Would Bundesliga ABOLISHING 50+1 rule increase league competitiveness? | ESPN FC

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 ноя 2024
  • The ESPN FC crew examine Uli Hoeness's comments on the Bundesliga's current ownership rules and the pros and cons of abolishing the 50+1 rule to increase competitiveness within the league.
    ----
    Subscribe to ESPN UK: bit.ly/1oGUzVA
    Follow ESPN UK across multiple platforms:
    / espnuk
    / espnuk
    www.espn.co.uk/

Комментарии • 268

  • @johannesklement5873
    @johannesklement5873 2 года назад +37

    50+1 is a thing you can experience. There are clubs in the German third league that have more spectators than clubs in EPL or La Liga. Going to German football games is about celebrating football

    • @shashankn4895
      @shashankn4895 2 года назад

      out of curiosity which matches in 3rd division had more spectattors?

    • @johannesklement5873
      @johannesklement5873 2 года назад +9

      @@shashankn4895 In 20/21 third league for example: Kaiserslautern vs Dortmund 2: 48.416 or Kaiserslautern vs Saarbrücken: 46.895

    • @shashankn4895
      @shashankn4895 2 года назад

      @@johannesklement5873 ohok thanks mate.

    • @MrMurgen
      @MrMurgen Год назад

      @@johannesklement5873 This season propably Dynamo Dresden?

  • @domii1548
    @domii1548 2 года назад +34

    Scrapping 50+1 would probably lead to Bayern getting some massive investor =, making the league even less competitive.
    Not as if scrapping 50+1 means investors will all of a sudden become interested in Freiburg or Koln, Bundesliga needs to figure out how to increase the financial power of the other teams within the 50+1 framework. The move to distribute TV rights more evenly is a good start.
    scrapping 50+1 would do nothing for competitiveness, it would only make the fan experience less valuable, and at the moment that is the one thing the Bundesliga has that no other top 5 league does.

    • @StuTheDon17
      @StuTheDon17 2 года назад +12

      Or a huge investor could take over a club like Dortmund and make the league more competitive.

    • @kingmonde
      @kingmonde 2 года назад +12

      Could turn a team in a great city like Berlin into a powerful European force.

    • @Delboy0
      @Delboy0 2 года назад +15

      You clearly haven’t seen the how this worked for the Premier League or in Paris. If they scrapped this 50+ 1 rule Berlin and Hamburg would be the first teams to get international investment because they bigger cities Munich and when success comes they would have a big fan base in economically powerful regions that could surpass Bayern on the field and commercially. Man City, PSG and Chelsea are all in the top 6 most richest clubs in the world because they are successful teams economically powerful regions of London, Paris and Manchester where they can sell out stadiums, charge high prices and grow their fan bases in highly populated areas. Part of the problem with 50+1 is it locks teams in Germany into very amateurish fan ownership models so Bayern only have to compete against small city clubs like Dortmund or Leipzig so will never be at the level of Bayern economically and the big city clubs have bad fan fan ownership. 50+1 will lead to professional ownerships of the big city clubs that will be a real threat to Bayern

    • @slinslin83
      @slinslin83 2 года назад +1

      @@Delboy0 munich is a bigger money city than Berlin, Berlin isn't even in the top 3 in that regard

    • @russellward4624
      @russellward4624 2 года назад +1

      Bayern already have a huge investor. People need to stop pretending they're owned by the little guy.

  • @dominicblais2578
    @dominicblais2578 2 года назад +7

    I'd be surprised if very many people outside of Germany (or are German nationals in other countries) watch Bundesliga.

    • @Mazrati
      @Mazrati 2 года назад +3

      The Bundesliga is very popular here in the US but at the same majority of the US population is German descent.

    • @austriangroyper9308
      @austriangroyper9308 2 года назад +3

      @@Mazrati majority of US population is British descent, not German. But the Bundesliga is popular in the US because there have been some good American players that moved there.

    • @Mazrati
      @Mazrati 2 года назад +1

      @@austriangroyper9308 nope it’s German only 24 million people here are of English descent while German makes up 50 million.

    • @Ikhlashasib10
      @Ikhlashasib10 2 года назад +3

      tf are you talking bout loads of people watch bundesliga you living under a rock something

  • @lilbaz8073
    @lilbaz8073 2 года назад +18

    Forgot it also comes the year that the tv rights in bundesliga are going to be more evenly split. Making it more competitive. Stop pissing on our backs and telling us it's raining.

  • @dm9078
    @dm9078 2 года назад +17

    Leverkusen, Wolfsburg, Hoffenheneim all are not subject to 50+1 and for all intents and purposes RB have gutted 50+1. Over the last two years Jetta’s main investor has spent €250 million on players. Why haven’t they challenged Bayern?

    • @ganeshramchandran5553
      @ganeshramchandran5553 2 года назад +11

      It's still not enough to challenge Bayern. Can Leverksuen, Wolfsburg, Hoffenheim spend 70m on one player? Can Dortmund do that? Without financial competence, there is very little competition on the field. Look at the squad Bayern have and look at the others. Bayern face the same issue because they have a thin squad as compared to others in Europe.

    • @yashmufc
      @yashmufc 2 года назад

      @@ganeshramchandran5553 Perfectly summed up 😁👏

    • @patrickamponsah679
      @patrickamponsah679 2 года назад

      @@ganeshramchandran5553 Bayern don't have a thin squad as compared to others

    • @MrAlpaca19
      @MrAlpaca19 2 года назад

      It's not about challenging Bayern but about Bayern challenging the other European giants. Bayern is closer to Man City, Liverpool, Real Madrid than Wolfsburg, RB Leipzig are from them

    • @Minmataro718
      @Minmataro718 2 года назад

      Bayern can spend more.

  • @Delboy0
    @Delboy0 2 года назад +18

    If they scrapped this 50+ 1 rule Berlin and Hamburg would be the first teams to get international investment because they bigger cities Munich and when success comes they would have a big fan base in economically powerful regions that could surpass Bayern on the field and commercially. Man City, PSG and Chelsea are all in the top 6 most richest clubs in the world because they are successful teams economically powerful regions of London, Paris and Manchester where they can sell out stadiums, charge high prices and grow their fan bases in highly populated areas. Part of the problem with 50+1 is it locks teams in Germany into very amateurish fan ownership models so Bayern only have to compete against small city clubs like Dortmund or Leipzig so will never be at the level of Bayern economically and the big city clubs have bad fan fan ownership. 50+1 will lead to professional ownerships of the big city clubs that will be a real threat to Bayern.

    • @since-oj9ce
      @since-oj9ce 2 года назад +3

      Schalke would be a powerhouse again. Their fanbase is amazing.

    • @vatsalsingh1555
      @vatsalsingh1555 2 года назад +8

      Not totally, hamburg, frankfurt and munich, munich is a technology hub of gernmany not to mention manufacturing powerhouse and good economic hub, it will always attract good investment.

    • @aniket33591
      @aniket33591 2 года назад +1

      That's good, it will only inspire regional development.

    • @Richard-ib1ry
      @Richard-ib1ry 2 года назад +2

      Exactly..but berlin already invested 200 million and nothing happened to them?

    • @slinslin83
      @slinslin83 2 года назад +1

      absolute non-sense

  • @silverjackk
    @silverjackk 2 года назад +8

    But Frankfurt has won the Europa League this season, Bayern won the Champions League 2 years ago?

  • @mmehdi3437
    @mmehdi3437 2 года назад +10

    Well in the past years English teams have been buying more talents from Bundesliga than Bayern, if this trend continues we'll have to go to London to see best German players play each week. There is no way Bundesliga teams can compete with billionaire club owners who spend money for fun. Something has to change, maybe Germany can return the tax money from players contracts to the clubs, that way the club's spending power can become maybe twice as much

    • @MrAlpaca19
      @MrAlpaca19 2 года назад

      Oh yes, let's tax everyone and everything but not football clubs to avoid their pockets from running empty....

    • @mmehdi3437
      @mmehdi3437 2 года назад

      @@MrAlpaca19 Many countries give tax relief to sporting clubs, Germans have three choices, 1- Keep the 50+1 rule and become a second tier league that only germans watch on their weekend for fun, 2- Accept Arab sheikhs or Americans as their club owners and forget their club's cultures, or 3- Give their clubs some tax relief to help them compete with the rest of Europe. I think option 3 is the best one

    • @Inshallahsiuuuu
      @Inshallahsiuuuu Год назад

      @@mmehdi3437 most Germans will pick option 1

    • @mmehdi3437
      @mmehdi3437 Год назад

      @@Inshallahsiuuuu Well clearly, because that's what we are seeing today

    • @Inshallahsiuuuu
      @Inshallahsiuuuu Год назад

      @@mmehdi3437 I mean we have 4 teams from Germany in the round of 16 for the Champions League as well as Freiburg, Union, and Leverkusen all in Europa. Only the prem has more, so I dunno what you mean by 2nd tier league

  • @painlesszm1421
    @painlesszm1421 2 года назад +13

    How is RB Leipzig a 50+1 club?

    • @TheMaxeey
      @TheMaxeey 2 года назад

      they are not, that's why no-one likes them in Germany

    • @tststststs00999
      @tststststs00999 2 года назад +8

      The members are actually working in Red Bull 🤣

    • @Aanike09
      @Aanike09 2 года назад +7

      They have only 17 members on their board if I’m not wrong because they bought the club in the third division. For example if membership costs 100€ at Bayern. It costs 10k or smthg at RB Leipzig. Making it virtually impossible for anyone else to buy shares. Hope this helps

  • @harryrobertson9838
    @harryrobertson9838 2 года назад +2

    They are obsessed with us! Uniformed! Newcastle United fans was celebrating Mike Ashley leaving! I love how we are rattling the elite! Haha

  • @cryfier
    @cryfier 2 года назад +12

    As a German I hope 50plus1 gets scraped. Loved to see better players and games in the league!

    • @james_isaac
      @james_isaac 2 года назад +3

      I guess you are in the minority

    • @Delboy0
      @Delboy0 2 года назад

      @@james_isaac He knows the reality of 50+1 being German, English fans just like 50+1 because they just crave power and don’t think about reality of it.

    • @stffghh
      @stffghh 2 года назад

      You're ignorant then,you ain't no real football fan

    • @james_isaac
      @james_isaac 2 года назад

      @@Delboy0 oh i understand

    • @austriangroyper9308
      @austriangroyper9308 2 года назад +1

      Hope you like ticket prices going way up 🤡

  • @Intensive444
    @Intensive444 2 года назад +15

    Hoeneß lost his mind. If he were younger, he wouldnt have said that. No one knows how it will end up with those sold leagues and Bundesliga has overtaken Serie A with 50+1. Bayern, Dortmund, Leipzig can still win the CL with a good run. Those sold leagues ruined themselves for short-term success, but on long term, they will regret it. I wish Bundesliga will not make the same mistake and keep staying strong with that 50+1 rule.

    • @micahkiyimba8641
      @micahkiyimba8641 2 года назад +1

      Serie A has had 3 different champs in 3 yrs. tho

    • @noname-ot7vd
      @noname-ot7vd 2 года назад

      Bundesliga is still trash

    • @Ikhlashasib10
      @Ikhlashasib10 2 года назад +1

      @@micahkiyimba8641 but bundesliga clubs will beat serie A cubs

    • @AR-rg2en
      @AR-rg2en 2 года назад +1

      Serie A is a lot better than Bundesliga.

    • @Ikhlashasib10
      @Ikhlashasib10 2 года назад +1

      @@AR-rg2en But bundesliga teams will beat them on head to head even Bayern alone will destory all serie A clubs

  • @4thGenna.
    @4thGenna. 2 года назад +18

    Bundesliga will be interesting for me this season and overall. Lots of teams I'm interested in watching because so many talent.
    Borussia Mochengladbach is a must watch for me. So is Bayer Leverkusen, RBL, Frankfurt and of course, Dortmund. They are loaded with talent it's incredible. JBGittens for Dortmund is a must watch for me and so many more. Watch out for that baller name Adeyemi

    • @realeroma3852
      @realeroma3852 2 года назад +3

      Good to know Arsenal fans are branching out after watching their team get thrashed 4-0 every other week

    • @philmitchell91
      @philmitchell91 2 года назад +2

      Keep telling yourself that, Bayern are going to win the league again lol.

    • @gabrielguerrero7189
      @gabrielguerrero7189 2 года назад +1

      @Iago it means nothing to you , it is still a European trophy, it will give Roma a confidence boost

    • @4thGenna.
      @4thGenna. 2 года назад +2

      @@realeroma3852 why are you mad that u can't contribute to the subject

    • @4thGenna.
      @4thGenna. 2 года назад

      @@philmitchell91 i did not said otherwise. Your point?

  • @양태성-p7i
    @양태성-p7i 2 года назад +33

    It's a lose lose, keep 50+1 they stay a "farmers" league, remove 50+1 then they become like every other league where fans "have no" say

    • @jeeonlyaccount2401
      @jeeonlyaccount2401 2 года назад +7

      I thought soccer is a business,glad to know in some part its still a game

    • @SunmasterThirteen
      @SunmasterThirteen 2 года назад +1

      @@jeeonlyaccount2401 Yeah, a game where only one team wins

    • @vvmmuu
      @vvmmuu 2 года назад +4

      @@SunmasterThirteen Yeah gotta agree Sunny, that Spanish league is rubbish...oh you weren't talking about them, were you talking about the French league? Sorry!

    • @SunmasterThirteen
      @SunmasterThirteen 2 года назад +2

      @@vvmmuu No, I wasn't talking about the La Liga or Ligue 1. Lille won the title in 2021, and so did Athletico Madrid.

    • @vvmmuu
      @vvmmuu 2 года назад +1

      @@SunmasterThirteen Oh SORRY I thought you were as in the last 18 years only twice has either Barcelona or Real Madrid not won the title, and in France in the last ten years PSG has won 8 since being taken over by Qatar. Again my bad as you're so smart with stats!

  • @jamapaza
    @jamapaza 2 года назад +1

    Without the 50+1 rule there would be only two leagues, the PL and the BL. Spain, Italy and France would die! The PL and the BL would buy all good players.

  • @tonyleukering8832
    @tonyleukering8832 2 года назад

    Love the tie, Stevie!

  • @Raptorman0909
    @Raptorman0909 2 года назад +3

    The Premiere League has its problems to and that problem is only getting worse. City won 2 of 5 titles from 2011/2012 to 2016/2017 or a third of the titles, but from 2017/2018 to the present, 5 seasons, City won 4 of 5. They now have Haaland. They may need to institute something similar to the NFL draft rule. Part of the reason you don't see such rules is because the English want to have the best team in the world and unlimited money fuels that hope! It also fuels the disparity that has produced an EPL that is in reality two leagues: a league at the top consisting of just 2 teams; and then everyone else!

  • @BlackRose-vi2yg
    @BlackRose-vi2yg 2 года назад +6

    If it wants to be more competitive in the modern era it has to get rid of that rule for sure. Clearly 50+1 is not working

  • @Rrrandstaysuh
    @Rrrandstaysuh 2 года назад +1

    Why do you guys keep asking a Ex Dortmund and Ex Frankfurt player about Bayern??
    This Jan guys know nothing about Bayern ffs stop it ESPN

  • @thelwulf5501
    @thelwulf5501 Год назад +1

    France and Germany are two Nations that produce excellent football players yet their leagues are boring. Something has to give.

  • @Minmataro718
    @Minmataro718 2 года назад +1

    One thing i truly dislike about football. Every league is dominated by one or two teams. Even with relegation and promotion from the lower leagues certain teams have a clear advantage with funds. How is it ok as a football supporter to know that your team will never compete with clubs like that within the same league because of the amount of money they're allowed to use on players? Why can't it be regulated globally by FIFA? Are they afraid if they cap spending euro clubs wont have the pull to romance south American players to those big leagues? idk why its like this and why everyone is ok with it.

    • @MrMurgen
      @MrMurgen Год назад

      How is it ok as a football supporter to know that your team will never compete with clubs like that ?
      Because fans are supporting there club no matter what.
      It is not about winning it all. It does not matter to win all the time.
      It is about celebrating football, the club, the city or the region the club belongs to.
      That said. Yes i would support a financiall fairplay system. If globally would be managabel ? I do not think so. Its allready hard to have it in one country not speaking about regions or world.

  • @dorkknight8846
    @dorkknight8846 2 года назад +1

    when Jurgen Norbert Klopp leaves Liverpool , I'd like him to go and win the league for Napoli but I'd love him to go back to Dortmund and stop that Bayern Monopoly

    • @myownlilbubble
      @myownlilbubble 2 года назад

      He signed an extension till 2027.
      I think he would either go to Basel or try a smaller laliga club like Villareal. Villareal is a small town like club. Suits his style. For Basel, he did said that if he did not win anything in Liverpool within the 3 years as promised, he would end up in Switzerland.

  • @jonpool9030
    @jonpool9030 2 года назад +7

    Funny how PSG's dominance in ligue 1 is derided and I'd used to explain why they won't win the CL but it's never used against Bayern

    • @russellward4624
      @russellward4624 2 года назад +3

      Because they're snobs. They think certain clubs have a devine right to success and others don't.

    • @azizb5625
      @azizb5625 2 года назад

      maybe because bayern won 6 champions leagues while playing 11 finals, while qatar saint germain won 0 CL? gotta think before saying dumbshit

    • @alexandruciripan2781
      @alexandruciripan2781 2 года назад +4

      Because one has played 11 finals and won it 6 times, how many does PSG have?

    • @jonpool9030
      @jonpool9030 2 года назад +1

      @@alexandruciripan2781 that makes no sense. When Bayern won and played those finals they weren't winning the Bundesliga every season. Plus Bayern twice as old as PSG is so they had a significant head start.

    • @alexandruciripan2781
      @alexandruciripan2781 2 года назад +1

      @@jonpool9030 It is the truth, PSG success will always be determined by CL.Also Bayern has 6 won and another 5 finals played that they lost, so the CL is not a hurry but when you spend more than 1 bilion € in tranfers you are expected to fucking win it

  • @JAPARICAN50-50
    @JAPARICAN50-50 2 года назад +1

    Good we need some arsenals and Man Uniteds in there

  • @marianchicago4002
    @marianchicago4002 2 года назад +6

    Bayern Munich won’t be winning bundesliga every year once Lewandowski leaves, his amount of goals made the league lopsided. Don’t get me wrong, Bayern Munich will still win plenty of future titles, just not every year like now.

    • @leanhoven
      @leanhoven 2 года назад +2

      It has never been close

    • @vatsalsingh1555
      @vatsalsingh1555 2 года назад +5

      You are talking like lewandowski was messi of this team who used create and finish, he needed thomas muller and other forwards to score goals, they have sadio mane and few other players, it will be close title racwe but bayern will still start as a favorites.

  • @riyangin2868
    @riyangin2868 2 года назад +12

    Just erase the league and give the trophy every year to Bayern lol

  • @franklerch1012
    @franklerch1012 2 года назад +1

    ucl champions 2 years ago, European cup champions this year… what is uli on about?

  • @SavageIntent
    @SavageIntent 2 года назад +4

    I am proud of the 50+1 rule. Germany has some of the best atmospheres and fan cultures in Europe, Always packed games, always affordable, the beer is affordable. and German teams have won the Champions League and the Europa League more recently than French or Italian clubs, so I'm unsure why people are saying German clubs cannot win in Europe.
    I personally would hate if my team was bought by some war criminal while the fans lose their say in the club... I'm proud of our teams winning in Europe DESPITE the 50+1 rule. But also they should into breaking Bayern's iron grip on the league, which as is mentioned in the video wont be guaranteed if the rule is abolished, as then Bayern will have even more money.

  • @KarpeDM1860
    @KarpeDM1860 2 года назад +8

    You know I have heard a lot from English fans about how they wish they had the 50+1 rule so they could save clubs like bury fc or derby county or whatever. A bunch of clubs in England have been bought by billionaires so only a handful of clubs can actually win the league. I’d rather watch bundesliga over English premiere league or la liga any day.

    • @Delboy0
      @Delboy0 2 года назад +1

      English fans just like the idea of having more power and know nothing about the reality. Just look at Hamburg that should be the second biggest team in Germany if not bigger than Bayern but because they are run by clueless fans, they are in second division. Being passionate about something doesn’t mean you have the skills to run a football team correctly. Part of the problem is Bayern is the only German team run like a Premier League team and the rest of German football is very amateurish due to 50 +1 that is why Bayern have won 10 titles in 10 years, so you comment that 50+1 has made Bundesliga more competitive than Premier League is quite frankly ridiculous given the Premier League has had 5 different teams win the Premier League in 10 years. And if you were to ask English fans if they would want 50+1 rule if that meant only 1 team would win the league for the next 20 years and 100% would all say no, because it is the competitiveness of English football that makes English fans love the game, where any team can beat any team. Big investors has made Premier League teams more professionally run not just in the Premier League but in the 4 divisions and this is leading to England producing better players for the national team, where national teams like Germany and Portugal are stealiNg English developed talent.

    • @KarpeDM1860
      @KarpeDM1860 2 года назад +3

      @@Delboy0 the fans don’t run the day to day operations in Germany, it’s still the managers, presidents and so on. The only thing the fans really have a say in are ticket prices and concessions and such. The reason why Bayern have been so successful is for years they just buy the best players from the bundesliga whenever they lose the title. Case in point lewandowski was bought by Bayern after Dortmund had two straight titles. The reason why Hamburg went down to the second league is bc of mismanagement by the office, not the fans. And as for the premiere ship being better talent wise? Yea that’s true but when every other team is owned by an American billionaire, or a Saudi prince, or a Russian oligarch (granted he lost the club) or a Chinese corporation, yea you’re gonna get bigger names when the owners can shell out 100 million pounds or euros or whatever. It’s the same in every sport. Sure Bayern have won 10 league titles in a row but they haven’t won 10 cups in a row. That competition is very competitive. just bc a club like Hamburg is “big” doesn’t guarantee results. They have a youth movement going on now and they’ll be back up next year.

    • @yourdailyjoe3155
      @yourdailyjoe3155 2 года назад

      @@KarpeDM1860 What are people going to mainly focus on? League or cups. You said only a handful of clubs can win the premier league. Only a single club can win the bundesliga so why would you rather watch that than either la liga or premier league. The logic isn't making sense.

    • @emmanuel96604
      @emmanuel96604 2 года назад +2

      @@Delboy0 You clearly don't watch germany. Most of Germany's players play in Germany

  • @aniket33591
    @aniket33591 2 года назад +2

    50+1 doesn't need to go, it needs to be tweaked. Instead of applying on investment, 50+1 should be applied to board room representation of clubs as in 51% board members from fan associations of the particular club. That way clubs will be able to spend any amount of money, their investors are willing to and still remain fan owned.

    • @The_Real_Kal-El
      @The_Real_Kal-El 2 года назад

      lol why would any billionaire want fans to control their money.

    • @aniket33591
      @aniket33591 2 года назад

      @@The_Real_Kal-El You probably don't know that 50+1 makes bundesliga clubs majority fan owned. And if so there should be no hesitance in extending that ownership literally.

  • @MrMurgen
    @MrMurgen Год назад

    the other way around is the way to go.
    Do not tell me that Football Fans in UK or Itally are happy when there club is ruined by investors. Or they can"t affored ticket prices anymore.
    Football needs a financial fair play that works. As a german i need to say i prefer the Bundesliga as it is. If that results in losing in europe, well than it is like it is.

  • @4thGenna.
    @4thGenna. 2 года назад

    TheAthleticUK: Liverpool would not be put off by a huge £120M asking price for Jude Bellingham. The English midfielder is also attracting interest from Chelsea and Real Madrid.
    👀

    • @DisasterArtist1997
      @DisasterArtist1997 2 года назад

      0% Chance of him leaving this summer

    • @4thGenna.
      @4thGenna. 2 года назад

      @@DisasterArtist1997 It didn't specify what time..

  • @augustusglupsch1895
    @augustusglupsch1895 2 года назад +2

    hahahaha, bayern can´t compete. they won the champions league 2 years ago....

  • @tebogoteka7791
    @tebogoteka7791 2 года назад +7

    He is saying this because Bayern cannot compete in the European market when it comes to signing players, so by abolishing the 50+1 rule investors will invest more into Bayern because they are the most attractive club in Germany.

    • @Ikhlashasib10
      @Ikhlashasib10 Год назад

      "He is saying this because Bayern cannot compete in the European market when it comes to signing players"
      urmm what did you say?

  • @stnbch3025
    @stnbch3025 2 года назад +1

    Load of nonsense. Competition is not about the top spot but about the overall ratio and the Bundesliga is fine as it is.

    • @eavyeavy2864
      @eavyeavy2864 2 года назад

      This so much

    • @PyroMiniYak
      @PyroMiniYak Год назад

      There’s nothing fine about one team winning 11 years in a row.

  • @JoachimPfeiffer
    @JoachimPfeiffer 2 года назад

    Somebody with very deep pockets and extra money to spend on the Bayern (and a big payday for Uli) must have whispered in his ear.

  • @jsnagra1able
    @jsnagra1able 2 года назад +2

    How about a salary cap like in North American leagues?

    • @BlackRose-vi2yg
      @BlackRose-vi2yg 2 года назад

      Never work because will lead to all the top players going abroad to earn more.

  • @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl
    @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl 2 года назад +6

    They should also ban selling players to other teams in the league

    • @mitchelljeffords8970
      @mitchelljeffords8970 2 года назад +1

      😂 unbelievable comment

    • @r6plays126
      @r6plays126 2 года назад +1

      That’s stupid ur now restricting how players are allowed to live their lives since ur practically kicking them out of the country when a team what’s to sell them

    • @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl
      @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl 2 года назад

      @@mitchelljeffords8970 hey you gotta throw ish at the wall and see what stick everyone know all the team in the Bundesliga is bayern academy 🤣🤣 might as well see if it work

    • @blaaaaaaahhhhkathi
      @blaaaaaaahhhhkathi 2 года назад +1

      It also wouldn't make a difference because then the best players would just go to different leagues, and Bayern could buy players from other leagues because they still have more money to play with

  • @tomm9963
    @tomm9963 2 года назад

    Can't think why the former Bayern President would want to get rid the 50+1. They're the only club that would benefit from 50+1 being removed

  • @kylesenninger8542
    @kylesenninger8542 2 года назад

    3:35HEAVY line right there

  • @goober776
    @goober776 2 года назад +3

    No, what would make the league more competitive is other teams not surrendering their players to bayern . In any other league if a club sells a big player they would preferably like to sell in another league.

    • @Aanike09
      @Aanike09 2 года назад +3

      Most bundesligas players in the last 5 years have gone to other leagues not Bayern Munich

  • @Mannschaft23
    @Mannschaft23 2 года назад

    Hahaha them you remember that Bayern had Ribery Robben Muller Neuer Lahm Schweinsteiger and that Bayern would won Premier League like 6 years in a row with team. Premier league was poor next to Bayern players in that era.

  • @TheMaxeey
    @TheMaxeey 2 года назад +5

    Wow never thought that Hoeneß would get that senile. without 50+1, there will simply no German be seen in a stadium anymore :D
    I get the frustration against state own clubs but that business model will not stay forever, our business model has been successful for over 100 years. I rather see Bayern win the next 10 years than having investors ruin our clubs like Hertha, 1860,..

    • @storm21410
      @storm21410 2 года назад +1

      Why wouldn't state owned clubs remain forever? The states are diversifying their assets and football is one of them, away from oil. The final nail in the coffin was Newcastle. No point supporting clubs when once Klopp and Guardiola leave, City will remain having the money and Liverpool will have to buy cheap.

  • @frankfestus114
    @frankfestus114 2 года назад

    What about premier League now

  • @26DeislerFCB
    @26DeislerFCB 2 года назад +1

    would make it very hard for bayern to snap bundesliga players for cheap like they did in the past,

  • @AyodiJnr
    @AyodiJnr 2 года назад +1

    Liverpool are always the benchmark

  • @Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights
    @Colby_0-3_IRL_and_title_fights 2 года назад +10

    The 50+1 rule is what makes Bundesliga interesting and special. Get rid of it and become Ligue 1.

  • @friendlybane
    @friendlybane 2 года назад +1

    Might as well sell the entire league to Saudi Arabia Crown Prince MBS.

  • @myownlilbubble
    @myownlilbubble 2 года назад +2

    If other german clubs could stop salivating over themselves to sell their best players to Bayern...maybe..just maybe.....the 50-1 rule won't matter.
    Saying players don't play for money is ridiculous naive. Not every player demand the price of Neymar, Messi and CR7....but they do move clubs for money and the chance to have some trophy to their names...and that club is Bayern Munich in BL.

  • @peacefulliberal5641
    @peacefulliberal5641 2 года назад +1

    Dont worry, soon EPL will be the same.

  • @wafieksmith
    @wafieksmith 2 года назад +1

    so basically socialism vs capitalism

  • @DisasterArtist1997
    @DisasterArtist1997 2 года назад +4

    i rather stick to 50+1 but never win the Champions League again

  • @Richard-ib1ry
    @Richard-ib1ry 2 года назад +4

    Bundesliga should remove 50+1 rule or at least allow german investors to buy the club..this league is going nowhere with 50+1

  • @bigtguitars7312
    @bigtguitars7312 2 года назад

    It’s not a difference in the fan culture at all Jan English fans want what German fans already have. They would be foolish to accept this

    • @tststststs00999
      @tststststs00999 2 года назад +2

      English premier league is the best in the world because of American, Russian and Arab money.

    • @42void42
      @42void42 Год назад

      @@tststststs00999 true

  • @tinashe3753
    @tinashe3753 2 года назад +3

    They should allow foreign investment to own more than 51% otherwise Bayern wil dominate bundesliga for ages.

    • @moneymusic6755
      @moneymusic6755 2 года назад

      Bro plz explane to me that 50+1 rules

  • @RealDealMil
    @RealDealMil 2 года назад

    Bayern need more money to win the UCL?????
    Dude ur team taking a Pure L vs Villarreal has nothing to do with money
    If people want the bundesliga to be competitive tell Dortmund stop being a b!$/? And stop letting players go and getting proper players to add to the team

  • @hyenalaughingmatter8103
    @hyenalaughingmatter8103 2 года назад

    No NO and NO!

  • @chrisgil764
    @chrisgil764 2 года назад +1

    What diffence would a Change make? Bayern would generate far More Money than the Rest of the League . The gap between them and the Rest would get far bigger.

    • @Alex-ce1os
      @Alex-ce1os 2 года назад

      and that ? the other teams will also grow and stop being embarrassing in the champions I'm from bayern and I want them to eliminate that rule

  • @moneymusic6755
    @moneymusic6755 2 года назад

    What's the meaning of the 50+1 rule in Bundesliga ? Someone should plz explain to me

  • @megarohan16
    @megarohan16 2 года назад

    He is saying it because he is now former president..

  • @jimmihendrixhendrix9575
    @jimmihendrixhendrix9575 2 года назад

    Bayern will never allow it.

  • @lazyfingers4382
    @lazyfingers4382 2 года назад

    the sell outs from espn and the epl want every league to be as spinless as them

  • @razii87
    @razii87 2 года назад

    Well done Jan, on the casual Racism

  • @matthewjamison
    @matthewjamison 2 года назад

    Germans have integrity

  • @russellward4624
    @russellward4624 2 года назад

    They don't need to do all this. All they need to do is install a wage cap. cut Bayerns wage bill by 50% and the league becomes 1,000xs more competitive and it doesn't change anything for the other clubs.

    • @BlackRose-vi2yg
      @BlackRose-vi2yg 2 года назад +2

      That is no good for the champions league etc. No top player will go there and then outside of Germany no one will want to watch it.

  • @tshudimamabolo740
    @tshudimamabolo740 2 года назад

    Frank!

  • @DIN_A8
    @DIN_A8 2 года назад +1

    Lets face it.. Germany is the biggest economy by far in the EU. If they would be „PL Level Handling“ the PL would be the Farmers League in about 4-8 years.

    • @jaysmith2858
      @jaysmith2858 2 года назад

      Would you like some fish to go with that massive chip on your shoulder?

    • @DIN_A8
      @DIN_A8 2 года назад

      @@jaysmith2858 yes, please

    • @jaysmith2858
      @jaysmith2858 2 года назад

      @@DIN_A8 🐟 There you go. Sauerkraut?

    • @DIN_A8
      @DIN_A8 2 года назад

      @@jaysmith2858 does it go with jellied eel or what ever the f you are having?

    • @jaysmith2858
      @jaysmith2858 2 года назад

      @@DIN_A8 I wouldn't know. I've never tried them.

  • @chillheel128
    @chillheel128 2 года назад

    I think get rid of 50+1 but has 55/45 so the fans the 45 of the choices so it doesn’t become another man united

  • @rajmalla5310
    @rajmalla5310 2 года назад

    no wonder lewandwoski hhad so many goals last 2 ,3 season

  • @stormtechentertainment9423
    @stormtechentertainment9423 2 года назад +1

    Nagelsmann is gonna destroy Bayern this coming season so I think after Bayern crumble and fall apart new teams will start to emerge.

  • @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl
    @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl 2 года назад

    Chelsea Ex Owner should buy a Bundesliga Team, we all know he loves to spend big and expect big results too

  • @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700
    @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700 2 года назад +4

    Trust me, if Spain and Germany don't change EPL will become far superior because of the money going in the league all the best player wi go to EPL for the money

    • @Ryan-pw6rt
      @Ryan-pw6rt 2 года назад +4

      money can't buy you trophies, Bayern and Real Madrid will still be better than the English oil clubs

    • @jaysmith2858
      @jaysmith2858 2 года назад +2

      @@Ryan-pw6rt Real Madrid are the original (and still) state funded, bank assisted, FA helped club. The difference is that it's not as obvious and well known as what has happened with the likes of Man City, PSG, and now Newcastle United.

    • @irnesmujic976
      @irnesmujic976 2 года назад +1

      @@jaysmith2858 Newcastle is coming for the premier league title 😀

    • @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700
      @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700 2 года назад +1

      @@Ryan-pw6rt that doesn't make any sense. If money can't buy trophies how Real Bayern gotten the best players? What I mean is, players will go to EPL because La Liga and Germany can't compete monetary wise. So EPL will have 6 to 8 good teams because of the money. And to answer your statement, without money football wil die because no one will play for free.

    • @tststststs00999
      @tststststs00999 2 года назад

      @@Ryan-pw6rt Money can't buy you trophies. But it can give you a competitive league which is exciting to watch.

  • @JUSTAMFG2005
    @JUSTAMFG2005 2 года назад +9

    The Bundesliga is an awful example of competition. Sorry, but this league is no different than Ligue 1 in France. The Dutch and Portuguese have more competitive leagues.

    • @JsBlazIN
      @JsBlazIN 2 года назад +5

      The league is better then ligue 1 because atleast someone In Bundesliga wins UCL and gets far and doetmund has competed in UCL before. France has literally no one lol

    • @4thGenna.
      @4thGenna. 2 года назад +5

      @@JsBlazIN France just produces the most talents and best players in the world

    • @noirfifa2897
      @noirfifa2897 2 года назад +2

      @JsBlazIN Monaco and Lyon have both done better in the CL recently than Dortmund. Also just because they have one team that wins the CL doesn’t mean the whole league is better, your logic is just stupid.

    • @JsBlazIN
      @JsBlazIN 2 года назад +1

      @@noirfifa2897 that's exactly what it means what are you talking about. The more teams that are represented from that league in ucl and Europa league shows the status of that league.

    • @JUSTAMFG2005
      @JUSTAMFG2005 2 года назад +3

      @@JsBlazIN The only competitive team is Bayern. Dortmund is going to end up like Marseille - a UCL title, but eventually it will go into obscurity. Either way, there is no point in following either league.

  • @mr.sushi2221
    @mr.sushi2221 2 года назад +3

    Bayern are crumbling rn so idk

    • @emmanuel96604
      @emmanuel96604 2 года назад +1

      How??
      They won the league and made it to the quarter finals and lost because of lack of personnel's in midfield

    • @mr.sushi2221
      @mr.sushi2221 2 года назад

      @@emmanuel96604 lots of top talents are choosing other teams than Bayern. The ones that are choosing Bayern rn are looking to move on in 3-5 years.

    • @emmanuel96604
      @emmanuel96604 2 года назад

      @@mr.sushi2221 what exactly are you saying????
      Give me examples

    • @emmanuel96604
      @emmanuel96604 2 года назад

      @@mr.sushi2221 bayern just signed mane, grav..., nous I'm not really sure about their spellings and de light wants to join them over Chelsea. So if you are a bayern hater just come out clean and stop all this nonsense

    • @mr.sushi2221
      @mr.sushi2221 2 года назад +1

      @@emmanuel96604 okay. Wertz when he signed from koln, schloterback, sule jsut left them for Bvb,adayemi, a blonde guy in Manchester, Jude chose Bvb over them, when he moved to Leipzig nkunku, alaba and Kroos both left for Madrid those are old tho. Not saying Bayern are not still ahead. I’m saying that they are falling.

  • @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl
    @UnrulyRebel-hd2pl 2 года назад +6

    Farmers League

  • @andrewhylton8712
    @andrewhylton8712 2 года назад +1

    The German "League" is a joke. Why don't they just give Bayern the title in August and let the rest fight it out for the UCL and relegation places? You might as well

    • @eavyeavy2864
      @eavyeavy2864 2 года назад

      Funny people who think football focus is for supporter contradict themselves when they brought up medium team need to win title or make league entertaining for outsider

  • @jorgehoek8486
    @jorgehoek8486 2 года назад

    Football is a simpel game 22 men kick the ball for 90/120mins & in the end the Germans win

  • @Louey_
    @Louey_ 2 года назад +3

    Nobody outside Germany watches

    • @claudemakelele2856
      @claudemakelele2856 2 года назад +3

      Lol..I do

    • @TheMaxeey
      @TheMaxeey 2 года назад +3

      and no-one inside of Germany cares

    • @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700
      @imthecreatorofmyrealitymyf700 2 года назад +2

      Facts. Sometimes I try to watch but I fall asleep

    • @jessekuntz458
      @jessekuntz458 2 года назад +2

      I watch every Bayern game and I don't live in Germany and I'm not German.

    • @Louey_
      @Louey_ 2 года назад

      @@claudemakelele2856 exactly your a nobody

  • @mbuguaaida8470
    @mbuguaaida8470 2 года назад +1

    FARMERS LEAGUE

  • @robertheron7017
    @robertheron7017 2 года назад

    Their is no completion in the German league that's why it's boring.

  • @kritikal1993
    @kritikal1993 2 года назад

    Go away… premier league is the best league. People will still watch the premier league. No1 cares about bundesliga except for Germans. All the best players need to come to premier league and compete with the best