Yep, back in 2011. But the screenwriter slacked off, Gibson lost his cool, and another controversy ensued. He moved on from the project because of it. But I e always wanted him to return to it. Maccabees done Braveheart style? Yes please!
@ Perhaps. I can't verify if what you say is true. Maybe we should wait for someone perfect to create the production...perhaps you or me? Let's get started. Hmmm....I don't have a clue how to go about it. You?
This is one of the most underserved pieces of Scripture. The Maccabees were amazing! Here @j bennett Really wish that Mel would go forward with that film.
Dave Erhardt - Having intricate knowledge of the bible is not requirement for entering Heaven. Furthermore, it is not a book of puzzles as some protestants think which has to be decoded by the Holy Spirit (different protestant sects seem to call on different Holy Spirits). The Catholic church has extracted the essential teachings of the bible and laid it out in a non puzzling manner in the "Catechism of the Catholic church" which has copious references to the bible for each entry. The Catechism is a far better tool to attain salvation through leading a sinless life as promulgated by the Catholic church.
@@sklenars Yes the catechism is very important. In my Bible studies we often use selections from the catechism that connect with our studies. I will never have an intricate knowledge of the Bible or the catechism, but I'm slowly learning both. I am not young, I'm 67 and retired. I go to Mass often during the week, I got to Bible studies, and learn about the Catholic church, the teachings, and it's history. That's all I can do. May God be with you.
@@daveerhardt1879 I wish you many blessings on your journey. Age - wise, I'm slightly ahead by some 4 years. Having been brought up as Catholic, but like so many others of my generation I was swept up with the attractions of the world and didn't give the teachings of the church much thought until my nomadic life came to an end and I had time to study what the church was all about. It is the one true, Catholic and Apostolic church of which I can truly say I am a devout part of. Prayer and especially the rosary are essentials for living the Catholic life.
@@sklenars Best of luck to you too. I am a convert, I converted in 1990. I didn't take and practice my Faith seriously until my wife died in 2010. I pray the Rosary and Divine Mercy chaplet daily. Thank you for the kind words.
@@daveerhardt1879 , I am greatly heartened by this discourse between you and sklenars...I returned to my Holy Roman Catholic faith two years ago AFTER 49 years of personal exile...I left at age 13 when they changed the altar and turned their backs on Christ, changed vestments to look like idiots and spoke English instead of Latin...I left because God was no longer in His House but demons...I returned when I discovered the TLM had quietly come back...as a result my 26 year old son was baptized in the original Roman Rite with three exorcisms and then confirmed last year by my great hero...Bishop Athanasius Schneider....miracles can and DO happen! God Bless you both heartily!
Thank you for this excellent synopsis of the Maccabee’s and also your encouragement for us as Catholics to be warriors to defend the faith that has been passed down by the Catholic Church.
I fell in live with this version of pange lingua when we where looking online for the other version we sing at church. Gregorian/templar chant gives me peace.
I'm so glad I found your channel. I've never heard of Macabee's until several months ago when I first heard you talking about it, and now it's my favorite book of the old testament.
Being raised as a Protestant, all your videos are so interesting... attending an episcopal church now... leaning towards Catholicism all the time. Just trying to get my husband on board
I'll pray for you! Come home, pray the Rosary faithfully and your husband will come around eventually with the help of the intercession of Our Lady. God bless!
I'm sorry but please seek out more. Follow a 1st century faith. Not a man made hypocritical faith. There are alot of beautiful people in catholicism but that walk is so far from the true walk. It's man made not God made. The Messianic movement is the walk of christ not catholic, Baptist and so on. Please please seek more first.
@@krislerch6262 Let me ask you something, why was this supposed "Messianic Movement" completely removed from the world until the last 80 years of so? If that's THE way to Christ, that means that for about 1880 years nobody knew Christ. It's a little silly, and maybe a little gnostic: you have the secrets revealed by God, not those gross Catholics who carried Western Civilization! I thought that God said the gates of Hell would never triumph over the Church, and if the Church ceased to exist from about the year 120 until recently Hell pretty much triumphed. When I was in 7th grade I read the whole Bible and got into Hebrew Roots, It's insane. It's not historic. It's all lies, those people are insane. Some of them even want to remove Paul from Scripture. Proud to be a convert to the Catholic Faith, the faith of the 1st century that remains unchanged in sacraments and faith.
Can't tell you how much I enjoy your bible teaching videos; very valuable and so effectively done. I enjoy your work on the crisis but those videos are lengthy and when unbalanced with spiritual food can become disheartening. I realize the truth can be painful, but this gives us the strength to endure it. Keep up the fight. Although no longer a priest, you certainly have a congregation that appreciates your efforts and many of whose souls have benefited.
Thanks so much. I learned a lot. I am especially being reminded that the Christian life is a struggle and ongoing battle for greater things, even if we may sometimes lose sight of this. Thank you!
I've been thinking about putting a bumper sticker on my car that says exactly this: "Be the Maccabee!" I"ll see if I can have some custom-made if no one else has done it yet.
I just wanted to let you know that I was extremely impressed with your book “Sword and Serpent,” and bought the first volume. I really appreciate the price. Great sample-sold me. Thanks.
@Anthony Louis I am very happy to hear that. I knew they were very close to the Catholic Church despite the split 1000 years ago. None of the Protestant Churches include these Books.
Trail Blazers I know. Fr. Carlos doesn’t know how to say it, neither does Fr. Wanjiru. Saints peter and Paul is my home parish, but I now go to the SSPX in San Antonio! We should talk some more!
As a Catholic Radical Vegan straight from Divine Doctrine Dogma Genesis Deutronomy &Leviticus and never look back simply living the reality in Joy by Grace.
Taylor Marshall is an incredible theologian when he just focuses on scripture and history and leaves the politics and conspiracy theories out of it. But that other stuff gets the views. I can't even watch a current Taylor Marshall video. But his old stuff👌
Watching this on the 2nd day of Hannukah 2020. Thank-you for pointing out how so much theology is set forth in 2 Maccabees regarding prayers for the dead, the intercession of the saints, and the resurrection of the dead. So much inspiration as well. We must always prepare for martyrdom.
I admired the Maccabees but my admiration will always be with the Creator who loves his chosen race. How he preserved Jerusalem to all kings and kingdoms. Divine power always there to protect his temple and his people. He is true to his promise. Glory to God in the Highest.
Viva Cristo Rey Hymn A rallying cry for war is heard on Earth And everywhere. The warriors are ready holding their swords And enlisting to fight. They were trained for this. They will defend the Truth, And the fire that burns in their blood Will not be extinguished. Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey. This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth. Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord. Our Captain and Champion. To fight for Him is a great honor. We know that this battle is not easy And many will cower, And under the bullets of our enemy They shall surely perish. I will raise my sword aloft highly As my Lord uses it. No one ever defeats Him. He has the force of God. Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey. This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth. Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord. Our Captain and Champion. To fight for Him is a great honor. We know no greater joy, No more honorable endeavor exists, Than to be on the front with my brothers, And deliver our lives together For the One who deserves glory, And has recruited us through love. Before Him all knees bend And all hearts bow. Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey. This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth. Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord. Our Captain and Champion. To fight for Him is a great honor.
Very informative. I attended Catholic School for 8 years and although they had religion class they never taught from the Bible. I still considered this extra Biblical as I am a Protestant but I do believe it broadens my studies of Christianity. Thank you and God bless
I always saw the way strategies in Braveheart to be directly from Maccabees. Not sure if that was how they were actually carried out or if that was Mel Gibson's addition?
Thanks to you Dr. Marshall, I now pay more attention to the readings of the Maccabees. THANK YOU for sharing this and God bless you and your family! I can now show my Protestant sister exactly WHERE it says in the OT why we pray for the dead. I can not, for the life of me, understand WHY ANYONE wouldn't want to pray for the souls in purgatory ESPECIALLY deceased members of their family??? Praying for the Holy Souls is part of my mission!
In Jewish tradition Judah was called Maccabee because it was the acronym of the his Hebrew battle cry מי כמוך באלים ה' = מכבי, "Who is like You among the heavenly powers?".
Dr.Taylor. Have you and Time discussed the prophesy of The Three Days of Darkness? I have recently come across the reference to Saint Padre Pio's letter to the church addressing what Jesus reportedly told him. Very curious. Dr. Phil
Im a Protestant and find this information most educational. God lead me to study Martin Luther. But these books seem so enlightening. The added books of your bible. .
Does the Jewish experience under Greek rule explain the exclusion of the Septuagint by the Jewish leaders? That they thought their was Greek Influence in the Septuagint and that is why they excluded those books?
Good morning my Catholic brother. yes you’re right we will have to make a stand like the Macabee did.. You see, before, our church had been a farm with the sheep of God and a lot of wolves would come and hurt us, would kill our priests, would martyr our brothers and sisters and we wouldn’t defend ourselves giving them the other cheek.. but now we are up against those who have apostizised; those who have infiltrated our church.. They have rejected God after knowing him! and they are choosing damnation.. this isn’t your ordinary clueless pagan.. no cardinal or pope can give us a doctrine contrary to the doctrine given by God to the children of God which has been perfectioned in two thousand years of Christian evolution with the assistance of the Holy Spirit without being an apostate.. make no mistake we will have to make a stand and soon.. however my fear is that we aren’t only against cardinals or even our pope but we’re against ma sons and they might be murderers.. so it really starts to look ugly and a difficult task
Thanks Dr. Marshall for such informed teachings. Now I am starting to read the first and second Maccabees in entirety. Edit: kindly advise the best Catholic Bible you would recommend to us.
I'm reading the Douay Reims Bible. Working my way through Maccabees (or rather Machabees, according to this version) and I'm up to chapter 4. All because of Dr Marshall's recommendation. It's quite an adventure already.
If more read and understood Maccabees (forced to eat forbidden food), the more we'd understand Right to Refuse "medicine" made with abortion. We would not have unethic vaccines.
MOST EXCELLENT WORK!! Dear Dr. Marshall, I ordered your book, "Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church" via a "MATERIALS SUGGESTION FOR PURCHASE FORM" from my local library; I suggest everyone do likewise, so that it is in their local library too, where it belongs! That said, I believe your attitude towards MACCABEE as being a role model for Christians to emulate is, without an appropriate compensatory explanation, irresponsible. Plus I have heard that the MACCABEEs are thought to be judaizing Nephilim in the same sense St. Paul referred to judaizers, usurpers of the proper priesthood, which should be chronicled, not hidden, so it really does belong in the canon, just properly noted. Request Clarification, we have room to reason, Thanks Dr. Marshall !!!
have a question for you. Do Jews at the time of Jesus name their children their own name. Like I'm a Jew and my name is Judah and I gave birth to a son. Is it in the tradition of the Jews to name the child my name Judah
Do you know if it is a sin not to tell someone if they are committing a sin? (If it is, does it include everyone, Non-Catholic, Catholic, non Christian) Thank you :)
The Maccabees has been one of my favorite Old Testament stories. The sacrifice of the mother and seven sons somewhat reminds me of the bakers and florists who are being taken to court becasue they refuse to make a same sex cakes or arrange flowers for same sex weddings.
Dear Dr. Marshall, the Jews do not consider Maccabee books as holy. Don't you think that the Jews should be able to decide their own canon? Just asking for a friend.
The Church didn't determine the canon for the Jews. The Church set the canon of Scripture for Christians and Christianity. The Church determined what books were acceptable to be read in Mass. This list of books became known as "the books", or "bible" in Greek.
@@bobinindiana Did you actually read what I wrote? And it doesn't matter what the Jews decide. They hold no authority from God. The Church holds authority from God.
@@petertalsness3238 that makes sense. My RCIA instructor said my Bible wasn’t the Catholic version - it’s a New Living Translation. Which is a good Catholic one?
{2:21} Propitius sit nobis Deus: non est nobis utile relinquere legem, et iustitias Dei: {2:21} May God be forgiving to us. It is not useful for us to abandon the law and the justices of God.
There wasn't a single normative version of Judaism until well into the Christian era, so there was no single normative canon. Then one sect emerged and dominated all the others, long after Christ's death, and they closed the canon and omitted books that were too Christian. I believe an important question for Protestants is, "Why do you insist on a version of the Bible that matches Jews' version? The Jews reject Christ!" Gary Michuta wrote a great book entitled, "Why Catholic Bibles are Bigger" and he goes through the entire history of the canon.
@@ellobo4211 I really don't know what the Jews look to today. I've been thinking about studying it though to understand better about the origins of the Mass. Catholics who convert from Judaism say that the Mass is very Jewish. One source I am going to look to is Roy Schoeman.
@@ellobo4211 I've watched part of a debate with him and Dr. E. Michael Jones (an incredible and knowledgeable Catholic) but not the whole thing. I need to watch it all. I don't know if Dr. Brown was a devout Jew or just cultural. Roy Schoeman admits to being cultural and agnostic before his conversion. Yes it's good to know the other side's point of view. I also follow David L. Gray. He made an excellent point in response to one of my comments on his channel. He said, "People have a greater appreciation for things they choose, than the things they are born into." Although as a cradle Catholic I refuse to give up my inheritance just because it was handed down poorly. I'm figuring out what I should have been taught long ago.
Why would you want to be like the people who murdered someone for a different religious view. Don’t know why I’m asking a catholic that though, you guys are very behind on the morality thing
"Maccabee" is a mistranslation. Juday's real title was simple "Yehuda haMatsbee", Judah the Leader. The Greek language did not have the 'ts' Tsaid sound, so they substituted a double kappa. There's no hammer involved. Goto to Thor is you want a hammer.
We defeat Satan and Demons by holding YOURSELF accountable as these are your lower selves . You have to know this was a scare tactic created by Roman Catholicism. The Greek god Pan . There’s your devil. Created just like Jesus was at the council of nicea 325 AD. Who is Serapis? 😂😂
We should petition Mel Gibson to return to his Maccabees film he was making.
He was making a Maccabees movie? That would be great
Tell me more.
Yep, back in 2011. But the screenwriter slacked off, Gibson lost his cool, and another controversy ensued. He moved on from the project because of it. But I e always wanted him to return to it. Maccabees done Braveheart style? Yes please!
@ Perhaps. I can't verify if what you say is true. Maybe we should wait for someone perfect to create the production...perhaps you or me? Let's get started. Hmmm....I don't have a clue how to go about it. You?
Maybe anti semites should stick to Jesus movies...
This is one of the most underserved pieces of Scripture. The Maccabees were amazing! Here @j bennett Really wish that Mel would go forward with that film.
Love these 10 minute Bible studies. Catholics should know the Bible better. Thanks Dr.Marshall!
Dave Erhardt - Having intricate knowledge of the bible is not requirement for entering Heaven. Furthermore, it is not a book of puzzles as some protestants think which has to be decoded by the Holy Spirit (different protestant sects seem to call on different Holy Spirits). The Catholic church has extracted the essential teachings of the bible and laid it out in a non puzzling manner in the "Catechism of the Catholic church" which has copious references to the bible for each entry.
The Catechism is a far better tool to attain salvation through leading a sinless life as promulgated by the Catholic church.
@@sklenars Yes the catechism is very important. In my Bible studies we often use selections from the catechism that connect with our studies. I will never have an intricate knowledge of the Bible or the catechism, but I'm slowly learning both. I am not young, I'm 67 and retired. I go to Mass often during the week, I got to Bible studies, and learn about the Catholic church, the teachings, and it's history. That's all I can do. May God be with you.
@@daveerhardt1879 I wish you many blessings on your journey. Age - wise, I'm slightly ahead by some 4 years. Having been brought up as Catholic, but like so many others of my generation I was swept up with the attractions of the world and didn't give the teachings of the church much thought until my nomadic life came to an end and I had time to study what the church was all about. It is the one true, Catholic and Apostolic church of which I can truly say I am a devout part of. Prayer and especially the rosary are essentials for living the Catholic life.
@@sklenars Best of luck to you too. I am a convert, I converted in 1990. I didn't take and practice my Faith seriously until my wife died in 2010. I pray the Rosary and Divine Mercy chaplet daily. Thank you for the kind words.
@@daveerhardt1879 , I am greatly heartened by this discourse between you and sklenars...I returned to my Holy Roman Catholic faith two years ago AFTER 49 years of personal exile...I left at age 13 when they changed the altar and turned their backs on Christ, changed vestments to look like idiots and spoke English instead of Latin...I left because God was no longer in His House but demons...I returned when I discovered the TLM had quietly come back...as a result my 26 year old son was baptized in the original Roman Rite with three exorcisms and then confirmed last year by my great hero...Bishop Athanasius Schneider....miracles can and DO happen! God Bless you both heartily!
Thank you for this excellent synopsis of the Maccabee’s and also your encouragement for us as Catholics to be warriors to defend the faith that has been passed down by the Catholic Church.
I love the Latin hymn at the beginning; it takes me back to being in the Church choir before the VII changes. Now that was prayful and awe-inspiring.
I fell in live with this version of pange lingua when we where looking online for the other version we sing at church. Gregorian/templar chant gives me peace.
I'm so glad I found your channel. I've never heard of Macabee's until several months ago when I first heard you talking about it, and now it's my favorite book of the old testament.
Being raised as a Protestant, all your videos are so interesting... attending an episcopal church now... leaning towards Catholicism all the time. Just trying to get my husband on board
I'll pray for you! Come home, pray the Rosary faithfully and your husband will come around eventually with the help of the intercession of Our Lady. God bless!
They will hate you for joining the Church He called *"My Church."*
Stick with the truth.
Don't go back to mystery Babylon.
I'm sorry but please seek out more. Follow a 1st century faith. Not a man made hypocritical faith. There are alot of beautiful people in catholicism but that walk is so far from the true walk. It's man made not God made. The Messianic movement is the walk of christ not catholic, Baptist and so on. Please please seek more first.
@@krislerch6262 Let me ask you something, why was this supposed "Messianic Movement" completely removed from the world until the last 80 years of so? If that's THE way to Christ, that means that for about 1880 years nobody knew Christ. It's a little silly, and maybe a little gnostic: you have the secrets revealed by God, not those gross Catholics who carried Western Civilization! I thought that God said the gates of Hell would never triumph over the Church, and if the Church ceased to exist from about the year 120 until recently Hell pretty much triumphed.
When I was in 7th grade I read the whole Bible and got into Hebrew Roots, It's insane. It's not historic. It's all lies, those people are insane. Some of them even want to remove Paul from Scripture.
Proud to be a convert to the Catholic Faith, the faith of the 1st century that remains unchanged in sacraments and faith.
Thanks Mr. Marshall ... I love you presentation. God bless
Can't tell you how much I enjoy your bible teaching videos; very valuable and so effectively done. I enjoy your work on the crisis but those videos are lengthy and when unbalanced with spiritual food can become disheartening. I realize the truth can be painful, but this gives us the strength to endure it. Keep up the fight. Although no longer a priest, you certainly have a congregation that appreciates your efforts and many of whose souls have benefited.
Be the Maccabee 🔨
Thank you god bless you for the beautiful synopsis
This knowledge is a blessing. Thank you Dr Marshall.
I'm definitely showing this to my brother knights. They would love this.
Thanks so much. I learned a lot. I am especially being reminded that the Christian life is a struggle and ongoing battle for greater things, even if we may sometimes lose sight of this. Thank you!
Thank you Dr Taylor Marshall. there is no doubt that you know Scriptures and how to present it clearly... God bless you... now I look for more...
Great breakdown. I’m about to start reading these books this week.
Great analogy! Look 👀 forward to seeing it.
I've been thinking about putting a bumper sticker on my car that says exactly this: "Be the Maccabee!" I"ll see if I can have some custom-made if no one else has done it yet.
Interesting. Thank you.
This video was really well done! Thanks very much and God Bless 🙏🏻✠
Thanks for a good presentation and summary of the Maccabees. I'm protestant so I haven't read these but I'm curious to learn more.
Thank you for posting!
Excellent job!! Thank you vey much, Dr. Marshall...
Every time i hear about the Maccabees it a mazes me how our Jew Brothers don't have the Maccabean books in the Torah yet they celebrate Hannukah..
Maybe some of Pharasees and Sadducess ashamed that their anscestors did not fight like Macabbee, so they want to hide the details.
The Torah is The first 5 Books of The Old testament not the whole old testament
People confuse Torah and TaNaKh alot
wonderful summary. great brother
THANK YOU.. DR MARSHAL
I just wanted to let you know that I was extremely impressed with your book “Sword and Serpent,” and bought the first volume. I really appreciate the price. Great sample-sold me. Thanks.
Great video 🫶 Thank you and God bless 😇
Going to be great! Glad I subscribe to you
Omg! This was beautifully done.
Thank you for this lecture. I downloaded a free sample of your book…thanks for the recommendation.
VERY Informative, as always Dr. Marshall! Thank you, and GOD bless!
Beautiful!
Thank you! Only we, Catholics, include the Books of the Maccabees in the Bible.
@Anthony Louis I am very happy to hear that. I knew they were very close to the Catholic Church despite the split 1000 years ago. None of the Protestant Churches include these Books.
Great teaching , thank you Mr Marshall.
Thank you so much, what a great resource!
This deserves to be a Film
thanks
Been rereading the Bible. Just reading 1 Maccabee this morning.
Dr. Marshall, you should come to New Braunfels Texas! It has many Catholic Churches, and deep Catholic history!!
Heck yeah! unfortunately there's no TLM here :(
Trail Blazers I know. Fr. Carlos doesn’t know how to say it, neither does Fr. Wanjiru. Saints peter and Paul is my home parish, but I now go to the SSPX in San Antonio! We should talk some more!
God Bless You.
I think it's meant to say, "BE the Maccabee." 😉
Most excellent!
Pray an act of perfect contrition everyday.
As a Catholic Radical Vegan straight from Divine Doctrine Dogma Genesis Deutronomy &Leviticus and never look back simply living the reality in Joy by Grace.
No Swine meat where Our Lord exorcise the Demons who beg to be allowed to fled to the Swine
Taylor Marshall is an incredible theologian when he just focuses on scripture and history and leaves the politics and conspiracy theories out of it. But that other stuff gets the views. I can't even watch a current Taylor Marshall video. But his old stuff👌
Love this Video thx Doc.
Watching this on the 2nd day of Hannukah 2020. Thank-you for pointing out how so much theology is set forth in 2 Maccabees regarding prayers for the dead, the intercession of the saints, and the resurrection of the dead. So much inspiration as well. We must always prepare for martyrdom.
I admired the Maccabees but my admiration will always be with the Creator who loves his chosen race. How he preserved Jerusalem to all kings and kingdoms. Divine power always there to protect his temple and his people. He is true to his promise. Glory to God in the Highest.
Nice Pange Lingua opening.
Thank you Mr. Marshall . So, Maccabees saved monoteismus.
I can't even find Maccabees in my Bible apps. That includes the Douey-Reims.
AMEN
Viva Cristo Rey Hymn
A rallying cry for war is heard on Earth
And everywhere.
The warriors are ready holding their swords
And enlisting to fight.
They were trained for this.
They will defend the Truth,
And the fire that burns in their blood
Will not be extinguished.
Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey.
This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth.
Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord.
Our Captain and Champion.
To fight for Him is a great honor.
We know that this battle is not easy
And many will cower,
And under the bullets of our enemy
They shall surely perish.
I will raise my sword aloft highly
As my Lord uses it.
No one ever defeats Him.
He has the force of God.
Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey.
This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth.
Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord.
Our Captain and Champion.
To fight for Him is a great honor.
We know no greater joy,
No more honorable endeavor exists,
Than to be on the front with my brothers,
And deliver our lives together
For the One who deserves glory,
And has recruited us through love.
Before Him all knees bend
And all hearts bow.
Viva Cristo Rey. Viva Cristo Rey.
This is the war’s rally cry that inflames the earth.
Viva Cristo Rey. Our sovereign Lord.
Our Captain and Champion.
To fight for Him is a great honor.
Very informative. I attended Catholic School for 8 years and although they had religion class they never taught from the Bible. I still considered this extra Biblical as I am a Protestant but I do believe it broadens my studies of Christianity. Thank you and God bless
I always saw the way strategies in Braveheart to be directly from Maccabees. Not sure if that was how they were actually carried out or if that was Mel Gibson's addition?
Thanks to you Dr. Marshall, I now pay more attention to the readings of the Maccabees. THANK YOU for sharing this and God bless you and your family! I can now show my Protestant sister exactly WHERE it says in the OT why we pray for the dead. I can not, for the life of me, understand WHY ANYONE wouldn't want to pray for the souls in purgatory ESPECIALLY deceased members of their family??? Praying for the Holy Souls is part of my mission!
dude, this is cool
In Jewish tradition Judah was called Maccabee because it was the acronym of the his Hebrew battle cry מי כמוך באלים ה' = מכבי, "Who is like You among the heavenly powers?".
Dr.Taylor. Have you and Time discussed the prophesy of The Three Days of Darkness? I have recently come across the reference to Saint Padre Pio's letter to the church addressing what Jesus reportedly told him. Very curious. Dr. Phil
Recognize and resist? Is it enough?
Im a Protestant and find this information most educational. God lead me to study Martin Luther. But these books seem so enlightening. The added books of your bible. .
Lol you prottie heretics removed these holy books from Sacred Scripture to fit your perverse doctrine
@@ryangianan1439 Well God the trinity loves us all.
I wonder what would be the comment on G. Brown putting down the hannukah candles lighten in the Polish Parliament …
Is the hannukah and Judaism still the same as during the Old Testament times?
Dr Marshall. Did RUclips delete your video discussing you confronting a NO priest? I was watching it and it just deleted.
Does the Jewish experience under Greek rule explain the exclusion of the Septuagint by the Jewish leaders? That they thought their was Greek
Influence in the Septuagint and that is why they excluded those books?
Good morning my Catholic brother. yes you’re right we will have to make a stand like the Macabee did.. You see, before, our church had been a farm with the sheep of God and a lot of wolves would come and hurt us, would kill our priests, would martyr our brothers and sisters and we wouldn’t defend ourselves giving them the other cheek.. but now we are up against those who have apostizised; those who have infiltrated our church.. They have rejected God after knowing him! and they are choosing damnation.. this isn’t your ordinary clueless pagan.. no cardinal or pope can give us a doctrine contrary to the doctrine given by God to the children of God which has been perfectioned in two thousand years of Christian evolution with the assistance of the Holy Spirit without being an apostate.. make no mistake we will have to make a stand and soon.. however my fear is that we aren’t only against cardinals or even our pope but we’re against ma sons and they might be murderers.. so it really starts to look ugly and a difficult task
T
Thanks Dr. Marshall for such informed teachings.
Now I am starting to read the first and second Maccabees in entirety.
Edit: kindly advise the best Catholic Bible you would recommend to us.
I'm reading the Douay Reims Bible. Working my way through Maccabees (or rather Machabees, according to this version) and I'm up to chapter 4. All because of Dr Marshall's recommendation. It's quite an adventure already.
My Bible has 3rd Maccabees.
If more read and understood Maccabees (forced to eat forbidden food), the more we'd understand Right to Refuse "medicine" made with abortion. We would not have unethic vaccines.
MOST EXCELLENT WORK!! Dear Dr. Marshall, I ordered your book, "Infiltration: The Plot to Destroy the Church" via a "MATERIALS SUGGESTION FOR PURCHASE FORM" from my local library; I suggest everyone do likewise, so that it is in their local library too, where it belongs! That said, I believe your attitude towards MACCABEE as being a role model for Christians to emulate is, without an appropriate compensatory explanation, irresponsible.
Plus I have heard that the MACCABEEs are thought to be judaizing Nephilim in the same sense St. Paul referred to judaizers, usurpers of the proper priesthood, which should be chronicled, not hidden, so it really does belong in the canon, just properly noted.
Request Clarification, we have room to reason, Thanks Dr. Marshall !!!
could, or should Catholics celebrate Chunuka?
Tell holy land I said " Hi" .
Why haven’t they made a film on Tobit?
have a question for you.
Do Jews at the time of Jesus name their children their own name.
Like I'm a Jew and my name is Judah and I gave birth to a son. Is it in the tradition of the Jews to name the child my name Judah
What's the chant's name at the beginning?
My maiden name is in Maccabees… Datema
Thank you but 6:46 you said "Maccabeean Greeks" but your slide says "Macedonian Greeks".
Great job though!
P.S.: "Time" was meant to be Tim. :)
Do you know if it is a sin not to tell someone if they are committing a sin? (If it is, does it include everyone, Non-Catholic, Catholic, non Christian)
Thank you :)
Did Jesus ever celebrate Hanukkah? Did he ever refer to the Maccabees in the New Testament? Did the Greeks invade Jerusalem?
@Caroline Schönheim I have to Ask, was the temple torn down by the Romans around 70AD?
6:50 "Maccabean Greeks"
Hey Dr, there is an error at 6:51. Maccabee greek or macedonian greek ;)
Moises etablished 6 feaat. There were 7 feast plua the weekly sabbath.
The Maccabees has been one of my favorite Old Testament stories. The sacrifice of the mother and seven sons somewhat reminds me of the bakers and florists who are being taken to court becasue they refuse to make a same sex cakes or arrange flowers for same sex weddings.
Why isnt it explained how they took their freedom back, to bloody?
6:50 you wright down Macedonian Greeks which is correct but you Miss say it as Maccabeen Greeks
Vodka: Probably just a slip of the tongue. :)
Dear Dr. Marshall, the Jews do not consider Maccabee books as holy. Don't you think that the Jews should be able to decide their own canon? Just asking for a friend.
@@AveChristusRex My question is about Jewish canon and not about Christian canon. Just asking for a friend.
@Erin Aboudara, yeah, Jews don't accept your canon, do they? Just asking for a friend. 🌏🌎🌍
The Church didn't determine the canon for the Jews. The Church set the canon of Scripture for Christians and Christianity. The Church determined what books were acceptable to be read in Mass. This list of books became known as "the books", or "bible" in Greek.
@@habituallinestepper9879 No, they RCC did not determine the canon for the Jews. The Jews determined their own canon.
@@bobinindiana Did you actually read what I wrote?
And it doesn't matter what the Jews decide. They hold no authority from God. The Church holds authority from God.
Hold on, so Troy and Sparta were Jewish settlements?
Is Taylor Marshall Catholic?? You bet your Maccabee!
I don’t see this in my Bible.... am I missing something?
You must have a protestant version then. You are missing 7 books.
@@petertalsness3238 that makes sense. My RCIA instructor said my Bible wasn’t the Catholic version - it’s a New Living Translation. Which is a good Catholic one?
@@katiejon17 The Douay Rheims Bible is still the most eloquent version. I would go with that version.
{2:21} Propitius sit nobis Deus: non est nobis utile relinquere legem, et iustitias Dei:
{2:21} May God be forgiving to us. It is not useful for us to abandon the law and the justices of God.
really macabbee fav book? Genesis and Job shows Yahwehs's majestic power
Why did Jews ommit these books ?
There wasn't a single normative version of Judaism until well into the Christian era, so there was no single normative canon. Then one sect emerged and dominated all the others, long after Christ's death, and they closed the canon and omitted books that were too Christian.
I believe an important question for Protestants is, "Why do you insist on a version of the Bible that matches Jews' version? The Jews reject Christ!"
Gary Michuta wrote a great book entitled, "Why Catholic Bibles are Bigger" and he goes through the entire history of the canon.
@@julieelizabeth4856 that's very true ..are there Jews today you think that hold to the Septuagint?
@@ellobo4211 I really don't know what the Jews look to today. I've been thinking about studying it though to understand better about the origins of the Mass. Catholics who convert from Judaism say that the Mass is very Jewish. One source I am going to look to is Roy Schoeman.
@@julieelizabeth4856 ruclips.net/video/w0IThMUEiO4/видео.html
@@ellobo4211 I've watched part of a debate with him and Dr. E. Michael Jones (an incredible and knowledgeable Catholic) but not the whole thing. I need to watch it all. I don't know if Dr. Brown was a devout Jew or just cultural. Roy Schoeman admits to being cultural and agnostic before his conversion. Yes it's good to know the other side's point of view. I also follow David L. Gray. He made an excellent point in response to one of my comments on his channel. He said, "People have a greater appreciation for things they choose, than the things they are born into." Although as a cradle Catholic I refuse to give up my inheritance just because it was handed down poorly. I'm figuring out what I should have been taught long ago.
Purgatory!!!!!
6:49 correctly: 'macedonian' (not 'maccabean').
St. Pedro Calungsod. ruclips.net/video/60NWUtKYrug/видео.html
Why would you want to be like the people who murdered someone for a different religious view. Don’t know why I’m asking a catholic that though, you guys are very behind on the morality thing
Come out of her.
"Maccabee" is a mistranslation. Juday's real title was simple "Yehuda haMatsbee", Judah the Leader. The Greek language did not have the 'ts' Tsaid sound, so they substituted a double kappa. There's no hammer involved. Goto to Thor is you want a hammer.
We defeat Satan and Demons by holding YOURSELF accountable as these are your lower selves . You have to know this was a scare tactic created by Roman Catholicism. The Greek god Pan . There’s your devil. Created just like Jesus was at the council of nicea 325 AD. Who is Serapis? 😂😂