Horowitz is amazing, but I like Gilels' interpretation more than Horowitz'. Gilels hits a soft spot in my heart when playing this, that I don't get from hearing Horowitz'. This is a true piece of art , and those 4 who dislikes don't know what they're disliking!
No, listen to Sofonitsky's scriabin, he was and is still unmatched. Gilels learned this piece by listening to him, by the way, Gilels considered him the greatest pianist in the world, which is true, listen to Sofronitsky's Schumann Etudes if you have any doubts.
Gilels affascina con questa splendida interpretazione! È proprio il caso di dire la grande musica Russa ai Russi... La profondità della Scuola Compositiva e di quella Interpretativa creano una incommensurabile armonia sonora che identifica come unico possibile modo di suonare Sriabin.... Genio Gilels, e regolatezza! Marco Rotondi
Благодарю вас за возможность просмотра этого контента! Эмиль Гилельс мой любимый исполнитель!! Высочайший уровень исполнительского мастерства ! Глубокое проникновение в замысел композитора, ясность образов, прекрасное владение инструментом!! Когда играет Гилельс, царит Музыка!! Он, как преданный её поклонник, служит ей , старая сам ь. стараясь сам оставаться в тени!!!
Indeed. He was a remarkable musician with only his contemporary, Richter, matching him. His subtlety and interpretation express so much. From the same recital the Bach B minor Prelude brings tearful ecstasy.
J'acquiesce tes propos godisdead92.Quel son, quelle conduite de phrasé, quelle énergie intérieure ! Tout est présent pour nous émouvoir au plus profond. Quel artiste !
Absolutely lovely. So poignant. I wish he had made more of the counter melody at :15 to :26. As marvelous as this interpretation is, Ashkenazy is even better!!!
It is amazing to see the already emotionally complex nature of this very early Scriabin's piece in contrast with, for example, the light (in the two senses) nature of most of Mendelssohn's early (and later) works. Everything is within classical music land. And Scriabin occupies an unique place on it.
je suis tellement heureux de lire de telles commentaire sur ce merveilleux musicien merci a vous tous car c'est vrais il a un son tellement profond et parlant qu'on dirait par moment qui parle vraiment ,tellemnt c'est expressive et emouvant
Nobody compares to Horovitz when it comes to this piece. Horowitz plays it like God. There was and will not be a better performance. Even the great Emil Gilels, despite the fact that he plays beautifully, was unable to come close to the perfection, which in the case of this etude is named after Horovitz.
Three thoughts: take them as you will, Gilels plays this beautifully. Scriabin said he was a mystic, did he forsee an early death So zoomed forward in maturity? Horowitz?!?!? What did he see, experience, feel? That is just another level. In the same composer?!
You're right, I've just checked. I don't know where I had read 14 or 15, but as you say, it's amazing for a 17 year old as well. In fact, it's a beautiful composition period - regardless of the composer's age.
I think you misunderstood my comment. This is why I put the word "simple" in quotation marks--precisely because it indeed is NOT simple. I found it one of the most challenging "simple" pieces ever.
Performed with great sensitivity. The music of Scriabin is truly romantic and sensitive and requires a very "feeling" performance.. I enjoy very much the minor keys that convey so much "feeling". Harry E W Smith, E.D., A.D.M. Dip Health Couns
Opus 2 is pretty early, this is an amazing piece for early Scriabin. I give the nod to Horowitz though, only because he brings out the other voices and plays a little bit slower.
it has the same meaning (origin text / score) but its a german word like "kindergarden / kindergarten". I was just curious about that because we have so many english words in our language like pullover and i dont no any german word for it =)
Gilels spielt wirklich was in den Noten steht. Bei etlichen anderen (ebenfalls grandiosen) Interpretationen nehmen sich die Pianisten ziemlichen Freiraum (z.b. Horowitz)
@leahgwilliams You can play it slower. But it has to be played by great artists. Gilels is,Horowitz is Or better said : Were With greetings to you Janvkimm.
@Bolkonskya I'm sorry now to wrote this about Horowitz, I don't feel always like this. He is really great pianist. But some part from him I like and another not. I can just listen to all of them great maestros.
Musica che già in qualche precedente tua vita hai udito, lontana. Non creata dal Compositore, ma nata dalla Primitiva natura delle cose, forse da Dio stesso...
Horowitz is amazing, but I like Gilels' interpretation more than Horowitz'. Gilels hits a soft spot in my heart when playing this, that I don't get from hearing Horowitz'. This is a true piece of art , and those 4 who dislikes don't know what they're disliking!
Did u provoke it to 16 dislikes?
@@advaithkaruna6199 "Will you please be quiet, please?" Don't be mad, it's the name of a story.
@@l.w.paradis2108 absurd
@@advaithkaruna6199 No, the story is very good.
No, listen to Sofonitsky's scriabin, he was and is still unmatched. Gilels learned this piece by listening to him, by the way, Gilels considered him the greatest pianist in the world, which is true, listen to Sofronitsky's Schumann Etudes if you have any doubts.
It's amazing how much one can learn from such a 'simple' piece of music. Takes me back.
Gilels affascina con questa splendida interpretazione!
È proprio il caso di dire la grande musica Russa ai Russi...
La profondità della Scuola Compositiva e di quella Interpretativa creano una incommensurabile armonia sonora che identifica come unico possibile modo di suonare Sriabin....
Genio Gilels, e regolatezza!
Marco Rotondi
Magnifique interprétation, beaucoup de sensibilité!
Благодарю вас за возможность просмотра этого контента! Эмиль Гилельс мой любимый исполнитель!! Высочайший уровень исполнительского мастерства ! Глубокое проникновение в замысел композитора, ясность образов, прекрасное владение инструментом!! Когда играет Гилельс, царит Музыка!! Он, как преданный её поклонник, служит ей , старая сам ь. стараясь сам оставаться в тени!!!
Emil Gilels.Great of greatest.
Wonderful performance of a beautiful piece - all the more amazing because Scriabin was 14 or 15 years old when he wrote it!
Horowitz incomparable in this. His sound is from another world, he tears out your heart. Gilels is very fine.
I cannot understand comparison of pianists of the highest level: everyone reveals something oersonal in his/her playing.
Thank you, Mr. Chaimovich. I am thrilled by your genius as well.
Una completa armonia col brano e semplicemente unica.Grazie.
Yes, the Lord! Wunderful, this sensuality in sound, this noblesse!!!
Gilels was someone who could make you realize how underutilized the piano has been even after listening to it for decades. He was a true artist. Rip.
Gilels is the best of all👍👍👍 There is no pianist like him I know...
Indeed. He was a remarkable musician with only his contemporary, Richter, matching him. His subtlety and interpretation express so much. From the same recital the Bach B minor Prelude brings tearful ecstasy.
J'acquiesce tes propos godisdead92.Quel son, quelle conduite de phrasé, quelle énergie intérieure ! Tout est présent pour nous émouvoir au plus profond. Quel artiste !
Gilels is a MASTER pianist! R.I.P to him!
Gilels and Scriabin, wonderful combination!
Such a beautiful interpretation. I cannot think of a better interpretation of this piece.
Gorgeous!
Absolutely lovely. So poignant. I wish he had made more of the counter melody at :15 to :26. As marvelous as this interpretation is, Ashkenazy is even better!!!
Grandissimo Gilels!
Superb.
Magnificent.
WOW! Amazing! I love Scriabin!!
It is amazing to see the already emotionally complex nature of this very early Scriabin's piece in contrast with, for example, the light (in the two senses) nature of most of Mendelssohn's early (and later) works.
Everything is within classical music land.
And Scriabin occupies an unique place on it.
amazing!! thanks for posting this video
Wow! I feel like i just struck a gold! Thanks for this, BIG TIME!
je suis tellement heureux de lire de telles commentaire sur ce merveilleux musicien merci a vous tous car c'est vrais il a un son tellement profond et parlant qu'on dirait par moment qui parle vraiment ,tellemnt c'est expressive et emouvant
...this is a stupefying and provocative reading of a masterpiece.
Actually Scriabin composed this while studying in the Moscow Conservatory at the age of 17.
Nobody compares to Horovitz when it comes to this piece. Horowitz plays it like God. There was and will not be a better performance. Even the great Emil Gilels, despite the fact that he plays beautifully, was unable to come close to the perfection, which in the case of this etude is named after Horovitz.
Three thoughts: take them as you will,
Gilels plays this beautifully.
Scriabin said he was a mystic, did he forsee an early death So zoomed forward in maturity?
Horowitz?!?!? What did he see, experience, feel? That is just another level. In the same composer?!
You're right, I've just checked. I don't know where I had read 14 or 15, but as you say, it's amazing for a 17 year old as well. In fact, it's a beautiful composition period - regardless of the composer's age.
Shura Cherkassky also played this piece as beautifully as Horowitz or Gilels.
piano345 Shura is amazing and not enough recognized I think!!
Sofronitsky tops the three of them.
Comme c'est beau !
Gilles is the Lord of music and there is no one besides him!
I agree with you. His playing style and ...... .I am crazy fun.
I think you misunderstood my comment. This is why I put the word "simple" in quotation marks--precisely because it indeed is NOT simple. I found it one of the most challenging "simple" pieces ever.
Lovely
Performed with great sensitivity. The music of Scriabin is truly romantic and sensitive and requires a very "feeling" performance.. I enjoy very much the minor keys that convey so much "feeling".
Harry E W Smith, E.D., A.D.M. Dip Health Couns
Lo mejor del mundo el piano!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
love scriabin's music
Bravo !
@Bret6464 right on! I've got a recording of richter playing 2/1 somewhere, will have to upload it sometime
So sad that Mr. Gilels died when he was 69. If god gave him 15 years more to live. I think he will be as good as Horowitz or even better!!!
Probably the most stupid remark I've ever read ... "as good as Horowitz". They were different personalities .. point.
pwvictor even better!!!!!!!!!!
perhaps in his earlier years, but I still think this interpretation is better than Horowitz's later performances. But I still think both are great.
He is very good! I can't even compare him with Horowiz, I like them both! He's not fast at all!
istreba penso anche io che sia stupendo
@36beachbum
it is gilels
史克里亞賓式的情感...
昇華了chopin豐富了自我~
i love it!
the sheet music kinda looks like tristesse by Chopin (structure wise)
Es una interpretación muy bonita. :)
Was playing this piece on my channel recently with a bit of composition. Let me know what you think. Thanks :)
Search Gourari Scriabin for a really inspired version of this. She is Amazing!
And Sviaoslav Richter too...
@iansquared3 dracula often attends these recitals to get music for his ipod
Opus 2 is pretty early, this is an amazing piece for early Scriabin. I give the nod to Horowitz though, only because he brings out the other voices and plays a little bit slower.
it has the same meaning (origin text / score) but its a german word like "kindergarden / kindergarten". I was just curious about that because we have so many english words in our language like pullover and i dont no any german word for it =)
Gilels spielt wirklich was in den Noten steht. Bei etlichen anderen (ebenfalls grandiosen) Interpretationen nehmen sich die Pianisten ziemlichen Freiraum (z.b. Horowitz)
@leahgwilliams
You can play it slower.
But it has to be played by great artists.
Gilels is,Horowitz is
Or better said : Were
With greetings to you
Janvkimm.
I have urtext infront of me here. It was published when he was 17 with other juvenilia but he was 14 when he actually first wrote it down...
Cette interpretation est bien superieure a Horowitz, Gilels etait le Dieu du piano!
Great playing! I just uploaded this piece too :)
Do you say "Urtext" also in england? =)
or are you a german living in gb?
@Bolkonskya I'm sorry now to wrote this about Horowitz, I don't feel always like this. He is really great pianist. But some part from him I like and another not. I can just listen to all of them great maestros.
@iansquared3 Its Chopin Reincarnated
Horowitz made the definitive recordings of these Scriabin Etudes.
As for Gilels, I think he plays too powerfully and without a sense of pathos.
Yes, no one compares to Horowitz!
My god, look at those massive hands! They match his head!
@Bret6464 Richter? :P
as far as I know, that is simply the english word for it. What does it literally mean in German? I'm semi-fluent but that's one word I don't know! =D
It is Dracula!
That's Count Dracula.
little idiot, you are dracula... !
im learning this now:P
but i sound like crap abhahaxx
Das Sweater? lol, no we have loooooooads of german words in English!!! Zeitgeist, Doppelganger, Rucksack to name a few...
Only Gilels could "compete" with Horowitz sounds. Well, also Shura Cherkassky.
Sofronitsky surpasses both of them. In Scriabin as well.
Try Horowitz
No way. Horovitz is unapproachable.
Agreed. Gilels very fine. But Horowitz in the stratosphere.
c'est bizarre ça ressemble un peu à du Michel Legrand, vous trouvez pas ?
brigitte, I think that michel got some inspiration and made it his own music....
@@nicolassimion6967 wow are you Sherlock Holmes?
He looks like he's about to fall off that seat.
Musica che già in qualche precedente tua vita hai udito, lontana.
Non creata dal Compositore, ma nata dalla Primitiva natura delle cose, forse da Dio stesso...
Preferisco Horowitz soprattutto per il tocco
più fluido , più morbido
più cantabile e più sensibile
alle armonie del brano.
la seule interprétation comparable à celles de horowitz...
horowitz is much better,he does the absolute scriabin with full of emotions
@elicandondo but I really don't like listen or look horowitz, I feel like no soul in his music,sorry I feel like that
Too fast((
Horowiz is better in this piece.
*****
not at all)
I like the way he plays but this interpretation is too fast....
Скрябин это композитор совсем не для Гилельса.