This is a long video, so have added time stamps and chapters for you to navigate the parts that you are most interested in. 00:00 How, When, Why 01:24 Separatist movement 02:00 The election rigging, 1987 05:12 Violence against Pandits (1980s) 08:37 The Princely state (1947) 10:30 Discrimination 12:16 Role of Jagmohan, Governor 19:11 Militancy in Kashmir 25:05 Abduction of Rubaiya Saeed 28:00 70 terrorists released by JK govt (1989) 29:23 Situation in Refugee camps 30:30 Decline in population of Kashmiri Pandits 34:58 Myths spread by the media 36:11 Killing of Political activists 39:56 Denial of the Kashmiri Pandit Exodus 42:00 Support Newsworthy
That is precisely the false narrative you are made to believe. Hindus have never harmed anyone in the history of mankind. Hindu scriptures dont have concept of kafir or non-believer religion.
Rahul ji, Why is it hard to use the word “Terrorism” instead of “ Panic” ? Why “Exodus” instead of “ Genocide” ? Why “separatist” instead of “terrorist”? Why an apology statement in the concluding line?
Because he belongs to Pseudo Secular Lobby. Infact he was the one who mocked Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri when Vivek was facing the difficulties due to Corona Pandemic. Rahul Pandita co produced Shikara movie which was no less than a Hell like experience for KPs. This guy is an opportunist who is trying to steal the frame. Lets not fall into traps of these fraud hindus.
@@ketanojha Hey why are u spreading lies. He isnt producer of any movie. Just becuase he is not thinking like you, he suddenly becomes a villain to u. Even my ancestors were kashmir exodus like Rahul Pandita. Pls accept without hatred.
धन्यवाद, अनुभा भोसले जी और राहुल पंडित जी मैं,71 वर्षीय सनातन धर्मी हूँ. और कश्मीरी पंडितों के बारे में बहुत कुछ पढ़ा, सुना(पलायन/EXODUS). लेकिन आज जब मैंने राहुल पंडित जी से जो कुछ सुना, बहोत दुख हुआ, यह इसलिए के हम सनातन धर्मी कितने कायर/डरपोक और हमारे सरकार, पुरोगामी विचार करने वाले, वृत्तपत्र समूह और अपने को जगतगुरु, विश्व के सबसे बड़े हिन्दू संघटन(आर एस एस इत्यादि)इन पंडितो के लिए कुछ भी नही कर सके.*शेम*. विश्व के कोई भी मानवाधिकार संगठन को इस बारे में आवाज नाही उठाई, बहोत शर्म के बात है. पहलीबार, मैने कश्मीर पंडितो के बारे 1947से आज तक जो ब्यौरा दिया वह सराहनीय है. कोई दिल्लीवासीय अगर इस वीडियो देख चुके है, तो इसे आपके मुख्यमंत्री अरविंद केजरीवाल को अवश्य भेजिए, जिन्होंने कश्मीरी पंडितों की मजाक उड़ाया और अपमान किया.
It is usual in India that minority groups, whether based on caste, language, religion etc. suffer discrimination of different types. This is particularly so in villages and small towns. But in Kashmir, what Pandits have suffered over the years is exceptional, ruthless, fanatic religious genocide. It is even surprising that there was hardly any protest against it in India or by BJP or RSS. Central Govt failed miserably in protecting India's citizens. This is a disaster of monumental proportions in independent India, just like 1984 riots.
Dear Rahul, deepest respects to you and your journalism. Listening to you and having watched the movie, both have clarified the facts to me. While the movie as I see has focused to show the most intense period during that time, you have tried to explained the some of key facts leading up to it and thereafter. I find both complimenting to understand the whole situation. The bottom line for me, the complete failure of all governments ( state & center) over 30+ years to formally accept this as a grave tragedy of independent India and not providing the community the support to heal - seems almost criminal.
As a community member that was subjected to such horror and pain, look at this man's tone and mannerisms, you'll not find any hate besides his heart bleeding. A thousand thanks to you brother for sharing this with us. I always listen to you and you're indeed a great person. My heartfelt regards Swami Anupam Anand
Very nice. Rahul Pandita as he always is - professional, scientific and never vindictive. But that is also tall order for ordinary Kashmiri pandits who have grown up with that "othering" sentiment for as long as their memory can go.
@Sunny Gates Facts don't care about your feelings. When Mr Ashok Pandey attributed a fake quote to Mr Jagmohan in his Kashmir Files video then Islamists/leftists shared it wildly. Islamo-leftist cabal love convenient lies and hate the truth, it's not surprising at all that you are seething in the comment section
Mr. Rahul: Your journalism proves that no political or social maneuvering can change religious conflicts - The only way out is to somehow free indoctrinated minds.
Bewkoof ho..ye 7th Exodus hai moorkh..We have been knowing the truth for long.Vivek has done a great service to India by holistically telling the truth..
Very well explained and articulated the real problem that plagued the Kashmiri society from 1947 . Kashmiri pandita were being systematically thrown out of the valley by not giving them seats in professional colleges inspite of their merit .
Question here is why never this true status of Kashmiri Victims shown in any Bollywood movies earlier ? Now when Indian citizens realising the truth still there are other groups in all strength to prove its fake movie. What a shame! Only in India this kind of politics is seen. Other countries stand united against Terrorism but it happens only in India where Human Rights are meant for Terrorist and Refugee Camps are meant for innocent Citizens. Article 370 when removed , I never knew rather I never learnt what it meant. But now I can understand how important it was. Every Indian citizen has right to know and learn about its constitution. But we as a common man so focused in our daily work forget about this and at the end it's so necessary to know the truth of each act in our country.
@Sunny Gates what are you talking about? He has written a book Shikara which is his personal story and he is a Kashmiri pandit definitely he has suffered more than Vivek Agnihotri who is making crores. I think Viveks should donate some percentage of his earnings to the welfare of Kashmiri pandits.
@@swapnildarmora6258 i agree a 100%... Also his book our moon has blood clots explains everything in detail.. these fools calling him names don't know a thing!
I fail to understand...When Shikara was made ...why didn't you establish a candid conversation with Mr Vidhu Chopra ? ..ki sir ..this is piece of shit you made .. ..but anyway ..you came up with some facts now...thank you for that . ..this video should have been out when Shikara was released
There was. He did an 1hr + interview with lallantop back in 2018 or so, where he covered all these facts. You can look it up. It was part of Kitabwala series i guess
Just finished reading the book "Our Moon has Blood Clots. Have grown up in Jammu with KP friends and listened to these stories. Have also watched "The Kashmir Files". All these accounts are pretty complementary of each other. Don't know why Rahul Pandita ji would come out against the Kashmir Files movie. If there are minor differences between how Rahul ji wants to tell the story and how Vivek ji wants to tell it, they both are actually complementary to each other.
Yes, Rahul Pandita ridiculed Vivek for his upcoming movie on Kashmir. Vivek said he would do what Rahul Pandita could never do for his community. Now rest is history
RP i really wanted u to bring out these facts after ur film shikara but that film apparently did more of whitewashing of the pain of exodus as per statements of KPs after watching the film ... At least now after the TKFs u brought out these facts
That movie is more about a love couple , so its not appropriate to show such cruel scenes, which wud get eventually censored, since its not backed up by any political party since then.
@@NehaSharma-bv1nl but they were Selling the film by"the untold story of Kashmiri pandits" that's why KP were disappointed with that. Its OK to make film like SIKARA but selling by saying this is the story of KP you are just ignoring genocide
This man has suffered, and as others are pointing put, the book and the movie are in a way complementary. RP deserves a lot of credit for the details that he brings out. Perhaps we can just drop the Shikara thing as a kind of grace from our part, instead of rubbing it in his face every time.
sir i am a big fan of you ........read your book our moon has blood clots in my p.g days .......admire the way you speak truth to power ......we need people like you to make india great .
Rahul sir has been truthful to himself and his entire community in this video.... I don't understand why he wrote a whitewashed movie like Shikara?...but this video speaks truth with quoted facts.... Huge respect for that.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
it is not whitewashed, that movie is more about a love couple , so its not appropriate to show such cruel scenes, which wud get eventually censored, since its not backed up by any political party since then.
Not very convincing counter . Have watched the kashmir files and support the movie and the facts shown . Wish makers had shed light on the 26 Sikh killings in kashmir .
He basically showed in the movie what he is narrating here...far been than the propaganda movie Shikara which made kashmiri Hindus abuse the director in the screening 😂
listened to whole video. It validates what Vivek Agnihotri's Kashmir files. But where are you Rahul before this movie. You squandered your chance by doing Shikara.
Thank you so much Rahul Panditaji. I will be forwarding this video to every friend of mine! Thank you again. So well articulated. You are a star of our community. Thank you very much. God bless you.
Since RP spoke of Uri 1947, it's surprising he didn't speak of Jammu massacre of muslims in 1947 done by the Hindu maharaja's police/army and RSS. The number of muslims killed is mind boggling (conservative est is 48000). Surely that event was an important one in history of the relationship between the two communities. Jammu was a Muslim majority city. Post massacre and exodus, muslims became a minority there. Talking abt KP exodus is fine, but really sad nobody wants to talk abt a far worse genocide and exodus
@@ishaanpandey6214 Inconvenient and uncomfortable truths are always false. That wiki article on Jammu massacre is based on several academic works, newspaper articles and even a reputed court judge's book
@@sapnapandhi1310 Uh wrong. Baramulla massacre happens on 26-27th October by pak afridis where people of all religions were targeted. Jammu massacre started in SEPTEMBER and went on happening into October. Here the Hindu rajah killed his own population, shamelessly colluding with rss. And anyways one massacre doesn't justify another, especially by the state. Godhra doesn't justify state sponsored Gujarat pogrom🙂
Kashmir: History (August 1947 ) :JAMMU ROITS IN 1947: The Reason :: In such a climate of fear and uncertainty, by April 1947, non-Muslims from the violence in the Rawalpindi division were arriving in other parts of the Punjab and the Kashmir region, expecting to return after the violence ceased. With in a week of the killings, ‘a large flock’ of the Hindus and Sikhs from Rawalpindi division started migrating to neighbouring Kashmir region. The embittered Sikh and Hindu refugees’ tales of violence raised animosities wherever they settled. They planned revenge and produced and circulated wildly inflammatory pamphlets and brochures. Their horrified tales of the Muslim perpetration circulated widespread and served as an occasion to launch a reign of terror on the Jammu Muslim population. Shortly flight and violence went hand in hand. Violence Jammu was increasingly locked into an all-India pattern, as killings in one part of the country were justified as retribution for violence in another part. Jammu’s Muslims were to pay a heavy price in August-October 1947 for the early disturbances in the West Punjab.
Kashmir Files pales before Rahul Pandita's "Our Moon has blood Clots" The book is his personal account as a victim of the exodus and also deeply detailed and descriptive. It does justice in its description of the horrors faced by the Kashmiri Pandits.
Yes! It was difficult to sleep for a week after I read it.. similar to Sanjay Suri's 1984... terrible incidents of independent India.. unfathomable but true!
I have read your book on Kashmiri Pandit exodus and you never hide facts in interviews but I wonder why did you choose to write for a movie like 'Shikara'. You should have written for Kashmir Files
Shikara looks bad/meek in hindsight. At the time when Shikara was made, no movie had touched the subject of exodus. He has been vocal about the issue since forever, and even if a bad one, it was a step towards highlighting the issue. So I can totally understand him jumping into a project which talked about it. That shows you how desperate we were to tell the story till now.
@@DeepankerKaul yes , Shikara did touch the subject of exodus which surprisingly many weren't aware of. But in a Twitter war between ,I found him ridiculing Vivek for his upcoming movie. Of course,Vivek retaliated strongly. But this conflict didn't make much sense to me
@@ac_te_c_ Oh then why does he has to pop out now explaining and clearing all the so-called myths about kashmiri pandits "exodus". If you go read his tweets, you will understand how this "professional writer" promotes and fuels the leftist Islamist liberal narrative. Again nothing wrong in expressing what he believes or pretends to believe in and sharing that but literally ab ghanta farak nai padta.
@@AkashSharma-oe9no do you know he is a Kashmiri Pandit? Do you know he did an interview with Lallantop 2 years ago where he explained all things in detail? Do you know he has already written a book Shikara which contains all the details?
Expect Rahul Pandita to be branded a traitor and be treated as a Pariah by the left after this. He gave out facts with total disregard for his political leanings. Respect
@@dennisthemenace4288 cancel culture is result of being Woke where definition of woke is twisted meaning anything that particular countries leftist philosphy agree with. Cancel culture from Sanghis ??? They are so few Sanghis in academia , in bueracracy, in media. Who is cancelling ..just one two names here and there .
You say Jagmohan is unfairly blamed for GawKadal massacre. If that was so, wasn't it his responsibility to order an investigation and find the truth. After all, he was the centre of power at that time. He never took such an action because he approved it. Btw, he repeated it again with CRPF forces during Mirwaiz's funeral with 60 (govt figures) to 100 (bbc report) killed in firing. Don't make him out as so innocent.
I am not saying he is not to be blamed. I am saying there has been no investigation in it so far, including during his tenure. But, to be fair, his tenure hardly lasted a few months. Someone should have done it at least after him.
@@rahulpandita5376 , I don't believe KPs left Kashmir only because of Jagmohan and , definiely, biggest blame is on Pak-supported terrorists. But , Jagmohan came with a clear communal agenda and wanted a free-hand to crush kashmiris with iron fist and preferred KPs out of the equation. His acts during those 5 months helped a lot in alienating kashmiris further. As much as you defend Jagmohan limited from a KP's perspective, your credibility will increase much if you accept his very evident failures from larger perspective.
No, it was for Jagmohan kashmiri pundits were saved. Had there no Jagmohan there would be no pundits on earth at this time. Only the terrorist supporter and congress blame him. In real he was innocent and he was saviour.
By removing 370 modi govt did 80% work to bring back the control and improve law and order. Now the pandits will go back as soon as those culprits get exemplary punishment. So govt should bring justice and all the culprits should be in jail. Muslim community should understand they can do the nonsense any more, kashmir is the integral portion of India, they will be punished if they brake law and order. Govt should create environment so pundit community get confidence to get back. Kashmir has the potential to become a best tourist destination if govt make sure there is peace, safety and security. Govt should keep viglent all the mosque and destroy if involved with any kind of violence including stone throwing or encourage fundamentalism. Those Kashmiri Muslims occupied the Kashmiri pandits property should pay the penalty. Need to create confidence and environment of peace.
Rahul Pandita sir Apna apni book mai Jo likha hai Wahi ... Vivek Agnihotri na Apni film ma dikhaya ha Shama Kaul aap Jagmohan g & us time k situation Ko hi byan kia gaya hai Film ma
Rahul had already written a book that contains all the details. He did an interview with Lallantop two years ago citing all these details. He himself had to leave the Kashmir valley as a Kashmiri Pandit. I really don't understand what credibility does Vivek Agnihotri hold in front of this guy!!!
He has the ability of being a foul mouthed oppurtunist with a phenomenal talent of sycophancy! He's also known to transform into a doormat when in presence of those who hold the reigns!
Jish zulm ko Rahulji aur unke parivaar ne saha uske wavjood Yeh Insaan sach ki Baat kar raha. Kuch logo ko uparwaala bahut pyaar se taraashta tabhi toh halaat unka kuch nahi bigaad sakte.
क्या कारण था क्या हमारी सरकारें सोयी हुईं थी या वो मुस्लिम दुनिया का खौफ था या भारत में मुस्लिम वोटरों का टूटने का खतरा जो कश्मीरी पंडितों के कत्लेआम का जिम्मेदार था
I'm reading Our moon has blood clot it is very well written so far. But here in this video during the last 2 minutes, Rahul sir aapne apna narrative thoda narrow kar diya hai.. I didn't get you when you said ki aapko Indian state ka flag bearer hone ki jarurat nahi hai.. If you aur any1 here can help me to understand your perspective it will be a huge help.
Almost all Brahmins who wear threads trace their origin to Kashmir. My own forefathers were given asylum by a Pandya king of Tamilnadu. If the government permits we all can return at our own costs even if there is risk of deaths. Let us not fear death.
Kashmir is plagued with injustices to its people . This is just what I have understood from many sources including Hindu and Muslim. A Hindu king instead of doing the right thing by his people, sold Kashmir to India and ran away from Kashmir . The kashmiri Pandits persons in there did everything they could to keep spying for India and reporting Intelligence to India. In The valley there was a deep mistrust of Pandits .it did not help that all economics in the valley had to go through a Pandit. There was an estimate that thy controlled over 70% of trade . Donno how true . India there is a strategic need for Kashmir and has used the very fight for kashmiri rights against them by denying the people the right for self determination . I would say in a frustrated state people will resort to violence aginst the nearest party . Just like in Gujurat attacks on Muslims by Hindus . Many of such hatred continues till this day . One person remarked of Indian freedom fighters were terrorists to the British but freedom fighters to its own people.
Sir ap.na bi yahi kaha tha Interviews Mai NDTV & Lallantop ka interviews apka record pa pade ha Baqi apnai to book likhi ha pori Ap na khud bola ha pandit aurton ko. Chod ke jane ka Elan kia tha Jo Vivek agnihotri na dikhaya ha
Bhai kon kahta hai ki 1987 se pahle kashmiri pandits ki life bed of roses thi???? The 1990 me jo exodus hua it was 7th exodus usse pahle se hi ye sab chahlu hai bhai ...kyu ghuma fira ke baate kar rahe ho
This is a fact-filled, chronological outline by a survivor that still gives an idea of possible causes & most importantly, how things built up to that explosive situation in 1990. Otherwise the general impression is that people just suddenly woke up one day & started killing neighbours & friends in 1990. Pls try to add sub titles in as many languages (if possible!) so facts are there on record, & don't get distorted by anyone - RW or LW.
Thanks Rahul Ji, for throwing some light on the subject. If possible would you please shine some more light on the plight of Kashmiri Muslims especially after the coming of the Hindutva Regime in New Delhi? Please mention there: if the sweeping manslaughter of a Muslim Majority in J & K & the rest of India is attributed to a Revengeful course in the light of the past?
@@brachisaurous So you are armed to the teeth: your biased reply is a "HIGHLIGHTED" Reply already?!!! NOW Tell me who has a better claim :"Chit bhi apni, patt bhi apni...". Agay nahi bolun to achha hai. But lemme try once again to explain: See there can't be a smoke without fire. And given the context (Failure of Russian Invasion of Afghanistan, before that the Choice of the Kashmiri King to join India while Majority we're Muslims & the most UNFORTUNATE rise of the Unislamic Extremism in early 1980's and all of these must have caused the exodus is deplorable apart from being so unfortunate. Imagine how the state of India had neglected the just insecurities of Kashmiri Pandits & even after the exodus didn't look after them? And now how the General Kashmiri People are killed & harmed by the State Machinery as if the the Indian State is taking revenge from her own people? All those trouble makers: Yasin Malik and his ilks are either dead or soon will be.. But what about the Children whom we are making what we don't want. I think we should look at the past to learn from there the mistakes; which we should never commit. I am for the rehabilitation of the New age Kashmiri generation & for that I don't have to be a politician.
@@silentlatif jao na kashmir mein, idhar kya Kar rahe ho. go and help the "misguided youth". I've lost 2 family members (armed forces) due to insurgency since the 90s. YOU MUST BE DREAMING IF YOU EXPECT MERCY FOR THESE ANIMALS FROM PEOPLE WHO ARE DIRECTLY AFFECTED. easy to be idealistic from afar, or maybe your "bias" stems from something more fundamental ?
@@brachisaurousI am sorry for your loss but How many did your Dead Relatives kill (when the two of them were alive), and how many children did they blinded??? We always have had a super bandobast for your "Animals/I call simple civilians" since the time of the exodus. What stopped us from nipping Extremism bud in 1990? You are a FUNDAMENTALIST: who lives in a fools paradise that having the Official Gun, you can just go about doing anything, much like those who wanted to make Kashmir an Islamic State? Your approach to me is as bad as theirs. Why you have to be superior just because you are a Majoritarian mindset. Can't you coexist peacefully.
Sir , completely surprised by how you start and how you end this video. You summarize it really well by passing a message that Kashmiri pundits should not be expected to be flag bearers of either secularism or pluralism , all the time and we should give them some allowance for the price they have already paid for this . But Sir , you are the one who has let Kashmiri Pundits down by not walking the talk. With this video you have actually told us that things were much worse for much longer then it was depicted in the movie . With your words you have corroborated the movie. But in your acts you have grievously erred by not doing your bit for the cause. You wrote a script for a dud movie and chose to compromise a good chance , at the cost of being accepted in the vacuous company of people in Bollywood with no humanity . It seems this video is an attempt to reconcile your conscious to your suspension of a just cause . It is a pity that an erudite person like you , who is author of so many great books was compelled to make choices that you made while you chose to deride the first honest attempt by someone to highlight the plight of your community. But respected sir , better late than never . Good that you are fighting other inducements and enticements that are keeping you away from a just cause . May god give you the strength to stick to the just cause .
You are most secular person as per liberal ppl but they never acknowledge your pain.. Myths are mostly spread by liberal secular of this country which you are exposing today..
You were opposing Vivek agnihotri and this movie earlier...Rahul. Look at your earlier tweets. You wrote nonsensical movie like Shikhara. Now suddenly you want to ride the wave of Kashmir pandit sympathy. Shame on you. Vivek is more of a man than you even though he isn't a Kashmiri. You are just an opportunistic coward.
Sir, why use the "majority-minority" terminology? It is confusing and entirely unnecessary. Just use Muslim-Hindu. That would be more sincere and direct.
Audio-Visual media is the most strongest medium to portray the truth. Movies hence provide the best possible way to convey the message. Whether the director of the movie has other motives becomes irrelevant here till he portrays the truth. It is said that Justice can be delayed but never denied. Same goes for Truth. Conspirators may use every weapon in their arsenal to supress the truth, but slowly it emerges like a phoenix. Thanks to the movie, the common man of India is now coming to know of the pain the Kashmiri pandits had to go through, since centuries. More painful since Independence as Kashmir was supposed to be an integral part of India and the Indian establishment failed the Kashmiri Pandits big time. Kashmiri Pandits were treated as outsiders in their own country. Thankfully now people will realize the true colour of the Congress & Communists & its leaders since Independence. Communists in Bengal also have a bloody history of massacres. Its time a movie is made on that. Very few people in India may have heard a place called Marijhapi where the communists have blood on their hands. It time people know who the real enemy is !
Rahul aap bhi to selective truths bata rahe hain. Not one mention of kashmiri Muslim civilians being KILLED by terrorists and armed forces both! It's as if you're totally blind to their plight!!
Absolutely honest 👌. You are right grief is something that needs time to heal. This is rightly presented as an emotion that is not easy to heal because it was a targetted massacre and uprooting over years. Amazing that reporters researchers teaching community politicians Center all fell prey to it knowingly or unknowingly brushing it aside as not worth an issue that affects the nation. India until now has not decided about Kashmir. We have now taken a stand that we will not let go the state and that is reflected in the form of the removal of the articles. The real Kashmiris are the ones who can rebuild it back to it. So reinvesting into it is an opportunity you must not miss.
Your careful usage of words is a remarkable job , done by a thorough professional. A Professional who will use the word exodus instead of genocide and so many more, throughout your monologue. What I am more interested in is would you rather name the genocide of Jews as final solution as well. Or the terrorist attack of 9/11 be re-termed as an airline accident. I think so you will not........my respected elder friend ( not really ) , first learn to call a spade a spade then try to dictate your openion to others.
Rahul, you made shikara, which was completely a lie but with a poster that said unfold story of kashmiri pandits . Then you challenged another filmmaker to make it, when he has made you are nitpicking inaccuracies in that. Where were all these facts when you chose to whitewash terrorism in shkara.
He never made shikara....he's not a film director or producer...maybe he was used as an adviser and also the movie was roughly based off of his book " our moon has blood clot". Also talking about the new movie "kashmir files" It has several plot holes along with subliminal propaganda. The movie is excellent and well acted but our emotional fool people have started promoting it by saying " you're anti national/ anti hindu if you don't see this movie" and rather than helping and sympathizing the victims they're calling out Muslims and blaming them ( if there was a movie named 'Gujrat files' trust me Muslims would do the same ) Also in a recent interview Mr. Vivek Agnihotri was asked will this money (pointing towards Kashmir files) be used for the betterment of the Kashmiri pandit and he replied with " Well atleast let us earn some money. The movie haven't earnt anything " ( we all know it's a 100Crore + movie )
Interesting that when talking about incidents of 1947 Kashmir, Rahul avoids talking about huge massacre of Muslims in neighbouring Jammu which happened weeks before the Pathan invasion he cites. Remember that it is all part of same state. Muslims who were 61% of Jammu population in 1941 was reduced to a minority after this. : To quote a 10 August 1948 report published in The Times, London: “2,37,000 Muslims were systematically exterminated - unless they escaped to Pakistan along the border - by the forces of the Dogra State headed by the Maharaja in person and aided by Hindus and Sikhs. This happened in October 1947, five days before the Pathan invasion and nine days before the Maharaja’s accession to india.” As a result of the massacre/migration, Muslims who were a majority (61 per cent) in the Jammu region became a minority.
Oh great more what about'tism... Okay let's play this game, do you how many Kashmiri exoduses for KPs have been there throughout history? Seven! The earliest dates all the way back to the 1300s when Sikandar Shah forcefully converted and killed Hindus in the valley! Sorry but if you wanna compare numbers you'll still come up short
@@krishnakumarshenoy4980 , No , Kashmir was a princely state ruled by hindu dogra kings where no provincial elections happened. He feared that muslim majority in his kingdom might force him to join Pakistan. So, he and the dogra tribes decided to take matters into their own hands to pre-emptively target muslims and he succeeded to change the demographics of jammu. Every other murders in erstwhile J&K state followed this event.
@@AlexRogers4U , This 7 number is just a curious figure thrown around to fit the 7 seas/ 7 heavens/7 wonders-of-world kind of wording to catch the fancy. Muslims in kashmir valley were hindus, but it is foolish to claim that they converted forcibly. Also, if you read ancient kashmir history , you will also find hindu kings like Harsha who was an expert in plundering temples and killing locals. Most of these are politically motivated.
Jab Mohabbat Na biki duniya mein, to humne Bazaaron ko Nafrat se garam kr diya. Aur Jab hum masle na suljaa sake aawaam ki, to jhooti siyasat se nazron ko nam kr diya..
![ROSÉ(로제) - APT. (Band VER.) (With. 이영지) [더 시즌즈-이영지의 레인보우] | KBS 241129 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IW8qaemx74g/mqdefault.jpg)
This is a long video, so have added time stamps and chapters for you to navigate the parts that you are most interested in.
00:00 How, When, Why
01:24 Separatist movement
02:00 The election rigging, 1987
05:12 Violence against Pandits (1980s)
08:37 The Princely state (1947)
10:30 Discrimination
12:16 Role of Jagmohan, Governor
19:11 Militancy in Kashmir
25:05 Abduction of Rubaiya Saeed
28:00 70 terrorists released by JK govt (1989)
29:23 Situation in Refugee camps
30:30 Decline in population of Kashmiri Pandits
34:58 Myths spread by the media
36:11 Killing of Political activists
39:56 Denial of the Kashmiri Pandit Exodus
42:00 Support Newsworthy
That is precisely the false narrative you are made to believe. Hindus have never harmed anyone in the history of mankind. Hindu scriptures dont have concept of kafir or non-believer religion.
Rahul ji,
Why is it hard to use the word “Terrorism” instead of “ Panic” ?
Why “Exodus” instead of “ Genocide” ?
Why “separatist” instead of “terrorist”?
Why an apology statement in the concluding line?
Because he belongs to Pseudo Secular Lobby. Infact he was the one who mocked Vivek Ranjan Agnihotri when Vivek was facing the difficulties due to Corona Pandemic. Rahul Pandita co produced Shikara movie which was no less than a Hell like experience for KPs.
This guy is an opportunist who is trying to steal the frame. Lets not fall into traps of these fraud hindus.
His masters wont allow him. If he reads our comments, he would make it we kashmiri pandits and you Hindus.
Ask your feku
because that shows difference between well educated & educated but ignorant.
@@ketanojha Hey why are u spreading lies. He isnt producer of any movie. Just becuase he is not thinking like you, he suddenly becomes a villain to u. Even my ancestors were kashmir exodus like Rahul Pandita. Pls accept without hatred.
धन्यवाद, अनुभा भोसले जी
और राहुल पंडित जी
मैं,71 वर्षीय सनातन धर्मी हूँ.
और कश्मीरी पंडितों के बारे में बहुत कुछ पढ़ा, सुना(पलायन/EXODUS).
लेकिन आज जब मैंने राहुल पंडित जी से जो कुछ सुना, बहोत दुख हुआ,
यह इसलिए के हम सनातन धर्मी कितने कायर/डरपोक और हमारे सरकार, पुरोगामी विचार करने वाले, वृत्तपत्र समूह और अपने को जगतगुरु, विश्व के सबसे बड़े हिन्दू संघटन(आर एस एस इत्यादि)इन पंडितो के लिए कुछ भी नही कर सके.*शेम*.
विश्व के कोई भी मानवाधिकार संगठन को इस बारे में आवाज नाही उठाई, बहोत शर्म के बात है.
पहलीबार, मैने कश्मीर पंडितो के बारे 1947से आज तक जो ब्यौरा दिया वह सराहनीय है.
कोई दिल्लीवासीय अगर इस वीडियो देख चुके है, तो इसे आपके मुख्यमंत्री अरविंद केजरीवाल को अवश्य भेजिए, जिन्होंने कश्मीरी पंडितों की मजाक उड़ाया और अपमान किया.
It is usual in India that minority groups, whether based on caste, language, religion etc. suffer discrimination of different types. This is particularly so in villages and small towns. But in Kashmir, what Pandits have suffered over the years is exceptional, ruthless, fanatic religious genocide. It is even surprising that there was hardly any protest against it in India or by BJP or RSS. Central Govt failed miserably in protecting India's citizens. This is a disaster of monumental proportions in independent India, just like 1984 riots.
BJP protested that time but failed videos of Narendra Modi (1990s) in Kashmir available on internet
Dear Rahul, deepest respects to you and your journalism. Listening to you and having watched the movie, both have clarified the facts to me. While the movie as I see has focused to show the most intense period during that time, you have tried to explained the some of key facts leading up to it and thereafter. I find both complimenting to understand the whole situation. The bottom line for me, the complete failure of all governments ( state & center) over 30+ years to formally accept this as a grave tragedy of independent India and not providing the community the support to heal - seems almost criminal.
Thank you, Manu.
As a community member that was subjected to such horror and pain, look at this man's tone and mannerisms, you'll not find any hate besides his heart bleeding.
A thousand thanks to you brother for sharing this with us. I always listen to you and you're indeed a great person.
My heartfelt regards
Swami Anupam Anand
Thank you.
@@rahulpandita5376 Pls upload videos from your own channel. You're brilliant when you talk about literature and current affairs.
Respect for Rahul Pandita for this video.
This is exactly what 'The Kashmir Files' has portrayed. Why were you opposing it then?
True
Exactly my question! I
Pressure from the pseudo secular lobby and Jihadi sympathizers media like newslaundry wiree Quint and many others
Requesting viewers to also go through the Twitter battle between this gentleman and Mr. Vivek Agnihotri regarding the kashmir files movie
Right..this gentleman is showing his gentleness there..!!
@@appysharma6238 lol
@@appysharma6238 you would too if u were a victim and someone tried to exploit the situation for monetary gains alone
Very nice. Rahul Pandita as he always is - professional, scientific and never vindictive. But that is also tall order for ordinary Kashmiri pandits who have grown up with that "othering" sentiment for as long as their memory can go.
Thank you for a v informative talk. Hope the Kashmiri Pandits are able to reclaim what they lost.
Thanks you. I have not watched the Kashmir files till now. But after listening to these facts now will watch for sure.
@Sunny Gates he himself has suffered , go read his book first then you will get to know the real picture
Pls do watch &then research urself u'll get to know the truth...
@Sunny Gates Facts don't care about your feelings.
When Mr Ashok Pandey attributed a fake quote to Mr Jagmohan in his Kashmir Files video then Islamists/leftists shared it wildly. Islamo-leftist cabal love convenient lies and hate the truth, it's not surprising at all that you are seething in the comment section
Also Please watch the movie Shikara ( RP screenplay and writer) - the pain of KPs was depicted without any bitterness
Mr. Rahul: Your journalism proves that no political or social maneuvering can change religious conflicts - The only way out is to somehow free indoctrinated minds.
Please say this to your people who call us kafir
Ghar wapsi hee ek matra tarika hai
Bewkoof ho..ye 7th Exodus hai moorkh..We have been knowing the truth for long.Vivek has done a great service to India by holistically telling the truth..
Very well explained and articulated the real problem that plagued the Kashmiri society from 1947 . Kashmiri pandita were being systematically thrown out of the valley by not giving them seats in professional colleges inspite of their merit .
Question here is why never this true status of Kashmiri Victims shown in any Bollywood movies earlier ?
Now when Indian citizens realising the truth still there are other groups in all strength to prove its fake movie. What a shame! Only in India this kind of politics is seen. Other countries stand united against Terrorism but it happens only in India where Human Rights are meant for Terrorist and Refugee Camps are meant for innocent Citizens.
Article 370 when removed , I never knew rather I never learnt what it meant. But now I can understand how important it was.
Every Indian citizen has right to know and learn about its constitution. But we as a common man so focused in our daily work forget about this and at the end it's so necessary to know the truth of each act in our country.
@Sunny Gates what are you talking about? He has written a book Shikara which is his personal story and he is a Kashmiri pandit definitely he has suffered more than Vivek Agnihotri who is making crores. I think Viveks should donate some percentage of his earnings to the welfare of Kashmiri pandits.
@@swapnildarmora6258 i agree a 100%... Also his book our moon has blood clots explains everything in detail.. these fools calling him names don't know a thing!
I fail to understand...When Shikara was made ...why didn't you establish a candid conversation with Mr Vidhu Chopra ? ..ki sir ..this is piece of shit you made .. ..but anyway ..you came up with some facts now...thank you for that . ..this video should have been out when Shikara was released
VVC is a pandit too!
@@ABhattacharya I know
There was. He did an 1hr + interview with lallantop back in 2018 or so, where he covered all these facts. You can look it up. It was part of Kitabwala series i guess
@@ABhattacharya VVC sold his soul to money and Bollywood.
@@DeepankerKaul yes and people will ignore it because it doesn't fit their narrative. Vivek Agnihotri is just making money.
Great chronological explaination of the Kashmiri Pandit exodus
Thank you
Sabki kundli hai mere pass.
🕉️🕉️ Hindu Ekta zindabad.
Just finished reading the book "Our Moon has Blood Clots.
Have grown up in Jammu with KP friends and listened to these stories.
Have also watched "The Kashmir Files".
All these accounts are pretty complementary of each other.
Don't know why Rahul Pandita ji would come out against the Kashmir Files movie.
If there are minor differences between how Rahul ji wants to tell the story and how Vivek ji wants to tell it, they both are actually complementary to each other.
There was a twitter war between Rahul Pandita and Vivek Agnihotri related to movie based on Kashmir. Is he the same Rahul Pandita?
Indians fight amongst themselves, others take advantage of it.
Yes, Rahul Pandita ridiculed Vivek for his upcoming movie on Kashmir. Vivek said he would do what Rahul Pandita could never do for his community. Now rest is history
Wahi gaddar
35:03 She was Barkha Dutt why are you not taking the name...
You know, don't you? So do others. Let journalists decide how they want to present a story, as long as truth is not compromised.
To defend his girlfriend burkha Dutt's name..
Because he is great admirer of Arundhati Roy.
Appreciate such an evidence based discourse.
RP i really wanted u to bring out these facts after ur film shikara but that film apparently did more of whitewashing of the pain of exodus as per statements of KPs after watching the film ... At least now after the TKFs u brought out these facts
That movie is more about a love couple , so its not appropriate to show such cruel scenes, which wud get eventually censored, since its not backed up by any political party since then.
@@NehaSharma-bv1nl but they were Selling the film by"the untold story of Kashmiri pandits" that's why KP were disappointed with that.
Its OK to make film like SIKARA but selling by saying this is the story of KP you are just ignoring genocide
This man has suffered, and as others are pointing put, the book and the movie are in a way complementary. RP deserves a lot of credit for the details that he brings out. Perhaps we can just drop the Shikara thing as a kind of grace from our part, instead of rubbing it in his face every time.
sir i am a big fan of you ........read your book our moon has blood clots in my p.g days .......admire the way you speak truth to power ......we need people like you to make india great .
Rahul sir has been truthful to himself and his entire community in this video.... I don't understand why he wrote a whitewashed movie like Shikara?...but this video speaks truth with quoted facts.... Huge respect for that.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
it is not whitewashed, that movie is more about a love couple , so its not appropriate to show such cruel scenes, which wud get eventually censored, since its not backed up by any political party since then.
Bollywood me waisi hi movie banti rahi hai Vivek Agnihotri doesn't consider himself part of Bollywood that's why he had guts to show reality
@momo is a pxdx and xllxh is a pxdx enabler Rahul has written a book Shikara go and read that book it has all details.
@@NehaSharma-bv1nl then why it is promoted as Kashmir pandit story . Don't try to oversmart
@@nitlover8319 Kashmiri Pundits can't have a love story?
This is future of Hindus if they still believes secularism because India not devided on secularism
Not very convincing counter . Have watched the kashmir files and support the movie and the facts shown . Wish makers had shed light on the 26 Sikh killings in kashmir .
What do u mean?
Sane voices like Rahul Pandita should triumph over the bigoted voices like Agnihotri's.
He basically showed in the movie what he is narrating here...far been than the propaganda movie Shikara which made kashmiri Hindus abuse the director in the screening 😂
@@nitlover8319 he already has written a book citing all facts 2-3 years ago
@@swapnildarmora6258 he wrote the book in 2013
listened to whole video. It validates what Vivek Agnihotri's Kashmir files.
But where are you Rahul before this movie. You squandered your chance by doing Shikara.
The book, Our moon has blood clots.
Thank you so much Rahul Panditaji. I will be forwarding this video to every friend of mine! Thank you again. So well articulated. You are a star of our community. Thank you very much. God bless you.
Extremely informative and true.
कितना काला सच छिपा हुआ है कश्मीर में😢।
Videos like these should be part of school curriculum - know facts without any bias.
Agree
RAHUL Pandita g
Na jo yahan bola ha & apni book ma
Likha ha wahi Faroq Abdullah & Mufti ka role tha & wahi Vivek Agnihotri na
Apni Film ma dikhaya ha
I can never doubt integrity of Rahul Pandita ! He has lived the tragedy..
Then you'll find yourself hoodwinked often. Not all victims are honest. Many use their personal tragedy for their own nefarious agenda.
Since RP spoke of Uri 1947, it's surprising he didn't speak of Jammu massacre of muslims in 1947 done by the Hindu maharaja's police/army and RSS. The number of muslims killed is mind boggling (conservative est is 48000). Surely that event was an important one in history of the relationship between the two communities. Jammu was a Muslim majority city. Post massacre and exodus, muslims became a minority there. Talking abt KP exodus is fine, but really sad nobody wants to talk abt a far worse genocide and exodus
Everything is false there is no case . just wikipidia source is not enough
@@ishaanpandey6214 Inconvenient and uncomfortable truths are always false. That wiki article on Jammu massacre is based on several academic works, newspaper articles and even a reputed court judge's book
Jammu massacre occurred following killing of many Hindus in baramula by kabayalees whom local Muslims helped
@@sapnapandhi1310 Uh wrong. Baramulla massacre happens on 26-27th October by pak afridis where people of all religions were targeted. Jammu massacre started in SEPTEMBER and went on happening into October. Here the Hindu rajah killed his own population, shamelessly colluding with rss. And anyways one massacre doesn't justify another, especially by the state. Godhra doesn't justify state sponsored Gujarat pogrom🙂
Kashmir: History (August 1947 ) :JAMMU ROITS IN 1947: The Reason :: In such a climate of fear and uncertainty, by April 1947, non-Muslims from the violence in the Rawalpindi division were arriving in other parts of the Punjab and the Kashmir region, expecting to return after the violence ceased.
With in a week of the killings, ‘a large flock’ of the Hindus and Sikhs from Rawalpindi division started migrating to neighbouring Kashmir region. The embittered Sikh and Hindu refugees’ tales of violence raised animosities wherever they settled. They planned revenge and produced and circulated wildly inflammatory pamphlets and brochures. Their horrified tales of the Muslim perpetration circulated widespread and served as an occasion to launch a reign of terror on the Jammu Muslim population. Shortly flight and violence went hand in hand. Violence Jammu was increasingly locked into an all-India pattern, as killings in one part of the country were justified as retribution for violence in another part. Jammu’s Muslims were to pay a heavy price in August-October 1947 for the early disturbances in the West Punjab.
Excellent viewing indeed
Kashmir Files pales before Rahul Pandita's "Our Moon has blood Clots"
The book is his personal account as a victim of the exodus and also deeply detailed and descriptive. It does justice in its description of the horrors faced by the Kashmiri Pandits.
so why he did not put the same in Shikara movie?
@@ramPrare23 the director was vidhu vinod chopra..that explains
@@ramPrare23 He wrote according to the directors & genre requirement
Already sab Vivek Agnihotri ke peeche pade hai if he showed everything that movie would never have seen the theatres
Yes! It was difficult to sleep for a week after I read it.. similar to Sanjay Suri's 1984... terrible incidents of independent India.. unfathomable but true!
Rahul Pandita tries to bust prevalent myths propagated by the perpetrators of crime. Factual, logical and straight from the horses mouth. Kudos.
I have read your book on Kashmiri Pandit exodus and you never hide facts in interviews but I wonder why did you choose to write for a movie like 'Shikara'. You should have written for Kashmir Files
Paisaaaaaa. And validation by the oppressors.
Shikara looks bad/meek in hindsight. At the time when Shikara was made, no movie had touched the subject of exodus. He has been vocal about the issue since forever, and even if a bad one, it was a step towards highlighting the issue. So I can totally understand him jumping into a project which talked about it. That shows you how desperate we were to tell the story till now.
Kashmiri Files is produced by BJP stooge, Anupam Kher and Vivek. Propaganda to fit your narrative.
@@DeepankerKaul yes , Shikara did touch the subject of exodus which surprisingly many weren't aware of. But in a Twitter war between ,I found him ridiculing Vivek for his upcoming movie. Of course,Vivek retaliated strongly. But this conflict didn't make much sense to me
👌👌
You got a chance to show your narrative with Shikara, ab kya faayda, ghanti bajate raho koi farak nai padta.
RP is professional writer, Not a reformist, He writes for as VC , I noticed a Sudden Jump Jan 90 and March 90, why?
@@ac_te_c_ Oh then why does he has to pop out now explaining and clearing all the so-called myths about kashmiri pandits "exodus". If you go read his tweets, you will understand how this "professional writer" promotes and fuels the leftist Islamist liberal narrative. Again nothing wrong in expressing what he believes or pretends to believe in and sharing that but literally ab ghanta farak nai padta.
@@AkashSharma-oe9no Absolutely correct, entire talk is calculated as if justfying the Azadi Narra.
@@AkashSharma-oe9no do you know he is a Kashmiri Pandit? Do you know he did an interview with Lallantop 2 years ago where he explained all things in detail? Do you know he has already written a book Shikara which contains all the details?
Expect Rahul Pandita to be branded a traitor and be treated as a Pariah by the left after this. He gave out facts with total disregard for his political leanings. Respect
Traitor by left why??! That means he was leftist?
branding traitor and anti national are sanghi credentials.
im confused ...
@@dennisthemenace4288 cancel culture is result of being Woke where definition of woke is twisted meaning anything that particular countries leftist philosphy agree with. Cancel culture from Sanghis ??? They are so few Sanghis in academia , in bueracracy, in media. Who is cancelling ..just one two names here and there .
@@pratikshatiwari7011 Yes a self proclaimed one.
You say Jagmohan is unfairly blamed for GawKadal massacre. If that was so, wasn't it his responsibility to order an investigation and find the truth. After all, he was the centre of power at that time. He never took such an action because he approved it.
Btw, he repeated it again with CRPF forces during Mirwaiz's funeral with 60 (govt figures) to 100 (bbc report) killed in firing.
Don't make him out as so innocent.
I am not saying he is not to be blamed. I am saying there has been no investigation in it so far, including during his tenure. But, to be fair, his tenure hardly lasted a few months. Someone should have done it at least after him.
@@rahulpandita5376 , I don't believe KPs left Kashmir only because of Jagmohan and , definiely, biggest blame is on Pak-supported terrorists. But , Jagmohan came with a clear communal agenda and wanted a free-hand to crush kashmiris with iron fist and preferred KPs out of the equation. His acts during those 5 months helped a lot in alienating kashmiris further. As much as you defend Jagmohan limited from a KP's perspective, your credibility will increase much if you accept his very evident failures from larger perspective.
No, it was for Jagmohan kashmiri pundits were saved. Had there no Jagmohan there would be no pundits on earth at this time. Only the terrorist supporter and congress blame him. In real he was innocent and he was saviour.
Always in denial, yes, the pandits left because they were bored, happy??
Well said Rahul
By removing 370 modi govt did 80% work to bring back the control and improve law and order. Now the pandits will go back as soon as those culprits get exemplary punishment. So govt should bring justice and all the culprits should be in jail. Muslim community should understand they can do the nonsense any more, kashmir is the integral portion of India, they will be punished if they brake law and order. Govt should create environment so pundit community get confidence to get back. Kashmir has the potential to become a best tourist destination if govt make sure there is peace, safety and security. Govt should keep viglent all the mosque and destroy if involved with any kind of violence including stone throwing or encourage fundamentalism. Those Kashmiri Muslims occupied the Kashmiri pandits property should pay the penalty. Need to create confidence and environment of peace.
Rahul Pandita sir
Apna apni book mai
Jo likha hai
Wahi ... Vivek Agnihotri na
Apni film ma dikhaya ha
Shama Kaul aap
Jagmohan g & us time k situation
Ko hi byan kia gaya hai Film ma
How can first killing be in 89 when you told stories from 60's 50's and 40's too
Rahul had already written a book that contains all the details. He did an interview with Lallantop two years ago citing all these details. He himself had to leave the Kashmir valley as a Kashmiri Pandit. I really don't understand what credibility does Vivek Agnihotri hold in front of this guy!!!
He has the ability of being a foul mouthed oppurtunist with a phenomenal talent of sycophancy! He's also known to transform into a doormat when in presence of those who hold the reigns!
I hope Rahul P had done better interviews with Vidhu Vinod Chopra at that of Shikara and make authentic film that time.
Thanx for giving fact
So well explained. But why it doesn’t reflected in Movie like Shikara
Thank you for putting Facts and evidence based analysis
This video helped me understand the movie even better.
Jish zulm ko Rahulji aur unke parivaar ne saha uske wavjood Yeh Insaan sach ki Baat kar raha. Kuch logo ko uparwaala bahut pyaar se taraashta tabhi toh halaat unka kuch nahi bigaad sakte.
Bahut shukriya
Tumhara uparwala toh hum sabko kaafir samajhta hai. Aur usne humare liye dohjak ki aag muqarrar kar rakhi hai.
Rahul to aapne Shikara jaisi movie kyun banner di when it was based on your book
Excellent Rahul ji
क्या कारण था क्या हमारी सरकारें सोयी हुईं थी या वो मुस्लिम दुनिया का खौफ था या भारत में मुस्लिम वोटरों का टूटने का खतरा जो कश्मीरी पंडितों के कत्लेआम का जिम्मेदार था
Aisa lagta hai jaisa abhi bhi iss community se darr gaya nahi hai. Ab pura desh inki baat kar raha hai, ab inko himmat karna chahiye.
Why this was not written in your book and the movie Shikara...I have seen ur tweets for Viveek and his reply too
So plz go and sleep
Much of this in the book.
I'm reading Our moon has blood clot it is very well written so far.
But here in this video during the last 2 minutes, Rahul sir aapne apna narrative thoda narrow kar diya hai.. I didn't get you when you said ki aapko Indian state ka flag bearer hone ki jarurat nahi hai..
If you aur any1 here can help me to understand your perspective it will be a huge help.
बहुत अच्छा लगा
Thank you
Almost all Brahmins who wear threads trace their origin to Kashmir. My own forefathers were given asylum by a Pandya king of Tamilnadu. If the government permits we all can return at our own costs even if there is risk of deaths. Let us not fear death.
Wish there were English subtitles
Kashmir is plagued with injustices to its people . This is just what I have understood from many sources including Hindu and Muslim.
A Hindu king instead of doing the right thing by his people, sold Kashmir to India and ran away from Kashmir .
The kashmiri Pandits persons in there did everything they could to keep spying for India and reporting Intelligence to India. In The valley there was a deep mistrust of Pandits .it did not help that all economics in the valley had to go through a Pandit. There was an estimate that thy controlled over 70% of trade . Donno how true .
India there is a strategic need for Kashmir and has used the very fight for kashmiri rights against them by denying the people the right for self determination .
I would say in a frustrated state people will resort to violence aginst the nearest party . Just like in Gujurat attacks on Muslims by Hindus . Many of such hatred continues till this day .
One person remarked of Indian freedom fighters were terrorists to the British but freedom fighters to its own people.
Aaj frst time aapne Kashmiri pandits ke liye exodus word use Kiya ha genocide ki jageh koi wajeh
Pls add English subtitles so that everyone can understand.
I agree.
Sir ap.na bi yahi kaha tha
Interviews Mai
NDTV & Lallantop ka interviews apka record pa pade ha
Baqi apnai to book likhi ha pori
Ap na khud bola ha pandit aurton ko. Chod ke jane ka Elan kia tha
Jo Vivek agnihotri na dikhaya ha
राहुल जी आपने अच्छी तरह से कोहरे को साफ किया है,धुंध छटी है अब।सुबह जरूर होगी।आने वाला समय कश्मीरी पंडितों का होगा।धन्यवाद
MP mein Ratlam ke pass ek gaon hai wanha bhi Hindu ke aise halat bane hain, unhe gaon chodne majboor kiya par koi news nahi hai
Bhai kon kahta hai ki 1987 se pahle kashmiri pandits ki life bed of roses thi???? The 1990 me jo exodus hua it was 7th exodus usse pahle se hi ye sab chahlu hai bhai ...kyu ghuma fira ke baate kar rahe ho
This is a fact-filled, chronological outline by a survivor that still gives an idea of possible causes & most importantly, how things built up to that explosive situation in 1990. Otherwise the general impression is that people just suddenly woke up one day & started killing neighbours & friends in 1990. Pls try to add sub titles in as many languages (if possible!) so facts are there on record, & don't get distorted by anyone - RW or LW.
निस्संदेह कश्मीर समस्या के लिए कांग्रेस जिम्मेदार है। समय रहते अगर इसे समझा जाता तो यह कत्लेआम न होता
Thanks Rahul Ji, for throwing some light on the subject. If possible would you please shine some more light on the plight of Kashmiri Muslims especially after the coming of the Hindutva Regime in New Delhi? Please mention there: if the sweeping manslaughter of a Muslim Majority in J & K & the rest of India is attributed to a Revengeful course in the light of the past?
don't worry bhai, kashmiri muslims are already armed to the teeth. jeet Gaye to gazi, haar Gaye to jannat! win win situation hai...
@@brachisaurous So you are armed to the teeth: your biased reply is a "HIGHLIGHTED" Reply already?!!! NOW Tell me who has a better claim :"Chit bhi apni, patt bhi apni...". Agay nahi bolun to achha hai.
But lemme try once again to explain: See there can't be a smoke without fire. And given the context (Failure of Russian Invasion of Afghanistan, before that the Choice of the Kashmiri King to join India while Majority we're Muslims & the most UNFORTUNATE rise of the Unislamic Extremism in early 1980's and all of these must have caused the exodus is deplorable apart from being so unfortunate. Imagine how the state of India had neglected the just insecurities of Kashmiri Pandits & even after the exodus didn't look after them? And now how the General Kashmiri People are killed & harmed by the State Machinery as if the the Indian State is taking revenge from her own people? All those trouble makers: Yasin Malik and his ilks are either dead or soon will be.. But what about the Children whom we are making what we don't want.
I think we should look at the past to learn from there the mistakes; which we should never commit. I am for the rehabilitation of the New age Kashmiri generation & for that I don't have to be a politician.
@@silentlatif jao na kashmir mein, idhar kya Kar rahe ho. go and help the "misguided youth". I've lost 2 family members (armed forces) due to insurgency since the 90s. YOU MUST BE DREAMING IF YOU EXPECT MERCY FOR THESE ANIMALS FROM PEOPLE WHO ARE DIRECTLY AFFECTED.
easy to be idealistic from afar, or maybe your "bias" stems from something more fundamental ?
@@brachisaurousI am sorry for your loss but How many did your Dead Relatives kill (when the two of them were alive), and how many children did they blinded??? We always have had a super bandobast for your "Animals/I call simple civilians" since the time of the exodus. What stopped us from nipping Extremism bud in 1990? You are a FUNDAMENTALIST: who lives in a fools paradise that having the Official Gun, you can just go about doing anything, much like those who wanted to make Kashmir an Islamic State? Your approach to me is as bad as theirs. Why you have to be superior just because you are a Majoritarian mindset. Can't you coexist peacefully.
Pure shame... don't u feel ashamed of urself atleast somewhere or for sometime..& Yes no.of books doesn't matter!!! Traitor...
i will do my part and share this video . can he tell more ?
Why dont you go to court with your points?
Exodus?????
Genocide not exodus
Sir .. Please do same detailed video on 2002 Gujrat raite .. Vr more then 2000 minorities vr killed and nearly 2 lakhs left ther homes ..🙏🏻
Along with Godhra train burning where children and women were also burned alive by fanatics.
Sir , completely surprised by how you start and how you end this video. You summarize it really well by passing a message that Kashmiri pundits should not be expected to be flag bearers of either secularism or pluralism , all the time and we should give them some allowance for the price they have already paid for this . But Sir , you are the one who has let Kashmiri Pundits down by not walking the talk. With this video you have actually told us that things were much worse for much longer then it was depicted in the movie . With your words you have corroborated the movie. But in your acts you have grievously erred by not doing your bit for the cause. You wrote a script for a dud movie and chose to compromise a good chance , at the cost of being accepted in the vacuous company of people in Bollywood with no humanity . It seems this video is an attempt to reconcile your conscious to your suspension of a just cause . It is a pity that an erudite person like you , who is author of so many great books was compelled to make choices that you made while you chose to deride the first honest attempt by someone to highlight the plight of your community. But respected sir , better late than never . Good that you are fighting other inducements and enticements that are keeping you away from a just cause . May god give you the strength to stick to the just cause .
Excellent. You've put it so well!
You are most secular person as per liberal ppl but they never acknowledge your pain.. Myths are mostly spread by liberal secular of this country which you are exposing today..
I know if u support Kashmir file then so called intellectual kabal of India throw you out. You know in your heart that movie represent fects
Hindu have no caste in kashmir but muslim have
What a joke rahul ? .
not convinced
You were opposing Vivek agnihotri and this movie earlier...Rahul. Look at your earlier tweets.
You wrote nonsensical movie like Shikhara.
Now suddenly you want to ride the wave of Kashmir pandit sympathy.
Shame on you.
Vivek is more of a man than you even though he isn't a Kashmiri. You are just an opportunistic coward.
Aapko .itna kuch pata hai..par aapne kashmir par banayi movie mein Kashmiri pandits par kuch nahi dikhaya 👌👌
Kitab jo likhi thee
Sir, why use the "majority-minority" terminology? It is confusing and entirely unnecessary. Just use Muslim-Hindu. That would be more sincere and direct.
Audio-Visual media is the most strongest medium to portray the truth. Movies hence provide the best possible way to convey the message. Whether the director of the movie has other motives becomes irrelevant here till he portrays the truth. It is said that Justice can be delayed but never denied. Same goes for Truth. Conspirators may use every weapon in their arsenal to supress the truth, but slowly it emerges like a phoenix. Thanks to the movie, the common man of India is now coming to know of the pain the Kashmiri pandits had to go through, since centuries. More painful since Independence as Kashmir was supposed to be an integral part of India and the Indian establishment failed the Kashmiri Pandits big time. Kashmiri Pandits were treated as outsiders in their own country. Thankfully now people will realize the true colour of the Congress & Communists & its leaders since Independence. Communists in Bengal also have a bloody history of massacres. Its time a movie is made on that. Very few people in India may have heard a place called Marijhapi where the communists have blood on their hands. It time people know who the real enemy is !
Rahul aap bhi to selective truths bata rahe hain. Not one mention of kashmiri Muslim civilians being KILLED by terrorists and armed forces both! It's as if you're totally blind to their plight!!
A very partial and selective analysis
Absolutely honest 👌. You are right grief is something that needs time to heal. This is rightly presented as an emotion that is not easy to heal because it was a targetted massacre and uprooting over years. Amazing that reporters researchers teaching community politicians Center all fell prey to it knowingly or unknowingly brushing it aside as not worth an issue that affects the nation. India until now has not decided about Kashmir. We have now taken a stand that we will not let go the state and that is reflected in the form of the removal of the articles. The real Kashmiris are the ones who can rebuild it back to it. So reinvesting into it is an opportunity you must not miss.
Your careful usage of words is a remarkable job , done by a thorough professional. A Professional who will use the word exodus instead of genocide and so many more, throughout your monologue. What I am more interested in is would you rather name the genocide of Jews as final solution as well. Or the terrorist attack of 9/11 be re-termed as an airline accident. I think so you will not........my respected elder friend ( not really ) , first learn to call a spade a spade then try to dictate your openion to others.
Rahul Pandita supported fake narrative in Uselessj shikara
Rahul, you made shikara, which was completely a lie but with a poster that said unfold story of kashmiri pandits .
Then you challenged another filmmaker to make it, when he has made you are nitpicking inaccuracies in that.
Where were all these facts when you chose to whitewash terrorism in shkara.
He never made shikara....he's not a film director or producer...maybe he was used as an adviser and also the movie was roughly based off of his book " our moon has blood clot".
Also talking about the new movie
"kashmir files"
It has several plot holes along with subliminal propaganda. The movie is excellent and well acted but our emotional fool people have started promoting it by saying " you're anti national/ anti hindu if you don't see this movie" and rather than helping and sympathizing the victims they're calling out Muslims and blaming them ( if there was a movie named 'Gujrat files' trust me Muslims would do the same )
Also in a recent interview Mr. Vivek Agnihotri was asked will this money (pointing towards Kashmir files) be used for the betterment of the Kashmiri pandit and he replied with " Well atleast let us earn some money. The movie haven't earnt anything " ( we all know it's a 100Crore + movie )
Interesting that when talking about incidents of 1947 Kashmir, Rahul avoids talking about huge massacre of Muslims in neighbouring Jammu which happened weeks before the Pathan invasion he cites. Remember that it is all part of same state. Muslims who were 61% of Jammu population in 1941 was reduced to a minority after this. :
To quote a 10 August 1948 report published in The Times, London: “2,37,000 Muslims were systematically exterminated - unless they escaped to Pakistan along the border - by the forces of the Dogra State headed by the Maharaja in person and aided by Hindus and Sikhs. This happened in October 1947, five days before the Pathan invasion and nine days before the Maharaja’s accession to india.” As a result of the massacre/migration, Muslims who were a majority (61 per cent) in the Jammu region became a minority.
Oh great more what about'tism... Okay let's play this game, do you how many Kashmiri exoduses for KPs have been there throughout history? Seven! The earliest dates all the way back to the 1300s when Sikandar Shah forcefully converted and killed Hindus in the valley! Sorry but if you wanna compare numbers you'll still come up short
This happened because of the riots started by jinnah
@@krishnakumarshenoy4980 , No , Kashmir was a princely state ruled by hindu dogra kings where no provincial elections happened. He feared that muslim majority in his kingdom might force him to join Pakistan. So, he and the dogra tribes decided to take matters into their own hands to pre-emptively target muslims and he succeeded to change the demographics of jammu. Every other murders in erstwhile J&K state followed this event.
@@AlexRogers4U , This 7 number is just a curious figure thrown around to fit the 7 seas/ 7 heavens/7 wonders-of-world kind of wording to catch the fancy. Muslims in kashmir valley were hindus, but it is foolish to claim that they converted forcibly. Also, if you read ancient kashmir history , you will also find hindu kings like Harsha who was an expert in plundering temples and killing locals. Most of these are politically motivated.
@@anwarmi2000 have a read, if you can read remove your bias and read
Islamic Je haa dis everywhere few even in comments section crying for victim card.
Sad..
तू रहने दे तेरी रगों को पंडितों के ख़ून नही ,इसी लिए पंडित से पंडिता बन गया
Jab Mohabbat Na biki duniya mein, to humne Bazaaron ko Nafrat se garam kr diya.
Aur Jab hum masle na suljaa sake aawaam ki, to jhooti siyasat se nazron ko nam kr diya..
KASHMIRI panditone kya atyachar kiye bina musalmano ke sath sekado rakhana pasand kiya aur akhir me kya huwa ki pandito ko bhagwan pada
Hata rahul pandita kya gow ..apuz ma aas wanan,me seet kar che debate...