Nobody is discrediting or questioning the greatness of this legendary game, we are questioning the unethical and greedy practices of a triple A gaming studio
This. Every few years they'd try to upsell the game with new "dlc's". That translates to we added a new car but it looks like all the other cars and we hope you don't notice
What’s unethical about releasing their own game for 50 dollars? Nobody is forcing anyone to buy it. You could say greedy sure but they’re a company, the entire point is to make money. You saying unethical just sounds like entitlement, like “we’re owed this game at a lower price” when you are not
if the game had marked improvement like they did with the next gen machines and gta v i'd gladly pay for their effort. this however is just repackaged dogshit
@@average__height8033 while I get what you’re saying this is Rockstar’s thing now. They’ve reissued Bully, GTA 3, San Andreas 4 and now 5 three times itself and LA Noire. This isn’t a one off like you’re eluding too.
Ya know, I honestly wouldn’t consider it to be that bad of a deal if it was just $25 or $30. It would give more people an easier option if they wanna play it but don’t have access to an older console like the PS3. Ubisoft did something similar when they ported over some of their PS3 era games onto the PS4 like Far Cry 3, Blood Dragon, Assassins Creed 3 and Assassins Creed Rogue. But they only charged $15 for each of those games. $50 for a 13 year old game is outrageously expensive. Kinda interesting to think that Ubisoft is giving the consumer a better deal than Rockstar.
maybe I'm just being a cheapskate but even 25 or 30 bucks would still be a bit pricey I think if it was like 20 I would say fine maybe just maybe 15 but that seems like a low-ball so prolly 20 if PS3 vérsion of this game costs that then why can't the PS4 version be that price the PS4 version is nothing special despite maybe it having resulution changes and that's it
The full game on Xbox cost $40 so it’s only $10 off. Xbox did all the work around not rockstar. So it’s different here and PlayStation doesn’t have backwards compatibility like Xbox does. I’m kind of excited to see a video about how it runs on the switch. I might get it when it’s half off or if it’s $30 maybe.
@dmer-zy3rb What's even more sad is that the PS3 specs are a lot more powerful than that of the 360. Yet, developers like Bethesda and R* couldn't figure out how to work with it.
Don't tell Nintendo about yuzu... I'm sorry Nintendo your switch good but nothing can compare emulation is just sooo awesome you can change resolution etc etc
Thank you for acknowledging Maui, as someone that lives on Oahu we try our best to help those that had to flee the island. Great comparison video too, sad they didn’t remaster the game though
@@elperrodelautumo7511 I don’t wanna get political on a RUclips video but I agree that it’s bs, a lot of families are suffering and getting nothing, $700 per home owner is scraps. Also sad the person that was supposed to do the alarm didn’t wanna push the button because it’s “for tsunamis “ and when asked bro didn’t even regret his decision
Canadian here. It's priced at 69.99$ before taxes on the PS Store here in Canada. I almost fell off the toilet when I saw the price. I can quite literally get a brand new AAA title in Spider Man 2 or Assasins Creed: Mirage for 20$ more come October. Rockstar honestly gave us a basic port, not a remaster. Then they hoped we wouldn't notice and tried charging us a remaster price.
A true remake is the only way I could justify a price tag that's above the original old-gen versions. It's pure cope to say this is worth almost as much as a new 2020s game.
Thank you for the comparison Patrick. I see no reason to spend $50 when I’ve got the Game of the Year Edition on PS3 and still love to play it to this day. Keep up the great work man, take care!
@@greekanimefun long story short when I got my ps4 in 2015 I thought I had no more use for the ps3 and decided to sell it..just 2 days after selling I discovered a video game called red dead redemption and I was so enticed by it's gameplay and art direction I had to get it only to realize my ps3 was sold..8 years later ps4 port for rdr1 came out I was happy I bought the game and enjoying every minute of it because I never played it before. I do agree it's unfairly priced but since I never played the game before I am enjoying it.
see how u are getting scammed with consoles? barely to no backwards compatibility, forcing you to move onto nexgt consoles and sell your current one, then they release some 13 year old game thats ported not even remade or remastered, to force you to buy that shit. lol consoles are a big scam dude. pc ftw. backwards compatible and emulators.@@rxshovxx
I bought a brand new ps3 copy for $10 on eBay n had it shipped to me in like 2days… I’d never pay rockstar $50 for a game they failed to bring to modern consoles. Releasing it on ps4 just makes them look behind in technology
The fact they don't even released this game with 60fps support is mind boggling it's 13 year old game On the PC emulator the game runs just fine at 60fps and higher without any bugs and glitches The main menu and the UI also are also low resolution assets from original so it looks weird at 4k Lot of these stuff could have been fixed if they released a PC port , at least I can play this game on emulator
Go ahead and play it on PS3 then, and you’ll realize it’s not as good looking as you remember in 720p on a modern TV. Get a clue. Haters gonna hate. 💁♂️
@@flouserschird What's even funnier is the fact that it doesn't even render at 720p. It's actually 640p. The PS3 port was ass. The game performs and looks better on 360.
The ps3 version seems to have more darker shadows. Idk much about gaming graphics but a great example is when he leaves the train station to the salon the stations shadow looks more darker and dramatized
That's what I was thinking when I saw it. While it's probably more accurate lightning, it does remove a bit of that stylistic look from the original on the PS4 version. Also, and IDK if it's just me, but the color hue looks a bit different. The original PS3/360 version had that color hue reminiscent of those 60s Sergio Leone spaghetti westerns.
As someone who makes my own money, I'm probably gonna buy it. I know it's not really worth it but i really wanna play this game again and i don't have a ps3 or a PC.
The real problem is that people are still buying shark cards. GTA online and it’s micro transactions have done far more damage than a solid RDR1 port ever will. I’ll buy RDR1 10 times before I buy a shark card. I also find it funny you all bought the GTA trilogy when it was clearly broken, but your mad that PS4/PS5 players can finally play RDR1.
This is why people are impossible to satisfy these days. How many times did we all say we'd pay $60 just to have our old games back? Red dead, mw2, need for speed most wanted, the old gtas? Rockstar tried updating the old gtas before selling them and it was a shit storm, now they tried just giving us exactly what we remembered and yall cry about it. It's honestly pathetic watching everyone complain.
You're a fucking legend, THANKS!! Thing is, I have my PS3 still, with the game on it. And yesterday I was SO close to purchase it on my PS4. But I felt the price was hefty considering I have it available. So, NO PURCHASE!
same only reason i want to buy it again is because the fps on my ps3 is absolute garbage and it runs in 720p. like 24 fps (if even) and super choppy. it’s just not a good gameplay experience. still might wait for a sale tho
I'm gonna be honest on this one, this is only worth it if you find it on a deep discount (I.E. at least 75% off, which might be Black Friday). Otherwise, as much as I love this game, I have to pass on this because of how Rockstar has handled this along with the GTA Definitive Edition. I do like how you nailed Marston's outfit to the exact detail Pro. I remember having this on the 360 and having it come with the map which one of the best things about it.
If you got the series X and the original version of RDR, you’re fine. It’s upscaled beautifully. The only reason to get this is if you want it on the switch or never played it before.
Professional you're such a good dude about this stuff, I was introduced to you through Saints Row and it's good to see someone have that old school youtube honor
Who else here, on your very first playthrough of the game, sat through the entire carriage ride on missions where you have to sit shotgun despite having the option to skip to the destination so you don't accidentally skip potential lore in the game?
I recall I bought RDR for XBOX360 around 10 years ago, and it was 3 years after it was first released. It also came with the DLC, and for the whole package I paid 10 bucks on Cyber Monday. Rockstar just charged a premium port for the old gen console, that is simply unacceptable.
One thing I heard: The port works, but it's not really worth the 50 bucks. A bright idea is to buy a used copy like you said or wait for it to be on sale.
Hey guys I will have that GTA Online money guide up later tonight. I am sorry I am just so exhausted today. I am going to go to bed now its so late. Here is the Amazon link for Red Dead 1 for $17.92. I have seen alot of comments of people telling me I shouldn't be telling them what to do with their money. I am not. If you want to buy this PS4 port for $50 go ahead but I am just telling you I think its a waste of money in my opinion. www.amazon.com/Dead-Redemption-Game-Year-sony-playstation3/dp/B005N4HBIW/ref=sr_1_1?crid=FAY70XYEOHQH&keywords=red%2Bdead%2Bredemption%2Bps3&qid=1692358760&sprefix=red%2Bdead%2Bredemption%2Bps%2Caps%
The professional is right he isn't trying to put out that people shouldn't buy it hes explaining his side of it to everyone wether you chose to listen and understand what he's talking about or be like you shouldn't be telling people what to do with his money he is only expressing his opinions and thoughts on the matter what you choose to do after the video is up to you he just wanted to put his thoughts out there and someone responded with basically you can't talk him what to do and he's not doing that he's discussing wether the port is worth the 50 dollars or not
Man. What a joke modern triple A gaming has become. I remembered being so impresssed in the late 2000s and early 2010 by the amazing games we werr getting and was so hopefull at what the future would be like. Boy was i wrong and man were we spoiled too early. We are literally at the best console generation here and yet i see so much laziness with this generation of modern triple a Development. Im so disappointed 😥
I have the feeling that GTA 4 it's next in line on the port category (the Xbox 360 store it's closing next year, don't discard that the rdr port also go to Xbox one like some possible GTA 4 port), the price and the missed opportunity to do something better are the main issues.
Props mate. To you, Muta, Tez, Sonny, Ghille and a few others. It was so discouraging to see some fall by the wayside, prominent figures, and all because they got an early copy. Totally going back on their own words about this shameless crap from Rockstar. Honestly, Take Two could sell a port of GTA IV in much the same manner and charge 100 quid and people will still unfortunately flock to this. I do wonder how many casuals will just assume this a remaster when buying it too?
I completely agree with your assessment. Its fine, could have been better, could have been worse but 50 is a bit high for it especially without multiplayer. I will be waiting for a physical copy on sale (or second hand) as I think as I can play in on Xbox One X and is a great experience.
What I am curious about is the infamous Undead Nightmare Headless glitch that made the game almost unplayable. Seeing as this is just a port with the smallest possible changes I highly doubt it was fixed.
I keep hearing about this glitch, but never saw ANYTHING at all while playing through UM myself. I bought the physical version of it though...idk if that makes a difference.
Ah that brings back memories Iol. I used to play with cheats a lot and i can tell you it always happened to me one way or another without fail. Wont lie it was real funny at times, but annoying.
That only seem to be a problem on the 360 version. I don’t know if the PS4 version is just the PS3 version tho. I also don’t know if it’s on the Switch version, but I don’t seem to hear anyone talk about that problem.
Here's the thing...older gamers like you for example , they care about these things...Rockstar are happy as long as kids get their parents to pay for the games..it's an easy win for Cockstar even if we like it or not
i will always prefer the original artstyle that was intended by the devs when the game released originally... i hate if they tinker around with colour correction etc.
I already have the Xbox 360 version of Red Dead Redemption and it's backwards compatible on Xbox One and Xbox Series consoles and I bought the game for $10.00 CAD
It's crazy how a emulated version on PC, can run 60FPS and upscaled to 4k...Rockstar is just lazy...There is no excuse for this..People paying 50$ for a basic port are insane...
No it's definitely not worth 50 Bucks especially if the PS3 version of the game is way better than a PS4 version. Red dead redemption looks way brighter on the PS3.
Did you also tested Undead Nightmare? I heard some rumors that this PS4 version of Undead Nightmare would come with a game breaking glitch that make the zombies headless and because of that it would be impossible to kill them.
That’s been a glitch on the Xbox One version for years, it was also very rarely present on the old gen version. It isn’t really game breaking as restarting the game fixes it but it is super annoying. The heads just turn invisible, you can still shoot them in the head. If they didn’t bother fixing this however, the game is in no way worth 50$. As if it was anyway, given the incredible rarity of glitches on old gen copies.
It looks almost the same I have to say I like the colors in the PS3 version I noticed they're vibrant and stick out and the PS4 port has a grey ness to it.... If you don't understand what I'm talking about vibrant colors look at the lamps in the saloon and look at the car they take off the boat... The lighting and colors just pop ever so slightly more on the og definitely not worth it
2010 after beating Read Dead Redemption: "Oh wow what a great game I can't imagine what Rockstar will be capable of in 2023! 2023:..................................................................................................................................................................................
It was a masterpiece then, and is a masterpiece today. I mean, 50 bucks isn't really too much to ask for. My ps3 is really janky on if it wants to work or not so I'm so glad to get to play this again. I'm gonna wait for the physical though.
I agree that it’s still worth it. PS3 looks janky next to ps4. I don’t love the new version’s lighting or lack of multiplayer but tbh, the multiplayer on ps3 is kinda dead anyway and the lighting you won’t really notice unless it’s side by side. And the animations and reflections in the ps4 version look a lot smoother and the graphics look less plasticy. I still consider the new version as a worthwhile upgrade upgrade
"Strauss Zelnick wants you to find the difference between this picture and this picture." *shows PS3 and PS4 versions of RDR* Me, an intellectual: "They're the same picture."
I would probably buy it if it had a multiplayer mode. The color saturation has been corrected which is pretty nice. The texture buff isnt noticeable unless you have object that are far away. Btw does it have at least the Undead DLC?
The only difference is the shaders. The PS4 port shaders remove a few details. Rockstar never bothers to touch audio because when I played the Mobile port of the GTA games. They still have the same quality which it does annoys me because of the in-game voices still sounds like a game from the 90's
@@Puxi it's fake. These things has been going on for a few years and RUclips doesn't do a thing to get rid of it so a lot of RUclipsrs are aware of this and warn their viewers to avoid them.
Yes that would be cool I mean unlike some people I wouldn't expect it to look like GTA VI lol but like you say those kinds of upgrades and it being available on PS5/PS4 gen would be appreciated. Unfortunately they'd probably just port it like they did RDR with no real changes and possibly some music taken away..
Finally, Someone made a Honest Opinion about RDR's Lazy Port. Always love your Content, Pro, especially your opinions about these games. PS4 Must Be a Real Remaster with RDR2's Graphics, While the Switch is Understandably a Port Because The Switch has the same power as PS3/X360. Rockstar has Fallen from Grace since GTA Online's The Doomsday Heist Update, A Wise Character from GTA III Once Said: "I WANT COMPENSATION FROM THIS INSULT!!!"
Playing this game on ps3 on modern displays is a chore. 720p game output looks terrible on my 4k tv. 1080p is much more serviceable. No current version of this game beats playing this at 4k on series x (I'm sure ps5 is on par or slightly better tho) shame they couldn't at least make the game 60fps then I'd consider rebuying it. But my 360 copy I got for 10 bucks is the exact same lol
Lighting and slightly upgraded textures is the difference mostly. But when I did the part when John goes to Mexico with Irish the water was really shining. It definitely was a slightly better upgrade than the original.
And Zelnick said that at Take 2 they don't "just port their games", yet the PS3 game manages to look the same or WAY better than this "new" version on a "modern PlayStation" system
Im not sure if its just nostalgia or how the ps3 was built but the ps3 version just looks slightly better than the 4 port when it comes to shadows and textures imo so your actually paying for a slightly inferior version, great job rockstar you messed up again, thank you professional for showing this and calling rockstar out on their bs and laziness
I can’t wait to play Multiplayer with theprofessional Also hope he could help me get all the multiplayer trophies fingers crossed if he’s willing to do it for someone who started to play RDRO 4 months ago
Lmao look at your ass crying for a multiplayer in a single player game not everything has to be MULTIPLAYER if you want multi go buy ps3 or Xbox and shut up
Thank you for the comparison Professional. Surely PS4 not only lacks mutliplayer but that small detail which i saw when John was almost pulling out his gun, the wind blowing his hair which was in PS3 version. Even the lighting is faded in PS4
@@beanbean9469The colors pop up better but that can be quite solved by changing the brightness, contrast and saturation from settings. The colors on PS4 are the same as the Xbox versions. The anti-aliasing is better on PS4 due to the FSR2, which offers a bigger advantage in image clarity compared to the Xbox versions and PS3 - as result the foliage and the edges of objects are also smoother as opposed to the jagged edges on the PS3 and Xbox versions. Also the shadows have better resolution compared to the older versions which look pretty rough at a higher distance. It also looks better than PS3 in image clarity. The PS3 has slighty worse textures, no MSAA, low resolution and poor perfomance and anti-aliasing compared to the Xbox 360 version.
@@beanbean9469That's because the PS4 port is a conversion from the Xbox 360 version that also had thicker ambient fog that quite ruined the color grading.
My old landlord that im cool with has 2 copies of red dead redemption i was mad that i couldn't play it on the 4 im glad your doing this video i rather wait then to buy it for $50
I personally think the PS3 version looks better than the PS4 version. All I can see is that the PS4 version is slightly lighter, that's it! I definitely won't be buying it anytime soon, but I wonder who actually bought this game?
I think the ps3 one looks better just because it has much better looking shadows, as well as slightly higher contrast which makes the characters pop more
what people need to realize it, as much as it sucks for the older fans who were around when the game came out, this is probably targeted specifically for younger people who haven't lived the PS3 era and are like 15 - 16 years old and big fans of RDR2 and now they have a chance to experience RDR1, i know it sucks but this is rockstars plan seemingly and newer fans deserve this game. not everybody has a PS3.
@@uuserrrname "this game isnt on PC, it never was" you cant read my comment, Rockstar keeps making mistakes by not releasing it on PC in the first place and not fixing that with this port
Can you pin this comment?
NO AND HE NEVER WILL 😈
Hi
@@Louis_Guiabernnice
@@Louis_Guiabern Aaand he just did
@@Louis_Guiabernwell, you look silly
Rockstar made us an offer we COULD refuse.
Leave the red dead port, take the cannoli
If company made a bad service pirate them since they can make better product even gaben know this situation use a yuzu or xenia as way play in pc
Thats every offer.
One we had to refuse
What do you mean that's how much the game actually costs even when it came out the first time
Nobody is discrediting or questioning the greatness of this legendary game, we are questioning the unethical and greedy practices of a triple A gaming studio
EXACTLY!
My ps3 doesnt look like that.
Mines blurry even with a HDMI and a good tv.but mine aint the super slim editions so idk
This the studio that kept releasing GTA 5 for 15 years bruh what u expect 😂
This. Every few years they'd try to upsell the game with new "dlc's". That translates to we added a new car but it looks like all the other cars and we hope you don't notice
What’s unethical about releasing their own game for 50 dollars? Nobody is forcing anyone to buy it. You could say greedy sure but they’re a company, the entire point is to make money. You saying unethical just sounds like entitlement, like “we’re owed this game at a lower price” when you are not
It’s sad to see gaming go this way, wish companies would realize they can make good money from good games
It’s also because of inflation and ever thing getting more expensive to live
RDR is a good game
@@lucifer_69960shame they charge £30 more than they should to let people play it
@@lucifer_69960 the original gta 3d trilogy is good, that doesn't mean that the definitive edition is also good.
They are making money from good games 🤣
New era of gaming is here! We will be paying full price for old games to be able to play them every time we have a new platform.
if the game had marked improvement like they did with the next gen machines and gta v i'd gladly pay for their effort. this however is just repackaged dogshit
dude it’s one game
@@average__height8033 while I get what you’re saying this is Rockstar’s thing now. They’ve reissued Bully, GTA 3, San Andreas 4 and now 5 three times itself and LA Noire. This isn’t a one off like you’re eluding too.
@@TheCheesewalrus ok, but you don’t pay full price for any of those except GTA Vlol
@@average__height8033 yea because they know that absolutely nobody would pay $100 for this.
Ya know, I honestly wouldn’t consider it to be that bad of a deal if it was just $25 or $30. It would give more people an easier option if they wanna play it but don’t have access to an older console like the PS3. Ubisoft did something similar when they ported over some of their PS3 era games onto the PS4 like Far Cry 3, Blood Dragon, Assassins Creed 3 and Assassins Creed Rogue. But they only charged $15 for each of those games. $50 for a 13 year old game is outrageously expensive. Kinda interesting to think that Ubisoft is giving the consumer a better deal than Rockstar.
maybe I'm just being a cheapskate but even 25 or 30 bucks would still be a bit pricey I think if it was like 20 I would say fine maybe just maybe 15 but that seems like a low-ball so prolly 20 if PS3 vérsion of this game costs that then why can't the PS4 version be that price the PS4 version is nothing special despite maybe it having resulution changes and that's it
That's still bad
I’d pay $10 for it. I’ll wait till it’s on sale which I’m sure it will be for the holidays.
Ubisoft has a habit of selling unfinished games. Rockstar very much the opposite but yeah doesn’t excuse what they’ve done.
The full game on Xbox cost $40 so it’s only $10 off. Xbox did all the work around not rockstar.
So it’s different here and PlayStation doesn’t have backwards compatibility like Xbox does.
I’m kind of excited to see a video about how it runs on the switch.
I might get it when it’s half off or if it’s $30 maybe.
Besides the resolution and the aliasing, the PS3 looks better. Best example here 6:50
I was thinking the same thing, go R*, really go
Yeah, the PS4 version looks a lot flatter. Duller colors. The warmness is gone...like the lamp at 7:28.
@antiquecardboard just noticed that in the same scene even the dynamic lighting from the windows is gone as well
ps3 also (sadly) featured a bit less vegetation than the 360 version.
@dmer-zy3rb What's even more sad is that the PS3 specs are a lot more powerful than that of the 360. Yet, developers like Bethesda and R* couldn't figure out how to work with it.
The real crime is this not being released for PC, we all know damn well they weren't going to put in much work or destroy it trying to "improve" it.
They didn’t do it cause they are scared modders would do the work for em
@@NedFlanders1040 no because that like to released the PC version one year later
just play it on switch emulator, it's free, 60fps and 4k
Don't tell Nintendo about yuzu...
I'm sorry Nintendo your switch good but nothing can compare emulation is just sooo awesome you can change resolution etc etc
Play it on switch emulator yuzu
Thank you for acknowledging Maui, as someone that lives on Oahu we try our best to help those that had to flee the island. Great comparison video too, sad they didn’t remaster the game though
All the dollars are going to Ukraine instead of at home
@@elperrodelautumo7511 I don’t wanna get political on a RUclips video but I agree that it’s bs, a lot of families are suffering and getting nothing, $700 per home owner is scraps. Also sad the person that was supposed to do the alarm didn’t wanna push the button because it’s “for tsunamis “ and when asked bro didn’t even regret his decision
@elperrodelautumo7511 "all the dollars" is a gross overstatement.
@@LoCoAde87NPC
@@LoCoAde87how petty
It's so sad that the greed gets in the way of giving good service.
Canadian here. It's priced at 69.99$ before taxes on the PS Store here in Canada. I almost fell off the toilet when I saw the price. I can quite literally get a brand new AAA title in Spider Man 2 or Assasins Creed: Mirage for 20$ more come October. Rockstar honestly gave us a basic port, not a remaster. Then they hoped we wouldn't notice and tried charging us a remaster price.
It's so sad how rockstar has become like this
Not R*, it's Take2interactive.
@tk-media8829 definitely both. Sam Houser is complicit in the decision making.
@@tk-media8829Both are responsible.
@@tk-media8829 it's Rockstar and take two
@@tk-media8829Rockstar made the decision to release it like this so it's their fault too
I think there’s something magical about how you got dressed in the outlaw outfit for this, well done once again, professional
A true remake is the only way I could justify a price tag that's above the original old-gen versions. It's pure cope to say this is worth almost as much as a new 2020s game.
Thank you for the comparison Patrick. I see no reason to spend $50 when I’ve got the Game of the Year Edition on PS3 and still love to play it to this day. Keep up the great work man, take care!
ps3 got better shadows bro.
I sold my ps3 by accident and I saw this port as my only opportunity to play red dead 1
@@rxshovxx how can someone sell his ps3 by accident?
@@greekanimefun long story short when I got my ps4 in 2015 I thought I had no more use for the ps3 and decided to sell it..just 2 days after selling I discovered a video game called red dead redemption and I was so enticed by it's gameplay and art direction I had to get it only to realize my ps3 was sold..8 years later ps4 port for rdr1 came out I was happy I bought the game and enjoying every minute of it because I never played it before.
I do agree it's unfairly priced but since I never played the game before I am enjoying it.
see how u are getting scammed with consoles? barely to no backwards compatibility, forcing you to move onto nexgt consoles and sell your current one, then they release some 13 year old game thats ported not even remade or remastered, to force you to buy that shit. lol
consoles are a big scam dude. pc ftw. backwards compatible and emulators.@@rxshovxx
The PS4 version looks like it lost the PS3's heatwave effect, it reminds me of the GTA SA rereleases compared to the PS2 port
It’s still there
@@RonnieMcnuttGaming42Obasically what the guy above me said, it's still there yeah, but it's toned down a lot more
Ps2 wasn't a port, it was the original
I bought a brand new ps3 copy for $10 on eBay n had it shipped to me in like 2days… I’d never pay rockstar $50 for a game they failed to bring to modern consoles. Releasing it on ps4 just makes them look behind in technology
It makes them greedy
The fact they don't even released this game with 60fps support is mind boggling it's 13 year old game
On the PC emulator the game runs just fine at 60fps and higher without any bugs and glitches
The main menu and the UI also are also low resolution assets from original so it looks weird at 4k
Lot of these stuff could have been fixed if they released a PC port , at least I can play this game on emulator
Which gpu do you have bro? And how much ram
@@abhi.dx2345i have a 4070, and 32 gigs of 6000 ram. i get like 70ish fps up to 90 on 1440p using Xenia
@@yoda9256I was gonna say, 70fps on rdr1 with rpcs3 would require a supercomputer lol.
Try the switch emulator
You can run the game on a lower end pc pretty well
That is the most expensive reshade in gaming history lmao
*Complains rockstar is garbage
* Buys more of their stuff just to complain more
"I Criticize Rockstar when they do good and praise them when they do bad" - My man!
Only colors look muted in PS4 version and it seems they left HUD as it was no redraw or upscale. It seems emulation never been so tempting before.
The thing is, you can get rdr and a ps3 for about 60$.
*39.99$ with multiplayer and undead nightmare
Go ahead and play it on PS3 then, and you’ll realize it’s not as good looking as you remember in 720p on a modern TV. Get a clue. Haters gonna hate. 💁♂️
@@flouserschird What's even funnier is the fact that it doesn't even render at 720p. It's actually 640p. The PS3 port was ass. The game performs and looks better on 360.
It runs and looks like shit on the ps3. All you guys do is complain Take two is the problem here not rockstar
Thank God that I still play Red Dead Redemption on PS3 and XBOX 360. Thank God I'm not paying $50 for the PS4 port. Rockstar really disappointed us.
I honestly am glad there's no multi-player for this version. As a trophy hunter I despise multi-player trophies
The ps3 version seems to have more darker shadows. Idk much about gaming graphics but a great example is when he leaves the train station to the salon the stations shadow looks more darker and dramatized
probably because they improved the lighting and shadows, ps3 mostly runs in 640p compared to 1080p shadows
That's what I was thinking when I saw it. While it's probably more accurate lightning, it does remove a bit of that stylistic look from the original on the PS4 version. Also, and IDK if it's just me, but the color hue looks a bit different. The original PS3/360 version had that color hue reminiscent of those 60s Sergio Leone spaghetti westerns.
Thank your for bringing us these videos. We appreciate it.
As someone who makes my own money, I'm probably gonna buy it. I know it's not really worth it but i really wanna play this game again and i don't have a ps3 or a PC.
The real problem is that people are still buying shark cards. GTA online and it’s micro transactions have done far more damage than a solid RDR1 port ever will. I’ll buy RDR1 10 times before I buy a shark card. I also find it funny you all bought the GTA trilogy when it was clearly broken, but your mad that PS4/PS5 players can finally play RDR1.
This is why people are impossible to satisfy these days. How many times did we all say we'd pay $60 just to have our old games back? Red dead, mw2, need for speed most wanted, the old gtas? Rockstar tried updating the old gtas before selling them and it was a shit storm, now they tried just giving us exactly what we remembered and yall cry about it. It's honestly pathetic watching everyone complain.
Exactly
Humans☕
If they would have added multiplayer in there I think people would have thought about paying the $50!
Wait... Are you telling me there is no multiplayer on this?
You're a fucking legend, THANKS!! Thing is, I have my PS3 still, with the game on it. And yesterday I was SO close to purchase it on my PS4. But I felt the price was hefty considering I have it available. So, NO PURCHASE!
same only reason i want to buy it again is because the fps on my ps3 is absolute garbage and it runs in 720p. like 24 fps (if even) and super choppy. it’s just not a good gameplay experience. still might wait for a sale tho
I'm gonna be honest on this one, this is only worth it if you find it on a deep discount (I.E. at least 75% off, which might be Black Friday). Otherwise, as much as I love this game, I have to pass on this because of how Rockstar has handled this along with the GTA Definitive Edition. I do like how you nailed Marston's outfit to the exact detail Pro. I remember having this on the 360 and having it come with the map which one of the best things about it.
Oh you guys didn’t hear? Updated particle effects (the fucking dust) and extra sunrays are the very definition of a remaster
If you got the series X and the original version of RDR, you’re fine. It’s upscaled beautifully.
The only reason to get this is if you want it on the switch or never played it before.
Very well said, Rockstar could have atleast added new content. Seems not, so better to play the X360 version.
Professional you're such a good dude about this stuff, I was introduced to you through Saints Row and it's good to see someone have that old school youtube honor
15:45 "I criticize Rockstar when they do good and praise them when they do bad" You might wanna change that😂
Wrong timestamp
@@Stylebender1989 He edited it out
Who else here, on your very first playthrough of the game, sat through the entire carriage ride on missions where you have to sit shotgun despite having the option to skip to the destination so you don't accidentally skip potential lore in the game?
I recall I bought RDR for XBOX360 around 10 years ago, and it was 3 years after it was first released. It also came with the DLC, and for the whole package I paid 10 bucks on Cyber Monday. Rockstar just charged a premium port for the old gen console, that is simply unacceptable.
One thing I heard: The port works, but it's not really worth the 50 bucks. A bright idea is to buy a used copy like you said or wait for it to be on sale.
Hey guys I will have that GTA Online money guide up later tonight. I am sorry I am just so exhausted today. I am going to go to bed now its so late. Here is the Amazon link for Red Dead 1 for $17.92. I have seen alot of comments of people telling me I shouldn't be telling them what to do with their money. I am not. If you want to buy this PS4 port for $50 go ahead but I am just telling you I think its a waste of money in my opinion. www.amazon.com/Dead-Redemption-Game-Year-sony-playstation3/dp/B005N4HBIW/ref=sr_1_1?crid=FAY70XYEOHQH&keywords=red%2Bdead%2Bredemption%2Bps3&qid=1692358760&sprefix=red%2Bdead%2Bredemption%2Bps%2Caps%
I would be exhausted too if i had to make videos on r*'s dirty scams using their old games
@@MarcLeslie98fm only difference on ps5 would be loading bro its designed for ps4 so ps5 won't change no graphic
That is alright mate. You have a Goodnight rest homie ❤ 🐀
The professional is right he isn't trying to put out that people shouldn't buy it hes explaining his side of it to everyone wether you chose to listen and understand what he's talking about or be like you shouldn't be telling people what to do with his money he is only expressing his opinions and thoughts on the matter what you choose to do after the video is up to you he just wanted to put his thoughts out there and someone responded with basically you can't talk him what to do and he's not doing that he's discussing wether the port is worth the 50 dollars or not
Man. What a joke modern triple A gaming has become. I remembered being so impresssed in the late 2000s and early 2010 by the amazing games we werr getting and was so hopefull at what the future would be like.
Boy was i wrong and man were we spoiled too early.
We are literally at the best console generation here and yet i see so much laziness with this generation of modern triple a Development.
Im so disappointed 😥
I have the feeling that GTA 4 it's next in line on the port category (the Xbox 360 store it's closing next year, don't discard that the rdr port also go to Xbox one like some possible GTA 4 port), the price and the missed opportunity to do something better are the main issues.
Bought RDR2 for ps4 a couple days ago for 13 bucks and then just got RDR for ps3 today for 5 bucks and change! Thanks for the review!
Props mate. To you, Muta, Tez, Sonny, Ghille and a few others. It was so discouraging to see some fall by the wayside, prominent figures, and all because they got an early copy. Totally going back on their own words about this shameless crap from Rockstar.
Honestly, Take Two could sell a port of GTA IV in much the same manner and charge 100 quid and people will still unfortunately flock to this. I do wonder how many casuals will just assume this a remaster when buying it too?
Hello The Profesional. Can you do a lore video about Edgar Ross from Red Dead Redemption 2, and Red Dead Redemption 1.
I completely agree with your assessment. Its fine, could have been better, could have been worse but 50 is a bit high for it especially without multiplayer. I will be waiting for a physical copy on sale (or second hand) as I think as I can play in on Xbox One X and is a great experience.
The only difference is the port is a little more cleaner and not to laggy while playing
What I am curious about is the infamous Undead Nightmare Headless glitch that made the game almost unplayable. Seeing as this is just a port with the smallest possible changes I highly doubt it was fixed.
I keep hearing about this glitch, but never saw ANYTHING at all while playing through UM myself. I bought the physical version of it though...idk if that makes a difference.
Ah that brings back memories Iol. I used to play with cheats a lot and i can tell you it always happened to me one way or another without fail. Wont lie it was real funny at times, but annoying.
That only seem to be a problem on the 360 version. I don’t know if the PS4 version is just the PS3 version tho. I also don’t know if it’s on the Switch version, but I don’t seem to hear anyone talk about that problem.
Here's the thing...older gamers like you for example , they care about these things...Rockstar are happy as long as kids get their parents to pay for the games..it's an easy win for Cockstar even if we like it or not
i will always prefer the original artstyle that was intended by the devs when the game released originally... i hate if they tinker around with colour correction etc.
I already have the Xbox 360 version of Red Dead Redemption and it's backwards compatible on Xbox One and Xbox Series consoles and I bought the game for $10.00 CAD
I can't believe that there's actually people defending it being worth $50 and brushing it aside
It's crazy how a emulated version on PC, can run 60FPS and upscaled to 4k...Rockstar is just lazy...There is no excuse for this..People paying 50$ for a basic port are insane...
Yet you're playing it because it's for a walk through just ridiculous don't listen to a guy who plays dress up for his videos
No it's definitely not worth 50 Bucks especially if the PS3 version of the game is way better than a PS4 version. Red dead redemption looks way brighter on the PS3.
$50 bucks for a mere port is such a scam
Are you sure your yellow text at 15:45 is correct ?
Did you also tested Undead Nightmare? I heard some rumors that this PS4 version of Undead Nightmare would come with a game breaking glitch that make the zombies headless and because of that it would be impossible to kill them.
That’s been a glitch on the Xbox One version for years, it was also very rarely present on the old gen version.
It isn’t really game breaking as restarting the game fixes it but it is super annoying. The heads just turn invisible, you can still shoot them in the head.
If they didn’t bother fixing this however, the game is in no way worth 50$. As if it was anyway, given the incredible rarity of glitches on old gen copies.
@@coolkid9967 Rockstar logic: would a complementary can of baked beans smooth things over?
Thank you for bring up these quality of information.
It looks almost the same I have to say I like the colors in the PS3 version I noticed they're vibrant and stick out and the PS4 port has a grey ness to it.... If you don't understand what I'm talking about vibrant colors look at the lamps in the saloon and look at the car they take off the boat... The lighting and colors just pop ever so slightly more on the og definitely not worth it
2010 after beating Read Dead Redemption: "Oh wow what a great game I can't imagine what Rockstar will be capable of in 2023!
2023:..................................................................................................................................................................................
It was a masterpiece then, and is a masterpiece today. I mean, 50 bucks isn't really too much to ask for. My ps3 is really janky on if it wants to work or not so I'm so glad to get to play this again. I'm gonna wait for the physical though.
I agree that it’s still worth it. PS3 looks janky next to ps4. I don’t love the new version’s lighting or lack of multiplayer but tbh, the multiplayer on ps3 is kinda dead anyway and the lighting you won’t really notice unless it’s side by side. And the animations and reflections in the ps4 version look a lot smoother and the graphics look less plasticy. I still consider the new version as a worthwhile upgrade upgrade
"Strauss Zelnick wants you to find the difference between this picture and this picture."
*shows PS3 and PS4 versions of RDR*
Me, an intellectual: "They're the same picture."
In all honesty, the ps3 version looks slightly better.
I feel like since he made both screens smaller side by side, the difference in quality is less noticeable.
Nice to see Pro Stand his ground unlike those shills on twitter.
I would probably buy it if it had a multiplayer mode. The color saturation has been corrected which is pretty nice. The texture buff isnt noticeable unless you have object that are far away.
Btw does it have at least the Undead DLC?
It does
Yes it has undead nightmare and hardcore mode
Yessss!!! If u don't have a ps3 Xbox 360 or one this is worth it if ur a true rdr fan
Damn. I just bought the PS3 version on Amazon but it wasn’t from your link. I hope it still comes fresh and works.
It runs at a solid 30 on the port. On ps3 it feels super choppy at like 20-25 frames
Also only play in 720p…
@@flouserschird the ps3 version isn’t 720 it’s below that in the 600s
Yessir I’ve been waiting for this vid
The only difference is the shaders. The PS4 port shaders remove a few details. Rockstar never bothers to touch audio because when I played the Mobile port of the GTA games. They still have the same quality which it does annoys me because of the in-game voices still sounds like a game from the 90's
Bro did you also got a message from professional? He told me I won in some giveaway but never saw the prize. I unsubbed. He was so nice...
@@Puxi that is not me. That’s a scam . Report the comment it’s an imposter . What video did you see the comment on ?
@@Puxi it's fake. These things has been going on for a few years and RUclips doesn't do a thing to get rid of it so a lot of RUclipsrs are aware of this and warn their viewers to avoid them.
I would like to see a remaster of GTA 4. More dense population and traffic. Better vegetation and physics of water and such. Maybe a map expansion.
Yes that would be cool I mean unlike some people I wouldn't expect it to look like GTA VI lol but like you say those kinds of upgrades and it being available on PS5/PS4 gen would be appreciated. Unfortunately they'd probably just port it like they did RDR with no real changes and possibly some music taken away..
Finally, Someone made a Honest Opinion about RDR's Lazy Port. Always love your Content, Pro, especially your opinions about these games. PS4 Must Be a Real Remaster with RDR2's Graphics, While the Switch is Understandably a Port Because The Switch has the same power as PS3/X360. Rockstar has Fallen from Grace since GTA Online's The Doomsday Heist Update, A Wise Character from GTA III Once Said: "I WANT COMPENSATION FROM THIS INSULT!!!"
Playing this game on ps3 on modern displays is a chore. 720p game output looks terrible on my 4k tv. 1080p is much more serviceable. No current version of this game beats playing this at 4k on series x (I'm sure ps5 is on par or slightly better tho) shame they couldn't at least make the game 60fps then I'd consider rebuying it. But my 360 copy I got for 10 bucks is the exact same lol
Lighting and slightly upgraded textures is the difference mostly. But when I did the part when John goes to Mexico with Irish the water was really shining. It definitely was a slightly better upgrade than the original.
Why is "fundraiser" highlighted in titles but when you click on them theirs nothing?
Do you think they will ever add MP To the PS4 version?
Awesome cosplay pro you deliver as always man
Pro you didn't gotta spend your cash for us dude what you say is true
And Zelnick said that at Take 2 they don't "just port their games", yet the PS3 game manages to look the same or WAY better than this "new" version on a "modern PlayStation" system
Definitely doesn't + it runs way worse but still not worth more than 20$ especially with 30fps.
Im not sure if its just nostalgia or how the ps3 was built but the ps3 version just looks slightly better than the 4 port when it comes to shadows and textures imo so your actually paying for a slightly inferior version, great job rockstar you messed up again, thank you professional for showing this and calling rockstar out on their bs and laziness
Love your work man!
Yet Quake 2 has had more work done and is half the price
I can’t wait to play Multiplayer with theprofessional
Also hope he could help me get all the multiplayer trophies fingers crossed if he’s willing to do it for someone who started to play RDRO 4 months ago
The ps3 version actually looks better 😂
10:36 my reaction to this re-release
Are you kidding me. No multiplayer?
Thanks a lot T2/R*. Screw you Strauss.
Lmao look at your ass crying for a multiplayer in a single player game not everything has to be MULTIPLAYER if you want multi go buy ps3 or Xbox and shut up
Don't you people get it? Multiplayer is what made R* the shameless money grabbers they are today
@@Chris-nn3vu No, RDR1 multiplayer was actually good
@@luchi02luchi02 The only one I see crying here is you, go cope more elsewhere
Thank you for the comparison Professional. Surely PS4 not only lacks mutliplayer but that small detail which i saw when John was almost pulling out his gun, the wind blowing his hair which was in PS3 version. Even the lighting is faded in PS4
Apart from reduced shimmering from the anti aliasing there's not much difference. Certainly not a $33 difference anyway 😮
and the awful pop up from the first game?
Hopefully they will port in to ps5 if not a full blown remake like everyone wanted
The fact that people defend this shit is even more terrible.
You won't believe this Rockstar have bundled this game with Red Dead Redemption 2 and it's being sold for $100 on the PS Store and Xbox Store.
I can beat that
Get Red Dead Redemption for $7.50, Max Payne 3 for $5 right now on PSN
Feb 19, 2014
Rockstar never disappoints to disappoint us...
Rockstar games is literally Dutch from RDR 2 they used to be 1 of the best developers and now everyone lost faith in them
it's the same, and the PS3 version looks 10x better
yeah the saturation is weird on the port
@@beanbean9469The colors pop up better but that can be quite solved by changing the brightness, contrast and saturation from settings. The colors on PS4 are the same as the Xbox versions. The anti-aliasing is better on PS4 due to the FSR2, which offers a bigger advantage in image clarity compared to the Xbox versions and PS3 - as result the foliage and the edges of objects are also smoother as opposed to the jagged edges on the PS3 and Xbox versions. Also the shadows have better resolution compared to the older versions which look pretty rough at a higher distance. It also looks better than PS3 in image clarity. The PS3 has slighty worse textures, no MSAA, low resolution and poor perfomance and anti-aliasing compared to the Xbox 360 version.
@@beanbean9469That's because the PS4 port is a conversion from the Xbox 360 version that also had thicker ambient fog that quite ruined the color grading.
My old landlord that im cool with has 2 copies of red dead redemption i was mad that i couldn't play it on the 4 im glad your doing this video i rather wait then to buy it for $50
I personally think the PS3 version looks better than the PS4 version. All I can see is that the PS4 version is slightly lighter, that's it! I definitely won't be buying it anytime soon, but I wonder who actually bought this game?
I love how the PS3 game was actually brighter than the PS4 one 💀
I think the ps3 one looks better just because it has much better looking shadows, as well as slightly higher contrast which makes the characters pop more
what people need to realize it, as much as it sucks for the older fans who were around when the game came out, this is probably targeted specifically for younger people who haven't lived the PS3 era and are like 15 - 16 years old and big fans of RDR2 and now they have a chance to experience RDR1, i know it sucks but this is rockstars plan seemingly and newer fans deserve this game. not everybody has a PS3.
Majority of younger people have PCs too these days and they didn't think of that, and newer fans shouldn't pay full price for this game port
Nah if that was the cars they would of used AI to render the game in the Fortnite style like they did with GTA DE
They could emulate it on pc, it's the same gsme snyway, it's not like they changed something
Fail
@@uuserrrname "this game isnt on PC, it never was" you cant read my comment, Rockstar keeps making mistakes by not releasing it on PC in the first place and not fixing that with this port