There is no such thing as a pitch perfect vocalist 100% of the time. Live concert set's are long and extremely difficult to maintain at studio level especially for vocalist. But Amy come's pretty damn close to that level of perfection. She pore's her heart and soul into every song she sings. And that's enough for me.
i just wanted to say .......I love lacuna coil , sirenia, nightwish, halestorm, epica .......but only songs from evanescence can touch my heart so deep , that i could cry all day and night !!!!!!!!! She's got a voice like an angel !!!!
100 percent agree with you, everybody can't pull it off all the time. I seen her live and she was amazing. they 2 ediots at the top saying she needs to lower her tone....Ha! It wouldn't be Evanescence if she done that. ppl have bad days, voices are shakes at times, doesn't mean she needs to change her genre of music
+ヒルホリクロエ Not true. My vocal master do not really like her actually. I'm a massive fan and the first time he told me she's not that good I was not happy, but he's right. She's not a really bad singer, but her technique is not good. She lacks her lower notes and she does not use her mixed voice properly: sometimes she forces her chest voice causing herself damage and lack of control during the transitions between chest and head voice.
+Riccardoderek your vocal master is wrong. how can you listen to them? have they sold millions of albums? have they sold out gigs in just about every developed country in the world? I think not! what make your vocal master so much better??
Joe Thomas Sorry, but your opinion is so wrong. Many bad singers sold millions of album because they make good music or because they just got syle. But that doesn't mean their singing technique is bad.
I don't believe that she's a bad singer at all, she's the best I've ever heard. Even when she's singing live, she still sings a LOT better than most singers.
When I put on an Evanesence, my friend was like, "what the heck is this? She's a horrible singer. Put on something that has meaning like R5!" I literally slapped her.
Every singer has off performances. There was a few a few instances there that she was slightly off. But these bands tour sometimes 300 days a year. She is an excellent singer with a haunting pitch. But dont expect perfection every time.
i'm a little monster and i love Lady Gaga so much she has amazing strong vocals but Amy Lee will always and forever be the number one best voice i've ever listened to . you can recognize her voice even if you are not a fan or even if you never listened to the song before it's just so mesmerizing .
So...??? Does she have to sing every song that you command her to sing. Who the Hell are you to demand anything of her. If you are as good a singer as she is, go out there and do what she's doing and become as popular as she is, then come back and show me in a video how much better you are than her.
Alissa White-Gluz, Maria "Masha Scream" Arkhipova, Floor Jansen, Annette Olzon, Angela Gossow, Simone Simons, Anna Murphy, and the oh so obligatory mention of Tarja Turunen.
Jörg Krause OOowh, yeah she's also good. But I like Amy's voice. Everybody has a different taste. If everybody liked green apples we would not have green apples anymore and to much yellow and red apples.
Baby wake up. I've never ever ever EVER in my life heard ppl saying that Amy Lee can't sing. About Bieber, Rihanna, Taylor, even Lana... yes. But Amy? Never.
She's just PERFECT! Evanescence songs are usually hard to sing but she does sooo well, it's normal when in a concert everything isn't perfect, but let's ask another singer to do what she does and sing the way she do, she has tooooo much talent, for me is PERFECT!
Does anyone know how hard her songs are plus her vocal range is monstrous I have heard other versions of her songs but no one could do it better why would anyone say she can't sing everyone has there mess ups,I am just saying I am a huge fan of her voice, never heard one like it
Does Amy have bad performances? Yes, but every artist has them. You're not gonna be on your A game every concert. You're just not. She puts so much effort into her performances that sometimes she might not sound the greatest. With that being said, it's obvious she can sing. Anyone who disagrees really needs to look up the facts. I have listened to the acoustic versions of some of their songs and I was blown away and got chills. And yes, I've watched concerts that were normal and not acoustic and she did awesome too. She's up and down but that doesn't make her a bad singer. Amy Lee in my opinion is in the top 10 vocalists of our generation. Unfortunately, she doesn't get the credit she deserves. Also, people really need to stop comparing her to Tarja or Sharon etc. She and them have different voices.
JansenMaYaN I don't need to watch it. Mainly because the link isn't working....but I've seen her bad performances. However, I've seen her sing beautifully too. So how can you say she can't sing when she has good performances too and everyone that knows her, especially in the band, says what a beautiful voice she has? It's common sense. Also way to say that on a video that proves she can sing....
Згодна щодо голосів. Слухаю і Тарью і Крістіну Скабіа, і Емі, і Шерон але саме тому, що вони різні. Це доповнює жанр, він стає банатогранним. Колись мене теж намагались переконати, що вона погано співає, порівнювали її акустичний спів із співом Шерон. Не переконали.:)) Дійсно дуже мало співаків, що один в один відтворюють студійний звук, т.б. з тих виконавців які поєднують з електронним звуком. Акустика узагалі складна річ. Вона вимагає академічності, так само як піаніно. З тих, хто на сцені звучить так само як в студії я знаю тільки вокаліста Квін (Queen Freddie Mercury). Це взагалі помилка вважати, що звук має бути ідентичним. Він повинен відрізнятися. Голос повинен відповідати звуку інструменту. Різні інструменти = різне виконання.
After a while, your vocal cords can get tired and day after day with all that singing, that's got to put strain even heavier on them. I used to sing karaoke and after about five or six songs, my throat couldn't do it. Big props to all musicians, having to do this day in and day out, especially those with masterful skills like Amy. Even a goddess can get worn out.
Exactly. .. that's what everyone dosent understand when they tour it takes a toll on your vocal cords..playing from city to city. .by the way i don't even know why this nitwit uploaded this garbage. lol. . Trying to compare if she is a good singer. . She is a professional nitwit. . lol gosh man people these days... it never seems to amaze me.
Jessie Nebulous [Cripple Gamer Chick] Yes... This guy is trying to let people know that she is a good singer, but we already know that she is a good singer. .. what's with the vid? That's what I don't understand. . What's he trying to prove actually? ??
JR Black It's self-explanatory, really. The creator explains that they have encountered people criticizing Amy's live vocals, and they made this video explaining that singing live (vs lip syncing) have various factors involved and the performance is not going to sound exactly the same as the recorded version. I've run into people complaining that she sounds different live, and I generally say something to the same effect as this video (perhaps in a more coherent manner; I'm a writer, and the video creator is clearly not). It just sounds like you haven't run into anyone making those criticisms about her but believe me, some people don't like her voice. I don't understand it, but everyone likes different things. But that's what the video is trying to "prove."
People need to stop saying that she can't sing. Cause she can! I want every person that has ever said that she can't sing try to sing one of her songs!
RandomPerson, oh boy - I wish them luck! As someone who has tried and is finally able to sing some (without anyone else listening mind you) - that‘s NOT EASY!
I told my friend to listen to Evanescence. He listened to, "Call Me When You're Sober" (I love that one❤️) He said that she was good (wrong, she's AMAZING!), but the next day, he said that was her only good song. I almost did an uppercut on him😂😂😂😂😂he's lucky I didn't 😂😏
i saw her in 2012, chile, and her live performance was such an amazing thing, she sings pretty much better than from his albums, she made every single person on the arena cry by the emotion,
Plus she carries it all off whilst playing piano and/or the harp, also near to perfectly. I think she has one of the most powerful current female voices in music. I went to one of their concerts a couple of years ago and I didn't hear one bum note in the entire performance. I think sometimes its more to do with bad sound level at the performance, as it must be very hard with such powerful songs to keep the backing music low enough so that the vocalist isn't struggling to keep their voice audible. At the concert I went to the sound was spot on for someone with a voice as strong as hers. Though I couldn't have been heard above it if I screamed in one pitch note! lol
I happen to love Amy Lee, but I do want to point two things out: 1) Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and none of those opinions are wrong. That's why they are opinions. 2) For anyone saying that Amy can't sing live, I'd like you to try running around a stage for two hours singing the way she does and then criticize her. Rant over :)
Let me just start out by saying i LOVE amy lee. She has a beautiful voice, great presence, and an impressive range. But her technique is terrible. Itsnot an insult, but sometimes i literally worry that shes going to blow her voice out. Her breathing is awful, she gasps for breath (which does have a lot to do with running all over the stage. HOWEVER, i believe that you shouldnt sacrifice the quality of your singing just to put on a good rock show), and ive noticed also that with the high notes, she seems to go for vocal gymnastics rather than quality singing. Her range is impressive, again, but she sings through her throat and nose, shes often pitchy and raspy, and at times it actually sounds painful. I AM NOT SAYING AMY IS A BAD SINGER. But she abuses her vocal cord in a way that is appalling. She shows no respect for that beautiful voice,and im just afraid that if she doesnt start doing something different, shes going to lose it
ehh. I was in a freakishly picky, critical mood that night and I feel like a dick for this comment. I would KILL for her pipes. I'm a singer too (not in her league, obviously) and I abuse the hell out of my voice, which is probably why I'll never make it to superstardom. I think the above comment was genuinely made out of concern for the longevity of her voice though. it would be a crime if one day Amy lost her voice and didn't get it back. :(
actually... yes I did notice that. the concerts in 2015 were on POINT. I think the ones I was referring to may have just been a few off/sick nights back in 2012. I actually thought that between 2003-2012, her live performances grew more strained (except for the acoustic shows. unearthly good). but I also heard something about her being sick for quite a few shows so I'm sure that would do it. anyway... back to what you were saying... yes. especially in recent years, she's gotten better. I also failed to account for the fact that with each new album, she's singing more and more vocally challenging material. the self-titled album? good god. I'm pretty sure ONE night of singing that stuff would blow my voice out. ha. anyway yeah. if I could choose between having a trained, but just good nothing special about it voice and having a voice like Amy's, not professionally trained... well I think you know the answer to that. anyway, rant aside... I know what you mean. especially between 2012 and now, her voice and singing skills have soared to new heights. that new cover EP? she brought that whole chill-inducing-with-her-voice factor to a whole 'nother level. sorry. I can go on and on in my comments if you haven't noticed. ANYWAY... the main point of this was that I had no right to be critical. I'm definitely not up there doing what she does night after night, and it would be a huge stretch to say I have even half her vocal talent. thanks for being cool about me being a prissy amateur music critic XP
I agree. She has a potential to sing perfectly but with her wrong technique she's killing her voice. My former vocal teacher would kill me for that way of singing.
Its Annoys Me ! When I Hear Comments Like ( Amy Can`t Sing OR Her Voice Isn`t Hight Enuogh or Something Like That ! ) What The Hell You Want To Hear !! Better Than This !? IMPOSSIBLE !! She Became A Mother & New Music Is Avalable Now ! We Saw Her Concerts & We Could Hear Her Voice Well ! We Know Exactley How She Sing ! !! She`s Just Amazing ! Hot ! Perfect !!! I Just Can`t Believe That Amy Has Haters !! You Can`t Hear Her Voice & Say That She wasn`t Good Enough !!! YOU CAN`T SAY IT !!!!! Bcoz Her Reality Voice Can`t Let You Say All Of That pullshits !! >_
So do I Amy Lee is my idol. She inspires me keep singing because my friends say I can sing like Amy Lee wen I showed thim her. Also she will never stop being amazing and beautiful to me. If you disagree then ok but that's how I feel
Amy is perfect by nature and justin bieber lovers prefer fake useless popstars instead of someone real like Amy. I'm glad you guys and I aren't blind like them. :)
Even Christina Aguilera with her power house vocals has her bad days. You can have a big voice and use it so much and expect to have it flawless everyday.
People seem to expect high notes from all female singers these days, or they "are no good". But look at Bonnie Taylor. Her songs were (and still are) great "classic rock ballads". You can't expect all women to be able to warbler like Mariah Carey (who, though I am not a fan, style wise, I can respect for her amazing range) and it seems to be that Mariah's frequent use of the whistle register is causing irreparable damage to her voice, as Axl Rose's soul tearing falsetto did to him. Amy is a mezzo-soprano. That means her natural register is lower than the typical female pop star, who all tend to be full soprano. It gives her that edge of being able to go lower than most, though making those higher notes more of a strain. It's not that a mezzo can't sing as high a note as a soprano, it is just slightly more difficult. (As a mezzo-soprano myself, I can relate to that.) Add to the fact that she is adding that gravelly "rock" signature to the notes and generally having to belt them out over screaming fans, while bouncing around the stage, every night (plus sound checks and rehearsals) and the whole atmosphere of playing live and anybody could have a bad night. As for recordings and "editing" with autotune, has it never occurred to people that when recording a song, if a singer is unhappy with it, they can have a "do-over"? When the band Queen recorded "One Vision" they did it so many times that it was late night and they were all worn out when Freddie threw in the "Gimme Fried Chicken". It broke the tension and frustration, they kept the line in. I mean, c'mon, if Queen can turn a nightmare recording session into a comedy "rock legend" like that, anybody can make a mistake! Remember, to err is human, to forgive, divine, to let rip and not care is ROCK!
Oh and I am considered (by some) to be a pretty good singer but next to Amy, I probably sound more like a hippopotamus or something. (I'm honest enough with myself to know I resemble a hippo far more than I resemble her too, lol.)
+Lynzi Oliver-Musto I don't think that most female pop stars are sopranos at all. They seem to mostly be mezzos, without a lot of range to their voice, and there are even a lot of lower mezzos/altos (Lady Gaga, Rihanna, Lana del Rey). If we're talking about a homogenous mix of voices, look at male pop singers. I couldn't name you more than one or two who isn't a tenor. And if they're baritones at all, it's not by much. Basses don't even exist in pop.
Kanga Banga I agree, tenor and mezzo seems to cover the majority. And I, for one, would be so happy if the "whistle" register just went away. It's painful to listen to.
Puedo dar fe de que Amy es una de las mejores cantantes y vocalistas que hay ahora mismo. Simplemente decir que cuando vi a Evanescence en 2006 en uno de sus conciertos se me puso la carne de gallina al escucharla. También hay que tener en cuenta que el rock exige mucha potencia vocal, la voz se desgasta más rápidamente que con otros géneros musicales, donde los intérpretes no necesitan cantar con tanta fuerza. Aparte que ella se entrega al 100%, canta no solo con la voz sino también con el alma y el corazón, dándolo todo para que nosotros disfrutemos. Quién diga que es mala cantante, que se vea los acústicos, que son muy buenos.
Amy Lee has the most beautiful voice I've clearly ever heard! And I mean, yeah, everyone says I have a beautiful voice in my family and I jump around a lot like Amy! It's the times when you really see there voice when they are relaxed. Amy sings beautifully! And sometimes I love to listen to the really old songs she recorded and compare them to the new ones just to see how much her voice has gotten stronger! I
As long as we know she has her skill and talent, it doesn't really matter what other people say. She has amazing vocals and carries a note beautifully in my opinion, if her voice cracks a little whilst performing, who gives a fuck? She wants to give a good show and she does a fantastic job of it.
Thank you, someone who actually took the time to put the feeble-minded *and* very few Amy Lee haters in their place. AND, I'm sure you've turned the skeptics into believers. Amy Lee is LEGIT. One key point to add: ANYTHING from a sore throat to lack of sleep can hinder one's musical performance. Does anyone *ever* consider sicknesses or just sheer grogginess as possibilities for a poor live performance? -- You *have* to.
AMY LEE is amazing she is pretty much the queen of rock and if she messes up (everyone does no one perfect) she acts like it never happen. and that's y she haunts everyone with her voice because it has sooo much emotion. Said and Done Period
Ece Erdem she's mentioned it in some form of interview and she's said it whilst at a gig i've been to so, maybe she lied? but i don;t think so. it's a common fact that she was influence by classical music in her younger singing years and then in an interview she noted on dabbling a bit in the classical/opera vocal range and techniques, and as i said she's mentioned it when i've been to see them
@@aleishaparham3160 She's a classically trained pianist. Not vocalist. She never had opera training. And she never claimed to have. She has admitted that she never had any vocal training other than participating in her school choir ( which I doubt can be classified as any training at all ). I think she only started taking up singing lessons after the release of their third album in 2011. Before that she was self-trained. She had classical training in piano though.
@@eirenity 2 vocal lessons definitely do not count as vocal training. Also, from what I recall, she said she didn't have any vocal lessons before fallen. She had a stage coach that taught her a few things about stage presence, how to stand on stage, how to be expressive, etc. but not vocal lessons. Anyway, even if she did have 2 vocal lessons these are not enough. And she definitely didn't have classical training nor did she ever sing opera.
As a singer and performer I can tell you there are good days and bad days for all of us! Being the lead vocalist of a band performing long sets takes a lot of energy! When you hear someone as amazing as Amy sing poorly, remember there are a variety of valid reasons to consider. Here are just a few: Monitors go out/vocals drop from singer's monitor(s). The audience still hears the singer in the PA, but the singer cannot hear herself/himself at all. We cannot hear ourselves in the same speakers as the audience with loud guitars and drums all around... Kind of like when you have headphones turned up loudly in your ears and try to sing. ;) Sometimes we get sick and our vocals aren't the best, but we can't cancel a gig that people have already paid to see. Not unless we are sick to the point of our voice or "instrument" being broken or impaired. A professional will lots of times go out on stage with a variety of illnesses. If our pipes still work and we are able to move, we will suffer thru it. Because, as you know, "the show must go on!" Even if it's not as good as it would normally be. We not only have contracts to fulfill, but also fans to please. People would rather come to a mediocre show than have it be canceled: True story! Another reason for bad vocals: emotions running too high or deep in the moment. I can personally attest to the fact that once I start to cry I cannot sing if my life depended on it. My vocal cords tense up and I can't get more than a squeak out! I have had instances on stage where I had to fight that kind of emotion. In doing so, I had shaky/pitchy vocals. When you are a high energy performer, jumping or moving on stage, you can very easily stop singing from the right spot or too loudly and not only sound bad, but also hurt your vocals. Your body tensing up because you are moving/jumping/dancing or not being able to hear yourself very well in the monitors will make you sing to loudly and hurt your voice, too. I mean, really... I could go on even longer but I think most of you get the point. Everyone has bad days and good reasons for not being up to par. If I could confiscate every single recording of myself singing badly, believe me.... That would be great! I'm pretty sure Amy would agree! :)
I love Amy lees voice it's beautiful. But hey she's gonna have bad days. Being a singer my self your voice isn't perfect everyday. At least she sings live I can't say that about many other singers
I haven't ever heard anyone say she's a bad singer. In fact, that was part of the (hate to use the word, but it fits best) 'gimmick' that I think got Evanescence got so huge. They were a metal band, with not just a female singer, but one who was on par with the top female pop singers.
a Amy é demais a Amy é diva ela tem uma voz que ninguém nunca viu então seu lixos que falam mal dela parem de falar mal e de compara-la a esses cantores lixo de Justin bieber Taylor swift e o resto da cambada porque ela é top e não merece ser comparada com esses lixos ela tem uma voz de anjo e é a melhor cantora que eu já vi na minha vida.. Amy!!! eu te adoro você é minha cantora favorita
I fucking looooove amy lee, she and Jesse J are both perfect liveee! If you guys havent heard jessie j live, look up a studio version, she's fucking amazinggg
Where the hell do people get the idea that you either can or can't sing; like it's black or white. Ridiculous! I'd like to hear the people who say she "can't sing" try to sing her songs! And a voice is a human instrument; no one is perfect, nor should they be. We don't all Luke every voice or style but that does not mean the singer can't sing
Amy Lee is not just a good singer, She is a good composer as well. Very articulate, comprehensive and sensible. Listen to the lyrics of My Immortal the line that says " I held your hand through all these years but Im alone all along." notice the rhyme of the word alone and all along perfectly fitted to the lines. She could have said all the while but her ingenuity suggest the right words,phrase.My Immortal was intelligently composed the lyrics are simple yet meaningful and not boring. More power to you Amy continue to entertain us with your songs.
Amy Lee is a great singer, her songs are hard to sing, especially singing live and having to jump around at the same time too, that's at times she sounds off key. I noticed other people can't sing her songs, Not in the same tone range.
How could anyone say she's a bad singer? Thats insanity!! Seriously, she has the most amazing voice. Studio, Live, accoustic, even fucking acapella, hands down the best female singer. #MyheartisbrokenLiveBigFMGermany
I'm just going to put this out there because I saw a lot of comments saying she doesn't have formal training. The woman was top of her choir and even wrote songs for their concerts. I believe singing in a choir all through out school would count as formal training. She may or may not have seen a one on one vocal coach. Amy is also a natural alto yet easily a mezzo-soprano. She is NOT a natural soprano. It takes a lot of practice to work up to those notes and be fully comfortable doing so as it isn't in her natural/comfort range vocally. There for when jumping, dancing, even not having correct posture will cause the voice to falter if not in your natural range. As for not sounding the same as recorded, we all know singing in a special room made specifically for vocals/music to sound good is way different than being on a stage in a venue. Also when songs for albums are made they record over and over. Then cut and put together the best sounding bits, the final product sounding "perfect"
even the video that says about how amazing she sings, her voice cracks in 1:36 when she says 'me' lol. amy lee could be a good singer but she choose to write very hard songs for her to sing. this is why she can't even sing her own songs without cracking, and her tune always changes during her songs. i am not a hater but it would be much better if she would write her songs in lower keys.
Oh seriously she's an AMAZING singer! The fact that she chooses to sing hard songs and that she does them really good ( so you found one word she was off-key in the whole song what's the fucking big deal) and you just can't ignore her voice when you hear it - in fact, lot of people here said her voice did them chills (true) - all of that make her an absolute incredible singer.
i don't agree with you. she is professional and she shouldn't be mistakes. but every song is full of mistakes. so she could write her songs in lower keys so she could sing them perfectly. but she just suck now.
דנקדונט מהמיק No there is not just one word out of key in her live performances (in this perfomance of The change, her voice cracked also when she said "I'm about to lose my mind"). In almost every performance, her voice goes out of tune at a time. Singers are human, they can make some mistakes sometimes or have a day off, but in Amy's case, the same mistakes always come back all the time. She just should take vocal lessons for having a better technique and take care of her voice.
Lithium Sapphire I agree with you, she tends to write songs with extremely high notes on them, and she has said herself she's not a super trained singer (being in the highschool choir doesn't count), so in the end, that's the reason her voice sounds too strained and she can't hit many notes after being more than 20 mins on a stage. Other singers are better technically speaking. That doesn't mean Amy is a bad singer. She's amazing. But she really needs a vocal coach and I have always thought the same as you: she needs to lower the tone of her songs. Great singers in all genres do it all the time. Why not her?
All you showed me was that she is AMAZING. Depending on the sound systems, concert events, how long she had been performing, etc. you are going to get different sounds.
I love watching videos of her sing live because she just puts so much emotion into her music. Of course, you can hear it on the album versions too, but you can see it live.
Amy Lee has one of the most beautiful and strongest voices I've ever heard. And if you say she isn't a good singer when she is live, remember SHE IS WEARING A COREST. that is hard to sing in.
I saw her at the unplugged big fm Concert in Germany and it was just amazing!!! She sings so powerful and her Voice is really magical! I still love her
Incredible video, and a great fan tribute. Amy and the band have blessed us fans with unforgettable talent and music. Cant wait to see what they do next! Thanks for the great video!
She had a strong voice, so it's hard for her not to sing loud and powerful..It's more difficult than singing with full strenght of voice. Believe me. She has the most amazing voice ever and she proves that in every concert.
i seriously have never seen any hate comments of her. i have to really preoccupy my mind to get over her voice for a few days. i feel like a magical spell has been casted on me because i can NEVER get her voice out of my head and it’s just stunningly so beautiful and better than any other bands voices. no auto tune like anyone else’s. such a lucky girl because she can REALLY hit those notes And She been studying music ALL HER LIFE! the BEST celebertie voice i have EVER HEARD MY WHOLE LIFE! better than taylor swift and EVERYONE ELSE OMFG I WANT TI MEET HER SO SO SO SO SO SO SOOOOOOSO SO SO SO SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BBBBBBBAAAAAAADDDDDDDLLLLLLYYYYYYYYY😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Amy lee is a naturally talented singer. I love her voice and she helped me get through some dark times in my life with her music. I use her voice to sing her songs and it moves me. When you go on tour for so long, your voice can get hoarse, sound dry, pitchy, etc. Remember that these musicians have to sing every day across the globe when they go on tour so they can sometimes strain their vocals. You also need to take into account that these musicians also can suffer from exhaustion from traveling so much and do not get a chance to rest their voices. It's a tough business when it comes to the entertainment industry and they have to force themselves to keep going so they don't lose their contracts.
I think the fact that they(all singers) sing different from the album,makes the concert be more exciting and amazing. And if you want to hear exactly the vocals,GO AND HEAR IT FROM THE CD ¬¬
The only reason artists don't sound the same on stage isn't because of auto tune or anything but because the mic in a studio isolates sound. Live mics can't so that
I have heard Amy sing unplugged. She has an amazing voice. Unlike 90% of singers nowadays, she doesn't need autotune or manipulation by some sound engineer to make her sound good. She has a natural gift.
My Heart Is Broken - Acoustic live at Sirius XM is, in my opinion, the best performance of the song. Her vocals are absolutely flawless and sung in the original key.
LOVE HER. I swear is voice is awesome because of her choir days, years of practice and her vocal teacher because when I did choir it amazingly changed my singing voice for the better! Her voice is lovely!
I saw Ev live twice, she was mind blowing.....she puts everything into a show, and is bound to miss the odd note, or go off key.....she is only human !. I still love her now, and cannot wait for the next album, whenever that may be.
Depends on stage/acoustics/echo/tuning/other instruments etc. Singing live can be tough which is why a lot of artists like spears/beiber etc lip sync/auto tune.
I don't need flawless. If need errors completely, I will listen to the CD. She gave me a real voice, real feelings. Her performances touched my heart every time
Never In a million years would I think she was a bad singer, and this video just proves it more. Great video! And sadly I do know people who think she's a horrible singer, my friends sadly.... I despise my friends for that sometimes. Lol
Amazing. she sounds fantastic. There's going to be days when she's had coughs and colds that will affect vocals.. she's only human. To have a voice like her in the first place is a blessing for her and her audience. No one is like her physically or vocally. Well done Amy Lee for being unique . 👌👏
3ª voz mais bonita do mundo na opinião de uma revista, acho que não é pouca coisa, eu ainda procuro uma voz com a potência da voz da Amy, eu tinha um show dela em Full HD no Rock in Rio 2011, e nunca tinha notado o quão precioso era a sua voz, pena que perdi esse show e tive que baixar na péssima qualidade de internet em 720p com áudio pior que um MP3... Pra mim ela é uma rainha do Rock, sua voz me encanta, me arrepia, e cada dia mais viro fã, e não é só eu que gosto, milhões, só que existe gente que não goste, e eu respeito que não goste, mas pra perder tempo fazendo vídeo falando mal do que não gosta é idiotice, infantilidade, procure algo mais útil a fazer!
Are you serious someone said that Amy Lee couldn't sing.?
Must be tone deaf...!!!
Omg ikr
No I mean to Rue Stahl not Chick Zombie
***** YOU ARE TONE DEAF BECAUSE SHE CAN SING and SHE SINGS BETTER THAN MOST PEOPLE THAT ARE SINGING TODAY.
+Rue Stahl true
No not everyone can sing like Amy Lee. Amy Lee is one of the best singers today.
She has one of the most beautiful voices I've ever heard!!:)
There is no such thing as a pitch perfect vocalist 100% of the time. Live concert set's are long and extremely difficult to maintain at studio level especially for vocalist. But Amy come's pretty damn close to that level of perfection. She pore's her heart and soul into every song she sings. And that's enough for me.
i just wanted to say .......I love lacuna coil , sirenia, nightwish, halestorm, epica .......but only songs from evanescence can touch my heart so deep , that i could cry all day and night !!!!!!!!! She's got a voice like an angel !!!!
Yess!Amy and christina from lacuna coil have many similarities
Each of these are great groups. I'll add The Pretty Reckless, Within Temptation, Florence + The Machine, Flyleaf, and Paramore to the list.
No! Amy Lee is a best singer !
hmm.....
Your Favorite Aries Definitely.
Yes!
Who the fuc said she sings bad?
People would be shitheads for saying Amy Lee can't sing. She's incredible, are they kidding?
***** THANK YOU! :D
Ikr I love Amy Lee too she's has a lot of talent
Who ever said Amy Lee has a bad voice tell them to get off the drugs!
Even vocal masters like Amy have bad days, don't bring her down for that. :)
100 percent agree with you, everybody can't pull it off all the time. I seen her live and she was amazing. they 2 ediots at the top saying she needs to lower her tone....Ha! It wouldn't be Evanescence if she done that. ppl have bad days, voices are shakes at times, doesn't mean she needs to change her genre of music
like
+ヒルホリクロエ Not true. My vocal master do not really like her actually.
I'm a massive fan and the first time he told me she's not that good I was not happy, but he's right.
She's not a really bad singer, but her technique is not good. She lacks her lower notes and she does not use her mixed voice properly: sometimes she forces her chest voice causing herself damage and lack of control during the transitions between chest and head voice.
+Riccardoderek your vocal master is wrong. how can you listen to them? have they sold millions of albums? have they sold out gigs in just about every developed country in the world? I think not! what make your vocal master so much better??
Joe Thomas Sorry, but your opinion is so wrong. Many bad singers sold millions of album because they make good music or because they just got syle. But that doesn't mean their singing technique is bad.
I don't believe that she's a bad singer at all, she's the best I've ever heard. Even when she's singing live, she still sings a LOT better than most singers.
Yes.
I like her, and I think she's a good singer. Stop hating on Amy Lee. ❤
well, SOME singers NEVER fail!
cause they use playback LOL
Exactly!!!
She isn't one of them ....
김미수
So true
When I put on an Evanesence, my friend was like, "what the heck is this? She's a horrible singer. Put on something that has meaning like R5!" I literally slapped her.
tell ur friend to get better music
tell her i said there the music
Thats when its time for an ovary punch :)
oh yeah
R5 is no match for the Amy. :)
Yeah um.. I just died a little. Amy Lee is a goddess. Chills. Chills. I feel haunted and entranced by her voice. MY GOD AMY LEE, YOU'RE LOVELY.
i've the same feeling ^^
That's what I love about her voice, it's hauntingly beautiful and mesmerising.
You feel haunted? Get it? The song? No?
Okay then, I'll just listen to made of stone in silence
Every singer has off performances. There was a few a few instances there that she was slightly off. But these bands tour sometimes 300 days a year. She is an excellent singer with a haunting pitch. But dont expect perfection every time.
i'm a little monster and i love Lady Gaga so much she has amazing strong vocals but Amy Lee will always and forever be the number one best voice i've ever listened to . you can recognize her voice even if you are not a fan or even if you never listened to the song before it's just so mesmerizing .
any one who says she cant sing should watch a live version of lithium.. but i mean shes the shit. one of the best female vocalists out there
i meant Hello***
Alexa Charbonneau at concerts she does. They have concert videos of her performing hello.
So...??? Does she have to sing every song that you command her to sing. Who the Hell are you to demand anything of her. If you are as good a singer as she is, go out there and do what she's doing and become as popular as she is, then come back and show me in a video how much better you are than her.
+Rue Stahl and who is this too??? cause I didn't say anything of the sort.
Myranda Arianna Sorry wrong person. I meant Alexa. I meant to tell Alexa she was wrong.
Amy lee is the best female singer i have ever heard. She gots the best female voice ever.
cough cough hayley williams... amy is a close second though
Alissa White-Gluz, Maria "Masha Scream" Arkhipova, Floor Jansen, Annette Olzon, Angela Gossow, Simone Simons, Anna Murphy, and the oh so obligatory mention of Tarja Turunen.
Best Female Voice is Tarja Turunen.
Jörg Krause
OOowh, yeah she's also good. But I like Amy's voice. Everybody has a different taste. If everybody liked green apples we would not have green apples anymore and to much yellow and red apples.
Baby wake up. I've never ever ever EVER in my life heard ppl saying that Amy Lee can't sing. About Bieber, Rihanna, Taylor, even Lana... yes. But Amy? Never.
i've heard it a lot. Fools. e.e
taylor swift?
Amy lee AND Taylor swift are both awesome
yes,yes they are
Rihanna can sing
She's just PERFECT! Evanescence songs are usually hard to sing but she does sooo well, it's normal when in a concert everything isn't perfect, but let's ask another singer to do what she does and sing the way she do, she has tooooo much talent, for me is PERFECT!
Does anyone know how hard her songs are plus her vocal range is monstrous I have heard other versions of her songs but no one could do it better why would anyone say she can't sing everyone has there mess ups,I am just saying I am a huge fan of her voice, never heard one like it
All that i'm living for acoustic forever!!!
her acoustic stuff is the best
vanessa powell Hell yeah
agreed
YASSSS!!!
Does Amy have bad performances? Yes, but every artist has them. You're not gonna be on your A game every concert. You're just not. She puts so much effort into her performances that sometimes she might not sound the greatest. With that being said, it's obvious she can sing. Anyone who disagrees really needs to look up the facts. I have listened to the acoustic versions of some of their songs and I was blown away and got chills. And yes, I've watched concerts that were normal and not acoustic and she did awesome too. She's up and down but that doesn't make her a bad singer. Amy Lee in my opinion is in the top 10 vocalists of our generation. Unfortunately, she doesn't get the credit she deserves. Also, people really need to stop comparing her to Tarja or Sharon etc. She and them have different voices.
No, she's a really bad singer, you've to watch this : /watch?v=tgDF2xIk_Uo
JansenMaYaN I mean that's your opinion, but you're wrong.
2012nebula you've to watch this /watch?v=tgDF2xIk_Uo before saying that i'm wrong haha...
JansenMaYaN I don't need to watch it. Mainly because the link isn't working....but I've seen her bad performances. However, I've seen her sing beautifully too. So how can you say she can't sing when she has good performances too and everyone that knows her, especially in the band, says what a beautiful voice she has? It's common sense. Also way to say that on a video that proves she can sing....
Згодна щодо голосів. Слухаю і Тарью і Крістіну Скабіа, і Емі, і Шерон але саме тому, що вони різні. Це доповнює жанр, він стає банатогранним.
Колись мене теж намагались переконати, що вона погано співає, порівнювали її акустичний спів із співом Шерон. Не переконали.:)) Дійсно дуже мало співаків, що один в один відтворюють студійний звук, т.б. з тих виконавців які поєднують з електронним звуком. Акустика узагалі складна річ. Вона вимагає академічності, так само як піаніно. З тих, хто на сцені звучить так само як в студії я знаю тільки вокаліста Квін (Queen Freddie Mercury). Це взагалі помилка вважати, що звук має бути ідентичним. Він повинен відрізнятися. Голос повинен відповідати звуку інструменту. Різні інструменти = різне виконання.
Couldn't sing? I wish I couldn't sing! She is absolutely amazing....
After a while, your vocal cords can get tired and day after day with all that singing, that's got to put strain even heavier on them. I used to sing karaoke and after about five or six songs, my throat couldn't do it. Big props to all musicians, having to do this day in and day out, especially those with masterful skills like Amy. Even a goddess can get worn out.
Exactly. .. that's what everyone dosent understand when they tour it takes a toll on your vocal cords..playing from city to city. .by the way i don't even know why this nitwit uploaded this garbage. lol. . Trying to compare if she is a good singer. . She is a professional nitwit. . lol gosh man people these days... it never seems to amaze me.
+JR Black Um, you do realize the video is supporting Amy's abilities, not criticizing them, right?
Jessie Nebulous [Cripple Gamer Chick] Yes... This guy is trying to let people know that she is a good singer, but we already know that she is a good singer. .. what's with the vid? That's what I don't understand. . What's he trying to prove actually? ??
JR Black It's self-explanatory, really. The creator explains that they have encountered people criticizing Amy's live vocals, and they made this video explaining that singing live (vs lip syncing) have various factors involved and the performance is not going to sound exactly the same as the recorded version. I've run into people complaining that she sounds different live, and I generally say something to the same effect as this video (perhaps in a more coherent manner; I'm a writer, and the video creator is clearly not). It just sounds like you haven't run into anyone making those criticisms about her but believe me, some people don't like her voice. I don't understand it, but everyone likes different things. But that's what the video is trying to "prove."
+Joshua Strickland Couldnt have said it any better
People need to stop saying that she can't sing. Cause she can! I want every person that has ever said that she can't sing try to sing one of her songs!
***** I agree with you, Kai. but like this video states, she's still a great performer and she gives her all.
RandomPerson, oh boy - I wish them luck! As someone who has tried and is finally able to sing some (without anyone else listening mind you) - that‘s NOT EASY!
I told my friend to listen to Evanescence. He listened to, "Call Me When You're Sober" (I love that one❤️) He said that she was good (wrong, she's AMAZING!), but the next day, he said that was her only good song. I almost did an uppercut on him😂😂😂😂😂he's lucky I didn't 😂😏
LolLolLol
:) ikr! Sarah ward now when ever I show him something Evanescence or Amy Lee related, he says, "no no no no no no!!"
bitch please... she is perfect
i saw her in 2012, chile, and her live performance was such an amazing thing, she sings pretty much better than from his albums, she made every single person on the arena cry by the emotion,
I dislike bullying.
Plus she carries it all off whilst playing piano and/or the harp, also near to perfectly. I think she has one of the most powerful current female voices in music. I went to one of their concerts a couple of years ago and I didn't hear one bum note in the entire performance. I think sometimes its more to do with bad sound level at the performance, as it must be very hard with such powerful songs to keep the backing music low enough so that the vocalist isn't struggling to keep their voice audible. At the concert I went to the sound was spot on for someone with a voice as strong as hers. Though I couldn't have been heard above it if I screamed in one pitch note! lol
Her voice give me chills, it's so sweet, it's like a lullaby. Come on guys, sing for a hundred or thousand people mess a lot with the voice
I happen to love Amy Lee, but I do want to point two things out:
1) Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and none of those opinions are wrong. That's why they are opinions.
2) For anyone saying that Amy can't sing live, I'd like you to try running around a stage for two hours singing the way she does and then criticize her.
Rant over :)
Amy Lee has a very impressive and beautiful voice with so much power and emotion and the best lyrics ever
Let me just start out by saying i LOVE amy lee. She has a beautiful voice, great presence, and an impressive range. But her technique is terrible. Itsnot an insult, but sometimes i literally worry that shes going to blow her voice out. Her breathing is awful, she gasps for breath (which does have a lot to do with running all over the stage. HOWEVER, i believe that you shouldnt sacrifice the quality of your singing just to put on a good rock show), and ive noticed also that with the high notes, she seems to go for vocal gymnastics rather than quality singing. Her range is impressive, again, but she sings through her throat and nose, shes often pitchy and raspy, and at times it actually sounds painful. I AM NOT SAYING AMY IS A BAD SINGER. But she abuses her vocal cord in a way that is appalling. She shows no respect for that beautiful voice,and im just afraid that if she doesnt start doing something different, shes going to lose it
I think that she knows how to sing correctly, she studied it :)
ehh. I was in a freakishly picky, critical mood that night and I feel like a dick for this comment. I would KILL for her pipes. I'm a singer too (not in her league, obviously) and I abuse the hell out of my voice, which is probably why I'll never make it to superstardom. I think the above comment was genuinely made out of concern for the longevity of her voice though. it would be a crime if one day Amy lost her voice and didn't get it back. :(
actually... yes I did notice that. the concerts in 2015 were on POINT. I think the ones I was referring to may have just been a few off/sick nights back in 2012. I actually thought that between 2003-2012, her live performances grew more strained (except for the acoustic shows. unearthly good). but I also heard something about her being sick for quite a few shows so I'm sure that would do it. anyway... back to what you were saying... yes. especially in recent years, she's gotten better. I also failed to account for the fact that with each new album, she's singing more and more vocally challenging material. the self-titled album? good god. I'm pretty sure ONE night of singing that stuff would blow my voice out. ha. anyway yeah. if I could choose between having a trained, but just good nothing special about it voice and having a voice like Amy's, not professionally trained... well I think you know the answer to that. anyway, rant aside... I know what you mean. especially between 2012 and now, her voice and singing skills have soared to new heights. that new cover EP? she brought that whole chill-inducing-with-her-voice factor to a whole 'nother level. sorry. I can go on and on in my comments if you haven't noticed. ANYWAY... the main point of this was that I had no right to be critical. I'm definitely not up there doing what she does night after night, and it would be a huge stretch to say I have even half her vocal talent. thanks for being cool about me being a prissy amateur music critic XP
Camilla Pellegrini she hasn't. She only has been in a choir in her teens. That is not the same as studying singing.
I agree. She has a potential to sing perfectly but with her wrong technique she's killing her voice. My former vocal teacher would kill me for that way of singing.
Its Annoys Me ! When I Hear Comments Like ( Amy Can`t Sing OR Her Voice Isn`t Hight Enuogh or Something Like That ! )
What The Hell You Want To Hear !! Better Than This !? IMPOSSIBLE !!
She Became A Mother & New Music Is Avalable Now !
We Saw Her Concerts & We Could Hear Her Voice Well !
We Know Exactley How She Sing ! !!
She`s Just Amazing ! Hot ! Perfect !!!
I Just Can`t Believe That Amy Has Haters !!
You Can`t Hear Her Voice & Say That She wasn`t Good Enough !!! YOU CAN`T SAY IT !!!!!
Bcoz Her Reality Voice Can`t Let You Say All Of That pullshits !! >_
:/
So do I Amy Lee is my idol. She inspires me keep singing because my friends say I can sing like Amy Lee wen I showed thim her. Also she will never stop being amazing and beautiful to me. If you disagree then ok but that's how I feel
Amy is perfect by nature and justin bieber lovers prefer fake useless popstars instead of someone real like Amy. I'm glad you guys and I aren't blind like them. :)
Their live performances are so much better than from any other band !!!!!
I've seen them live multiple times and she sounded awesome everytime!
Even Christina Aguilera with her power house vocals has her bad days. You can have a big voice and use it so much and expect to have it flawless everyday.
People seem to expect high notes from all female singers these days, or they "are no good". But look at Bonnie Taylor. Her songs were (and still are) great "classic rock ballads". You can't expect all women to be able to warbler like Mariah Carey (who, though I am not a fan, style wise, I can respect for her amazing range) and it seems to be that Mariah's frequent use of the whistle register is causing irreparable damage to her voice, as Axl Rose's soul tearing falsetto did to him.
Amy is a mezzo-soprano. That means her natural register is lower than the typical female pop star, who all tend to be full soprano. It gives her that edge of being able to go lower than most, though making those higher notes more of a strain. It's not that a mezzo can't sing as high a note as a soprano, it is just slightly more difficult. (As a mezzo-soprano myself, I can relate to that.) Add to the fact that she is adding that gravelly "rock" signature to the notes and generally having to belt them out over screaming fans, while bouncing around the stage, every night (plus sound checks and rehearsals) and the whole atmosphere of playing live and anybody could have a bad night.
As for recordings and "editing" with autotune, has it never occurred to people that when recording a song, if a singer is unhappy with it, they can have a "do-over"? When the band Queen recorded "One Vision" they did it so many times that it was late night and they were all worn out when Freddie threw in the "Gimme Fried Chicken". It broke the tension and frustration, they kept the line in. I mean, c'mon, if Queen can turn a nightmare recording session into a comedy "rock legend" like that, anybody can make a mistake! Remember, to err is human, to forgive, divine, to let rip and not care is ROCK!
Oh and I am considered (by some) to be a pretty good singer but next to Amy, I probably sound more like a hippopotamus or something. (I'm honest enough with myself to know I resemble a hippo far more than I resemble her too, lol.)
Hippos are freaking awesome.
You can't really compare in the end unless you can narrow it down to a particular genre or instrumentals / vocals
+Lynzi Oliver-Musto I don't think that most female pop stars are sopranos at all. They seem to mostly be mezzos, without a lot of range to their voice, and there are even a lot of lower mezzos/altos (Lady Gaga, Rihanna, Lana del Rey).
If we're talking about a homogenous mix of voices, look at male pop singers. I couldn't name you more than one or two who isn't a tenor. And if they're baritones at all, it's not by much. Basses don't even exist in pop.
Kanga Banga I agree, tenor and mezzo seems to cover the majority. And I, for one, would be so happy if the "whistle" register just went away. It's painful to listen to.
Puedo dar fe de que Amy es una de las mejores cantantes y vocalistas que hay ahora mismo. Simplemente decir que cuando vi a Evanescence en 2006 en uno de sus conciertos se me puso la carne de gallina al escucharla. También hay que tener en cuenta que el rock exige mucha potencia vocal, la voz se desgasta más rápidamente que con otros géneros musicales, donde los intérpretes no necesitan cantar con tanta fuerza. Aparte que ella se entrega al 100%, canta no solo con la voz sino también con el alma y el corazón, dándolo todo para que nosotros disfrutemos. Quién diga que es mala cantante, que se vea los acústicos, que son muy buenos.
She's So Talented❤❤🎶🎼
Amy Lee has the most beautiful voice I've clearly ever heard! And I mean, yeah, everyone says I have a beautiful voice in my family and I jump around a lot like Amy! It's the times when you really see there voice when they are relaxed. Amy sings beautifully! And sometimes I love to listen to the really old songs she recorded and compare them to the new ones just to see how much her voice has gotten stronger! I
have any of you heard her new song, we'll the soundtrack Lockdown? Oh god, her voice is perfect.
As long as we know she has her skill and talent, it doesn't really matter what other people say. She has amazing vocals and carries a note beautifully in my opinion, if her voice cracks a little whilst performing, who gives a fuck? She wants to give a good show and she does a fantastic job of it.
Thank you, someone who actually took the time to put the feeble-minded *and* very few Amy Lee haters in their place. AND, I'm sure you've turned the skeptics into believers. Amy Lee is LEGIT.
One key point to add: ANYTHING from a sore throat to lack of sleep can hinder one's musical performance. Does anyone *ever* consider sicknesses or just sheer grogginess as possibilities for a poor live performance? -- You *have* to.
AMY LEE is amazing she is pretty much the queen of rock and if she messes up (everyone does no one perfect) she acts like it never happen. and that's y she haunts everyone with her voice because it has sooo much emotion. Said and Done Period
I love seeing clips of where her opera training comes in, I love her voice
She doesn't have any training except she sang in school choir.
Ece Erdem she's mentioned it in some form of interview and she's said it whilst at a gig i've been to so, maybe she lied? but i don;t think so. it's a common fact that she was influence by classical music in her younger singing years and then in an interview she noted on dabbling a bit in the classical/opera vocal range and techniques, and as i said she's mentioned it when i've been to see them
Ece Erdem Wow a Turk
@@aleishaparham3160
She's a classically trained pianist. Not vocalist. She never had opera training. And she never claimed to have. She has admitted that she never had any vocal training other than participating in her school choir ( which I doubt can be classified as any training at all ). I think she only started taking up singing lessons after the release of their third album in 2011. Before that she was self-trained. She had classical training in piano though.
@@eirenity
2 vocal lessons definitely do not count as vocal training. Also, from what I recall, she said she didn't have any vocal lessons before fallen. She had a stage coach that taught her a few things about stage presence, how to stand on stage, how to be expressive, etc. but not vocal lessons. Anyway, even if she did have 2 vocal lessons these are not enough. And she definitely didn't have classical training nor did she ever sing opera.
For all those people saying you can see the strain on her face that's actually called emotion.
As a singer and performer I can tell you there are good days and bad days for all of us! Being the lead vocalist of a band performing long sets takes a lot of energy! When you hear someone as amazing as Amy sing poorly, remember there are a variety of valid reasons to consider. Here are just a few: Monitors go out/vocals drop from singer's monitor(s). The audience still hears the singer in the PA, but the singer cannot hear herself/himself at all. We cannot hear ourselves in the same speakers as the audience with loud guitars and drums all around... Kind of like when you have headphones turned up loudly in your ears and try to sing. ;) Sometimes we get sick and our vocals aren't the best, but we can't cancel a gig that people have already paid to see. Not unless we are sick to the point of our voice or "instrument" being broken or impaired. A professional will lots of times go out on stage with a variety of illnesses. If our pipes still work and we are able to move, we will suffer thru it. Because, as you know, "the show must go on!" Even if it's not as good as it would normally be. We not only have contracts to fulfill, but also fans to please. People would rather come to a mediocre show than have it be canceled: True story! Another reason for bad vocals: emotions running too high or deep in the moment. I can personally attest to the fact that once I start to cry I cannot sing if my life depended on it. My vocal cords tense up and I can't get more than a squeak out! I have had instances on stage where I had to fight that kind of emotion. In doing so, I had shaky/pitchy vocals. When you are a high energy performer, jumping or moving on stage, you can very easily stop singing from the right spot or too loudly and not only sound bad, but also hurt your vocals. Your body tensing up because you are moving/jumping/dancing or not being able to hear yourself very well in the monitors will make you sing to loudly and hurt your voice, too. I mean, really... I could go on even longer but I think most of you get the point. Everyone has bad days and good reasons for not being up to par. If I could confiscate every single recording of myself singing badly, believe me.... That would be great! I'm pretty sure Amy would agree! :)
I love Amy lees voice it's beautiful. But hey she's gonna have bad days. Being a singer my self your voice isn't perfect everyday. At least she sings live I can't say that about many other singers
She has one of the most beautiful voices I've ever Heart!!:)
I have never heard ppl say she cant sing
I haven't ever heard anyone say she's a bad singer. In fact, that was part of the (hate to use the word, but it fits best) 'gimmick' that I think got Evanescence got so huge. They were a metal band, with not just a female singer, but one who was on par with the top female pop singers.
Haters gonna hate .. we love evanescence and Amy as she is .. just ignore all those who are saying that
Her voice may not always sound the same, but I think every peformance is amazing!
a Amy é demais a Amy é diva ela tem uma voz que ninguém nunca viu então seu lixos que falam mal dela parem de falar mal e de compara-la a esses cantores lixo de Justin bieber Taylor swift e o resto da cambada porque ela é top e não merece ser comparada com esses lixos ela tem uma voz de anjo e é a melhor cantora que eu já vi na minha vida.. Amy!!! eu te adoro você é minha cantora favorita
Concordo com VC
Concordo com VC
I fucking looooove amy lee, she and Jesse J are both perfect liveee! If you guys havent heard jessie j live, look up a studio version, she's fucking amazinggg
estoy deacuerdo, amo a las 2 ♥! son tan buenas en vivo las 2 hacen llorar a cualquiera
All this people are use to lip singers lol, that's why they cannot appreciate live singer. Amy lee gots a such excellent voice the best out there
Where the hell do people get the idea that you either can or can't sing; like it's black or white. Ridiculous! I'd like to hear the people who say she "can't sing" try to sing her songs! And a voice is a human instrument; no one is perfect, nor should they be. We don't all Luke every voice or style but that does not mean the singer can't sing
amy lee good voice
Amy Lee is not just a good singer, She is a good composer as well. Very articulate, comprehensive and sensible. Listen to the lyrics of My Immortal the line that says " I held your hand through all these years but Im alone all along." notice the rhyme of the word alone and all along perfectly fitted to the lines. She could have said all the while but her ingenuity suggest the right words,phrase.My Immortal was intelligently composed the lyrics are simple yet meaningful and not boring. More power to you Amy continue to entertain us with your songs.
Amy Lee is a great singer, her songs are hard to sing, especially singing live and having to jump around at the same time too, that's at times she sounds off key. I noticed other people can't sing her songs, Not in the same tone range.
Evanescence will forever be the band👌
amy Lee is a good singer
How could anyone say she's a bad singer? Thats insanity!! Seriously, she has the most amazing voice. Studio, Live, accoustic, even fucking acapella, hands down the best female singer. #MyheartisbrokenLiveBigFMGermany
Amy really has no vocal training so she does best with waht little voice she has..I give her credit to put herself out there! Kudos
She does have vocal training. I think it was something for opera, which is why she can sing so high
I'm just going to put this out there because I saw a lot of comments saying she doesn't have formal training.
The woman was top of her choir and even wrote songs for their concerts. I believe singing in a choir all through out school would count as formal training. She may or may not have seen a one on one vocal coach. Amy is also a natural alto yet easily a mezzo-soprano. She is NOT a natural soprano. It takes a lot of practice to work up to those notes and be fully comfortable doing so as it isn't in her natural/comfort range vocally. There for when jumping, dancing, even not having correct posture will cause the voice to falter if not in your natural range.
As for not sounding the same as recorded, we all know singing in a special room made specifically for vocals/music to sound good is way different than being on a stage in a venue. Also when songs for albums are made they record over and over. Then cut and put together the best sounding bits, the final product sounding "perfect"
Some people don't know what real talent is anymore. For example, Nicki Minaj, no talent what-so-ever.
She is human.
With a great voice
even the video that says about how amazing she sings, her voice cracks in 1:36 when she says 'me' lol. amy lee could be a good singer but she choose to write very hard songs for her to sing. this is why she can't even sing her own songs without cracking, and her tune always changes during her songs. i am not a hater but it would be much better if she would write her songs in lower keys.
Oh seriously she's an AMAZING singer! The fact that she chooses to sing hard songs and that she does them really good ( so you found one word she was off-key in the whole song what's the fucking big deal) and you just can't ignore her voice when you hear it - in fact, lot of people here said her voice did them chills (true) - all of that make her an absolute incredible singer.
+lithium sapphire
i don't agree with you. she is professional and she shouldn't be mistakes. but every song is full of mistakes. so she could write her songs in lower keys so she could sing them perfectly. but she just suck now.
דנקדונט מהמיק No there is not just one word out of key in her live performances (in this perfomance of The change, her voice cracked also when she said "I'm about to lose my mind"). In almost every performance, her voice goes out of tune at a time. Singers are human, they can make some mistakes sometimes or have a day off, but in Amy's case, the same mistakes always come back all the time. She just should take vocal lessons for having a better technique and take care of her voice.
Lithium Sapphire I agree with you, she tends to write songs with extremely high notes on them, and she has said herself she's not a super trained singer (being in the highschool choir doesn't count), so in the end, that's the reason her voice sounds too strained and she can't hit many notes after being more than 20 mins on a stage. Other singers are better technically speaking. That doesn't mean Amy is a bad singer. She's amazing. But she really needs a vocal coach and I have always thought the same as you: she needs to lower the tone of her songs. Great singers in all genres do it all the time. Why not her?
when i discover this band after listening their first song i found myself.amy is my life
All you showed me was that she is AMAZING. Depending on the sound systems, concert events, how long she had been performing, etc. you are going to get different sounds.
This was a great mix and example of how great of a singer and artist Amy Lee really is. 👍 definitely a big like in this one!!!
By far she is one of the most talented live vocalists.
I love watching videos of her sing live because she just puts so much emotion into her music. Of course, you can hear it on the album versions too, but you can see it live.
Amy Lee has one of the most beautiful and strongest voices I've ever heard. And if you say she isn't a good singer when she is live, remember SHE IS WEARING A COREST. that is hard to sing in.
I saw her at the unplugged big fm Concert in Germany and it was just amazing!!! She sings so powerful and her Voice is really magical! I still love her
Incredible video, and a great fan tribute. Amy and the band have blessed us fans with unforgettable talent and music. Cant wait to see what they do next! Thanks for the great video!
she's my Angel of darkness
Some people won't like her voice and that's ok but she can sing. I find her voice so soothing, beautiful and deep at the same time.
She had a strong voice, so it's hard for her not to sing loud and powerful..It's more difficult than singing with full strenght of voice. Believe me. She has the most amazing voice ever and she proves that in every concert.
I really love this video :) You really brought a beautiful side of Amy out :3 I love her to pieces :3
i seriously have never seen any hate comments of her. i have to really preoccupy my mind to get over her voice for a few days. i feel like a magical spell has been casted on me because i can NEVER get her voice out of my head and it’s just stunningly so beautiful and better than any other bands voices. no auto tune like anyone else’s. such a lucky girl because she can REALLY hit those notes And She been studying music ALL HER LIFE! the BEST celebertie voice i have EVER HEARD MY WHOLE LIFE! better than taylor swift and EVERYONE ELSE OMFG I WANT TI MEET HER SO SO SO SO SO SO SOOOOOOSO SO SO SO SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BBBBBBBAAAAAAADDDDDDDLLLLLLYYYYYYYYY😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Amy lee is a naturally talented singer. I love her voice and she helped me get through some dark times in my life with her music. I use her voice to sing her songs and it moves me. When you go on tour for so long, your voice can get hoarse, sound dry, pitchy, etc. Remember that these musicians have to sing every day across the globe when they go on tour so they can sometimes strain their vocals. You also need to take into account that these musicians also can suffer from exhaustion from traveling so much and do not get a chance to rest their voices. It's a tough business when it comes to the entertainment industry and they have to force themselves to keep going so they don't lose their contracts.
I think the fact that they(all singers) sing different from the album,makes the concert be more exciting and amazing.
And if you want to hear exactly the vocals,GO AND HEAR IT FROM THE CD ¬¬
The only reason artists don't sound the same on stage isn't because of auto tune or anything but because the mic in a studio isolates sound. Live mics can't so that
I have heard Amy sing unplugged. She has an amazing voice. Unlike 90% of singers nowadays, she doesn't need autotune or manipulation by some sound engineer to make her sound good. She has a natural gift.
Her voice is SO beautiful, forever wishing I have it
My Heart Is Broken - Acoustic live at Sirius XM is, in my opinion, the best performance of the song. Her vocals are absolutely flawless and sung in the original key.
my god she is a true siren, thank god she has blessed us with her voice,
LOVE HER. I swear is voice is awesome because of her choir days, years of practice and her vocal teacher because when I did choir it amazingly changed my singing voice for the better! Her voice is lovely!
I love this woman and her music ever since i was in primary school an until now i still love her
I saw Ev live twice, she was mind blowing.....she puts everything into a show, and is bound to miss the odd note, or go off key.....she is only human !.
I still love her now, and cannot wait for the next album, whenever that may be.
Depends on stage/acoustics/echo/tuning/other instruments etc. Singing live can be tough which is why a lot of artists like spears/beiber etc lip sync/auto tune.
I don't need flawless. If need errors completely, I will listen to the CD.
She gave me a real voice, real feelings.
Her performances touched my heart every time
Never In a million years would I think she was a bad singer, and this video just proves it more. Great video! And sadly I do know people who think she's a horrible singer, my friends sadly.... I despise my friends for that sometimes. Lol
Amazing. she sounds fantastic. There's going to be days when she's had coughs and colds that will affect vocals.. she's only human. To have a voice like her in the first place is a blessing for her and her audience. No one is like her physically or vocally. Well done Amy Lee for being unique . 👌👏
3ª voz mais bonita do mundo na opinião de uma revista, acho que não é pouca coisa, eu ainda procuro uma voz com a potência da voz da Amy, eu tinha um show dela em Full HD no Rock in Rio 2011, e nunca tinha notado o quão precioso era a sua voz, pena que perdi esse show e tive que baixar na péssima qualidade de internet em 720p com áudio pior que um MP3...
Pra mim ela é uma rainha do Rock, sua voz me encanta, me arrepia, e cada dia mais viro fã, e não é só eu que gosto, milhões, só que existe gente que não goste, e eu respeito que não goste, mas pra perder tempo fazendo vídeo falando mal do que não gosta é idiotice, infantilidade, procure algo mais útil a fazer!
She's amazing!! Who would ever think she can't sing!!
I love how she puts all her heart on every note, it's really beautiful, and moving. Definitely, Amy Lee is really underrated.
Best female vocalist in any rock band in living memory. No argument.