Ron saw the door was closing on his tenure and just decided to throw up both of his middle fingers to the organization. I'm so glad the Snyder Era is finally over with and the team is looking all the better now that he's gone.
That’s not hindsight, it was a stupid pick the second it was made. Gonzo was a consensus top 5-10 prospect that year and Forbes was looked at as an undersized day 2 prospect that only fit 2 schemes in the entire league. It was literally the defensive version of the Eagles taking Jalen Reagor over Justin Jefferson where EVERYONE knew it was a stupid ass pick immediately 😂
As a charger fan, I did see improvement from him this past season, however, he really struggles against good teams. In the wildcard game and the ravens game this past season he did not look like an NFL caliber receiver. I obviously want the guy to be good but I just don’t think he has what it takes to be a reliable receiver 🤷🏼♂️
@CoasterFlix342 harsh? He’s getting paid millions to be a leader and to be good not to suck. Sure you can say his receivers are injured but he still sucked then. A “sophomore slump” isn’t a good explanation a proper one is that he’s not as good as we thought
I trust Weidl/Kahn, but let’s not fail to give Mediocre Mike his due diligence here considering he’s kept Broderick playing out of position since his rookie year, but you know, Dan Moore has been locking down the blindside really well 🙄 Next year: LT - BJ, LG - Seumalo, C - Frazier, RG - McCormick, RT - Fautanu **as it should be
The fact that Zay Flowers was the Ravens first ever pro bowl receiver really says a lot about how bad the ravens are at drafting the position. Honestly kind of a miracle they managed to get this one right.
Am I the only one here questioning what makes Gonzalez an A+ when Gibbs and Carter have been studs? Are we grading the value of the pick or the talent of the prospect?
Not to speak for them, but it’s probably a mix of both. Getting someone that good that late is slightly better than someone of the same caliber at an earlier pick
@@c-boagames261 I'd understand if he was picked ~25th overall, but Gonzalez was only picked 5 slots after Gibbs and 8 slots after Carter, yet has not had anywhere near the same impact (respectfully to Gonzalez; it's tough to do so coming off of a season ending injury year 1 and being on a terrible team year 2). I feel like an A+ on Gonzalez is projecting too much. Carter and Gibbs are arguably top 5 at their position. Gonzalez isn't there yet
Injuries count for Stroud but not other QBs? Also, he had Diggs and Dell while Nico was out. And he just lost Dell like 2 weeks ago. Let's not pretend all 3 have been out at the same time. And his oline isn't worse than last year but he has regressed himself which has made the oline look worse. Stroud has regressed....that's ok. Let's see if he can take the offseason and improve.
@@trevormagers556 now you're just making up stats. I looked it up. Through week 3 he wasn't top 5. Through week 9 he wasn't top 5. Through week 12 he wasn't top 5. So don't bring lies to this. And a lot of yards, with no points means one thing. He's getting a lot of possessions thanks to his defense and he's not scoring and getting more possessions. For example, Jayden Daniels went almost 3 games without punting and wasn't even top 10 in yards those weeks
@toadvine7952 how is a RB supposed to carry a team that is inconsistent? Bijan, Drake and Tyler were the only reliable players last season on the offense. This season there's Mooney, but the qb play was inconsistent once again.
Picking an RB when you already have a young 1000 yard rusher is definitely a luxury pick. Not to mention they have needed a QB, receivers, and help on defense for years.
Anthony Richardson is the equivalent of Tim Tebow. He can run and then gets constantly injured. His pedestrian completion percentage is not professional caliber.
Honestly I would be willing to give him 1 more year. He’s got the upside of a Josh Allen, he’s just extremely raw and needs more time… I love AR and hope he can bring the colts back from obscurity.
@@Garfieldforpresident2024 His problem isn't that he's 'raw'. It's not rocket science to slide instead of taking a big hit. I also might give him one last year. The Colts should pick up another young QB and force him to compete for his job.
Yes. I've been saying this. People say his potential is sky high, but he hasn't completed 60% in a season since his junior year of high school. He can't throw. He can fling it down the field, but he has never had accuracy. Tebow is the comp for him. You don't magically learn how to play QB at the NFL level if you have never been good at it before. People fall in love with the height/weight/40 time, but at the end of the day he is a Wildcat RB
@@mpr2604 There's charts showing he's excellent if not elite in man coverage, and he almost never allows TDs. I'm not a fanboy and think he's a little over-rated, but he can cover just fine. If anything it is his run defense that is more over-rated than his coverage IMO. 18 missed tackles last year, the lack of size sometimes shows up when he goes screen busting. Love his heart but he's still a little dude.
Van Ness was a baffling pick that early. He has yet to develop ANY pass rush moves. He's decent against the run, but far from impactful in any area. The impact players who went after him, at positions the Packers needed at the time, and now, would all be difference makers in GB.
Cj has taken us to the divisional twice in a row when we were a 3-13-1 team the season before I genuinely think you are just a hater if you are giving him anything less than an A
2:27 giving AR a C- is stupid. Bro needs to be an F/D-. The Colts only have 21 drops this season. The drop % is because he doesn’t throw the ball. He’s a terrible QB.
@speakerz17 are you mentally ill? AR can’t throw basic passes. He can’t read a defense. He’s a RB who has never completed a season. His most impressive stat this season is Running 70 yards in a game while JT ran for over 200. Why do you think all receivers on the Colts had a bad year this year except AP?
@@StaleyBearjr 21 drops total. He does not throw the ball well, and does not throw it accurately. There are several teams with 21+ drops. Don’t be stupid with statistics, and misread em, like AR with a pass.
@@mattyaboi1653still has the highest drop %, even if the total drops aren’t the highest when he does throw they’re being dropped. The colts are also one of the heaviest run teams. Just because the scheme isn’t pass happy doesn’t mean the drops aren’t a big issue
The coaching staff in Dallas had Mazi lose weight from 330+ to the mid 290’s in his rookie year, the new coaches let him muscle back up in year two, getting to the mid 320’s by the second half and surprise
@6:39 This season, PFF actually has Skoronski as one of the best Guards in the League for Pass Protection. His run game is what pulls his overall grades down.
Giving CJ a B after one bad half of a season with almost all his WRs out and a horrendous offensive line is completely ridiculous when he’s been elite his entire career before. Not to mention how bad the Texans were before he got there and now they’re in the playoffs two straight years
Why is it that Stroud gets a pass for a bad season when his system falls apart, but Purdy gets endlessly criticized, even though he has a worse oline, the worst separation, no semblance of a run game, and absolutely terrible defense
@henrylee09purdy has been going through it longer no doubt. It's been for years. He went from Mr irrelevant to starter and is criticized like he was a top 10 pick. CJ is getting his but I don't feel like it's near purdy. If CJ gets the same mess next year we can say they are both hated on equally but cj literally hasn't been In the league as many years as purdy has been called a fraud
@ turned Baker and Geno around, prolly better because he’s had a full year of confidence and development after Dave turned his career around, let’s not forget he was fighting for the starting job last season
All four of Ron Rivera's first round picks for the Commanders are no longer with the team. His coaching was bad enough, but his talent evaluation was abysmal.
So interested to see what Bryce does next year Also an interesting thing to note about Anthony Richardson.. when you see a stat about drops like that .. sometimes a quarterback just doesn’t throw a catchable ball, it’s hard to see for us because the camera is sideways in a fan’s perspective but when it’s head on and they watch film they can see it easier. Throwing a catchable ball is such an important part of being a great passer. Peyton manning threw the most catchable ball of all time
Darnell should probably be closer to a B+. He was pretty dominant this year. Top 20 graded tackle and when you remove all the left tackles from that PFF list, there’s really only 4 or 5 RTs ahead of him.
Young and Stroud might end up being the most fascinating quarterback comparison saga in NFL history. It's like The Birth of Tragedy in football form. One is physically gifted and a spontaneously gifted playmaker (dionysian), and the other is a calm, calculated houdini with a significant height disadvantage (apollonian). Their mirroring outlooks are fascinating in that sense.
As a packers fan I disagree about Van Ness. He has been slowly growing in play time and talent and I’m personally excited to see his coming years because he’s really shown up on our defense recently.
I don’t see it. Yes, he’s slowly getting better but the bar was not high. He’s a first-round pick, and right now, two years in, he’s been a clear disappointment.
@@snowantric7370 well, of course. He’s got two more years and he’s gonna get playing time so let’s see what happens. Gary didn’t light it up early, either, but he’s a solid player. All I’m saying is his body of work so far does not excite me, as it does you. Cooper, Williams - those guys have had immediate impact and they do excite me.
I mean GB new LVN was gunna be a work in progress, Iowa has a tendency to start seniors over over higher ceiling players and GB took a shot on LVN knowing that. Give him another year in the new defense scheme as well
Bijan has the highest mph reached by the line of scrimmage. He gets up to 11 mph before the line. And he's also made the most missed tackles this season, while being top three in yards
Why do people still think Zay Flowers is better than addison and even more why do they think hes a probowler respectfully hes a good wr but needs to work on his hands and route running to be on par with JA
@@adsafgasgasdfasdfI pulled up the stats: zay has 74 catches on 114 targetsfor 1059 and 4 tds. Addison has 62 catches on 93 targets for 875 and 9 tds as wr 2
Bro I didn't realize the colts had an 11.3 drop percentage. That's insanely high. Like if they only dropped 3% he'd have a 60% completion rate, which is the same as Eli Manning had over his entire career. That and their O-line has been playing pretty poorly too. He makes some bad passes sure, but that stat really makes me wonder if he's actually performing much better than it seems already after the benching
I hate that you said Anthony Richardson has MVP potential. It’s not the physical traits that make MVP QBs, it’s the passing ability and mental part of the game that makes QBs MVPs. He’s just a bad QB with great athletic ability.
As a Washington fan, I still don't understand why Ron + team selected Forbes. Everyone was thinking we'd go Gonzalez. Forbes seemed liked by his teammates just wasn't the best on the field
If Anthony Richardson was hitting 60% of his passes it would be a different story. But battling it out with Tebow for lowest all-time completion percentage in a season? I don't see it happening.
Stroud led the Texans to 2 straight division titles won his first playoff game and he gets a B??? What absolutely insane standard do you have for QBs? Was he supposed to win MVP and a Super Bowl his first two seasons????
Broderick has been playing greatly this past last half of the year, he’s let Najee have those big holes and also Warren. He does let a lot of sacks but he’s not the worst fs
The reason Stroud looks so much worse this year is because of the O-line. Having watched nearly all of his games when he was in college, his whole thing was that if he was in a stable pocket, he was probably the best passer in college football. That's what happened when they played georgia in the CFP a few years ago. However, when he's put under pressure, his accuracy drops significantly. He's a pure pocket passer, and isn't really a guy who can make good throws under pressure. I don't think he's regressed really, I think it's more that his biggest weakness is just way easier to spot this year since last year he had super solid O-line play. He still looks the same to me when he's not forced out of the pocket. He just gets forced out 3-4x as much now so we're seeing him throw in scrambles which he's never been great at
CJ Stroud is still an A+ pick an will go back to his elite playing ways after this sophomore slump he is currently going through. Will Anderson JR. is also an A+ pick as well.
Bears fans know Darnell Wright is good. Probably better than his numbers even because of how often we leave our tackles on an island. It’s the rest of the line that’s the problem both individually and how they play as a unit.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
The Lions getting Gibbs, Campbell, Laporta, and Branch back to back to back to back is pretty stunning
Their GM has been so good.
Lions and Eagles made out like bandits that draft
@@ryant3556 Brad holmes!
Epic draft. Once in 20 yrs type draft.
and the fact people were saying it was a terrible draft at the time too.. shows u how much grades on draft day don't matter
That Emanuel Forbes pick is so insane even without hindsight
Ron saw the door was closing on his tenure and just decided to throw up both of his middle fingers to the organization. I'm so glad the Snyder Era is finally over with and the team is looking all the better now that he's gone.
It’s just ridiculous how bad the Commanders drafted. Picking an F player instead of an obvious A+ player Shameful
Ron Rivera smh
As a pats fan…man…never made sense to me and it never will. THANKS WASHINGTON!!
Thank you for your stinging analysis, Captain Hindsight. What would we do without you
That’s not hindsight, it was a stupid pick the second it was made. Gonzo was a consensus top 5-10 prospect that year and Forbes was looked at as an undersized day 2 prospect that only fit 2 schemes in the entire league. It was literally the defensive version of the Eagles taking Jalen Reagor over Justin Jefferson where EVERYONE knew it was a stupid ass pick immediately 😂
I think that they redeemed themselves by picking Jayden Daniel’s
Johnston having 13 for 186 leas than 24 hours after this is humorous lol. In all seriousness, great analysis!
he just went off lol
I said something similar. Call out the chargers fan base to troll haha
If he didn't have Brick Hands he would be Elite
As a charger fan, I did see improvement from him this past season, however, he really struggles against good teams. In the wildcard game and the ravens game this past season he did not look like an NFL caliber receiver. I obviously want the guy to be good but I just don’t think he has what it takes to be a reliable receiver 🤷🏼♂️
Jalen Carter is an A+. Will Anderson is an A+.
Excited for Young’s development. Buddy went off for five total touchdowns in the season finale against the Falcons
And Gibbs just had 4 TDs last night. Talk about a fantastic pick.
Seattle nailed the 2023 draft like holly now they just gotta draft a whole new oline this upcoming draft
only problem is qb
You are lucky if you get even one starter o line in a draft
Seattle has been great at drafting for a while
@@koop2.1.5 Seattle is feast or famine lately. For every Witherspoon and JSN there is a D Eskridge and Rashad Penny
@@caleblawton7780 hopefully they draft Jaxson dart in the second round
this was solid. great in depth look at players without dragging on
Simple and to the point I like it
Might wanna bump Gibbs to an A+ after last night
Cj is just having a sophomore slump
Not a real thing
He just sucks
@@Vpmp1223that’s harsh and wrong
@CoasterFlix342 harsh? He’s getting paid millions to be a leader and to be good not to suck. Sure you can say his receivers are injured but he still sucked then. A “sophomore slump” isn’t a good explanation a proper one is that he’s not as good as we thought
@@Vpmp1223holy casual
I think the biggest downfall of Broderick Jones is the amount of penalties he incurs, though he has been getting better
I trust Weidl/Kahn, but let’s not fail to give Mediocre Mike his due diligence here considering he’s kept Broderick playing out of position since his rookie year, but you know, Dan Moore has been locking down the blindside really well 🙄
Next year: LT - BJ, LG - Seumalo, C - Frazier, RG - McCormick, RT - Fautanu **as it should be
The fact that Zay Flowers was the Ravens first ever pro bowl receiver really says a lot about how bad the ravens are at drafting the position.
Honestly kind of a miracle they managed to get this one right.
Am I the only one here questioning what makes Gonzalez an A+ when Gibbs and Carter have been studs? Are we grading the value of the pick or the talent of the prospect?
Not to speak for them, but it’s probably a mix of both. Getting someone that good that late is slightly better than someone of the same caliber at an earlier pick
@@c-boagames261 I'd understand if he was picked ~25th overall, but Gonzalez was only picked 5 slots after Gibbs and 8 slots after Carter, yet has not had anywhere near the same impact (respectfully to Gonzalez; it's tough to do so coming off of a season ending injury year 1 and being on a terrible team year 2). I feel like an A+ on Gonzalez is projecting too much. Carter and Gibbs are arguably top 5 at their position. Gonzalez isn't there yet
Skoronski had his appendix removed during his rookie season. That seriously set back his development. I think he'll end up being an A+.
CJ’s offense has been injured all year. Diggs is out for the season, Collins missed time, Dell is out for the season, and his O-Line is a wreck.
Injuries count for Stroud but not other QBs?
Also, he had Diggs and Dell while Nico was out. And he just lost Dell like 2 weeks ago. Let's not pretend all 3 have been out at the same time. And his oline isn't worse than last year but he has regressed himself which has made the oline look worse.
Stroud has regressed....that's ok. Let's see if he can take the offseason and improve.
So what's the excuse when he had Collins and Dell healthy at the same time?
@@Ryan-wx1bi When he was still top 5 in yards for 90% of the season?
Go watch the Christmas Day film. None of what you said explains why he was throwing behind his guys or 5 yards over their heads.
@@trevormagers556 now you're just making up stats. I looked it up. Through week 3 he wasn't top 5. Through week 9 he wasn't top 5. Through week 12 he wasn't top 5. So don't bring lies to this.
And a lot of yards, with no points means one thing. He's getting a lot of possessions thanks to his defense and he's not scoring and getting more possessions.
For example, Jayden Daniels went almost 3 games without punting and wasn't even top 10 in yards those weeks
Disagree about Bijan as a luxury bc he is much more productive as a pass catcher than any other Falcons RB the last 2 seasons.
What a great pick Bijan is. He's carried the Falcons to an 8-8 record in a pathetic division. lol
@toadvine7952 how is a RB supposed to carry a team that is inconsistent? Bijan, Drake and Tyler were the only reliable players last season on the offense. This season there's Mooney, but the qb play was inconsistent once again.
Definitely a luxury pick you needed so much help on the edge and at corner doesn't mean he's not good, he is but 100% luxury
Picking an RB when you already have a young 1000 yard rusher is definitely a luxury pick. Not to mention they have needed a QB, receivers, and help on defense for years.
@@bamafan18 Lines been trash for a decade. Falcons just can't/won't draft good linemen either.
Lions reached for 2 guys who have been studs so far
Gibbs should be S tier that guy is crazy good
Most touchdowns in the NFL this year; doubters put _that_ in your pipe and smoke it!
Bijan better
Anthony Richardson is the equivalent of Tim Tebow. He can run and then gets constantly injured. His pedestrian completion percentage is not professional caliber.
Honestly I would be willing to give him 1 more year. He’s got the upside of a Josh Allen, he’s just extremely raw and needs more time… I love AR and hope he can bring the colts back from obscurity.
@@Garfieldforpresident2024 His problem isn't that he's 'raw'. It's not rocket science to slide instead of taking a big hit. I also might give him one last year. The Colts should pick up another young QB and force him to compete for his job.
Him having the playoff wins and regular season wins of Tim Tebow would be an improvement
He's has an even worse accuracy than Tebow which is wild
Yes. I've been saying this. People say his potential is sky high, but he hasn't completed 60% in a season since his junior year of high school. He can't throw. He can fling it down the field, but he has never had accuracy. Tebow is the comp for him. You don't magically learn how to play QB at the NFL level if you have never been good at it before. People fall in love with the height/weight/40 time, but at the end of the day he is a Wildcat RB
Finding your franchise QB makes it an A pick.
Yes! I’ve been calling Gibbs “Kel” since he was in college lol! Nice video, man. I’m subscribing.
Devon witherspoon an A if Gonzo an A+
He sucks at coverage
@@mpr2604 There's charts showing he's excellent if not elite in man coverage, and he almost never allows TDs. I'm not a fanboy and think he's a little over-rated, but he can cover just fine. If anything it is his run defense that is more over-rated than his coverage IMO. 18 missed tackles last year, the lack of size sometimes shows up when he goes screen busting. Love his heart but he's still a little dude.
Van Ness was a baffling pick that early. He has yet to develop ANY pass rush moves. He's decent against the run, but far from impactful in any area. The impact players who went after him, at positions the Packers needed at the time, and now, would all be difference makers in GB.
Cj has taken us to the divisional twice in a row when we were a 3-13-1 team the season before I genuinely think you are just a hater if you are giving him anything less than an A
this video was made before he won his second playoff game
Great video. Good insights, you go in draft order instead of reverse, you are quick and efficient. Loved it!
2:27 giving AR a C- is stupid. Bro needs to be an F/D-. The Colts only have 21 drops this season. The drop % is because he doesn’t throw the ball. He’s a terrible QB.
Bro does NOT watch the games lmao
@speakerz17 are you mentally ill? AR can’t throw basic passes. He can’t read a defense. He’s a RB who has never completed a season. His most impressive stat this season is Running 70 yards in a game while JT ran for over 200. Why do you think all receivers on the Colts had a bad year this year except AP?
His receivers lead the league in drop percentage?
@@StaleyBearjr 21 drops total. He does not throw the ball well, and does not throw it accurately. There are several teams with 21+ drops. Don’t be stupid with statistics, and misread em, like AR with a pass.
@@mattyaboi1653still has the highest drop %, even if the total drops aren’t the highest when he does throw they’re being dropped. The colts are also one of the heaviest run teams. Just because the scheme isn’t pass happy doesn’t mean the drops aren’t a big issue
The coaching staff in Dallas had Mazi lose weight from 330+ to the mid 290’s in his rookie year, the new coaches let him muscle back up in year two, getting to the mid 320’s by the second half and surprise
6:12 as a bears fan darnell is the only oline men that should stay on the roster
As a bears fan, that’s incorrect
Not the oline’s fault entirely, Caleb can’t deliver the ball on time
@ how can he when 85% of the time he gets the ball and someone is already in the back field
@@micahqgecko he never has a pocket to stand in lol
Braxton Jones is very solid when healthy
Always to the point and entertaining 🔥
Discovered your channel recently and have been loving your content! Keep up the great work!
🤖
@6:39
This season, PFF actually has Skoronski as one of the best Guards in the League for Pass Protection.
His run game is what pulls his overall grades down.
Gibbs added 4 td tonight 😂😂😂
I believe in Broderick Jones. He’s playing out of his natural position and has gradually improved this season. I can’t believe he’s only 23 still.
Giving CJ a B after one bad half of a season with almost all his WRs out and a horrendous offensive line is completely ridiculous when he’s been elite his entire career before. Not to mention how bad the Texans were before he got there and now they’re in the playoffs two straight years
Why is it that Stroud gets a pass for a bad season when his system falls apart, but Purdy gets endlessly criticized, even though he has a worse oline, the worst separation, no semblance of a run game, and absolutely terrible defense
@ I think both are good QBs in bad situations this year but I’ve seen a lot more criticism for CJ
@@JessePinkman08 really? Maybe it’s cause I only look over the 9ere but Christ he’s getting destroyed
Even when he is protected he isnt throwing very accurately compared to his rookie year
@henrylee09purdy has been going through it longer no doubt. It's been for years. He went from Mr irrelevant to starter and is criticized like he was a top 10 pick. CJ is getting his but I don't feel like it's near purdy. If CJ gets the same mess next year we can say they are both hated on equally but cj literally hasn't been In the league as many years as purdy has been called a fraud
Imagine being the chargers getting the only non A in 4 straight receivers drafted
Don’t forget, the Lions got Sam LaPorta and Brian Branch in rd 2. Home run draft for Detroit.
CJ Stroud is probably worried about his bud Tank Dell and Stefon Diggs
Your take on Wright gave me a reason to subscribe
0:45 Dave canales is the qb whisperer
Not really. Tampa Bay and Baker have been way better this year without him.
@ turned Baker and Geno around, prolly better because he’s had a full year of confidence and development after Dave turned his career around, let’s not forget he was fighting for the starting job last season
pretty sure rod wave is the qb whisperer
All four of Ron Rivera's first round picks for the Commanders are no longer with the team. His coaching was bad enough, but his talent evaluation was abysmal.
So interested to see what Bryce does next year
Also an interesting thing to note about Anthony Richardson.. when you see a stat about drops like that .. sometimes a quarterback just doesn’t throw a catchable ball, it’s hard to see for us because the camera is sideways in a fan’s perspective but when it’s head on and they watch film they can see it easier. Throwing a catchable ball is such an important part of being a great passer. Peyton manning threw the most catchable ball of all time
Gibbs an A+
Please rank players on aura again and see who lost and gained aura, Sam Donald might have the all-time record in most aura gained in one season
Feel like you underrated Anton Harrison. Had a fantastic rookie season and still had a decent year two. I'd say right now, it's more like a B pick.
Darnell should probably be closer to a B+. He was pretty dominant this year. Top 20 graded tackle and when you remove all the left tackles from that PFF list, there’s really only 4 or 5 RTs ahead of him.
Will Anderson Jr he's so good bro and him in 51 is just so drippy
I’m about ready to give up on Richardson. He’s injury prone, he’s got poor work ethic, and he’s not developing his mechanics
The Carolina Reaper took CJs talent like space jam
how tf is gibbs not A+
seahawks cooked this draft
And are still in mediocrity hell
@@Johnhargrove18sped
Finally some love for Gonzo. He got snubbed hard out of the pro bowl this year
Who got in over him? Other than surtain which of obvious
@@EDP445_bsMarlon Humphrey, Derek stingley, and I think ward from the browns.
@@SeaTackytheyre all better than him especially stingley and ward
@@baronthebreeze casual
@@Yeeta3223 hes not better than all if them stop glazing
Young and Stroud might end up being the most fascinating quarterback comparison saga in NFL history. It's like The Birth of Tragedy in football form. One is physically gifted and a spontaneously gifted playmaker (dionysian), and the other is a calm, calculated houdini with a significant height disadvantage (apollonian). Their mirroring outlooks are fascinating in that sense.
With a brutal OL, not sure you can put that on Stroud. Silly to have him a “B”
I think this is a perfect list.
Addison is a better receiver than Flowers. He is just in the same offense as JJ.
No he isn’t it’s not even close
@ after last night man, you might be right 😂😂😂
I dont like doing grades till their rookie contract is up some guys start hot and others have to wait.
Valid
As a packers fan I disagree about Van Ness. He has been slowly growing in play time and talent and I’m personally excited to see his coming years because he’s really shown up on our defense recently.
I don’t see it. Yes, he’s slowly getting better but the bar was not high. He’s a first-round pick, and right now, two years in, he’s been a clear disappointment.
You must be his Mom. The bum is a bust.
@@scooter5940 even if talent takes time to develop, it’s better than having no talent at all. Give it like 2 more years and he’ll be better.
@@snowantric7370 well, of course. He’s got two more years and he’s gonna get playing time so let’s see what happens. Gary didn’t light it up early, either, but he’s a solid player. All I’m saying is his body of work so far does not excite me, as it does you. Cooper, Williams - those guys have had immediate impact and they do excite me.
That was cool information--Thanks. Wondering how much closer to elite the Redskins would be today if they had selected Gonzales.
whos here after johnston had a 186 yard game lol
Not time to tap out on AR hahahaha love it
Jahmyr Gibbs put up amazing numbers while being the Lion's number 2 back. I think he should have a couple of ++ added to his grade.
I mean GB new LVN was gunna be a work in progress, Iowa has a tendency to start seniors over over higher ceiling players and GB took a shot on LVN knowing that. Give him another year in the new defense scheme as well
Bro and Bryce went craaaazy today
Bijan has the highest mph reached by the line of scrimmage. He gets up to 11 mph before the line. And he's also made the most missed tackles this season, while being top three in yards
B is completely fair for Stroud imo. One good year and one bad. Bryce Young’s supporting cast is nothing special either.
Quentin Johnston has actually had a sneaky good season 711 yards and 8 tds in 15 games aint nothing to laugh about
He still drops too many passes.
So averaging 45 yards a game now is "sneaky good"? Awesome.
@@cameronhurst9432 Yeah, it is lmao. Too bad about your parlay tho. Addiction is a mfer
Good content. No fluff just facts and evidence to back it up. Thank you...
Steve Smith warned us about Quentin Johnston and damn he was right again if I was a GM I would ask for his opinion on this year’s wrs
He has gotten better
Why do people still think Zay Flowers is better than addison and even more why do they think hes a probowler respectfully hes a good wr but needs to work on his hands and route running to be on par with JA
People love the undersized speedsters. Hes pretty good not great though
@@adsafgasgasdfasdfexactly lmao. I’m an eagles fan and I can see that. I would look like a decent nfl receiver opposite jj
@@Deontelewis846no the hell you wouldn’t
@@adsafgasgasdfasdfI pulled up the stats: zay has 74 catches on 114 targetsfor 1059 and 4 tds. Addison has 62 catches on 93 targets for 875 and 9 tds as wr 2
@@adsafgasgasdfasdfhe gets more targets and has barely more yards with less tds can’t tell me that better stats
Man poor Herbert. Imagine having Zay or Addison instead of QJ 😭
Bro I didn't realize the colts had an 11.3 drop percentage. That's insanely high. Like if they only dropped 3% he'd have a 60% completion rate, which is the same as Eli Manning had over his entire career. That and their O-line has been playing pretty poorly too. He makes some bad passes sure, but that stat really makes me wonder if he's actually performing much better than it seems already after the benching
Jahmyr Gibbs should be an A+! 😮😮😮😮😮
This needs to be remade
Forbes turned out bad but it wasn't considered a massive stretch at the time. The draft is all hindsight.
Hard not to say every non QB pick before Jalen Carter should have been Jalen Carter
Jalen Carter is a killer so he fits the city of Philadelphia perfectly. All those junkies with no morals love cheering for a killer like him.
I'm happy for Bryce Young. Some guys would crumple after a tough start, but the kid clearly has moxie.
I hate that you said Anthony Richardson has MVP potential. It’s not the physical traits that make MVP QBs, it’s the passing ability and mental part of the game that makes QBs MVPs. He’s just a bad QB with great athletic ability.
As a Washington fan, I still don't understand why Ron + team selected Forbes. Everyone was thinking we'd go Gonzalez. Forbes seemed liked by his teammates just wasn't the best on the field
If Anthony Richardson was hitting 60% of his passes it would be a different story. But battling it out with Tebow for lowest all-time completion percentage in a season? I don't see it happening.
Still crazy to me that the best WR in this class went in the 5th round
Gibbs, Gonzalez, Witherspoon should be A+
Stroud led the Texans to 2 straight division titles won his first playoff game and he gets a B??? What absolutely insane standard do you have for QBs? Was he supposed to win MVP and a Super Bowl his first two seasons????
Thanks.
Broderick has been playing greatly this past last half of the year, he’s let Najee have those big holes and also Warren. He does let a lot of sacks but he’s not the worst fs
When you showed the player it would’ve been nice to have their pick number on the screen too
Strouds second season is purely circumstantial and they’re playing a first place schedule, which is uncommon for a QB who was 2nd overall.
Jordan Addison always was, is and will be better than Zay Flowers
Christian Gonzalez has given me a thumbs up before to sign my jersey but didn’t because of a loss lol😭
i would recommend either talking quieter or turning the volume down a tad
The reason Stroud looks so much worse this year is because of the O-line. Having watched nearly all of his games when he was in college, his whole thing was that if he was in a stable pocket, he was probably the best passer in college football. That's what happened when they played georgia in the CFP a few years ago. However, when he's put under pressure, his accuracy drops significantly. He's a pure pocket passer, and isn't really a guy who can make good throws under pressure. I don't think he's regressed really, I think it's more that his biggest weakness is just way easier to spot this year since last year he had super solid O-line play. He still looks the same to me when he's not forced out of the pocket. He just gets forced out 3-4x as much now so we're seeing him throw in scrambles which he's never been great at
Johnston isnt rotational, he is on the field most snaps. he's also top ten in rec tds this year
Darnell Wright has been an A. He graded out as a top 5 tackle in the league this year...
Addison is clearly an A+
Not even a Vikings fan but I’m taking Addison before njiba and zay
Not an A+ but he’s good
@@averygreen2244JSN is better.
@@averygreen2244 you're braindead if you would take Addison over jsn🤡
QJ must’ve watched this before the game
CJ Stroud is still an A+ pick an will go back to his elite playing ways after this sophomore slump he is currently going through. Will Anderson JR. is also an A+ pick as well.
Carter should be A+
Nah Will Anderson Jr. is better he is the A+ pick.
Carter deserves credit for not killing anymore innocent people.
@@chrisanders713Negative Jalen Carter is an All Pro and sees just as much double teams as Chris Jones.
9:13 Would love if you included the college teams, I remember Forbes getting drafted cause he was so small, but don’t remember where he went.
Bears fans know Darnell Wright is good. Probably better than his numbers even because of how often we leave our tackles on an island. It’s the rest of the line that’s the problem both individually and how they play as a unit.