You forgot that while Mahabharat and Ramayan were so-called Hindu story; Indian National Broadcaster Doordarshan also ran TV series on Tipu SUltan, And Mirza Ghalib. The man (B R Chopra) who made Mahabharat also made 'Bahdurshah Jhafar' for TV. BTW, do not forget that 'Mahabharat'- the tv series was written by Dr. Rahi Masoom Reza. A Muslim scholar.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤The last question arguably the most important. Aamir Khan was asked a similar question on the rot in Indian movies and he replied “ people get what they deserve”. Probably said out of frustration but might be mostly correct.
Anchor is very well aware and intellectual. I have a huge appreciation for you, may be i don't agree on every point but i appreciate your depth of knowledge.
Kalyug title ka matlab Kaliyug ki mahabharat. Drawing the parallels from the great mythological epic Mahabharat he shows how timeless the epic is. Even today (means in Kaliyug) story repeats.
Good analysis and discussion by Pakistani guys you are all well knowdgable sensible and indian cinema I am happy to know that your are discussing my hero benegal
Benegal made his first film at the age of 40 and then proceeded to make movies for the next 50 years, gave us great atists like Naseeruddin Shah, SMita Patil, Farukkh Shekh, Om Puri, Shabana Azmi! RIP
It's a welcoming development that Shyam Benegal's work is being discussed in Pakistan. Unfortunately, a deeper and proper understanding of the real significance of Shyam Benegal's socio-political relevance of Shyam Benegal's work is commendable despite being shallow. Understanding of Benegal's superb depiction of the realities of the period & times that he selects as the backdrop of his films is superficial. Pakistani society may not exactly be like India's nevertheless, the basic problems and issues of both countries; such as the rich & poor schism, class struggle, exploitation by the rich & powerful class, etc.
Seeing the number of people in the audience in the capital of Pakistan, one can understand the state of the Pakistani film scene! Where are the youth? Is there no film school in Islamabad? Are no film courses offered in the university there? I feel embarressed watching this program with only a handful of interested participants, a program about the work of a great Indian film director, a great South Asian filmmaker recognized by the world for his art but seemingly unheard of and his brilliant work unseen in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. This is a shame! But I must add, we'll done Black Hole for honouring one of India's film heroes 🙏🇮🇳
It is ridiculous to say that Ramayan and Mahabharat should not be screened on national TV because India is a secular state. A secular state is restricted to the affairs of the administration of the state whereby the state should not discriminate on the basis of religion. Nothing more, nothing less. A secular state does not mean it should act like a communist state whereby religion should be untouchable.
What is shocking is the audience number at this most wonderful event. there is truly no hope for Pakistan intellectual life
Typical Pakistani Lahori Churan aur Rawalpindi manjan 😂😂
You forgot that while Mahabharat and Ramayan were so-called Hindu story; Indian National Broadcaster Doordarshan also ran TV series on Tipu SUltan, And Mirza Ghalib. The man (B R Chopra) who made Mahabharat also made 'Bahdurshah Jhafar' for TV. BTW, do not forget that 'Mahabharat'- the tv series was written by Dr. Rahi Masoom Reza. A Muslim scholar.
Thank you very much for arranging this beautiful programme on legendary film maker Shyam Bengal . Thanks a lot.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤The last question arguably the most important. Aamir Khan was asked a similar question on the rot in Indian movies and he replied “ people get what they deserve”. Probably said out of frustration but might be mostly correct.
Anchor is very well aware and intellectual. I have a huge appreciation for you, may be i don't agree on every point but i appreciate your depth of knowledge.
Excellent discussion, thanks
Very good discussion. I learnt a lot by your talks. Thank you so much. Keep it up please.
Kalyug title ka matlab Kaliyug ki mahabharat. Drawing the parallels from the great mythological epic Mahabharat he shows how timeless the epic is. Even today (means in Kaliyug) story repeats.
Manthan is a story of world's largest and the most successful co-operative movement, AMUL.
AMUL's gross turnover in 2024 was INR 128 billion
Good analysis and discussion by Pakistani guys you are all well knowdgable sensible and indian cinema I am happy to know that your are discussing my hero benegal
Thanks to TBH for this most beautiful and enriching discussion. Sharing it with like minded souls in India and abroad
great tribute a great filmmaker.. audience may be few ppl...your effort is great...keep it up
Benegal made his first film at the age of 40 and then proceeded to make movies for the next 50 years, gave us great atists like Naseeruddin Shah, SMita Patil, Farukkh Shekh, Om Puri, Shabana Azmi! RIP
Congratulations on 100K. Well deserved.
Good effort but it is sad that there is no audience . what it shows is stark reality of Pakistan.
Thanks to TBH for a session on Sir Shyam Benegal. But the vacant seats is little disappointing. Anyway thanks. With love from New Delhi, India.
It's a welcoming development that Shyam Benegal's work is being discussed in Pakistan. Unfortunately, a deeper and proper understanding of the real significance of Shyam Benegal's socio-political relevance of Shyam Benegal's work is commendable despite being shallow. Understanding of Benegal's superb depiction of the realities of the period & times that he selects as the backdrop of his films is superficial. Pakistani society may not exactly be like India's nevertheless, the basic problems and issues of both countries; such as the rich & poor schism, class struggle, exploitation by the rich & powerful class, etc.
An excellent tribute to a legendary Shyam Benegal.
If people are fans here of story driven cinema and don't mind reading subtitles I'll recommend y'all to watch malyali cinema.
Seeing the number of people in the audience in the capital of Pakistan, one can understand the state of the Pakistani film scene! Where are the youth? Is there no film school in Islamabad? Are no film courses offered in the university there? I feel embarressed watching this program with only a handful of interested participants, a program about the work of a great Indian film director, a great South Asian filmmaker recognized by the world for his art but seemingly unheard of and his brilliant work unseen in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. This is a shame! But I must add, we'll done Black Hole for honouring one of India's film heroes 🙏🇮🇳
Heartening to see this❤
Bhumika was based on the life of well-known Marathi stage and screen actress of the 1940s Hansa Wadkar
Bravo Team The Black Hole
👏👏👏
Attendance tells us a lot about where Pakistan is currently intellectually.
😔
Very nice video
Sad to see vacant seats 😢
Bahtreen Season- Great Work TBH 😊
Audience participation & attendance is extremely poor, I hope many more Pakistanis watch this show and enjoy
Interesting fact: Guru Dutt was his cousin
It should be bit louder sound.
1:11:08 Salman Khan Amir Khan saif ali khan sharukh Khan are top lvl actors in India but not a single hindu star in Pakistan so shame
Ankur was Shabana's first movie as well
50:49 😂agar hindustan me Mahabharata or ramayan nahi banegi tho kya islamic desho me banegi?
Goa se salaam. Congratulations to TBH for hitting the 100K mark. Also for timely and excellent remembrance of Shyam Benegal and his films.
Salim, ha ha ha you have adopted a very funny fake name !!
It is ridiculous to say that Ramayan and Mahabharat should not be screened on national TV because India is a secular state. A secular state is restricted to the affairs of the administration of the state whereby the state should not discriminate on the basis of religion. Nothing more, nothing less. A secular state does not mean it should act like a communist state whereby religion should be untouchable.
Bhut accha prayas
1:20:25 secular word illigally edit in India constitution in 1970
50:49 😂 ab hindustan me Hindu apne serial bhi na banaye?
پچیس تیس لاکھ کے شہر سے دس بندے آۓ ہیں سنجیدہ آڈینز کی حالت دیکھیے 😢
Indian film history Aur personalities Ko apna bol raha hai … Kya ghatiya adami hai ye ..
Why is there so much negativity in your comment? Probably a robo-response by a troll.
Wah what a crowd there is? That's why pakistan lost all intellectual property.
ankur ka matlab hai paida hona…