The kiss scene is a contrast--the chaos of the circus versus the complete absorption in each other of Anne and Wentworth. It's a metaphor for how Anne has moved past listening to other voices and distractions when it comes to determining her future and fate.
I'm glad they had the scene at the end, where the Captain proposes to Anne in a room full of people, who are suddenly stunned. It gives us a good feeling, a closure.
Came across your review by chance and what a great review it is. The 1995 adaptation is possibly my all time favourite along with Pride and Prejudice from the same year. As you said, Persuasion is quite different from Austen's earlier work which is reflected in characterization and storylines. I can't even recall how many times I've seen it and I always marvel at how Anne changes and becomes more and more beautiful as the story progresses. She is positively radiant in the last scene when Wentworth asks for her hand in front of all the guests. The film starts at sea with the men rowing a boat and ends at sea. Perfect.
I too love the addition of Admiral Croft and his wife. I also love Harvill and Benick. Many really great characters. I love how everyone besides Anne's family recognizes her value and love her.
This is also my favorite film version of the book and I credit almost all of it to Amanda Root. She is excellent and so expressive...fewer words needed. She also becom es more and more physically attractive as the film progresses...not sure if that was accidental or done on purpose...changing from an almost wasted look into a very pretty woman.
The more I think about the end scene in Persuasion 95 the more I like it. The circus add a distraction that our 2 lovers hardly notice as they kiss. They are the only 2 people in the world. BTW. The circus was added because this scene was actually filmed on a busy and used street in bath and they needed people to hide rather obvious modern areas of the city like street crossings and some modern signs.
I also like the circus. It does emphasize how lost to the outer world the two lovers are; but I also think the explosion of noise and colour, so different from any other scene in the film, might symbolize the explosion of joy in the hearts of Anne and Frederick, quiet as they seem on the outside.
An excellent review of one of my favourite films not just of Jane Austen adaptations but any film. As noted it is a sublime book and it does miss out some of the Uppercross back story, but not to its detriment in my opinion. The casting, acting, sets and costumes are perfect and the music is sublime in its mood setting for each particular scene. A small masterpiece which I never tire of watching.
Outstanding review and comments, Jerome!! I love this adaptation and am also a big fan of the 2007 version. "Persuasion" is actually one of my favorite love stories because of its maturity, its clear-eyed depiction of regret and longing, and its relatability. I have to say that I despise the 2022 version, for several reasons, but I think they can all be distilled to one concept that you so eloquently conveyed: "Ann Elliot is not the same type of heroine as Elizabeth Bennet and Emma Woodhouse. It is a great mistake to try to make her fit that mold." Yes, indeed.
This was a great review! I hope your review gets people to view this version. This is by far my most favorite adaptation of Persuasion. Especially after viewing the latest one which you said so graciously, exists. It is most unfortunate it does exist, but I’m glad you concentrated on this version instead! I’ve always loved Amanda Root in everything I’ve seen her in. She was perfect, showing so much emotion without a word of dialog most of the time. Also top on my list is Sophie Thompson’s portrayal of Mary. She was hilarious and pitiful all at the same time, especially when she was saying how sick she was while stuffing her face with all that food! Ciaran Hines was wonderful as well. I loved the restraint he showed in this portrayal. How I wish he was more like this when he did Mr. R in Jane Eyre. Is it possible to love one performance and despise another by the same actor? Guess so. You know who else I liked? The duo of Nurse Rook and Mrs. Smith so minor but such enjoyable performances by them! BTW, I recognized the Jane Eyre actors right off! I’m so glad you edited that in. Goes to show, like you I have watched Persuasion and all those Jane Eyre adaptations a whole lot. Once again you have done a thoroughly delightful review.
What a terrific review! Persuasion is my fav JA novel and I adore the 1995 movie. You really nailed why it is such a great adaptation. One of my fav scenes is the montage at Uppercross where everyone is complaining to Anne about Mary. It adapts the scene from the novel so well. Thanks for barely mentioning the Netflix travesty. I just wanted to throw things at my TV. It took me 2 weeks to watch it
I absolutely loved the soprano soloist's voice and arias! Beautifully filmed, and added a wonderful dimension to this beloved movie! Thank you! It is my favorite version of Persuasion too.
@@Weiselberry Of course, you are correct about #1 (was there any doubt?:). But my #2 must be 2009 Emma. Is it possible that Jonny Lee Miller's Knightley (at least) rivals Mr. Darcy?? #notsorry
The best version of Persuasion. Two brilliant actors Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds, my favorite Jane Austin film. And I have read all her stories as she was a really good authoress.
Brilliant review, Jerome! I often wonder about the choice the filmmakers made for the characters to be eating so much food too and am still unsure what the purpose was, but it gives a real, honest, lived-in feel to this fictional world that they reside in. I love that there are crumbs on the table when Captain Wentworth and Anne meet for the first time after so many years, that both Mary & Elizabeth with their snobbery and rudeness are often seen shovelling cake and sweets into their mouths whilst Anne quietly sips at her cups of tea - and yet I still don’t know what it all *means*! Thanks again for the brilliantly detailed review
Great discussion! Anne Elliot is a kind of extension of Charlotte Lucas... both are bordering on 'spinsterhood' and neither is considered especially attractive but they both have a kind of admirable industriousness, innate intelligence and ability to see through other people's nonsense. In that regard, I think they're very deeply connected to Jane Austen and her view of herself. Amanda Root is incredible in the role... the other versions of Persuasion are dreck. I also think the film captures the Regency era better than any other film... including servants, assistants, dirt, the class system... it's all there.
Your reviews often prompt me to watch films I’ve overlooked, but this review is so beautifully detailed, it’s the first one that’s given me the feeling that I’d watched the film (I haven’t, but I’m definitely going to).
@@Weiselberry Just a quick thank you for the review. I have just finished watching the film and thoroughly enjoyed it. A great example of “less is more”.
Wonderful review Jerome! This is one of my mom's favorite movies, in fact we all have seen it so many times since childhood that my siblings and myself don't particularly care for the movie. However, as an adaptation it's by far the best one. My mom likes the 2007 version too, which I thought was alright. We both absolutely hated the Netflix version 🤦♀️🤦♀️ I will say that when I do watch this movie, it makes me hungry from all that food 😋🤤. Also, that Jane Eyre trivia was so awesome! I only knew about the two leads!
if there had been an epilogue to this story I would imagine that Ann would be thought of in a different by her sister and father after she married the captain.
The Kiss Scene, I always thought was a beautiful and great contrast of Anne and Wentworth ignoring all distractions, including a cheerful parade. Almost seems like a celebration of their quiet determination to make a fresh start and when they leave while having their conversation out of earshot reminds me of the passage in the book. Yeah, you can't hear what they were saying but Austen wrote that we are suppose to see a couple engage in quiet intimacy. As for Amanda Root made up haggardly . . . I disagree. Possibly more simple or a little more plain than Austen MIGHT have intended, but you know what, not everyone in life is saccharin cute to look and they shouldn't be. I always thought Amanda Root's portrayal of Anne was light, simple, economical and fresh . . . the opposite of the rest of her family.
I guess it's just in that one sequence, the walk to Winthrop and back, where her appearance is what I would describe as haggard. Sorry, I should have been more specific. It's not meant to be a criticism of Root's appearance in any way. I suspect most people would be cold, worn out, unkempt, and sniffly after such a lengthy, impromptu "walk." I know I'd be red-faced, congested, and stumbling all over the place, begging for a rest. I also really like Anne's simple, modest costumes. The gowns and trim are pretty without being conspicuous in any way. She is indeed a clear contrast with the rest of the Elliots.
I first saw this film nearly fifteen years ago, and it was one I always wanted my mom to see some day, so a few years ago I bought her the DVD. Of course, as happens sometimes, it took a while to get around to it, but we finally watched it last year and she really liked it, as well. It was a fun surprise to see your video appear the other day. I watched it with my mom, and we both enjoyed your fun and informative analysis.
I rewatched this yesterday! It’s one of my all-time favorites and I think it captures the feeling of the novel. (Could’ve done without the clown show though.)
I was lucky enough to see this film on the big screen on the film's limited release in my country. I have loved this rendition ever since and have yet to seen a movie version or mini series to top Persuasion (1995). Edit: I did buy the DVD when it was released.
Both this and the 2007 version have their own charms. 2007's Sally Hawkins is closer to what I imagined Anne to look like. Persuasion is my favorite Jane Austen novel. I do like Ciaran Hinds as Wentworth.
This version of Persuasion was my "gateway drug" into Jane Austen movies and novels. After having watched it many times, I finally had to read the book to know why Anne's sister, Elizabeth was so rotten and why Mrs. Clay was giving side-glances to Mr. Elliot.
I absolutely love this movie and I’ve seen so many times. Anne is very sweet and dependable. Of course being a woman, Kieran Hinds is very easy on the eyes. Not sure why Elizabeth is such a shrewd. I bought the book as it has all the letters exchanged in the movie. I can’t wait to read the letter to Anne from Frederick. Thank you for your clear and concise review.
Excellent review, as always! Persuasion is my favourite Austen and this is one of my favourite adaptations of her work (Sense and Sensibility from 1995 is competing for the first place in my list). I love how quiet and melancholic this movie is, without turning Anne into something else as you said. I specially love the scene of Anne and Wentworth first encounter, the sense of "I forgot to breathe" it conveys is very well done in my opinion. My only complaint has always been the bizarre characterization for some of the secondary characters as well as the unsual look of some sets (specially every place the Elliots call "home") but your review is enlightening about all that. Also... I kind of like that strange ending with the circus. It's very... mmm... unique but I like the way it serves to give Anne and Wentworth their private, unnoticed moment.
I thoroughly enjoyed your thoughts on my favorite Persuasion. I agree with most everything you said. I noticed that Elizabeth is constantly eating however I didn't notice how much food is present in the scenes. Great actors in every role.
Mary, although very flawed, in on a higher level than Elizabeth or Sir Walter. There is genuine love for Anne from Mary. Anne is valued by Mary, and Mary is glad to see her. Yes, Mary is hypochondriac with a possible borderline personality, but she is real.
I believe Kubrick's night interiors in Barry Lyndon were all naturally candle lit. I have a fond memory of seeing this Persuasion with my 14yo daughter in 1995.
I agree 100% with your vision of the movie adaptation, and conclusion about the book. ;) And yes, my favorites heroins in Austen are Fanny Price, Elinor Dashwood and Anne Elliot. (Most deep book in my opinion is Mansfield park).
I wish I could analyze books and movies the way you do. I have watched this version of Persuasion at least three times, but I will watch it again thinking of of your wonderful and detailed review. Also, it’s time to reread the novel. Thank you.
I like you have read, listened to the audible books too many times to count over the years. The 1995 version is my favorite…..hoping for a truly great remake (similar to Pride & Prejudice- K.Knightly version) BF I die😊
Excellent and very perceptive review. I agree completely with what you say that this is the best screen adaptation of the book . As well as the two excellent lead performances I really like Fiona Shaw and John Woodvine as the Crofts (you are spot on about their friendship and kindness to Anne and they show what Anne and Wentworth 's future will be ) . I also like that Mrs Smith is given time as her stoicism in face of illness contrasts with the selfishness of the Elliots. Great review and second your closing comments that the book is the best !
Excellent review of a great movie. I never noticed the way certain characters, elements, or scenes were juxtaposed, but that's a great point and something I'll have to watch for in my next viewing.
I always enjoyed the carnival parade and took it as a metaphor for what they are feeling as the enjoy their first kiss and the understanding between them.
It's weird because everyone hates on Northanger Abbey when I find it one of the best novels from Jane Austin. So comical and spot on. I still have yet to warm up to other novels from her. Still, I love your video about Persuasion and everything. It's another novel that I might or might not read.
Oh, I think you should read it. I recommend it to anyone who's interested in Austen but is wary of Pride and Prejudice or Sense and Sensibility for whatever reason. Persuasion is an excellent and accessible book. I love Northanger Abbey too. I'm bewildered by how often it's left out of the conversation when it's such a skillful and entertaining parody of the Gothic novel. It was pretty daring of Austen to make fun of that genre so openly when it was so popular.
I first watched this when I was around 5-6 (the year it came out…I’m getting old! Lol) . I really disliked it as a kid, I think because it wasn’t as ‘beautiful’ as other Austen films (thinking about Emma 96, Gwenyth Paltrow and 95 PnP with Colin Firth). The older I get, and the more watches I give it, the more I love it! Your review was great! You brought out some details that I never noticed and the Jane Eyre connections 🤯 I had no idea there were so many! Thanks again! I love all your period film/tv reviews. The way you talk about your mom enjoying the films with you is similar to me with my mom. I have my own children now and I’m now getting to introduce them to the wonderful world of Austen and Bronte 😊
I'm not a big critic , I seem to find something to like in all the versions I've seen but this one is my favorite Persuasion although I like Sally Hawkins in everything I've seen her in . I liked your take , thanks .
I seem to have really good luck getting hold of things you talk about through my local library system, starting to wonder if some of the classics are mandatory according to some super-secret library code.
I consider this film the quiet achiever amongst the Jane Austen adaptations of the 90's.A made for television feature that was picked up by Sony Pictures Classics and given theatrical exhibition in the U.S. and other territories.The modest small screen origins make this less stylish than Sense and Sensibility and Emma.Yet in some ways this works in Persuasion's favour. The natural lighting,unfussy camera work and location filming give an air of realism.Like you were there.Whatever that means for an audience who never lived in Regency Britain?Amanda Root makes for a very appealing lead.Most of her screen appearances seem to have been on television.She makes my heart go boom boom.Ciaran Hinds continues to chalk up many fine performances.Including an Oscar nomination for Belfast last year. I would now like to address an elephant in the room.Persuasion 2022 with Dakota Johnson.Greeted with disdain and discontent. Considered feeble and inferior.With attempts at humour that went down like a lead balloon.With direct addressing to the audience.Saw it.I believe the judgment was way too harsh.It was enjoyable enough.Can't hold a candle to 95.But far from terrible like many have suggested.But what do I know? I very much like the themes of this story.The idea that you can try again.The door never closes completely.There is always hope.And sometimes you shouldn't listen to your family. Thank you Lady Weiselberry.
In the late 90s, we saw a slew of modern retellings of classic literature (She's All That, Clueless, She's the Man, 10 Things I Hate About You, etc), do you think Persuasion could be retold through a simliar method? I'd actually love to hear your thoughts on these modern retellings as both original stories and adaptations.
Another commenter provided some helpful information about the circus being used to mask more modernized sections of the street they couldn't otherwise cover up. Makes sense. I figure the scene was creatively shot to make the circus seem much bigger than it was, but presumably they had to hire a few more talented extras, assuming they didn't just happen to have a firebreather or a juggler hanging around.
@@Weiselberry wow that’s a great behind the scenes detail. I will have to give them the credit that i did buy into the circus being of the time period. They were talented actors.
I noticed a line in the film which I believe was intended to pave the way for it. Mrs. Clay sees Sir Walter reading the paper and asks about the news, and he says something about a circus being in town. I don't remember the line exactly, but it stuck out to me as a subtle preparatory comment.
I've always found the addition of the circus to be puzzling, and eventually decided it represented the outer world of fools and mountebanks as a contrast to the two lovers, perfectly honest with each other at last, and in harmony.
I went to a lecture on its production. The lighting of internal scenes by candlelight had been inspired by Kubrick's Barry Lyndon. I'm a big fan of your reactions, please forgive me for pointing out Roger Michell has no T in his name.
I was aware of the unusual spelling and tried to say it without letting a T-sound slip in there, but it's pretty close to impossible. Is it pronounced like the name Michelle?
@@Weiselberry That's exactly right. He passed about a year ago, probably best known now for Notting Hill. Someone else with the same surname Keith Michell was said to be the best ever Henry 8th. Have you ever seen the mini-series?
This is my favorite version, however I haven't fully seen the old mini series, or the newest one (and after seeing bits and pieces don't want to) but I completely agree the book is the best form for the story. This is probably my favorite book of hers-tied with Northanger Abbey. Every now and again I watch 2007 but it something is just missing in it for me 🤷♀️
No, that didn't appeal to me. That kind of thing typically doesn't, though it can be mildly amusing. I guess I'd rather just read or watch Austen things myself than watch other fictional characters talk about them.
@@Weiselberry I can understand your position on that - sort of the problem I have with those CSI shows (coming up with a rationale for bullets bending around building). In the case of the Book Club movie, I was intrigued mostly by interaction and personal lives of the Book Club members, and how it ending in a very romantic scene.
,, thank you for all the great layers you make in the composition of your reviews, the edits are always of fine labour ✨🤗💐 x ,, I wonder, if you ever get annoyed slightly if the wardrobes have inferior tailoring for the period when hems and seams would have been made sturdy and to last,, I can hardly abide pieces set in the fourties, where, apart from the one overweight actor who has had something quickly run up on a machine, everyone else has been seemingly dressed by moss bros ✨🙄🎉
The 1995 is my favorite adaptation also. Very rarely are adaptations able to improve upon a book, especially the classics. They become classics for a reason! The most recent version (2022) is a joke! The 2006 is semi-ok. The 1971 is good, but the costumes research was not up to par.
I've had my eye out but haven't come across this movie yet, my loss. Re low lighting: If you know the movie Barry Lyndon, you'll be familiar with similar scenes that appear to be lit only by candlelight. This is because they are lit only by candlelight. Kubrick explains how he used a brand new camera (or lens, I forget now) that is capable of picking up extremely low lighting. It made it difficult for the actors because they could hardly see anything but it made the visuals very authentic.
Another commenter posted a link to the movie on RUclips (with foreign subtitles). I can't view it because Sony copyright blocked it, but maybe you can?
Which one is your guilty pleasure Kaiju or 19th Century social criticism.Thank you for exposing me to both😊 I found Danger UXB on Internet archives.Its bound to be a favorite and started The Sandbaggers 1978 Brit Cold War stuff on YT.
First, I quickly dare to ask -- is there a Hedwig amidst your parliament of owls? Anyhow, I'm not that big an Austen fan but this is still a very strong recommendation, thank you.
The superior version by far, in my opinion. But the circus... oof! I don't care if they weren't distracted by it, I was, lol. Toned down a bit, maybe would've been ok..?
The reason for the circus makes sense, but the version.of circus seems too modern,.or foreign ? Early 1800s English circuses were probably different ?The music sounds too 20th c.?
“ A very fine young man indeed, more air than one often see in Bath. Irish, I dare say.” - Lady Dalrymple…..Great book, fantastic book, unbelievably exquisite book and a wonderful film adaptation 🤣 in all seriousness I do like the book a lot and also feel this 1995 film adaptation is the best version, I like the book more but really like this film, I think it’s so well cast and really works overall. Amanda Root is terrific and grounds it because she brings a reality to Anne, she’s a real person amongst a collection of fairy tale characters, Anne’s almost in a world where her father is the wicked stepmother and her sister is the wicked stepsister, Anne being Cinderella. Her character and performance also has a way of grounding the characters she interacts with, none more so than Frederick, like most of the other characters his personality fills a room until Anne and he speak, then he becomes grounded, he and his thoughts become as real as Anne, they almost take solace in each others stillness while being surrounded by over the top characters and personalities, perhaps with the exception of the Crofts each side character wouldn’t feel out of place in that loud festive parade while both Anne and Frederick have learned to ignore it all, ignoring the brashness and uneducated opinions of those loud voices that were once overbearing, they’ve decided their love and affection is what really matters. I also really like Admiral and Mrs. Croft, they carry that same quiet affection and comfort when in each others company we see Anne and Frederick also have, a steady and calm ship in a rough sea. Mary, “ I had better sit your side Anne if you have had your rest.” Wow! Lol, her character is so irritating but funny, my seat is damp and yours is dry, move over I’m taking your spot lol, even her choice of words, I had better sit your side, not may I or could I please sit your side, shouldn’t have even asked, I had better, why? So we can both be damp or would you have me stand for the duration of their visit? Anne’s sister Elizabeth definitely took after her father lol, the rage Elizabeth carries, Anne must’ve taken after her mother. Anne’s father is no Mr. Bennett, When Frederick speaks of his plan to marry Anne and her father says “ but why” her father doesn’t see her and probably never has, it was sad. “ You ought perhaps to allow a larger portion of prose in your daily study, too much poetry maybe unsafe “ lol, that is very funny. Benwick, there’s another interesting character. You’re so right about the homes we’re invited into during the story, you explained how each one has is own character and warmth depending on the characters we meet while there, the houses with the warm characters are homely and welcoming regardless of how well to do they are, and the houses we meet the cold character’s are vey unwelcoming and show little comfort. Home is where the heart is, as long as a house has heart in it thats all that really matters, and i guess running water, electricity too lol. I also felt it would’ve been better to just hear Frederick when Anne was reading the letter and also think adding the festival was a strange idea but I’ve come to accept it. I agree completely with what you said about Ciaran Hinds Rochester, he was much better in the radio play and assume his performance in the 97 version was down to other factors. “ A very fine review indeed, more air than one often sees on RUclips. Weiselberry, I dare say.” Oscars. I’ve looked through all the winners and I’m shocked by how many I’ve seen, 78 or 79 :0. My top eight would be similar to yours if not the exact same, maybe some films would change positions but it probably would be the same films, top two would be the same as yours, Casablanca is a strange one, it’s almost like it’s such a good film it’s reputation has harmed it, most people seem to think of it as THE CLASSIC FILM and it’s almost become uncool to mention it, its like if you say you like it people will think you don’t watch classic film, Casablanca is the only one you’ve heard of, it’s the go to pick for people who’ve not seen anything else made before the 90s, but it’s great and has lasted the span of time because it’s as good as it’s reputation, it’s endlessly quotable, the characters are so incredible, without Rick Blaine would there have been characters like Han Solo, Bond or Indiana Jones, maybe not, it has a powerful message too. Like you I was unsure what I’d pick as number one but Casablanca is it. The Best Years of our Lives is an easy number two for me also, I did consider putting it at one but as much as I thought about it I had to put Casablanca as one. I felt the same way about Gone with the Wind lol, it’s hard to deny it belongs there. ( Imagining a husband and wife having breakfast somewhere in Georgia, Wife : Want jam on your toast? Husband : frankly my dear I don’t eat jam :D, it’s 2023 no reason the husband wouldn’t be putting jam on his own toast but I needed to make my dumb Gone with the Wind joke work lol ) All of your honourable mention’s would probably be mine also, I might add Unforgiven to my honourable mentions list. It’s tough, I’m broken, It can be difficult for me to feel as positive about newer films over classics, I liked the Artist and was glad it won but not many Oscar viewers felt that way, it appealed to me because it was a black and white silent film, a love letter to movies we don’t see anymore, it’s not a masterpiece but I thought it was decent and I liked seeing it win best picture, it’s probably evidence of how skewed and broken my brain has become lol, it was a new film pretending to be an old film so it got a pass from me, dog is cute in it too. The most surprising thing about looking at the list of winners is realising films that probably should’ve won aren’t there, I thought I’ll probably put Singing in the Rain on my list, oh right, it’s not there, Citizen Kane either, Shadow of a Doubt, Vertigo, Rear Window, Rope, The Third Man, The Searchers and so many more. Thinking about The Sound of Music on your best picture list and your review of Persuasion I think the portrayals of Frederick and Baron Von Trapp by Ciaran Hinds and Christopher Plummer have some similarities. There was a point when I’d try to watch the Oscars when it was possible because of my interest in film or watch highlights the next day because it’d go through the night, I’d get some junk food and power through it. The desire to do so has begun to vanish over the last few years, it feels like the Oscars and broadcasters are now more influenced by a television audience than those working in the film industry, I’ve always seen the Oscars as films employee of the month, voted for by those who’ve worked on the films and those on the outside shouldn’t really have a say in who wins or who’s nominated but now they do, we film enthusiasts will always have an opinion on if we think the right film won or was nominated but I don’t feel I should have a direct influence or they’d just be the MTV movie awards, films like those made by Marvel or whatever popular film is out is now is more likely to be nominated just to attract an audience, if a film like one from Marvel is fantastic and deserves it then great, but it doesn’t feel that way. I think the Oscars should go back to how it was in the 1930s and not being televised at all, it also feels like apart from a few there’s not really any movie stars anymore either, stars don’t really open films comic book characters do. After saying all that there is a record number of Irish nominees this year so I think I’ll probably try to watch it lol. I apologise for the long comment once again. ~ Thank you Ms Weiselberry ~
I enjoyed this adaptation of "Persuasion" a lot - like I do of all the other versions - but I think it's a bit overrated and consists of some minor issues and a major one. The major issue I have with this movie has to do with the character of William Elliot. This is why I don't share the belief that it's the best adaptation of Austen's 1818 novel.
Thanks for not reviewing the 2022 Netflix travesty "adaption" of Persuasion!!!! Have you watched any of Whit Stillman's films? He's very influenced by Austen. I think you'd love "Metropolitan"!
I need to see more of Whit Stillman's films, but that is interesting as the only one of his films I have seen (and which I quite enjoyed) was Love & Friendship, his adaptation of a Jane Austen novella (though I must confess that while I have seen many film adaptations of her works, I've never read them, so I don't know how good of an adaptation it or any of the others were).
The kiss scene is a contrast--the chaos of the circus versus the complete absorption in each other of Anne and Wentworth. It's a metaphor for how Anne has moved past listening to other voices and distractions when it comes to determining her future and fate.
I'm glad they had the scene at the end, where the Captain proposes to Anne in a room full of people, who are suddenly stunned. It gives us a good feeling, a closure.
yes...its like anne finally became visible to all of these people
Came across your review by chance and what a great review it is. The 1995 adaptation is possibly my all time favourite along with Pride and Prejudice from the same year. As you said, Persuasion is quite different from Austen's earlier work which is reflected in characterization and storylines. I can't even recall how many times I've seen it and I always marvel at how Anne changes and becomes more and more beautiful as the story progresses. She is positively radiant in the last scene when Wentworth asks for her hand in front of all the guests. The film starts at sea with the men rowing a boat and ends at sea. Perfect.
I too love the addition of Admiral Croft and his wife. I also love Harvill and Benick. Many really great characters. I love how everyone besides Anne's family recognizes her value and love her.
This is also my favorite film version of the book and I credit almost all of it to Amanda Root. She is excellent and so expressive...fewer words needed. She also becom es more and more physically attractive as the film progresses...not sure if that was accidental or done on purpose...changing from an almost wasted look into a very pretty woman.
The more I think about the end scene in Persuasion 95 the more I like it. The circus add a distraction that our 2 lovers hardly notice as they kiss. They are the only 2 people in the world. BTW. The circus was added because this scene was actually filmed on a busy and used street in bath and they needed people to hide rather obvious modern areas of the city like street crossings and some modern signs.
I also like the circus. It does emphasize how lost to the outer world the two lovers are; but I also think the explosion of noise and colour, so different from any other scene in the film, might symbolize the explosion of joy in the hearts of Anne and Frederick, quiet as they seem on the outside.
My response to the circus is to wonder what that is all about. I see it as something totally irrelevant.
@@briteddy9759I was so wrapped up in Anne and Wentworth I didn't notice them the first three viewings
I still don't like it. I found the circus distracting.
Persuasion is my favorite Austin book and this adaptation is excellent.
An excellent review of one of my favourite films not just of Jane Austen adaptations but any film. As noted it is a sublime book and it does miss out some of the Uppercross back story, but not to its detriment in my opinion. The casting, acting, sets and costumes are perfect and the music is sublime in its mood setting for each particular scene. A small masterpiece which I never tire of watching.
Outstanding review and comments, Jerome!! I love this adaptation and am also a big fan of the 2007 version. "Persuasion" is actually one of my favorite love stories because of its maturity, its clear-eyed depiction of regret and longing, and its relatability. I have to say that I despise the 2022 version, for several reasons, but I think they can all be distilled to one concept that you so eloquently conveyed: "Ann Elliot is not the same type of heroine as Elizabeth Bennet and Emma Woodhouse. It is a great mistake to try to make her fit that mold." Yes, indeed.
I loved Pride and Prejudice when I was a young lady, but as a woman of mature years I have grown to appreciate Anne Elliott.
The DEFINITIVE version of Jane's masterpiece. Unbeatable. The characters all have the depth that other versions lack
This was a great review! I hope your review gets people to view this version. This is by far my most favorite adaptation of Persuasion. Especially after viewing the latest one which you said so graciously, exists. It is most unfortunate it does exist, but I’m glad you concentrated on this version instead!
I’ve always loved Amanda Root in everything I’ve seen her in. She was perfect, showing so much emotion without a word of dialog most of the time. Also top on my list is Sophie Thompson’s portrayal of Mary. She was hilarious and pitiful all at the same time, especially when she was saying how sick she was while stuffing her face with all that food! Ciaran Hines was wonderful as well. I loved the restraint he showed in this portrayal. How I wish he was more like this when he did Mr. R in Jane Eyre. Is it possible to love one performance and despise another by the same actor? Guess so. You know who else I liked? The duo of Nurse Rook and Mrs. Smith so minor but such enjoyable performances by them!
BTW, I recognized the Jane Eyre actors right off! I’m so glad you edited that in. Goes to show, like you I have watched Persuasion and all those Jane Eyre adaptations a whole lot. Once again you have done a thoroughly delightful review.
What a terrific review! Persuasion is my fav JA novel and I adore the 1995 movie. You really nailed why it is such a great adaptation. One of my fav scenes is the montage at Uppercross where everyone is complaining to Anne about Mary. It adapts the scene from the novel so well. Thanks for barely mentioning the Netflix travesty. I just wanted to throw things at my TV. It took me 2 weeks to watch it
I absolutely loved the soprano soloist's voice and arias! Beautifully filmed, and added a wonderful dimension to this beloved movie! Thank you! It is my favorite version of Persuasion too.
“It exists.” 😂😂😂
My favorite adaptation, and one of the best Austen adaptations of all, imo (probably #3 for me).
Nice! Number 1 being 1995 Pride and Prejudice and number 2 being...?
@@Weiselberry Of course, you are correct about #1 (was there any doubt?:).
But my #2 must be 2009 Emma.
Is it possible that Jonny Lee Miller's Knightley (at least) rivals Mr. Darcy?? #notsorry
I prefer Ciaran Hinds as Captain Wentworth in Persuasion than his role as Rochester in Jane Eyre.
I love this movie so much. It's my favorite of all Austen adaptations, and not only because Persuasion is my favorite Austen novel.
The best version of Persuasion. Two brilliant actors Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds, my favorite Jane Austin film. And I have read all her stories as she was a really good authoress.
Brilliant review, Jerome!
I often wonder about the choice the filmmakers made for the characters to be eating so much food too and am still unsure what the purpose was, but it gives a real, honest, lived-in feel to this fictional world that they reside in. I love that there are crumbs on the table when Captain Wentworth and Anne meet for the first time after so many years, that both Mary & Elizabeth with their snobbery and rudeness are often seen shovelling cake and sweets into their mouths whilst Anne quietly sips at her cups of tea - and yet I still don’t know what it all *means*!
Thanks again for the brilliantly detailed review
Great discussion! Anne Elliot is a kind of extension of Charlotte Lucas... both are bordering on 'spinsterhood' and neither is considered especially attractive but they both have a kind of admirable industriousness, innate intelligence and ability to see through other people's nonsense. In that regard, I think they're very deeply connected to Jane Austen and her view of herself. Amanda Root is incredible in the role... the other versions of Persuasion are dreck. I also think the film captures the Regency era better than any other film... including servants, assistants, dirt, the class system... it's all there.
Very in depth!! Thank you!!!
Your reviews often prompt me to watch films I’ve overlooked, but this review is so beautifully detailed, it’s the first one that’s given me the feeling that I’d watched the film (I haven’t, but I’m definitely going to).
Aw, thanks! Fortunately, there's a lot I didn't discuss plot-wise, so if you watch it (and I hope you do!), it should still be fresh! :)
@@Weiselberry Just a quick thank you for the review. I have just finished watching the film and thoroughly enjoyed it. A great example of “less is more”.
Wonderful! I'm so glad you liked it!
My favorite version also.
Wonderful review Jerome! This is one of my mom's favorite movies, in fact we all have seen it so many times since childhood that my siblings and myself don't particularly care for the movie. However, as an adaptation it's by far the best one. My mom likes the 2007 version too, which I thought was alright. We both absolutely hated the Netflix version 🤦♀️🤦♀️ I will say that when I do watch this movie, it makes me hungry from all that food 😋🤤. Also, that Jane Eyre trivia was so awesome! I only knew about the two leads!
if there had been an epilogue to this story I would imagine that Ann would be thought of in a different by her sister and father after she married the captain.
The Kiss Scene, I always thought was a beautiful and great contrast of Anne and Wentworth ignoring all distractions, including a cheerful parade. Almost seems like a celebration of their quiet determination to make a fresh start and when they leave while having their conversation out of earshot reminds me of the passage in the book. Yeah, you can't hear what they were saying but Austen wrote that we are suppose to see a couple engage in quiet intimacy. As for Amanda Root made up haggardly . . . I disagree. Possibly more simple or a little more plain than Austen MIGHT have intended, but you know what, not everyone in life is saccharin cute to look and they shouldn't be. I always thought Amanda Root's portrayal of Anne was light, simple, economical and fresh . . . the opposite of the rest of her family.
I guess it's just in that one sequence, the walk to Winthrop and back, where her appearance is what I would describe as haggard. Sorry, I should have been more specific. It's not meant to be a criticism of Root's appearance in any way. I suspect most people would be cold, worn out, unkempt, and sniffly after such a lengthy, impromptu "walk." I know I'd be red-faced, congested, and stumbling all over the place, begging for a rest. I also really like Anne's simple, modest costumes. The gowns and trim are pretty without being conspicuous in any way. She is indeed a clear contrast with the rest of the Elliots.
I first saw this film nearly fifteen years ago, and it was one I always wanted my mom to see some day, so a few years ago I bought her the DVD. Of course, as happens sometimes, it took a while to get around to it, but we finally watched it last year and she really liked it, as well. It was a fun surprise to see your video appear the other day. I watched it with my mom, and we both enjoyed your fun and informative analysis.
I rewatched this yesterday! It’s one of my all-time favorites and I think it captures the feeling of the novel. (Could’ve done without the clown show though.)
I was lucky enough to see this film on the big screen on the film's limited release in my country. I have loved this rendition ever since and have yet to seen a movie version or mini series to top Persuasion (1995).
Edit: I did buy the DVD when it was released.
Very well done. Thank you
Both this and the 2007 version have their own charms. 2007's Sally Hawkins is closer to what I imagined Anne to look like. Persuasion is my favorite Jane Austen novel. I do like Ciaran Hinds as Wentworth.
Great review, JW...👍
Excellent observations, Jerome. Thank you for the review.
Thank you so much!
This version of Persuasion was my "gateway drug" into Jane Austen movies and novels. After having watched it many times, I finally had to read the book to know why Anne's sister, Elizabeth was so rotten and why Mrs. Clay was giving side-glances to Mr. Elliot.
I agree with you utterly.
Definitely a favorite adaptation of mine. I love the subtle but great performances given by the two main actors.
I absolutely love this movie and I’ve seen so many times. Anne is very sweet and dependable. Of course being a woman, Kieran Hinds is very easy on the eyes. Not sure why Elizabeth is such a shrewd. I bought the book as it has all the letters exchanged in the movie. I can’t wait to read the letter to Anne from Frederick. Thank you for your clear and concise review.
Excellent review, as always! Persuasion is my favourite Austen and this is one of my favourite adaptations of her work (Sense and Sensibility from 1995 is competing for the first place in my list). I love how quiet and melancholic this movie is, without turning Anne into something else as you said. I specially love the scene of Anne and Wentworth first encounter, the sense of "I forgot to breathe" it conveys is very well done in my opinion. My only complaint has always been the bizarre characterization for some of the secondary characters as well as the unsual look of some sets (specially every place the Elliots call "home") but your review is enlightening about all that.
Also... I kind of like that strange ending with the circus. It's very... mmm... unique but I like the way it serves to give Anne and Wentworth their private, unnoticed moment.
I thoroughly enjoyed your thoughts on my favorite Persuasion. I agree with most everything you said. I noticed that Elizabeth is constantly eating however I didn't notice how much food is present in the scenes. Great actors in every role.
Mary, although very flawed, in on a higher level than Elizabeth or Sir Walter. There is genuine love for Anne from Mary. Anne is valued by Mary, and Mary is glad to see her. Yes, Mary is hypochondriac with a possible borderline personality, but she is real.
I believe Kubrick's night interiors in Barry Lyndon were all naturally candle lit. I have a fond memory of seeing this Persuasion with my 14yo daughter in 1995.
I agree 100% with your vision of the movie adaptation, and conclusion about the book. ;) And yes, my favorites heroins in Austen are Fanny Price, Elinor Dashwood and Anne Elliot. (Most deep book in my opinion is Mansfield park).
Finally, someone who agrees with me about that circus scene.
Other than that, it’s probably my favorite Austen adaptation.
I wish I could analyze books and movies the way you do. I have watched this version of Persuasion at least three times, but I will watch it again thinking of of your wonderful and detailed review. Also, it’s time to reread the novel. Thank you.
Thanks for this super neat review!
I like you have read, listened to the audible books too many times to count over the years. The 1995 version is my favorite…..hoping for a truly great remake (similar to Pride & Prejudice- K.Knightly version) BF I die😊
“Bedraggled”…I use this word often and my husband thinks it is funny. Thanks for being such a great source for all kinds of movies!
Excellent and very perceptive review. I agree completely with what you say that this is the best screen adaptation of the book . As well as the two excellent lead performances I really like Fiona Shaw and John Woodvine as the Crofts (you are spot on about their friendship and kindness to Anne and they show what Anne and Wentworth 's future will be ) . I also like that Mrs Smith is given time as her stoicism in face of illness contrasts with the selfishness of the Elliots.
Great review and second your closing comments that the book is the best !
great video
Thank you for a great review. Your line, "There is also the one from 2022 which...exists," made me laugh out loud!
It is a tribute to Our Jane's powers of imagination that she could conceive of such dreadful sisters with such an excellent one as Cassandra.
Excellent review of a great movie. I never noticed the way certain characters, elements, or scenes were juxtaposed, but that's a great point and something I'll have to watch for in my next viewing.
Sweet late night 90s movie review by Jerome! Hope your weekend is going great!
I always enjoyed the carnival parade and took it as a metaphor for what they are feeling as the enjoy their first kiss and the understanding between them.
It's weird because everyone hates on Northanger Abbey when I find it one of the best novels from Jane Austin. So comical and spot on. I still have yet to warm up to other novels from her. Still, I love your video about Persuasion and everything. It's another novel that I might or might not read.
Oh, I think you should read it. I recommend it to anyone who's interested in Austen but is wary of Pride and Prejudice or Sense and Sensibility for whatever reason. Persuasion is an excellent and accessible book. I love Northanger Abbey too. I'm bewildered by how often it's left out of the conversation when it's such a skillful and entertaining parody of the Gothic novel. It was pretty daring of Austen to make fun of that genre so openly when it was so popular.
Northanger Abbey is in my top three. I love it! You’re right, it’s hilarious
I first watched this when I was around 5-6 (the year it came out…I’m getting old! Lol) . I really disliked it as a kid, I think because it wasn’t as ‘beautiful’ as other Austen films (thinking about Emma 96, Gwenyth Paltrow and 95 PnP with Colin Firth). The older I get, and the more watches I give it, the more I love it!
Your review was great! You brought out some details that I never noticed and the Jane Eyre connections 🤯 I had no idea there were so many! Thanks again! I love all your period film/tv reviews. The way you talk about your mom enjoying the films with you is similar to me with my mom. I have my own children now and I’m now getting to introduce them to the wonderful world of Austen and Bronte 😊
Aw, that's so great that you're getting to share these movies now with your own kids! :D
I saw this recently. Good movie, great novel.
This is one of my favorite movies.
I'm not a big critic , I seem to find something to like in all the versions I've seen but this one is my favorite Persuasion although I like Sally Hawkins in everything I've seen her in . I liked your take , thanks .
Thanks for this review on this 90s movie.
I seem to have really good luck getting hold of things you talk about through my local library system, starting to wonder if some of the classics are mandatory according to some super-secret library code.
I consider this film the quiet achiever amongst the Jane Austen adaptations of the 90's.A made for television feature that was
picked up by Sony Pictures Classics and given theatrical exhibition in the U.S. and other territories.The modest small screen
origins make this less stylish than Sense and Sensibility and Emma.Yet in some ways this works in Persuasion's favour.
The natural lighting,unfussy camera work and location filming give an air of realism.Like you were there.Whatever that
means for an audience who never lived in Regency Britain?Amanda Root makes for a very appealing lead.Most of her
screen appearances seem to have been on television.She makes my heart go boom boom.Ciaran Hinds continues to
chalk up many fine performances.Including an Oscar nomination for Belfast last year.
I would now like to address an elephant in the room.Persuasion 2022 with Dakota Johnson.Greeted with disdain and discontent.
Considered feeble and inferior.With attempts at humour that went down like a lead balloon.With direct addressing to the
audience.Saw it.I believe the judgment was way too harsh.It was enjoyable enough.Can't hold a candle to 95.But far from
terrible like many have suggested.But what do I know?
I very much like the themes of this story.The idea that you can try again.The door never closes completely.There is always
hope.And sometimes you shouldn't listen to your family.
Thank you Lady Weiselberry.
By far the best version....
In the late 90s, we saw a slew of modern retellings of classic literature (She's All That, Clueless, She's the Man, 10 Things I Hate About You, etc), do you think Persuasion could be retold through a simliar method? I'd actually love to hear your thoughts on these modern retellings as both original stories and adaptations.
Hi Jerome! Another Jane Eyre connection for you: Amanda Root narrated the Naxos audiobook version of Jane Eyre! :)
Thank you, Sister Jerome!
My favorite version of my favorite Austin.
I wish Netflix or BBC iplayer would show all the adaptations of Persuasion. I would love to binge watch and see them all again.
The circus is the biggest mystery to me. So random and also so expensive probably.
Another commenter provided some helpful information about the circus being used to mask more modernized sections of the street they couldn't otherwise cover up. Makes sense. I figure the scene was creatively shot to make the circus seem much bigger than it was, but presumably they had to hire a few more talented extras, assuming they didn't just happen to have a firebreather or a juggler hanging around.
@@Weiselberry wow that’s a great behind the scenes detail. I will have to give them the credit that i did buy into the circus being of the time period. They were talented actors.
I noticed a line in the film which I believe was intended to pave the way for it. Mrs. Clay sees Sir Walter reading the paper and asks about the news, and he says something about a circus being in town. I don't remember the line exactly, but it stuck out to me as a subtle preparatory comment.
I think the circus is an outer representation of the joy the two characters are feeling inwardly.
I've always found the addition of the circus to be puzzling, and eventually decided it represented the outer world of fools and mountebanks as a contrast to the two lovers, perfectly honest with each other at last, and in harmony.
Roger Mitchell made a 2020 film called the Duke that is quite charming
I went to a lecture on its production. The lighting of internal scenes by candlelight had been inspired by Kubrick's Barry Lyndon. I'm a big fan of your reactions, please forgive me for pointing out Roger Michell has no T in his name.
I was aware of the unusual spelling and tried to say it without letting a T-sound slip in there, but it's pretty close to impossible. Is it pronounced like the name Michelle?
@@Weiselberry That's exactly right. He passed about a year ago, probably best known now for Notting Hill. Someone else with the same surname Keith Michell was said to be the best ever Henry 8th. Have you ever seen the mini-series?
This is my favorite version, however I haven't fully seen the old mini series, or the newest one (and after seeing bits and pieces don't want to) but I completely agree the book is the best form for the story. This is probably my favorite book of hers-tied with Northanger Abbey. Every now and again I watch 2007 but it something is just missing in it for me 🤷♀️
I have not seen this film but thanks to your enjoyable review, I just might check it out 😉!
I never saw that movie all the way through, but did you watch the 'Jane Austin Book Club'?
No, that didn't appeal to me. That kind of thing typically doesn't, though it can be mildly amusing. I guess I'd rather just read or watch Austen things myself than watch other fictional characters talk about them.
@@Weiselberry I can understand your position on that - sort of the problem I have with those CSI shows (coming up with a rationale for bullets bending around building).
In the case of the Book Club movie, I was intrigued mostly by interaction and personal lives of the Book Club members, and how it ending in a very romantic scene.
,, thank you for all the great layers you make in the composition of your reviews, the edits are always of fine labour ✨🤗💐 x
,, I wonder, if you ever get annoyed slightly if the wardrobes have inferior tailoring for the period when hems and seams would have been made sturdy and to last,, I can hardly abide pieces set in the fourties, where, apart from the one overweight actor who has had something quickly run up on a machine, everyone else has been seemingly dressed by moss bros ✨🙄🎉
The 1995 is my favorite adaptation also. Very rarely are adaptations able to improve upon a book, especially the classics. They become classics for a reason! The most recent version (2022) is a joke! The 2006 is semi-ok. The 1971 is good, but the costumes research was not up to par.
I love how all you had to say about the 2022 adaptation is "it exists". Yes, that embarrassing adaptation does not deserve the time of day.
I've had my eye out but haven't come across this movie yet, my loss.
Re low lighting: If you know the movie Barry Lyndon, you'll be familiar with similar scenes that appear to be lit only by candlelight. This is because they are lit only by candlelight. Kubrick explains how he used a brand new camera (or lens, I forget now) that is capable of picking up extremely low lighting. It made it difficult for the actors because they could hardly see anything but it made the visuals very authentic.
Another commenter posted a link to the movie on RUclips (with foreign subtitles). I can't view it because Sony copyright blocked it, but maybe you can?
@@Weiselberry can't see the link but the search works :)
@@Weiselberry Saw it. Love it. ❤
Ciarán Hinds can do no wrong after he played Caesar in Rome so well.
Which one is your guilty pleasure Kaiju or 19th Century social criticism.Thank you for exposing me to both😊 I found Danger UXB on Internet archives.Its bound to be a favorite and started The Sandbaggers 1978 Brit Cold War stuff on YT.
Haha, the kaiju reviews are the ones that tend to surprise people who know me in real life. But I don't know that I'd call them *guilty* pleasures. :)
First, I quickly dare to ask -- is there a Hedwig amidst your parliament of owls? Anyhow, I'm not that big an Austen fan but this is still a very strong recommendation, thank you.
Snowy owls, yes, but no officially licensed Hedwigs here.
The superior version by far, in my opinion. But the circus... oof! I don't care if they weren't distracted by it, I was, lol. Toned down a bit, maybe would've been ok..?
The reason for the circus makes sense,
but the version.of circus seems too modern,.or foreign ? Early 1800s English
circuses were probably different ?The
music sounds too 20th c.?
I'd be Anne Elliot to Ciaran Hinds anyday!
“ A very fine young man indeed, more air than one often see in Bath. Irish, I dare say.” - Lady Dalrymple…..Great book, fantastic book, unbelievably exquisite book and a wonderful film adaptation 🤣 in all seriousness I do like the book a lot and also feel this 1995 film adaptation is the best version, I like the book more but really like this film, I think it’s so well cast and really works overall. Amanda Root is terrific and grounds it because she brings a reality to Anne, she’s a real person amongst a collection of fairy tale characters, Anne’s almost in a world where her father is the wicked stepmother and her sister is the wicked stepsister, Anne being Cinderella. Her character and performance also has a way of grounding the characters she interacts with, none more so than Frederick, like most of the other characters his personality fills a room until Anne and he speak, then he becomes grounded, he and his thoughts become as real as Anne, they almost take solace in each others stillness while being surrounded by over the top characters and personalities, perhaps with the exception of the Crofts each side character wouldn’t feel out of place in that loud festive parade while both Anne and Frederick have learned to ignore it all, ignoring the brashness and uneducated opinions of those loud voices that were once overbearing, they’ve decided their love and affection is what really matters. I also really like Admiral and Mrs. Croft, they carry that same quiet affection and comfort when in each others company we see Anne and Frederick also have, a steady and calm ship in a rough sea. Mary, “ I had better sit your side Anne if you have had your rest.” Wow! Lol, her character is so irritating but funny, my seat is damp and yours is dry, move over I’m taking your spot lol, even her choice of words, I had better sit your side, not may I or could I please sit your side, shouldn’t have even asked, I had better, why? So we can both be damp or would you have me stand for the duration of their visit? Anne’s sister Elizabeth definitely took after her father lol, the rage Elizabeth carries, Anne must’ve taken after her mother. Anne’s father is no Mr. Bennett, When Frederick speaks of his plan to marry Anne and her father says “ but why” her father doesn’t see her and probably never has, it was sad.
“ You ought perhaps to allow a larger portion of prose in your daily study, too much poetry maybe unsafe “ lol, that is very funny. Benwick, there’s another interesting character. You’re so right about the homes we’re invited into during the story, you explained how each one has is own character and warmth depending on the characters we meet while there, the houses with the warm characters are homely and welcoming regardless of how well to do they are, and the houses we meet the cold character’s are vey unwelcoming and show little comfort. Home is where the heart is, as long as a house has heart in it thats all that really matters, and i guess running water, electricity too lol. I also felt it would’ve been better to just hear Frederick when Anne was reading the letter and also think adding the festival was a strange idea but I’ve come to accept it. I agree completely with what you said about Ciaran Hinds Rochester, he was much better in the radio play and assume his performance in the 97 version was down to other factors.
“ A very fine review indeed, more air than one often sees on RUclips. Weiselberry, I dare say.”
Oscars.
I’ve looked through all the winners and I’m shocked by how many I’ve seen, 78 or 79 :0. My top eight would be similar to yours if not the exact same, maybe some films would change positions but it probably would be the same films, top two would be the same as yours, Casablanca is a strange one, it’s almost like it’s such a good film it’s reputation has harmed it, most people seem to think of it as THE CLASSIC FILM and it’s almost become uncool to mention it, its like if you say you like it people will think you don’t watch classic film, Casablanca is the only one you’ve heard of, it’s the go to pick for people who’ve not seen anything else made before the 90s, but it’s great and has lasted the span of time because it’s as good as it’s reputation, it’s endlessly quotable, the characters are so incredible, without Rick Blaine would there have been characters like Han Solo, Bond or Indiana Jones, maybe not, it has a powerful message too. Like you I was unsure what I’d pick as number one but Casablanca is it. The Best Years of our Lives is an easy number two for me also, I did consider putting it at one but as much as I thought about it I had to put Casablanca as one. I felt the same way about Gone with the Wind lol, it’s hard to deny it belongs there. ( Imagining a husband and wife having breakfast somewhere in Georgia, Wife : Want jam on your toast? Husband : frankly my dear I don’t eat jam :D, it’s 2023 no reason the husband wouldn’t be putting jam on his own toast but I needed to make my dumb Gone with the Wind joke work lol ) All of your honourable mention’s would probably be mine also, I might add Unforgiven to my honourable mentions list. It’s tough, I’m broken, It can be difficult for me to feel as positive about newer films over classics, I liked the Artist and was glad it won but not many Oscar viewers felt that way, it appealed to me because it was a black and white silent film, a love letter to movies we don’t see anymore, it’s not a masterpiece but I thought it was decent and I liked seeing it win best picture, it’s probably evidence of how skewed and broken my brain has become lol, it was a new film pretending to be an old film so it got a pass from me, dog is cute in it too. The most surprising thing about looking at the list of winners is realising films that probably should’ve won aren’t there, I thought I’ll probably put Singing in the Rain on my list, oh right, it’s not there, Citizen Kane either, Shadow of a Doubt, Vertigo, Rear Window, Rope, The Third Man, The Searchers and so many more. Thinking about The Sound of Music on your best picture list and your review of Persuasion I think the portrayals of Frederick and Baron Von Trapp by Ciaran Hinds and Christopher Plummer have some similarities.
There was a point when I’d try to watch the Oscars when it was possible because of my interest in film or watch highlights the next day because it’d go through the night, I’d get some junk food and power through it. The desire to do so has begun to vanish over the last few years, it feels like the Oscars and broadcasters are now more influenced by a television audience than those working in the film industry, I’ve always seen the Oscars as films employee of the month, voted for by those who’ve worked on the films and those on the outside shouldn’t really have a say in who wins or who’s nominated but now they do, we film enthusiasts will always have an opinion on if we think the right film won or was nominated but I don’t feel I should have a direct influence or they’d just be the MTV movie awards, films like those made by Marvel or whatever popular film is out is now is more likely to be nominated just to attract an audience, if a film like one from Marvel is fantastic and deserves it then great, but it doesn’t feel that way. I think the Oscars should go back to how it was in the 1930s and not being televised at all, it also feels like apart from a few there’s not really any movie stars anymore either, stars don’t really open films comic book characters do. After saying all that there is a record number of Irish nominees this year so I think I’ll probably try to watch it lol. I apologise for the long comment once again.
~ Thank you Ms Weiselberry ~
Jerome, could you PLEASE do One True Thing (1998) or Marvin's Room (1996)? XO
15:01 😂
I enjoyed this adaptation of "Persuasion" a lot - like I do of all the other versions - but I think it's a bit overrated and consists of some minor issues and a major one. The major issue I have with this movie has to do with the character of William Elliot. This is why I don't share the belief that it's the best adaptation of Austen's 1818 novel.
1995, the best
I would like your thoughts on Love Stinks (1999) starring French Stewart and Bridgette Wilson. I could not stop laughing watching this film.
Thanks for not reviewing the 2022 Netflix travesty "adaption" of Persuasion!!!! Have you watched any of Whit Stillman's films? He's very influenced by Austen. I think you'd love "Metropolitan"!
I need to see more of Whit Stillman's films, but that is interesting as the only one of his films I have seen (and which I quite enjoyed) was Love & Friendship, his adaptation of a Jane Austen novella (though I must confess that while I have seen many film adaptations of her works, I've never read them, so I don't know how good of an adaptation it or any of the others were).
Is one allowed to quote Mr. Samuel Langhorne Clemens here? 😈