Le Pen runs France the better. We'll see what's left or your European "Union" then
No.
The North of Ireland will always be the same .Religion needs to be taken out of politics, unless it does,nothing will change.
The English have no one to blame for this mess except themselves. Difficult to sympathize.
Am I the only one to find it outrageous that the UK government has been negotiating with a minority Northern Ireland party?
Is it any wonder that Catholic and Nationalist people feel discriminated against, not just in Northern Ireland but in the rest of the UK as well?
Exactly. Especially when they are the only party in favour of Brexit in the first place
Not really. It's about finding the status quo, not about going too far in the opposite direction. I'm sure Sinn Fein are happy enough that the devolved parliament is returning.
Would you have preferred for the shutdown to continue indefinitely? How else was Stormont ever going to be restored?
Sinn Féin also has the power to do this. The assembly requires cooperation from both Nationalists and Unionists
@@alexpotts6520 hard to answer that. I don't believe the UK government should be at the DUP'S beck and call. They pulled it with May, with Johnson and now twice with Sunak. If they don't attend they shouldn't get paid!
Return Northern Ireland to Ireland ASAP, you will have a much happier people.
A Nationalist First Minister will not wash well with ardent Unionists so Northern Ireland's political crisis will just roll on and on and on because in all future Assembly elections demographics will dictate a Nationalist First Minister, the Union between Northern Ireland and Great Britain is steadily growing weaker and as it does the Unionism will grow more militant. Troubled times ahead unfortunately which is a shame because Northern Ireland now enjoys a unique position as part of the EU internal market and part of the UK internal market.
Couldn’t agree more. Unionists should embrace NI’s new economic advantage it has over the Republic in any future referendum. Who knows? this deal might be the worst own goal for The Republic of Ireland and the EU. As NI will benefit from international investments and could steal business from the south.
@@cobzzy3878 Northern Ireland will hopefully of course receive international investment if things remain steady there but the Republic as you call it (Ireland is the official name) will continue to gain the vast amount of investment coming to the island because Ireland has decades of experience and pedigree in this area, Ireland has developed the necessary infrastructure, Ireland has the necessary education systems to support international investment, Ireland is politically and economically very stable and Ireland remains a core member of the EU.
I do hope Northern Ireland develops at pace because it will make it's transition to the United Ireland easier when unification inevitably comes.
It is so great when you talk about matters that you actually understand cause they're close to you. Please stick to British politics and never again adventure yourselves into foreign political affairs where you're completely out of teach with the reality on the ground, nor you understand properly the historical context of the events and countries you're talking about.
I wonder which news story you're so bitter about him not taking your side on. Although if I was a gambling man I'd bet I know which it is.
Examples would be helpful
Just give Northern Ireland back to Ireland and move on
3:56 "Nah Fam that sucks" - this is exactly how I imagined DUP party members to speak
We don't use the word fam over here and would say "that's shite" rather than that sucks. The DUP attempt to sound proper but their supported would sound more like "na mate, that's shite like"
Nah fam that sucks
What do ye think they are teenagers or drug dealers 😂
I find the injection of ebonics in what could turn into a very serious situation amusing
@@MomMom4Cubs I wouldn't worry too much, people from here are more than used to ignorant comments and 70% of the country think that the DUP are backwards twats.
@@liamo6889 a lot of the are though 😂the DUP takes input from the LLC which is the spokesmen for loyalist paramilitaries. Loyalist paramilitaries are the ones who sell drugs in loyalist areas.
Source: raised in loyalist areas. Bought my thrills from loyalist paramilitary members.
The DUP are doing more for Republicans than Sinn Fein could ever do. How do they not see they are very much annoying their base
It's time for reunification!
The northern Irish disagree
@@Finnbobjimbob
Enjoy Sinn Féin first minister!
@@Finnbobjimbobexactly
You already know damn well how this will all end.
5 years, 10 years, 20 years... this is not a matter of if, this is a matter of when.
Let's unify this damn island into one country and be done with this, sorry unionist you can't make this last forever.
You can convince them it's inevitable but you can't convince them it's a good idea. Nationalists didn't give up when they were outnumbered, so you can hardly expect unionists to do the same.
@@alexpotts6520unionists are literally dying out & plenty still left are even re-considering unification
Nationalists were not outnumbered, the British created NI to make them a minority on their own land. The unionists want to be British - they can always go live there.@@alexpotts6520
As an outsider looking in from the US, it really seems that the DUP wants to restart The Troubles. I readily admit that I likely don't know or have a full understanding of this, but their endgame seems to be to break the Good Friday agreement.
They never even supported the GFA in the first place, the DUP directly created several terrorist organisations but you never see mainstream voices discuss that in the same way they do about the IRA and SF.
They might plausibly want to (they did vote against it in 1998) but I don't know how they can when literally everyone else with a vested interest wants it to be maintained.
Northern Irish Unionists operated an apartheid state for most of 70 years locking Nationalist Irish out of any representation. Ardent Unionism has now been compelled to share power in Northern Ireland and they do not like it and will use every opportunity to undermine the structures of power sharing. Northern Ireland is changing with the demographic there rapidly moving towards Nationalism and unification with the rest of Ireland, ardent Unionism is powerless and frustrated with this inevitable process and this is what is largely responsible for the current difficulties.There are difficult years ahead hopefully these difficulties will not again manifest themselves into violence.
Really? As an outsider I was thinking the same thing but about the EU
@@fitzstv8506Rubbish. Irish republicans reneged on the 1922 agreement and decided to steal back land. They did this by bringing terrorism to the streets of Northern Ireland to bully their way to power. They were no victims or freedom fighters, they were terrorists. They created Unionism. The Loyalists are not powerless, Stormont is power sharing so Sinn Fein have no more power than the DUP no matter what Mary Lou tries to portray. You are indulging in wishful thinking.
📝 Summary of Key Points:
📌 The political crisis in Northern Ireland was triggered by Brexit and the introduction of checks for goods under the Northern Ireland Protocol.
🧐 Sinn Féin emerged as the largest party in the May 2022 election, but the DUP continued to protest against the Northern Ireland Protocol.
🚀 A new deal has been agreed upon, including renaming the Green Lane to the UK internal markets Lane and reducing customs-related frictions for imports into Northern Ireland.
🚀 The deal may not satisfy the DUP's hardliners, as their demand for no checks in the Irish Sea conflicts with protecting the integrity of the EU's single market.
💡 Additional Insights and Observations:
💬 "The DUP deemed this framework unacceptable as it did not meet their seven tests."
📊 No specific data or statistics were mentioned in the video.
🌐 The video does not provide specific references or sources.
📣 Concluding Remarks:
The political crisis in Northern Ireland, triggered by Brexit, has led to months of negotiations resulting in a new deal. While it is seen as a step in the right direction, the fundamental Brexit dilemma remains, and it is uncertain if the deal will satisfy the DUP's hardliners. The resolution of the political crisis is still uncertain, but there is hope that the deal will lead to the restoration of a functioning government in Northern Ireland.
Generated using TalkBud
3:00 or thereabouts: "...the first time in the nation's history..." Describing Northern Ireland as a nation could be problematic.
Not really, like it doesn't have a set definition so it could be anything from a province to a nation depending on how you view it.
Its a constituent nation of the UK, so in that regard it's a nation, but in the UN it's not sovereign so in that regard it's not a nation.
Its just about perspective and anyone who gets in a big fuss over it mustn't want an actual conversation or debate and just want to be an asshole so dont deserve respect.
Not as problematic as the goddamn Tories.
The UK is a country made up of other countries. Its not problematic because the UK grandfathered it in to the rules.
Now, downgrading it from being a country would problematic, and might risk the union..
It's a colony
@@AiSard it’s not a country either
You ask "Is Northern Ireland’s Political Crisis Finally Over?". The answer = NO.
While there is a party in power that does not really want Northern Ireland to work as a principality of the United Kingdom then any plans will be defeated from the offset.
That's not why they pulled out of government. They pulled out of government because there was going to be a nationalist first minister and they are too bitter to accept it. Look at the timeline, it speaks for itself
*thank you!* been repeatedly disappointed at tl;dr's biased coverage of issues from norn iron
NO ...there will always be an issue to bring down Stormont as presently structured. a march route , a language issue , a flag , the Pope, the republic government , the uk government, a new bank holiday'''....
It’s a British land border, nothing to do with Ireland
Well....
I want to see the Sein Fein First Minister move NI more towards the Republic and eventually a united Ireland, and part of the EU.
So where that leave the unionist bigots. Well they can all apply to resettle in England, or Rwanda which is a safer country.
The solution to being an oppressed minority is not to wait until you're the majority and then become the oppressor.
Fortunately, Leo Varadkar is more sensible on this issue than you. He made some comments a couple of months ago about the dangers of Ulster unionists becoming second-class citizens in a United Ireland, and he's completely right.
@@alexpotts6520 how would that make them an oppressor though ?
@@alexpotts6520”Wa wa wa, I’ve been colonising Ireland for centuries and now my feelings are hurt because Irish people don’t like me now for some reason!”
@@alexpotts6520 But the entire Northern Ireland are second-class citizens in Britain.
@@bothi00 Forced resettlement to another country, especially of people who have lived somewhere their whole lives, is a very obvious form of oppression.
The DUP have played a terrible political game over the past 8 years. Voting for brexit and then refusing to compromise or work with Sinn Fein on power sharing has pushed NI residents further into reunification with ROI. I believe we will see a referendum on reunification within the next 10-20 years depending on how brexit plays out.
If Stormont can even stay open long enough to address the public sector workers not having any pay increases in 10 years. Health, Education and infrastructure budgets.
The position of Vito needs to be removed from the assembly. Zero MLAs want this to happen , it is too good be true £150,000 / year once you diagree with your fellow politicians. Knowing the behavior of 90% of the MLAs expect a collapse in May 2024 for 2 years again! on full Pay!
Like, the thing is they're arseholes but the DUP really believe everything they say. They didn't do this to get a free holiday. They (wrongly) thought they were helping to save the union.
Very nice report, thank you!
Regards.
Mrs. Ragone
There is no Irish border. The Irish never put a border. There is a British border in Ireland. They can move it where they like but it's them who have the border.
We the Irish don't want a border and never did.
DUP and co. Should return to their beloved motherland ……. Yeah they’d have to take a boat but that would solve lots of issues too
Britain should conquar potato land again, that will solve it too.
I mean kudos for the teams involved in sorting this out to even get this far. Having a border with the EU without a border between RoI and the UK, is a paradox. One that should have been spotted way before the public was allowed to vote on Brexit.
I mean, many people *did* spot it...
@@alexpotts6520 Lots of "Experts" Right? 😭
@@alexpotts6520 No one who stated it clearly enough.
People's memories are short. The Commission had already given the green light to there being no border at all, which is close to where we are now.
That was negotiated on the initiative of then Taoiseach Enda Kenny. He began talks in Belfast immediately after Cameron announced the tabling of the referendum bill, long before the referendum result was known. The Commission agreed the no border position, because there is no other option that doesn't change Northern Ireland's constitutional status. Under the Good Friday Agreement, that can't happen without specific negotiation involving all parties to the GFA, including the guarantors, the EU and the US.
The Commission issued a paper giving their reasoning. Briefly; NI is small only 1% the size of the EU economy, it is isolated from any major through EU trade routes by its geographic position, and the vast majority of trade between the UK and Ireland is in agricultural products, where the two governments have agreed a regulatory regime that was well policed and applied and was in excess not only of current EU regulations, but also in excess of any likely EU regulations in the future.
This not obscure news at all. It was covered on all main news bulletins, including a complete explanation by the EU correspondent of the BBC, Katya Adler. There were vox pop interviews with people on the streets of Belfast.
So the question is why wasn't this agreement simply wheeled out at the appropriate time?
Varadkar's role is suspect, but there's nothing definitive to point to. However, if we look at the two major powers in Europe, we see Macron's "The British must be punished" and Merkel's "The British cannot be seen to gain". By the time Boris Johnson came along, with a clear mandate to "Get Brexit Done", they were determined to achieve these objectives, and Northern Ireland became the weapon they used. Johnson had no choice but to accept a lousy deal, leaving the mess to be sorted out later, which is exactly what has happened.
The border is not the problem. The clash between the CTA and EU single market is the problem.
Irish reunification 2024!
The fact that Ireland still isn't unified is so funny, how are you letting the UK have a piece of the island after all their fuck ups LMAO
Because there are people living there who want to be part of the Union. What matters isn't the opinion of the landmass but the opinion of the people living there.
The people living here have the right for self determination and for a referendum on if we want to stay part of the UK or join Ireland. Although things have been moving towards a United Ireland passing, it's not quite there yet.
Glad you get a chuckle out of complex political matters and the aftermath of civil conflict.
That didn't operate in 1921; in fact, the boundary of Northern Ireland was fixed at the largest possible area while still enclosing a Unionist " majority " in that area.
No-one ever expected the minority within it, to persevere through the discrimination, to themselves become the majority.
@im_Carlisle it was set up as a country that was never expected to have a nationalist majority and only recently has that started to change. You may have been aware of that if you had done a little more reading. Northern Ireland also often gets better results at secondary level education than England so if you are calling Northern Irish stupid, I'm not sure what you think that makes the English...
@@mnm1273they are colonists, they aren’t Irish because they took the land from the Irish, about time for them to go back home to ENGLAND
You have to applaud TLDR for deciphering this piece on NI.👏
I was critical of your understanding of the function of the US Supreme Court, but this post was an excellent precis of the NI situation.
N̶o̶ Surrender
I wonder what Brexiteers are thinking now. Do they actually think?
The only sane way is to give NI back to Ireland - it is so obvious it should not need stating. An independent Scotland back in the EU is another no brainer!
Give against its population will.
That sounds not the right thing to do.
Agreed. What is being presented in the video is but one more kick in the can down the logical road of a united Ireland. When will Westminster politics wake up to the fact that the age of empire is long dead 🤦
I mean, there's a world of difference between Northern Ireland and Scotland. Namely:
- Northern Irish nationalism is about become part of a different state; Scottish nationalism is about building a new state from scratch, which is significantly harder.
- Northern Ireland already has a process in place for how this would happen, set out in the Good Friday Agreement. Scotland doesn't, which is why there have been endless arguments about the legality of a second independence referendum called unilaterally by the Scottish government.
- and most obviously, a United Ireland seems to be built on demographics which are trending inexorably in one direction; whereas Scottish independence is not like that, it's more of a "normal" political issue that waxes and wanes with public opinion (and specifically at the moment appears to be waning).
@@danielwebb8402 We see positive signs of an unreligious, unnationalistic future with a mentally healthier new generation of people which is much better educated, not least regarding science, environment and climate!
@@alexpotts6520 The thing that doesn't sit right with me though, is that Scotland voted to remain in the EU, and after the Brexit vote the call for Scottish independence was the largest is has been in decades, and there was a palpable majority for Scottish succession. The call for a reforendum was immense, but if was denied to the Scotts, since if it was given then, the result would've been obvious, which would've been detrimental to the rest of the UK. You're saying that it's waning again, and if that's true, what happened to self determination? It would be so insulting if a couple of years down the line, when all the permanent economic damage and divergence from the EU and subsequent 'forced' integration and alignment within the UK would have made Scottish independence/rejoining of the EU very difficult, for there to be an reforendum then, when the will/spirit of the people has simmered down, almost gone to sleep, by years of perpetuation. Maybe a bit too philosophical, but hopefully you get what I mean.
United Ireland and Scottish Independence is coming!
😂
There is a lot about northern ireland that people just don't understand. The crisis still remains. 🤔🤔
Commenting 4 algorithm
Sounds to me like all solutions lie outside of Northern Ireland. Right?? It’s a world where self-determination is but pretty words on a U.N. declaration.
The solution is a united Ireland. It is not if, it is when.
@@fishyq5077But only when the majority in NI and the Republic want it.
Charles III is sovereign of Northern Ireland.
Ulster says Nooo.
There is no way to keep both sides happy with Brexit as it fundamentally conflicts with good Friday agreements and the goals of either entirely one side or various points of both. Idiocy
Ulster is a province
You can only speak for 6 of them, but... all of Ulster belongs to the republic
From the Atlantic to the sea,
A United Ireland will be free
The only solution is to reunify all of Ireland as it's own sovereign state. As an English descended American I assure you, the Unionists in Ireland are also English Descended just like myself. We called them Red Coats back in the day. They can go back to where they came from and return the land of Ireland to the Irish.
Well said👏
Why don't you take your own advice and return the land to the indigenous American tribles hmmm?. English settlers were in Ireland long before the New World was even discovered so what's your excuse?
Imagine voting against trading with 27 countries as the DUP did? Imagine claiming the union with Britain is under threat by allowing trade with the EU? NI's position in the UK can only change if a majority of the population in NI vote to leave and join with the Republic of Ireland, a main tenet of the Good Friday Agreement, voted for by 95 per cent of the entire island of Ireland, thus the Republic giving up it's claim on the territory of NI. Good enough for the DUP? "NO!!" The DUP voted against the GFA and were routed in the referendum, also the people of NI voted against Brexit despite the DUP campaigning for a yes vote. So who do they represent? If they were being honest they want a return to the NI statelet set up in 1922, a Protestant State for a Protestant People, that was the statement then and that's why the DUP keep saying NO to everything. Now that they have said yes to power sharing with Sinn Fein Donaldson might end up the same as David Trimble who saw the writing on the wall for unionism and stuck his neck out only to be chopped off by rabid loyalists. The GFA stopped the violence, that wasn't good enough for them. Really they are dinosaurs denying the meteor ever fell on them and are an embarrassment to any real and pragmatic politics.
Funnily enough, they do literally deny that a meteor ever fell on the dinosaurs. Those fossils were just put there by God as a test of your faith, don't you know?
"Dinosaurs denying the meteor" is quite the analogy, considering the DUP quite literally do deny the dinosaurs, the meteor, and anything else more than 6000 years old.
Quite the ambitious title!
Brexit is a gift that just keeps on giving. Our grandchildren will still laugh at the political crisis brexit created, since it will not end before 2077
It seems this deal allows NI to suffer the bad consequences (poor quality imports damaging local economy and decreasing quality of life) of the choices of a Westminster government where NI has little voice and no power.
Sounds like a great plan to convince NI that it would be much better off as part of the Republic.