Can the UK repair its relationship with the EU?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 138

  • @JohnnyinMN
    @JohnnyinMN 15 дней назад +10

    Relations can be repaired. ‘Rejoining’ cannot. The British need to grow up and move on with whatever is left of the country.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 13 дней назад +2

      The UK government is not asking to rejoin, which is just as well given some of the infantile comments scattered on these comments pages!

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 13 дней назад +1

      We did grow up and move on. We decided we didn't want to be in this organization.

    • @hubert19831
      @hubert19831 13 дней назад +1

      What's so special about EU?

    • @nanakonadu-
      @nanakonadu- 12 дней назад +4

      ​@@Sjb-on5xt
      So why do we still hear from British people about Brexit regret,
      And how the EU is treating the British unfairly, etc, almost on a daily basis?
      Enjoy your choice and
      Continue moving on,

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 12 дней назад

      @@nanakonadu- There no regret on leaving the EU. A decision that was well overdue. The only caveat is we didn't leave it completely, signing up to the TCA. On leaving there should've been no deals, just leave.

  • @renard8137
    @renard8137 13 дней назад +7

    No, beyond repair.

  • @antonio3220
    @antonio3220 13 дней назад +13

    We don't want the UK back in!

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 13 дней назад +4

      The feelings are quite mutual from the UK.

    • @antonio3220
      @antonio3220 13 дней назад

      @Sjb-on5xt your country is a third world ****hole. Truly the first Islamic country with a nuclear weapon

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 12 дней назад

      Who is 'we'? Making generalisations about an entire nationality is straight out of the Farage playbook, and makes you no better than the likes of him.

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад +1

      @jonphoenix I never heard of anyone here in the EU who wants the UK back. And also remember that it just needs one country's veto against an application from the UK and the thing is done. So definitely no, we do not want the UK back.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 8 дней назад

      @Harry-tb8yo You're somewhat jumping the gun, the UK government is not asking for EU membership. Until it makes such a request (years away at least), there is nothing to veto. A recent poll by YouGov and Datapraxis for the European Council of Foreign Relations suggests that voters in the EU and UK are far more willing to forge closer ties than politicians/officials in Brussels and London are. So there is far more nuance to 'we do not want the UK back' than your comment implies.

  • @ab-ym3bf
    @ab-ym3bf 13 дней назад +4

    "they've been filling their diaries with visits to Brussels"
    Which is not an indicator of them wanting to repair relations. The Uk so far has shown zero effort in wanting to actually repair relations. the new ukgov hasnt made a single step towards implementing the WA and TCA, have turned down offers of closer cooperation, even soured negotiations about program participations with "demands" and lower contribution requests, have not named a single person for the Uk contingent of the body supervising the TCA.
    Their filled diaries are for photo ops, free lunches, demands and divide and conquer tactics.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 13 дней назад

      A bit simplistic. There are disputes with elements of the WA and TCA. The EU have also made 'demands', which is normal for the start of any negotiation. Come back in a year or so, things will probably look a lot warmer.

    • @ab-ym3bf
      @ab-ym3bf 12 дней назад

      @jonphoenix nothing simplistic was said in my post. You on the other hand come up with "demands" for negotiations, where no negotiations are on the calender.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 12 дней назад

      @@ab-ym3bfA UK-EU summit is in the calendar for spring 2025, there will be negotiations as part of that.

    • @Jordon168
      @Jordon168 12 дней назад

      We (UK) have shown a clear intent to repair our relations with the EU. The UK and the EU have agreed to hold annual summits starting this year signalling a mutual desire to enhance cooperation. Starmer was invited to attend an EU leaders meeting back in February marking the first such participation by a UK leader since Brexit. This invitation reflected a thaw in UK-EU relations and a willingness to engage in strategic cooperation.

    • @Jordon168
      @Jordon168 12 дней назад

      @@ab-ym3bf Your statement is very much simplistic because you have completely dismissed all UK government actions as purely for “photo ops” free lunches, demands and divide and conquer tactics. Yes okay there are valid criticisms about the UK’s post-Brexit approach but painting all efforts with such a broad brush completely overlook areas where progress has been made or where genuine efforts to engage actually exist. You’re statement does not account for more recent efforts by the UK to engage with the EU such as agreements to participate in Horizon Europe the planned annual summits starting in 2025 and discussions around economic and trade renegotiations. These steps indicate some level of intent to engage constructively which you’re statement ignores.

  • @artturretje423
    @artturretje423 12 дней назад +1

    Main Lesson Identified: don't trust populist politicians. Remember that Boris Johnson bus with the slogan of so many million pounds for NHS...

  • @jonphoenix
    @jonphoenix 13 дней назад +2

    I'm an optimist, and am glad to see the new UK government make steps to improve relations with the EU. I'm sure it will take time, but any new agreements will benefit the UK and EU for the longer run.

    • @samhartford8677
      @samhartford8677 13 дней назад +1

      We in the EU invest 1% of our GDP to have the power to make deals that are in our interest. We are not going to give up on that investment, because you in the UK enjoyed blaming us for all your problems. So, basically, after your idiotic government gave up its meager cards, all deals will only be if they are in our interest. You do not have the power to get us to make agreements that are not in our interest. Sorry, but this is just how international relations function. You can wait for your special relationswhip with the US and see how well it functions.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 12 дней назад

      @@samhartford8677 All governments and organisations negotiate in their own interest, this is not exclusive to the EU. You seem to just have an axe to grind against the UK. Fortunately, cooler heads than you in the EU will negotiate a pragmatic way forward. There are still mutual interests with fishing, security/defence, youth exchange programme, and (probably in the longer term) economic/financial cooperation. Hope that closer cooperation doesn't disappoint you 👍

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад +1

      The EU made it clear that it is very satisfied with the TCA as it is right now. Therefore I don't know what kind of agreements you talk about that should benefit the EU and the EU, other than the current TCA.

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад +1

      @jonphoenix Security and defense agreements won't give the UK any kind of easier access to the single market. The UK government still rejects the EU's proposed youth mobility scheme so I don't know where you get the idea from that youth exchange programs are of mutual interest. Obviously they are not. Economic cooperation is covered by the TCA. Financial cooperation aka financial services have deliberatly been excluded from the TCA as it is not in the EU's interest to have these carried out in a third country.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 8 дней назад

      @ I guess time will tell, but it's still the early stages of the so-called 'reset' and any negotiations that form part of this. UK-EU interests are not fixed and can change, and initial negotiation positions can soften. Let's wait and see what happens next.

  • @asoutoimporters8383
    @asoutoimporters8383 13 дней назад +2

    Not interested in joining. Get lost labour

  • @bluskies1000
    @bluskies1000 3 дня назад

    I answered a question like this somewhere else.
    There is talk of a North American Union, it could include the UK and be called the North Atlantic Union :) Then expand the economy would be the name of the game.

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад

    EU does not need agricultural products from the UK unless their pickers can return to the kingdom.

  • @Shortbaldandbroke
    @Shortbaldandbroke 12 дней назад

    An EU and UK association agreement would help massively. UK pays in get the trade, accepts free movement but can continue trading with others and does not have to implement all laws. It is the only way otherwise cozy up to Trump and become the 51st state. There are no other options.

    • @stephenpockley5665
      @stephenpockley5665 11 дней назад

      never having FOM again

    • @Shortbaldandbroke
      @Shortbaldandbroke 10 дней назад

      @@stephenpockley5665 Then continue to suffer.

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад

      Third countries cannot join the single market. Only EU and EFTA members can. UK is not a member of any of them and won't become that in the foreseeable future. So what you call an option is in reality no option.

  • @chrismitchell4622
    @chrismitchell4622 15 дней назад +8

    UK needs to concentrate on global trade and totally ignore the EU accept through NATO!

    • @peter1.f.t.p275
      @peter1.f.t.p275 13 дней назад +1

      VOLLIDIOT

    • @Adam_Malcher
      @Adam_Malcher 12 дней назад

      @@chrismitchell4622 Fantastic idea. It will easily beat China, India or US alone. Easy peasy lemon squeezy.
      In what year you are living?

    • @Adam_Malcher
      @Adam_Malcher 11 дней назад

      @@paullarne Have you seen any economic data regarding your country recently? Please first take a look and argue later. Apparently Boris is still living in your head and telling you things that are not real.

    • @Adam_Malcher
      @Adam_Malcher 11 дней назад

      @@paullarne Sure. Because we all know that EU consist only of Germany and France. I can asure you that there are few more countries with better economy results than UK.

  • @asoutoimporters8383
    @asoutoimporters8383 13 дней назад +4

    We voted to leave

  • @Shortbaldandbroke
    @Shortbaldandbroke 12 дней назад

    Any Mobility scheme not open to all ages will be dealt with, with legal advice.

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад

    Farage should be like Boris and among others Reps behind bars

  • @cathalduffy1618
    @cathalduffy1618 15 дней назад +7

    Implement the TCA in full before the UK talks about anything else especially more cherry picking.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 13 дней назад +2

      Yes it's only the UK who ever cherry picks, no other country or organisation does this 🤣

    • @cathalduffy1618
      @cathalduffy1618 11 дней назад

      @paullarne This is incorrect. The UK keeps trying to cherry pick a deal it has already ratified in government and still has not implemented in full. Their is no easy way around that. 🎉

    • @cathalduffy1618
      @cathalduffy1618 11 дней назад

      @paullarne Again incorrect . So let's disagree and then let's see what happens. I can see the WTO getting involved in this one .

    • @cathalduffy1618
      @cathalduffy1618 11 дней назад +1

      @paullarne Not with a UK economy that has basically been stagnant for 14 years . The UK has nothing to offer the EU.

    • @cathalduffy1618
      @cathalduffy1618 11 дней назад

      @paullarne If you still continue with below par English politicians you Will end up in a IMF programme.

  • @intertextuality
    @intertextuality 3 дня назад

    We don't want the UK back in EU

  • @JN-om6rw
    @JN-om6rw 4 дня назад

    AfteR they see that they are getting nowhere with the Trump government the UK might be sufficiently grounded to seek a deal with the EU

    • @bluskies1000
      @bluskies1000 3 дня назад

      There is talk of a North American Union, it could include the UK and be called the North Atlantic Union :)

  • @chelolevine397
    @chelolevine397 14 дней назад

    We need a referendum to know what the British public want. Then move all together towards the results of the referendum, whatever the results are!!

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 13 дней назад +1

      We already had 1 referendum and 2 elections on the EU to know the British public wanted out.

    • @franciscouderq1100
      @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад

      Again !!! Why u didn’t have enough with rhe last one ? 🤣🤣🤣

    • @nanakonadu-
      @nanakonadu- 12 дней назад

      You have had One in 2016, and the same thing was said,
      Now you want another referendum ?
      Just make up your minds

  • @JN-om6rw
    @JN-om6rw 4 дня назад

    Maybe (SM) Single Market or (CU) Customs Union only

  • @michaeldonovan6076
    @michaeldonovan6076 12 дней назад +1

    Britain without question must seat itself at the european round table,
    Trade is vital for jobs stability freedom of movement security Britain must hold a referendum its the peoples choice,
    Relying on the US,,never Trumps a putine lover.

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад

    That woman is talking a lot of nonsense as well.
    Why would the UK more in favor of trading with the US than its large nearest neighbor the EU 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

    • @bluskies1000
      @bluskies1000 3 дня назад

      Because there is greater profit trading with the USA?

  • @Candyfloss119
    @Candyfloss119 7 дней назад

    Jim allistair doesn’t understand anything 😆

  • @petergreenwood7731
    @petergreenwood7731 14 дней назад +3

    The EU was a trade bloc.
    Its now a vindictive military bloc
    Trading R resources for U (Donbas) has not worked.
    Now they face resource poverty
    R and the EU prospered, they had disputes but it worked.
    Guess who LITERALLY blew it up?

    • @peter1.f.t.p275
      @peter1.f.t.p275 13 дней назад +1

      VOLLIDIOT

    • @Adam_Malcher
      @Adam_Malcher 13 дней назад +1

      EU is a military bloc you say? And how many generals, tanks or planes does it have?
      Dear Peter. You are talking nonsense and making a fool of yourself. Please contact your psychiatrist asap.

    • @franciscouderq1100
      @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад +1

      EU is not only a Trade Block read the Treaty of Rome and stop talking nonsense while making a fool of yourself !

    • @michaeldonovan6076
      @michaeldonovan6076 12 дней назад

      Your talking about Nato silly person,,Britain is Nato,,so is the US whom created Nato,,don't think for a minute Nato & Europe are the same,,get real educate yourself,
      Britain is in collapse you need Europe open borders free trading and saving 100B plus per year,
      Think jobs,think trade,think education, that's Europe,
      Nato is the what your talking about,,that's a different organization, Nato is member country's whom join to create security from Russia,China,India get the picture you get educated my friend,,its 2025

  • @khairulnaeim756
    @khairulnaeim756 14 дней назад

    The way he talks... like simple things...

  • @Peterthegreat1234
    @Peterthegreat1234 8 дней назад

    Better be prepared for some serious groveling.

  • @franciscouderq1100
    @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад +1

    I less and less like and approve VdL role at the EU. Way to close to the US and Uk and more and more “german” in her way to do things. She is becoming a liability.

  • @taniaduenas4283
    @taniaduenas4283 15 дней назад

  • @peter1.f.t.p275
    @peter1.f.t.p275 13 дней назад +3

    So you are still trying to CHERRYPICK

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 13 дней назад

      You're acknowledging that the rest after cherry picking isn't that attractive.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 12 дней назад +1

      Every government and organisation cherry picks when it suits them.

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад

      @jonphoenix And the EU is no more interested in UK's attempts to cherry picking.

  • @maxharbig1167
    @maxharbig1167 14 дней назад +2

    Of course the UK can repair its relationship with the EU. All it has to do is fulfill its obligations under the WA, NIP and TCA and we're all pals together ain't we?😀😀

    • @Sjb-on5xt
      @Sjb-on5xt 13 дней назад

      Yes quite, it was a botched up Brexit. All these are destined to be scrapped.

    • @jonphoenix
      @jonphoenix 13 дней назад

      I think we can be a bit more ambitious than that 😀

    • @franciscouderq1100
      @franciscouderq1100 12 дней назад

      Got to be 2to Tango, tho

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад

      @jonphoenix Maybe the EU is not interested in the UK's "ambitions" to cherry pick again. That's over.

  • @iancoles1349
    @iancoles1349 13 дней назад

    Uu no

  • @michaeldonovan6076
    @michaeldonovan6076 12 дней назад

    Britain needs to recooperate per year the loss of a 100B plus
    This will without question get Britain back on track,
    Britain needs to freely trade without borders,

    • @Harry-tb8yo
      @Harry-tb8yo 8 дней назад

      @@paullarne Yes, for the EU.

  • @HassanHosseini128
    @HassanHosseini128 13 дней назад

    What are they laughing at?

  • @Magdi-c5p
    @Magdi-c5p 9 дней назад

    No coming back to EU he is day dreaming

  • @khairulnaeim756
    @khairulnaeim756 14 дней назад +1

    Not so easy...hmm..none both can restore it back...a child play become disaster...X🥸