something that not a lot of people if any have mentioned is that anna cut the umbilical cord with the knife she just pulled from the head of a runner. that would introduce cordyceps much closer than a bite on her thigh that would then have to travel through her body and across the cord in a matter of seconds.
Okay hate to break this to you but dr mike is wrong about field medicine we stopped giving morphine out in the field three years ago we give ketamine now because it doesn't inhibit the respatory system.
Dr. Mike is correct because there is no need to move her she was gonna die there was no saving her because she was shot on stomach and it's one of the worst place you can get shot because it's hard to fix it even in ICU let alone outside
22:55 In the game, FEDRA issued news pamphlets where they clearly mentioned the stages of Infected. Considering that the fungus majorly sprouts from the head, and taking into consideration that Joel lived for 20 years or less as a smuggler, he would definitely know.
I wish instead of Dr. Mike telling us about the realism in the context of our world, he would talk about what the character’s options might be in a best case scenario and then go on to what We should do in real life if we’re hurt like that. Still love him though and love all your reactions! Haha love when yall would point out when he got it kinda wrong “Excise me Dr. Mike!” Had a blast :D
The form of the choke depends entirely on the type of choke. There are different methods. If you're doing an airway choke, then yes, you want the forearm across the front of the throat. However, during the blood choke, Joel's positioning was correct. You want the elbow across the front of the throat so that your bicep and forearm are squeezing either side of the neck to cut off the arteries.
Indeed, there's a choke which cuts off the airway and a strangle, which cuts off the blood flow to brain. Strangulation done as demonstrated (and done correctly) will knock a person out in about
The scientist in the cold open of the show was probably referring to mutated versions of the fungi, not the present versions of the fungus. Mutated versions would be harder to tackle with.. Especially considering how rapidly it spread and how the world devolved so quickly for them to even work on a cure effectively
Expanse is also one of the scientifically accurate shows involving space travel, well there are fantastical elements weaved into the premise but the space travel stuff is shown really well
@Cinepals, 20:30 "My blood is medicine" is the lie Marlene told Ellie. Marlene always knew that process to make a cure was more than blood--they had her blood for three weeks and went nowhere with that. Marlene might not have known that Ellie would have to die, but she certainly that that was on the table. Marlene lied to Ellie, that was the only way she was going to get Ellie to sign on to something she already didn't want to do. Marlene made it clear that the Fireflies were going to let Ellie go, and the next thing they did was make her feel like important and like a savior. They made her believe that all she'd have to do was let them harvest her blood and for her to participate in tests. That sounds a hell of a lot better than, the truth. Even Joel thought they'd need more than jest Ellie's blood. He told Ellie after they left Kansas that he imagined the process wasn't as simple as blood. I don't know what Joel was thinking, but I think it was something more painful like them taking bone marrow, but we will never know. Anyway, the blood plot was a lie used to get Ellie to agree to go to the Firefly hospital. Once she was there, they were always going to kill her because the cordyceps they wanted were in her brain. Even Joel knew cordyceps grew in the brain, so that seems to have been common knowledge. Marlene was very careful not to tell Ellie anything about Cordyceps and kept Ellie focused on giving blood.
She didn't lie to "trick" her- they had no medical supplies or ability to test Ellie with what they had at the QZ, they could only monitor her for known basic symptoms + they had to group up the rest of the Fireflies to leave the QZ, which is why they kept her there so long. It's also why they needed to go all the way to Salt Lake City in the first place, so they could find out how to make the cure. Yeah it's common knowledge that it grows in the brain, even Ellie might've known that, but none of those characters are doctors/scientists and truly knew what the cost of making the vaccine would mean on a cellular level. Marlene isn't a mustache-twirling villain that was tricking anyone, she legitimately didn't want Ellie to die, but in the end, she saw value in her sacrifice by convincing herself that it would give Anna, her best friend's death, meaning.
in second game is a place/hospital , where Abi go to take same medicine , and i believe in that place they research the infected and make experiments .
When seeing that seen in last of us show where the doctor explain a fungal infection risk to human and nobody in audience takes him serious I think on news reporters starting to talk a about covit months before 2020 non of them seemed to take it seriously and when it happened those same reporters where in high panic mode.
Dr Mike analyzes these films purely from a medical perspective, its very fun for medical students, nursing students, physician assistant students, CNA's, NP students, etc to be able to learn more about medicine. he 100% is purposely ignoring the context of the situation haha
What Achara said is inaccurate. The correct form for a figure-4 rear naked choke is to actually put the subject's neck in the crook of your elbow, because you are using the elbow as a vice, applying pressure at the sides of the subject's neck with your arm and forearm, cutting off circulation. The more you squeeze, the more effective it becomes. This is very fast, takes around 10 seconds to immobilise the subject, as Doctor Mike said. If you use the forearm on the choke, it turns into an air choke, not a blood choke, which means it can take much longer to work (1-5 minutes)*, and is far more lethal**. While this variation exists, it is not advisable to use it. *The reason air chokes take longer to work is because the subject has to expend all of the residual oxygen in their bloodstream before losing consciousness due to hypoxia. They can still struggle and fight during this time. Every time they manage to take another breath, they get more time. A blood choke is faster because it immediately cuts off the blood supply to the brain, causing loss of consciousness from cerebral ischaemia. **The reason air chokes are more lethal is because releasing the hold doesn't revive the subject. The subject still has no oxygen in their bloodstream. You have to perform CPR or they'll die. In the case of a blood choke, as soon as you release the hold, the subject's brain gets oxygenated blood, so they recover almost immediately, albeit disoriented.
Although I understand that from a medical professionals pov it’s annoying to see medically inaccurate depictions in Tv shows, I feel like many of the scenarios in TLOU felt very natural from a character standpoint. Like Ellie has very little medical knowledge, so she doesn’t know where to inject the medicine. And even though I screamed NOO!! At Joel pulling out the broken baseball bat, I don’t think it’s far fetched that a person who’s in a stressful situation, high on adrenaline and probably in shock would do that.
Btw everyone in the last of us universe should know that cordyceps grows inside the brain. It's never stated outright in the show, but in the game the official name for the disease, is CBI aka Cordyceps brain infection. They couldn't just take samples of her blood because that's not how the disease works. The fungus starts spreading throughout the nervous system and the muscles in the body to puppet around the host, eventually reaching the brain, where it fully takes hold. The reason ellie is immune is because the growth inside her is receiving chemical messengers from her brain telling it that there's no need to grow any further because the host is already "infected". Which is why they need to remove to replicate the messengers.
In real life nature cordycepes doesn’t even touch the brain it encloses the brain in a mycelium shell preventing you and your brain to control your body so essentially you still know what your doing and where you are going but have absolutely no control because cordycepes in reality only invades and attacks the muscular system and major nerve endings mostly the ones that control movement. In the game yes they modify the infection to infect the brain
It is stated outright in the show actually, the scene with Joel in the hospital... So yeah, your comment is a bit unnecessary except for people that aren't paying attention.
@@Osama-KIN_TMZ01 Joel says "it grows in the brain", to which Marlene says "it does". That's about all we get in the show. And apparently alot of people weren't paying attention because I've been hearing people ask "why they don't just draw her blood?" all over the internet. Also this is youtube... 99% of people's comments are unnecessary.
@@MrZomBie775 @Ethen Millard I get that, but still, the way you phrased it in the comment was making it sound as it's a deep reference that no-one knew about from the show... Also no, not 99% of comments are unnecessary, corrections and feedbacks are a thing, like what I'm doing now, did you get that statistic from the same place that told you the show didn't mention the memo lol?
@Casey Muller That’s nice, I have Been diagnosed with a cancer and I will definitely need her help and would also want to know how to get in touch with her. I hope she cures other sickness also?
23:40 but I feel writers do need to do their research regarding medical stuffs because we the audience think that the movie/series have done enough research on these things and if at all we audience happen to have such kinda injuries, would try to treat it in a similar way as a first response. Example in Indian 80s, 90s movies I have seen in multiple movies where a snake bite is treated by sucking the poison from the bite mark, which recently I got to know is not the correct way. I also see memes of hacking computers and databases in movies scenes which is completely bizarre but that I can go along with the story because chances of anyone following the steps shown on screen doing it in reality and able to hack the system successfully is almost impossible. Hence movies/series need to show and say atleast 90% accuracy in medical things.
Tactical Bacon Productions (Imma keep brining that channel up until it's known) talked about how killing Ellie for the cure would have been very overwhelmingly pointless. Resources, tribes, distribution, etc.
His explanation for why dissecting her brain was a bad idea has been what I’ve been screaming about since the game. It makes no sense. In the game it puts it as a confirmed will work thing but I still didn’t agree about it being 100% gonna work with your literal only immune carrier on a end of species level infection.
Yeah it served it's purpose for the story but in reality it makes no sense lol. They have no way of knowing it would work. They would have done so many trials and tests with her and infected patients, like with her blood, before they would even come to the decision to dissect her brain and kill her in the process, that would be the last resort.
According to the doctor. Honestly, I really have to question his medical knowledge here, because a lot of people are taking that aspect for granted. And I am talking about the doctor in the show, NOT Dr.Mike.
i totally agree that the show isn't to be super real... and Joel and Ellie aren't a doctors,,, make sense that they tried to practice medicine. but didn't know better. i don't think the show failed in that... Joel recover, everyone react like Joel is in the video game mode xD we aren't certain that woud damage his organs and seems that he rest for some days... so, chill Dr. Mike :) Dr. Mike was really angry in this video... i don't wanna be is pacient for sure rsrsrs
He is purely using normal situations medical practices. Which is good. But he is a little too harsh and kind of makes me feel like making fun of the stitching scene. Dude, she's 14. She was born in the apocalypse. She went to military school where they made her believe that the infection came from monkeys. How tf she's gonna know how to prepare the clean, properly stitching session. Lol
Sure, story comes first, but especially in medical things shows and movies also have some responsibilties. For example: CPR is pretty much always portrayed completely wrong. They give the person a couple of pumps (or just punch their chest) and either the person comes to live or they call it a day and pronounce the person dead. In reality CPR can be done for quite a long time (we are talking 100s of chest compressions and mouth to mouth/nose, not just 3 to 5 attempts) and still save a life. Drowning victims have been brought back to life after 30 minutes or more of CPR, provided they were cold enough to reduce brain damage. So, showing CPR as something that decides over life or death in 20 seconds is utterly irresponsible. Directors: portray CPR correctly or not at all!
“When your watching an Aaron Sorkin-,” let me stop you there, I would not be, (better example for Jaby’s point is Star Trek.) Check out The West Wing Thing podcast 👍🏼 I have to say, most of the problems I had with the series are also what he pointed out. So that’s cool. The other issues I had are coincidentally similar to Sorkin, (but with less misogyny, lol,) Craig Mazin clearly doesn’t know anything about actual politics, specifically leftist/revolutionary politics, and so he takes the easy way out and makes truisms and the generalizations we know having grown up surrounded by propaganda reality in his shows-The Martian was good because the writer(s) consilted NASA, Mazin could talk to a single leftist, just about any Anarchist or Marxist who has knowledge of theory and those aspects of the series would make it so much easier to stick with the writing. The thing about The Last Of Us tho, it’s so good it surpasses those flaws. I would probably rewatch it as often as I rewatch season one of The Walking Dead or seasons 1-3 of Fear The Walking Dead 🤷🏻♀️ ya know. Still, it is a bit frustrating when Joel starts explaining how the infection moved through the supply chain and then into the baked goods-it doesn’t really make sense. With how fast people turn it would be just as easy and reasonable to suggest that it started in the flour mills and then the infected spread the disease faster than the bombs could stop them. We have so many examples of zombies overrunning places-28 Weeks Later, Fear The Walking Dead, etc.-we would just go along with that explanation rather than get some of us stuck in the show’s supply-chain logic.
Let's all get the baseball bat stuck. And then we wait for what exactly? That a doctor comes by? Boy, this is an apocalypse. You pull the thing out and hope for the best.
with all due respect if i was in the world such as last of us every minute of the life will be spent on how to survive hell with how to do certain things
You people are defending Joel, saying Dr. Mike needs to see this realistically. OK, but why the fuck did joel wrap her foot? It doesn't do even a little bit of any good, and don't tell me he's doing the best he could --- it means he doesn't know anything and the show made a mistake. It wouldn't be hard to find some wood there, Mike isn't asking you to buy a brace. Or if he can't find wood, he should have left her there, not wrapped tape around her foot since it doesn't do anything. He should have known that. Just handwaving and doing something for the sake of camera doesn't mean the show is accurate or even realistic. If joel is medically trained, he must do something keeping in mind his situation and his resources, not act like a fool.
The Fireflies almost killed their golden goose. If their ridiculous theory was wrong, and they kill ellie.. uggghhhh. The show makes no sense. Jaby says writing can ignore science. I disagree. Why can't I demand both good writing and reasonable accuracy or atleast plausibility? I won't demand accuracy if they themselves didn't start their over posturing right from the beginning where the "scientist" explains how dangerous fungi is using the latest buzzword "global warming"(btw global warming was known years and years ago, it's now that all the hippies are yapping about it) and right by the side saying fungi doesn't have a cure which is glaringly false. I wouldn't worry about realism if the show didn't try to style itself as ultra realistic in everything else. If you want to be realistic, do the work. This show earns the badge, but didn't do any work. Fuck this. And Jaby, is science education so bad in america that people everywhere are ok with all sorts of inaccuracies and call it "art"?
thats why i like dr hope, he takes everything into account, including superhuman strength and stuff like that. and hes calm which is already a big thing
The problem here - that apparently no one seems to realise - is that when this happens in real life, people who only watch movies and tv shows like this will perform first aid like they do in the movies, and as a result, the victim will most likely die. That is why it is important that these kind of videos exist
@@th01m3nn you said what exactly I things in real life there's so of us will face this scene and all we know is wrong information that's why it's so important they do the right thing in medical scenes
something that not a lot of people if any have mentioned is that anna cut the umbilical cord with the knife she just pulled from the head of a runner. that would introduce cordyceps much closer than a bite on her thigh that would then have to travel through her body and across the cord in a matter of seconds.
Oh yes! Absolutely! I hadn’t even thought about that!
Agreed I never caught that
dr mike is just saying this from medical perspective....he definitely is not keeping the situation in mind
Just because somebody sucks at fighting in a movie doesn't mean people won't improperly emulate it.
Okay hate to break this to you but dr mike is wrong about field medicine we stopped giving morphine out in the field three years ago we give ketamine now because it doesn't inhibit the respatory system.
Dr. Mike is correct because there is no need to move her she was gonna die there was no saving her because she was shot on stomach and it's one of the worst place you can get shot because it's hard to fix it even in ICU let alone outside
22:55 In the game, FEDRA issued news pamphlets where they clearly mentioned the stages of Infected. Considering that the fungus majorly sprouts from the head, and taking into consideration that Joel lived for 20 years or less as a smuggler, he would definitely know.
Dr. Mike is cool. Really love the questions that he asked that the game and show left unanswered.
I wish instead of Dr. Mike telling us about the realism in the context of our world, he would talk about what the character’s options might be in a best case scenario and then go on to what We should do in real life if we’re hurt like that. Still love him though and love all your reactions! Haha love when yall would point out when he got it kinda wrong “Excise me Dr. Mike!” Had a blast :D
I mean he kind of does both. He gets into the realism while also discussing options the characters should take.
He literally does exactly that, idk what you're watching.
The form of the choke depends entirely on the type of choke. There are different methods. If you're doing an airway choke, then yes, you want the forearm across the front of the throat. However, during the blood choke, Joel's positioning was correct. You want the elbow across the front of the throat so that your bicep and forearm are squeezing either side of the neck to cut off the arteries.
Indeed, there's a choke which cuts off the airway and a strangle, which cuts off the blood flow to brain. Strangulation done as demonstrated (and done correctly) will knock a person out in about
Except he's talking about a magical crack resulting from the position, not the choke itself.
@@ronc5825They are commenting on What Achara said not the doctor.
The scientist in the cold open of the show was probably referring to mutated versions of the fungi, not the present versions of the fungus. Mutated versions would be harder to tackle with.. Especially considering how rapidly it spread and how the world devolved so quickly for them to even work on a cure effectively
The Martian is hell of a good movie. One of my favourite movies of all-time.
Good tv show too
Expanse is also one of the scientifically accurate shows involving space travel, well there are fantastical elements weaved into the premise but the space travel stuff is shown really well
@Cinepals,
20:30 "My blood is medicine" is the lie Marlene told Ellie. Marlene always knew that process to make a cure was more than blood--they had her blood for three weeks and went nowhere with that. Marlene might not have known that Ellie would have to die, but she certainly that that was on the table. Marlene lied to Ellie, that was the only way she was going to get Ellie to sign on to something she already didn't want to do. Marlene made it clear that the Fireflies were going to let Ellie go, and the next thing they did was make her feel like important and like a savior. They made her believe that all she'd have to do was let them harvest her blood and for her to participate in tests. That sounds a hell of a lot better than, the truth.
Even Joel thought they'd need more than jest Ellie's blood. He told Ellie after they left Kansas that he imagined the process wasn't as simple as blood. I don't know what Joel was thinking, but I think it was something more painful like them taking bone marrow, but we will never know.
Anyway, the blood plot was a lie used to get Ellie to agree to go to the Firefly hospital. Once she was there, they were always going to kill her because the cordyceps they wanted were in her brain. Even Joel knew cordyceps grew in the brain, so that seems to have been common knowledge. Marlene was very careful not to tell Ellie anything about Cordyceps and kept Ellie focused on giving blood.
Cordysceps don't grow in the brain. Neurons are sent via the nervous system.
She didn't lie to "trick" her- they had no medical supplies or ability to test Ellie with what they had at the QZ, they could only monitor her for known basic symptoms + they had to group up the rest of the Fireflies to leave the QZ, which is why they kept her there so long. It's also why they needed to go all the way to Salt Lake City in the first place, so they could find out how to make the cure. Yeah it's common knowledge that it grows in the brain, even Ellie might've known that, but none of those characters are doctors/scientists and truly knew what the cost of making the vaccine would mean on a cellular level. Marlene isn't a mustache-twirling villain that was tricking anyone, she legitimately didn't want Ellie to die, but in the end, she saw value in her sacrifice by convincing herself that it would give Anna, her best friend's death, meaning.
Let me just say that we only have a few antifungal. In certain cases fungi can lead to death. Just like toe fungus is really hard to TRULY cure.
18:42 Jaby wanting to invent "Blood Vision."
in second game is a place/hospital , where Abi go to take same medicine , and i believe in that place they research the infected and make experiments .
12:20 funny you mentioned this. In the news very very recently, reports a new fungal infection is found to be medicine resistant. I kid you not.
"Just so know"
-Achara
I can't believe that Dr. Mike would do a reaction with real world problem solving in reference to a completely fictional world Peoops! 😂
I can't believe you don't understand the point of the video
When seeing that seen in last of us show where the doctor explain a fungal infection risk to human and nobody in audience takes him serious I think on news reporters starting to talk a about covit months before 2020 non of them seemed to take it seriously and when it happened those same reporters where in high panic mode.
20:08 Jaby: "Eat butts." Achara: "Oh, yeah." Me: "WORD?!!! Y'all get down like that over there?"
Dr Mike analyzes these films purely from a medical perspective, its very fun for medical students, nursing students, physician assistant students, CNA's, NP students, etc to be able to learn more about medicine. he 100% is purposely ignoring the context of the situation haha
"What are you wrapping?' Lol
DR MIKE is always entertaining.
love these dr mike reactions
What Achara said is inaccurate. The correct form for a figure-4 rear naked choke is to actually put the subject's neck in the crook of your elbow, because you are using the elbow as a vice, applying pressure at the sides of the subject's neck with your arm and forearm, cutting off circulation. The more you squeeze, the more effective it becomes. This is very fast, takes around 10 seconds to immobilise the subject, as Doctor Mike said. If you use the forearm on the choke, it turns into an air choke, not a blood choke, which means it can take much longer to work (1-5 minutes)*, and is far more lethal**. While this variation exists, it is not advisable to use it.
*The reason air chokes take longer to work is because the subject has to expend all of the residual oxygen in their bloodstream before losing consciousness due to hypoxia. They can still struggle and fight during this time. Every time they manage to take another breath, they get more time. A blood choke is faster because it immediately cuts off the blood supply to the brain, causing loss of consciousness from cerebral ischaemia.
**The reason air chokes are more lethal is because releasing the hold doesn't revive the subject. The subject still has no oxygen in their bloodstream. You have to perform CPR or they'll die. In the case of a blood choke, as soon as you release the hold, the subject's brain gets oxygenated blood, so they recover almost immediately, albeit disoriented.
15:30 the baby may have been infected from the knife cutting the umbilical cord.
Although I understand that from a medical professionals pov it’s annoying to see medically inaccurate depictions in Tv shows, I feel like many of the scenarios in TLOU felt very natural from a character standpoint. Like Ellie has very little medical knowledge, so she doesn’t know where to inject the medicine. And even though I screamed NOO!! At Joel pulling out the broken baseball bat, I don’t think it’s far fetched that a person who’s in a stressful situation, high on adrenaline and probably in shock would do that.
Jaby got buff 💪
Dr Mike mad Pedro didn’t really break the guys neck for the show. Haha
More dr mike please 🙏
Btw everyone in the last of us universe should know that cordyceps grows inside the brain. It's never stated outright in the show, but in the game the official name for the disease, is CBI aka Cordyceps brain infection. They couldn't just take samples of her blood because that's not how the disease works. The fungus starts spreading throughout the nervous system and the muscles in the body to puppet around the host, eventually reaching the brain, where it fully takes hold.
The reason ellie is immune is because the growth inside her is receiving chemical messengers from her brain telling it that there's no need to grow any further because the host is already "infected". Which is why they need to remove to replicate the messengers.
In real life nature cordycepes doesn’t even touch the brain it encloses the brain in a mycelium shell preventing you and your brain to control your body so essentially you still know what your doing and where you are going but have absolutely no control because cordycepes in reality only invades and attacks the muscular system and major nerve endings mostly the ones that control movement. In the game yes they modify the infection to infect the brain
Cordysceps don't grow in the brain. They control the nervous system. Which sends neurons to control body parts. Anatomy 101.
It is stated outright in the show actually, the scene with Joel in the hospital... So yeah, your comment is a bit unnecessary except for people that aren't paying attention.
@@Osama-KIN_TMZ01 Joel says "it grows in the brain", to which Marlene says "it does". That's about all we get in the show. And apparently alot of people weren't paying attention because I've been hearing people ask "why they don't just draw her blood?" all over the internet.
Also this is youtube... 99% of people's comments are unnecessary.
@@MrZomBie775 @Ethen Millard I get that, but still, the way you phrased it in the comment was making it sound as it's a deep reference that no-one knew about from the show... Also no, not 99% of comments are unnecessary, corrections and feedbacks are a thing, like what I'm doing now, did you get that statistic from the same place that told you the show didn't mention the memo lol?
Ela dando a vida pra defender as escolhas a todo tempo kkkkkkk, amo.
but Ellie actually isn't Immune she is 100% infected by the fungal infection, so she isn't actually immune
Having to Live with one of the worse sickness can be exhausting but I still have to believe I can be healed.
@Casey Muller That’s nice, I have Been diagnosed with a cancer and I will definitely need her help and would also want to know how to get in touch with her. I hope she cures other sickness also?
@Casey Muller Thank you a lot you are a life saver. I have found her website on the internet.
Dr. Mike talking about weak immune systems
Me with RA: 👀👀👀
Haha Dr Mike is great. Chest compressions, chest compressions, chest compressions! 😂
I am with Achara on this one ..
23:40 but I feel writers do need to do their research regarding medical stuffs because we the audience think that the movie/series have done enough research on these things and if at all we audience happen to have such kinda injuries, would try to treat it in a similar way as a first response. Example in Indian 80s, 90s movies I have seen in multiple movies where a snake bite is treated by sucking the poison from the bite mark, which recently I got to know is not the correct way. I also see memes of hacking computers and databases in movies scenes which is completely bizarre but that I can go along with the story because chances of anyone following the steps shown on screen doing it in reality and able to hack the system successfully is almost impossible. Hence movies/series need to show and say atleast 90% accuracy in medical things.
in the game they already had MRI scans of her brains, blood tested etc.
Tactical Bacon Productions (Imma keep brining that channel up until it's known) talked about how killing Ellie for the cure would have been very overwhelmingly pointless. Resources, tribes, distribution, etc.
you guys should absolutely react to yellowjackets!!!
His explanation for why dissecting her brain was a bad idea has been what I’ve been screaming about since the game. It makes no sense. In the game it puts it as a confirmed will work thing but I still didn’t agree about it being 100% gonna work with your literal only immune carrier on a end of species level infection.
Yeah it served it's purpose for the story but in reality it makes no sense lol. They have no way of knowing it would work. They would have done so many trials and tests with her and infected patients, like with her blood, before they would even come to the decision to dissect her brain and kill her in the process, that would be the last resort.
According to the doctor. Honestly, I really have to question his medical knowledge here, because a lot of people are taking that aspect for granted.
And I am talking about the doctor in the show, NOT Dr.Mike.
Well when you put it like that Joel definitely did the right thing bc them doctors didn’t know shiii lol
You know, there are medical shows that are very dramatic, and medically accurate. They don’t have to cancel each other out.😂
You guys should react to the game theory video on whether or not Ellie was immune, it’s a fun theory!
ruclips.net/video/DOtXhr0EoTU/видео.html
Dr Mike spits facts, these two defend fiction, as if he's not aware that it's just a show/video game.
Birth scene inspired by blade
i totally agree that the show isn't to be super real... and Joel and Ellie aren't a doctors,,, make sense that they tried to practice medicine. but didn't know better. i don't think the show failed in that... Joel recover, everyone react like Joel is in the video game mode xD we aren't certain that woud damage his organs and seems that he rest for some days... so, chill Dr. Mike :) Dr. Mike was really angry in this video... i don't wanna be is pacient for sure rsrsrs
Why don't you guys do a collab with Dr. Mike. That'd be fun!
Dont forget to reaction kdrama Duty After School ..best drama 👍
Interstellar is also accurate.
8:12 is Achara talking about rear naked choke?
Please react to asteroid city trailer by wes Anderson 🙏🙏🙏
He is purely using normal situations medical practices. Which is good. But he is a little too harsh and kind of makes me feel like making fun of the stitching scene. Dude, she's 14. She was born in the apocalypse. She went to military school where they made her believe that the infection came from monkeys. How tf she's gonna know how to prepare the clean, properly stitching session. Lol
Military schools do teach a lot in regard to first aid tho.
Warrior???
Your hand okay jaby?
My fav couple xd (pun intended). Good luck Jaby, not that you need it.
Sure, story comes first, but especially in medical things shows and movies also have some responsibilties. For example: CPR is pretty much always portrayed completely wrong. They give the person a couple of pumps (or just punch their chest) and either the person comes to live or they call it a day and pronounce the person dead. In reality CPR can be done for quite a long time (we are talking 100s of chest compressions and mouth to mouth/nose, not just 3 to 5 attempts) and still save a life. Drowning victims have been brought back to life after 30 minutes or more of CPR, provided they were cold enough to reduce brain damage. So, showing CPR as something that decides over life or death in 20 seconds is utterly irresponsible. Directors: portray CPR correctly or not at all!
These 2 should get married
“When your watching an Aaron Sorkin-,” let me stop you there, I would not be, (better example for Jaby’s point is Star Trek.) Check out The West Wing Thing podcast 👍🏼
I have to say, most of the problems I had with the series are also what he pointed out. So that’s cool. The other issues I had are coincidentally similar to Sorkin, (but with less misogyny, lol,) Craig Mazin clearly doesn’t know anything about actual politics, specifically leftist/revolutionary politics, and so he takes the easy way out and makes truisms and the generalizations we know having grown up surrounded by propaganda reality in his shows-The Martian was good because the writer(s) consilted NASA, Mazin could talk to a single leftist, just about any Anarchist or Marxist who has knowledge of theory and those aspects of the series would make it so much easier to stick with the writing.
The thing about The Last Of Us tho, it’s so good it surpasses those flaws.
I would probably rewatch it as often as I rewatch season one of The Walking Dead or seasons 1-3 of Fear The Walking Dead 🤷🏻♀️ ya know.
Still, it is a bit frustrating when Joel starts explaining how the infection moved through the supply chain and then into the baked goods-it doesn’t really make sense. With how fast people turn it would be just as easy and reasonable to suggest that it started in the flour mills and then the infected spread the disease faster than the bombs could stop them. We have so many examples of zombies overrunning places-28 Weeks Later, Fear The Walking Dead, etc.-we would just go along with that explanation rather than get some of us stuck in the show’s supply-chain logic.
What happened to your hand jaby?
Let's all get the baseball bat stuck. And then we wait for what exactly? That a doctor comes by? Boy, this is an apocalypse. You pull the thing out and hope for the best.
Um Achara you good? 7:15
There are so many wrong things in movies that the best you can do is just go over it an enjoy the movie or series.
The point he is making is that it's 1968 and it probably didn't exist at that time
Lots of people volunteer for vaccine studies. 🙃
Jaby sounds like he knows his stuff about this kind of thing....coming from a guy with a plaster on the palm of his hand ✋ 😮😉😏🤫🤔😬🤤😷🤒🤢🤮🤧🥵🥶🥴😵💀🧟♂️
Live yo life YOLO😂🎉🎉
with all due respect if i was in the world such as last of us every minute of the life will be spent on how to survive hell with how to do certain things
You people are defending Joel, saying Dr. Mike needs to see this realistically. OK, but why the fuck did joel wrap her foot? It doesn't do even a little bit of any good, and don't tell me he's doing the best he could --- it means he doesn't know anything and the show made a mistake. It wouldn't be hard to find some wood there, Mike isn't asking you to buy a brace. Or if he can't find wood, he should have left her there, not wrapped tape around her foot since it doesn't do anything. He should have known that. Just handwaving and doing something for the sake of camera doesn't mean the show is accurate or even realistic. If joel is medically trained, he must do something keeping in mind his situation and his resources, not act like a fool.
If the Last of Us (show and game) was realistic it woulden’t be any fun guys
You guys were so defensive towards the show 😅😅
Jaby is rude to Achara on both of his channels! He tries very hard to not make it obvious!
why do you have a band aid in palm ?
So.. Joel did the right thing
A react video about a react video! What is this, re-ception?
The Fireflies almost killed their golden goose. If their ridiculous theory was wrong, and they kill ellie.. uggghhhh. The show makes no sense. Jaby says writing can ignore science. I disagree. Why can't I demand both good writing and reasonable accuracy or atleast plausibility? I won't demand accuracy if they themselves didn't start their over posturing right from the beginning where the "scientist" explains how dangerous fungi is using the latest buzzword "global warming"(btw global warming was known years and years ago, it's now that all the hippies are yapping about it) and right by the side saying fungi doesn't have a cure which is glaringly false. I wouldn't worry about realism if the show didn't try to style itself as ultra realistic in everything else.
If you want to be realistic, do the work. This show earns the badge, but didn't do any work. Fuck this.
And Jaby, is science education so bad in america that people everywhere are ok with all sorts of inaccuracies and call it "art"?
we are reacting to bunch of people reacting to a person reacting to a vedio where bunch of people reacting to each other on it.
Dr Hope’s Sick Notes has better commentary than Dr Mike tbh. He’s the OG doc who makes these commentaries and Dr Mike never acknowledged him.
A reaction on a reaction? I'm the dude playing a dude, disguised as another dude. I know which dude I am.
I know this is all in fun but 💯 would not like to site and watch this show or any other like it with him 😂
Dr Mike literally proving that Joel made the right choice LMAO
Reacting to a guys reacting lol,nice. I think I will react to you guys reacting to a guy reacting😅
Jaby do u know amir khan had an affair with fatima sana sheik who played hi s daughter in dangal
Well, this should be interesting yet irritating.
Few years from now youtubers be reacting to reaction of..reaction of.. reaction of... reaction to...reaction of some random video.
I really hate these types of videos. I mean FFS it's a fantasy drama, not a fly on the wall documentary after all. lol
cool. no one aksed.
thats why i like dr hope, he takes everything into account, including superhuman strength and stuff like that.
and hes calm which is already a big thing
The problem here - that apparently no one seems to realise - is that when this happens in real life, people who only watch movies and tv shows like this will perform first aid like they do in the movies, and as a result, the victim will most likely die. That is why it is important that these kind of videos exist
@@th01m3nn Yep because we're all going to find ourselves in a situation like this someday.......not...lol
@@th01m3nn you said what exactly I things in real life there's so of us will face this scene and all we know is wrong information that's why it's so important they do the right thing in medical scenes
Hi react to some series
Doctor Mike is angry about a fantasy show. What's new?
Lets just create bullshit and say its fantasy...