'How much of a gun guy are you?' Ian: 'Well I use boxes of cartridges as book holders for my massive library of gun books, does that answer your question?'
The Saint-Étienne manufacture doesn't exist anymore. In France, the government killed the light armament industry. Instead, we bought the HK 416 from the germans which is sad imo. The HK 416 might be a good weapon, but it's just an piston AR-15 and doesn't have a full size barrel and overall compact size unlike the FAMAS thanks to it's bullpup design. The main problem with the FAMAS was the cost of the internal parts. The only thing it needed was a simpler internal design like the croatian VHS 2, even if we had to copy the internal of an AK rifle + the same adjustable stock from the VHS, get rid of the useless bipod, and an AR style ambidextrous safety selector.
Er... that's the point? Eugene Stoner isn't alive anymore, hence "What would Stoner do [if he was still alive and working on the AR15]?" Saint-Étienne does not exist anymore, hence "What would Saint-Étienne do [if they were still around and working on the FAMAS]?"
Stoner 63 a WWMASD project would be really neat. The other day I walked past a bunch of soldiers on patrol (yeah we got our military patrolling the streets, don't ask), most of them had EOTechs reflex sights fitted on their rifles, I would have liked to ask those soldiers about their prefered attachments but I didn't want to look weird...
Look at this idiot trying to distance himself from gun fans because he views them as lesser for having a hobby that is currently culturally negative to be interested in. I see this exact sentiment in hundreds of gun related youtube video comments every single day, as if being a firearm mega fan is somehow bad.
Astute observation, friend...(although Beretta owns a lot more than I’d have guessed). How about the Swiss? Have they already appreciated? My K-31 is much more accurate than me, (& many of the others who have tried it). It makes me feel like a much better marksman than I am, similar to the feeling my Tikka .223 gives me. A Finnish rifle owned by Beretta.
There is something to add on buying a machine gun. Some states don't allow possession of machine guns. So the the first step would be to move to a state that allows it or change the state law.
The best gun cleaning "solution" is hot water. I do a lot of black powder shooting and could'nt live without it. When I was doing my 11 months in national service in Finnish Army, I once cleaned my heavily fouled RK62 (lots of blank ammo!) in hot shower. It was the cleanest gun I have ever seen, and our armory sergeant said: " Yes, clean, but the next time gets you 10 days in the cage!". Oil and lots of scrubbing only after that...
Risto Alanko cool story. I am from Switzerland and if my Stgw90 got really dirty, i used Running Water too. Now im finished with my service, i have my select fire rifle at home, waiting to be castrated when i am about 30 years old, when i take it in to private posession.
Something that becomes very apparent when you look into the history of technology, just in general, the answer to the question "why not earlier?" is almost always metallurgy. More generally you could say it's "materials science" but in practice, before the 20th century, that means metallurgy. EDIT: the history of metallurgy is also the single biggest refutation of the idea that technology was stagnant in the middle ages: the invention of the blast furnace meant that medieval steel was to Roman iron what an AK-47 is to a musket.
JammingWithAkira I think it was a money saving scheme I read some where that the l85 was only supposed to last until 2012 or something but MoD found it cheaper just to upgrade the weapon and prolong it's service life a little longer. Although a friend of mine in the army said their gonna replace it in 2025
30:00 IMO The best bullpup within its own cateory is the P90. Simply a perfect design for a multitude of reasons i would be happy to argue ^^. One may also talk about equaly the RFB for .308 or the new MDR for 5.56.
The little-known K&M M17s beats the RDB, RFB, & MDR. Best trigger, accuracy, & reliability (once the gas is dialed in!) RDB certainly is close as it is cheaper and ambidextrous.
I'd like to add on the point of 3D printing that additive manufacturing is inherently weaker in design than most other methods. In plastic, for example, an injection moulded part can be very very strong because the liquid polymer can cool into a single monolithic piece. In additive manufacturing you have each layer cool individually one on another, which creates a kind of "wood grain" to the final product. The danger of delamination means that extra care has to be put into planning layer directions in stress bearing parts. In that case, something like a single weld makes more sense- like your WWSD lowers. The honeycomb internal is made possible by casting the parts in two halves then welding them. Yes that makes the seam a weak point, but that's better than hundreds or thousands of them in a print.
That's really only with the plastic methods. Metal-based 3d printing tends to not be built up in the same ways, and some methods are a good percentage of the strength of conventional machining parts. Heat treating is likely to be superior with solid parts. For 3d printing to be useful for metal or plastic, you want a part that's either a low production volume, or too complex to economically machine. A barrel is not likely to be one of those, being built around a cylinder. I would think that all the other parts with various machined surfaces that mate which each other would be more likely to move to 3d printing first.
one day Ian is going to be that 100yr old dood that knows EVERYTHING about guns, machining processes, history etc. he's well on his way. Excellent class, bud, the robe has got me cracking up (sips a tea mug). love your show, keep up the good work.
Now Ian needs to adopt a thick English accent (think David Attenborough...nay Jeremy Clarkson), "Today on Blasterpiece Theatre..." :D (Edited, Hope GunFun approves...)
Michael Smith I'm against this for one thing David Attenborough has a standard rule that he can only pronounce seven words out of 10 correctly . I think that he must've had some kind of bet. let's see if I can get away with pronouncing something standard and common like algae or bacteria wrong and make them think I'm right just because I'm British. then I'll say some of the most evil crap ever like you know it be better for the environment of people in Third World countries died . Which of course he has made statements along that nature several different times . He has made some good documentaries but he is pretentious and is evil.
@@GunFunZS words pronounced different from how you pronounce them aren't pronounced wrong. Hes speaking an entirely different dialect. He also thinks all humans are bad for the environment, and hes not wrong
@@philllax1719 I'm not talking about dialects He does pronounce a lot of words completely wrong for any dialect. I think he does it on purpose as a trademark actually.
32:10 The Desert Tech MDR should definitely be mentioned here! I realize it's new and no one has a lot of experience with it, and it's also not a military gun, but it should definitely be a contender! If it can bring Karl around regarding bullpups, it must be good! ;)
I know this is an old comment It's really kind of sad. I have a few old remington shotguns from my grandpa. They are very nice and good quality, with engravings. I don't think I would buy a new remington, but the old ones are very nice. Old being 30-60 ish years old so some are old (late 1950s)
@@kyle18934 there has a been a major shift since about the 80s and really kicking off into the 90s where "long life" products began to have shorter and shorter lives. It's a mixture of it being more economical to produce things of lesser quality *and* people needing to re-buy things more often leads to more sales for businesses.
The biggest thing I’d say for Remington is just pushing quality control as low as possible so the higher ups can make as much money as possible, at least that’s what I experienced at Ruger so I am kind of comparing the two.
Dear Gun Jesus: You have to write a book about mechanics aspects of gun, the how and why of different actions (blockback, gas, ...). With illustrations and diagrams. It looks like nobody written one before, and even Internet is severely lacking in that regard; your videos being the most extensive coverage of the matter I ever found.
Nathaniel Fitch of The Firearm Blog had started a series of articles on all the types of operating mechanisms, but he never finished it; and now he has moved on to work at the Institute of Military Technology, so we'll never see it completed. Here are some of what he did cover: www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/13/operating-systems-101-blowback/ www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/13/operating-systems-101-short-recoil/ www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/17/operating-mechanisms-201-rotary-locking/ www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/17/operating-mechanisms-201-tilting-barrel-locking/ www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/20/operating-mechanisms-201-ljungmann-vs-stoner-direct-impingement/
As noted by others there are a lot of topics to cover and it really depends on how details you want to get. The more detailed you get you end up creating topic specific subjects which are short run, small production engineering books. You tend to not find them easily because maybe it only sold ten books and or locked away in a technical school in one language printing. On the other spectrum you'll find tons of coffee table books which aren't that great but cover the basics, I was looking at one the other day at a bookstore (omg, I was shocked they still exist!--a bookstore not the book).
D Tyle. By "mechanics" I mean mostly actions, but also triggers/receivers mechanisms, magazines (single/double stack, single/double feed), belts, attachment systems for sights, etc. I want to know how they work and how to compare one approach to another.
1.) There is so many ways to make gun work. That making book about most guns "in detail" is next to impossible. About common guns and common knowledge everything is already on internet. Just search for it. 2.) If something is rather modern(meaning after WWI) it will be covered most probably by patents unless it was created during war but at the same time things created during war have "special treatment" and usually there is shit ton of information about them. There must by technical drawings and explanations in them. Also because it's patented it can not be in books. 3.) Problems about how something work ect. Rly problems are almost only with prototype guns(quite often lack of pictures and patents), very old ones(just nobody bothered with pictures and finding patents can be pain in ass) and brand new ones when ordered by government(no patents)
First time I've ever disagreed with you Ian...the AUG series is undoubtedly a better rifle than a famas. More reliable, higher capacity, longer barrel/range. Also the AUG platform is in continued use to this day in various guides, whereas the FAMAS is not used by any large military at this point.
No french military firearm produced in state arsenals has never been a commercial success, it was not the purpose, and there were never real export policy
My understanding of the smoking cap or fez, is that it keeps the smell of smoke out of your hair, much as the smoking jacket keeps it off your clothes. Ian would need a smoking turban.
Given your appreciation of the Famas, i really wonder what you would think of the Croatian VHS-1 and VHS-2 rifles. Having been issued both, I can say that they are a better than I thought they would be, but not amazing. They are an interesting combination of design "inspirations". Heavy as sin, though, and I'm glad I don't have to lug them around anymore.
The Croatians must have really liked the Famas sights when they were designed the VHS. Infact a lot of external elements of the VHS seen to have been inspired by the FAMAS and G36.
The VHS-1 also had the FAMAS style safety/selector switch and Grenade sights. Also noticed that the VHS's use G36 style charging handle, G36 style Magazines and even G36 optics.
the G-36 optics are genuine g-36 optic, that were either removed from G-36 rifles in stock or purchased exclusively and then attached to the pic rail on the VHS-1D1 rifles. I am not aware of how fond people were of this solution. The G-36 dual optic is generally very positively considered in the Croatian Armed Forces, but the VHS-1 had a very high bore offset iron sights and the G-36 optic is quite tall on it's own.
The closest process to 3D printing in those terms, is the lost wax process. My father used to work in that field and it was widely used in the Swiss arms manufacture to get the precision of milling with the capabilities of casting.
9 Hole's video on the Vector is really interesting, he makes the case that Kriss poorly marketed it as a military SMG when it's real use case, especially in semi is as a vehicle-bourne PDW. No snag points, high capacity, compact, etc. Maybe not the most realistic use case for most people but I think it makes a lot more sense that way.
Is that possibly the answer? As it happens I was looking for an M2 Submachine gun. Could SMGs and MGs be rolled into one, with the M3 being the Grease Gun?
HoNose Muppet no, the M2 smg was briefly in service but was cancelled and replaced by the M3 after a small number of guns were built in '43. ruclips.net/video/so4RZLtFcZc/видео.html is on the predecessor to the Hyde-Inland M2, the Hyde Model 33
I can see an application for squeeze bore in very long range, medium payload, high precision artillery. You kinda need to have a crazy swappable artillery barrel gun, but it still beats a missile in cost. I'M NOT CRAZY
3D Printing / Additive Manufacture / Rapid Prototyping technology has been available for decades. The problem with that tech for firearms production or such, is cost and strength. Every layer is a weak point, which is why manufactures retain use of the technology for prototyping and masters for casting.
Ballistol. Fuckin ballistol on EVERYTHING. I use it on my machineguns, my historical guns, and my wife! It's goot at cleaning, preserving, and lubricating.
Thank you for answering the question about missing US firearm designations, it was something I had been looking for every so often and not getting anywhere. I had seen the the videos on the m15 and m6 though I just wasn't connecting the m6 to the rifle designations.
I'm confused by the TKB-59. Did Korobov try two barrels and decide it wasn't enough? Wouldn't that be more likely to be worth using, instead of the bigger jump from one to three?
Ian, I love you, but please don’t spread that bs 1903 Springfield myth. Bubba blowing up his rifle with hand loads does not mean it’s inherently unsafe. There hasn’t been a failure since the 1930’s
Re: Squeeze or taper bores, the Colt Canada cold hammer forged barrels used in the C7 and C8 series of rifles have a very slight taper to the bore, as well as an in-line forging of the chamber. It doesn't require 3D printing, just a carefully hammer forged barrel around a mandrel with a taper machined into it.
3d printing has been used in a hypersonic engine casing to make cooling passages, but I suspect it isn't particularly pressure resistant. A squeeze bore gun would have to be made out of some new super alloy and require special ammo.
Not to forget to mention that "DP" guns are additionally rendered totally inoperable. Their bolt faces are milled away, the barrel slotted at the breach and further down the barrel, rod inserted and welded solid.
The hk sl7 is a roller delayed blowback in .308. The chamber is fluted to facilitate extraction. I noticed carbon build-up around the chamber. You need to clean it. Awesome rifle, reliable and accurate.
The difference between short-stroke piston and tappet systems basically comes down to where the operating rod is attached: on short-stroke, the op rod is attached to the piston, and on a tappet, the op rod is attached to the bolt carrier. It's that simple. FN's SCAR and F2000 rifles are both tappet systems, and they are easily disassembled in the field for maintenance.
ostiariusalpha Just to be a pedant: What would the G36 family of guns be? There's a connecting rod between the gas piston and bolt, and that rod isn't attached to any of them, it sits in a channel in the receiver.
+That_German_Guy I would still call the G36/SL8 a short-stroke system, since the operating rod is slaved to the piston, even if it isn't mechanically fastened to it.
Odds are unchanged and still claiming that they are the best and most modern . Wait I mean perfection . they will be the only company that hasn't upgraded the chassis and human hand shaped handles .
If the Glock came on the market circa 1986, that's 34 yrs already . And back in the mid '80s , it really was revolutionary . At the time , the original G17 had the second most ergonomic hi cap grip shape, behind only the Browning Hi Power, which held 4 fewer rounds . Before Glock , the baseline comparison was a S&W M459 . Virtually every service-ish pistol since has been designed in reaction to the Glock .
The only example I have seen was in N. Africa, an old German anti-tank gun said to squeeze 40mm down to 37mm. I don't know how it got rusty in the desert.
Thank you for all the answers - learning so much in such a short span of time. I disagree on the FAMAs as the P90 seems better. Not as much damage, less recoil. (student now sits down to be educated)
Hey nice smoking jacket. Like your ammunition book stops too! Ha!! Nice touch. Enjoy your channel I always learn something. It shows you put in a lot of time and research. Thanks!
Ian I love the show and was just curious how and or where you got all this knowledge on firearms and their history, did you go to a school or are self taught?
Hi Ian, Steyr AUG runs the Gas Tappet system, and having used the Austeyr F88 when I was younger, I found it easy to remove, clean and adjust, M1 Carbines from memory have a Gas Tappet rather than a short stroke Piston too, but it's been a long time since our country let us have them in Civilian hands..
Ian, At nineteen minutes why didn't you mention that Japanese semi-auto gas operated Pederson rifle from the mid 1930's trials? You did an episode on that and it was fascinating!
For Milsurps in a humid area I have had excellent luck with a 1 to 10 mix of ballistol/water for the bore after corrosive ammo, just soak the bore really well and use a regular bore brush. Then wipe all the metal with a generous coat of plain ballistol, then store in silicone gun sock. Cut them in sections for pistols. I had a couple guns rust using other protectants such as CLP and regular gun oils, REM Oil sucks for long term protection IMO, but since I switched to Ballistol I haven't had an issue. I just soak a rag with it and after every range session the whole gun gets wiped with it inside and out. For stuff I don't shoot I take them out once a year at least and re-apply the Ballistol. For really expensive stuff I use RIG grease and coat everything in that using one of their RIG Rags or a natural hair paintbrush
Ok for full on gun Jesus next time be in front of both a personal library and a fireplace with robe and pipe and have the pipe lit at least in the beginning
Re machine guns: you are pretty much a fool of you do an individual transfer rather than a purpose made NFA trust. Also you Can fill out the crossing street lines form in such a way that includes multiple states over several months . Most of the people I know who use NFA title II Items do this in advance of their competition season naming all the states they might go to . I.A.A.L.
So I've never been the biggest fanboy for the FAMAS but would you be able to share your FAMAS/specs with Brandon/AK Guy to theoretically 3D print a modern "casing" for the internals which should all be arguably still good? Just curious and obviously RUclips hates the 3D Print + PewPew combo but all the same would love to see a "Mystery variant" video that might appear in the future lol.
Steyr AUG - currently manufactured w/ US-based support, available to the average shooter, lightweight, field-serviceable, cleaner and field-adjustable short-stroke gas piston system, tool-less barrel swaps, modern versions have picatinny rail for choice of optics, built-in collapsible vertical foregrip. FAMAS- hasn't been made in almost 20 years, unicorn bugle-gun for US shooters, dirty blowback system/less reliable, does have a cool bipod though.
Here in s.e. Georgia, it seems to never be dry. One guy showed me his very expensive over and under shotgun. Beautiful, rich blue, engraving with gold inlay. He flips it over, deep rust all the way down, action 'rust welded' and white bleached out wood. He says, "I left it on my truck's carpet. ......Can you 'clean this up ?" ..........I teared up, and it was not even my gun.
![Tee Grizzley - Blow for Blow (feat. J. Cole) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNLN5xsx5dc/mqdefault.jpg)
'How much of a gun guy are you?'
Ian: 'Well I use boxes of cartridges as book holders for my massive library of gun books, does that answer your question?'
MandaloreTheMad true!
Don't forget the secret wall behind this wall which stores even more guns, can only be accessed by pulling out the right gun book
i guess Im kinda off topic but do anybody know a good place to stream new tv shows online ?
@Jackson Jaime I would suggest FlixZone. You can find it on google =)
@Frederick Demetrius Yup, I've been watching on FlixZone for months myself :D
Full Smoking Jacket.
Lmao!
It was my first question. Where do we get that jacket Ian!?
perfect for a cigar
This comment is golden. Ian has the best fanbase
I love that smoking jacket so much
'What Would Saint-Étienne Do?' FAMAS series confirmed for 2019?
An AUG, probably, F90 specificity
The Saint-Étienne manufacture doesn't exist anymore. In France, the government killed the light armament industry. Instead, we bought the HK 416 from the germans which is sad imo. The HK 416 might be a good weapon, but it's just an piston AR-15 and doesn't have a full size barrel and overall compact size unlike the FAMAS thanks to it's bullpup design. The main problem with the FAMAS was the cost of the internal parts. The only thing it needed was a simpler internal design like the croatian VHS 2, even if we had to copy the internal of an AK rifle + the same adjustable stock from the VHS, get rid of the useless bipod, and an AR style ambidextrous safety selector.
Stoner 63 that company form france doesn’t exist anymore
Er... that's the point? Eugene Stoner isn't alive anymore, hence "What would Stoner do [if he was still alive and working on the AR15]?" Saint-Étienne does not exist anymore, hence "What would Saint-Étienne do [if they were still around and working on the FAMAS]?"
Stoner 63 a WWMASD project would be really neat. The other day I walked past a bunch of soldiers on patrol (yeah we got our military patrolling the streets, don't ask), most of them had EOTechs reflex sights fitted on their rifles, I would have liked to ask those soldiers about their prefered attachments but I didn't want to look weird...
Shout out to all those collectors who share their guns so that they can be shown to everyone.
ThrowingItAway not all heroes wear capes
"Everything in firearms design is a compromise"
Oof I'm telling Hk on you
HK compromises on cost.
@@roflchopter11 ?
@@teaser6089 HK can make good gun, but can not have good (=low) price tag.
@@Tunkkis You pay for the quality you get
I am not even obsessed with guns like some people, I just like mechanical things. You make the content interesting Ian thank you.
lIkE sOmE pEoPlE.
Look at this idiot trying to distance himself from gun fans because he views them as lesser for having a hobby that is currently culturally negative to be interested in. I see this exact sentiment in hundreds of gun related youtube video comments every single day, as if being a firearm mega fan is somehow bad.
@@AR15andGOD he pees sitting down.
@@edm192 another deleted comment?
Yet, im the dumb one?
My wife has no interests in guns and watches some of these with me. My kids love Ian's videos
the french, finns, italians, and japanese are all definitely underappreciated in the world of firearms design
Astute observation, friend...(although Beretta owns a lot more than I’d have guessed). How about the Swiss? Have they already appreciated? My K-31 is much more accurate than me, (& many of the others who have tried it). It makes me feel like a much better marksman than I am, similar to the feeling my Tikka .223 gives me. A Finnish rifle owned by Beretta.
There is something to add on buying a machine gun. Some states don't allow possession of machine guns. So the the first step would be to move to a state that allows it or change the state law.
or just don't follow illegal laws like a fascist collaborationist.
Love the ammo box book ends
Ryan Wagner right!!!!
I was hoping I wasn’t the only one to notice
What are the pros and cons of using ammo boxes for book ends?
I worked at a place where we used inert landminnes as door stops. Reason: To hiss off Political vistors.
And a random pistol (Luger?) as well lol.
The best gun cleaning "solution" is hot water. I do a lot of black powder shooting and could'nt live without it. When I was doing my 11 months in national service in Finnish Army, I once cleaned my heavily fouled RK62 (lots of blank ammo!) in hot shower. It was the cleanest gun I have ever seen, and our armory sergeant said: " Yes, clean, but the next time gets you 10 days in the cage!". Oil and lots of scrubbing only after that...
Risto Alanko cool story. I am from Switzerland and if my Stgw90 got really dirty, i used Running Water too. Now im finished with my service, i have my select fire rifle at home, waiting to be castrated when i am about 30 years old, when i take it in to private posession.
In an emergency with a black powder weapon.... pee down the barrel..... cleans it out quick time so you can fire again... lol 🤪🤣😂
FlamingTP if it’s the emergency pee or death as the choices I know which one I am picking... lol 😂
@@luzianwasescha6056 is that a joke or are you really getting castrated
@@AR15andGOD nope, just the rifle to semi auto only😅
Something that becomes very apparent when you look into the history of technology, just in general, the answer to the question "why not earlier?" is almost always metallurgy. More generally you could say it's "materials science" but in practice, before the 20th century, that means metallurgy.
EDIT: the history of metallurgy is also the single biggest refutation of the idea that technology was stagnant in the middle ages: the invention of the blast furnace meant that medieval steel was to Roman iron what an AK-47 is to a musket.
i found a mauser in my grandpas house with 1899 and serbian coat of arms on the reciver
Wow what a coincidence I found my grandpas .762 NATO mag that was issued with his M14 in Vietnam ... still in charger too
do you have a moment to talk about our Lord and savior, Gun Jesus?
Cody Opperman iI
He's the one true White Jesus
Blasphemy! Hr is not a gun Jesus. He is Colonel Jesus Sanders
Hahahaha
Really that bit is the only thing Ian has done that I disliked.
Using ammunition as book ends is an idea I should have had by now...
With what you said about the L85 being too heavy, don’t worry the MoD listened and the new A3 is a whole 100 grams lighter!!!!
I believe it is 100 grams lighter than the standard model with the plastic handguard, it is a lot lighter than the guns with the DD railed handguard.
The L85 is a terrible weapon. I'd rather carry a stick into battle.
gabriel bielawski no you wouldn't.
JammingWithAkira The British army should adopt the c8/c7
JammingWithAkira I think it was a money saving scheme I read some where that the l85 was only supposed to last until 2012 or something but MoD found it cheaper just to upgrade the weapon and prolong it's service life a little longer. Although a friend of mine in the army said their gonna replace it in 2025
30:00 IMO The best bullpup within its own cateory is the P90. Simply a perfect design for a multitude of reasons i would be happy to argue ^^.
One may also talk about equaly the RFB for .308 or the new MDR for 5.56.
@@brianmead7556 pistol calibers are pistol calibers. they dont matter that much.
The little-known K&M M17s beats the RDB, RFB, & MDR. Best trigger, accuracy, & reliability (once the gas is dialed in!) RDB certainly is close as it is cheaper and ambidextrous.
Please do a video on the SMAW spotting rifle if you ever get the chance. A roller delayed primer actuated action, completely insane little gun.
I'd like to add on the point of 3D printing that additive manufacturing is inherently weaker in design than most other methods. In plastic, for example, an injection moulded part can be very very strong because the liquid polymer can cool into a single monolithic piece. In additive manufacturing you have each layer cool individually one on another, which creates a kind of "wood grain" to the final product. The danger of delamination means that extra care has to be put into planning layer directions in stress bearing parts. In that case, something like a single weld makes more sense- like your WWSD lowers. The honeycomb internal is made possible by casting the parts in two halves then welding them. Yes that makes the seam a weak point, but that's better than hundreds or thousands of them in a print.
It depends. the socalled “3d printing” is a class of many different technologies. Few of them are very strong.
Tell that to space X with they're 3D printed super draco engines.
That's really only with the plastic methods. Metal-based 3d printing tends to not be built up in the same ways, and some methods are a good percentage of the strength of conventional machining parts. Heat treating is likely to be superior with solid parts.
For 3d printing to be useful for metal or plastic, you want a part that's either a low production volume, or too complex to economically machine. A barrel is not likely to be one of those, being built around a cylinder. I would think that all the other parts with various machined surfaces that mate which each other would be more likely to move to 3d printing first.
one day Ian is going to be that 100yr old dood that knows EVERYTHING about guns, machining processes, history etc. he's well on his way. Excellent class, bud, the robe has got me cracking up (sips a tea mug). love your show, keep up the good work.
Ballistol is just a great product. I use it all around the house. A non toxic wd40 so to speak.
That's all I use on my PCP air rifles
If there was any further proof needed that Ian reads the comments...
Now Ian needs to adopt a thick English accent (think David Attenborough...nay Jeremy Clarkson), "Today on Blasterpiece Theatre..." :D (Edited, Hope GunFun approves...)
Michael Smith I'm against this for one thing David Attenborough has a standard rule that he can only pronounce seven words out of 10 correctly . I think that he must've had some kind of bet. let's see if I can get away with pronouncing something standard and common like algae or bacteria wrong and make them think I'm right just because I'm British. then I'll say some of the most evil crap ever like you know it be better for the environment of people in Third World countries died . Which of course he has made statements along that nature several different times . He has made some good documentaries but he is pretentious and is evil.
Well that's a eye opener GunFun. I'll admit I haven't seen a recent Attenborough documentary. I'll try to find a different Englishman.
Blasterpiece Theatre. Start it. I double dare you.
@@GunFunZS words pronounced different from how you pronounce them aren't pronounced wrong. Hes speaking an entirely different dialect. He also thinks all humans are bad for the environment, and hes not wrong
@@philllax1719 I'm not talking about dialects He does pronounce a lot of words completely wrong for any dialect. I think he does it on purpose as a trademark actually.
Would be interesting to see some sort of tunable blowback system. Maybe as simple as a changeable weight on the bolt.
32:10 The Desert Tech MDR should definitely be mentioned here! I realize it's new and no one has a lot of experience with it, and it's also not a military gun, but it should definitely be a contender! If it can bring Karl around regarding bullpups, it must be good! ;)
"Yeah long story short Remington aint what it used to be" *sips tea*
I know this is an old comment
It's really kind of sad. I have a few old remington shotguns from my grandpa. They are very nice and good quality, with engravings. I don't think I would buy a new remington, but the old ones are very nice. Old being 30-60 ish years old so some are old (late 1950s)
@@kyle18934 there has a been a major shift since about the 80s and really kicking off into the 90s where "long life" products began to have shorter and shorter lives. It's a mixture of it being more economical to produce things of lesser quality *and* people needing to re-buy things more often leads to more sales for businesses.
@@zakleclaire1858 it's like how laptops last for 3-5 years when they lasted for 10 years before.
For 32 french long ammo try gadcustomcartridges.com. I have one box from them that works very well in my '35 pistol.
The biggest thing I’d say for Remington is just pushing quality control as low as possible so the higher ups can make as much money as possible, at least that’s what I experienced at Ruger so I am kind of comparing the two.
Now I'm really curious about the M60 and the M249 designations.
Wait. You live in Arizona...*gasp* I live in Arizona! *Fangirl screetch*
Heh, Ballistol. Can’t escape that stuff even 100 years after its invention. I guess something about German quality does ring true…
Dear Gun Jesus: You have to write a book about mechanics aspects of gun, the how and why of different actions (blockback, gas, ...). With illustrations and diagrams. It looks like nobody written one before, and even Internet is severely lacking in that regard; your videos being the most extensive coverage of the matter I ever found.
candid moe what do you mean by this "firearm mechanics" could cover so many different topics
Nathaniel Fitch of The Firearm Blog had started a series of articles on all the types of operating mechanisms, but he never finished it; and now he has moved on to work at the Institute of Military Technology, so we'll never see it completed.
Here are some of what he did cover:
www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/13/operating-systems-101-blowback/
www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/13/operating-systems-101-short-recoil/
www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/17/operating-mechanisms-201-rotary-locking/
www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/17/operating-mechanisms-201-tilting-barrel-locking/
www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2016/06/20/operating-mechanisms-201-ljungmann-vs-stoner-direct-impingement/
As noted by others there are a lot of topics to cover and it really depends on how details you want to get. The more detailed you get you end up creating topic specific subjects which are short run, small production engineering books. You tend to not find them easily because maybe it only sold ten books and or locked away in a technical school in one language printing. On the other spectrum you'll find tons of coffee table books which aren't that great but cover the basics, I was looking at one the other day at a bookstore (omg, I was shocked they still exist!--a bookstore not the book).
D Tyle. By "mechanics" I mean mostly actions, but also triggers/receivers mechanisms, magazines (single/double stack, single/double feed), belts, attachment systems for sights, etc. I want to know how they work and how to compare one approach to another.
1.) There is so many ways to make gun work. That making book about most guns "in detail" is next to impossible. About common guns and common knowledge everything is already on internet. Just search for it.
2.) If something is rather modern(meaning after WWI) it will be covered most probably by patents unless it was created during war but at the same time things created during war have "special treatment" and usually there is shit ton of information about them. There must by technical drawings and explanations in them.
Also because it's patented it can not be in books.
3.) Problems about how something work ect. Rly problems are almost only with prototype guns(quite often lack of pictures and patents), very old ones(just nobody bothered with pictures and finding patents can be pain in ass) and brand new ones when ordered by government(no patents)
First time I've ever disagreed with you Ian...the AUG series is undoubtedly a better rifle than a famas. More reliable, higher capacity, longer barrel/range. Also the AUG platform is in continued use to this day in various guides, whereas the FAMAS is not used by any large military at this point.
FAMAS will not be used anymore not because the gun is bad,but simply because there's no armory that manufacturing them....
No french military firearm produced in state arsenals has never been a commercial success, it was not the purpose, and there were never real export policy
I had always wondered about those "missing" weapon designations. Today I learned something new. Nice.
I would love a video on different strange types of ammo. Like caseless rounds and telescoping ammo for example.
Love the outfit! The only thing missing is a Fez.
Iirc that is a official part of the smoking attire.
My understanding of the smoking cap or fez, is that it keeps the smell of smoke out of your hair, much as the smoking jacket keeps it off your clothes. Ian would need a smoking turban.
Given your appreciation of the Famas, i really wonder what you would think of the Croatian VHS-1 and VHS-2 rifles.
Having been issued both, I can say that they are a better than I thought they would be, but not amazing.
They are an interesting combination of design "inspirations".
Heavy as sin, though, and I'm glad I don't have to lug them around anymore.
MatoVuc Better than Beta!
The Croatians must have really liked the Famas sights when they were designed the VHS.
Infact a lot of external elements of the VHS seen to have been inspired by the FAMAS and G36.
The original VHS-1 had Famas like iron sights, though that was not long after replaced with HK style iron sights a la G-36C and G-3.
The VHS-1 also had the FAMAS style safety/selector switch and Grenade sights. Also noticed that the VHS's use G36 style charging handle, G36 style Magazines and even G36 optics.
the G-36 optics are genuine g-36 optic, that were either removed from G-36 rifles in stock or purchased exclusively and then attached to the pic rail on the VHS-1D1 rifles.
I am not aware of how fond people were of this solution. The G-36 dual optic is generally very positively considered in the Croatian Armed Forces, but the VHS-1 had a very high bore offset iron sights and the G-36 optic is quite tall on it's own.
The closest process to 3D printing in those terms, is the lost wax process. My father used to work in that field and it was widely used in the Swiss arms manufacture to get the precision of milling with the capabilities of casting.
9 Hole's video on the Vector is really interesting, he makes the case that Kriss poorly marketed it as a military SMG when it's real use case, especially in semi is as a vehicle-bourne PDW. No snag points, high capacity, compact, etc. Maybe not the most realistic use case for most people but I think it makes a lot more sense that way.
I hope all missing M designations will eventually get a ForgottenWeapons video! :D
I've been trying to find the M1 machine gun preceding the Browning M2. All I get is "did you mean the M1 Thompson?"
Is that possibly the answer? As it happens I was looking for an M2 Submachine gun. Could SMGs and MGs be rolled into one, with the M3 being the Grease Gun?
HoNose Muppet no, the M2 smg was briefly in service but was cancelled and replaced by the M3 after a small number of guns were built in '43. ruclips.net/video/so4RZLtFcZc/видео.html is on the predecessor to the Hyde-Inland M2, the Hyde Model 33
Gun Jesus has spoken!
It shall hence forth be known that the FAMAS is the best!
Is that a Bergmann on the top shelf?
Is Ian wearing a smoking jacket?
He was in the last book review as well.
I believe that’s a “pimp robe” lol
Ian, great detailed explanations on all of these questions. The entire video was very interesting. Keep up the excellent work!
I can see an application for squeeze bore in very long range, medium payload, high precision artillery. You kinda need to have a crazy swappable artillery barrel gun, but it still beats a missile in cost.
I'M NOT CRAZY
3D Printing / Additive Manufacture / Rapid Prototyping technology has been available for decades.
The problem with that tech for firearms production or such, is cost and strength. Every layer is a weak point, which is why manufactures retain use of the technology for prototyping and masters for casting.
The big boom in AM was when a lot of patents ran out at once
this is the only channel where i am happy to watch 1hour long qa video
one hour of plain talking, and i sat and listened every single word of it
Video too short, want more.
your hair is fabulous Ian
I can attest that the M-8 pistol is a flare gun. We have 2 on my ship
The Pipe! You're just spreading it on thick at this point.
He needs a fez or other night cap now.
OMG yes. Fez, please.
Well, it made me go instaclick that thumbs up within half a second of playtime!
Or a smoking cap matching his jacket
Scotch isn't thick, obscure, or French enough for Ian. Maybe Armagnac?
The Pipe, The setting. HE is gun JESUS!!!
Ballistol. Fuckin ballistol on EVERYTHING. I use it on my machineguns, my historical guns, and my wife! It's goot at cleaning, preserving, and lubricating.
Thank you for answering the question about missing US firearm designations, it was something I had been looking for every so often and not getting anywhere. I had seen the the videos on the m15 and m6 though I just wasn't connecting the m6 to the rifle designations.
My brother asked me the same thing, with tanks added into the mix - "How did they go from the M4 to the M60 and then to M1?"
The North Cape book is currently available from CheckPoint Charlie's for $25. I have no idea how much they have in stock.
And update: Looks like it's gone. Wonder if they only had the one copy that I ordered...
I'm confused by the TKB-59. Did Korobov try two barrels and decide it wasn't enough? Wouldn't that be more likely to be worth using, instead of the bigger jump from one to three?
Ian, I love you, but please don’t spread that bs 1903 Springfield myth. Bubba blowing up his rifle with hand loads does not mean it’s inherently unsafe. There hasn’t been a failure since the 1930’s
This video makes me want to design and develop a forward-recoil-operated gun, just so Ian can do a video on what a crap idea it is!
Re: Squeeze or taper bores, the Colt Canada cold hammer forged barrels used in the C7 and C8 series of rifles have a very slight taper to the bore, as well as an in-line forging of the chamber. It doesn't require 3D printing, just a carefully hammer forged barrel around a mandrel with a taper machined into it.
3d printing has been used in a hypersonic engine casing to make cooling passages, but I suspect it isn't particularly pressure resistant. A squeeze bore gun would have to be made out of some new super alloy and require special ammo.
Not to forget to mention that "DP" guns are additionally rendered totally inoperable. Their bolt faces are milled away, the barrel slotted at the breach and further down the barrel, rod inserted and welded solid.
I'm confused, is the scotch in the coffee mug? It has to be somewhere right?
Well done sir you are a scholar and a gentleman!
Is....Is he using boxes of ammunition as bookends?
Watched it from Start to End.
Another Hour well spent on enlightenment.
Thank you!
[slow clap] Well done sir, well done.
The hk sl7 is a roller delayed blowback in .308. The chamber is fluted to facilitate extraction. I noticed carbon build-up around the chamber. You need to clean it. Awesome rifle, reliable and accurate.
The difference between short-stroke piston and tappet systems basically comes down to where the operating rod is attached: on short-stroke, the op rod is attached to the piston, and on a tappet, the op rod is attached to the bolt carrier. It's that simple. FN's SCAR and F2000 rifles are both tappet systems, and they are easily disassembled in the field for maintenance.
ostiariusalpha Just to be a pedant: What would the G36 family of guns be? There's a connecting rod between the gas piston and bolt, and that rod isn't attached to any of them, it sits in a channel in the receiver.
+That_German_Guy I would still call the G36/SL8 a short-stroke system, since the operating rod is slaved to the piston, even if it isn't mechanically fastened to it.
Very nice way to class up the channel Ian. I wonder if he's a Balkan/English man or a Virginia man.
Kyle Curkan virginia I'd bet
So. Sure, balistol is a versitile product. But can you fry eggs with it?
i was really expecting him to say "oh hi, i didnt see you there"
19:26 Makes me wonder how Glock will look 50 years from now.
Odds are unchanged and still claiming that they are the best and most modern . Wait I mean perfection . they will be the only company that hasn't upgraded the chassis and human hand shaped handles .
If the Glock came on the market circa 1986, that's 34 yrs already .
And back in the mid '80s , it really was revolutionary . At the time , the original G17 had the second most ergonomic hi cap grip shape, behind only the Browning Hi Power, which held 4 fewer rounds .
Before Glock , the baseline comparison was a S&W M459 .
Virtually every service-ish pistol since has been designed in reaction to the Glock .
Yes! The pipe and robe!
There was like 500 questions on Patreon. For 25, you took 1h, well I'm ok to watch a Q/A video of 20 hours :)
Ian = Gun Facts Jesus
@Forgotten Weapons Did you get your own chair of wisdom?
We need to set up a living firearms museum , it's a easy and legal way to own full auto guns. Gun rentals... And the guns are way cheaper
Biggest use of squeeze bores I'm aware of were the Little John adaptors for British 2pdr tank and anti-tank guns, used on Tetrarch tanks and similar.
The only example I have seen was in N. Africa, an old German anti-tank gun said to squeeze 40mm down to 37mm. I don't know how it got rusty in the desert.
Spankies basement. Can imagine the occupants.
Thanks for the lesson Ian! I always get excited when I see the Q&A notifications!
I'm at about 50/50 for buying useful guns vs interesting ones. The PS90 and M44 are cool, but not the most useful.
Kriss Vector is fun to own for looks, even if it doesn't have a giggle switch.
Gun Jesus is looking dapper. Thanks for all you guys at Forgotten Weapons and InRange.
Thank you for all the answers - learning so much in such a short span of time.
I disagree on the FAMAs as the P90 seems better. Not as much damage, less recoil.
(student now sits down to be educated)
Dim lighting in background, candles or warm light....to me this is bedtime stories with Ian :)
Hey nice smoking jacket. Like your ammunition book stops too! Ha!! Nice touch. Enjoy your channel I always learn something. It shows you put in a lot of time and research. Thanks!
Ian I love the show and was just curious how and or where you got all this knowledge on firearms and their history, did you go to a school or are self taught?
Hi Ian, Steyr AUG runs the Gas Tappet system, and having used the Austeyr F88 when I was younger, I found it easy to remove, clean and adjust, M1 Carbines from memory have a Gas Tappet rather than a short stroke Piston too, but it's been a long time since our country let us have them in Civilian hands..
Ballistol: Good enough for the Germans since 1905...
the swiss stg57 is also delayed
Ian,
At nineteen minutes why didn't you mention that Japanese semi-auto gas operated Pederson rifle from the mid 1930's trials? You did an episode on that and it was fascinating!
For Milsurps in a humid area I have had excellent luck with a 1 to 10 mix of ballistol/water for the bore after corrosive ammo, just soak the bore really well and use a regular bore brush. Then wipe all the metal with a generous coat of plain ballistol, then store in silicone gun sock. Cut them in sections for pistols.
I had a couple guns rust using other protectants such as CLP and regular gun oils, REM Oil sucks for long term protection IMO, but since I switched to Ballistol I haven't had an issue. I just soak a rag with it and after every range session the whole gun gets wiped with it inside and out. For stuff I don't shoot I take them out once a year at least and re-apply the Ballistol. For really expensive stuff I use RIG grease and coat everything in that using one of their RIG Rags or a natural hair paintbrush
Ok for full on gun Jesus next time be in front of both a personal library and a fireplace with robe and pipe and have the pipe lit at least in the beginning
Also high backed chair and scotch
And a Rhino head over the fireplace
CLASSY AF... I thoroughly enjoy the theatrics. Keep it going. Love the channel
Excellent presentation thank you for your time posting this information.
Re machine guns: you are pretty much a fool of you do an individual transfer rather than a purpose made NFA trust. Also you Can fill out the crossing street lines form in such a way that includes multiple states over several months . Most of the people I know who use NFA title II Items do this in advance of their competition season naming all the states they might go to . I.A.A.L.
So I've never been the biggest fanboy for the FAMAS but would you be able to share your FAMAS/specs with Brandon/AK Guy to theoretically 3D print a modern "casing" for the internals which should all be arguably still good? Just curious and obviously RUclips hates the 3D Print + PewPew combo but all the same would love to see a "Mystery variant" video that might appear in the future lol.
Steyr AUG - currently manufactured w/ US-based support, available to the average shooter, lightweight, field-serviceable, cleaner and field-adjustable short-stroke gas piston system, tool-less barrel swaps, modern versions have picatinny rail for choice of optics, built-in collapsible vertical foregrip.
FAMAS- hasn't been made in almost 20 years, unicorn bugle-gun for US shooters, dirty blowback system/less reliable, does have a cool bipod though.
Here in s.e. Georgia, it seems to never be dry.
One guy showed me his very expensive over and under shotgun.
Beautiful, rich blue, engraving with gold inlay.
He flips it over, deep rust all the way down, action 'rust welded' and white bleached out wood.
He says, "I left it on my truck's carpet. ......Can you 'clean this up ?"
..........I teared up, and it was not even my gun.
30:24 but... the A2 tho..? Quick-change barrel, rails, collapsible grip that can double as a monopod, decent trigger (from what I heard)..