In this era/generation, they want everything in 30 secs. 😢😢 So they believe/manipulate anything easily😮. Research panna ready illa. Thanks for this detailed and clear explanation 📚📚👏👏
தயவுசெய்து இந்த காணெளியை ஆங்கிலம் மற்றும் இந்தி மொழிகளில் வெளியிட்டு வட இந்திய சகோதரர்களுக்கு கச்ச தீவு சர்ச்சையின் உண்மைகளை தெளிவுப்படுத்த வேண்டும். அருமையான பதிவு. பாராட்டிற்குரி முயற்சி. நன்றி ஐயா 🙏🏻
Well explained sir 🎉🎉🎉 Today my professor asked about this issue in class. Now I got clear answer.❤ BJP just taking this issue in hand only for vote politics.
அருமையான விளக்கம் ஐயா... நடுநிலையான விளக்கம் கொடுத்தீர்கள் , அரசியல் வாதிகள் மக்களை குழப்பிக் கொன்டு இருக்கும் நேரம்... எங்களை நேர் வழியில் நடத்துகிறீர்கள் நன்றி 🙏
Yeah, clearly there's a difference between a man who had a very successful IPS career & highly famous and clean throughout his service, resigned his job just like that and entered politics for good cause unlike others who acted in cinema and with dumbest head entered politics, some others who play flute for the gopalapuram family and being slaves to them... Annamalai's political career is just 3 years old brother and he already made you boil, right from gopalapuram kothadimais to half informed tharkuris😂...
@@senthil3770 if u so struggled in TN governance better To go n live happily with ur family girls in UP , MANIPUR.... y u live in state of adimai ruling???? 😂😂😂😂😂
Best explanation sir 💥💥💥... All are doing politics with this issue but only you explained the indepth and clear explanation in different point of views... You never failed to impress us sir ✨❤️
I find ii hard to fanthom when the video starting from 1195 year about Sri Lanka ownership. If we go early India should claim northern part of Sri Lanka as they were under Tamil kings rule for ages. But we can't go by this logic. The picture starts with leasing of this island to British by king of Ramnad. A strong evidence. The bug stops here in my view and it is clearly belongs to India.
Thanks for your always clear and evidential explanations, even retired genuine officers join politics, also they fell in to dirty politics, all politics power
அருமையான விளக்கம் sir. காங்கிரஸ் தவறு செய்துவிட்டது ஏற்று கொள்கிறோம் ஆனால் அவர் செய்த தவறை பிஜேபி அரசு செய்ய கூடாது. இதை வைத்து இரண்டு அரசு அரசியல் செய்து கொண்டு இருக்கிறது. ஆனால் என்னுடைய தனிப்பட்ட கருத்து என்னவென்றால். காங்கிரஸ் அரசு சரி இல்லை என்று தான் பிஜேபி அரசு வந்தது இவர்களும் காங்கிரஸ் குறை சொல்ல கூடாது...
Bro Congress thavrelam panala😂😂.. actually wadge bank ah vankanumnuthan kaatcha theva India kuduthuchi same date rendumai exchange panikitanga😂😂....BJP yen wadge bank pathi peasa matinguthuna anga crude extraction tender vida poranunga 200% adani kuthan athu pogum🤣😂..athu veliya therinja BJP eechagalukuthan problem athan reason 😂😂...
Prior to last ten years period we used to see daily news of our fishermen going to srilankan jail. All sort of story of their sufferings. But last ten years we don't see that much news. May be our foreign/external ministry is doing commendable job or fast to respond etc. To be I had seen this decreased a lot.. please clarify
It is quite an explanation but from such a Senior Official I expected more. Your talk should have covered these points also. 1. Every party will explore the possibility of raking up an issue if some evidences are available to them and if used effectively will get them few more votes. The point is whether DMK is aware about this or not before it happened? In this instant case, BJP had exposed some documents which clearly establish that DMK is aware about “கச்சத்தீவு” even before the decision was taken. 2. All including you, haven’t explained why this Article 6 was deleted and is it because of this deletion our fisherman are being harassed by Sri Lankan Navy? 3. Some more information on the positive and negative sides of the issue would have helped.
It is a small piece of land. I don't mind to conceding it. According to annamalai this has to do with international line around the area and a wealth resources of fish in those areas. Tamil fishermen used to fishing in those area traditionally for ages. After this ceding our fishermen were going to srilankan jail regularly affecting their livelihood as this ceding lead to breaching the international line. Please eloborate this side of the story on factual accuracy.
நேருஜி சொன்னதை தான் இவரும் சொல்கிறார்... அங்க ஒன்னுமில்லை அது ஒன்னுக்கும் ஆகாது ஒரு IAS Officer சொல்லுவது not good... திருடன் திருடியது தப்பு இல்லை... நீங்கள் திருடு போனதை சொன்னது தான் தவறு... 1910ல் எதோ church இருந்ததாம் அது ஶ்ரீலங்கா control ல இருந்ததாம் அதனால் அவங்களுடையது முடிவு செய்யப் பட்டதாம்... இதுவேல்லாம் okay மீன் பிடிக்கும் உரிமையையும் தாரைவார்த்ததை ஏன் இவர் சொல்லவில்லை... he told BJP is not good... Okay... DMK and Congress are excellent parties of India because the parties are marder the Tamil people of Srilanka... Keep it up Sir...
Thanks, sir, but you missed explaining the sea level of permission near the island-of Sri Lanka, which has more power and sea control due to the island. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
Another important piece of information is that DMK was in alliance with Congress I called Indra Congress till July 1976 ( emergency started time). So Karunanidhi couldn't use this alliance!!!
Little correction sir. It appears that our minister Jayashankar is talking about a minutes of meeting held in st George fort chenna, in October 1973, Mr Karunanidhi concurred to proposal to tranfer kaccha theevu to Ceylon. It is clamed that Karunanidhi conceded this as one of the favours to Delhi to sink the findings of sarkaria commission against him. It appears all the ostensibly token agitation were done as a part of stage management drama by Karunanidhi to deceive public. As kid, I could recall wherever I went house of relatives and friends, this was the talk of the town. Elders used to scold Karunanidhi for his acting and call him a thief. Looking back now this looks like a beginning of the fall of Karunanidhi. I also recall that 1975/76 when Karunanidhi and his men were put into jail under MISA. Stalin also went to jail I think. I could sense people were happy to see him in jail. Around the same time (1976/77) MGR emerged as a power house breaking away from DMK and went on to become CM . It is not that just charisma of MGR but people hatred against Karunanidhi kept him away from police till th death of MGR. Remember Karunanidhi is a very outstanding dramatist, story writer and excellent script writer in addition to exemplary oratory skills and believed that these skills can manage anything and get away. But skills can only take you some where and you need a value to stay there longer which MGR have had in tons.
Sir- international waters and so many fishermen’s life compromised by this handover which happened behind the doors. This decision clearly shows the vision of our leaders. Getting back something which was given like this is never going to be easy and may take many years. At the least as a damage control fishing by our Indian fishermen should be allowed and more so no more arrests of them should be negotiated by whom so ever is in power.
Many of the youtuber's are giving only a partial data which suppresses the Thamizh's welfare.... still you seem to be good..... Many view's are to be changed sir..... Last view is a good one sir ...Our Fishermen should be benefited.......
Sir, Today I have seen a video in "The wire" interview of Nirumaba subramaninan who is saying that Wadge Bank and Katcha Theevu were mutually accepted by India during Bilateral talks .
Hai sir I start preparation for upsc last 3 months but 1week before I did minor fitsula opration .there is a any chances for disqualify in Medical test sir .I consult my doctor but he dont know about that sir
Very well explained Bro.Isreal Jebasingh and i don't think anyone can explain these details . Are there any customs there as you mentioned about visa requirements. I am following your other political explanation and it's too good . Please keep updating about Kejriwal news Kennedy Mumbai
Sir, I Come to know that fishing and arresting our fishermen are different issue. No catch is available near Katcha theevu now but available in Srilanka waters. Is is true Sir?
Sir pls clarify that upsc group 'A' ips officer salary and group 'B' ips officer salary..is it same for both or different? Orelse put a video like upsc group A ips officers vs Group B Pondicherry ips offcers in details....how group B ips officers selected nd their training,posting , salary, how cadre are allocated after upsc exam to group B officer ... Main thing is after upsc main examination,how they are selected to group B Pondicherry police service,how they r allocated,cadre details and am an upsc aspirant i want to choose Pondicherry police service (group B)...pls clarify everything sir!
Sir பங்ளா தேசத்திற்கு எவ்வளவு நிலம் கொடுத்தோம், கச்சத்தீவிற்கு எவ்வளவு நிலம் என்பது இங்கு பிரச்சனை கிடையாது , கச்சத்தீவு தீவு , இலங்கை என்பது சீனாவிற்கு அருகில் உள்ளது மேலும் சீனாவின் ஊடுருவல் என்பது இலங்கையில் அதிகமாக இருக்கிறது, சீனா ஒன்றும் இலங்கையுடன் நட்புறவு கொள்ளவோ இல்லை தாராள மனப்பான்மையுடனோ இலங்கைக்கு கடன் கொடுத்து அதை கடனாளியாக்க வில்லை. இதெல்லாம் சீனா செய்ததற்கு காரணம் இலங்கை இந்தியாவின் அண்டைநாடு என்ற ஒரு காரணம் தான். இது நம் நாட்டின் பாதுகாப்பு சார்ந்த விஷயம் எத்தனை ஏக்கர் , அதில் வளம் உள்ளதா இல்லையா என்பது பிரச்சினை இல்லை.
Sir i have a doubt, that you have mentioned kacha theevu as disputed area but how did ExPM indhira gandhi gave it to srilanka in a exchange manner when katchatheevu was already with srilanka based on british srilanka consortium in 1920.??
He is spreading lies. After British india, It was held by pillaimar and ahmed. They were the last Indians who had ownership of that land. When it was given to sri lanka, it was purely idnian territory. This guy is bluffing to satisfy dmk.
BJP govt too during multiple meetings of Indian PM with Srilankan PM ignored the request of TN govt regarding kachathev issue. Katchadevula resource onnu illa but it could be a strategic location for defence point of view dane sir, rather using Andaman nicobar against China. Please explain sir
Sir nammma fisherman ku use agura maari why can't we make artificial island like Palm Island. It doesn't affect the Relations between both the countries. We can select the area with minimal environmental problems.
Sir Fishermen issue is entirely different..There is a type of fishing called trawling which is widely banned across the world. This method of fishing is destructive way of fishing as it is excessively sweeping Juveniles along with adults including spawning adults..So fishery resource management advicers of many countries and even FAO either have banned this fishing or allowing in controlled manner for ensuring sustainable resource managment. Sri Lanka is also one of the country that has completely imposed ban on trawl fishing and is allowing non destructive fishing like gillnet and Hooks and line fishing which are less detritus to juvenile as mesh size is big enough to let juveniles escape through.But in India trawling is not banned. Our fishermen were indiscriminately employing this method which resulted resource depletion in and around pak strait area. They fished even to the extend of ploughing bottom area and thereby impacted protected coral eco system which houses small prey fishes for feeding bigger fishes..After this depletion they started moving their fleets to this resource rich Island for exploiting lopster and Prawns. Till then SL govt allowed Indian fishermen who were practicing artesenal fishing method like hooks and line and gillnetting as these methods are environment friendly sustainable methods and widely practiced by SL fishermen..Once our TN trawl fleets entered this territory and started exploiting their resource indiscriminately, fishermen in SL raised this issue in their country. Consequently SL govt reacted with forces against these exploiters for protecting their resources..Still SL govt's stant is they are ready to allow TN artesenal fleets but not trawl fleets. But TN fishermen demands trawls operation in that area which is categarically denied by SL govt in the interest of protecting their resources for their own country fishermen..We had many dialogues earlier..So fault is our side..our political parties with no knowledge are politicising this issue for vote...we too have regulations and acts like mesh regulation and area of operation for trawl fishing but none of them are follwed by trawl fishermen. Here also dispute exists between trawl fishermen and small boats with outboard engine ..But this industry is highly politicised. if govt officials intervene to resolve this issue by existing fishing acts trawl fishermen take aid of political intervention to control upon officials..They never bother about preserving wealth for future..This tendency is running high on TN fishermen's mind when compare to other states of India..
ஐயா நான் IAS ஆகுனும்னு பெரிய ஆசை.ஆனா ஒரு idea இல்லை. உங்களுடன் ஒரு உரையாடல் செய்ய வேண்டும். உதவுவிர்களா. Please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please🙏🙏
Sir but congress alliance with dmk dane, இதத் திரும்ப பெரலனா no confidence raise பன்னுவோம் Or next election ல alliance withdraw பண்ணுவோம்னு சொல்லியிருகலாமே. Even cauvery water issue both BJP and Dmk was silent only
wadge bank பற்றி document உள்ளதா? katchatheevu decide on maritime boundaries .with lot of information he is trying to confuse the listener. Exchange என்ற பொய் சொல்ல வேண்டாம்
Sir, i feel there is no necessity to bring this issue right now..its just political gimmicks...moreover it may affect the friendly relation with srilanka also...because, the ruling government at that time might have done things which would have been right at that point of time..its unfair to go and fight right now....my stand is just come up with mutual diplomatic co-ordination between two nations to allow fishermen from tamilnadu to use that area for fishing without any problems.....and solve this issue amicably...but this could have been done in past 10 years... but in present, Right now there is so much unwanted hatred within India on basis of politics ,religion and also violences across nation, manipur issue, ladakh issue, Electoral bonds etc....govt should focus more on bringing unity and equality in India than all these useless warfare... One thing is we ppl should be united to save our democracy, equality and secularism at all cost irrespective of any political party that comes to power...we should always voice out our truth firmly at all costs...
Sir, please go through the Thamizh scholar's & research intellectuals for the history of Thamizh so that our rich history of Katcha theevu related to Thamizh history will be understood? When you are knowing about Malla's inscription, why have you not known about Thamizh history? Please understand that Chola's were down(or not very strong) and even Pandiyaas started stepping down during Malla's period....... please refer Mr.Ayyanathan to understand the real history.... Please let's not give a different view which is not true.......
India should employ its Navy to safeguard our fishermen and also monitor our fishermen doesnt exceed thier limits and also there should be bilateral agreement to Prevent arrest of our fishermen getting imprisoned for 1 year just for mere fishing violation
Sir monthly magazine for current affairs edachi solluga sir yenaku idha pdf or digital la padika interest ila so shop varga mari edaxhi suggested panuga sir
Israel sir, You explained well about katchateevu.Good.But you failed to do your homework when you released videos on Nitish Kumar rejoining/kajiriwal arrest issues.
@@IsraelJebasinghOfficialwho removed article 6 secretly in 1976.. Please tell that also to your idiotic viewers who believe you.😂😂 How much ever u try its always going to be bjp at centre.😂😂
வாட்ஜ் பேங்க் கன்னியாகுமரியில் இருந்து 50 மைல் மட்டுமே இலங்கையிலிருந்து 250 மைல். இது ஒரு மணல் மேடு நகரும் தன்மையுடைது இத்தனை தூரத்தில் இருக்கும் இடத்திற்குஇலங்கை உரிமை கொண்டாட முடியாது. வங்கதேச எல்லை 1948 இருந்தே பிரச்னை வங்கதேசத்திற்குள் இந்திய கிராமங்களும், இந்தியாவிற்குள் வங்கதேச கிராமங்களும் இருந்தன. இங்குள்ள மக்கள் எந்த நாட்டை சேர்ந்தவர்கள் என்பதே கேள்விக்குறியாக இருந்தது. புதிய ஒப்பந்தத்தின் படி எல்லை கோடு எளிதாக வரையறுக்க முடியும் மேலும் 25000 மேற்பட்ட மக்கள் குடியுரிமை பெற முடியும். இந்த ஒப்பந்தம் நாடாளுமன்றத்தின் இரு அவைகளிலும் அனுமதியோடுதான் நிறைவேற்றப்பட்டது.
Sir I don't want to blame our former prime minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi ji, because of some external relations with Sri Lanka she gave it with some returns but you said a wrong information regarding (Karunanithi) that he was protesting against it for giving, he just wanted to escape from CBI and ED at that time he had many scam allegations against him and Indira ji has rights to implement the presidents rule only for that reasons he kept quiet. I strongly support and agree that Indira Gandhi ji have given that land for external relations which we even got another land with wealth as you said, but kindly don't say that Karunanithi opposed that and protested against it he was afraid that if he oppose that Indira Ji will implement presidents rule by dissolving the regime. Waiting for your reply sir.
சரியாக சொன்னீங்க, கச்சத்தீவு இந்தியாவும் இலங்கையும் பயன்படுத்தி கொள்ளலாம். அதை இரு நாடுகளுக்கும் பொதுவாக பயன்படுத்த agreement பண்ண வேண்டும். இலங்கையின் கலாச்சாரம் மற்றும் பண்பாட்டு நம்முடைய இந்தியா வோடு முக்கியமாக தமிழ்நாட்டோடு ஒத்து போகிறது. அதுமட்டுமின்றி நம்முடைய தமிழ் மக்களும் அங்கு வசிக்கின்றனர். இலங்கையில் நம்ம தமிழ் மொழி ஆட்சி மொழியாகவும் உள்ளது. எனவே நாம் கச்சத்தீவுக்காக இலங்கையின் உறவை விட்டுவிட்டால் சீனா 🇨🇳காரன் அந்த வாய்ப்பை பயன்படுத்திக்கொள்வான். நாம் செய்யும் சில முட்டாள் தனமான காரியங்கள் நம்முடைய எதிரிகளுக்கு சாதகமாக இருக்கும். எந்த அளவுக்கு இலங்கையிடம் பேச்சுவார்த்தை நடத்தி உறவை வலுப்படுத்த முடியுமோ அது தான் நல்லது , இலங்கை மட்டும் முழுவதும் சீனா🇨🇳 வசமாகிவிட்டால் தென் இந்தியாவின் பாதுகாப்பு கேள்விக்குறி தான்.
Sir, thank you for the explanation Sir, most important at this hour, if possible Please add the island came into existence due to some volcanic eruption, Smt Gandhi gve as an strategic move after operation buddha. Thnk you Sir
u r not neutral sir..,u point of view is one-sided..u r totally against bjp..,ivalo clear ah solringa ...,berubari case yethunala nadanthathu num solliruklamae sir..(its against the nehru-noon agreement)this border issue is started during nehru period..and bjp government solves it in the 100th amendment of constitution.
and 1 more thing kattcha theevu la yaarum vaazhala nu solringa crtu than but antha surrounding la than fishing nadakuthu..,so only prblm..., intha prblm ah core ah use pannama anga people vaazhrathu ilanu solli yevlo divert panna mudiyumo avalo pannitinga..super sir ..
intha problem ah civil servant ku padikuravangaluku nalla theriyum nu solli..pora pokula oru statement sollitu poitinga..,nan previous ah sonna statement ah purinjika tnpsc aspirant ah erunthale pothum.. internet la oru information yaaruna (ivara maathiri oru person)sonna direct ah nambathinga da..knjm avathu research pannunga..!
His point is , what is the need to speak this issue just before election... BJP didn't know this matter from 2014 - 2024 ??? if this is wrong waht about shiachen glacier n arunchal pradesh occupied by China after 2014????? Who should be neutral now????
In this era/generation, they want everything in 30 secs. 😢😢 So they believe/manipulate anything easily😮. Research panna ready illa. Thanks for this detailed and clear explanation 📚📚👏👏
Thanks
தயவுசெய்து இந்த காணெளியை ஆங்கிலம் மற்றும் இந்தி மொழிகளில் வெளியிட்டு வட இந்திய சகோதரர்களுக்கு கச்ச தீவு சர்ச்சையின் உண்மைகளை தெளிவுப்படுத்த வேண்டும். அருமையான பதிவு. பாராட்டிற்குரி முயற்சி. நன்றி ஐயா 🙏🏻
There are so many channels out there
சரியான நேரத்தில் சரியான தகவல் தந்தமைக்கு நன்றி
Most Welcome
ரொம்ப அருமை ரொம்ப தெளிவான ஒரு விளக்கம் தந்துள்ளீர்கள் ஒரு கடினமான ஒரு பேசு பொருளைப் பற்றி தெளிவாக விவரமாக பேசி உள்ளீர்கள். அருமை ஐயா
Thanks
அருமையான விளக்கம் இபொழுது தான் உண்மை என்னவென்று தெரிகிறது
Thankyou
@@IsraelJebasinghOfficial😊😊
L
L😊l
😊l
@@IsraelJebasinghOfficial😊😊
L
L😊l
😊l
O
Well explained sir 🎉🎉🎉 Today my professor asked about this issue in class. Now I got clear answer.❤ BJP just taking this issue in hand only for vote politics.
அருமையான விளக்கம் ஐயா...
நடுநிலையான விளக்கம் கொடுத்தீர்கள் , அரசியல் வாதிகள் மக்களை குழப்பிக் கொன்டு இருக்கும் நேரம்... எங்களை நேர் வழியில் நடத்துகிறீர்கள் நன்றி 🙏
Thanks
This video shows difference between Ex IAS Israel Jebasingh Sir ❤ and Ex IPS 🐐 Annamalai 😂 ...
Poi Puzhuguni Aatukutti Annamalai 😂😂
@VasanthKumar-jk5jr🐐😂
Yeah, clearly there's a difference between a man who had a very successful IPS career & highly famous and clean throughout his service, resigned his job just like that and entered politics for good cause unlike others who acted in cinema and with dumbest head entered politics, some others who play flute for the gopalapuram family and being slaves to them...
Annamalai's political career is just 3 years old brother and he already made you boil, right from gopalapuram kothadimais to half informed tharkuris😂...
This video shows difference between EX IAS Israel jebasingh and EX IPS Annamalai and EX IPS Ravi😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@senthil3770 if u so struggled in TN governance better To go n live happily with ur family girls in UP , MANIPUR.... y u live in state of adimai ruling???? 😂😂😂😂😂
Best explanation sir 💥💥💥... All are doing politics with this issue but only you explained the indepth and clear explanation in different point of views... You never failed to impress us sir ✨❤️
Thanks
No one is talking about a piece of land received as quid pro quo. You did. Thanks for the information 😊
சரியான நேரத்தில் சரியான தகவல். நன்றி
Thanks
Waiting for your video for this issue to clarify the doubts
as usual, a crystal clear explanation. thank u sir
So nice of you
Excellent and a needed explanation Brother. 🎉
Excellent sir Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent 💯
Sir clean and clear explanation 🎉🎉
Thanks and welcome
I find ii hard to fanthom when the video starting from 1195 year about Sri Lanka ownership. If we go early India should claim northern part of Sri Lanka as they were under Tamil kings rule for ages. But we can't go by this logic.
The picture starts with leasing of this island to British by king of Ramnad. A strong evidence. The bug stops here in my view and it is clearly belongs to India.
❤
Thanks for awareness sir
Eye opening and therila nu solrathu politics aah kooda irukkum sir...ellaa election naadagam...but good to hear clear explanation..... Thankyou Sir
அண்ணாமலை அவர்களுக்கு நன்றி கச்சதீவு பற்றி அறிந்து கொள்வதற்கு காரணமாக இருந்த
It is an open history, not necessarily RTI required.
🐐: - 🐐kutty annamalai nu sollu😂
Thanks for your always clear and evidential explanations, even retired genuine officers join politics, also they fell in to dirty politics, all politics power
Thanks
Sir....after long time to see you...I'm happy ...
So nice of you
Sir! IPS Exam ku obc caste candidates 160cm height eruntha pothu ma sir. Pls reply me!!!
அருமையான விளக்கம் sir. காங்கிரஸ் தவறு செய்துவிட்டது ஏற்று கொள்கிறோம் ஆனால் அவர் செய்த தவறை பிஜேபி அரசு செய்ய கூடாது. இதை வைத்து இரண்டு அரசு அரசியல் செய்து கொண்டு இருக்கிறது. ஆனால் என்னுடைய தனிப்பட்ட கருத்து என்னவென்றால். காங்கிரஸ் அரசு சரி இல்லை என்று தான் பிஜேபி அரசு வந்தது இவர்களும் காங்கிரஸ் குறை சொல்ல கூடாது...
Bro Congress thavrelam panala😂😂.. actually wadge bank ah vankanumnuthan kaatcha theva India kuduthuchi same date rendumai exchange panikitanga😂😂....BJP yen wadge bank pathi peasa matinguthuna anga crude extraction tender vida poranunga 200% adani kuthan athu pogum🤣😂..athu veliya therinja BJP eechagalukuthan problem athan reason 😂😂...
Arumaiyana vilakkam
use full message sir
Prior to last ten years period we used to see daily news of our fishermen going to srilankan jail. All sort of story of their sufferings. But last ten years we don't see that much news. May be our foreign/external ministry is doing commendable job or fast to respond etc. To be I had seen this decreased a lot.. please clarify
A nice and clear explanation of the issue.. Sir
Clear explanation sir..thank you ❤
You are welcome
நன்றி சார் 🎉❤
Thank you sir ❤
Sir kindly upload video about upsc exam syllabus
Thank you sir for excellent clarification on this dispute
Thanks
It is quite an explanation but from such a Senior Official I expected more. Your talk should have covered these points also.
1. Every party will explore the possibility of raking up an issue if some evidences are available to them and if used effectively will get them few more votes. The point is whether DMK is aware about this or not before it happened? In this instant case, BJP had exposed some documents which clearly establish that DMK is aware about “கச்சத்தீவு” even before the decision was taken.
2. All including you, haven’t explained why this Article 6 was deleted and is it because of this deletion our fisherman are being harassed by Sri Lankan Navy?
3. Some more information on the positive and negative sides of the issue would have helped.
Absolutely Right Sir
Sir good explanation in election controversy time and it gives clarity to aspirants
Thanks
It is a small piece of land. I don't mind to conceding it.
According to annamalai this has to do with international line around the area and a wealth resources of fish in those areas. Tamil fishermen used to fishing in those area traditionally for ages. After this ceding our fishermen were going to srilankan jail regularly affecting their livelihood as this ceding lead to breaching the international line. Please eloborate this side of the story on factual accuracy.
நேருஜி சொன்னதை தான் இவரும் சொல்கிறார்... அங்க ஒன்னுமில்லை அது ஒன்னுக்கும் ஆகாது ஒரு IAS Officer சொல்லுவது not good... திருடன் திருடியது தப்பு இல்லை... நீங்கள் திருடு போனதை சொன்னது தான் தவறு... 1910ல் எதோ church இருந்ததாம் அது ஶ்ரீலங்கா control ல இருந்ததாம் அதனால் அவங்களுடையது முடிவு செய்யப் பட்டதாம்... இதுவேல்லாம் okay மீன் பிடிக்கும் உரிமையையும் தாரைவார்த்ததை ஏன் இவர் சொல்லவில்லை... he told BJP is not good... Okay... DMK and Congress are excellent parties of India because the parties are marder the Tamil people of Srilanka... Keep it up Sir...
Yes he is support Congress dmk
FULL VIDEO paathingala😂😂
Wadge bank number oru edam eruka 😂😂
Great Sir
Thanks, sir, but you missed explaining the sea level of permission near the island-of Sri Lanka, which has more power and sea control due to the island. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
Another important piece of information is that DMK was in alliance with Congress I called Indra Congress till July 1976 ( emergency started time). So Karunanidhi couldn't use this alliance!!!
Little correction sir. It appears that our minister Jayashankar is talking about a minutes of meeting held in st George fort chenna, in October 1973, Mr Karunanidhi concurred to proposal to tranfer kaccha theevu to Ceylon.
It is clamed that Karunanidhi conceded this as one of the favours to Delhi to sink the findings of sarkaria commission against him. It appears all the ostensibly token agitation were done as a part of stage management drama by Karunanidhi to deceive public. As kid, I could recall wherever I went house of relatives and friends, this was the talk of the town. Elders used to scold Karunanidhi for his acting and call him a thief.
Looking back now this looks like a beginning of the fall of Karunanidhi. I also recall that 1975/76 when Karunanidhi and his men were put into jail under MISA. Stalin also went to jail I think. I could sense people were happy to see him in jail. Around the same time (1976/77) MGR emerged as a power house breaking away from DMK and went on to become CM . It is not that just charisma of MGR but people hatred against Karunanidhi kept him away from police till th death of MGR.
Remember Karunanidhi is a very outstanding dramatist, story writer and excellent script writer in addition to exemplary oratory skills and believed that these skills can manage anything and get away. But skills can only take you some where and you need a value to stay there longer which MGR have had in tons.
Better write movie story yu will get chance
@@Sparkler-lr1uf thank you..good Idea. Would like this theme to develop into a full fledged script
@@shanthalakshmi2082 send it to me once done
Super explanation sir ❤
Thanks and welcome
Sir- international waters and so many fishermen’s life compromised by this handover which happened behind the doors. This decision clearly shows the vision of our leaders. Getting back something which was given like this is never going to be easy and may take many years. At the least as a damage control fishing by our Indian fishermen should be allowed and more so no more arrests of them should be negotiated by whom so ever is in power.
Super sir
பொய் மனிதர்களின் உண்மையான முக திரையை கிழித்து விட்டதற்கு நன்றி! வாய்மையே வெல்லும்! பொய்யும் பொய்யர்களும் சாகும்!!!
Thanks
Very great sir🎉🎉
Thankyou
Super sir vera level
Many of the youtuber's are giving only a partial data which suppresses the Thamizh's welfare.... still you seem to be good..... Many view's are to be changed sir..... Last view is a good one sir ...Our Fishermen should be benefited.......
Good afternoon sir i have a dout sir who is powerfull sir an magiatrate or an ias pfficer
Sir, Today I have seen a video in "The wire" interview of Nirumaba subramaninan who is saying that Wadge Bank and Katcha Theevu were mutually accepted by India during Bilateral talks .
Hai sir
I start preparation for upsc last 3 months but 1week before I did minor fitsula opration .there is a any chances for disqualify in Medical test sir .I consult my doctor but he dont know about that sir
Very well explained Bro.Isreal Jebasingh and i don't think anyone can explain these details . Are there any customs there as you mentioned about visa requirements. I am following your other political explanation and it's too good . Please keep updating about Kejriwal news
Kennedy
Mumbai
Thanks
அருமை சார்
What is the benefits of sethu project and why unable to start the project?
Sir,
I Come to know that fishing and arresting our fishermen are different issue. No catch is available near Katcha theevu now but available in Srilanka waters. Is is true Sir?
All problems are due to Union Government only. Everything is perfect with state government, Right Sir ??
Sir pls clarify that upsc group 'A' ips officer salary and group 'B' ips officer salary..is it same for both or different? Orelse put a video like upsc group A ips officers vs Group B Pondicherry ips offcers in details....how group B ips officers selected nd their training,posting , salary, how cadre are allocated after upsc exam to group B officer ...
Main thing is after upsc main examination,how they are selected to group B Pondicherry police service,how they r allocated,cadre details and am an upsc aspirant i want to choose Pondicherry police service (group B)...pls clarify everything sir!
Sir பங்ளா தேசத்திற்கு எவ்வளவு நிலம் கொடுத்தோம், கச்சத்தீவிற்கு எவ்வளவு நிலம் என்பது இங்கு பிரச்சனை கிடையாது , கச்சத்தீவு தீவு , இலங்கை என்பது சீனாவிற்கு அருகில் உள்ளது மேலும் சீனாவின் ஊடுருவல் என்பது இலங்கையில் அதிகமாக இருக்கிறது, சீனா ஒன்றும் இலங்கையுடன் நட்புறவு கொள்ளவோ இல்லை தாராள மனப்பான்மையுடனோ இலங்கைக்கு கடன் கொடுத்து அதை கடனாளியாக்க வில்லை. இதெல்லாம் சீனா செய்ததற்கு காரணம் இலங்கை இந்தியாவின் அண்டைநாடு என்ற ஒரு காரணம் தான். இது நம் நாட்டின் பாதுகாப்பு சார்ந்த விஷயம் எத்தனை ஏக்கர் , அதில் வளம் உள்ளதா இல்லையா என்பது பிரச்சினை இல்லை.
Sir i have a doubt, that you have mentioned kacha theevu as disputed area but how did ExPM indhira gandhi gave it to srilanka in a exchange manner when katchatheevu was already with srilanka based on british srilanka consortium in 1920.??
He is spreading lies. After British india, It was held by pillaimar and ahmed. They were the last Indians who had ownership of that land. When it was given to sri lanka, it was purely idnian territory. This guy is bluffing to satisfy dmk.
@@MrRaghavann So u r bluffing to satisfy BJP...😂😂
@@MrRaghavannseringa sir poi case podunga
exlant Explain 🎉❤
Thanks
Super sir...
What about article 6 in that issue sir??can u pls explain abt this sir??
BJP govt too during multiple meetings of Indian PM with Srilankan PM ignored the request of TN govt regarding kachathev issue.
Katchadevula resource onnu illa but it could be a strategic location for defence point of view dane sir, rather using Andaman nicobar against China.
Please explain sir
Nice explanation sir...
Thanks
👍👍👍
Sir ias officers can invest in share market
Well explained sir 👍
Thanks
Sir nammma fisherman ku use agura maari why can't we make artificial island like Palm Island. It doesn't affect the Relations between both the countries. We can select the area with minimal environmental problems.
Sir said no fishing activities is happening near katchathevu both srilanka and India
Then why artificial island??
Thank you sir
Welcome
Wadge bank பற்றி இன்னும் சொல்லி இருக்கணும். It is a strategic defence point
Sir Fishermen issue is entirely different..There is a type of fishing called trawling which is widely banned across the world. This method of fishing is destructive way of fishing as it is excessively sweeping Juveniles along with adults including spawning adults..So fishery resource management advicers of many countries and even FAO either have banned this fishing or allowing in controlled manner for ensuring sustainable resource managment. Sri Lanka is also one of the country that has completely imposed ban on trawl fishing and is allowing non destructive fishing like gillnet and Hooks and line fishing which are less detritus to juvenile as mesh size is big enough to let juveniles escape through.But in India trawling is not banned. Our fishermen were indiscriminately employing this method which resulted resource depletion in and around pak strait area. They fished even to the extend of ploughing bottom area and thereby impacted protected coral eco system which houses small prey fishes for feeding bigger fishes..After this depletion they started moving their fleets to this resource rich Island for exploiting lopster and Prawns. Till then SL govt allowed Indian fishermen who were practicing artesenal fishing method like hooks and line and gillnetting as these methods are environment friendly sustainable methods and widely practiced by SL fishermen..Once our TN trawl fleets entered this territory and started exploiting their resource indiscriminately, fishermen in SL raised this issue in their country. Consequently SL govt reacted with forces against these exploiters for protecting their resources..Still SL govt's stant is they are ready to allow TN artesenal fleets but not trawl fleets. But TN fishermen demands trawls operation in that area which is categarically denied by SL govt in the interest of protecting their resources for their own country fishermen..We had many dialogues earlier..So fault is our side..our political parties with no knowledge are politicising this issue for vote...we too have regulations and acts like mesh regulation and area of operation for trawl fishing but none of them are follwed by trawl fishermen. Here also dispute exists between trawl fishermen and small boats with outboard engine ..But this industry is highly politicised. if govt officials intervene to resolve this issue by existing fishing acts trawl fishermen take aid of political intervention to control upon officials..They never bother about preserving wealth for future..This tendency is running high on TN fishermen's mind when compare to other states of India..
ஐயா நான் IAS ஆகுனும்னு பெரிய ஆசை.ஆனா ஒரு idea இல்லை. உங்களுடன் ஒரு உரையாடல் செய்ய வேண்டும். உதவுவிர்களா. Please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please🙏🙏
While attacking bjp......firemode 🔥🔥🔥
While attacking dmk and congress........soft mode😅
😂
Please upload video about modi dictatorship in india. Kindly requesting you sir🙏🙏🙏
Balancing report
Super na
Arunachal pradesh, Akshay chin 😂 became more horrible in NDA period but now kachateevu is talking point.😅
😊😊😊great
Sir please upload how to read newspaper for upsc
Done video in Officers Path RUclips channel
Recent politics trend.. Twitter trend...
Sir but congress alliance with dmk dane, இதத் திரும்ப பெரலனா no confidence raise பன்னுவோம் Or next election ல alliance withdraw பண்ணுவோம்னு சொல்லியிருகலாமே.
Even cauvery water issue both BJP and Dmk was silent only
This video shows difference between EX IAS Israel jebasingh and EX IPS Annamalai and EX IPS Ravi😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ok
wadge bank பற்றி document உள்ளதா? katchatheevu decide on maritime boundaries .with lot of information he is trying to confuse the listener. Exchange என்ற பொய் சொல்ல வேண்டாம்
Sir please ask petrol price
Sir, i feel there is no necessity to bring this issue right now..its just political gimmicks...moreover it may affect the friendly relation with srilanka also...because, the ruling government at that time might have done things which would have been right at that point of time..its unfair to go and fight right now....my stand is just come up with mutual diplomatic co-ordination between two nations to allow fishermen from tamilnadu to use that area for fishing without any problems.....and solve this issue amicably...but this could have been done in past 10 years... but in present,
Right now there is so much unwanted hatred within India on basis of politics ,religion and also violences across nation, manipur issue, ladakh issue, Electoral bonds etc....govt should focus more on bringing unity and equality in India than all these useless warfare...
One thing is we ppl should be united to save our democracy, equality and secularism at all cost irrespective of any political party that comes to power...we should always voice out our truth firmly at all costs...
True
Sir, please go through the Thamizh scholar's & research intellectuals for the history of Thamizh so that our rich history of Katcha theevu related to Thamizh history will be understood? When you are knowing about Malla's inscription, why have you not known about Thamizh history? Please understand that Chola's were down(or not very strong) and even Pandiyaas started stepping down during Malla's period....... please refer Mr.Ayyanathan to understand the real history.... Please let's not give a different view which is not true.......
India should employ its Navy to safeguard our fishermen and also monitor our fishermen doesnt exceed thier limits and also there should be bilateral agreement to Prevent arrest of our fishermen getting imprisoned for 1 year just for mere fishing violation
Yes
Sir monthly magazine for current affairs edachi solluga sir yenaku idha pdf or digital la padika interest ila so shop varga mari edaxhi suggested panuga sir
Officers Pulse
@@IsraelJebasinghOfficial where can I get that and i need hard copy and not soft copy like pdf
It's available in officers ias academy website. You can take printout.
Israel sir, You explained well about katchateevu.Good.But you failed to do your homework when you released videos on Nitish Kumar rejoining/kajiriwal arrest issues.
Ok
@@IsraelJebasinghOfficialwho removed article 6 secretly in 1976.. Please tell that also to your idiotic viewers who believe you.😂😂
How much ever u try its always going to be bjp at centre.😂😂
🙏🙏🙏🥰🇮🇳
வாட்ஜ் பேங்க் கன்னியாகுமரியில் இருந்து 50 மைல் மட்டுமே இலங்கையிலிருந்து 250 மைல். இது ஒரு மணல் மேடு நகரும் தன்மையுடைது இத்தனை தூரத்தில் இருக்கும் இடத்திற்குஇலங்கை உரிமை கொண்டாட முடியாது.
வங்கதேச எல்லை 1948 இருந்தே பிரச்னை வங்கதேசத்திற்குள் இந்திய கிராமங்களும், இந்தியாவிற்குள் வங்கதேச கிராமங்களும் இருந்தன. இங்குள்ள மக்கள் எந்த நாட்டை சேர்ந்தவர்கள் என்பதே கேள்விக்குறியாக இருந்தது. புதிய ஒப்பந்தத்தின் படி எல்லை கோடு எளிதாக வரையறுக்க முடியும் மேலும் 25000 மேற்பட்ட மக்கள் குடியுரிமை பெற முடியும். இந்த ஒப்பந்தம் நாடாளுமன்றத்தின் இரு அவைகளிலும் அனுமதியோடுதான் நிறைவேற்றப்பட்டது.
6:48 ஒன்றிய அரசு பூனைக்குட்டி வெளியே வந்துருச்சி 😡😡😡
ஒன்றியத்தை ஒன்றியம்னுதானே சொல்ல முடியும்😂😂😂😂😂
@@lazad9482what is the meaning for ondriyam in English?
@@SelvaKumar-mg8xr union
Union government than actual govt.
@@SelvaKumar-mg8xrUnion Government of India
Sir I don't want to blame our former prime minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi ji, because of some external relations with Sri Lanka she gave it with some returns but you said a wrong information regarding (Karunanithi) that he was protesting against it for giving, he just wanted to escape from CBI and ED at that time he had many scam allegations against him and Indira ji has rights to implement the presidents rule only for that reasons he kept quiet.
I strongly support and agree that Indira Gandhi ji have given that land for external relations which we even got another land with wealth as you said, but kindly don't say that Karunanithi opposed that and protested against it he was afraid that if he oppose that Indira Ji will implement presidents rule by dissolving the regime.
Waiting for your reply sir.
Naa idha paththi enna nenaikire naa sir neenga politics varalam nu nenikire😊
சரியாக சொன்னீங்க, கச்சத்தீவு இந்தியாவும் இலங்கையும் பயன்படுத்தி கொள்ளலாம். அதை இரு நாடுகளுக்கும் பொதுவாக பயன்படுத்த agreement பண்ண வேண்டும். இலங்கையின் கலாச்சாரம் மற்றும் பண்பாட்டு நம்முடைய இந்தியா வோடு முக்கியமாக தமிழ்நாட்டோடு ஒத்து போகிறது. அதுமட்டுமின்றி நம்முடைய தமிழ் மக்களும் அங்கு வசிக்கின்றனர். இலங்கையில் நம்ம தமிழ் மொழி ஆட்சி மொழியாகவும் உள்ளது. எனவே நாம் கச்சத்தீவுக்காக இலங்கையின் உறவை விட்டுவிட்டால் சீனா 🇨🇳காரன் அந்த வாய்ப்பை பயன்படுத்திக்கொள்வான். நாம் செய்யும் சில முட்டாள் தனமான காரியங்கள் நம்முடைய எதிரிகளுக்கு சாதகமாக இருக்கும். எந்த அளவுக்கு இலங்கையிடம் பேச்சுவார்த்தை நடத்தி உறவை வலுப்படுத்த முடியுமோ அது தான் நல்லது , இலங்கை மட்டும் முழுவதும் சீனா🇨🇳 வசமாகிவிட்டால் தென் இந்தியாவின் பாதுகாப்பு கேள்விக்குறி தான்.
Sir, thank you for the explanation Sir, most important at this hour, if possible Please add the island came into existence due to some volcanic eruption, Smt Gandhi gve as an strategic move after operation buddha. Thnk you Sir
True
Dei pulugandi, dmk and admk vaaye thorakala😂😂 parliamrnt la. Seri nee ottu mutta pasanga pakura varai unaku varumanam dhan.😂
Hello😂
u r not neutral sir..,u point of view is one-sided..u r totally against bjp..,ivalo clear ah solringa ...,berubari case yethunala nadanthathu num solliruklamae sir..(its against the nehru-noon agreement)this border issue is started during nehru period..and bjp government solves it in the 100th amendment of constitution.
and 1 more thing kattcha theevu la yaarum vaazhala nu solringa crtu than but antha surrounding la than fishing nadakuthu..,so only prblm..., intha prblm ah core ah use pannama anga people vaazhrathu ilanu solli yevlo divert panna mudiyumo avalo pannitinga..super sir ..
intha problem ah civil servant ku padikuravangaluku nalla theriyum nu solli..pora pokula oru statement sollitu poitinga..,nan previous ah sonna statement ah purinjika tnpsc aspirant ah erunthale pothum..
internet la oru information yaaruna (ivara maathiri oru person)sonna direct ah nambathinga da..knjm avathu research pannunga..!
@@seenusivathmika3085 yes , same suits fr annamalai...
His point is , what is the need to speak this issue just before election... BJP didn't know this matter from 2014 - 2024 ??? if this is wrong waht about shiachen glacier n arunchal pradesh occupied by China after 2014????? Who should be neutral now????
@@sanjeevsanjay1356China is claiming hasn't occupied srunachal pradesh get your facts right.😂
blasted sir
Thanks
Katchchathivula HINDU temple irundave ni india ku support panna matta...Niye oru Christian missionary apo yaruku support pannuvenu teriumda