Becker BK7 VS KA BAR fighting knife

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 137

  • @SaaltyBravo
    @SaaltyBravo 5 лет назад +10

    the Becker BK7 is the Only knife you'll ever need and it'll guaranteed outlive you. But I have both of these knives and I love both of them.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад +1

      I love my 7 but I would never give up my Junglas for it. If they would just learn how to make a good grip, it be hard to beat these BKs.

    • @cburgz3697
      @cburgz3697 4 года назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay Mod your grip!

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +2

      @@cburgz3697 thats the point. If you need to mod your knife, it wasn't made right in the first place

  • @markbailey15
    @markbailey15 4 года назад +1

    Just started watching your channel in the past week, from across the water in Northern Ireland. Love what your doing, keeping it real, keeping it fresh, keep up the good work.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      Thanks bro. My Grandmother was a Corker! I've got some sheep shanker blood in me! Haha

    • @markbailey15
      @markbailey15 4 года назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay ahaha awesome bro

  • @Airik1111bibles
    @Airik1111bibles 5 лет назад +6

    There is something about the leather handle kabar that just feels awesome , they have a really good weight balance . They look simple on camera but holding one and seeing that kabar quality up close in person is killer. The cool thing with Beckers is modding them yourself, even a simple poor man mod looks awesome. You can stencil the scales with a wood burning tool strip the coating and patina the blade plus buy a kydex sheath but still even with that crappy sheath it looks killer.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад +1

      I did a video where I made custom grips for my BK9. You might dig that

  • @jackblack7827
    @jackblack7827 9 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks for the video. I've seen two Ka-bar fighting utility knives break at the handle, both times by people throwing them and they hit on the side of the blade and handle, rather than sticking in. So I would recommend that people not throw them. You would not want to throw your only weapon in a fight, whether it was a cougar or a person attacking you, so it's not a very useful knife skill to begin with. If people really want to throw knives, there are throwing knives for sale as well as shuriken.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  9 месяцев назад

      I am not a fan of the skinny stick tang

  • @mercifulone7065
    @mercifulone7065 2 года назад +2

    Great comparison! I’m deciding between the two. The Bk7 seems to be the better tool. For me, the biggest advantage of the Kabar fighting knife is being about 2 oz lighter.

  • @JoeDoomsday
    @JoeDoomsday 6 лет назад +4

    Hey Donnie B. ! Put size 15, plumbing O' Rings in the grooves of the Ka-Bar handle, for Better Grip. - A 4" inch piece of Bicycle inner tube "Ranger Band" on the BK7, The Grip becomes Fantastic. Its tough to get the ranger band on, But I must say it's well worth it. The inner tube is around $5 dollars at Walmart & Home Depot has the size 15, O-Rings for $3 for a set of 6.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  6 лет назад +2

      I appreciate that. I've seen the o rings on the KA-BAR but not the tube on the Becker. That would even work still wrapping fishing line and hook first.

    • @southernpartisan1772
      @southernpartisan1772 5 лет назад +1

      Yep I love the way the o rings feel on mine

  • @ferlottes
    @ferlottes 6 месяцев назад +1

    Good news ! BUCK General 120 Sheet fits perfectly the KBar usmc !!!

  • @pmaster375
    @pmaster375 3 года назад +2

    I've got the BK22 and put the black canvas micarta scales on it. Makes all the difference in the world!

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  3 года назад +1

      It should come with them from the start. Bullshit that they force feed people that plastic crap for the price they do then rape you for more, for the scales that should come on it.

  • @tubes5150
    @tubes5150 5 лет назад +2

    I have the Kabar USMC . Love this knife !
    I did however purchase another plane Kabar leather sheath ( looks exactly like the USMC sheath ).
    2 reasons - The first reason is that I’m a Navy Veteran ( 87-91 ).
    The second is just for collection purposes, the USMC sheath will stay safe and unmarked .
    Anyway - Cool Video and thanks for posting . The Kabar knife is one of my favorites!!

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад +1

      It's the classic that never gets old.

    • @greekveteran2715
      @greekveteran2715 5 лет назад +2

      Ka-bar mark I navy knife,with kraton handles,is my favorite fixed blade knife and the last reason about this,is that I am a navy veteran too It is the best I ever had and I own a lot.

  • @gianpalacio5635
    @gianpalacio5635 2 года назад +1

    I’ve used my navy kabar by putting it thru steel point first while a metal hammer hammers it from the bottom. Only the tip was a bit hurt, the USMC ka-bar is a beast.

  • @Roberthurz
    @Roberthurz 5 лет назад +5

    Great review. I have both, love both... but I am a Becker guy. Everyone is different... I personally love the handle on the BK 7 and have the BK 2, 9, 21. I find it comfortable and easy to hang on to myself...but... not everyone likes the handles... in fact most prefer something else. I never forget that everyone has a different perspective. I am in your camp... on which of the two is better.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад +1

      I prefer the Esee 6 over these 2 so I wasn't playing favorites. I just think the BK is better. I love the handle shape so I won't be changing it.

  • @ronalddunne3413
    @ronalddunne3413 4 года назад +4

    Not too fond of the KaBar as an only knife- carried one in '71-72 and couldnt wait to swap it out for a Buck 120 "General" which I carried for @ 40 years before it sprouted legs and walked off. Do wish I had hung on to the KaBar, tho, "just cuz", as it was part of my life back in the day and because it was the ONLY KaBar or similar knife with a chrome or nickled blade for humid climates.... I like the serrations for certain cutting chores, would like to see more knives with that offering. The BK7 edge needs an inch or two serration, the back-clip sharpened, and maybe the allens holding the grips on given a wee drop of loctite and it would truly be the "superior" knife... but that's just me!
    Thanks again for another great presentation, Donnie B!

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      I have a love hate relationship with KA-BAR

  • @timbo4374
    @timbo4374 4 года назад +1

    I stripped the coating on my BK7, put rosewood scales on it, and bought a custom leather sheath that is wet fitted for excellent retention. Made a good knife a great knife. Oh yeah, almost forgot..I did a hand rubbed satin finish on it too, although admittedly, it's not as purdy now that I've used the crap out of it, lol. However, doing that sanding on it thinned it out just a tiny bit behind the edge, so it cuts even better now, yet is still plenty strong enough to chop and baton. I had to sand it because it had vertical grind lines in the blade once I stripped it.I also squared up the spine for scraping ferro rods or scraping fatwood fluff. I put a lot of work into it, and added about 120 bucks to the overall cost with the scales and sheath, but damn, it's an excellent knife now. It's my go to blade when I want a larger blade for light chopping. I've used the crap out of it.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      Putting that much into it you could have just got a blade that has everything you wanted. But the key is you have everything you want.

    • @timbo4374
      @timbo4374 4 года назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay I don't regret it one bit. I love it, and as you so eloquently put it, I got exactly what I wanted. It's an awesome knife, and that stock sheath just outright sucked! The scales only cost me about 35 bucks, and the sheath was about 70 bucks The rest was just elbo grease which is pretty cheap, lol..

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      @@timbo4374 indeed

  • @southernpartisan1772
    @southernpartisan1772 5 лет назад +7

    I don't disagree with the balance difference between the two but nobody is going to be flipping a blade around in a real fight. Real fights usually consist of multiple thrust (sewing machine)

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад +1

      I hear what you're saying, but sometimes in combat especially, when the time comes, angles are important and getting to them faster than the other guy really helps. Believe me.

    • @southernpartisan1772
      @southernpartisan1772 5 лет назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay Touche. good point.... we need every advantage possible, especially if we are resorting to our blade.

  • @rnkmode1876
    @rnkmode1876 3 года назад +2

    I'm late to the Becker game, just ordered a BK7 & G10 handle scales. I'm stoked.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  3 года назад +1

      The scales will make a huge difference

  • @Supra_Mare_Cultro_Bloke
    @Supra_Mare_Cultro_Bloke Год назад +1

    youtube algorithm reads my mind! scary! i own a bk7, now doing research on 2211

  • @johnmutton799
    @johnmutton799 3 года назад +2

    Get a second cut file and flatten the sides of the handle, then blend it in to a oval shape. Then use sand paper to smooth out. Put tape in line with the grooves, then scribe the edges with sharp knife. Then use a squre needle file to re-cut the grooves. Finish with oil, then seal with a leather balm. Then when dry seal with natural shoe polish. Then the knife is brilliant! Good utility knife, and self defence knife. Always wondered why the guard is bent towards the hand? Any thoughts?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  3 года назад

      The guard is the way it is because it's not a designed combat knife. They used an old hunting knife factory and just kept stamping out hunting knives but painted black. Thats why the KA-BAR is a good utility knife but a horrible combat knife. Shit balance, shit grip, shit tang. Great steel.

  • @michaelroutson383
    @michaelroutson383 4 года назад +3

    You can put #11 Rubber O rings on the handle of the leather Ka bar right in the groves for a better grip!

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      Oh I know. The problem is that you shouldn't have to

  • @jetlee7743
    @jetlee7743 5 лет назад +3

    I see a lot of knife test as wood choppers that is set as a bench mark... I wonder about the best tools for the job..like an Axe for wood chopping? There are some nice survival axes. I would go for a lighter dual edge with glass breaker on board sharpener for my applications

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад

      You are absolutely correct. I think the wood chop test is purely to show off the strength of the edge. A weak blade will warp, chip or dull during wood chops. It's nice to know that having a knife for absolute survival, that your edge can handle even the things you "shouldn't" need it for.

    • @jetlee7743
      @jetlee7743 5 лет назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay. The design and purpose indicate ability. This will hold more weight on the craftmanship and composite of the knife. Ka bar and lmf ii are very different field uses but I see them compared frequently

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  5 лет назад

      @@jetlee7743 The Gerber Infantry and Ka Bar "USMC" as it's commonly known are both military issued knives. Since both were combat used, I can see them often being paired up.

    • @jetlee7743
      @jetlee7743 5 лет назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay yes for sure

  • @bawidamann939
    @bawidamann939 3 года назад +1

    Very cool video..what you think which one would be better in combat the BK7 or Esee 6?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  3 года назад +1

      For combat, may be the BK, but both do about the same job

  • @Andy-walkaboutnutty
    @Andy-walkaboutnutty 2 года назад +1

    I really enjoyed the video, it was a great comparison review. I have both and it's the rats tail and retainer pin that spoils it for me. It could be a week point in the structure and that's a big fail. They're both great knives, love them both but time has over taken granddads knife, the grandson is out in front like a real trooper. 👍

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  2 года назад +1

      Over time, the KA-BAR has become less loved for me. So I could easily go with the 7, but both still have great steel

  • @TheArkansasBushcrafter
    @TheArkansasBushcrafter 3 года назад +1

    Great video underrated channel 💯

  • @BabakPA
    @BabakPA 5 лет назад +1

    Very nice video! Loved it! Thank you

  • @falconmoose5435
    @falconmoose5435 2 года назад +1

    .....And that is why I have some K-Bar fighting /utility 7 inch and a K-Bar BK9' (No BK7.) in my bags..... Well.................. along with a multitude of Mora's. and a Condor Golok.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  2 года назад

      Not my favorite, but I sure wouldn't want it in my ribs!

  • @LegionTacticoolCutlery
    @LegionTacticoolCutlery 5 лет назад +4

    HA! I bought the bk7 and 9. Just waiting for them to come in!!!

  • @cburgz3697
    @cburgz3697 4 года назад +1

    Great vid! I enjoyed :)

  • @jamisonbarlow7930
    @jamisonbarlow7930 2 года назад +1

    Well actually Ethan Becker designed the bk7 as a fighting knife an upgrade to the kabar usmc style literally to be stronger and more durable… hence the name bk7 fighting utility knife

  • @djdjdsdjdjdd3959
    @djdjdsdjdjdd3959 4 года назад +2

    Is the bk9 with Micarta handle scales better than the Junglas?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      No but it's AWESOME

    • @djdjdsdjdjdd3959
      @djdjdsdjdjdd3959 4 года назад +1

      Donnie B All Day what can the Junglas do better?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      @@djdjdsdjdjdd3959 Its not a mater of "do" better, but overall shape and feel. I does slightly out chop the BK because it's got a smoothe full flat grind.

    • @djdjdsdjdjdd3959
      @djdjdsdjdjdd3959 4 года назад +1

      Donnie B All Day what one is more durable would you say?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      @@djdjdsdjdjdd3959 They are both 1095 and perfectly heat treated. The difference is that Esee has a no questions asked lifetime warranty.

  • @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie
    @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie 4 года назад +2

    I’ve been thinking about getting a Becker bk7,should I do it

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      It's great steel, comfortable in the hand, but cheap scale material. I have other options, but that said, the blade is still awesome.

    • @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie
      @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie 4 года назад +1

      Then what do you prefer more,I like that Bowie platform

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      @@Ilovebigbassandicannotlie I'm a Bowie guy myself but for a survival knife I like the Esee blades and stull from Steel Will. I also just designed a few that are going into production. I'd take all three of my upcoming blades over the Becker.

    • @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie
      @Ilovebigbassandicannotlie 4 года назад +1

      Good for you buddy,can’t wait to see them

  • @bawidamann939
    @bawidamann939 4 года назад +1

    Cool video cool knives, have an eye on that bk7. Can you please tell me how wide the blade is on that bk7 in centimeters?

  • @jamess.829
    @jamess.829 4 года назад +2

    I carried a Ka-Bar in the field when I was in the Marine Corps. We used them as utility knives and thought that the issue bayonet made a better fighting knife. We broke a few Ka-Bars using them and they usually broke the tip off more than at the handle where the tang starts even though I've seen a few of those breaks too. I sharpened the knives for my platoon and I used to file the false edge down to where the point was more centered with the handle instead of up swept. It made the point a lot stronger too since it took the thin part of the point down. Never made sense to me to have the point up swept instead of centered. They seemed to hold an edge pretty well and you could really get them sharp. One last thing, I never saw a Ka-Bar in the Marine Corps that had the USMC on the blade or the sheath. They were plain black sheaths and I think the blade simply had the OLEAN NY on the blade. Don't remember if the KA-Bar was above the OLEAN NY or not.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      I was luckily not issued the KA-BAR. We were blessed with the Gerber LMF Infantry II. I just recently designed a better option for the KA-Bar. Production will begin soon. Going to be a beast

    • @Jolleaus0004
      @Jolleaus0004 3 года назад +2

      @@DonnieBAllDay LMF is a small knife compared to these.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  3 года назад

      @@Jolleaus0004 I'd take the LMF back to Afghanistan over the KA-BAR in a heartbeat. Not even a second thought.

  • @henrycruz45cal
    @henrycruz45cal 11 месяцев назад

    The kbar is the best fighting knife say noone compared to modern knifes

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  11 месяцев назад

      Clearly you know nothing about M.E.A.N. and what it means for POB in a knife

  • @Grayday117
    @Grayday117 5 лет назад +1

    18:20 this nigga just hammered wood into wood like it was nothing

  • @cburgz3697
    @cburgz3697 4 года назад +1

    what about the D2 blade fighting knife?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      Same knife with crappy round rubber grip and a different steel.

  • @brnobre4301
    @brnobre4301 2 года назад +1

    👍🏼

  • @henrycruz45cal
    @henrycruz45cal 11 месяцев назад

    Nice healthy tree

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  11 месяцев назад

      no. a micro burst knocked down the top half

  • @Cymatic7
    @Cymatic7 6 лет назад +2

    I chose to go with the BK7 but I was seriously considering the Esee 6 for it not having a thumb ramp and having the finger choil. One guy I was watching earlier basically took the features I wanted on the Esse 6 and smacked it on the BK7. I really like the way he modded his BK7, you should check it out:
    ruclips.net/video/m8iEIF5UOvw/видео.html

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  6 лет назад

      I've seen the BK7 mods. I considered doing it to mine. Adding a choil and grinding down the ramp is pretty simple but if you really want those features, just stick with the Esee 6. The Esee has a flat spine, a choil, better handle scales, a better heat treat and a better coating, not to mention a better warranty. I'll do a vs between them at some point. I have so many knives to go through and I'm always adding to my collection. You should check out my video on the Steel Will Roamer. Similar to the Esee, half the price.

  • @Bruce6001
    @Bruce6001 4 года назад +1

    It’s not about the knife it’s about who’s using it

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      Truth. Some are still better than others for certain tasks. Id' rather have a Natchez Bowie over a Buck 110 if my task was to off an arm in a single blow.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      For some reason, your other comment isn't showing, but I can see it in the notifications. If you're asking me personally? With a blade against just about anyone I'm confident. I'm a combat vet, trained in the arts all my life and hold an undefeated heavyweight title. But if you ask, if you put both knives in the hands of a guy and his 100% equal clone, the only difference would be in the knife. Weight distribution for weight distribution, I'd go with the side that has the better weighted knife.

    • @Bruce6001
      @Bruce6001 4 года назад +1

      Donnie B All Day yes I deleted it because I didn’t want to be rude, I was speaking of an average untrained person vs a trained opponent, or a survival situation with a person with no experience in the wild vs someone that’s been experienced with outdoor survival situations

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +1

      @@Bruce6001 Never assume I'll take a comment the wrong way. Your opinion on my channel is your right. As far as the point, if you gave an untrained person a Katan, I can kill him with a spoon. It's impossible to claim equality in something when utilized unequally. But as far as either of these blades, I would trust my life to both.

    • @Bruce6001
      @Bruce6001 4 года назад +1

      Donnie B All Day I understand I just didn’t know how to word what I was thinking, I currently own many good knifes and I’m having a hard time choosing one for my bug out bag including the fighting knife from ka bar, I want something that’s not going to fail, something that’s good for self defense and other survival needs it isn’t easy lol

  • @juan-carlostome7127
    @juan-carlostome7127 4 года назад +1

    My choice for me the black

  • @MrEdium
    @MrEdium 4 года назад +1

    GREAT REVIEW BUT LEATHER IN MUD & WATER.... DOESN'T WORK.

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад +4

      I absolutely get your point as kydex and the like are better suited to last through the muck, but if you want to know how well a leather sheath holds up in mud and water, ask the Romans, Vikings, Highlanders, American Indians, pioneers, cowboys, soldiers from WWI, WWII, Korea or Viet Nam. Those leather sheaths and scabbards went through a daily daily dose of hell between the battle fields and the plains, still are found near mint today. I have one. BUT, they would be in even better condition if they were a plastic.

    • @MrEdium
      @MrEdium 4 года назад +2

      @@DonnieBAllDay NEVER THOUGHT OF THAT. THANK YOU & PLEASE STAY SAFE 😷👨‍⚕️

  • @juan-carlostome7127
    @juan-carlostome7127 4 года назад +1

    Army!🇺🇸

  • @MadM0nkey
    @MadM0nkey 5 лет назад +1

    BK7 FTW

  • @tomritter493
    @tomritter493 4 года назад +1

    Lol I carried a bar for yrs all over the world .as almar once said in a fight I want a clever

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      Most people don't care what they're carrying as long as they aren't fighting me. Haha

  • @fredflintstone1547
    @fredflintstone1547 4 года назад +1

    i refute your choil argument. knife-man says choils are dumb dumb and waste of blade space. more handle is better than useless blade space with respect to conservative blade design

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      Do you bushcraft? Have you ever had a need for lashing? Do you do nimble knife work? I refute your refute. Haha!

    • @Ve-suvius
      @Ve-suvius 3 года назад

      I agree on the no choil .
      Most bushcraft knives have no choil.
      And I'm speaking about 4 inch blade kind of knives
      Scandi knives etc. You want the edge go all the way to the handle. Then you can comfortably cut some wood without the uncomfortable use of a choil.
      The bushcraft set up is often short knife without choil. Axe or hatchet or machete.
      Large blades are nice to play around with. But for real work you get out the machete or axe.

  • @koskalp
    @koskalp 4 года назад +1

    13:40 be carefull ...your legs

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      a good leg stab makes for good video. Haha

  • @creepywhiteguy3621
    @creepywhiteguy3621 4 года назад +1

    I love and hate my kabar 1211

    • @creepywhiteguy3621
      @creepywhiteguy3621 4 года назад +1

      it does every thing I need it to do but every time I look at it I'm like it's bent

    • @creepywhiteguy3621
      @creepywhiteguy3621 4 года назад +1

      it's really hard to ignore it

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      I hate that KA-BAR has some of the best steel yet some of the worst handles

    • @creepywhiteguy3621
      @creepywhiteguy3621 4 года назад +1

      @@DonnieBAllDay when you thew your kabar at a tree did it bend?

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  4 года назад

      @@creepywhiteguy3621 no

  • @henrycruz45cal
    @henrycruz45cal 11 месяцев назад

    Silly

  • @hdsporty79
    @hdsporty79 2 года назад +1

    Ok Ricardo Montalvan "RRRich Corrrinthian leather"

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  2 года назад +1

      Leather smell is an aphrodisiac

    • @hdsporty79
      @hdsporty79 2 года назад

      @@DonnieBAllDay I agree when out with the wife I always end up in some sort of leather store be it western store or wilsons leather I can not ignore the smell of leather. 👍

  • @vinylmassacre1659
    @vinylmassacre1659 6 лет назад +2

    I remember my first gay bar I was just in there to get directions on how to get away from there

    • @DonnieBAllDay
      @DonnieBAllDay  6 лет назад

      DJ BILLY B old school mix oh yes, the blue oyster. I remember it well.