Every time I listen to not just this song but the entire album I think, how can you be in that much pain and manage to create something this beautiful out of it. Well done Peter, well done.
Just learned of this song today, and after hearing the original, I feel this is the best version. So tender and poignantly phrased. I'm still not sure I understand the lyrics, but will let the song settle around me until I do.
This is the best Peter Gabriel ´ s voice and interpretation of this song , I like the chorists’s voices a little less ... if we could mix this Peter ´s version with Sinead O’Connor’s version of the woman part it would be a feast for my ears and my heart !
@@melbae21 Agree on both counts. With the backing vocalists, I think Ana's voice is fine. I am not a fan of Melanie's voice, and that's the more prominant one you hear of the two singers. But you can't fault a dad for wanting his daughter on stage with him. I like Sinead's vocals on this song but I prefer Paula Cole's even more.
the chordal structure reinterpretation was much unexpected. i thought i was just gonna hear what PG sounds like more recently, and this was a real treat -- although i prefer the earlier version. still, very well done.
Heartstoppingly beautiful and melancholic
Truly one of the best songs he’s ever written.
What a fabulous voice he has. No one else could sign this
That plaintiff wail..Shatters me every time.
Every time I listen to not just this song but the entire album I think, how can you be in that much pain and manage to create something this beautiful out of it. Well done Peter, well done.
Pain? Can you pls tell me more on that? Why PG is not any releasing any new album...
On which Album is this Song?
@@katharinagschwantner1779 Us, released in 1992
@@jyothsna231He has now 😊
@@Musicdok yes he did... bright and darker!
Unico penso che più canta e ci stupisce sempre più questo brano poi incredibilmente emozionante.🎉❤❤❤❤❤
Beautiful. Rest in peace Sinead.
Just learned of this song today, and after hearing the original, I feel this is the best version. So tender and poignantly phrased. I'm still not sure I understand the lyrics, but will let the song settle around me until I do.
Amazing poignant version of one the most beautiful songs ever. Thank you for so much Peter Gabriel ❤️🙏
This is the best Peter Gabriel ´ s voice and interpretation of this song , I like the chorists’s voices a little less ... if we could mix this Peter ´s version with Sinead O’Connor’s version of the woman part it would be a feast for my ears and my heart !
@@melbae21 Agree on both counts. With the backing vocalists, I think Ana's voice is fine. I am not a fan of Melanie's voice, and that's the more prominant one you hear of the two singers. But you can't fault a dad for wanting his daughter on stage with him. I like Sinead's vocals on this song but I prefer Paula Cole's even more.
Concordo da emozione incredibilmente
I needed this song so badly tonight 😢 Sometimes it feels like I just can't go on.
I hope you are doing OK. 🙏
I wish I could thank this man for inspiring me the way he has as an artist. You sir are a legend💕🙏
Ich liebe deine Stimme Peter du bist ein so toller Musiker und Künstler ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Exellente
This are medicine songs. What a pleasure! Thank u Peter Gabriel
Love the combination of Peter with the symphony orchestra on this beautiful song.
HIS VOICE IS STILL ABSOLUTELY LOVELY!❤
Amazing even today. Talent at its best
Great rendition of a great song.
Classic!
Magical, memorable, emotional and powerfully captivating 🙏
Wow! No words!
Absolutely beautiful
omg what a fine and gentle way to interprete that song..
One of the greats, thanks for posting this gem 👍🏽
Great as usual! I love it! Listening again and again!
Amazing . Never fails ❤️
3:50
i think i had an eargasm
I am out of words indeed🤗🤗🤗 the crown is yours👑
Oooooh Mr Gabriel 😊😊😊❤such beauty
😭😭😭shedding tears
Beautiful!
Madre mía que maravilla
Thank you so much for posting!
Peter is so einmalig 🔥💪💚
Purely angelic
Peter signore della leggenda
Biutiful
Beautiful
All the while, the distance grows between you and me......I do not understand.......dam that makes you think about life and what you have.
the chordal structure reinterpretation was much unexpected. i thought i was just gonna hear what PG sounds like more recently, and this was a real treat -- although i prefer the earlier version. still, very well done.
Masterpiece
fantastica . Grazie per averla postata
Gratidão 🙏
Geniusz❤️❤️❤️❤️
Omg
Incredible - curious about where abd when this performance took place - any info ?
❤️
What a stunning rendition. Thank you for posting. Is this at Verona?
♥
Who's that singer beside ane brun?
Melanie Gabriel, Peter's daughter
😋
Is Peter crying?
The songs about Peters wife cheating on him and his regrets, so im sure this song makes him emotional
Not good without Sinead
Biutiful
Beautiful
Beautiful
Biutiful
Biutiful